Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Quinn2win
Nov 9, 2011

Foolish child of man...
After reading all this,
do you still not understand?


"No, no, I'll eat iiit! Asmo, Asmo, pass!"
"Kya-hahahaha! Over here, Levia onee-samaaa!"

I wonder where they swiped it from. They were fighting over a donut or something, playing around really loudly.

"HEY!! Ange-sama is reading, so can't you be a little more quiet?!"
"Yelling stuff like that makes you the loudest one, Satan! Be silent!! You foolish little sister!"
"Y-You're the loud one, Lucifer onee-sama!! I-Is there something you'd like to say to me?!"

I was already used to the oldest and the third oldest sister arguing with each other. Even though they're both so quick to anger, it's a bit funny how they're both having to hold back a little. They might be surprisingly like each other.

"*cackle*cackle* You were told to be noisy, but this is a bit too much. Should I make them lower the volume a little?"



"Ange-samaa, go to the next page quickly! You read really sloow!"
"You like to read, Mammon? You looked like you'd be the worst at doing boring things."
"Mammon controls greed. That also includes a thirst for knowledge. Still, she wants to keep that knowledge all for herself, so be warned that she refuses to let people read any book you give her, and sometimes burns them after reading them."
"I like knowing things that no one else knows. I like being able to do things that no one else can do. So I like studying and practicing. Because I want to keep wisdom that no one else knows about all to myself."

As Mammon said that, her eyes sparkling, she peered down at the page that was open and read through it again. You could see the greed that made her covet that page even more thoroughly than I did.



By now, I've gotten so that I can summon all of the Seven Sisters of Purgatory at once and still calmly read a book like this. This place, although I can't recall exactly where it is, is a quiet and calm street-side bench. I'd been young back then, so I don't remember the details of its location.

Still, I remember that my days walking here were a lot of fun. Together with Dad, Mom, and even Onii-chan, it was a memory of a very rare and very happy day when everyone had been together... The people who walked by every once in a while didn't notice me. They just pleasantly ignored me and passed by as though everything was normal. Even the Seven Sisters' incredible outfits weren't embarrassing or anything, because it wasn't like anyone was actually watching. Come to think of it, I'm getting pretty used to it. As long as they don't make me wear those.

I was sitting on a stylish bench, memorizing a timeline for world history. In an academy system where everything is based on collective responsibility, there's no tolerance for dunces. It seemed that I was considerably below the average grade for the class. According to those extremely intellectual girls, if I alone improved my grade, the average would rise drastically. They had been kind enough to show me with a graph drawn by colorful pens on a B4 sheet of drawing paper. Just thinking of the effort it had taken to draw that was repulsive.

But I've already spat out all those complaints. I've already voiced my constant and furious anger and sadness to these girls here. The Sisters were sometimes indignant, sometimes sympathetic, and sometimes mourned along with me. I was truly happy to be able to share emotions like that with friends.

It's said that they were originally furniture that existed to carry out Beatrice's cruel sacrifice ceremony. According to the occult message bottle I hated, it seems that several of them even attacked my family. But I don't believe that, and it's pointless to question them about it. They are furniture, so they only respond to their master's requests. Even if they really did attack my family, I can't hate them. What I really hated... was the Golden Witch, Beatrice. Or else that ringleader of the Ushiromiya Suspicion, Aunt Eva.



"Oh, sorry. I'm tired. Mind if I take a break?"
"Kyahaha! Ange-sama said break!"
"Let's play, let's play! Ange-sama, let's plaaay!!"

When they noticed that I had interrupted my studying, the most energetic youngest sisters gathered around me. And that wasn't all.



They had probably been very close by, but they must've hid themselves so that they wouldn't interrupt my studying.

'Uryu-! Ange! How's studying? How's studying?'
"Kyaaah!! Sakutaro-!! How are yooooouu?!"
"Wait a second! Let me squeeze him tooooooooooo!!"
"Don't we always say that the first one to get there wins?! Kyaa, cute, cute!"
'Ukyuu--, you're crushing meee! Uryuu--!'
"Your luck ran out when you showed up while all the Seven Sisters were gathered. Give up and let us hug you."
"Come on! It always turns out this way!! I apologize for my stupid older and younger sisters...!"
"Ahahahahaha. Sakutaro's happy to meet everyone, too. How's it going, Ange? How's the studying going?"
"Thanks. Well, not bad. They were nice enough to pass around printouts from a quiz that another class took earlier. Their beautiful sense of solidarity is enough to bring tears to my eyes. Well, at least it's probably better to put a timeline into my head."
'Uryu. You sure are good at studying, Ange. You'll be able to get a lot of points, uryu-.'
"Good work. I was terrible at studying, so I'm jealous of you for being able to get a good score when you study hard."
"You're joking. When it comes to English, Latin, and knowledge of the occult, you're much more amazing for being able to remember so much."
"I can remember anything when studying magic, but I can't remember anything boring. So that didn't help at all for tests."
"Well, it's true that occult knowledge would be like that, but your grades must've been pretty good in English, right?"



"Why? Doesn't that fit?"



"...I didn't really get it, so from that day on, on tests, I wrote everything in hiragana. But I got in trouble with Mama for some reason. Got in trouble with the teachers too."
"...You were probably born in the wrong country, Onee-chan."
"Then I'd rather have been born in a country of witches, so I could enter a witch school. Uu-."
'If that happened, you might've had much, much more wonderful magical friends! Uryu-!'
"Uu-♪ But it's not like I mind it now. After all, I can use lots of magic, and I've got a lot of magic friends. Sakutaro is all I need."
'I'm not the only one! There's also Sakusuke and Sakukichi, the animal band, Shimoda-kun the seal, Sanae-san the rabbit, Mr Pig-kun, and plenty more!'



Every time I ask, the number of names for her friends grows. But there's no doubt that Sakutaro is her best friend. I'm a little jealous of all those close friends.

"...What do you think? How are the Seven Sisters? Do you get along with them?"
"Those sisters are really energetic. They sometimes say shady stuff, but they aren't bad. I'd wanted to get a cute kid like Sakutaro, but I think being with them now is more than enough."
"*giggle* If you learn more of my Magic of Origins, I'm sure you'll be able to give birth to friends you'll like, Ange. Creation is still a bit too hard for you now."
"There's a difference between creation and summoning... And, resurrection is also different."



"Yes. I have a vessel for it. This."
"That's right. I'm sure that hair accessory will eventually become the key to summoning Battler. The rest is up to your training, Ange."
"Although not knowing how long it'll take is enough to make me cry."
'Uryu... Stay strong, even if it's tough... If you don't give up, Ange, it will definitely, definitely come true someday...'
"If someone gave me some proof that it'd definitely be granted, at least that would calm my heart."
'Uryu! Then I guarantee it! Without a doubt, Ange will surely have her wish granted someday!'
"...Thanks. I'm glad to hear it, even if you're just saying it to console me."
'It's not like that, uryu-.'
"Stop it, Ange. That kind of emotion will turn into the magic-resisting toxin. The feeling that your dreams will definitely come true is the best seed that buds into magic power."
"...That's right, sorry, Teacher."
"You need to be a bit greedier, Ange-sama. Go however far it takes to get the thing you desire! You're lacking the willpower to never give up until you get it!"
'Uryu-! That isn't true, Ange's doing her best...!'
"Thanks, Sakutaro, Mammon. Crying about it won't help anything. There's nothing I can do except hang in there. I'll try hard. I'll grit my teeth. I'll definitely make my dreams come true. With certainty."
'Uryu! You're awesome, Ange, do your best! Mammon and I will support you!'
"Yes, we'll support you. The greedier our master is, the more our worth will increase."
"More importantly, Ange-samaa! We've finally got 10 people gathered heeere!"
"We planned to have everyone play shiritori or something!"
"If you lose, there's a punishment game! Let me nibble your eeears!"
"Come on, is hunger the only thing inside that head of yours?!"



"No, no, nooooooo!! I waited so long for you to finish studying, so I can't stand it if you don't play with us!"
"I don't think it's a bad idea. Perhaps playing every once in a while is good for softening the mind."
"...You govern Sloth, right, Belpha? What you're saying sounds reasonable, but you're actually being sneaky, aren't you?"
"Hmph. My apologies. You are diligent, Ange-sama."
"If it's okay with Ange, I'd also like to play with everyone. Let's make some noise. It'll definitely be fun."
'Uryu-! Ange, Ange, let's play, let's play! Let's all do shiritori!'



BGM: HANE

"From 'uryu-'? I wonder. Maybe it really should be 'ryu'?"
"...It's rare for a word that ends like that to come up."
"Then I'm first!! I'll do a word starting with 'ryu'! Ryuuzu (watch crown)!"
"I wanted to go first! 'Ryuuto' (lute) would've been wonderful!"
"'Zu'? Feels like we keep getting tough ones. Wait a sec, what order are we going in? Who's next?"
'Uryu. I don't think it matters who. Whoever thinks of a matching word first.'
"What's that? Sounds interesting. How about the person who can say the most wins? It's fast-talking shiritori!"
"Then I'll go! 'Zucchini'! 'Ninniku itame' (garlic stir-fry)! 'Mekabu with pasta'! All of them delicious! Kyaha, I said three of them!"
"Belz takes three points. Can you use conjunctions?"
"If you could use 'with', then anything would work!! That last one doesn't count! Minus one point!! Let's start from 'me'."
"Then I'll go. 'Meringue'-!"
''Ge'?? ...U-U-Uryu-!'
"'Gesuidou' (Drainage system), 'umetatechi' (reclaimed land), 'chikashitsu' (basement). How'd you like them apples?"
"Onee-sama, those are all pretty crummy words, *giggle*!"
"S-So what? Then why don't you try following up with something refined!! Anyway, that's three points for me. The next one's 'tsu', okay, 'tsu'!"
"I've never played such a weird shiritori before. Uu-uu-! It's fun!"
'Uryu-! I don't get it at all, but it's fun. Uryu-!'



There's only the lively Seven Sisters, Maria onee-chan, Sakutaro, and me. I'm now surrounded by friends that are so fun to be with. The courage to accept a world of magic, a world of witches... That alone didn't change the fact that I was still locked up in an academy, without a single friend in my class. But despite that, I'm able to have such a fun and lively time.

...I'll also become a witch, like Maria onee-chan. And someday, I'll add my family to this fun circle. Dad, Mom. And Onii-chan. And if possible, George onii-chan and Jessica onee-chan. And the other relatives. I'll call everyone, everyone here without a single person missing, and we'll all gather together.



"I'm sure you'll become a Great Witch, Ange-sama. As long as you believe in that. We Seven Stakes of Purgatory will always serve by your side until that day comes."
"You'll be there for me...? No matter how long, you'll lend me your strength?"
"Of course. After all, I'm your friend. Right, Ange-sama?"
"...Yes, that's right. Let's all stick together and play together. Today, and in the future, always, always."
"Until the day your dream comes true, Ange-sama."





BGM: Fortitude

"..."

...In the end, I wasn't able to get a very good grade on my test. I tried memorizing things in my own way, but if you could manage anything by cramming the night before a test, no one would ever worry about tests.

"Normally, when you know the problems beforehand, you should be able to pass easily, right? Easily!"
"It's true that we didn't go so far as to write the answers into the blanks for you. We thought you'd studied at least that much."
"What the hell? Come on, are you serious? I can't believe it! They're almost all wrong, aren't they? Did you really study properly?!"
"...More or less..."
"This isn't what you call more or less, Ushiromiya-san. It's so horrible that it makes me dizzy, okay?"
"Oh, God. Please forgive her for getting a miserable grade on such an easy test... and for making the average score for the entire class plummet...!"
"*giggle*giggle*giggle*, *cackle*cackle*cackle*, ahahahahahahaha."



Enough to obscure my slight improvement. However, there were some things I had no excuse for. If I'd spent that entire day studying like mad, I might've been able to get a slightly higher score. But I hadn't gone that far.

After that on that day, I spent the whole time having fun playing shiritori with the Seven Sisters, Sakutaro and Onee-chan. As expected, the winner had been Maria onee-chan. She was a strong player thanks to her wide knowledge of trivia. Sakutaro had gotten the punishment game. He spent the whole time cheering for everyone else's answers, completely forgotting to think of any himself. Because of that, he'd been squished by the Seven Sisters and had his ears thoroughly nibbled, hadn't he?



"..."

They were surrounding me, twittering like small birds. They were annoying, smelly. On the outside of that circle was Mammon, an exasperated expression on her face...



"...It's probably because of that collective responsibility thing. Instead of worrying about their own grades, they're more concerned about how embarrassing it is for the class average to be low. Or maybe it's because they really hate the volunteer work they're forced to do as punishment."
"So in other words, they aren't studying because they want their grades to be good, but because of collective responsibility and since they hate volunteer work?"
"...They're jealous and embarrassed. They don't want to be inferior to anyone, and they don't want to be humiliated. That's the only feeling that drives them to study."
"What noisy people. If they want to study, why can't they just do it themselves?"
"In the end, without collective responsibility and volunteer work, they'd have no desire to study. How foolish it is to study without knowing the meaning of studying."
"Still, these guys really are annoying and stupid! Don't you dare disturb Ange-sama's precious day for even a minute!"
"Waaah, I hate those people!! Just get lost!!"
"I'm hungryyyyyy!! Go away noooooow, waaaah!!"
"...Sorry, everyone. I wonder why Humans are so shameful."
"It's probably because, instead of working hard themselves, it's easier to make you work hard and earn them a higher class average to satisfy their greed. Humans are all greedy. And they'll burden others with their greed to make things easier for themselves."
"...We'll eventually be reunited with them on the mountain of Purgatory. When they get to the fifth terrace, they'd better watch their step..."



...Since she's saying this, you can probably be sure that after those girls die, their journey to heaven won't be an easy one. No, on the contrary, let them just fall into hell.



BGM: Mystic Forest

The purpose of use was for a class study group. A wonderful little gathering so that they could all surround me and make me study. I'm so grateful I could cry. Which meant that every day, all of my lunch and three hours of my afternoon would be stolen. The academy and its student council, with its theme of student self-government, instantly approved of this pleasant activity that the students were taking up of their own initiative... In other words, I was no longer able to escape after school by leaving the classroom...

After school, the first class study group meeting started right away. Would they open a textbook, then kindly and carefully explain so that even I could understand it? Of course it didn't turn out like such a naive illusion. After school in the classroom, dozens of my classmates crowded around my desk.

First, before we started studying... Why were my grades so bad? What was the reason? It was decided that we couldn't start until I could clearly answer those questions, become aware of the problem, and show regret for my actions. Of course, there's no way for me to respond when asked a question like that. They've loathed me all this time. And they've rejected me and kept me at a distance, preventing me from joining in on their community. So, I've avoided their community myself. There shouldn't have been any conflict for either of us that way. So even in this group that was enthusiastic about raising the class average, they obviously kept me at a distance. Even if I tried to join in, they would probably ignore me, like they always did in the past.



"""Riiiiiiiigght!!!"""

They were getting themselves all worked up. I've already had enough of the hypocrisy of their tacked-on excuses.

"Ushiromiya-san, your problem is that you're lacking a cooperative personality. You mustn't be satisfied as long as everything's good for you alone."
"Those who gather in Saint Lucia's place of learning shall have a cooperative heart. It's written right there in the student handbook, right?"
"I think having a cooperative heart is what gives birth to the desire to study together and contribute to the entire class. I believe that itself is the thing you lack before you even start studying, Ushiromiya-san, but what do you say?!"
"Heeey, have you even been listening to us?! We went to all the trouble of staying after school to say this for your sake, right?!"

...I'm so grateful I could cry. Of course, they didn't like that. 'This way, it almost makes it look like we're bullying you', they reprimanded me. Fortunately, I'm normally all cried out anyway. If I'm told not to cry, I can hold it back.

First, I was made to write a letter of remorse and read it out loud. Of course, this was to be done by today. The class committee politely applied to the student council and the staff room for an extension on the use of this classroom. It seems it was accepted right away. Which means that starting now, I'll be forced into self-criticism for at least a full five hours here...



"That's not it, riiight?!?!"
"You getting low grades and causing us trouble isn't the root of the problem, is it?!"
"It's a cooperative attitude, right? A cooperative attitude!!"
"Come ooon!! Why do we even have to direct Ushiromiya-san on how to write a letter of regret?!"

Their abusive jeers flew about one after another. I followed their 'directions' and erased it.



"Hey, wait a sec, it's pointless if you just write whatever we say, right?!"
"Do you really know what 'regret' means?!"
"It's pointless if you don't write it in your own words, pointless!"
"I always thought you were a bit strange, Ushiromiya-san, but you really are weird! *giggle*giggle*giggle*!"

Even following their directions didn't change the jeers much, and now it felt like they were mocking me even more... So for several more hours, without rest, without even being allowed to go to the bathroom, much less dinner, I was continuously abused... I was coerced into writing a paragraph that humiliated myself...



The contents... were smeared black with tears and eraser marks. It certainly was my handwriting, but it was like a list of soulless letters, whose contents I couldn't even remember. Everything had been copied down according to their orders. So while I had been the one to write the letters, they weren't my words. I'd been coerced into writing them down... and even coerced into reading them aloud.

...Even after all this time, I was surprised to learn that, beyond just ignoring people and hiding their things, there are other ways to bully people...

"Heey! Read it aloud quickly!!"
"Look how many people are staying this late just for you, Ushiromiya-san. Why not thank us a little?"
"Isn't the fact that she doesn't feel gratitude a sign that she doesn't have a scrap of a cooperative attitude?"
"It's okay, Ushiromiya-san. We'll always be with you from now on. Why not study with us and remake yourself? Okay?"

Quinn2win fucked around with this message at 16:52 on Feb 5, 2017

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

EagerSleeper
Feb 3, 2010

by R. Guyovich
Ange needs to buy her own private academy. This is after Eva died, so she should have all the money by now to do so.

Lycaeon
Feb 20, 2013

A closed door is a closed mind.
Son of a bitch...

Poor Ange. :smith:

Edit: I maintain that Ange should use Eva's money to buy this place and shut it down.

Lycaeon fucked around with this message at 19:12 on Feb 5, 2017

lotus circle
Dec 25, 2012

Jushure Iburu
So don't worry

EagerSleeper posted:

Ange needs to buy her own private academy. This is after Eva died, so she should have all the money by now to do so.
The current scenes are still in flashback mode. This is still pre-Eva dying.

idonotlikepeas
May 29, 2010

This reasoning is possible for forums user idonotlikepeas!

tiistai posted:

Somehow I only just now remembered reading this post. Personally I have a bigger problem with Ange's original sprites.



Yeeeeeah, you're right, hers is much worse. His is actually alright, I think, apart from the stuff that is still ridiculous in the current design.

EagerSleeper posted:

Ange needs to buy her own private academy. This is after Eva died, so she should have all the money by now to do so.

We're bouncing around a lot in the timeline, but I'm pretty sure this is before she died. Ange is remembering the first time she learned magic had imaginary friends due to the horrifying stress she was under, because she's currently imagining those same friends while under horrifying stress, while trying to figure out what happened to her family and being chased by some jerks.

Robindaybird posted:

There definitely has to be meaning that out of all the Stakes, Ange picked Mammon to keep summoned.

ProfessorProf posted:

"I like knowing things that no one else knows. I like being able to do things that no one else can do. So I like studying and practicing. Because I want to keep wisdom that no one else knows about all to myself."

Might be related to that.

ProfessorProf posted:

'I'm not the only one! There's also Sakusuke and Sakukichi, the animal band, Shimoda-kun the seal, Sanae-san the rabbit, Mr Pig-kun, and plenty more!'

I am torn between a desire to see Mr. Pig-kun and a desire for there not to be any more characters in this story than there already are. (I lost count a long time ago.)

Tender Child Loins posted:

Still worried about Sakutaro.

Given Rosa, we can most likely guess what eventually happens to Sakutaro. No need to dwell on it, I think.

Lycaeon
Feb 20, 2013

A closed door is a closed mind.
Whoever wanted to get back to the gruesome murders, I second that motion. :smith:

I do however have another theory to put forward.

Both Maria and Ange are still inexperienced in imagining friends - the story constantly reminds us that they're apprentices at best. It's tiring and distracting for Ange to keep the stake sisters around; she has to constantly expend some mental effort to keep them materialized, enough to distract her from studying. Moreover, the stake sisters have...exceedingly one-dimensional personalities based on the seven sins, and even then are quite similar to each other. Maria's familiar, the catboy, might as well be a goldfish for all the personality he has. And the moment either Maria or Ange lose attention, their imagined friends could go poof in an instant.

What would someone more experienced in this art look like? We know whoever Beatrice was taught Maria the fundamental tenets behind imaginary friends - recorded in her diary and later imparted to Ange. What could a master witch create?

Instead of expending effort to imagine a friend, that friend could follow them around without them even having to think about it. They could hold extended, complicated conversations without the risk of distraction poofing the friend. The friend wouldn't be one-dimensional - they would be as sentient and complex as an actual person. The friend would, for all intents and purposes, be more than just imaginary. They would be independent. They would be real.

What would that look like? I'd say it would look a lot like this.

Beatrice may have been Shannon's imaginary friend, one which grew far beyond imagination and into an independent personality. Far more malicious than her creator, it wouldn't be a stretch to think she could've taken over Shannon, 'killing' her in a sense, and then literally killing everyone else on the island. Shannon's motives wouldn't matter anymore, as Beatrice would be for all intents and purposes a completely different person. It's obvious Shannon was already switching between the two at this point as Kanon could 'see' Beatrice as well, and it would be an understatement to say he did not approve of it.

Edit: It would go a long way to explaining why the murders were surrounded by so much occultist symbolism. Nothing we've seen from any of the characters (except Kinzo) would indicate they would have any reason to obsess so much over magic circles and religiously following the epitaph while murdering everyone. Beatrice, being an entity born purely of 'magic', would be the exact opposite.

Lycaeon fucked around with this message at 21:19 on Feb 5, 2017

witchcore ricepunk
Jul 6, 2003

The Golden Witch
Who Solved the Epitaph


A Probability of 1/2,578,917

Lycaeon posted:

What could a master witch create?

Instead of expending effort to imagine a friend, that friend could follow them around without them even having to think about it. They could hold extended, complicated conversations without the risk of distraction poofing the friend. The friend wouldn't be one-dimensional - they would be as sentient and complex as an actual person. The friend would, for all intents and purposes, be more than just imaginary. They would be independent. They would be real.

I was working on an Episode 2 review when I read your post, and now the whole thing's in the loving garbage because holy poo poo, witch power corresponding to the power to make imaginary friends into alternate personas = :hellyeah:. I'm throwing away that post because it strikes me that there's another character that fits your description, but I'm not sure I have enough textual evidence to support the theory. It's going to have to be kind of vague and generalized for now.

So I think Kanon might be another facet of Sayo, just like how Shannon and Beatrice are masks that she wears as well. I almost think that Kanon may have been the serious practice run: a way for Sayo to test out how far she could go with her "imaginary friends made real" thing. In so many ways, Kanon and Beatrice seem to be outlets for Sayo's rage, which has been sublimated so much that it must be completely detached from her sense of self. While Shannon is the paragon of acceptance when it comes to abuse and hardship, Kanon resists the whole way, giving voice to Sayo's innate sense of injustice. Perhaps, while Shannon is an experiment in ideal femininity, repressed anger and all, Kanon is the inevitable pressure relief valve required to prevent Sayo's mind from imploding. It's functionally the same as Ange's appreciation for the Seven Stakes and their ability to complain about her classmates for her sake.

I can't explain why Kanon and Jessica are able to have an intimate relationship, so that's an obvious weak point. However, it's become clearer and clearer that "furniture" seems to mean "imaginary person." Neither Shannon nor Kanon can give George and Jessica a straight answer about what it means because that would expose the whole farce. Though the logistics of this possibility are a bit of a nightmare, I think the psychological implications of this are awesome.

oath2order
Oct 12, 2013

It's MAGIC. I don't have to explain shit!


Funny thing I literally just noticed now after someone pointed it out to me. If you go back to the PS3 version of the opening, you can see writing on the recond that's playing at the very start.

"senza amore senza amore la verita non si"

Italian Title Drop. :allears:

Qrr
Aug 14, 2015


If we're looking at witch power as the creation of imaginary friends, then there's another candidate - Battler himself. Sure, it currently seems like meta battler is a construct of Ange, but if he isn't then the Battler-Beato contest could be something Battler is doing himself. He's combining a few things in it - the desire to solve these cases, the desire for no one in his family or their servants to be guilty, and the realization that yes, yes they are. So he uses his amazing witchy powers to create a more objective more knowledgable version of himself and an enemy - an enemy who lets him approach the idea that someone he knows is guilty at an angle, without needing to immediately face the truth. An enemy who takes the form of Beatrice, the "19th person" of the island, which is the idea he's truly trying to defeat.

And that's why the whole thing is framed as denying witches rather than straight up solving the crimes - he's got a lot of cognitive dissonance going on.

After all, just because you can create an imaginary friend doesn't mean you'll create a nice one.

witchcore ricepunk
Jul 6, 2003

The Golden Witch
Who Solved the Epitaph


A Probability of 1/2,578,917

Qrr posted:

If we're looking at witch power as the creation of imaginary friends, then there's another candidate - Battler himself.

Oooh, I like that. It's kind of fun considering the possibility that 1998 Ange is really just a mental projection of Battler's—like a "worst case scenario" of what will happen if he fails to solve the mystery. It might be Imaginception, but gently caress it!

Lycaeon
Feb 20, 2013

A closed door is a closed mind.

Tender Child Loins posted:

I was working on an Episode 2 review when I read your post, and now the whole thing's in the loving garbage because holy poo poo, witch power corresponding to the power to make imaginary friends into alternate personas = :hellyeah:. I'm throwing away that post because it strikes me that there's another character that fits your description, but I'm not sure I have enough textual evidence to support the theory. It's going to have to be kind of vague and generalized for now.

So I think Kanon might be another facet of Sayo, just like how Shannon and Beatrice are masks that she wears as well. I almost think that Kanon may have been the serious practice run: a way for Sayo to test out how far she could go with her "imaginary friends made real" thing. In so many ways, Kanon and Beatrice seem to be outlets for Sayo's rage, which has been sublimated so much that it must be completely detached from her sense of self. While Shannon is the paragon of acceptance when it comes to abuse and hardship, Kanon resists the whole way, giving voice to Sayo's innate sense of injustice. Perhaps, while Shannon is an experiment in ideal femininity, repressed anger and all, Kanon is the inevitable pressure relief valve required to prevent Sayo's mind from imploding. It's functionally the same as Ange's appreciation for the Seven Stakes and their ability to complain about her classmates for her sake.

I can't explain why Kanon and Jessica are able to have an intimate relationship, so that's an obvious weak point. However, it's become clearer and clearer that "furniture" seems to mean "imaginary person." Neither Shannon nor Kanon can give George and Jessica a straight answer about what it means because that would expose the whole farce. Though the logistics of this possibility are a bit of a nightmare, I think the psychological implications of this are awesome.

Everything you just said makes no sense, and yet it does. It's inexplicably damning.

But if it's true, and I honestly think it is, because reading this is making a lot of pieces come together that didn't make sense to me before...why Shannon and Kanon both seemed to believe they weren't human, why they both could see Beatrice, and why they were the only two people out of everyone on the island who saw their fates linked with the epitaph ritual around which the murders were committed...

It means I don't understand this story at all. :psyduck:

Quinn2win
Nov 9, 2011

Foolish child of man...
After reading all this,
do you still not understand?


BGM: Thanks for Being Born

And then... I spoke those humiliating words, but right away, jeers flew at me saying that they couldn't hear and to speak up.



I had no idea... that being forced to read a paragraph humiliating me would be so painful. My throat shook. My fingertips shook. The paragraph of humiliation written in my own handwriting made my eyes burn with a hot liquid. So my world blurred and twisted. I saw the girls surrounding me twist and bend. I saw them twist and bend into the impression I had of them. In other words, that was my true field of vision.

Beyond that twisted crowd of people, I could see my friends. Compassion could be seen in all of their eyes.



'Uryu-...'

Maria onee-chan and Sakutaro were looking at me with sad eyes. Probably because they realized that even cheap words of compassion would hurt me. They kept alternating between trying to say something... and hanging their heads.

"What the hell's wrong with these people...?!!"
"They're just the worst! Really pisses me off! What's so fun about gathering around Ange-sama and torturing her?!"
"It's a resentment they can't voice despite their jealousy. They don't care who it hurts, as long as they can let it out. What horrible people."
"Ange-sama! In this kind of situation, it's okay to go mad with rage for your own honor's sake!! Anger is an appropriate emotion and an appropriate reaction! If you don't get mad now, when will you get mad?!!"
"Stop it, don't stir Ange-sama up with cheap anger!! If Ange-sama could do that, she would've done it already!!"
"...You should only get angry if doing so will improve the situation. However, from a objective standpoint, doing that now would probably only aggravate the situation further. It may be humiliating, but the wisest thing to do now is to withstand it."
"Ahha! You really are a sloth, Belpha! Quit fooling around, I can't stand this!! I can't forgive them!!"
'...E-Everyone, calm down... It'll become a burden for Ange...'
"A burden?! What are you talking about? Is this the time or place to be calm?! We furniture are not so cruel as to cooly watch when our master is humiliated!!"
"Ange-sama!! You have no obligation to read such a humiliating letter! If you can't let out a cry of rage, then at least throw it onto the floor!!"
"You don't need to trash talk them, you don't need to yell so loud that they bend over backwards! Just throw the notebook on the floor with all your might...!! By doing just that, you'll be able to show your strong will!!"
"Don't start running on by yourself, Mammon!! I told you, right?! If Ange-sama could do it, she would've done so long ago!!"
"Nothing will be resolved by the eruption of momentary emotions. Can't you see that doing that will only make their treatment of Ange-sama even more severe?!"
"Waaaaaaaaaaaaahh!! Why is this happening to Ange-sama when she didn't do anything wrong?!"
"Not letting her eat dinner...and making her stay so long after school! I hate iiiiiiiiiiiiit!!"
"And it's not just tonight, but tomorrow and the day after too!! That's enough, you can't simply sit there bearing this humiliation!!"



Someone tugged at my hair. I was torn back into my tragic reality. I was no longer even permitted to listen to the Seven Sisters speaking on my behalf in my heart. My hair was lifted upwards, one of my hair ornaments came off, and I could hear the sound of it rolling on the ground. No one picked it up. To the contrary, they casually avoided it as though something filthy was rolling towards them.

I tried to follow it with my eyes, but my hair was tugged upwards again.

"Why do you neeever listen to us, even though we're talking about something so serious?!"
"In one ear and out the other, is it? Does anything get into that thick skull of yours?! Get a grip, okay?!"
"Are you really conscious of the trouble you're causing us? You aren't going to start saying that you just wrote it grudgingly because we told you to, right?!"
"Until you really show regret of your own will, this seriously isn't gonna end, okay?! It's not just for today. It'll seriously keep on going tomorrow and the day after, you see? Don't you play us for fools, okay?!?!"
"I mean, why are you still even alive? Is it normal to go on living like this? If it were me, I'd just die!"
"You can't live like this, can you?! 'Cause you being alive just means getting in other people's way all the time, right? If it were me, I definitely couldn't live on!"
"Yeah, yeah, I'd die too. If doing that's better for the world, then I'd die right away! Riiiiiiiiight?!!"



"Ange-sama..."



"Uh, ah..."
"You Seven Sisters of Purgatory are incredible furniture that can massacre mere Humans in a flash, right?! You're always boasting about it to me!! Then do it! Massacre them right now!! Right here, right now!!"
"...Well..."

For some reason, Lucifer hesitated. Why? What's wrong?! You're certain-kill furniture that can fly around faster than the eye can see and instantly pierce the hearts of a witch's enemies, right? And I'm giving you an order as your master!! Carry it out right away! Kill!! Kill them aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaall!!

"...A-Ange-sama... Please, calm down..."

If they had immediately followed my brutal order, making heaps of corpses with me at the center... I was ready to reflect on my own reckless actions of stealing human lives so readily, ready to regret and repent, just as they had wanted me to. I was prepared to do that. And yet, Lucifer just let an unsure expression rise to her face... and didn't move to carry out my order.

...I knew it.





:siren:Video: Disappear:siren:



"...A-Ange-sama,"
"...a-aaaaaahhh...!!!"

I glared into the worthless Lucifer's eyes. And pain seemed to accompany that gaze. As though she was being assaulted with a violent headache, Lucifer grasped her head with both arms. But it looked like she couldn't tear her eyes off my gaze. So she was assaulted with a pain that grew more and more violent.

"..."
"Guhguhguh, ah... gahgaaa, agaa...!! Gyack!!!"



Hopelessness and disappointment. Resignation and a dream's end. A cracking sound, like you'd hear from a frozen lake's surface during a fierce winter, rang out just once. At the same time, Lucifer's form, which was being tormented by a violent pain, stiffened in place and grew cloudy. It was almost as though a beautifully polished glass window had been heartlessly smashed and turned white from the countless fissures. And that was an accurate analogy. At some point, Lucifer's form had turned into a glass ornament of the same shape.



BGM: Golden Slaughterer

"Eeeek?!!"
"L-Luci-nee...!!"
"...Who's the second sister...? Leviathan? Carry out my order. Massacre them right now!!"
"N-No, um! Err, Ange-sama... Please calm your heart and listen... We, umm,"
"...aaah, gwaagahhgguguggah, kyaaggghh!!"

I'm not looking for excuses or back talk or an answer. I want nothing more than a swift confirmation of my order to eradicate the girls who are humiliating me. If you're going to say anything else, there's no need for me to listen until the end.



If she'd been smashed to bits and lost her original form, it probably wouldn't have seemed so brutal. So seeing the two of them halfway left over made the remaining younger sisters shake even harder...

"...Why won't you listen to my orders...? Why? WHY?!!"
"M-My apologies...!! H-Here, under the current conditions, the anti-magic power is... e-extremely strong and..."
"What's that? You can't do it because Humans are here? That's your logic? Isn't killing Humans what you do?! If you can't do that, then what use are you as furniture?!! Die!!!"
"Eeeeek!!"
"P-Please spare me, Ange-samaaaaa... ah, aaaah, khhagah, gihh, ack!!"

As she clutched her head with both arms, Satan also turned white and fell down face first.



"You can't do it because there are too many Humans? Then later on, I'll call them into the shadows one by one, and you can make a bloodbath of all of them, right?"
"...With your current magical power, it may be easy for you to converse with us. However, you still lack the training to materialize us in front of all of the Humans here...! I deeply understand your anger, but even if you could use us to attack...and murdered everyone here, that would only make your situation worse...! I know it's humiliating, but please control your anger for the time being..."



"...Will I get the same answer from the next three...? Are you gonna tell me you can't do it because the anti-magic power is too great? Are you gonna tell me you can't do it because my magical power is too weak?"
"...Then I won't ask you to kill all of them. Just one person's fine, so try and kill them. Right here, right now...!!"

As Asmodeus and Beelzebub held each other, they crouched down, cringing in fear under my glare. If they'd been able to obey my order, they probably would've carried it out immediately. And yet here they were, crouching down. Empty. Sad. And pathetic...

That's right, I've known. These girls can't even touch reality with one of their fingers...

"N-No, no...!! Belz, I'm scared, Beeelz!!"
"Ange-sama, spare us, spare us...!! I don't wanna diiiiiiiieee!!"
"Die, useless furniture! Why are you guys even alive? Why are you alive when your lives are worthless? It doesn't matter if you die, right? Die. I'm telling you to die!! Do you think any idiot would leave furniture that has no use lying around?!"



"P-Please stop, Ange-sama!!"
"...What is it, Mammon? Are you gonna be only one to fulfill my order?"
"That's right. You're my best friend. You alone will do it for me. Get them!"
"...A-As you are now, Ange-sama, even if you use us, you aren't capable of committing murder!! It's furniture's duty to help with things their master can do...! Things that even the master can't do, we can't do...!! Do you hate them, Ange-sama? You do hate them, right? I totally understand why you want to kill them!! Okay, in that case, go ahead and kill them, Ange-sama! If you stain your own hands with blood, then we, the Seven Sisters of Purgatory, will go along with you however far! However far you go!!"
"...I'm... asking you all... because I can't do it myself, aren't I...? Isn't being able to do things I can't the thing that makes you furniture?!!"
"Yes, we are furniture. Furniture to be used...!! Please, go ahead and use us to kill! You'll be the one killing, Ange-sama!! If you're saying that you want to kill, then go ahead, be my guest! No need to hesitate, go and carry it out right now!! And once you've prepared yourself mentally, once you're prepared to dirty your own hands, then we'll help you! But you haven't done that, Ange-sama!!"



"I get it already, you don't all have to tell me. You people can't do anything. You're nothing more than my delusions, illusions, daydreams...! I haven't had a single friend from the very beginning. You're just a phantom, a pretend friend I created in my heart, in my isolation, right? I've known from the very beginning!!!"



"We're just imaginary friends created to soothe lonely, lonely Ange-sama's heart because she doesn't have a single friend, but so what? If you want to look at reality, just look at it. You can stop looking at us and return to being surrounded and bathed with jeering over there!!"
"C'mon, c'mon, go back, welcome home to reality!! Just call on us only when it's convenient for you and pretend you have friends, then spur us on even though you don't have the guts to dirty your own hands, then deny and erase us once you realize that it's hopeless! Yes, please enjoy it, I'll leave with a shriek of anguish just like you want, Ange-sama!!"
"Just copy the jeering that you're being showered with right now, and do the same to us to get it off your chest. That's also furniture's duty!! Getting slammed against the floor when someone's pissed off is also a chair's important duty!! If that alone can absorb their master's bad mood even for an instant, there can be no greater honor for furniture. Kill me, deny me, your first and final friend...!!!"

At the end, Mammon had a mocking expression on her face, but for some reason, it looked splashed with tears.





"...Come over here, Sakutaro. Ange is a little agitated right now. So you mustn't get close."
'What about everyone else? Are all the Seven Sisters alive? Did they die...?'
"...It's okay. It looks gruesome, but those are the remains of their vessels after being deported from the human world. Shells that have been shed. So it's all right. They're probably deeply hurt, but they're okay. Everyone is alive. I'm sure we'll be able to meet them again someday."
'Uryu... Thank goodness, thank goodness...'
"...Ange has violated the contract of Mariage Sorcière. To do such a horrible thing, even though witches of the alliance must respect and accept one another... Even though they were all important friends to you, Ange..."



BGM: Thanks for Being Born

'Uryu, that's so cruel, so cruel...'
"...Just give it a rest with this playing witches thing. I'm begging you. Maria onee-chan and Sakutaro, I want you to disappear by yourselves. Even in my imagination, I don't want to kill and erase you."
'...W-We aren't your imagination... We're your friends, Ange, uryu...!'

Sakutaro said that as he hid behind Maria onee-chan, sobbing. Sakutaro doesn't exist. Sakutaro is also... an imaginary creature Onee-chan created to distract herself from her loneliness...

'...U-Uryu, it hurts, it hurts, Maria... Why? Why...? Uryu... uryu...'
"Stop it. Denying my friend is the one thing I will not permit."

The same power that had smashed the Seven Sisters was probably eating into Sakutaro as well. But Maria onee-chan was apparently protecting him with some other power. So Sakutaro's form didn't break and scatter.

Onee-chan glared at me sharply. It was a serious expression that I'd never seen before.

"Sakutaro is my furniture. You cannot erase him, Ange. However, trying to deny someone is the greatest form of scorn for a witch."



"Uu-!!! That's not true!! Sakutaro is my friend!! He was a stuffed animal once, but now he isn't!!"
"No, he's a stuffed animal. A stuffed animal made of cloth and cotton! He can't move or talk by himself! You're just talking for him like a ventriloquist, right?!"
"You call that magic? You call that a witch?! You call that...a friend?! I can't accept that!!"
'...Uryu... Am I... not me...? Am I... just a stuffed animal that... can't really talk... and not Maria's... friend...? U... ryu...'



As he clung to Onee-chan's body, he did all he could to continue standing, but his body began to gradually slip down... As he did, Onee-chan held him, yelling at me as tears streamed down her face...

"Uuu--!! Stop iit!! Don't burn Sakutaro with the magic-resisting toxin!! Don't bully him!! Don't insult him! Don't deny him!!"





'...Uryu, u...yu...'
"Sakutaro!! Sakutaro-!!! You aren't a stuffed animal, you aren't a stuffed animal, you're a friend!! Uuu--!!! Waaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhh!!!!"



"I hate you, Ange!! Uu-!! Why say something like that, hatehatehatehate!! I hate you!!"





...And then.

What had been peaceful days to me became a daydream and ended. By now, it's impossible to prove. No one can verify whether that really was magic or whether those really were my friends, or else nothing more than a daydream. I, the sole observer, concluded that they were a daydream. So that became the truth.

Perhaps, in the farther future, I'll observe it again, and when that happens, maybe I'll acknowledge that it wasn't a dream, that the Seven Sisters really were my friends, and that along with Maria onee-chan and Sakutaro, they did everything they could for me in my isolation. Something so vague is neither the truth nor an illusion. Maybe the reality here and now is the only world with the real me.

Where is the real me? The person standing amidst the girls' exposed wreckage that resembles broken glass sculptures, that girl who's breathing harshly, her shoulders heaving, isn't me. I'm... over there. The me that's surrounded by a crowd and being showered by jeers... and who's hanging her head, her eyes red...



BGM: None

I won't dream anymore. Because there's nowhere left to run. I'm... going back. I'll return myself to the cage made of flesh...



"...I hear you."
"Ah, you finally answered. You aren't thinking that this'll end if you stay silent, or that we'll forgive you if you cry, right?! We're asking if you're aware! We're asking if you're aware of the trouble you're causing those around you...!!"

...I... slowly nodded. I acknowledged it.



BGM: Mother

To separate myself from and disgrace those Sisters who spoke to me with reliable and kind words, despite being totally unable to help when I really wanted them to, I acknowledged that.

"...I, Ushiromiya Ange, do not have a cooperative attitude and caused trouble for my classmates. There is nothing to blame for that except my excessive inferiority complex towards all of my classmates because of my inability to study. And,"
"...It's a shame that I'm alive."

Starting there, I was no longer reading the paragraph they'd made me write. It was me... improvising. And... it was what was in my heart. They noticed that it wasn't what they'd anticipated, but while they did frown, no one spoke. So I continued.

"...That's right. It's a shame that I lived. I should've had them take me with them on that day in 1986. And yet, I was the only one who wasn't taken. Why am I here? This isn't the world I'm supposed to be in. No one will save me. For a time, I felt as though only the fictional friends I created inside myself could save me. But those friends were nothing more than a delusion, and they didn't save me at all. After all, this isn't a world of imagination, but a world of reality. So, in short, up until today, I've been having the same daydream. I hated my real classmates and only lived by interacting with the friends in my mind. Just now, I split up with those friends. So I am here."
"...I have no family. I've thrown my friends away too. There's no longer anything left for me. Why haven't I died? Someone asked that a short while ago. I think they're right. Why... am I alive? I should've died... in the year 1986. No, I must really have died. And yet, my dead soul is still locked up inside this cage of flesh. So I'll ask someone. If no one answers, I'll do it myself."



I spoke that sentence... and looked around. Dumbfounded girls. Shocked girls. Girls whose faces seemed to be saying 'What the heck is this kid talking about?' And, a bit late, more and more girls with faces that said 'Is this girl all right?' *whisper*. *chatter*. And then, *giggle*.

When I ordered the friends in my daydream to kill, they couldn't do it. And so. I asked real Humans to kill me, but of course, these girls can't do it either. In other words, both daydreams and reality are the same.

Doesn't this mean that, including this world...



Then, there's no problem, right? After all, on that day when I lost my family, I was already dead. Everything that happened afterwards is going on in my head, my life flashing before my eyes after I failed to die. Once I understood that, it felt like the scenery surrounding me began to twist and bend slightly. Yeah. I'll finally... wake up. I'll be released from this daydream world.

I feel my consciousness sliding away. That's all right. Fade farther and farther away... and take me to my family... Then, no matter what happens in this twisted, stale world, I won't mind it at all.

I saw the crowd get pushed aside as a teacher stepped in. Perhaps a teacher doing the rounds happened to notice a strange disturbance. The teacher was vigorously shouting something, moving to protect me. Watching that, I knew that an ally had appeared for me, even if there was only one, and I felt my awareness return very slightly.



Never again. Never again will I seek rescue from daydreams. This is the world of Humans. Nothing can save a Human... except other Humans...



'...Can Ange... find happiness this way...?'
"...If Ange believes that's the only way to find happiness, then it is the only way. If she can't accept the blue bird in the cage for what it is, then she must go and search forever."
'Uryu... Maria, are you... breaking off relations with Ange...?'
"...No, nothing like that. I only did that because that's what Ange wanted. We witches are sometimes persecuted. However, we always remain by everyone's sides. And our aid can always be asked for."
'...Will the day come... when Ange will play with us once again...?'
"Maybe. Or, she might forget, and it'll never come. In the human world, we call that growing up and saying goodbye to your childhood self. Still."





Aumanor
Nov 9, 2012
Can we please go back to everyone being horribly murdered on the island now?

tiistai
Nov 1, 2012

Solo Melodica
This episode is a wild ride

Sindai posted:

Wow, this is way too depressing. I hope we get back to the gruesome murders soon.

Reminder that things were quite happy when this quote was posted

tiistai fucked around with this message at 15:05 on Feb 6, 2017

Quinn2win
Nov 9, 2011

Foolish child of man...
After reading all this,
do you still not understand?
We'll be getting back to Rokkenjima soon. Not immediately, but soon.

resurgam40
Jul 22, 2007

Battler, the literal stupidest man on earth. Why are you even here, Battler, why did you come back to this place so you could fuck literally everything up?

resurgam40 posted:

Do you know the truly unforgivable thing about abuse, parent to child, sibling to sibling, master to servant? It isn't the violence itself, though that is bad enough; it isn't the fact that abuse can escalate to murder, either by the abuser going too far or the victim deciding they've had enough and killing the abuser, though that is truly monstrous.

No, the worst part of abuse is what it does to the survivors later, after they have internalized years of pain and degradation at the hands of someone who was supposed to take care of them- the altered mental state, the strangled capacities to learn and empathize, the quickness to use knife and fist yourself. And most of all, the viewpoint that comes when one stops asking "What did I do wrong?": you did nothing wrong, it's just the way of the dark, cold world. A vast merciless universe with no love or peace or help from pain, in which there are always two people, those who are hurt and those that do the hurting. If one does not have their foot in somebody else's face, then one is on the bottom and has lost, and there are only two recourses, to bash your way up to where it stops hurting so much, or look forward to the day that existence ends and the pain will stop.

Sorry to quote myself, but... this episode just brings back everything I was thinking when Rosa, herself a bullied, abused child, proceeded to abuse and bully the servants when suspicion and paranoia pointed to them. It is held by some that suffering teaches empathy for others who suffer, but a study of formative psychology reveals that the only way somebody learns empathy is through specific teaching and example, like any other learned skill... and like a skill, it a) can be exercised in good or bad ways, and b) has to be practiced every day, lest it be lost. Pain itself... just teaches that it hurts, and that hurting sucks, and that hurting should be avoided wherever possible, and (if no one teaches otherwise) at any cost. A cost which includes, purely for example: alcohol and drugs, giving your kid a smack, cheating on your spouse, just loving off to a spa and leaving your single child at home, lying, cheating, extortion, or as Ange demonstrates here, just giving the gently caress up. Renouncing all hope to be happy, even the concept of happiness itself- this is when Ange broke faith, when she cast away her hope to become the knight of infinite resignation, when she "grew up." But it's not really growing up, is it? It's breaking down, it's bending your head to your master, to logic, to realism, to the greater good- to whatever form cynicism takes in your mind. And cynicism kills "magic."

But then, what the hell is "magic," in relation to this story? Maria the Good Witch here seems to be saying that it's holding fast to dreams, respect for imaginary friends, and having hope that things will get better that is the source of magic and what witches are about... but Beatrice, in the few moments the mask has dropped, seems to be motivated by bitterness, revenge and spite, a torturous, cruel figure, which beyond an inexplicable bond with Maria, has no respect or dignity for anyone or anything, dreams or not. How does anything that she's done, or at least that is attributed to her, gel at all with what Maria is saying about the nature of magic here? And then there's the thing Mammon says about how you have to be willing and able to kill in order to command the Stakes to kill- not only is that incongruent with Maria's magic, but if true, it virtually guarantees that the murders were done without magic, in a mundane fashion. I know Maria is just one source here, a source which may not even be real as it seems to be based on a diary found after the fact... but if it is real, then where does all of this fit in?

Amidiri
Apr 26, 2010
Congratulations Ange on becoming the Witch of Dissociative Episodes, I guess.

Sindai
Jan 24, 2007
i want to achieve immortality through not dying

tiistai posted:

Reminder that things were quite happy when this quote was posted
I actually found the newest update a lot more cheerful than those, since it was already clear what was going on with Maria, Ange, and magic back then.

But here we see the birth of stone cold yakuza-evading witch-hunting Ange. :sun:

witchcore ricepunk
Jul 6, 2003

The Golden Witch
Who Solved the Epitaph


A Probability of 1/2,578,917
Now I really am hoping that future-Ange is just an illusion Beatrice is showing to Battler to dissuade him from denying magic.

Like Clockwork
Feb 17, 2012

It's only the Final Battle once all the players are ready.

Oof, poor Ange... Straight up disassociation from the stress of prolonged bullying isn't something I'm still dealing with, but it still stings to see it written so expertly. This whole school segment has been very hard to read for me, really, but the breakdown is the part that I had to look away for a bit and do something else because that poo poo's too real to me. Including the denial of magic and the like; that poo poo tends to die when you're the designated verbal punching bag. Sorry if this is a bit incoherent, I didn't expect this to hit so close to home.

I'd like to go back to the island murder party, it's less gruesome and depressing than this. :(

Lycaeon
Feb 20, 2013

A closed door is a closed mind.

resurgam40 posted:

But then, what the hell is "magic," in relation to this story? Maria the Good Witch here seems to be saying that it's holding fast to dreams, respect for imaginary friends, and having hope that things will get better that is the source of magic and what witches are about... but Beatrice, in the few moments the mask has dropped, seems to be motivated by bitterness, revenge and spite, a torturous, cruel figure, which beyond an inexplicable bond with Maria, has no respect or dignity for anyone or anything, dreams or not. How does anything that she's done, or at least that is attributed to her, gel at all with what Maria is saying about the nature of magic here? And then there's the thing Mammon says about how you have to be willing and able to kill in order to command the Stakes to kill- not only is that incongruent with Maria's magic, but if true, it virtually guarantees that the murders were done without magic, in a mundane fashion. I know Maria is just one source here, a source which may not even be real as it seems to be based on a diary found after the fact... but if it is real, then where does all of this fit in?

It means magic isn't real. Imagination is in the end imagination. No matter how much you try to hide in your delusions...

Reality always bites back and tears away the veil.

Even worse, it seems the higher one rises in one's dreams, the greater the fall when reality finally sets in. Ange wasn't a master witch. She was only an apprentice. And losing even that is destroying her.

Beatrice, or Sayo, likely reached heaven at the height of her dreams.

This entire story is her fall. :smith:

Lycaeon fucked around with this message at 20:56 on Feb 6, 2017

Fabulousvillain
May 2, 2015
Magic is a pretty convenient lie, seems like this time it just made accepting the truth so much harder. Also I forgot how to write in blue, anyone wanna an incompetent one out?

Quinn2win
Nov 9, 2011

Foolish child of man...
After reading all this,
do you still not understand?
Fixed + Italics = Blue.

Lycaeon
Feb 20, 2013

A closed door is a closed mind.

quote:

"Just copy the jeering that you're being showered with right now, and do the same to us to get it off your chest. That's also furniture's duty!! Getting slammed against the floor when someone's pissed off is also a chair's important duty!! If that alone can absorb their master's bad mood even for an instant, there can be no greater honor for furniture. Kill me, deny me, your first and final friend...!!!"

At the end, Mammon had a mocking expression on her face, but for some reason, it looked splashed with tears.

I take back what I said about the stake sisters being one-dimensional. There's something tragically brave and self sacrificial about what Mammon says here. :smith:

One of the tenets of the knight of resignation is that he inevitably falls. He is said to be a dancer, "able to make the movements upwards, and fall down again," into doubt and vacillation, and so becomes a stranger unable to attain his dream. Kierkegaard created the concept in order to address his faith in God - a faith that was constantly challenged and that he himself doubted. To him the knight of faith was someone better than him, someone who would fall from faith, inevitably, repeatedly, but unlike the knight of resignation, he would persevere in his belief. He would repeat the movement upward again, until at the peak of his movement he makes the leap of faith and walks in the sky instead of falling.

We see here Ange doubting, unable to make the movement of faith needed to stay afloat, something I think is reflected in what Mammon says. And so she falls back into torment, resigning herself to reality.

But she will pick herself up, and make that movement upwards into the sky again, towards faith and hope. After all, this scene takes place long after what we see here. She returns to Maria and Mammon. :unsmith:

Lycaeon fucked around with this message at 00:28 on Feb 7, 2017

idonotlikepeas
May 29, 2010

This reasoning is possible for forums user idonotlikepeas!

Sindai posted:

I actually found the newest update a lot more cheerful than those, since it was already clear what was going on with Maria, Ange, and magic back then.

But here we see the birth of stone cold yakuza-evading witch-hunting Ange. :sun:

Agreed. This is significant, character-wise:

ProfessorProf posted:



Never again. Never again will I seek rescue from daydreams. This is the world of Humans. Nothing can save a Human... except other Humans...

Obviously she didn't quite stick with it, but it's an important realization regardless. Sometimes you have to go all the way down to realize you can fix things in your world rather than by retreating into an imaginary one.

Lycaeon
Feb 20, 2013

A closed door is a closed mind.
I personally believe imagination and faith (What I think 'magic' is in this story) represent optimism and hope. Too much of it, or solely investing in it to the exclusion of reality, is tragic as we've seen. But on the other hand pure realism and cynicism can weigh one down completely, as God knows the real world is a miserable poo poo-hole. :smith:

If Ange retreated from hope for her family's return, she would never have taken Bernkastel's hand and embarked on her journey into the past to find out what happened. Hope in the impossible chance that she could bring them back is what brought her, and us, into this world. It's what's bringing her to re-open Maria's diary and reacquaint herself with the imaginary friends she once foreswore.

Otherwise she would've become cynical and miserable much like Eva was before her death. Much like she was already before she took Bernkastel's hand.

She's on firmer ground now in terms of holding a realistic outlook, but hope and optimism, and maybe a tiny dose of 'magic', are spurring her on. Regardless of whether her current struggle is delusional or not, I'm rooting for her.

Edit: I'd just like to re-state how amazing this novel is. I've read my fair share of literature but don't remember the last time I've felt so emotionally and mentally drawn in. The characters, the music, the drawings, the mystery...it's all coming together like an epic of immersion and I don't want it to end.

Edit2: With the exception of this part. This part can't end soon enough.

Lycaeon fucked around with this message at 02:00 on Feb 7, 2017

EagerSleeper
Feb 3, 2010

by R. Guyovich
Ange is probably really going to take Lambadelta's preposition seriously at this point so they don't have to put up with this stuff anymore. A+ for the writing of the bullying as realistic and horrible as it is in real life, but jeez...

Fabulousvillain
May 2, 2015

ProfessorProf posted:

Fixed + Italics = Blue.

Because of believing in magic; Ange, who thought she lost all hope, lost the hope she didn't even know she had. Thanks for the depression!

Aumanor
Nov 9, 2012
I'm strting to lose track of what was in the updates, what has been linked by others in the thread, and what I've stumbled into on my own: have we heard the vocal version of "Thanks for being born" yet?

tiistai
Nov 1, 2012

Solo Melodica

Aumanor posted:

I'm strting to lose track of what was in the updates, what has been linked by others in the thread, and what I've stumbled into on my own: have we heard the vocal version of "Thanks for being born" yet?

No and we won't in Umineko. It's actually on one of dai's Higurashi albums.

idonotlikepeas
May 29, 2010

This reasoning is possible for forums user idonotlikepeas!
You know the strangest thing about the most recent series of updates?

ProfessorProf posted:

Prepared Backlog: 10 updates

This number hasn't really changed.

tiistai
Nov 1, 2012

Solo Melodica
The strangest thing is that Prof's wrists are apparently still more or less holding up

Aumanor
Nov 9, 2012
I'm reading this completely blind so I haven't even peeked into the discord channel but I'm pretty curious how active it is.

tiistai
Nov 1, 2012

Solo Melodica
The Discord channel is mostly about metacommentary of the thread and Fire Emblem Heroes

Pretty active on an average day

Quinn2win
Nov 9, 2011

Foolish child of man...
After reading all this,
do you still not understand?


BGM: Mystic Forest

"..."



Sakutaro looked up at Maria sadly. Maria's face was covered with tears, and it looked as though it had even lost all traces of sadness...

"...Uu-. I hear you, Sakutaro. You aren't a stuffed animal made of cloth and cotton. You are... my friend. I hate Ange. Uuuuuuuuuuuu..."
'Uryu... Sorry, Maria. Sorry, Maria...! Uryu...!'

Sakutaro regretted doing that. By freezing her heart, Maria had finally been able to escape from her sadness. By speaking up and calling her back, he'd caused her to be overwhelmed with sadness again...

Sakutaro tried hugging Maria, letting go of her, and gazing at her uneasily, lost as to how he could bring Maria's spirits up. He might've looked a little humorous doing that. In the end, that was enough to distract Maria from her sadness...

"Sorry. Crying won't help anything anymore."
'You got in a fight with Ange, but you still have lots of friends, Maria... I'm not the only one. Everyone's here. Sakusuke and Sakukichi, the animal band, and many, many more...'

Maria looked at the many stuffed animals around her pillow, which were gathered together as though they were having an idle chat.

'...Everyone... is worried about you, Maria. They're all talking over and over about how to cheer you up, okay...?'
"...Everyone won't... go away... like Ange...?"
'They won't. We'll always be together.'
"...Really? All of you are only with me at home. We can't go out together when Mama's around, and we can't go to school."



"...Sakutaro, you're big, so you'd be found."
'Then you can take one of the kids that are small enough to walk around with. For example, what about them? If you take the friends in the forest band... look, they're small, so you can hide them in your pocket and go to school together.'
"...There's a lot of them in the band. I can't fit them all in my pocket."

She collected all of the forest band pieces that were scattered across her bed. There were about as many of them as pieces in a chess set, so it'd probably be impossible to fit them all in her pocket...

'In that case, you can just take friends that you're especially close with. You can take the four rabbits, your best friends in the forest band.'
"...I could fit four in my pockets. Yeah. This way, they won't be found."
'Now, you won't be alone even at school, Maria. Those kids will be with you even where I can't go.'
"...Yeah. Maybe... I won't be lonely that way. Maybe I can hold out... until coming home from school..."
'As long as we aren't found by the teacher and Mama, we can be with you at any time. So let's be together, play together forever. We definitely won't leave you all alone, Maria. Uryu!'

Maria's expression finally regained a little of its brightness.



Even without Ange, it was fun with everyone. And yet, strangely enough, it suddenly became sad without Ange, who had come in at the end. All that's happened is that I've returned to the world right before Ange entered it. So there's nothing to be sad about.

"...Yeah. I'm not lonely. Sakutaro and the others are with me."
'Uryu-! I looove you, Maria...!'
"I won't let any more Humans come into my world. Mariage Sorcière is an alliance between me and Beatrice only. From the start, even Beatrice didn't want to let Ange join. It's all right this way. Ange was still too young."
'...For now, until you can be friends with Ange again, I think it's okay to forget about it. You can play together once you've regained your high spirits, Maria. Until then, all of us will be by your side.'
"...Thank you. Sakutaro, everyone."



BGM: Apathy

Just like usual, she didn't have any Human friends at school, but her magic friends were always with her. The rabbit band she hid in her pockets talked with her during class, sounding like they were having fun. Just listening to that greatly embellished the time she spent in class.

Maria made it so that, as long as Mama and the teacher didn't find out, her other friends could always be with her. When Mama told Maria to go play outside, Maria would secretly pack Sakutaro and Sakusuke and the rest into her bag and play together at the library or somewhere. Even when Mama was late coming home and Maria went shopping for dinner, she always went with Sakutaro.



When Mama found out, Maria would get in trouble for bringing Sakutaro and the rest outside. When the teacher found out, Maria would get in trouble for bringing toys to school. The toxin must be strong in Mama and the teacher. That's why Sakutaro looks like a normal stuffed animal to them. After all, the convenience store man and the others say hello to Sakutaro.

...Not all Humans are hopeless. There are tons of people who, unlike Ange and Mama and teacher, can say hello to magic friends like I can...



"Yeah. But I've got Sakutaro, so I'm not lonely. Right, Sakutaro?"
'Uryu. It's not just Sakutaro today. Some other friends came too.'
"Oh, other friends, is it? What kind of friends did you bring today?"
"Today, the rabbits from the forest band are also with me. Look, in my pocket."

Maria began to line up four ceramic rabbit dolls on the register. As the owner of the shop looked at it, smiling, he sent a signal to a part-timer with his chin. Then, the sign on the other register that said 'closed' was taken down, and a voice called out for everyone to move over there. All of the people in line behind Maria lined up behind that one...

"I see, I see. You do have a lot of friends, Maria-chan. But I hope your Mama comes home soon."
"Uu-. Mama's busy with work again, so she's spending the night at the company. It's been very busy lately. She hasn't even been able to get much time to talk to me on the telephone."
"But I'm not lonely! I've got Sakutaro and the rest! Right?"
'Uryu-!!'
"I've even got all the rabbits from the band. Look. Kyu-kyu-♪"
"Is kyu-kyu- the sound a rabbit makes? My, I've never heard that."

After smiling at Sakutaro, who was poking his head out of her knapsack, she played around with the rabbit band on the register, making them frolic around.



...This was apparently a single mother household, where the mother had to work hard and couldn't come home very often. On top of that, it looked like this girl didn't even have any friends. As he watched her play around happily with her dolls and claim that she wasn't lonely despite everything, he couldn't help but feel a kind of compassion.

And actually, this wasn't limited to him alone. Maria had become quite famous in this shopping district...



"Uu-? Can't get a cream roll...?"
'Uryu. If you don't eat certain things, you won't get big. How about oden for today?'
"Uu-. Then I'll have some oden."
"Yep, yep, that's the ticket. Why don't I stick a whole bunch in there? Want mustard?"
'Uryu. I can't handle spicy things...'
"I see, I see. Then, you make sure you don't let it spill on the way home. It'll sure be delicious while it's hot."
"Uu-. Thank you."

She had planned on getting some sweet pastries for dinner, but since oden had been recommended to her, she would be having that tonight instead. Letting someone else determine the menu makes for an unexpected and interesting meal. Very often, Maria had to decide what her dinner would be on her own, so it was easy for the menus to get a little one-sided. So, it felt fun to have a meal she hadn't anticipated...

'Uryu-! Thanks for giving us extra, Mister!'
"Send my regards to your other friends at home. No stuffing yourself on your way back. Go straight home and eat it there."
"Uu-! Thanks Mister!!"

Maria raised the bag with the oden container high...



BGM: None

'...Uryu? What is it, Maria?'
"...The key isn't in my pocket."



She always methodically put it in the same pocket. So there was no way she had put it in another pocket, but she searched her whole body just in case. Unsurprisingly, it wasn't there.

'Did you drop it when you took your wallet out...?'
"No. When I took my wallet out, I definitely felt it. I also felt it when I searched my pocket partway here. It was there until partway. I didn't drop it! Uu-uu-uu-...!"

Even though the late autumn wind had been bearable when Maria had been thinking of returning home, where the heater was, now that she was confused and had lost her key, that wind tormented her. But no matter how hard she searched, she couldn't find her key. She turned out all her pockets and even tried taking off her jacket and hitting it, but to no avail. Of course, she also turned the knapsack Sakutaro was in upside down, but the key didn't come out.

"...Uu-. Uu-uu-uu-!!!"

Something that should have been there... wasn't where it was supposed to be. Why isn't the key there, when I didn't do anything wrong? Why isn't it?! Why?! Why...?!!!

Maria was cold and frustrated and angry, and she stamped on the ground... The bottom of her foot throbbed, but that didn't lessen her frustration. At the same time, her tears poured out.



BGM: Fortitude

It wasn't her fault. So, it was someone else's fault. But Maria didn't know who that someone was... and could do nothing but continue to let out a moan of anger.

'...Uryu... I'm sure you dropped it partway... Let's look for it, okay? Let's return on the road we came by and search, okay...?'
"...Uu-... Even though I went to all the trouble of buying oden... and got eggs and stuff for free... I won't be able to eat it while it's hot... Uuuu----!!!"
'...Maria, I know it's frustrating, but let's search, okay...? It's no one's fault, so let's search...'

Maria finally lent an ear to Sakutaro's words and began to trod back down the road she had come on. The wind was colder than before, and it felt like it was blowing in through the corners of her jacket in a mean way...

'Uryu... Let's watch our feet closely and search, okay...? Then let's get home quickly, let the heater warm us up, and eat oden, all right? I'm sure it'll be delicious.'
"...Uu-. Gone. Uu-. It's gone..."

As Sakutaro encouraged her, Maria searched for the key... But she made it all the way back to the convenience store where she'd bought the oden. She hadn't found it. Just in case, she asked the man at the convenience store whether they had found a dropped key, but they hadn't found anything. One more time, she returned home, paying close attention to the area around her feet. But, unsurprisingly, she didn't find it.

She was no longer frustrated enough to stomp her feet. But hot tears dripped down her face. The oden had cooled down completely. Even though she had been told it would be delicious when warm, she hadn't been able to eat it. Even though that man had given her so much free stuff...



"...Why can't I find it...? Uuuu, uuuuuuuu!"
'Maria, don't cry...! Let's do our best and search...! Maria...'

Maria was no longer able to hold back her tears. Sobbing, she clutched Sakutaro and held the bag of oden, returning once more down the road she had come by. Perhaps because more and more houses and stores had turned their lights off by now, it was even darker and harder to search than before. And, once again without finding the key, she returned to the convenience store.



"...Uu-... My key... It's gone..."
"Wasn't your mother away for the night? So, you can't get into your house without a key?"
"Uu-... Can't get in..."
"Well, that's not good... Did you try going to the police? They might be able to help you."
"...Mama said not to talk to policemen, even if they start talking to me."
"Oh? Well, why is that?"
"..."



So, Maria was indoctrinated into changing the stores she bought things at, so that she didn't catch the eyes of adults, and into saying no more than a greeting to policemen, even if they talked to her. Maria had obediently done as she was told. Instead of considering why she must do that, she was much more concerned with meekly obeying because her mother had told her so.

But the manager of the convenience store probably didn't think of it that way. In the first place, seeing such a young girl being forced to watch over the house alone, and so frequently, would make anyone worry...



"It's that child. Maria-chan, did you find your key?"
"...Uu-... Didn't find it..."
"What's your name, miss?"
"..."

The policeman asked her name, but Maria didn't answer.

"Did your mother tell you not to talk to policemen? Heheheh! Don't worry, no need to be scared of me. Have you eaten dinner yet, miss?"
"...I bought some, but I couldn't get into my house, so I couldn't eat it."
"What's your mother doing? Is she not coming home tonight? Is it her work?"
"...Uu-."
"Do you know how we can contact your mother at work?"
"..."

Maria hung her head limply. She didn't understand why the policeman was getting mad at her. No, he probably wasn't getting mad at her, but if this reached her mother's ears, then she would definitely be in trouble. Even if she didn't understand the reason why she would be in trouble, she at least understood that much. But the policeman wouldn't let Maria go. And her head was swimming from hunger.

The policeman noticed that, and it was decided that he'd listen to her story as they ate in the police box.



She had been told not to talk to policemen, but after being asked about Sakutaro, she responded, starting to feel that this wasn't a bad person. And anyway, she wouldn't be able to return home now, so she didn't know what to do. She told him Mama's work phone number, which she had been told to tell no one of and to use only in a very, very serious situation. In the tatami room inside the police box, as she ate the oden that was so hot it felt like it would burn her, she watched the policeman making the phone call, lazily thinking, 'Aah, I'm probably gonna get in trouble'.



BGM: Eternity

'...Uryu...'

He must have been listening to the phone ringing for a very long time. With the receiver up to his ear, the policeman looked up at the clock, grumbling.

"...Maybe they aren't picking up because their business hours are over. Hmmmmmm... Huh? Hello? Hello? Is this Anti-Rosa Ltd.? This is the Komatsugawa Police Department police box in front of Senbonzakura Station. Is President... umm... Udaikan... no, wait, President Ushiromiya available? ...Yes. What? She's on vacation?"



"Oh no, no, no, never mind. So, do you know where she might be? You haven't heard where to contact her, have you?"
"Sure, could you hold on for a second? Hey, anyone heard where the president went for her vacation? Or how to contact her?"
"I heard she was going for all-you-can eat crabs in Sapporo with her boyfriend. Aaaw, I'm sure such a cold place will do wonders for shrinking the distance between them, don't you? I haven't heard how to contact them."
"Yep, understood. Um, hello. I hear she went to Sapporo, but I'm not sure about how to reach her. Should I take a message?"
"Hmm, I see, what a shame. Well then, if you manage to get in touch with her again, could you tell her that we called? Sure, yes."

After that, I was taken to the police department, which was even bigger, and ended up spending the night there. Then, they asked me various things about myself.



And I was told 'You poor thing'. When I heard that, I learned for the first time.





Quinn2win fucked around with this message at 14:48 on Feb 7, 2017

Quinn2win
Nov 9, 2011

Foolish child of man...
After reading all this,
do you still not understand?

tiistai posted:

The strangest thing is that Prof's wrists are apparently still more or less holding up

It turns out that this thread was doing less damage to my wrists than trying to teach myself to play guitar was.

SystemLogoff
Feb 19, 2011

End Session?

:smith:

This game is depressing.

Aumanor
Nov 9, 2012
I have a feeling we're about to find out what happened to Sakutarou.

oath2order
Oct 12, 2013

It's MAGIC. I don't have to explain shit!


It was about midway though this update that I decided no, I didn't really need to read this part for a third time. :smith:

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Like Clockwork
Feb 17, 2012

It's only the Final Battle once all the players are ready.

Oh no, this won't end well... :ohdear:

  • Locked thread