Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Pinwiz11
Jan 26, 2009

I'm becom-, I'm becom-,
I'm becoming
Tana in, Tana in my mind.



I didn't think about this too long, but that doesn't stop me from writing a bunch of words!

--

I admit to not thinking about this until the thread came up, so I did not have a well-thought-out list in advance, but I did take some time to determine my criteria for “favorite.” Yes, in-ring performance is essential, but so many talented wrestlers are putting on 5-star matches that it’s almost not worth considering.

I decided to go with my emotional involvement in the wrestler’s journey over the last year. Wrestling is an incredible athletic spectacle, and I love a technical showcase, but it’s the melodrama that keeps me coming back. I wouldn’t have been a wrestling fan after my brief dalliance if it wasn’t for Lucha Underground, for example.

So, who had stories that kept me coming back time after time?

HONORABLE MENTIONS:

Bryan Danielson

His run after leaving WWE has been incredible, and while the matches have been solid, I’m just not feeling the story yet. Maybe it’s because he went heel vs. Hangman.

Dante Martin

Dante is a fantastic performer, AEW is wise to feature him, and the moment we thought he joined Team Taz was the type of “Oh gently caress!” moment I live for.

Hyper Misao

OH NO WHAT IS MISAO UP TO NOW

The Olympics Opening Ceremonies match. Enough said.

Kylie Rae

Kylie is one of my favorite wrestlers, I want her to be happy, and it looks like she’s on a positive path. To see her live at Freelance after I thought she retired again was a joy. Stay strong, Kylie.

Lulu Pencil

The story leading to the 30-minute match vs. Chris Brookes was so good I skipped out on Dynamite to watch it. I wore my Lulu Pencil shirt to many shows after that…

https://twitter.com/FisherNightsTT/status/1430454731453857792

…and because of that, I can see myself in the background during CM Punk’s return. PENCIL ARMY!!!!!

Malakai Black

The entrance rocks, and the House of Black has potential. However, I’m waiting for the House of Black to start acting more proactively.

Mat Fitchett

Mat has always been one of the favorite sons of AAW, but since I started going to shows, he’s been a Tag specialist as part of The Besties in the World. However, 2021 was the start of Mat’s single push. First, the Besties broke up. Then Mat started putting on amazing singles matches one after another (check out the match vs. Josh Alexander over the summer), eventually winning the Jim Lynam Memorial Tournament. Finally, he defeated Fred Yehi over Thanksgiving to win the Big F’n Belt 10 years to the day after his first AAW Appearance.

I still can’t believe that Mat hasn’t gotten a chance on a big stage. He and Vega have appeared in various places as a team, but I want to see him on TV regularly, dammit! All this despite him kicking me in the face that one time (I think it was Sami Callihan who messed up the move, but it was Fitchett’s boot that connected so…).

Mei Suruga

THAT… THAT… GOBLIN! She’s so good. But going away and being out of the ring for a couple of months hurt her standing in this.

Thunder Rosa

She’s so great! She kicks rear end! Now time to get to the “dethrone Britt Baker” factory.

MY TOP TEN

10. Kenny Omega

If I’m talking story, then I can’t exclude Kenny Omega. Kenny went into 2021 fresh after his championship win and straight into IMPACT, which we never thought would happen. Kenny’s rise and fall was the catalyst for many plots that played out last year, and it continues to ripple after he took time off to recover.

He’s only low due to the Heel factor. His reign relied too much on interference and he ran away from the fight too many times. drat, it felt so good for him to lose.

9. Nodoka Tenma

Nodoka is the best, a natural athlete and comedian. She’s leaving us in a couple of months, and I’m happy that she’s able to go on her terms. Now, suplex some fools between now and then!

8. Chris Brookes

Chris Brookes is the best and History’s Greatest Monster. :v: So much fun came from him this year, and I don’t think anyone else could have pulled off that match vs. Lulu Pencil. He’s terrific, and I can’t wait to see what other nonsense happens next.

7. Cody

He’s a face, and he’s a heel, and he’s a floor wax, and he’s a dessert topping, AND HE’S ON FIRE. NO REALLY, CODY IS ON FIRE.

The Ogogo match and associated build-up aside, Cody’s masterful playing of the crowds has been a joy to watch. I went back to loving Cody last year, and being in the room when Chicago THREW BACK HIS BELT was an epic story.

The Codyverse owns, accept it and come along for the ride. If I were talking about story potential for 2022, Cody would be very high on that list.

6. Serena Deeb

This is less an overarching story and more…

OH NO WHAT WILL DEEB DO NOW

…whenever one of her matches comes up. Deeb vs. Riho was a loving revelation, and while AEW’s Women’s Division has a lot of great workers, it’s the pairing with Deeb that catches my attention.

What cruelty will Serena Deeb dish out? Wait and see!

5. Maki Itoh

I was back at the hotel on the last night of DCI Finals in August, hanging out with my friends who I hadn’t seen in two years, and I kept watching my iPad showing the finals of the Tokyo Princess Cup vs. Shoko. I
was pleading with Itoh to win and squealed with joy when she did.

It’s been one hell of a year for Maki Itoh. Losing the tag tournament, immediately hopping on a plane to fly to Florida to appear at Revolution, winning a championship shot vs. the excellent Miyu Yamashita, almost but not winning that match, and eventually reclaiming the International Princess Championship on Jan 4.

Where do we go from here? I don’t know, but attention must be paid to what has come before.

4. Hangman Page

It was supposed to be at All Out, dammit! Hangman vs. Kenny at All Out. I was all eager to be in the room when Adam Page won the AEW Championship after two years of build. I was ready. I wanted it.
And then he lost his spot. And disappeared. And we had to wait. (All for a good reason, obviously.)

And then he came back, and it was glorious, and he stood up to Kenny, and it ruled, and then he won the belt and celebrated with his friends the Dark Order, and I cried.

Up next were the matches with Bryan Danielson.

Years of storytelling, paying off at the right time, and a high-profile follow-up story? Sold!

3. Eddie Kingston

Give Eddie five minutes on the microphone, and you can set up anything.

The Explosion didn’t work? Give Eddie the mic.

Need to set up a PPV match? Give Eddie the mic.

Need to set up the next feud? Interrupt Eddie’s cake time.

If there’s one good thing to come out of AEW, it’s Eddie Kingston getting his dues. One day Eddie will win an AEW belt and I’ll explode into glitter at his victory.

2. Penta El Zero Miedo
1. Rey Fenix


I’m still into wrestling because of Penta and Fenix, I’ve watched them have insane matches time after time before AEW, and while everyone loved them, I was waiting for their big moment.
That moment was at All Out. From the entrance to the storytelling, to those pf us in the crowd losing our minds, to Penta jumping in front to save Fenix, to Fenix wall jumping off of the cage, to the eventual victory…
…they’re so good. Give them all the belts.

I only own two wrestling figures, and it’s the Lucha Brothers. It’s hard to pick a favorite, right now Fenix takes the lead. Two months from now it could be Penta. If I could give them 1.5 each I would.

Get better Fenix, we can’t wait to see you again.

Go kick some rear end and break some arms, Penta.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Jerusalem
May 20, 2004

Would you be my new best friends?

We're two days in, a big thanks to all those who have added lists, and especially to those who have really gone above and beyond with the write-ups, graphics etc.

Anyway, some stats after the first two days!
  • We have added nearly twenty extra wrestlers since day 1, putting us up to 172 wrestlers listed so far, only 14 away from the TOTAL wrestlers listed across the entire thread last year!
  • Similarly, so far 63 Goons have posted their lists, only two away from the TOTAL number of Goons who made lists last year. I'm really hopeful we get that number up even higher, in 2019 114 Goons posted 202 different wrestlers, and there is a shitload more easily accessible wrestling out there than there was even two years ago!
  • Five wrestlers have broken the 100 points mark so far, and three have broken the 200 points mark. The top ranked wrestler so far has managed to break 300 already, surpassing the total points the #1 wrestler got in 2020 across the entire length of the ranking period.
  • Of the 172 wrestlers listed so far, 126 are male and 46 female. That works out to roughly a 74/26 percentage split so far, again very roughly in line with last year's end results, which worked out to around about a 70/30 split in the end.
  • The Top Twenty (accounting for tied scores) is broken down as follows: 17 men and 6 women; 16 from AEW, 3 from New Japan, 2 from Tokyo JOSHI Pro, 1 from Gatoh Move, and 1 from NOAH
  • WWE's Asuka, who was the highest ranked WWE wrestler in 2020's version of this thread, remains on 4 points. Yuka Sakazaki, who was the highest ranked women wrestler in the same poll, is also still only on 2 points!
  • Aoi and Atsushi Onita remain the youngest and oldest of all the wrestlers we have ages, at 19 and 64(!) respectively.
  • The average age of those listed so far is 32-years-old, the same age as Adam Cole, Andrade El Idolo, Arisa Nakajima, Bianca Belair, Hiromu Takahashi, Hyper Misao, Joey Janela, Kento Miyahara, Max Caster, Nick Jackson, Stu Grayson, Trish Adora and Yunamon.
  • I still do not have ages for: Justin Kyle, Kidd Bandit, LuluPencil, Nodoka Tenma or Pom Harajuku
  • In terms of promotions, AEW continues to hold a commanded lead with 62 individual members of their roster on the list. Their "nearest" competitor remains New Japan on 19. Tokyo Joshi Pro holds a narrow lead of 13 wrestlers to WWE's 12, though NXT also has four wrestlers on their list if you wanted to add those on. The big mover after day 1 was Impact, which now has 10 wrestlers from its roster listed.
  • Of last year's Top 25, outside of Mr. Brodie Lee for obvious reasons, the only wrestlers now missing from this year's thread is Mayu Iwatani
  • Chris Brookes very rudely passed Maki Itoh on the list, who promptly passed him back in order to maintain the proper order of things in the Itoh Respect Army.

Thanks again for all the great lists so far! :)

Rarity
Oct 21, 2010

~*4 LIFE*~

Jerusalem posted:

  • Chris Brookes very rudely passed Maki Itoh on the list, who promptly passed him back in order to maintain the proper order of things in the Itoh Respect Army.


:hai:

spamman
Jul 11, 2002

Chin up Tiger, There is always next season...

Jerusalem posted:


[*] The average age of those listed so far is 32-years-old, the same age as Adam Cole, Andrade El Idolo, Arisa Nakajima, Bianca Belair, Hiromu Takahashi, Hyper Misao, Joey Janela, Kento Miyahara, Max Caster, Nick Jackson, Stu Grayson, Trish Adora and Yunamon.

NICK JACKSON IS ONLY 32?! WHAT IN THE WORLD?!

Wasn't I watching this dude against MCMG like a billion years ago?

Jerusalem
May 20, 2004

Would you be my new best friends?

spamman posted:

NICK JACKSON IS ONLY 32?! WHAT IN THE WORLD?!

Wasn't I watching this dude against MCMG like a billion years ago?

If it makes you feel better, he didn't have his first 5 star match till he was 27-years-old!

Rarity
Oct 21, 2010

~*4 LIFE*~
You'd never know cause his hairline looks like its 52

spamman
Jul 11, 2002

Chin up Tiger, There is always next season...

Jerusalem posted:

If it makes you feel better, he didn't have his first 5 star match till he was 27-years-old!

What even is time? I'm so baffled.

IGgy IGsen
Apr 11, 2013

"If I lose I will set myself on fire."
I'm more surprised that Max Caster is 32. He looks like... 12.

Rarity
Oct 21, 2010

~*4 LIFE*~

IGgy IGsen posted:

I'm more surprised that Max Caster is 32. He looks like... 12.

At least he looks older than he acts

karmicknight
Aug 21, 2011

Jerusalem posted:

We're two days in, a big thanks to all those who have added lists, and especially to those who have really gone above and beyond with the write-ups, graphics etc.

Anyway, some stats after the first two days!
  • I still do not have ages for: Justin Kyle, Kidd Bandit, LuluPencil, Nodoka Tenma or Pom Harajuku

Thanks again for all the great lists so far! :)

https://twitter.com/ddtpro_eng/status/1375553502584303618

Rarity
Oct 21, 2010

~*4 LIFE*~

Seems legit

SG Bamboo
Aug 21, 2013

Smile. Win. Yay!

Rarity posted:

Seems legit

Mr Haku is a trusted source. He knew her personally, after all

TUS
Feb 19, 2003

I'm going to stab you. Offline. With a real knife.


10) Matt Cardona - His GCW run (well, World Title reign) was pretty brilliant and the way he embraced it was endearing.

9) Minoru Suzuki - I didn't watch much NJPW in 2020 but his US tour was a blast and saw a lot of matches I didn't think I'd ever see.

8) Kris Statlander - Been a fan since her showcase match against John Silver in Beyond several years ago and she's only gets better.

7) Nick Gage - Representin that Murder Death Kill Gang, representin for all his boys locked in the fuckin cell, eastern block, representin the motherfuckin h8 club, RIP Nate Hatred and RIP his brother Justice Pain and you know what it is... it's MDK ALLLLLLL FUCKEN DAY. The man, the king, the loving GOD of this poo poo.

6) Mox - Just being able to see him do his thing the way he wants to is such a joyous thing... totally ready for 2022 Jonathan Q Moxley

5) Bryan Danielson - I haven't read everyones posts but I feel like its safe to say that I would just be repetitive at this point. Always a blast to watch.

4) Eddie Kingston - I had the pleasure of being at AEW in Boston in October and Eddie/Danielson is still ingrained in my skull... so glad Eddie gets to (finally?) live comfortably doing what he loves.

3) MJF - Dude's heel work is so layered and nuanced it's brilliant... I hope 2022 has him with a title

2) Adam Cole - I don't think there's anyone that can get a crowd so riled up over waiting for one word in their theme song.

1) Chuck Taylor - Dustin never gets the credit he deserves and every day Best Friends don't have the Tag Titles, the world gets a bit bleaker for it.

Man this is tough... Im pretty sure if I sat down and did this next week, I'd have a different list... but here we are. So in actual order-

1) Chuck Taylor
2) Adam Cole
3) MJF
4) Eddie Kingston
5) Bryan Danielson
6) Mox
7) Nick Gage
8) Kris Statlander
9) Minoru Suzuki
10) Matt Cardona

Penguin Patrol
Mar 3, 2005

by Fluffdaddy
The worst part of reading everyone else's lists is going aww gently caress when you realize you left someone out.

I hope Suzuki doesn't find out... terrified for my life right now :ohdear:

Suplex Liberace
Jan 18, 2012



beggar posted:

Nick Gage (GCW)
If I could write 'the GCW roster' here I would. I dont catch it frequently enough to have individual favorites but every GCW show I watch is killer. Gage on AEW was mind blowing.

TUS posted:

Nick Gage - Representin that Murder Death Kill Gang, representin for all his boys locked in the fuckin cell, eastern block, representin the motherfuckin h8 club, RIP Nate Hatred and RIP his brother Justice Pain and you know what it is... it's MDK ALLLLLLL FUCKEN DAY. The man, the king, the loving GOD of this poo poo.

we are the mdk here

TUS
Feb 19, 2003

I'm going to stab you. Offline. With a real knife.


Suplex Liberace posted:

we are the mdk here

I was aware of Gage in CZW prior to the bank robbery, but I was at a random Beyond show where he squashed Sugar Dunkerton and after the match he grabbed me by the collar and screamed "HELL YEAH" into my face... I felt like that was my initiation into the MDK gang

SG Bamboo
Aug 21, 2013

Smile. Win. Yay!

Penguin Patrol posted:

The worst part of reading everyone else's lists is going aww gently caress when you realize you left someone out.

I hope Suzuki doesn't find out... terrified for my life right now :ohdear:

I tried to avoid this by doing 1-20 as well as *checks notes* 21 more Honorable Mentions

Rarity
Oct 21, 2010

~*4 LIFE*~
Starting a petition to force J-Ru to make next year's poll a top 25

forkboy84
Jun 13, 2012

Corgis love bread. And Puro


Penguin Patrol posted:

The worst part of reading everyone else's lists is going aww gently caress when you realize you left someone out.

I hope Suzuki doesn't find out... terrified for my life right now :ohdear:

It's OK, Suzu forgives you. All the penance you have to pay is to take a flat back bump on these bells & let Masashi Takeda slash your forehead with his big shears.

Jerusalem
May 20, 2004

Would you be my new best friends?

Rarity posted:

Starting a petition to force J-Ru to make next year's poll a top 25

The winner would have like 45000 points :stonklol:

sticklefifer
Nov 11, 2003

by VideoGames

Penguin Patrol posted:

I hope Suzuki doesn't find out... terrified for my life right now :ohdear:
Minoru Suzuki doesn't care about lists, whether he's #1 or #1000. He just wants to wander the world and beat rear end.

Rarity posted:

Starting a petition to force J-Ru to make next year's poll a top 25
I do feel like it could be categorized by promotion, or have more choices depending on how many promotions you watch. Like if someone watches 10 promotions, they're only getting in the top 1-2 from several of those because that's the maximum that they could squeeze in. If someone only watches AEW, you're just getting their tenth favorite wrestler in AEW in their #10 spot.

Senerio
Oct 19, 2009

Roëmænce is ælive!
I kept a rolling top 10 list so I wouldn't forget anyone who I cared about.

Sticky Nate
Jan 9, 2012

I don't care what the numbers say. The official wrestler of this subform should be Sting.

karmicknight
Aug 21, 2011

sticklefifer posted:

I do feel like it could be categorized by promotion, or have more choices depending on how many promotions you watch. Like if someone watches 10 promotions, they're only getting in the top 1-2 from several of those because that's the maximum that they could squeeze in. If someone only watches AEW, you're just getting their tenth favorite wrestler in AEW in their #10 spot.

That is how having many options works.

Jerusalem
May 20, 2004

Would you be my new best friends?

Yeah that just sounds like over-complicating the process AND it would cause multiple wrestlers to have to be left off of any list.

We should just celebrate that wrestling is so loving good now that we have such an embarrassment of riches for choices!

Penguin Patrol
Mar 3, 2005

by Fluffdaddy

Rarity posted:

Starting a petition to force J-Ru to make next year's poll a top 250

Rarity
Oct 21, 2010

~*4 LIFE*~
I'd like to take this moment to apologise to Miyu Yamashita who is definitely in my top 20 but I didn't want to spoil the swerve for my #1

Rick
Feb 23, 2004
When I was 17, my father was so stupid, I didn't want to be seen with him in public. When I was 24, I was amazed at how much the old man had learned in just 7 years.
Honorable mention to Maki Itoh. ]Extremely cool. Not quite in the Respect Army, somewhere in the Respect Coast Guard Reserves, but I'm down. Probably would've had her higher had I made time to watch more than two matches this year. Also to Adam Page; in the end helping me survive Raw was more important to me but I enjoyed your year quite a bit.


10. R-Truth - The only reason the 24/7 skits are ever funny is because of him and as someone who usually ends up watching these skits for some sick reason I appreciate him.
09. Shaquille O'Neal - Never going to pass an opportunity to recognize Shaq.
08. Xavier Woods - Never has a bad match, can tell an interesting story of him getting squashed in less than 2 minutes, makes jewels out of some of the worst material, and has really been good now that they've let him shine a bit.
07. Io Shirai - Probably would've been top 3 in 2020, still have to recognize her great work that occured this year. Has great matches with great people, good matches with people who are green as gently caress.
06. Jonothan Gresham - Revitalized a Pure division that had gotten pretty stale and did his best to carry a company doing what it could to sink.
05. Bobby Lashley - Superface monster leader of the WWE. Loved to watch him kick everyone's rear end and overcome the odds no matter how high they were.
04. Bryan Danielson - Didn't matter which bad wrestling company he was in this year, he was good.
03. Kenny Omega - Maybe the highest ceiling for stars in the biz, every move and every match has a purpose, every word has a purpose.
02. Kazuchika Okada - The god.
01. Tomohiro Ishii - What's greater than a god? A dog. loving love his matches and in a year where Okada was a bit mopey for the first half, Ishii was the most consistent great match haver this year.

Jerusalem
May 20, 2004

Would you be my new best friends?

Holy poo poo the Shaq match really was this year. I keep forgetting just how relatively short a time Jade Cargill has been a wrestler.

xbilkis
Apr 11, 2005

god qb
me
jay hova
Lashley being consistently booked strongly, getting a good manager and even having a good faction for a little bit really has been a miraculous-feeling bright spot of pandemic-era WWF. He even made his match with Brock happen. A flower growing from the concrete

Barreft
Jul 21, 2014

too many posts not enough lists

Cavauro
Jan 9, 2008

Can You Please Account For Popularity In This Poll And Assign Equal Points To The Less Popular

Big Dave
Nov 6, 2009

Friends don't shake hands, friends gotta hug!


I came up with like 50 names and had a extremely hard, stressful time narrowing it down to 10. I only watch indie wrestling and AEW.

1. Rickey Shane Page (Independent, 37)
R S P's My Favorite Wrestler. The promos and matches in the 44oh! vs H2O feud were incredible. In GCW he was a huge prick. In H2O he was the most evil man on the planet. In Beyond, he's a lovable babyface. A shame he covered up the drug free tattoo but pobody's nerfect.

2. Alex Colon (Independent, 37)
The best wrestler on God's green earth.

3. Atticus Cogar (Independent, 24)
Despite being mired with the dead weight that is Jordan Oliver for half the year, the Silver Toothed Satan should be GCW champ and he's been tearing it up everywhere else.

4. Masha Slamovich (Independent, 23)
The Ace of Beyond

5. Marcus Mathers (Independent, 18)
Sky's the limit for this kid. Literally unlimited potential.

6. Akira (Independent, 24ish I think??????)
The goddamn motherfucking death samurai. His ngi match alone would put him on this list.

7. Calvin Tankman (Independent, no clue sorry lol)
The best unsigned non-deathmatch wrestler in the US and he's really cool

8. Kennedi Copeland (Independent, 29)
She's easily the most endearing, likable person in deathmatch wrestling today

9. John Wayne Murdoch (Independent, 33)
Let's Hear It Guys 👏

10. Willow Nightingale (Independent, 27)
The most endearing, likable person outside of deathmatch wrestling today

I want to shout out in this post the recent class of H2O trainees Marcus Mathers, Austin Luke, Big Red Ryan Redfield, and Reid Walker. From watching so much H2O and H2O adjacent stuff this year and going to so many H2O shows, I've become really attached to these kids and love following their careers. Hopefully all four of them have bright futures ahead of them. Also other H2O guys like Jimmy "Chondo" Lyon, Dyln McKay, Steve Sanders, GG Everson, Bam Sullivan, etc

Also in the "aaaaa I can't cut these people out of my top ten" division: Joey Janela, Trish Adora, Megan Bayne, Chris Dickinson, Eric Ryan, Wheeler YUTA, Lee Moriarty, Kris Statlander, Mickie Knuckles, Brandon Kirk, Justin Kyle, and, of course, the boss Danny Demanto

Also also, a tag team top ten

1. Kristian Ross and Chris Bradley
2. Kings of the District
3. Young Studs
4. Santana and Ortiz
5. Waves and Curls
6. Lucha Bros
7. YoKai
8. The REP
9. Lone Rangers
10. The Mane Event (the circus one)

Captain Foo
May 11, 2004

we vibin'
we slidin'
we breathin'
we dyin'

I started watching wrestling again, and for the only time actually watching shows on a regular basis, at the show where CM Punk returned to wrestling. I'm now an AEW fan.

Honorable Mentions and notable omissions:
Adam Page and Kenny Omega
I group these two together for what I think are the same reasons a lot of folks do. However, I haven't been around to see them for that long, and while they're amazing to watch, the emotional arcs aren't landing the same way for me; I don't have history with them.

Jade Cargill
Physique is just incredible, and she showed flashes of being able to go in 2021, but in 2022 when she won the belt her promo skills seem to be developing and it turns out she can go! I'm kind of a dumb mark here, but I don't care.

Eddie Kingston
I love Eddie on the mic. Who doesn't? The Punk Feud was some incredible stuff. I just don't love the way his offense works, I find his in-ring style a bit goofy for how hard he otherwise is...though it's really minor nitpicks, ultimately.

Miro
Miro, please attack and dethrone god in 2022.

The LIST:
10. Cody Rhodes
He's just on another level as far as levels of dimensional chess. Every time he comes out something dumb is gonna happen, in a good way. His thankfulness monologue at the end of someone's vlog after winning back the TNT belt is spectactular. Also, he put himself through a flaming table.
9. Dax Harwood
Incredible tag team partner, and really stunned me in singles action. Rarely flashy but unbelieveably solid, both in-ring and cutting promos.
8. Pac
How does a guy that size move like that? So much fun to watch.
7. MJF
This guy heels. Fanatstic in the ring, too - that match with Darby was a masterpiece.
6. Kris Statlander
Crisp, clean, and powerful. Somehow makes a goofy character a real threat, and I think she should have the strap.
5. John Silver
BTE shows this guy to be funny as hell, and yet he can bring a real presence and power to the ring. My favorite member of DO.
4. Dante Martin
The kid jumps off the screen, literally and figuratively. Superb facial acting, too.
3. Rey Fenix
HOW DOES HE MOVE LIKE THAT? HOW DOES EVERY MATCH HAVE SOMETHING WE'VE NEVER SEEN BEFORE?
2. Adam Cole
The energy around Cole is contagious; I think his intro is the most over in the company. Every match is good, he plays a great heel, and is great on BTE. Trying not to be forward-looking on this list, but he's in the middle of the most interesting brewing feud options.
1. Bryan Danielson
Effortlessly gliding from face to heel with great mic work and then just...Being Bryan Danielson in the ring. I'm sure other people here have written it out more completely, but it sure seems like there's nothing he can't or won't do.

Jerusalem
May 20, 2004

Would you be my new best friends?

Captain Foo posted:

there's nothing he can't or won't do.

Hopefully this is wrong and he'll never re-sign with WWE :pray:

TV Zombie
Sep 6, 2011

Burying all the trauma from past nights
Burying my anger in the past

1. Mio Momono I saw her in Hana Kimura's memorial show and against Chihiro Hashimoto and I love how she can be the smallest wrestler in the match but she will give you so much poo poo. Whether it's kicking the ropes when your head is draped over it or give you repeated headbutts until you die, Mio is a future star, guaranteed (unless her injuries get to her).

Vs. DASH chisako
https://youtu.be/LPBiWrfvezE
Six Man Tag (marked at her confrontation with Hashimoto
https://youtu.be/xkAQj-svLq0?t=865

2. Katsuhiko Nakajima I loved his two defenses that I saw at the beginning of the year. Trying to catch up on his stuff.

3. Miyu Yamashita just the coolest

4. Tomohiro Ishii He may never win the big one, but he's the best in my heart.

5. PAC

6. Eddie Kingston

7. Orange Cassidy

8. Chie Koshikawa quit her job to focus on pro wrestling and she really helped hold the fort down for Choco Pro with Emi and Mei and Lulu being away for a while.

9. Riho She is so smooth in the ring and I think can get any crowd behind her eventually.

10. Chuck Taylor Please let him say poo poo on TV. So underrated.

GEORGE W BUSHI
Jul 1, 2012

TV Zombie posted:

1. Mio Momono I saw her in Hana Kimura's memorial show and against Chihiro Hashimoto and I love how she can be the smallest wrestler in the match but she will give you so much poo poo. Whether it's kicking the ropes when your head is draped over it or give you repeated headbutts until you die, Mio is a future star, guaranteed (unless her injuries get to her).

Gonna take the opportunity to post my match of the year from 2021, Mio vs Chihiro

https://youtu.be/UV0Qm660RGY

NutShellBill
Dec 4, 2004
I AM SPUTNIK'S PARACHUTE ACCOUNT
Here's a thing I haven't thought about in forever.

I had to actually sit and think about this for a good 30 minutes.


Honourable mentions:

Big E: He's just such a nice, likeable person. He's not great in the ring, but he's safe, and has personality for days. He deserved better.

Bayley: Injured for what seems like forever. Not even sure she would qualify as active. The fact that this natural babyface made to print money was told to turn heel, and decided on "Karen, who would like to wrestle your manager" and was still money? Amazing.

Sami Zayn: The original white bread baby face, booked as a geeky conspiracy nut who never wins.

Asuka: Does hanging out in catering count as active?

Chuck Taylor: I've always seen Chuck as the leader of that stable. Trent? is weird. Orange is unmotivated. Gulak is elsewhere. YUTA and Statlander are the new blood. Despite all his experience and natural charisma, he never gets to speak, and eats the pins in any match YUTA isn't in. In short... he doesn't get to do much of note.

Proud and Powerful: Please let them do something in 2022.

edit: gently caress. I forgot Miro. How did I forget Miro? Forgive me, Redeemer!



THE LIST

1) Orange Cassidy (AEW, 37): There was a time, when the gimmick was less polished, that I just thought he was narcoleptic. Now? He's the guy who I tune in to watch, no matter who he's facing.

2) Xavier Woods (WWE, 35): Only #2, because he works for WWE, which has a series of caveats, mostly involving screen time. Good in the ring. Great on the mic. Built an empire for himself.

3) Christian Cage: (AEW, 48) Active again! He's not as good as he once was. To give context, he once carried Ezekiel Jackson to a 3.75 star match for the WWECW title that fooled the company into calling Jackson up, for a big push. His supportive Jungle Dad re-invention is fun... but I think his matches with Kenny were his well-deserved last hurrah. But the future is still interesting.

4) Kenny Omega: (AEW, 38) He's Kenny Omega. He spent most of last year learning to wrestle while the ring was spinning. Omega & Callis made me happy in ways people will not understand. Canadian nostaglia~!

5) Kris Statlander: (AEW, 26) Statlander is my favourite women's wrestler, and putting her with Best Friends is a stroke of genius. I have never shipped a wrestling couple before. I ship Orange x Stat. I need Statlander vs. Asuka yesterday, please.

6) Brandon Cutler: (AEW, 34) I was disappointed when he broke his face, and went into stooge mode. And then I watched him stooge. There is an alternate universe version of AEW where the infinite coffers are not open, where people are asking when this guy is going to turn on the Bucks, and set off on his own story. He's excellent in the ring. Excellent at showing rear end. Excellent in front of a camera. I cannot believe he had to be convinced to un-retire to be in AEW.

7) Peter Avalon: (AEW, 32) Man, I wish he was 6'2" 215 lbs. Best JTTS on the planet. He's always telling a story with his facial expressions, whether it's disbelief that the opponent kicked out, or pleading with Cody Rhodes to not hit him in the face.

8) Stu Greyson: (AEW, 32) He's got a problem. Everything that he does, nearly perfectly, is done by PAC, even better. Incidentally, if I could get a... 25 minute PAC/STU match? Thanks!

9) PAC: (AEW, 35) I am confused as to why he only hovers around the title picture. Complete package. Muscles that are only theoretical. Ugly as sin, but this is wrestling!

10) Thunder Rosa (AEW, 35): I hope Britt Baker sends her a Xmas card every year til the sun burns out. Wrestling is weird. That match should have made Rosa, not Britt. Intense, fun and likable outside the ring... I can't believe she's not Women's Champ.

TV Zombie
Sep 6, 2011

Burying all the trauma from past nights
Burying my anger in the past

GEORGE W BUSHI posted:

Gonna take the opportunity to post my match of the year from 2021, Mio vs Chihiro

https://youtu.be/UV0Qm660RGY

Mio kicking out at 1 after a lariat and then trying to fire herself up before falling due to pain/exhaustion is amazing stuff.

I hope that they are rivals for the duration of their careers.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Jerusalem
May 20, 2004

Would you be my new best friends?

We're three days in, here's what's going on so far!
  • 183 wrestlers have been listed so far, 3 short of the total number of wrestlers listed in the entire thread last year!
  • 69 Goons have made lists, 4 more than last year's total!
  • Not a single one of these 69 goons listed Ryusuke Taguchi. Not nice :mad:
  • Seven wrestlers have broken the 100 points mark so far, with two more right on the cusp of getting there. 3 wrestlers are over 200 points, and 1 still over 300.
  • Of the 183 wrestlers listed so far, 135 are male and 48 female. This retains the roughly 74/26 percentage split from day 2, and remains very roughly in line with last year's end results or around a 70/30.
  • The Top Twenty (accounting for tied scores) is broken down as follows: 17 men and 4 women; 16 from AEW, 3 from New Japan, 1 from Tokyo JOSHI Pro and 1 from NOAH.
  • Atsushi Onita holds onto his oldest active wrestler status at 64, but Aoi has been trumped as youngest active wrestler by the 18-year-old Marcus Mathers.
  • The average age of those listed so far is still 32-years-old, the same age as Adam Cole, Andrade El Idolo, Arisa Nakajima, Bianca Belair, Hiromu Takahashi, Hyper Misao, Joey Janela, Kento Miyahara, Max Caster, Nick Jackson, Stu Grayson, Trish Adora and Yunamon.
  • I still do not have ages for: Justin Kyle, Kidd Bandit, LuluPencil, Nodoka Tenma or Pom Harajuku (who has been 3 for a very long time apparently).
  • In terms of promotions, the breakdown of the top promotions remains the same with AEW (62), New Japan (19), TJPW (13), WWE (12) and Impact (10). Though it isn't a specific promotion, there are twenty (20) Independent wrestlers on the list, not including 2 Independent Joshi wrestlers which I kept separate because it's normally a bigger section, it might just get folded into Independents. That makes the Independent Category the second biggest block of people's favorite wrestlers: yay Indies!
  • Mayu Iwatani continues to be missing, after making it into the Top 25 last year.
  • WWE's Asuka, who was the highest ranked WWE wrestler in 2020's version of this thread, remains on 4 points. Yuka Sakazaki, who was the highest ranked women wrestler in the same poll, is also still only on 2 points!
  • In terms of little silly "battles", MJF passed CM Punk today and thus technically speaking right now he's better than Punk, and WE know it? Tomohiro Ishii and Kazuchika Okada, Top 2 ranked wrestlers in the 2019 thread, are constantly switching places back and forth in their rankings. Brandon Cutler has just managed to get ahead of old rival Peter Avalon. The lowest rank wrestler (alphabetically) is currently Trish Adora... but she IS on the list, which is more than can be said for some surprising names I'll be keeping an eye on who have yet to make ANYBODY's lists.

Three days down, we've slowed down from the initial flurry but if you haven't made a list yet, please do! There are so many great wrestlers!

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply