Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
HookShot
Dec 26, 2005
Yeah, I have a couple credit cards I've had since 2006 or so that I use regularly and never close, I usually apply for 1-2 cards every 3-6 months, and so far it's never affected my credit so badly that I've been denied.

I'm also not looking to buy property in the next couple years either, when I get to that point I'll slow down on the churning and go a year without doing it or something, but I really doubt it has any real long term effect on my credit score, especially since I close the accounts within a year anyway.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Lexicon
Jul 29, 2003

I had a beer with Stephen Harper once and now I like him.

HookShot posted:

I usually apply for 1-2 cards every 3-6 months

Good lord! Gaming the signup bonuses I presume?! ;)

slidebite
Nov 6, 2005

Good egg
:colbert:

FrozenVent posted:

Your credit score is not a video game high score, there's no sense in min / maxing it. Close the cards.
I realize it's not a video game but the flip side is they're not hurting me/costing me anything by keeping them either and the open credit isn't massive. They're not in my wallet or used so the chance of theft is pretty much zero.

That said the point is taken and I will cancel them. It's not like I should keep them for perpetuity if I never plan to use them.

For interests sakes, I will see if I can get my credit score now and check again in 6 months to see what the difference is. Anyone know of any deals/codes for FICO score power?

melon cat
Jan 21, 2010

Nap Ghost

FrozenVent posted:

Your credit score is not a video game high score, there's no sense in min / maxing it. Close the cards.
Hold on there. Unless the cards are carrying a high balance/non-competitive interest rate, I wouldn't go ahead and just close them. If they're an active, healthy credit account closing them can actually hurt your chances of approval if you apply for credit applications later on.

melon cat fucked around with this message at 22:02 on Feb 4, 2024

HookShot
Dec 26, 2005

Lexicon posted:

Good lord! Gaming the signup bonuses I presume?! ;)

Yeah, exactly. As I said, in the last seven months I've gotten enough for a free round trip ticket to Europe.

tuyop
Sep 15, 2006

Every second that we're not growing BASIL is a second wasted

Fun Shoe

HookShot posted:

Yeah, exactly. As I said, in the last seven months I've gotten enough for a free round trip ticket to Europe.

Teach me, please.

blah_blah
Apr 15, 2006

tuyop posted:

Teach me, please.

Easiest first step is to cycle through the two Amex Aeroplan or Aeroplan equivalent cards -- the Amex Gold Rewards and the Amex Aeroplan Plus Gold to get 25k+30k = 55k Aeroplan points. You need a referral to max out the points, otherwise you get 45k -- PM me if you want one. Both cards require $500 of spending in 3 months (trivial) and have no annual fee for the first year. Then I guess you could get the new TD Aeroplan Visa Infinite with the first year fee waived (might have to ask for this at a branch or on the phone) for 15k points (mediocre). That gets you up to 70k Aeroplan without any fees in the first year (you can always cancel later) and the Amex cards also have pretty great rewards in general. Then get your partner to do the same for 90k more points (by referring her).

namaste friends
Sep 18, 2004

by Smythe
If it's not status points, they're worthless.

HookShot
Dec 26, 2005

blah_blah posted:

Easiest first step is to cycle through the two Amex Aeroplan or Aeroplan equivalent cards -- the Amex Gold Rewards and the Amex Aeroplan Plus Gold to get 25k+30k = 55k Aeroplan points. You need a referral to max out the points, otherwise you get 45k -- PM me if you want one. Both cards require $500 of spending in 3 months (trivial) and have no annual fee for the first year. Then I guess you could get the new TD Aeroplan Visa Infinite with the first year fee waived (might have to ask for this at a branch or on the phone) for 15k points (mediocre). That gets you up to 70k Aeroplan without any fees in the first year (you can always cancel later) and the Amex cards also have pretty great rewards in general. Then get your partner to do the same for 90k more points (by referring her).
This is all excellent advice. Minor detail - it's 20k points for the CIBC card. They also have two cards available, the regular and the gold Aeroplan, and you can have one of each at the same time.

Some other points:
- Amex has a policy that a person can have two charge cards and two credit cards at the same time, so you can have as many as four Amex cards at any given point. CIBC will only let you have one of each of their cards at once. TD is new to the Aeroplan stuff, I don't know what their policies are yet.
- I always apply for cards in pairs. Apply for one, wait a couple days, apply for another. Then I wait at least three, but not more than six months before I start applying for new ones.
- Use a calendar that you will check regularly and make sure you put an appointment to cancel the card after nine or ten months.
- Sometimes referrals to yourself work, but not always. Referrals to/from your spouse will always work. However, you have to have an Amex first before you can get in on that sweet, sweet spouse referral action.
- The business cards often give better bonuses than the personal cards. Since I have a business, I definitely take advantage of it.

With the Amex cards, sometimes they offer bonuses for transferring to BA Avios. I think it's about twice a year, you get a 25% bonus. Aeroplan also offer bonuses for transferring to their program from time to time. The last one was in December, the bonuses sucked, but it was still something. I usually wait for the bonus offers before I transfer my Amex points to Aeroplan. I don't do Avios so I don't know how that program works/whether it's worth it.


The main thing to consider with Aeroplan is that you want to use it for overseas travel only. This is because Air Canada and a number of other airlines charge "fuel surcharges" that are usually around 50% of the price of the regular ticket and makes it completely pointless to use the points. It's easy to find a list of airlines that are part of the Star Alliance that don't charge a fuel surcharge, and so I recommend sticking with those exclusively.

One of the big ADVANTAGES is you can use Aeoplan points to do a "mini RTW" as they're called. I'm basically stealing this from FlyerTalk, since I'm too lazy to write it out myself:

quote:

The Mini-RTW is a name given to a type of reward booking using Air Canada's Aeroplan miles. It is actually not a "round-the-world" ticket at all - it is a regular award redemption. Just as you would use 75K frequent flyer miles to go to Japan on another airline, you can use 75K to do so using Aeroplan miles. The difference is that Aeroplan allows you to "stopover" in multiple cities at no extra mileage cost, making it very attractive compared to other reward travel. It should be noted that this isn't really that much better than some other airlines. For example, Delta offers one stopover + open jaw, which is only one stopover worse than Aeroplan's deal. But many of the airlines only offer one stopover and no open jaw. So there is definitely value here.

In addition to your final destination (in which you can stay for days/weeks/months), you are allowed:

•Two stopovers in other cities (stay for days/weeks/months). You are allowed to trade one of these stopovers for an open jaw (where you land in one city, but take the next flight out of another city)
•10 segments (layovers during which you spend less than 24 hours in a given city)

So, disregarding the additional 10 segments, an award trip for Japan could actually look like this:

NYC > Tokyo (destination - one week) > Paris (stopover - one week) > London (stopover - one week) > NYC

You basically get three times the world exploration for the price of one. If you add on the extra layovers allowed, you can turn it into:

NYC > Los Angeles (one day) > Hawaii (one day) > Tokyo (one week) > Seoul (one day) > Hong Kong (one day) > Paris (one week) > Munich (one day) > London (one week) > Washington DC (one day) > NYC

Of course, you don't have to do the above. Spending so much time in airports can be exhausting. But the option is there for you if you want it.


Cultural Imperial posted:

If it's not status points, they're worthless.
Not if you like free plane tickets, they aren't. I put a lot of my everyday spending on the CIBC Aeroplan which gets me "distinction" points, which are basically the same as status points.

blah_blah
Apr 15, 2006

HookShot posted:

The main thing to consider with Aeroplan is that you want to use it for overseas travel only. This is because Air Canada and a number of other airlines charge "fuel surcharges" that are usually around 50% of the price of the regular ticket and makes it completely pointless to use the points. It's easy to find a list of airlines that are part of the Star Alliance that don't charge a fuel surcharge, and so I recommend sticking with those exclusively.

It's definitely not the most efficient redemption in existence but North American flights aren't that bad, YVR - SFO on AC/United (which is something I fly several times a year) is usually around $550 for round-trip direct flights in the best case scenario, or 25k Aeroplan points + $170 in ridiculous fees. So the miles still save me around $400 per flight.

EgonSpengler
Jun 7, 2000
Forum Veteran
When we used to fly Air Canada to northern BC Aeroplan points were a great deal. 15000 points would knock $500 off the price of the ticket. Since Westjet started flying into the region the competition has pushed prices down, so the value isn't as good anymore, saves about $300 on the same points cost.

I also flew business class to Europe a couple years back, but this was before Star Alliance partners started passing on the full taxes through Aeroplan. The value of redeeming Aeroplan is certainly lower than it was in the past.

tuyop
Sep 15, 2006

Every second that we're not growing BASIL is a second wasted

Fun Shoe

HookShot posted:

Free air travel :words:

Oh man, this is so much better than maybe having a good credit score.

EgonSpengler
Jun 7, 2000
Forum Veteran
Okay, so I just finished test running 3 different foreign exchange options, since I need to move a larger amount of funds into Canada next month. I'm moving Euros to CDN, so Norbert's Gambit isn't an option. Previously I had been using wire transfers from my bank in Europe, but the fees & exchange rate were just stupid. I tested converting a small transfer with each of them, because I'm paranoid about a five-figure number disappearing into the ether.

https://www.xe.com: I can not recommend them. Getting my money to them was easy enough, but they choked hard on transferring my funds to Canada. It took a week to resolve, and when the money arrived 7% of it was missing. The exchange rate was also the worst of the options I tried. Will contact them to find out what happened to the funds. All told they were 2.5% over mid-market, and the transfer to Canada was hit with a total of $12 in fees.

Vancouver Bullion & Currency Exchange Online (http://online.vbce.ca): I've been using their retail service in Vancouver for years, so I was already a fan. They always had the best retail rates on foreign currency, and before I moved to Europe they were quite convenient. In the last year or so they started offering an online service, which I finally set up. They scale the rate based on the volume, so a 100€ transaction would be 2% over mid-market, getting smaller with larger transactions. Best part was they did not charge any transfer fees on top of this. The cons are their website sucks once you create an account, it looks like an internal tool that's been released to the wild.

http://currencyfair.com: Probably the best option for large transfers available so far. Their prices vary based on what's being offered, but right now they are 0.9% over mid-market, and given the way their shop works (peer-to-peer trading) it can go lower than that. They charge $4 CDN for transferring the funds to Canada.

Given the fees and the differences in exchange rates, for small transactions (<$400) VBCE is probably the best bet. XE.com has a worse exchange rate and charges fees on the transfer, so they lose against everyone but my bank's wire transfer.

For transactions above $400, the exchange rate difference from CurrencyFair cancels out their $4 charge.

Looking at all of the sites, the spread on USD to Canadian is lower. Fees might vary with different banks & currencies as well, like I said, this is all about moving Euros to Canadian dollars.

HookShot
Dec 26, 2005

tuyop posted:

Oh man, this is so much better than maybe having a good credit score.
It totally is!


And yeah, I should correct that somehow flying north in Canada is still a great, great deal with Air Canada. I looked at flights to the Yukon and it was something like $150 in fees round trip, and those flights usually go for ridiculous amounts of money.


blah_blah posted:

It's definitely not the most efficient redemption in existence but North American flights aren't that bad, YVR - SFO on AC/United (which is something I fly several times a year) is usually around $550 for round-trip direct flights in the best case scenario, or 25k Aeroplan points + $170 in ridiculous fees. So the miles still save me around $400 per flight.

Oh nice, maybe it's not so bad domestically then. I've never actually used them for flights within North America, but I've looked up flights to Europe where the fuel surcharge was over $600, on top of the 60,000 point redemption.

Lexicon
Jul 29, 2003

I had a beer with Stephen Harper once and now I like him.

EgonSpengler posted:

:words: about currency

I have no idea if this will benefit you, but have you considered wiring it over as Euros? I think Scotiabank has the possibility for an EUR-denominated account. It might be more useful once it's over here to try and get a good rate.

Also, there's a possibility that you might be able to go EUR => USD, then USD => CAD (via Norbert) cheaper than the straight EUR => CAD transfer.

Good luck!

Kalenn Istarion
Nov 2, 2012

Maybe Senpai will finally notice me now that I've dropped :fivebux: on this snazzy av

Lexicon posted:

Does anyone here use the BMO World Elite Mastercard? I'm typically philosophically opposed to annual credit card fees, but the benefits for this seem actually well worth the $150 (after 2nd year) annual cost (rental car coverage, extended travel insurance, 2% of purchases for travel, airport lounge access).

I have one of these, it's unequivocally great, as long as you expect to spend >$7,500 per year on the card. We basically put everything on cards and then just pay it off every month so this is easy for our spending patterns. You do need to use their custom travel booking website (unless it's changed recently), but the service is subcontracted to Carlson Wagonlit who does all sorts of corporate / reward travel booking. They have access to the same prices and flights that anyone else does, and has a system for travel packages as well as individually booking flights and hotels, etc.

I also have a TD First Class Travel Visa Infinite. On that one you get 1.5% on all purchases in points, and 4.5% on any travel purchases. The points are redeemable on expediafortd.com (so basically expedia), which again gets pretty much the same pricing as any other major online booking site. I like both because once in a while you get a little better pricing on one or the other, and the BMO service is actually better at getting the flight ticket level you want (assuming you ever want something other than the absolute cheapest economy fare). For example, we just booked a trip to Hawaii. I used the BMO points that I had banked for about half off the flight as we wanted Tango Plus fares for the status, and used my TD points on the hotel. 3 days later, I already had 4.5% of my hotel booking back in points, so used those to book a dirt cheap flight to a goonp in the US next month. I tend to use the TD card a bit more, but they're both good programs.

e: both cards also have things like extended warranty and product loss insurance, as well as collision damage coverage on rentals. For example, I had a $400 camera replaced 5 days after I bought it when I dropped it in a lake. A different time, some shithead knocked the mirror off a rental car in a parking lot. I wasn't there, so didn't have anyone to make a claim against, but I just called Visa and they spoke to the rental company and it just went away - never even saw a damage bill.

Kalenn Istarion fucked around with this message at 19:40 on Jan 29, 2014

EgonSpengler
Jun 7, 2000
Forum Veteran

Lexicon posted:

I have no idea if this will benefit you, but have you considered wiring it over as Euros? I think Scotiabank has the possibility for an EUR-denominated account. It might be more useful once it's over here to try and get a good rate.

Also, there's a possibility that you might be able to go EUR => USD, then USD => CAD (via Norbert) cheaper than the straight EUR => CAD transfer.

Good luck!

International wire transfers hit me with some pretty steep fees. I sent 2000€ through my bank last month and I paid 35€ just in wire charges alone, which is what prompted me to find a better solution. Sending money within the EU is free, and the online services I mentioned all have European accounts set up to receive funds. The Scotiabank account isn't terrible as a place to hold Euros, but it doesn't offer me much more once the funds are in there. I still need to transfer them to Canadian dollars, and the banks aren't going to give a better rate.

I see where you are going with the second suggestion. I would need to set up a US dollar account to receive the funds, as well as set up a non-registered trading account. CurrencyFair has a better exchange on Euro -> US than Euro to CDN, so in theory it could be better, but given the $19.90 fee on a single Norbert's Gambit it's probably not worth the hassle. That said, I'll price it out once I actually have the funds, I'll be in Canada in two months and I can set up new accounts if I need to.

Lexicon
Jul 29, 2003

I had a beer with Stephen Harper once and now I like him.

EgonSpengler posted:

International wire transfers hit me with some pretty steep fees. I sent 2000€ through my bank last month and I paid 35€ just in wire charges alone, which is what prompted me to find a better solution. Sending money within the EU is free, and the online services I mentioned all have European accounts set up to receive funds. The Scotiabank account isn't terrible as a place to hold Euros, but it doesn't offer me much more once the funds are in there. I still need to transfer them to Canadian dollars, and the banks aren't going to give a better rate.

I see where you are going with the second suggestion. I would need to set up a US dollar account to receive the funds, as well as set up a non-registered trading account. CurrencyFair has a better exchange on Euro -> US than Euro to CDN, so in theory it could be better, but given the $19.90 fee on a single Norbert's Gambit it's probably not worth the hassle. That said, I'll price it out once I actually have the funds, I'll be in Canada in two months and I can set up new accounts if I need to.

I wasn't too sure what volumes of cash you were talking. If it's 6 figures or so, it may be worth figuring out some sort of scheme along the lines I mentioned. Otherwise, you're probably better off with VCBE or similar.

I will add that I used to use XE occasionally, and I always had good results with them over a usage period of quite a few years. That was always USD <=> CAD though, sometimes between Canadian banks and sometimes cross border. I've since gotten into NG, which of course is a far better option for that particular currency pair.

Lexicon
Jul 29, 2003

I had a beer with Stephen Harper once and now I like him.

Kalenn Istarion posted:

I have one of these, it's unequivocally great, as long as you expect to spend >$7,500 per year on the card. We basically put everything on cards and then just pay it off every month so this is easy for our spending patterns. You do need to use their custom travel booking website (unless it's changed recently), but the service is subcontracted to Carlson Wagonlit who does all sorts of corporate / reward travel booking. They have access to the same prices and flights that anyone else does, and has a system for travel packages as well as individually booking flights and hotels, etc.

Thanks - I think I might switch over to this then. The free first year definitely helps as an incentive to try it out, and I will comfortably hit that spending limit as I also charge everything monthly and then pay it off.

Kalenn Istarion
Nov 2, 2012

Maybe Senpai will finally notice me now that I've dropped :fivebux: on this snazzy av

Lexicon posted:

Thanks - I think I might switch over to this then. The free first year definitely helps as an incentive to try it out, and I will comfortably hit that spending limit as I also charge everything monthly and then pay it off.

I used to be able to put my business expenses on my personal card as well - the points I accrued were hilarious. I travel a lot for work so was getting 7.5% of every business trip back as travel funds (the TD card used to have an even better rate on travel). I ended up going to Turks, St. Lucia, and Barbados mostly on points over a few years. Since it sounds like you're self-employed, you might still be able to get away with that. Sadly, my current employer now requires using a corporate card.

Lexicon
Jul 29, 2003

I had a beer with Stephen Harper once and now I like him.

Kalenn Istarion posted:

I used to be able to put my business expenses on my personal card as well - the points I accrued were hilarious. I travel a lot for work so was getting 7.5% of every business trip back as travel funds (the TD card used to have an even better rate on travel). I ended up going to Turks, St. Lucia, and Barbados mostly on points over a few years. Since it sounds like you're self-employed, you might still be able to get away with that. Sadly, my current employer now requires using a corporate card.

I totally could get away with this for my business expenses - I currently have a separate card for those. It's a bit of a pain to co-mingle business and personal expenses though - it's unfortunate you can't have separate 'ledgers' within a single credit card account.

Kalenn Istarion
Nov 2, 2012

Maybe Senpai will finally notice me now that I've dropped :fivebux: on this snazzy av

Lexicon posted:

I totally could get away with this for my business expenses - I currently have a separate card for those. It's a bit of a pain to co-mingle business and personal expenses though - it's unfortunate you can't have separate 'ledgers' within a single credit card account.

Arguably you could just get a second (points) card for your business stuff, but the other option is to just keep receipts for your business stuff. I just had a folder next to my desk at home where I'd drop stuff at the end of the day and then take them into the office to file for cash reimbursement monthly or so. I made a short note on what each one was for. Not sure how picky Rev Canada is but see no reason that wouldn't be sufficient evidence for them as well.

Lexicon
Jul 29, 2003

I had a beer with Stephen Harper once and now I like him.

Kalenn Istarion posted:

Arguably you could just get a second (points) card for your business stuff, but the other option is to just keep receipts for your business stuff. I just had a folder next to my desk at home where I'd drop stuff at the end of the day and then take them into the office to file for cash reimbursement monthly or so. I made a short note on what each one was for. Not sure how picky Rev Canada is but see no reason that wouldn't be sufficient evidence for them as well.

I do keep receipts (fully paperless in Evernote) but my accountant also insisted that I get a separate card for business expenses to eliminate the inevitable headache of working out what belongs to what on a unified card.

Saltin
Aug 20, 2003
Don't touch

Kalenn Istarion posted:


I also have a TD First Class Travel Visa Infinite. On that one you get 1.5% on all purchases in points, and 4.5% on any travel purchases. The points are redeemable on expediafortd.com (so basically expedia), which again gets pretty much the same pricing as any other major online booking site. I like both because once in a while you get a little better pricing on one or the other, and the BMO service is actually better at getting the flight ticket level you want (assuming you ever want something other than the absolute cheapest economy fare). For example, we just booked a trip to Hawaii. I used the BMO points that I had banked for about half off the flight as we wanted Tango Plus fares for the status, and used my TD points on the hotel. 3 days later, I already had 4.5% of my hotel booking back in points, so used those to book a dirt cheap flight to a goonp in the US next month. I tend to use the TD card a bit more, but they're both good programs.


I switched to this card about 6 months ago and it's been working out pretty well. It's worth mentioning that not only are the points redeemable on the TDrewards/Expedia Scheme, but you can just straight up apply them against any travel. I booked directly through British Airways to get to Dublin for a wedding earlier this month and applied my points to the Credit Card charge from British Airways. It took a couple of days, but it totally works and lets you use the points to do things like finding the absolute cheapest flight or spend more on business class, etc.

One of the other things I like about it is I get an SMS every time it is used. I didn't have that service with my previous TD card (or maybe just wasn't aware of it), but it's a great feature, especially paired with zero liability guarantee if the card is used fraudulently.

Saltin fucked around with this message at 23:53 on Jan 29, 2014

A Jupiter
Apr 25, 2010

>

A Jupiter fucked around with this message at 02:33 on Apr 23, 2020

blah_blah
Apr 15, 2006

I have had a TD First Class Visa Infinite for at least 5 years now and it's been my main card until about 6 months ago. To be honest, it's a pretty mediocre card and definitely not a card worth paying an annual fee for (I always got the fee waived through my Select Service account). I guess it could be an okay card if you are booking lots of travel through the TD/Expedia website, but that's kind of an edge case. I did some quick math and each Aeroplan point is worth around 1.7c to me, and most of the midrange Aeroplan cards have bonus categories and hence probably generate closer to 1.25-1.5 points per dollar on average. Also, the signup bonus is just atrocious -- would you rather have 25000 Aeroplan points (worth around $400-450 to me) or $100 in Expedia credit?

That being said, if you do have a TD Select Service account, it's an okay card for $0 and a Visa (as opposed to, say, an Amex) so by all means pick one up.

HookShot
Dec 26, 2005

blah_blah posted:

I have had a TD First Class Visa Infinite for at least 5 years now and it's been my main card until about 6 months ago. To be honest, it's a pretty mediocre card and definitely not a card worth paying an annual fee for (I always got the fee waived through my Select Service account). I guess it could be an okay card if you are booking lots of travel through the TD/Expedia website, but that's kind of an edge case. I did some quick math and each Aeroplan point is worth around 1.7c to me, and most of the midrange Aeroplan cards have bonus categories and hence probably generate closer to 1.25-1.5 points per dollar on average. Also, the signup bonus is just atrocious -- would you rather have 25000 Aeroplan points (worth around $400-450 to me) or $100 in Expedia credit?

That being said, if you do have a TD Select Service account, it's an okay card for $0 and a Visa (as opposed to, say, an Amex) so by all means pick one up.

I agree with basically all of this, mine is my main recurring expense card since I've had it for years, and I don't pay the annual fee for it either with my select service account. But yeah, I wouldn't pay the annual fee for it at all. It's handy for booking hotels/car rentals, I will give it that.

blah_blah
Apr 15, 2006

Not sure if this keeps with the overall theme of the thread, but I just learned here that AC doesn't apply fuel surcharges for joint flights operated by their US-based partners. This means that if you're redeeming Aeroplan points for joint United/AC (for example) flights, you can save a ton of money by making sure you choose a United-operated flight instead of an AC-operated flight. For my SFO-YVR example the difference is $70.

FrozenVent
May 1, 2009

The Boeing 737-200QC is the undisputed workhorse of the skies.
Had a beer with a guy last night who's pretty convinced the Canadian housing market has already crashed, and it's smooth sailing from here on out as log as the rates stay low.

Thank god he can't afford a house.

whatupdet
Aug 13, 2004

I'm sorry John, I don't remember
Are there any cards where you can use points to cover fuel/taxes surcharges? I have Air Miles (BMO MC & AMEX) and it seems it's best suited for Canada/US travel as the charges are usually in the $150-230 range, whereas going overseas (to Europe for example) you're looking at $450-700 and sometimes I can get a return flight for under $1k so you're not saving much but using a ton of Air Miles.

Arabian Jesus
Feb 15, 2008

We've got the American Jesus
Bolstering national faith

We've got the American Jesus
Overwhelming millions every day

A Jupiter posted:

After reading through this thread and getting some more insight, I've decided to open up a TD Direct Investing account and start putting money into the e-Series index funds.

I have a crappy TD TFSA Mutual Fund account right now with a ridiculously high MER, so do I open up a new TFSA account on the TD Waterhouse website and move all my funds there? Will this be a roll-over or will this count towards my $5500 a year that I can put into TFSAs?

Also, I am going with a 40% bonds, 20% on Canadian, US and international equity each mix. I'm a fairly average, young student in my early 20s with occasional income from research fellowships, so I don't have that much capital. I am mainly looking to save money without just leaving it in a savings account doing nothing. Is this couch potato strategy still good for me? I'm looking to put maybe $5000-7000 into the index funds in total this year.

It's crazy I didn't have this knowledge before, thanks again the people in this thread!

I'm essentially in the same spot, have all the paperwork to open an e-series account. I'm just curious, I have a tfsa with PC Financial already is there a way I can transfer funds from my PC to the e-series account without effecting my contribution room? Would it be easier to open a tfsa with TD?

I also want to thank everybody in this thread, the knowledge here is priceless.

Saltin
Aug 20, 2003
Don't touch

Arabian Jesus posted:

I'm just curious, I have a tfsa with PC Financial already is there a way I can transfer funds from my PC to the e-series account without effecting my contribution room? Would it be easier to open a tfsa with TD?

You would ask PC to make a direct transfer to your new TD TFSA. As long as you don't withdraw the funds yourself, it's all good. If you withdraw them yourself and then deposit them to the new TFSA, that is considered a contribution, if they do a direct transfer for you, it's smooth sailing.

Kal Torak
Jul 17, 2003

When Giles sends me on a mission, he says "please". And afterwards I get a cookie.

whatupdet posted:

Are there any cards where you can use points to cover fuel/taxes surcharges? I have Air Miles (BMO MC & AMEX) and it seems it's best suited for Canada/US travel as the charges are usually in the $150-230 range, whereas going overseas (to Europe for example) you're looking at $450-700 and sometimes I can get a return flight for under $1k so you're not saving much but using a ton of Air Miles.

Just get a card that allows you to claim credits for travel instead of having to book through their travel agents or use aeroplan/airmiles. I have the Capital One Aspire World MasterCard that has been mentioned in this thread a few times and it is great. You can redeem points for any travel at any time. The rewards you receive are worth 2%. For instance, if you spend 30K, you get 60K in points which allows you to redeem for $600 worth of travel. I've had this card for about 3 or 4 years and wouldn't even consider switching.

Lexicon
Jul 29, 2003

I had a beer with Stephen Harper once and now I like him.

A Jupiter posted:

After reading through this thread and getting some more insight, I've decided to open up a TD Direct Investing account and start putting money into the e-Series index funds.

I have a crappy TD TFSA Mutual Fund account right now with a ridiculously high MER, so do I open up a new TFSA account on the TD Waterhouse website and move all my funds there? Will this be a roll-over or will this count towards my $5500 a year that I can put into TFSAs?

Also, I am going with a 40% bonds, 20% on Canadian, US and international equity each mix. I'm a fairly average, young student in my early 20s with occasional income from research fellowships, so I don't have that much capital. I am mainly looking to save money without just leaving it in a savings account doing nothing. Is this couch potato strategy still good for me? I'm looking to put maybe $5000-7000 into the index funds in total this year.

It's crazy I didn't have this knowledge before, thanks again the people in this thread!

If you're not going to be buying ETFs etc quite yet (I'm making this assumption based on your yearly amounts) why don't you forget about Direct Investing for now and just convert your mutual funds account over to e-series? All you need to do is fill out this form: https://www.tdcanadatrust.com/products-services/investing/mutual-funds/td-eseries-funds.jsp#what-does-td-offer ("convert an existing")

Once that's done, nothing will change in your account, login credentials, etc - except the low MER funds will now be available to you. Then you can sell the high MER ones and switch over to the low MER ones, and set up a purchase automation, etc. You won't need to worry about moving your TFSA either - it'll all stay in one place.

Kashwashwa
Jul 11, 2006
You'll do fine no matter what. That's my motto.
Just a heads up to people trading ETFs using Questrade - for some reason I was assuming you can buy AND SELL ETFs commission free. I think the wording "trade ETFs commission free" is what made me think that. Anyway, it's only buying that is free, you are still charged the commission on selling.

slidebite
Nov 6, 2005

Good egg
:colbert:

Keep in mind fees might be an issue, especially if he just recently bought them on low load.

Lexicon
Jul 29, 2003

I had a beer with Stephen Harper once and now I like him.

slidebite posted:

Keep in mind fees might be an issue, especially if he just recently bought them on low load.

Good point!

Kalenn Istarion
Nov 2, 2012

Maybe Senpai will finally notice me now that I've dropped :fivebux: on this snazzy av

whatupdet posted:

Are there any cards where you can use points to cover fuel/taxes surcharges? I have Air Miles (BMO MC & AMEX) and it seems it's best suited for Canada/US travel as the charges are usually in the $150-230 range, whereas going overseas (to Europe for example) you're looking at $450-700 and sometimes I can get a return flight for under $1k so you're not saving much but using a ton of Air Miles.

The TD First Class and BMO World Elite cards we discussed above both can pay surcharges with points. Think of your points as effectively cash that you can only apply to travel.

The Berzerker
Feb 24, 2006

treat me like a dog


I'm the guarantor for my younger brother's inheritance from our aunt's estate. I'm looking to find an investment guy who knows about this specific type of investment, because there are a lot of rules around what does and doesn't constitute a "good" investment of the money (for example I can't put anything in RESPs even though my brother plans to go to post-secondary, because if he changes his mind before then he'd lose all the gains). How do I start searching for this magical person? I'm in Toronto.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Lexicon
Jul 29, 2003

I had a beer with Stephen Harper once and now I like him.

The Berzerker posted:

I'm the guarantor for my younger brother's inheritance from our aunt's estate. I'm looking to find an investment guy who knows about this specific type of investment, because there are a lot of rules around what does and doesn't constitute a "good" investment of the money (for example I can't put anything in RESPs even though my brother plans to go to post-secondary, because if he changes his mind before then he'd lose all the gains). How do I start searching for this magical person? I'm in Toronto.

No specific advice other than: be careful. These be shark infested waters. Make sure you find someone to give you advice and pay for that advice, not just a glorified salesman who earns money off the particular products that get sold.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply