Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Very Nice Eraser
May 28, 2011
My understanding is that the "humps" on a GPR image represent areas where objects of different dielectric constants meet (like a ceramic cask with air inside). A pipe would look like a hump that stays the same shape as you walk along the length of the pipe. A grave would be a very wide hump that disappears very suddenly when you reach the foot or head.

Edit: that is to say, the screen captures above are vertical cross-sections into the ground. As you walk you could imagine stacking the screen shots side by side to extrude a long tunnel-shape.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

xie
Jul 29, 2004

I GET UPSET WHEN PEOPLE SPEND THEIR MONEY ON WASTEFUL THINGS THAT I DONT APPROVE OF :capitalism:
Cask from 2004 wasn't a solid object anymore, it was broken into a few pieces.

pumped up for school
Nov 24, 2010

Very Nice Eraser posted:

My understanding is that the "humps" on a GPR image represent areas where objects of different dielectric constants meet (like a ceramic cask with air inside). A pipe would look like a hump that stays the same shape as you walk along the length of the pipe. A grave would be a very wide hump that disappears very suddenly when you reach the foot or head.

Edit: that is to say, the screen captures above are vertical cross-sections into the ground. As you walk you could imagine stacking the screen shots side by side to extrude a long tunnel-shape.

Pretty much, yes! The downside of that means you have to go directly over the target; if you are looking for a box that is 1 ft on a side you'd better run lines 1 foot apart. That is a lot to look at. And unfortunately a small air-filled cask is going to look just like a rock because they are similarly-sized point-source targets. There's not enough volume of air to really be significant to the wavelengths you are returning from 4 feet underground. You'll just get the diffraction off the top of the box.

Corky Romanovsky
Oct 1, 2006

Soiled Meat

xie posted:

Cask from 2004 wasn't a solid object anymore, it was broken into a few pieces.

OK, I am not a Ground Penetrating Radar technician, but if it is ceramic in plexiglass, then any air pocket remaining alone could still produce a sufficient anomaly on the GPR scan, then also there is the ceramic and plexiglass.

Dielectric Constants:
Air ~1
Ceramic 10~15000 http://my.execpc.com/~endlr/dielectric_const_.html
Acrylic 2.3~3.3
Earth 10~15 http://home.earthlink.net/~w6rmk/soildiel.htm

e: ^Stupid rocks!
http://www.kgs.ku.edu/Current/2001/martinez/martinez.pdf

Corky Romanovsky fucked around with this message at 23:29 on Jul 16, 2013

Merlot Brougham
Dec 16, 2004

The White Darryl Strawberry


Salad Prong
Cask 4, Cleveland

xie posted:

Cask from 2004 wasn't a solid object anymore, it was broken into a few pieces.

If the online accounts of Cask 4 are accurate, I get the impression that it was possible, if not likely, that the damage occurred during the actual digging for the cask.

Guuse
May 11, 2009

Grand Poobah posted:

The thing that I find interesting about the Russian pane is that none of the onion domes match in style, and none of them seem to be exactly symmetrical to themselves either. The windows in the middle dome are also different shapes. Yes, this could obviously be attributed to the artist's hand, or other elements blocking the views, or even a combination of elements from different buildings. But I'm starting to wonder if the 2 pieces in the middle of that image point to maybe 2 peninsulas and 2 islands on a shoreline that the artist hid within a generic onion dome sketch (to give a Russian link).

The one on the right seems especially misshapen to me. I'd thought of the idea that maybe the space represented something else, too. With the scanning artifact in the OP version, I'd speculated that maybe it was the lower Hudson around the West Point area since it sort of seems to follow the flow of the river there. Looking at it in the later scans, though, it really doesn't. I hadn't noticed it when I originally posted it, but upon being repost you can roughly see the same shape between the "towers" here:



vs.



It looks like the mirror might be possible from the absolute most southern points of Governor Island, facing Ellis. But could you even see anything at that distance? And that would reopen the question of whether it would be possible to dig there. In any case, I have no idea what the Russian link would be to either there or the railroad/ferry terminal, other than perhaps just taking a swipe at the name Communipaw.

GWBBQ posted:

I can sort of see the "eye" in the painting in the book, but I'm pretty sure you're chasing scanning artifacts.

I sort of thought as much. I finally broke down and ordered the book so that I can see this stuff for myself. I'm pretty positive that there's a shadowy "S" and maybe "M/W/3" (like the BOS in the presumed Boston picture) on the sleeve of cask 9 the guy, though. It actually looks like there could be a ton of stuff in that picture.

Oswald Kesselpot
Jan 14, 2008

HONK HONK HONK

Megaman's Jockstrap posted:

Cask 3

Other than the cross on the knight's armor being matched to the crosses at Elizabethan Gardens and the outline of Roanoke Island in the stonework I have seen nothing else in that image that corresponds directly to something in the environment.

Since the final path to the treasure is so vague (you're on a beach, you can see the Wright Memorial, you're near something inland but still potentially touched by the tide) I figure there must be something in the image that gives a further clue...but I can't spot anything in the pictures that someone posted earlier.
I posted this same thought earlier. I could almost convince myself that we are looking at the wrong image, I even found some (admittadly stretching for them) possible numbers for a Philly long/lat, but the outline of Roanoke by the window is impossible to get past.

Urban Smurf posted:

Cask 3




It's a faint outline of a spoon and I didn't know it was there until someone else pointed it out. A small circular object in it looks characteristically like a pea, which seems like a great indicator for nearby Pea Island Refuge.
I think that is not a spoon, but a lever. If you look at the end of the "handle" it looks like it curved and actually coming out of the wall. Ad the pea is not a pea but a post that is sticking out of the wall and is being used to hold the lever in place.

Mnemosyne
Jun 11, 2002

There's no safe way to put a cat in a paper bag!!
Roanoke

Sham I Am posted:

I think that is not a spoon, but a lever. If you look at the end of the "handle" it looks like it curved and actually coming out of the wall. Ad the pea is not a pea but a post that is sticking out of the wall and is being used to hold the lever in place.

A friend of mine ordered a copy of the book and I looked particularly hard at this part of the image since I wasn't 100% sold that it was a spoon. In the real copy of the book, it's pretty unmistakably a spoon. It's hanging from a thread that goes back up to the arm of the armor, just like the way the bells are hanging.

Urban Smurf
Jun 12, 2013

Take this avatar, rotate it 180 degrees, mirror it, mark a point from the tip of the dogs noses and you will see it will line up to this image of the centaurs tail "exactly."
Cask 3 Mirlo Beach @ Rodanthe

I've never seen very good evidence to support the Roanoke based theory(ies). Someone said there's a plaque with verbatim from the verse and there's exact images, but I've never seen them brought to light in a distinct and method based way which would fit either a Chicago or Cleveland style solve.

Urban Smurf fucked around with this message at 21:41 on Jul 24, 2013

Nocheez
Sep 5, 2000

Can you spare a little cheddar?
Nap Ghost

Urban Smurf posted:

Cask 3 Mirlo Beach @ Rodanthe

I've never seen very good evidence to support the Roanoke based theory(ies). Someone said there's a plaque with verbatim from the verse and there's exact images, but I've never seen them brought to light in a distinct and method based way which would fit either a Chicago or Cleveland style solve.

What about the part "the land near the window" which very closely resembles the outline of Roanoke Island? I'm starting to consider taking the 5+ hour road trip to Roanoke Island in a couple of weeks to see if I can piece together the end of the riddle. I'm thinking it very well should be near that Sea Gate or in the general vicinity.

I'm not sure if/how it relates, but John White was a colonist and artist who did watercolors of the settlement. Could "Where White is in Color" have something to do with that?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_White_%28colonist_and_artist%29

More information on White. He apparently also made the first maps of the area (also, in color):
http://www.nps.gov/fora/historyculture/hariotandwhite.htm

Nocheez fucked around with this message at 16:07 on Jul 17, 2013

Sir Cornelius
Oct 30, 2011

Palicgofueniczekt posted:

OK, I am not a Ground Penetrating Radar technician, but if it is ceramic in plexiglass, then any air pocket remaining alone could still produce a sufficient anomaly on the GPR scan, then also there is the ceramic and plexiglass.

Depending on where it's buried and your equipment, the challenge involved with detecting such a small box on a GPRS scan will range from really hard to impossible.

Subliminal Sauce
Apr 6, 2010

Spreading freedom and spreading it thick; that's just a thing us right-wing nutjobs do!
Psssst...does anyone here know who'd be interested in an official "Preiss's Secret"™ Divining Rod? It's been specially blessed during a reading of the verses and dabbed with a drop of Preiss's favorite brandy (the rest of it was for me). "When the cask is near, the rod will bend queer."
Rod also comes with an officialistic Certificate of Digging Permission, printed on quality paper.
Bidding starts at $250.

I'm also working on setting up a Kickstarter fund to get some of Byron's DNA and cook up a clone. When it grows up enough, force it at gunpoint to find the casks.

rookhunter
Jun 14, 2013

Peenigrippe posted:

Psssst...does anyone here know who'd be interested in an official "Preiss's Secret"™ Divining Rod? It's been specially blessed during a reading of the verses and dabbed with a drop of Preiss's favorite brandy (the rest of it was for me). "When the cask is near, the rod will bend queer."
Rod also comes with an officialistic Certificate of Digging Permission, printed on quality paper.
Bidding starts at $250.

I'm also working on setting up a Kickstarter fund to get some of Byron's DNA and cook up a clone. When it grows up enough, force it at gunpoint to find the casks.

lmao

Id settle for buying the book rights and making JJP tell us his clues.

Urban Smurf
Jun 12, 2013

Take this avatar, rotate it 180 degrees, mirror it, mark a point from the tip of the dogs noses and you will see it will line up to this image of the centaurs tail "exactly."

Nocheez posted:

What about the part "the land near the window" which very closely resembles the outline of Roanoke Island?

Nocheez, maybe it is like verse 4's "seek the columns" which corresponds to image 4's columns. It's a very different sort of clue though, since the columns were structures at the entrance to a relatively small area. The outline of Roanoke Island is more like a map outline and is a very large area. Should we be looking at a map and all places in the "small area" nearby Roanoke's outline?

I've challenged myself to consider a different more cryptic reason for that line where alternative uses of the words might give it different meaning. "land" could mean "a place where you land", such as bringing a boat ashore, or a runway for a plane. A window is simply something you look out of/from. Something I like as a fit is the lookout platform on the Rec Pole, which originally was used by the US Life Saving Station workers for spotting sea vessels that run aground.

Nnep
Jun 17, 2007

3-2 2-0
I think the land near the window is pretty solid and matches the style of similar clues used in found casques.

BJG
Jun 4, 2013

New Orleans

I just tried taking a fresh look at this - see what you think.

At the place where jewels abound

La Petit Fleur ("small flower", cf flowers in image), New Orleans Jewellers at 534 Royal St.

http://lapetitfleur.com/

Apparently they've been trading in the French Quarter for over 40 years, though I don't know if it was at this location in 1982.

Fifteen rows down to the ground

Fifteen blocks south...



...takes you past Lafayette Square with possible "clock-boy" match to the Confederate Memorial Hall at 929 Camp St.







http://www.confederatemuseum.com/

They have old flags and stuff...(also a chess set).





In the middle of twenty-one
From end to end


21 bricks:



...also another possible interpretation of the "fifteen rows" - 14 steps plus kerb.



Only three stand watch

Dunno - possible reference to something in the museum?

As the sound of friends
Fills the afternoon hours


Could refer to any gathering really.

Here is a sovereign people
Who build palaces to shelter
Their heads for a night!


New Orleans (from Sarmiento quote).

Gnomes admire
Fays delight


Dunno. The litany refers to the "Fays of France" so there's a link there, and the fays also remind me of nearby Lafayette.

The namesakes meeting
Near this site


Junction of Lee Circle and Andrew Higgins.

BJG fucked around with this message at 10:47 on Jul 18, 2013

CK07
Nov 8, 2005

bum bum BAA, bum bum, ba-bum ba baa..
Jesus christ I can't believe I made it through 86 pages of this crazy awesome bullshit.

San Francisco

SF Bay-area goon here, I live in the East Bay but I could be convinced to take a special treasure-hunting trip to wherever. My boyfriend is an East Bay local and I showed him the alleged SF image. He definitely called out the window-tower-rock thing as being "Alcatrazy" and thought that the other rocks sort of looked like the waterfalls around Stow Lake in Golden Gate Park. Soooo then I finally agreed to go with him to pay the GGP bison a visit (after months of gentle wheedling on his part) and he very agreeably went along with my crazy staring at everything from different angles. I know GGP has pretty much been discounted, and I'm inclined to agree - the lamps don't really fit the silhouette, the Chinese pavilion had no matches, the waterfall area didn't ring any bells. The verse was also useless. I mean, it's an enormous park, there are tons of trails and nooks and crannies and poo poo, I didn't see but a little part of it. But it was fun to go treasure-hunting, we spent some of that energy on locating a few geocaches around the bison. I'm fascinated with this thread, keep up the good work everyone!

Corky Romanovsky
Oct 1, 2006

Soiled Meat

Sir Cornelius posted:

Depending on where it's buried and your equipment, the challenge involved with detecting such a small box on a GPRS scan will range from really hard to impossible.

Depending on whether you read my entire post and comprehend the "edit" at the end, your reply will range from really not making sense to having added little value. Not unlike this post.

einTier
Sep 25, 2003

Charming, friendly, and possessed by demons.
Approach with caution.
Houston

I'm still thinking about Houston, but I wanted some time away so that I could return to it with a fresh mind instead of falling into old pathways and lines of thinking.

Right now, I'm looking at part of the cryptic verse:

quote:

What we take to be
Our strongest tower of delight
Falls gently
In December night

The first part is found verbatim in Melville's Pierre: The Ambiguities. I don't think for a second that was unintentional or misdirection. It's the kind of book he would have been familiar with and is popular with book critics and publishers simply because it's extremely difficult to read and decipher. The quote in question comes from this paragraph:

quote:

AS the vine flourishes, and the grape empurples close up to the very walls and muzzles of cannoned Ehrenbreitstein; so do the sweetest joys of life grow in the very jaws of its perils.

But is life, indeed, a thing for all infidel levities, and we, its misdeemed beneficiaries, so utterly fools and infatuate, that what we take to be our strongest tower of delight, only stands at the caprice of the minutest event—the falling of a leaf, the hearing of a voice, or the receipt of one little bit of paper scratched over with a few small characters by a sharpened feather? Are we so entirely insecure, that that casket, wherein we have placed our holiest and most final joy, and which we have secured by a lock of infinite deftness; can that casket be picked and desecrated at the merest stranger's touch, when we think that we alone hold the only and chosen key?

Pierre! thou art foolish; rebuild—no, not that, for thy shrine still stands; it stands, Pierre, firmly stands; smellest thou not its yet undeparted, embowering bloom? Such a note as thine can be easily enough written, Pierre; impostors are not unknown in this curious world; or the brisk novelist, Pierre, will write thee fifty such notes, and so steal gushing tears from his reader's eyes; even as thy note so strangely made thine own manly eyes so arid; so glazed, and so arid, Pierre—foolish Pierre!

Oh! mock not the poniarded heart. The stabbed man knows the steel; prate not to him that it is only a tickling feather. Feels he not the interior gash? What does this blood on my vesture? and what does this pang in my soul?

And here again, not unreasonably, might invocations go up to those Three Weird Ones, that tend Life's loom. Again we might ask them, What threads were those, oh, ye Weird Ones, that ye wove in the years foregone; that now to Pierre, they so unerringly conduct electric presentiments, that his woe is woe, his father no more a saint, and Isabel a sister indeed?

Ah, fathers and mothers! all the world round, be heedful,—give heed! Thy little one may not now comprehend the meaning of those words and those signs, by which, in its innocent presence, thou thinkest to disguise the sinister thing ye would hint. Not now he knows; not very much even of the externals he consciously remarks; but if, in after-life, Fate puts the chemic key of the cipher into his hands; then how swiftly and how wonderfully, he reads all the obscurest and most obliterate inscriptions he finds in his memory; yea, and rummages himself all over, for still hidden writings to read. Oh, darkest lessons of Life have thus been read; all faith in Virtue been murdered, and youth gives itself up to an infidel scorn.

But not thus, altogether, was it now with Pierre; yet so like, in some points, that the above true warning may not misplacedly stand.

His father had died of a fever; and, as is not uncommon in such maladies, toward his end, he at intervals lowly wandered in his mind. At such times, by unobserved, but subtle arts, the devoted family attendants, had restrained his wife from being present at his side. But little Pierre, whose fond, filial love drew him ever to that bed; they heeded not innocent little Pierre, when his father was delirious; and so, one evening, when the shadows intermingled with the curtains; and all the chamber was hushed; and Pierre but dimly saw his father's face; and the fire on the hearth lay in a broken temple of wonderful coals; then a strange, plaintive, infinitely pitiable, low voice, stole forth from the testered bed; and Pierre heard,—"My daughter! my daughter!"

"He wanders again," said the nurse.

"Dear, dear father!" sobbed the child—"thou hast not a daughter, but here is thy own little Pierre."

But again the unregardful voice in the bed was heard; and now in a sudden, pealing wail,—"My daughter!—God! God!—my daughter!"

The child snatched the dying man's hand; it faintly grew to his grasp; but on the other side of the bed, the other hand now also emptily lifted itself and emptily caught, as if at some other childish fingers. Then both hands dropped on the sheet; and in the twinkling shadows of the evening little Pierre seemed to see, that while the hand which he held wore a faint, feverish flush, the other empty one was ashy white as a leper's.

"It is past," whispered the nurse, "he will wander so no more now till midnight,—that is his wont." And then, in her heart, she wondered how it was, that so excellent a gentleman, and so thoroughly good a man, should wander so ambiguously in his mind; and trembled to think of that mysterious thing in the soul, which seems to acknowledge no human jurisdiction, but in spite of the individual's own innocent self, will still dream horrid dreams, and mutter unmentionable thoughts; and into Pierre's awe-stricken, childish soul, there entered a kindred, though still more nebulous conceit. But it belonged to the spheres of the impalpable ether; and the child soon threw other and sweeter remembrances over it, and covered it up; and at last, it was blended with all other dim things, and imaginings of dimness; and so, seemed to survive to no real life in Pierre. But though through many long years the henbane showed no leaves in his soul; yet the sunken seed was there: and the first glimpse of Isabel's letter caused it to spring forth, as by magic. Then, again, the long-hushed, plaintive and infinitely pitiable voice was heard,—"My daughter! my daughter!" followed by the compunctious "God! God!" And to Pierre, once again the empty hand lifted itself, and once again the ashy hand fell.

It's pretty obvious he's talking about life here and in particular the life of Pierre's father. "Our strongest tower of delight" is our life -- or someone else's -- and it can be extinguished rapidly. Since this is immediately followed with "falls gently in December night", I think we should be looking at someone or something that died or ended in December and went away quietly. I remember the statue of Simon Bolivar mentions December -- it was erected on the anniversary of his death, December 17. I once thought that this was a key in Hermann Park, and I think it still might be. I wouldn't be at all surprised if the cask is buried near the Hermann Park Garden Center and particularly near Bolivar's statue.

There's some speculation on Atropos and the Atropos key from the section about the "Three Weird Ones", but I don't think it's right. This tends to lead one to Shakespeare's MacBeth and the Three Witches which are often referred to as "The Three Weird Sisters". Only one is given a name, and it is not Atropos, it's Hecate. Reaching further, this part of the play is inspired by the Nordic poem Darrađarljóđ, where twelve valkyries weave (loom?) and choose who will die in battle. Only six of the twelve valkyries are named, and none of them are Atropos. Working backward from Atropos, I can make a connection to the Shakespeare play as detailed in this wikipedia article. One of them (fate) uses the name Wyrd which is the basis for the word weird, but that's only one of them and there's no strong correlation with Atropos. They're never directly referred to as "Three Weird Ones" in any way. It's possible to "get there from here", but I think it's a pretty tenuous stretch, especially considering that the section comes so far after "strongest tower of delight".

einTier fucked around with this message at 00:29 on Jul 19, 2013

Urban Smurf
Jun 12, 2013

Take this avatar, rotate it 180 degrees, mirror it, mark a point from the tip of the dogs noses and you will see it will line up to this image of the centaurs tail "exactly."
Verse 9

Shell, limestone, silver, salt

This line is very interesting from a chemistry perspective.

Seashells are made of Calcium Carbonate (CaCO3)
Limestone is primarily Calcium Carbonate
Silver (Ag)
Salt is typically Sodium Chloride, but "salt" in the broader sense is the cation/anion result of an acid/base neutralization. CaCO3 is a salt.

As far as what the two might have in common as an application, silver may be treated for tarnish by applying calcium carbonate in solution or paste. That reminds me, I use to polish my fishing lures with toothpaste.

I'm still not completely sure of the object of this line of verse. I thought at one time it best described nacre such as the silvery mother of pearl shell of abalone:



I picked up a book from the 70's on the history of Roche Harbor (Afoot and Afloat in San Juan Islands was another book I researched) and read that the limeworks started in 1881 there produced 1500 barrels of lime a day, the largest producer west of the Mississippi. More about it's history here

Should the line be designed to capture the sense of "think of a pretty kind of sea shell", or the word "limestone" be a narrowing clue, the strong central source for the commodities abalone or limestone might both be used to point to San Juan Island, but only as an after thought, since both may be found in many other places as well.

An interesting connection to image 12 is the color hues of abalone may be seen in the circle filled panels. The wiki on abalone describes the colors of the shell and it's pearls: the iridescent nacre that lines the inside of the shell varies in color from silvery white, to pink, red and green-red, through to Haliotis iris, which shows predominantly deep blues, greens and purples.

Urban Smurf fucked around with this message at 01:11 on Jul 19, 2013

Urban Smurf
Jun 12, 2013

Take this avatar, rotate it 180 degrees, mirror it, mark a point from the tip of the dogs noses and you will see it will line up to this image of the centaurs tail "exactly."
Eintier, the "My daughter, my daughter" part reminds me of the Goethe poem Erlkonig, "My father, my father" when Death comes for a man's sick child and persuades the boy to come away with him. I really like the Atropos Key connection.

einTier
Sep 25, 2003

Charming, friendly, and possessed by demons.
Approach with caution.
Houston, again

I'm falling into that same old trap. I can see a connection to the Bolivar statue, and I want to believe that's where it is. Here's a good picture of the statue.



I'm trying to make myself believe that the "leaves" on the front of his jacket are the "Small, split, Three winged and slight" referenced in the poem, which would seem to indicate the cask is buried near this statue.

But I have a couple of problems.

1. There's no corresponding imagery in the painting. I'm getting there almost entirely by the verse, and while there's not much in the image, there's virtually nothing I can match up. Everything that I could make a case for is a real stretch.

2. I can't make Bolivar fit anywhere in the "center of four alike". He's number 15 on the map on this page. I'm pretty sure this is him off by his lonesome near the y-shaped path. There are four other busts that line the path on the opposite side, but he's not in the middle. I doubt the statues moved, but it's nearly impossible to verify how much might have changed in this location.

3. Assuming that Bolivar is correct, then the 982 must correspond to the old 982 locomotive. But how in the world do you get to the Memorial Garden from there? It's a very long walk from the train to the park -- by my reckoning, it's at least 1/4 of a mile (0.4 kilometer). We're a third of the way through the poem by the time we get to the 982 line -- would we really walk so far after that? I'm just not convinced.

Thoughts?

einTier fucked around with this message at 00:04 on Jul 21, 2013

Urban Smurf
Jun 12, 2013

Take this avatar, rotate it 180 degrees, mirror it, mark a point from the tip of the dogs noses and you will see it will line up to this image of the centaurs tail "exactly."
Cask 2 Verse 6

I really like the Edwin Booth connection to May 1913, but I've been thinking about the theme of lynching since a "golden pear" hanging on a branch that doesn't look like a pear bearing branch in the first place might be thought of as a "Strange Fruit", which was a poem written by Abel Meeropol, a white, Jewish high school teacher from the Bronx and a member of the Communist Party, as a protest against lynchings. The neck-chain with the Sumter shaped "face" might also be symbolic of lynching.

In May of 1913, Leo Frank was arrested for the murder of Mary Phagan (actually murdered on Apr. 26th). The Leo Frank Trial was the one article headline that I found interesting in my careful search of the New York Times archives (I read them all for the month of May in 1913).

Frank became the only known Jew lynched in American history.

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/anti-semitism/frank.html

Unfortunately, I'm not seeing how this might apply to Charleston.

crashdome
Jun 28, 2011
Milwaukee

This is probably not of much help but, I had 10 minutes to spare yesterday so I walked 6 blocks and grabbed a few shots of Plankinton Circle or whatever it's called in the Grand Ave Mall. Yes, I spend all my free time looking for clues now.

I hope to get to city hall soon.





Note: The dark areas near base in fountain are hordes of pennies.



edit: All my Mke Secret-related photos are here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/97715723@N04/

crashdome fucked around with this message at 16:12 on Jul 20, 2013

Merlot Brougham
Dec 16, 2004

The White Darryl Strawberry


Salad Prong
Cask 10 / Verse 8 - Milwaukee

crashdome posted:


Note: The dark areas near base in fountain are hordes of pennies.



Looks like quite few people went there to cast in copper. I know you've been working on that interpretation.

Edit:
To contribute, I haven't been following Milwaukee as close as some of the others, but I quite liked this comparison that TipsyMc posted on page 41. Unfortunately, it didn't seem to gain too much traction. Did I miss something that caused this to get dismissed?



Merlot Brougham fucked around with this message at 20:45 on Jul 20, 2013

Nnep
Jun 17, 2007

3-2 2-0

Merlot Brougham posted:

Cask 10 / Verse 8 - Milwaukee


Looks like quite few people went there to cast in copper.

Oh poo poo! Right next to the line referencing ascending steps too! I think you're on to something. Although it's the line before it, any idea step on nature?

The_Raven
Jul 2, 2004

Upon this a question arises: whether it be better to be loved than feared or feared than loved?
Cask 11, Verse 3, Boston

Someone had mentioned the USS Constitution (Old Ironsides) as the "metal walls". It should be noted that the ship lies at anchor in the shadow of this "green tower of lights", the Tobin Bridge...

einTier
Sep 25, 2003

Charming, friendly, and possessed by demons.
Approach with caution.

Nnep posted:

Oh poo poo! Right next to the line referencing ascending steps too! I think you're on to something. Although it's the line before it, any idea step on nature?

Yeah, you would "cast in copper" before you ascend the steps. While I think it would be nice to tie the previous lines in, if that's the place, you could just proceed from there.

TX297
Nov 7, 2005

IM A HUGE FAGGOT WHO STEALS BYOB AVATARS.

einTier posted:

Yeah, you would "cast in copper" before you ascend the steps. While I think it would be nice to tie the previous lines in, if that's the place, you could just proceed from there.

I'm extremely intrigued by the wordplay and it seems to be the sort of thing Preiss would do. Combined with the number of steps, I think we have a raging clue here.

einTier
Sep 25, 2003

Charming, friendly, and possessed by demons.
Approach with caution.

TX297 posted:

I'm extremely intrigued by the wordplay and it seems to be the sort of thing Preiss would do. Combined with the number of steps, I think we have a raging clue here.

It's more than that. Back on page 53 we were having a pretty lively discussion about this very thing. This kind of got overlooked:

crashdome posted:

It's worth an investigation. I wanted to head over there myself so if you can get there first, I say go for it!

Edit: holy crap... I just googled Zeidler Square for images and found this:
compass

So, we have

quote:

Cast in copper -- the fountain full of pennies
Ascend the 92 steps -- the steps of the circle
After climbing the grand 200 -- the street address is 200, and it is in the "Grand Avenue Mall"
Pass the compass and reach -- there's a compass
The foot of the culvert -- what culvert? Where from here?
Below the bridge -- where's the bridge?
Walk 100 paces -- ....

[edit]
Just one problem. That compass is part of an art display called The Wisconsin Workers Memorial. It was built in 1995. :(

You can see more pictures of it here, if you like. According to wikipedia, this display takes up most of the park. Anyone have any idea what the park looked like before?

Urban Smurf
Jun 12, 2013

Take this avatar, rotate it 180 degrees, mirror it, mark a point from the tip of the dogs noses and you will see it will line up to this image of the centaurs tail "exactly."
Cask 10

Dr. Bit/crashdome, you've found the strongest most definitive answer to the Milwaukee puzzle so far. The Plankington Arcade holds the key to this. Nice work!

If three lines of the poem fit that one spot, the wishing well, the number of steps, and Grand Ave., that puts a lot of importance on that location. Following the instructions to climb the stairs means you have just traveled in a circular path (flattened) and now you're wondering WTF did Preiss want me to walk in circle? The next line "pass the compass and reach" fits, since a compass is a tool used to draw a circle. I propose that the circle of stairs is the "locus" of a larger circle. The question then is what determins the radius of that larger circle? How about the tangent of Locust Ave? Next question, where's a good place to bury a casque near wherever that large rear end circle passes? How about a spot near 200 degrees?



Some other random thoughts,

From woman, with harpsichord

From woman = child, born to play harpsichord

Maybe this fits some of the speculation that there's a "helmet" connection to many of these puzzles. A "secrete" was a form of skullcap helmet and this is the first time I ever heard of a caul while reading about Polish wunderkind "Walter" Valentino Liberace, who was a child prodigy pianist who's first regular paying job was at the Plankington Hotel's Red Room, the site of the circle of stairs. Does the cowl worn by the woman in image 10 act as a clue to consider a child known to be born with a "caul", meaning they will be lucky or successful? I found a citation from a book published in 2000. Would be nice to see the citation that book used. Was there a famous interview around 1980 where Liberace spoke of his birth story? I have to wonder if Liberace's importance to this puzzle is simply to connect his middle name Valentino with the name of the fantasy fiction character Lord Valentine, the juggler,



Lord Valentine's Castle was published by Bantam Books Publishing in 1980, it won the Locus Award in 1981. This is the cover art from July 9th, 1981.

"The locus of a point moving at a fixed distance from a center point is a circle".

The word "locus" is found in the word "locust".

This is making me dizzy. Just out of curiousity I googled "Silverberg and Preiss" and discovered they collaborated on The Ultimate Dinosaur (1992). I wonder if Silverberg ever said, "yo, I like the juggler painting you used in The Secret..."

Wikimapia measures the Plankington Arcade at approx. 2.243 miles from Locust Ave. I've carefully measured the line extending along the 200 degree mark to a spot that looks extremely close to 100 meters northwest of Kosciuszko Park. Walk 100 steps southeast (you'll have to cut through the southwest corner of the Montesorri School)and you're standing at the northwest corner of Kosy Park.

E: I was unable to find any good citations for where Liberace's birth story was discussed prior to 1982. I'm going to have to consider the hood/cowl on the woman as not a clue to the effect of being a "caul" reference. It seemed too far fetched to begin with. The Liberace connection to the Plankington Arcade is also a bit over-the-top, so nix Liberace from the list of usable references. The Robert Silverberg book cover is still a great comparison, but I feel it does nothing purposeful. I can't recall the details of the story, not that it matters.

Urban Smurf fucked around with this message at 04:35 on Jul 24, 2013

TipsyMc
Sep 5, 2004

I visited BYOB and all I got was this lousy avatar

Merlot Brougham posted:

Cask 10 / Verse 8 - Milwaukee


Looks like quite few people went there to cast in copper. I know you've been working on that interpretation.

Edit:
To contribute, I haven't been following Milwaukee as close as some of the others, but I quite liked this comparison that TipsyMc posted on page 41. Unfortunately, it didn't seem to gain too much traction. Did I miss something that caused this to get dismissed?





I thought it was a good clue :shrug: You could see the City Hall spires from the location of that sculpture, much like in the painting.
Much of the area where the sculpture is (the Riverwalk) went through extensive renovations in the late 80's. I'm kind of leaning to the idea that if the cask was buried around there, it's long gone.

crashdome
Jun 28, 2011
While I think the 92 steps is a strong clue as its more exact than the grand staircase as far as we know, I'm not going to make any definte conclusions based off one or two clues. I wasn't the only one looking around there also. Don't give me too much credit. I just wanted to record visually all the staircases we think fit so we can expand from there. One reason I want to get to city hall is to verify through pics the 92 steps there too. I'll go back to the grand staircase also. One thing I've learned from reading this thread is small assumptions stated without solid proof seem to carry on as fact and I want to avoid that as much as possible in my own investigation of these theories and to help get others who don't live here some "on the ground" assistance.

So throw out your ideas and I'll try and visit them in my spare time. Although it seems I've been very busy lately. So, it'll most likely be visits to areas as I happen by and have the moment to snap a few pics.

GWBBQ
Jan 2, 2005


einTier posted:

Just one problem. That compass is part of an art display called The Wisconsin Workers Memorial. It was built in 1995. :(

You can see more pictures of it here, if you like. According to wikipedia, this display takes up most of the park. Anyone have any idea what the park looked like before?

quote:

In 1835 five Milwaukee pioneers: Byron Kilbourn, Solomon Juneau, Albert Fowler, James McCarty and Archibald Clybourn donated the 1.2 acre site to the City of Milwaukee.

The park, originally known as Union Square, is bounded by West Michigan Street on the north, West Everett on the south between North Third and North Fourth Streets. This site became the first public park within the City of Milwaukee.

The City of Milwaukee subsequently renamed the park Fourth Ward Square, which it was called when the site was ultimately turned over to Milwaukee County as part of the consolidation of parks in 1937.

During the 1950’s, the Milwaukee County Board named the park Pere Marquette. This move coincided with the receipt of a gift from Marquette High School of a life-size marble statue of Father Marquette which was placed in the park. (A bronze replica of the original statue now stands in the current Pere Marquette Park).

In the 1960’s, the site was renamed Carl F. Zeidler Park in honor of the former Mayor. Carl Zeidler, a Milwaukee born and educated lawyer, who became the City’s 33rd mayor in 1940 when he defeated Daniel Hoan. In 1942, Zeidler left office to become an officer in the U.S. Navy. Later that same year the ship he was serving aboard was torpedoed and all hands were lost. His younger brother Frank served as Milwaukee mayor from 1948 to 1960.

Zeidler Union Square came into being in 1995 when the County Board renamed the park to recognize the contributions of the labor movement in Milwaukee County’s history.

The Milwaukee County Labor Council AFL-CIO constructed a new gazebo/bandstand within the park. This facility, which contains features that symbolize various elements of the labor movement, replaced an aging bandstand which had been donated by Blue Cross of Wisconsin in 1977.

Thanks to the generosity of several civic-minded individuals almost 165 years ago as well as more recent contributions by business and labor, Zeidler Union Square is able to provide an oasis of green in the heart of downtown Milwaukee.

crashdome
Jun 28, 2011
Milwaukee

That's all super but, the statue the compass is on was, as far as I can find, established in 1995. Especially since it also has a pc keyboard as part of the elements. I'd love to be proven wrong though.

Edit: actually, Nevermind me. I'm not sure what the purpose of that quote is regarding.

Edit again: ok after getting my head out of my rear end and finally rereading the last few posts, I tried to find bandstand pics but failed. Also, it's sorta in the wrong direction anyways. There is grass along the river. Maybe something worth checking in that direction.

crashdome fucked around with this message at 23:16 on Jul 21, 2013

GWBBQ
Jan 2, 2005


I was just sharing what I was able to find about the history of the park. Google results are a pain in the rear end to sort through and the Milwaukee Historical Society doesn't have anything relevant available online.

crashdome
Jun 28, 2011
^^ Yeah, I finally figured out what you were saying. I don't know why I was so confused at first.

I guess that makes it worth a visit and maybe even asking a few people about it.

Here's areas of high interest to me in Milwaukee that I plan on visiting:

The "new" Pere Marquette Park
Zeidler Park (The "old" Pere Marquette Park)
The area where the Milwaukee River meets the Menomonee River
Lake Park (again)
Northwestern Mutual Building

I tried to look in other areas outside the center of the city but, I feel the trail goes too cold too quickly.

TipsyMc posted:

I thought it was a good clue :shrug: You could see the City Hall spires from the location of that sculpture, much like in the painting.
Much of the area where the sculpture is (the Riverwalk) went through extensive renovations in the late 80's. I'm kind of leaning to the idea that if the cask was buried around there, it's long gone.

Pere Marquette is across from it and yes, that might make it an "impossible" find.

Urban Smurf
Jun 12, 2013

Take this avatar, rotate it 180 degrees, mirror it, mark a point from the tip of the dogs noses and you will see it will line up to this image of the centaurs tail "exactly."
Milwaukee



Some thoughts on this compass theory,

The solution method doesnt really look too complicated. Step 1: find a place near City Hall that has 92 steps. Step 2: use a compass set from locus to Locust and draw a circle on your map. Step 3: look for a place that is 100 paces southeast from a point on the circle that fits with the remaining lines of poem. Step 4: find birch trees. Step 5: find proud tall fifth, Kosciuszko and his funky hat. Step 6: find tree that fits cape outline, its like the Chicago arch or Cleveland wall sketches. Step 7: rack your brain to fit the final pieces together...

Why place 0 degree mark at top? It could've been set at the 3 o'clock position (as is common in angle positioning), but since Locust Ave. seemed like the first nearest point of concern, let's set that as zero.

The "walk 100 paces" line serves as an error correction, since the convenience of choosing a radius distance on the map that matches perfectly with Locust Ave. only brings the arc close to Kosciuszko Park. The most direct route of "foot travel" involves cutting across the diagonal edge of the school's sports field. There's a row of houses there and some fencing to prevent travel. I don't know if that was the case in 1981. I don't know if it matters that much. Preiss could've went through the open entrance to the field on the Windlake Ave. side and then counted paces along that edge of field that connects to the Becher St. entrance to Kosciuszko Park.



I've found a birch tree just south of this main entrance along 9th street. Using aerials I believe I've found 3 more birch trees that you would pass in order to get to the Kosciuszko monument.

Confirmation of this birch tree count should be easy once someone has the time to take a 10-15 minute stroll through the park.

E: also, a good reason for the two words "and reach" that follow the line "Pass the compass..." might be to fit the 100 paces correction to get to the park entrance.

Here's some approximation from the wikimapia tool:

Urban Smurf fucked around with this message at 04:53 on Jul 24, 2013

crashdome
Jun 28, 2011
Milwaukee

I just checked that location out for you. I want to point out I have bias in that I don't subscribe to your theory at all as it makes no use of various keywords in the poem. I am, however, going past that park everyday and I am more than happy to investigate anything if I can do so easily. I tried to look around without any bias and I will say that your birch tree count does not add up no matter how much I tried. The 4th Birch you pointed out via PM to me just isn't there.

Click for crappy panorama of the location of the 4th birch tree I tried to take:


Here is a sub-set of pics I took as I biked through the park using the guide you gave me via PM.
I tried to title the pics as descriptive as I could.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/97715723@N04/sets/72157634756599338/with/9344668183/

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

grendelspov
Jun 12, 2008

fishbone posted:

Cask 3


"Look north at the wing
And dig
To achieve
By dauntless and inconquerable
Determination
Your goal."


North of the Elizabethan Gardens, at the end of the path through the Water Gate, looking north from beach, you can see the Wright Brothers Memorial way off in the distance

It's shape?


Thank you... "look north at the wing" makes a ton of sense in this interpretation. As someone who lives nearby and visits this area often, I really don't think that anyone would bury something on the beach or in dunes, etc, though. They're way to transient, even over short periods of time.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply