Endorph posted:

Despite being a major and critically acclaimed studio with 2 shows this year, Ufotable failed to make an appearance.

z0glin Warchief posted:

Both were video game adaptations (Tales and God Eater, right?), so I guess I'm not too surprised by this.

Endorph posted:

I GOT BORED SO HERE'S A BREAKDOWN OF THE STUDIOS FOR THE 73 ANIME THAT GOT VOTES

TAKEAWAYS

Bones was a clear winner, but special mention has to go to Deen: Of their four shows on the list, the lowest was Sakamoto, at 23rd place. Meanwhile, Bones had a show that only received 1 vote (Snow White) and a show that only received 2 votes (Stray Dogs).

No studio had 2 shows in the top 10.

Of the 10 studios in the top 10, 5 only have one show on the entire list. Quality over quantity?

Endorph posted:

I GOT BORED SO HERE'S A BREAKDOWN OF THE STUDIOS FOR THE 73 ANIME THAT GOT VOTES

Bones: 5 (Snow White, Stray Dogs, Concrete Revolutio, Boku no Hero Academia, Mob Psycho)


J.C. Staff: 4 (Heavy Object, Shokugeki no Soma, Saiki, Flying Witch)
Deen: 4 (Sakamoto, Tonkatsu DJ, Rakugou, Konosuba)
Sunrise: 4 (Akito the Exiled, Gundam Thunderbolt, Ironblooded Orphans, Love Live Sunshine)


Shuka: 3 (Durarara, Natsume Yuujinchou, 91 Days)
A-1 Pictures: 3 (Qualidea Code, Grimgar, ERASED)
Production I.G.: 3 (Joker Game, Amanchu, Haikyuu)
Silver Link: 3 (Anne Happy, Magic of Stella, Tanaka-kun)


Telecom: 2 (Orange, Lupin)
Satelight: 2 (Momokuri, Macross Delta)
Toei: 2 (Sailor Moon Crystal, Princess Precure)
Millepensee: 2 (Teekyu, Berserk)
Creators in Pack: 2 (Ojisan to Marshmallow, Miss Bernard)
TMS: 2 (ReLIFE, Sweetness and Lightning)
Doga Kobo: 2 (Three Leaves, New Game)
Bandai Namco Pictures: 2 (Gintama, Aikatsu Stars)
P.A. Works: 2 (Kuromukuro, Haruchika)
LIDENFILMS: 2 (Sekkou Boys, Poco's Udon World)
Diomedea: 2 (Mayoiga, Girlish Number)
David Production: 2 (Planetarian, Jojo's)
feel.: 2 (Galko, Dagashi Kashi)
Trigger: 2 (Kiznaiver, Luluco)


Shin-Ei: 1 (Shin Atashin'chi)
Xebec: 1 (Keijo)
3hz: 1 (Flipflappers)
KyoAni: 1 (Euphonium)
Mappa: 1 (Yuri On Ice)
Pili International: 1 (Thunderbolt Fantasy)
Lerche: 1 (Magical GIrl Raising Project)
White Fox: 1 (Re:Zero)
Pine Jam: 1 (Tawawa)
Hoods: 1 (Drifters)
Kinema Citrus: 1 (Ping Pong Girls)
Shaft: 1 (Koyomimonogatari)
Pierrot: 1 (Osomatsu)
Fanworks: 1 (Hagane Orchestra)
Zexcs: 1 (Fune wo Amu)
Brain's Base: 1 (Kiss Him Not Me)


For a total of 37 studios.

TAKEAWAYS

Bones was a clear winner, but special mention has to go to Deen: Of their four shows on the list, the lowest was Sakamoto, at 23rd place. Meanwhile, Bones had a show that only received 1 vote (Snow White) and a show that only received 2 votes (Stray Dogs).

No studio had 2 shows in the top 10.

Of the 10 studios in the top 10, 5 only have one show on the entire list. Quality over quantity?

Despite being a major and critically acclaimed studio with 2 shows this year, Ufotable failed to make an appearance.

AnacondaHL posted:

The moral of the story: if you guys want neat-o scoring and tie-breakers stuff, it doesn't really matter what system you use, but be clear about the rules upfront!


Also: if you really want to, for posterity, as long as you don't change your Top 5 votes, you can order them now! Just let me know and I'll apply it to the data! edit: it's a little cheesy though since the results have already been posted, but whatevs

GorfZaplen posted:

At last, empirical evidence that the DEEN meme must die.

Lucy Heartfilia posted:

hmm, only mob psycho 100 and re: zero are on my planning to watch list now. i didn't expect to already have so much overlap with the top ten.

AnacondaHL posted:

Can you weight these by the number of votes each studio got? Just asking before I start typing studio names into the spreadsheet!

Fangz posted:

Threw the scores from the current version of the spreadsheet into a principle components analysis:



The red arrows are shows, with long arrows being the especially popular ones that aren't predicted by liking other shows. Roughly speaking, if you're aligned to particular shows you liked them, and arrows that are close to each other represents shows that if you liked one, you probably liked the other. If you are close to someone on this chart you have similar tastes. If you are miles from everyone you're strange.

Unfortunately I don't necessarily believe in the scores right now. For me at least it's put me in the wrong way round.... OTOH I can believe that there's the quadrant of yuri (on and off the Ice to the top left, and I am solidly in it...)

This chart below is just with whether people top-5ed a show or not

AnacondaHL posted:

Can you weight these by the number of votes each studio got? Just asking before I start typing studio names into the spreadsheet!

Julias posted:

What were your favorite shows in 2016? Not necessarily your top 5, but which shows did you enjoy the most?

Xinder posted:

added rakugo to my backlog since the arrow for it was pointing directly at my name in the second graph. i take that as a challenge.

Mentat Radnor posted:

Just watched the first episode of Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju and holy poo poo.

I'm going to open a bottle of cheap wine and marathon the whole thing tonight.

Endorph posted:

ps: if my count is incredibly off, keep in mind im eyeballing this while eating chicken

Lucy Heartfilia posted:

here is a chronological list:
rakugo
konosuba
dagashi kashi
erased
flying witch
shokugeki no soma
love live sunshine
stella no mahou
keijo
hibike euphonium 2
girlish number
flip flappers

that's my top 12 out of 35 shows i completed in 2016

Nate RFB posted:

It's going to take more than 2 good shows in one year to make up for the dozens of terrible ones in other years IMO.

Fangz posted:

Threw the scores from the current version of the spreadsheet into a principle components analysis:



The red arrows are shows, with long arrows being the especially popular ones that aren't predicted by liking other shows. Roughly speaking, if you're aligned to particular shows you liked them, and arrows that are close to each other represents shows that if you liked one, you probably liked the other. If you are close to someone on this chart you have similar tastes. If you are miles from everyone you're strange.

Unfortunately I don't necessarily believe in the scores right now. For me at least it's put me in the wrong way round.... OTOH I can believe that there's the quadrant of yuri (on and off the Ice to the top left, and I am solidly in it...)

This chart below is just with whether people top-5ed a show or not

Endorph posted:

what about 4 good shows in one year

and is deen's track record really that bad? They have some real stinkers but they also made stuff like rurouni kenshin, fruits basket, king of bandits jing, shion no ou.

deen makes a ton of shows every year (this year they made 8), so it's no surprise that they've made some clunkers. I think their track record is pretty solid for how much they pump out and how many big name shows they've been attached to.

log horizon season 2 was terrible tho

Xinder posted:

am i really the only one to vote for durarara? it's like my last minute binge-watch was for nothing. how sad.

kater posted:

Top 10 No Normies* Allowed List 2016

1. Flying Witch
2. KonaSuba
3. Re:Zero
4. Flip Flappers
5. Yuri! On Ice.
6. Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash
7. Space Patrol Luluco
8. Haikyuu!!
9. Osomatsu-san
10. Thunderbolt Fantasy

*Anyone that listed any of the top 3 removed.

Grimgar got a huge boost. Maybe someone somewhere should be concerned.

AnacondaHL posted:

Added as mentions!

z0glin Warchief posted:

Fangz posted:

Threw the scores from the current version of the spreadsheet into a principle components analysis:



The red arrows are shows, with long arrows being the especially popular ones that aren't predicted by liking other shows. Roughly speaking, if you're aligned to particular shows you liked them, and arrows that are close to each other represents shows that if you liked one, you probably liked the other. If you are close to someone on this chart you have similar tastes. If you are miles from everyone you're strange.

Endorph posted:

what about 4 good shows in one year

and is deen's track record really that bad? They have some real stinkers but they also made stuff like rurouni kenshin, fruits basket, king of bandits jing, shion no ou.

deen makes a ton of shows every year (this year they made 8), so it's no surprise that they've made some clunkers. I think their track record is pretty solid for how much they pump out and how many big name shows they've been attached to.

log horizon season 2 was terrible tho

AlternateNu posted: