Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
SGT. Squeaks
Jun 18, 2003

Two men enter, one man leaves. That is the way of the hobotorium!
I dig the guys portfolio. It's got a uniqueness to it.

And Sigma-X is right on. The industry is small, and people change studios all the time. I could throw a dart at any major studio and I'm sure I've worked with someone there.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Buckwheat Sings
Feb 9, 2005

SGT. Squeaks posted:

And Sigma-X is right on. The industry is small, and people change studios all the time. I could throw a dart at any major studio and I'm sure I've worked with someone there.

This can't be quoted enough. It's freaking creepy how small this industry is.

Adraeus
Jan 25, 2008

by Y Kant Ozma Post

Clonkers posted:

Quick question Diplomaticus, in my current contract there is a clause stating anything I make while I work for this company belongs to the company. I signed this contract when I, you know, needed to eat and stuff but now I am finding that a little....annoying, is there any way for my company to try to take money off of me for things I do outside of office hours? Naturally anything I do while in the studio using their poo poo is all theirs, but the idea that they own anything I make at home just seems...wrong.
These are usually valid and enforceable contracts. Your options are a) renegotiate the terms of the contract, b) stay and try to get internal support for your project, or c) leave the company.

Leif.
Mar 27, 2005

Son of the Defender
Formerly Diplomaticus/SWATJester

Clonkers posted:

Quick question Diplomaticus, in my current contract there is a clause stating anything I make while I work for this company belongs to the company. I signed this contract when I, you know, needed to eat and stuff but now I am finding that a little....annoying, is there any way for my company to try to take money off of me for things I do outside of office hours? Naturally anything I do while in the studio using their poo poo is all theirs, but the idea that they own anything I make at home just seems...wrong.

Quick answer -- Possibly. Longer answer -- I'd have to review the contract. Shoot me an email to drosenthal at gameslaw.net

The Cheshire Cat
Jun 10, 2008

Fun Shoe

Black Eagle posted:

These are usually valid and enforceable contracts. Your options are a) renegotiate the terms of the contract, b) stay and try to get internal support for your project, or c) leave the company.

It's a standard clause in a LOT of creative oriented jobs, both in and outside the games industry. The theory is that you're being paid specifically to come up with ideas for the company, not just for the ideas you don't think are good enough to use yourself.

Of course it's entirely possible to renegotiate the contract, and depending on what you actually do, they may be more or less receptive (if you're in a non-design oriented position, they might be more lenient).

One word of caution: Make sure you're very familiar with the terms of your contract before you get too heavily involved in any of your own personal projects. Diplomaticus could probably help outline it better for you, but if you do a bunch of work on a project while you're at the company, even if you don't show it to anyone until you leave, they would still technically have the rights to it if they can prove you made it while working there.

LowPolyCount
May 16, 2004

Transform... for Justice!

ExtraNoise posted:

PAX Dev went well in my eyes. It would have been nice if there were fewer students/non-industry in attendance (or more devs) but the speakers all did a great job with their presentations and the after-hours chats were fantastic.

This is good to hear. I tuned out of PAX-Dev after Google announced they were hosting a game jam there. One of my friends also had good things to say about it.

Snooty
Jun 25, 2009
Well this might well be one of the happiest days of my entire life so far. After just one year of studies and a 3 month summer job stint I was offered a full 12 month contract at my studio, full of wonderful, inspiring and awesome people. It was the easiest decision I've ever had. Unbelievably joyous over this!!

Leif.
Mar 27, 2005

Son of the Defender
Formerly Diplomaticus/SWATJester
Goon marketing is the best marketing :3:

Maide
Aug 21, 2008

There's a Starman waiting in the sky...

Watchlar posted:

Well this might well be one of the happiest days of my entire life so far. After just one year of studies and a 3 month summer job stint I was offered a full 12 month contract at my studio, full of wonderful, inspiring and awesome people. It was the easiest decision I've ever had. Unbelievably joyous over this!!

Congratulations, good luck, work hard, and kick rear end! :)

Shalinor
Jun 10, 2002

Can I buy you a rootbeer?

Diplomaticus posted:

Goon marketing is the best marketing :3:
I have an unproven theory that these forums honestly function as a bit of a king maker in games and related industries. I remain convinced that at least some of the success that the NimbleBit guys found is because of their posting on here, I feel like the Dreadmor thread that exploded out might have contributed to their success, etc.

Leif.
Mar 27, 2005

Son of the Defender
Formerly Diplomaticus/SWATJester
I agree. Good feedback, knowledgeable and vocal audience, scrubs mostly kept out by the :10bux:.

Monster w21 Faces
May 11, 2006

"What the fuck is that?"
"What the fuck is this?!"
Also agreed. It's why I tried to get as many goons as possible into the APB beta as possible.

Even though it all turned sour.

NextTime000
Feb 3, 2011

bweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
<----------------------------
I am a bit intimidated here, but what the hell. Here is my website that hold my Game Portfolio and Resume: http://www.paulnexttime.com/

once again, I would point out that I have been in the application process for an Associate Flash/Flex Developer position at Riot Games since GDC. Though it is not like I have not heard from Riot much since I applied, I have been in contact with someone for this whole time; he has even helped me improve the ActionScript Project that is part of the application process! I am just getting a little panicky since I am a year out of school and I have not even managed to get a job at McDonald's or dare I say Gamestop.

Although I do have connections into many developers near me (my schools new Game Production Chair has a strong relationship with Scientifically Proven, a friend I graduated with is a producer at Vectorform AND now teaches at the school we graduated from) This Riot job has been such a tease. Since April I have had a constant feeling of "I could get finality on this job any day now..."

so should I spread out my eggs to other, more local, baskets? then again, Riot is almost done with their Dominion game mode, which would signify them getting done with a major crunch and I can hopefully finally find out if I got what it takes or something. Then after that if I get turned away I can fall back on trying to get into the local places.

well it is nice to get all this off my chest. [/:words:]

Violently Car
Dec 2, 2007

You are now entering completely darkness
You should just apply to any job that piques your interest instead of holding out for any specific one. Employers understand that it's business, and if you apply to them but choose a different job, it's not going to be a great personal insult to them.

Project Oni
Oct 19, 2007
Fanclub is full
I dunno if this is the appropriate venue to inquire about this, but I'm a tester Namco-Bandai Games America and I've got a bit of a problem.

Me and three other testers have been testing From Software's new title Dark Souls, putting in 9AM to 9PM shifts nearly every day for the past month. After all this time and countless bug reports, I come to see that our names are NOT in the game's credits. I see the names of other testers who have been testing the game for half the time we have, and others who have done even less. I've asked my lead about this and he told me he was trying to get our names in the game manual at least (my lead's a really cool dude, and he does seem genuine).

Now, From Software had over a month to get our names in the game credits. How long does it take to add four names to the text file? I have a feeling someone dropped the ball either at NBGA or From Software, and now the testers who have broken their backs get hosed. It's like we had nothing to do with the game, and we can't even use the experience as a reference in the future. It can't be legal for them to use our work and then not credit us.

I want to know if there's anything I can do to rectify this, since there is still a full month before the game gets released. This is bothering me more than it should, but I honestly just want my dues, and it's not just for me, but the other three who getting hosed. It's not like we'll ever get a second chance at testing Dark Souls.

Project Oni fucked around with this message at 21:17 on Aug 31, 2011

icking fudiot
Jul 28, 2006

Project Oni posted:

I dunno if this is the appropriate venue to inquire about this, but I'm a tester Namco-Bandai Games America and I've got a bit of a problem.

Me and three other testers have been testing From Software's new title Dark Souls, putting in 9AM to 9PM shifts nearly every day for the past month. After all this time and countless bug reports, I come to see that our names are NOT in the game's credits. I see the names of other testers who have been testing the game for half the time we have, and others who have done even less. I've asked my lead about this and he told me he was trying to get our names in the game manual at least (my lead's a really cool dude, and he does seem genuine).

Now, From Software had over a month to get our names in the game credits. How long does it take to add four names to the text file? I have a feeling someone dropped the ball either at NBGA or From Software, and now the testers who have broken their backs get hosed. It's like we had nothing to do with the game, and we can't even use the experience as a reference in the future. It can't be legal for them to use our work and then not credit us.

I want to know if there's anything I can do to rectify this, since there is still a full month before the game gets released. This is bothering me more than it should, but I honestly just want my dues, and it's not just for me, but the other three who getting hosed. It's not like we'll ever get a second chance at testing Dark Souls.

Technically there's not a lot that can be done on the dev side - a month out, they've passed certification and are probably going into disc fabrication. Changing the build to add names would force them to recertify and delay the entire game which there's 0 percent chance of them doing.

Your best bet is to get piggybacked onto a patch or title update at this point.

Project Oni
Oct 19, 2007
Fanclub is full

icking fudiot posted:

Your best bet is to get piggybacked onto a patch or title update at this point.
Well, at least it's not completely hopeless. I know there will probably be a day 1 patch ready to go for Dark Souls since the whole thing was pretty rushed, so maybe if I hound my lead, he can get us in there via patch.

Referencing the post about getting into developer QA on the first page, I was really hoping that having a huge title like Dark Souls under my belt would be the thing to help me move from lovely publisher QA testing to developer QA testing. I wonder if I can still reference my Dark Souls work even though I won't be credited.

Damnit, I better be in that game manual at least. :(

FreakyZoid
Nov 28, 2002

Project Oni posted:

I wonder if I can still reference my Dark Souls work even though I won't be credited.
Of course you can. Anyone who believes a game's credits are a full list of people who worked on that game is, unfortunately, an idiot.

Jaytan
Dec 14, 2003

Childhood enlistment means fewer birthdays to remember

Project Oni posted:

Damnit, I better be in that game manual at least. :(

Typically manuals are finalized even earlier than the game is so I wouldn't count on it.

FreakyZoid posted:

Of course you can. Anyone who believes a game's credits are a full list of people who worked on that game is, unfortunately, an idiot.

100% this. I've got a couple of titles on my resume I am not credited on and it has never come up.

Project Oni
Oct 19, 2007
Fanclub is full

FreakyZoid posted:

Of course you can. Anyone who believes a game's credits are a full list of people who worked on that game is, unfortunately, an idiot.

Jaytan posted:

100% this. I've got a couple of titles on my resume I am not credited on and it has never come up.

This is really good to know, thanks. That's really a load off. I've been apprehensive to mention too much of this ordeal at work because I don't want to be a pest.

Shalinor
Jun 10, 2002

Can I buy you a rootbeer?

Jaytan posted:

100% this. I've got a couple of titles on my resume I am not credited on and it has never come up.
It's a huge problem in MMOs. Sometimes they update the credits to keep track of who is supporting it post-release, sometimes they don't, etc, it gets weird fast. Half the staff would be screwed if anyone verified credits.

... but it still sucks, and you should fight to avoid it. It's no fun when your name isn't in the physical box on the shelf :(

Superrodan
Nov 27, 2007
When my small company was contracted to do work on an MMO, we were credited as a company rather than as individuals, so stuff like that happens too.

wodin
Jul 12, 2001

What do you do with a drunken Viking?

Shalinor posted:

It's a huge problem in MMOs. Sometimes they update the credits to keep track of who is supporting it post-release, sometimes they don't, etc, it gets weird fast. Half the staff would be screwed if anyone verified credits.

... but it still sucks, and you should fight to avoid it. It's no fun when your name isn't in the physical box on the shelf :(

Credits in the MMO industry pretty much mean pretty much nothing, unfortunately, because companies do stuff like this (http://www.shacknews.com/article/54263/warhammer-online-not-crediting-all). Your title at the old company, and being able to speak articulately about problems you faced and solved and the responsibilities you had are the major metrics for success in an interview. The 'the game industry is a small place' also goes double for MMOs because it's a relatively specialized skillset and there's a lot of inter-pollination between companies. You have to be a philosophical as well as technical fit, so there's sort of a double bar to cross.

Generally speaking the credit policy seems like updating box-to-box (e.g. when EQ2 releases a major expansion, the updated box has new credits with different) but work that's done interstitially on patches is uncredited.

Sigma-X
Jun 17, 2005

Violently Car posted:

You should just apply to any job that piques your interest instead of holding out for any specific one. Employers understand that it's business, and if you apply to them but choose a different job, it's not going to be a great personal insult to them.

Nexttime, this, a thousand times this. Why haven't you applied to 100 jobs in the time you've been waiting back to hear from Riot?

Oni, good luck getting your name somewhere but I wouldn't hold my breath.

About 2 months out from release, a game goes off to Cert, which is where Sony/MS/etc test the game and make sure it lives up to their standards (naming conventions, etc) and doesn't loving brick the system/crash repeatedly. If it fails, it will get quickly patched and go back for a second cert. At this stage in the process they're most likely either already certed and going through the manufacturing stage, or finishing up a second cert if they failed their first.

It was probably an oversight and it sucks that you weren't aware to look for it/part of the process for checking it, but I wouldn't worry about it hurting your career at least, nobody in the industry believes that credits are 'accurate,' they're usually a stamp of whoever was still in the office when it shipped off to certification, and anyone who left beforehand is lucky to get an 'additional' credit or special thanks credit.

The Cheshire Cat
Jun 10, 2008

Fun Shoe
Random question: Is there a thread here for the CryEngine SDK? I downloaded it a little while ago but I'm not sure where to start with it. I remember that a few people mentioned it earlier in this thread when it came out so maybe you guys might know if there is a thread?

(and if not; anyone comfortable enough using it to make one?)

SpaceDrake
Dec 22, 2006

I can't avoid filling a game with awful memes, even if I want to. It's in my bones...!

Clonkers posted:

Quick question Diplomaticus, in my current contract there is a clause stating anything I make while I work for this company belongs to the company. I signed this contract when I, you know, needed to eat and stuff but now I am finding that a little....annoying, is there any way for my company to try to take money off of me for things I do outside of office hours? Naturally anything I do while in the studio using their poo poo is all theirs, but the idea that they own anything I make at home just seems...wrong.

To add to this (and to go somewhat against Black Eagle's previous assertion), this is a depressingly common as many posters noted, but I don't believe such a clause has ever been seriously tested in court - and I mean tested tested, by a dude willing to drag the court battle all the way to the Supreme. If you signed the contract, they'll definitely try to call you on it if you release something, but the real enforceability of such a contract, signed or otherwise, is questionable, since as you note it brings up multiple ethical, legal and possibly even Constitutional questions.

I'd double check with Diplo or someone else before making something on your own (unless you feel like being The Guy Who Tests It), but at the same time such contracts are somewhat hard to enforce (and smaller companies may not feel it's worth their time to try and prove you worked on A Thing during the contract period). I Am Not A Lawyer applies, mind. But it's still a questionable clause, from what I understand of the legalities around it.

(Bigger hint, for future job offerings this is something you/anyone else ITT want to ask about and raise a stink about if they try to foist it on you)

SpaceDrake fucked around with this message at 05:52 on Sep 1, 2011

GeeCee
Dec 16, 2004

:scotland::glomp:

"You're going to be...amazing."

striff posted:

http://codymeyer3d.com/

would be nice to get some people in the industry opinion's.
I'm now employed as a 2D artist so I won't go into much as to the specifics of technique, but the best advice that I got from when I interviewed at Playground Games was that showing standalone props is nowhere near as impressive as showing a full environment with those props.

They also basically said that Prop Art is part of Environments as a whole, so the best thing to do would be to just crank out more environments like your UDK Sewer.

mutata
Mar 1, 2003

The couple companies I've worked for have had approval and exemption forms available for people to pass their project off and have the company sign off their rights to it ahead of time. I'd ask someone in legal if there is such a protocol and if not, could there be at your studio.

The Cheshire Cat
Jun 10, 2008

Fun Shoe
One thing is that often those clauses just boil down to right of first refusal. It really just means that if you have an idea, you have to run it past the company first in case they want to develop it. Often if you've done this, they'll just reject it and you're free to pursue it on your own without worrying about them later coming in and claiming it (since they already said no when you offered).

Chernabog
Apr 16, 2007



Last month I passed my first year inside the industry and I'm amazed at how much better I have gotten, even despite the fact that I am the only animator at my studio. I probably advanced faster in the last year than I ever did in 4 years of college. Although to be fair, I wouldn't have been able to do so without the proper foundation.
How do you guys feel that your abilities have developed after joining a real studio?

Snooty
Jun 25, 2009

Chernabog posted:

Last month I passed my first year inside the industry and I'm amazed at how much better I have gotten, even despite the fact that I am the only animator at my studio. I probably advanced faster in the last year than I ever did in 4 years of college. Although to be fair, I wouldn't have been able to do so without the proper foundation.
How do you guys feel that your abilities have developed after joining a real studio?

Same as you, pretty much. In the 4 months I've been with my studio so far I've developed more than in a year of school and personal practice. Can't wait to see what the results are a full year from now with this pace :)

Sigma-X
Jun 17, 2005

Chernabog posted:

Last month I passed my first year inside the industry and I'm amazed at how much better I have gotten, even despite the fact that I am the only animator at my studio. I probably advanced faster in the last year than I ever did in 4 years of college. Although to be fair, I wouldn't have been able to do so without the proper foundation.
How do you guys feel that your abilities have developed after joining a real studio?

I learned more in my first year than I did in the previous 2 years of self-education (didn't go to school for this). Looking back on the stuff I did for Red Faction Guerrilla, it all sucked compared to Red Faction Armageddon, where I did much better, and the current project I'm on I'm finally really getting into zBrush and also improving my texture skills tremendously.

You learn much quicker in a studio environment because you're surrounded by folks who know what they're doing and can provide honest, critical feedback and techniques.

Chernabog
Apr 16, 2007



When I look back at my reel now I don't even know how I landed a job.

And for me I don't think it was so much the critiques as much as the fact that I was (am) animating every single day for 8 hours.

Sigma-X
Jun 17, 2005

Chernabog posted:

When I look back at my reel now I don't even know how I landed a job.

And for me I don't think it was so much the critiques as much as the fact that I was (am) animating every single day for 8 hours.

Oh yeah, this definitely helps a lot, too. But I've picked up a lot of little workflow tips over the years through just osmosis.

One of the other things that I find interesting is that there's a lot of habits I've built to avoid issues/speed things along/etc that I'm completely unaware of until I try to explain my workflow or debug someone's stuff.

Leif.
Mar 27, 2005

Son of the Defender
Formerly Diplomaticus/SWATJester

SpaceDrake posted:

To add to this (and to go somewhat against Black Eagle's previous assertion), this is a depressingly common as many posters noted, but I don't believe such a clause has ever been seriously tested in court - and I mean tested tested, by a dude willing to drag the court battle all the way to the Supreme. If you signed the contract, they'll definitely try to call you on it if you release something, but the real enforceability of such a contract, signed or otherwise, is questionable, since as you note it brings up multiple ethical, legal and possibly even Constitutional questions.

I'd double check with Diplo or someone else before making something on your own (unless you feel like being The Guy Who Tests It), but at the same time such contracts are somewhat hard to enforce (and smaller companies may not feel it's worth their time to try and prove you worked on A Thing during the contract period). I Am Not A Lawyer applies, mind. But it's still a questionable clause, from what I understand of the legalities around it.

(Bigger hint, for future job offerings this is something you/anyone else ITT want to ask about and raise a stink about if they try to foist it on you)

We're still talking about IP assignments combined with non-competes? They're tested and generally solid. The IP assignments stem down from a Supreme Court case which outlines the rules regarding work-for-hire and IP assignments. Beyond that though, it's essentially without dispute that if you sign a valid document assigning your IP, absent any contractual defenses (I was drunk; forgery, etc.) it's a valid assignment. It CAN be argued, sometimes, that an overly aggressive IP assignment policy (e.g. I agree to assign all of my rights in any IP I create to X, forever, regardless of where I do it or on my personal time, etc.)can be contractually void for lack of consideration. That's a failure in the contract though, not in the underlying fairness of IP assignments.

The grey area exists only insofar as how far they extend and to what level they constitute a non-compete in a jurisdiction that doesn't recognize non-competes.

I love reviewing these things because a) generally unless you are a lead creative, the company doesn't care. b) they are opportunities, if you look at them in the right direction, to get your IP noticed by potential decision makers. c) It tends to be a common issue (though also a commonly misunderstood one), and therefore is relatively easy to research, making it cheap for you to hire me, reinforcing it as an attractive service for the industry, perpetuating the cycle. Everybody wins!

GeeCee
Dec 16, 2004

:scotland::glomp:

"You're going to be...amazing."

Chernabog posted:

How do you guys feel that your abilities have developed after joining a real studio?

Just being in an office with other developers for eight hours a day puts my productivity through the loving roof compared to what I was like as a student/graduate.

Only a month in though although my drawing and painting is progressing quite rapidly :D

Shalinor
Jun 10, 2002

Can I buy you a rootbeer?

Sigma-X posted:

You learn much quicker in a studio environment because you're surrounded by folks who know what they're doing and can provide honest, critical feedback and techniques.
This is, btw, why I tend to recommend landing a job with a reasonably-sized studio first. Working with a tiny indie studio can be fun, and maybe you can launch a studio straight out of college, but you learn SO MUCH in your first few years in the industry that you'll just miss out on otherwise.

My first job was the sole programmer for a tiny outfit. It was great, and we did some awesome stuff, but I didn't learn anywhere near as much as I did once I got here and had someone to tell me "well ok, that works, but THIS way is way better because...".

typhus
Apr 7, 2004

Fun Shoe
I'm done with my game and looking for new opportunities. If any of y'alls studios are looking for a narrative designer or game designer or whatever, ping me.

typhus fucked around with this message at 15:23 on Sep 1, 2011

NinjaShteve
Apr 28, 2010
Do you guys know any studios with internship programs that are available during the winter? I'm going into my senior year and I still don't have an internship and OU has an abysmal internship pool for game dev as of yet.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Jan
Feb 27, 2008

The disruptive powers of excessive national fecundity may have played a greater part in bursting the bonds of convention than either the power of ideas or the errors of autocracy.

The Cheshire Cat posted:

I remember that a few people mentioned it earlier in this thread when it came out so maybe you guys might know if there is a thread?

What you're recalling was probably discussion of the engine itself rather than of the SDK. I don't really think it needs its own thread, though?

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply