Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Kaza42
Oct 3, 2013

Blood and Souls and all that

wiegieman posted:

For your empire match, I'd say you definitely kept your foot force way too clumped together. He took a lot less mortar attrition than you did. You also wasted your cavalry. As a rule of thumb, they should never go into the front of a unit, and should definitely not be anywhere near spears or halberds.

Good point about the clumping. I realized how I wasted the cavalry, but didn't notice the mortar thing. Thanks for the advice

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Mukip
Jan 27, 2011

by Reene
A pair of Empire armies going at each other with mortars is fun. Kaza's formations were in the mirror match weren't appropriate. The infantry were too boxy, maximising the value of 420's artillery, and the cavalry should have been set to a wider frontage to maximise their charge. It would have made sense to advance with the infantry to give the cavalry something to play off, rather than charging them off by themselves.

I think an inadequate amount of distracting chaff hurt the Vampire Counts. 420 was able to focus a lot of his army on killing the Vargheists early on because they weren't tied up.

-----------

Now we move onto the second- and losers bracket. There were some big disparities in playing level in the first round but now it should have evened out a bit more.

Rules again:
Funds and unit size: Large
Timer:20 minutes. No stalling or evasive behaviour for the sake of achieving a draw.
Map: Praag for the first match. The loser decides what map to play in subsequent rounds.
Best out of three matches to decide the winner of each round. Post the replays and/or send them to me at muukip@googlemail.com

House rules with new starting map:
*No more than one healing item on the same character
*Max 3 heroes including your lord.
*No corner camping
*Max one summon creature spell per army

Second bracket:
Yukitsu v ClassicFascist
420 Gank Mid v Mukip (http://steamcommunity.com/id/Muukip)
Trujillo (http://steamcommunity.com/id/Sammvt) v ZoninSilver (http://steamcommunity.com/id/ZoninSilverflame/)
Captain Beans v ubercrunchy (steamcommunity.com/id/caedwalla)

Losers (winners at life) bracket:
ZearothK (http://steamcommunity.com/id/adievko/.) v Mr. Wookums (http://steamcommunity.com/id/ThymeForHerb)
Asmodai_00 v Kaza42
Triskelli v rockpete (http://steamcommunity.com/id/guderian/)
Obstacle2 v Vox Nihili ( http://steamcommunity.com/id/VoxNihi1i)

Mukip fucked around with this message at 18:08 on Sep 2, 2016

Trujillo
Jul 10, 2007
*Max one summon creature spell per army

Does that mean you can't summon a cygor and a manticore or that you can only summon once?

Mukip
Jan 27, 2011

by Reene
One, total per army.

Yorkshire Pudding
Nov 24, 2006



Both dwarf heroes look so dumb. What a shame.

Submarine Sandpaper
May 27, 2007


ZearothK I'll be available later today, then Sunday.

Kaza42
Oct 3, 2013

Blood and Souls and all that

Mukip posted:

One, total per army.

Does this apply to Raise Dead too?

Mukip
Jan 27, 2011

by Reene
Hmm. No, just Manticores and Cygors.

Vox Nihili
May 28, 2008

Mukip posted:

A pair of Empire armies going at each other with mortars is fun. Kaza's formations were in the mirror match weren't appropriate. The infantry were too boxy, maximising the value of 420's artillery, and the cavalry should have been set to a wider frontage to maximise their charge. It would have made sense to advance with the infantry to give the cavalry something to play off, rather than charging them off by themselves.

I think an inadequate amount of distracting chaff hurt the Vampire Counts. 420 was able to focus a lot of his army on killing the Vargheists early on because they weren't tied up.

-----------

Now we move onto the second- and losers bracket. There were some big disparities in playing level in the first round but now it should have evened out a bit more.

Rules again:
Funds and unit size: Large
Timer:20 minutes. No stalling or evasive behaviour for the sake of achieving a draw.
Map: Praag for the first match. The loser decides what map to play in subsequent rounds.
Best out of three matches to decide the winner of each round. Post the replays and/or send them to me at muukip@googlemail.com

House rules with new starting map:
*No more than one healing item on the same character
*Max 3 heroes including your lord.
*No corner camping
*Max one summon creature spell per army

Second bracket:
Yukitsu v ClassicFascist
420 Gank Mid v Mukip (http://steamcommunity.com/id/Muukip)
Trujillo (http://steamcommunity.com/id/Sammvt) v ZoninSilver (http://steamcommunity.com/id/ZoninSilverflame/)
Captain Beans v ubercrunchy (steamcommunity.com/id/caedwalla)

Losers (winners at life) bracket:
ZearothK (http://steamcommunity.com/id/adievko/.) v Mr. Wookums (http://steamcommunity.com/id/ThymeForHerb)
Asmodai_00 v Kaza42
Triskelli v rockpete (http://steamcommunity.com/id/guderian/)
Obstacle2 v Vox Nihili ( http://steamcommunity.com/id/VoxNihi1i)

At last, I will achieve my dream of being the big fish in a small pond!

Seriously though, it's pretty amazing how many extremely good players post ITT. Checking the leaderboard was certainly informative.

Internet Explorer
Jun 1, 2005





I haven't participated in the tournament, but just wanted to say thanks for organizing it and thank you to the participants. Just watching the thread and replays has been informational.

TipsyMcStagger
Apr 13, 2013

This isn't where
I parked my car...
Anyone got any good orc versus dwarf videos against AI? I wanna see some tactics.

I've been using a grimgor army of giants since i got frustrated, its been working very well.

Jester Mcgee
Mar 28, 2010

A lot of things have happened to me over my life.

I just picked this up the other day and have had a series of failed starts. I just can't figure out which faction to play as. Which legendary lord is the most powerful in a way that's easy for a complete moron to understand?

ZearothK
Aug 25, 2008

I've lost twice, I've failed twice and I've gotten two dishonorable mentions within 7 weeks. But I keep coming back. I am The Trooper!

THUNDERDOME LOSER 2021


Mr. Wookums posted:

ZearothK I'll be available later today, then Sunday.

Cool, tonight works for me. Added you on Steam, gimme a shout if you see me online and we'll go at it.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Jester Mcgee posted:

I just picked this up the other day and have had a series of failed starts. I just can't figure out which faction to play as. Which legendary lord is the most powerful in a way that's easy for a complete moron to understand?
ungrim. he walks in and melees people to death. dwarfs are really simple to play too, since their gimmick is they're just incredibly tanky.

fnordcircle
Jul 7, 2004

PTUI
If you have Beastmen I think they're the easiest, by far. Get minotaurs and a couple of gorebulls and just flat out win games.

Outside of that DLC, the first time I felt like I was doing well was with Chaos. Honestly it just feels easier to play a horde since you don't have to worry about anything but one army.

Jester Mcgee
Mar 28, 2010

A lot of things have happened to me over my life.

Thanks for the advice guys. I'll probably play dwarves and beastmen for a dozen turns or so and see if either one of them stand out to me.

Gejnor
Mar 14, 2005

Fun Shoe

Jester Mcgee posted:

Thanks for the advice guys. I'll probably play dwarves and beastmen for a dozen turns or so and see if either one of them stand out to me.

Another one is Vampire Counts, pick Mannfred as he is the strongest Legendary Lord in the game. Hes armoured, access to TWO spell trees AND he gets a life regen passive at level 2 if you pick it (you should pick it). He also gets a big monster that regens HP.

Besides that Vampire Counts can be played very defensively since you're not bothered as much by the other factions. You do get bothered some but not as much as say, the dwarfs who'll have to fight off orcs day 1. You can sit in your little corner and plan & prepare.

fnordcircle
Jul 7, 2004

PTUI
The problem I had with VC while learning the game was that the AI just gets steamrolled by Chaos and it ends up being my problem.

Part of why I think Empire is the hardest faction to play.

Gejnor
Mar 14, 2005

Fun Shoe

fnordcircle posted:

The problem I had with VC while learning the game was that the AI just gets steamrolled by Chaos and it ends up being my problem.

Part of why I think Empire is the hardest faction to play.

Thats a problem for another day! They won't show up til, what turn 70 at the earliest? He did mention he has had false starts, he wants to get the ball rolling? Then i figure VC is a good start. Its where i started after all..

Arc Hammer
Mar 4, 2013

Got any deathsticks?
Which multiplayer map is the closest to grassy flatlands from previous games? I want to do some testing.

Zasze
Apr 29, 2009
Count me In For the next tourney it looks pretty rad.

Soup du Journey
Mar 20, 2006

by FactsAreUseless
does the +corruption effect for adjacent provinces from balefire brassieresbraziers stack if i have a bunch of them in, like, eastern sylvania?

Sjonnar
Oct 22, 2011

Doctor Schnabel posted:

does the +corruption effect for adjacent provinces from balefire brassieresbraziers stack if i have a bunch of them in, like, eastern sylvania?

Yes.

1st_Panzer_Div.
May 11, 2005
Grimey Drawer

fnordcircle posted:

The problem I had with VC while learning the game was that the AI just gets steamrolled by Chaos and it ends up being my problem.

Part of why I think Empire is the hardest faction to play.

My issue is that I found the campaign start way too easy, so it's tough to learn.

TipsyMcStagger
Apr 13, 2013

This isn't where
I parked my car...

fnordcircle posted:

the AI just gets steamrolled by Chaos and it ends up being my problem.

I'm about to see this in my orc game, not sure how i'm going to handle these 3 death stacks of rank 6-7 troops that are heavily armored. My Armies of Black orcs/Giants, although great at stomping stuff in a fight aren't very good at chasing the harassers down.

Super 3
Dec 31, 2007

Sometimes the powers you get are shit.
I did some quick reading and couldn't find a good answer to it.

The description on the upgraded says spreads to the adjacent province, so i would assume that it's all corruption generated in that province that then spreads to all adjacent ones.

SickZip
Jul 29, 2008

by FactsAreUseless
Empire is the best starting faction. They do everything and face everything. It will make a man of you.

SickZip
Jul 29, 2008

by FactsAreUseless
Orc and Dwarf difficulty is really contingent on circumstances. Sometimes they'll be insanely easy and sometimes buckle up for a brutal grind to get out of your starting province because the one your not playing as confederated into a 20 province behemoth and all your fellow orcs/dwarves rolled over and died. The badlands are a land of contrasts. I wouldn't recommend them to a new player because those factions can degenerate into a tedious slog really easy

Empire is consistently tough. It will put you through your paces but none of your opponents tend toward wild snowballing.

VC is the most easy going faction. You can do whatever and usually triumph eventually.

Fangz
Jul 5, 2007

Oh I see! This must be the Bad Opinion Zone!

SickZip posted:

Orc and Dwarf difficulty is really contingent on circumstances. Sometimes they'll be insanely easy and sometimes buckle up for a brutal grind to get out of your starting province because the one your not playing as confederated into a 20 province behemoth and all your fellow orcs/dwarves rolled over and died. The badlands are a land of contrasts. I wouldn't recommend them to a new player because those factions can degenerate into a tedious slog really easy

Empire is consistently tough. It will put you through your paces but none of your opponents tend toward wild snowballing.

VC is the most easy going faction. You can do whatever and usually triumph eventually.

I agree with this.

I'll also add that I wouldn't advise playing Chaos or Beastmen on the Grand Campaign without having played as another faction first.

Ichabod Tane
Oct 30, 2005

A most notable
coward, an infinite and endless liar, an hourly promise breaker, the owner of no one good quality.


https://youtu.be/_Ojd0BdtMBY?t=4
It's me, I'm the tedious creep who loves stomping through Norsca until my chosen leader unit is level 30 and everyone else is level 9.

fnordcircle
Jul 7, 2004

PTUI

Blacktoll posted:

It's me, I'm the tedious creep who loves stomping through Norsca until my chosen leader unit is level 30 and everyone else is level 9.

^ This guy gets it.

Running around only having to keep an army alive helped me learn the game better than VC and Greenskins and Dwarves, who I tried before, because instead of getting WAAGH'ed or Archaeon + Sigvald + Everwatcher'ed to death because I had spread myself too thin, I was the tide of death and destruction. Horde mode saves me from myself and my propensity to spread too thin, etc.

Pornographic Memory
Dec 17, 2008

fnordcircle posted:

^ This guy gets it.

Running around only having to keep an army alive helped me learn the game better than VC and Greenskins and Dwarves, who I tried before, because instead of getting WAAGH'ed or Archaeon + Sigvald + Everwatcher'ed to death because I had spread myself too thin, I was the tide of death and destruction. Horde mode saves me from myself and my propensity to spread too thin, etc.

"He who defends nothing, defends everything" - sun tzu on hordes

DogsInSpace!
Sep 11, 2001


Fun Shoe

SickZip posted:

Orc and Dwarf difficulty is really contingent on circumstances. Sometimes they'll be insanely easy and sometimes buckle up for a brutal grind to get out of your starting province because the one your not playing as confederated into a 20 province behemoth and all your fellow orcs/dwarves rolled over and died. The badlands are a land of contrasts. I wouldn't recommend them to a new player because those factions can degenerate into a tedious slog really easy

Empire is consistently tough. It will put you through your paces but none of your opponents tend toward wild snowballing.

VC is the most easy going faction. You can do whatever and usually triumph eventually.

Yeah my VC run was really easy. Even the nations that said nastygrams of "we dont like you and so declare war" didn't really come around much. A few turns and some bribes later and we were buds again. NPCs tend to avoid the death attrition. Orc and Dwarf you will always have a 50/50 of the opposing side sending a full stack of buffed troops before turn 10. My first two games were dwarf and orc and I had to restart/savescum multiple times. Empire is a ton of fun but you will not only fight but need to get really good at diplomacy. VC and BM are definitely the most forgiving. The only caveat with VC is watch your stance and move metre in non dead territory. You will take some attrition. There are skills to allow you to slowly expand but VC tend to move like their troops: a slow tide of inevitable grinning death.

Best advice I can give newbs: savescum. Nobody will know and you don't have to post that you are savescumming thus avoiding terrible internet mockery. Save at the start of every turn. Keep 3-5 saves around. Its like training wheels. Accidentally let Azzy or Kemmler rush out ahead of everyone and get slaughtered in seconds? Load and try again. You decided to do a long trek into varg territory unsupported just for the hell of it and now you realize that was not the best decision? Reload that old save. You suck at Total War in general? You get retries and learn from your mistakes. Eventually you stop savescumming as much then one day you will hardly save at all. You might even forget to save completely and lose a great game when you lose power suddenly.

mod talk:
Settle anywhere mod. Yeah it radically changes the game. With my lasts vc game - How I expanded territory was consolidated all the vamp areas and then dug deep into the mountain areas behind me. Those same mountain areas were good money and almost never got harassed while my 2 stacks could wander where they needed. Funny enough one of my first and bestest friends was a wandering tribe of savage orcs that somehow managed to counter varg the vargs and settle the destroyed areas of kislev. I really like the settle anywhere mod not as much for me but for the random nations that will pop up in the funniest places. I've seen a Tilean and Brettonian colonies in Norsca. Again, savage orc Kislev.

Mukip
Jan 27, 2011

by Reene
Done my second round matches with 420 Gank Mid:
https://drive.google.com/open?id=0BxL-q9Tcsh-aQlB5TndZQ3VwR0E

First up was Bretonnia vs Empire. We both brought strong air corps, with two griffon character on his side and King Leoun along with Pegasus Knights on mine. I charged down the Amber Wizard straight away and cast a pair of buff and malus spells on the the flying units to ensure I won that fight, since it was pivotal. Having the air advantage for the rest of the fight was a huge advantage (because flying units are OP). I think 420 needed to have micro'ed that better and have his 2 (3 after Manticore was summoned) units working in tandem. My cavalry micro was pretty awful; I did nothing of value with my light cavalry and charged my realm knights into demigryphs for reasons I cannot recall. This forced me to do some demigryph baiting with Leoun. I got off a Urannon's Thunderbolt on them which helped a lot.

In the second match (Empire vs Dwarfs) 420 brings a Dwarf gun line, so I send the guys pell mell into his lines. Gun lines need time to do their work so I tried to tie all his units up with my plentiful swordsmen, while Greatswords chewed through things.

Mukip fucked around with this message at 00:31 on Aug 18, 2016

Arc Hammer
Mar 4, 2013

Got any deathsticks?
Seems CA still hasn't actually implemented the DX12 fix to GTX 960M users. There's a thread on the Total War forums where CA says that it won't be coming to the 960m because it doesn't support DX12, despite the patchnotes saying specifically they had implemented it for 960m and the Geforce website saying that the card does support DX12. Additionally, the launcher still says that my drivers are out of date despite updating them. The hell is going on?

fnordcircle
Jul 7, 2004

PTUI

Pornographic Memory posted:

"He who defends nothing, defends everything" - sun tzu on hordes

"Raze that poo poo homey" -Apostle Paul

Internet Explorer
Jun 1, 2005





My problem with Beastmen so far is that it seems like a lot of my battles are autoresolve just due to the sheer amount of razing you have to do. Also it's kind of hard to justify taking a moment to tech or build new units when you're watching your gold stockpile tick down every turn.

Dumb question, why do so many of the Beastmen "choices" add Chaos corruption? Am I supposed to be rooting for Chaos or something?

Nanomashoes
Aug 18, 2012

Internet Explorer posted:

My problem with Beastmen so far is that it seems like a lot of my battles are autoresolve just due to the sheer amount of razing you have to do. Also it's kind of hard to justify taking a moment to tech or build new units when you're watching your gold stockpile tick down every turn.

Dumb question, why do so many of the Beastmen "choices" add Chaos corruption? Am I supposed to be rooting for Chaos or something?

Beastmen were created by chaos and worship it.

TheNakedFantastic
Sep 22, 2006

LITERAL WHITE SUPREMACIST

Arcsquad12 posted:

Seems CA still hasn't actually implemented the DX12 fix to GTX 960M users. There's a thread on the Total War forums where CA says that it won't be coming to the 960m because it doesn't support DX12, despite the patchnotes saying specifically they had implemented it for 960m and the Geforce website saying that the card does support DX12. Additionally, the launcher still says that my drivers are out of date despite updating them. The hell is going on?

They have no idea how to code for drivers and the studio doesn't want to pay NVIDIA to help implement it. Goondolences.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Internet Explorer
Jun 1, 2005





Nanomashoes posted:

Beastmen were created by chaos and worship it.

Ok, but they are usually choices in the context of "you could choose option A, which will benefit you, or you could choose option B, which will inflect CHAOS!"

Why would I choose option B, unless I am trying to roleplay a Minotaur?

  • Locked thread