Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
comedyblissoption
Mar 15, 2006

Main Paineframe posted:

Yeah, why couldn't Obama have made a simple change that solely benefited the poor, like massively expanding Medicaid eligibility? Or infrastructure spending as economic stimulus? The joke, of course, is that he did attempt both those things, among many other policies that would have helped poor whites, but both were blocked by both state and national Republicans in the name of their ideological opposition to government programs that help poor people.

It's true that those groups' support for Dems dropped off about fifty years ago, particularly in the South...but that happens during the very height of LBJ's Great Society and his War on Poverty, when American poverty rates were dropping at unprecedented speeds (at least until Nixon dismantled key anti-poverty programs).

The narrative of liberal elitists laughing at poor rural whites from afar while doing nothing to help them is certainly a common one, but it's hard to square that with the actual facts. On the other hand, it sure bears an uncanny resemblance to cultural resentment of Northeastern elites that the South has held since before the Civil War!
in the 2009-2010 congress, the democrats had the presidency, a 58% majority in the house, and passed the ACA with a filibuster proof senate majority caucus. trying to hide behind republican obstructionism is a bankrupt argument

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Main Paineframe
Oct 27, 2010

comedyblissoption posted:

in the 2009-2010 congress, the democrats had the presidency, a 58% majority in the house, and passed the ACA with a filibuster proof senate majority caucus. trying to hide behind republican obstructionism is a bankrupt argument

lol, just gonna quote this one real quick before you realize your tremendous mistake

jBrereton
May 30, 2013
Grimey Drawer
Because they're scared of richer people who hate people as poor as them (see how nobody major went to jail over the 2008 crash, the healthcare thing was a piece of poo poo compared to anywhere civilised, and there's still no maternity leave in the US, because of this fear about The Economy), and because they are bitchmade they think this fear justifies an ugly cruelty to people poorer than themselves who they think deserve to hate/fear them in the same way.

Hope that helps!

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

Pener Kropoopkin posted:

That's not even germane to the point.

It is because every time one of you 101 level marxists grabs the mic all we hear about is corruption in the capitalist system and it's inevitable downfall, while failing to provide even a single example of a human economic system or other arrangement that's free of the sorts of things that happen whenever 2 humans talk to eachother. It's like you're gaming human interaction by a dungeons and dragons ruleset, except assuming you can roll a 20 every single time.

jarofpiss
May 16, 2009

gobbagool posted:

It is because every time one of you 101 level marxists grabs the mic all we hear about is corruption in the capitalist system and it's inevitable downfall, while failing to provide even a single example of a human economic system or other arrangement that's free of the sorts of things that happen whenever 2 humans talk to eachother. It's like you're gaming human interaction by a dungeons and dragons ruleset, except assuming you can roll a 20 every single time.

what

call to action
Jun 10, 2016

by FactsAreUseless

gobbagool posted:

It is because every time one of you 101 level marxists grabs the mic all we hear about is corruption in the capitalist system and it's inevitable downfall, while failing to provide even a single example of a human economic system or other arrangement that's free of the sorts of things that happen whenever 2 humans talk to eachother. It's like you're gaming human interaction by a dungeons and dragons ruleset, except assuming you can roll a 20 every single time.

single payer healthcare, it's like the tides, they go in and out and you can't explain it

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

yeah sorry kind of a wordy way of saying...communists, especially of the anime internet variety, seem overly fond of pointing out the flaws in capitalism while refusing to acknowledge their system sucks even worse, but for the exact same reason, which is the human beings will almost always do the wrong thing if it means helping out a friend or otherwise connected associate, be it done under the banner of Adam Smith or Vladimir Illyich Lenin. Pener, as someone who claims to have a history degree, should be able to acknowledge this, or alternatively, provide an example to the contrary from the vast number of successful communist societies.

That Robot
Sep 16, 2004

ask me anything about robots
Buglord
liberals don't hate the poor op

only conservatives hate the poor

Thoguh
Nov 8, 2002

College Slice

gobbagool posted:

yeah sorry kind of a wordy way of saying...communists, especially of the anime internet variety, seem overly fond of pointing out the flaws in capitalism while refusing to acknowledge their system sucks even worse, but for the exact same reason, which is the human beings will almost always do the wrong thing if it means helping out a friend or otherwise connected associate, be it done under the banner of Adam Smith or Vladimir Illyich Lenin. Pener, as someone who claims to have a history degree, should be able to acknowledge this, or alternatively, provide an example to the contrary from the vast number of successful communist societies.

Here's on C-SPAM we're advocates of the Gay Weed branch of Full Socialism Now, actually.

Pener Kropoopkin
Jan 30, 2013

gobbagool posted:

yeah sorry kind of a wordy way of saying...communists, especially of the anime internet variety, seem overly fond of pointing out the flaws in capitalism while refusing to acknowledge their system sucks even worse, but for the exact same reason, which is the human beings will almost always do the wrong thing if it means helping out a friend or otherwise connected associate, be it done under the banner of Adam Smith or Vladimir Illyich Lenin. Pener, as someone who claims to have a history degree, should be able to acknowledge this, or alternatively, provide an example to the contrary from the vast number of successful communist societies.

Marxism is self-critiquing, and so for that matter are almost all other schools of socialism. It's not like everybody just ignores the problems of Actually Existing Socialisms, the point is that they were still preferable to capitalism, and that there are better alternatives to past models.

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

Pener Kropoopkin posted:

Marxism is self-critiquing, and so for that matter are almost all other schools of socialism. It's not like everybody just ignores the problems of Actually Existing Socialisms, the point is that they were still preferable to capitalism, and that there are better alternatives to past models.

Yes cuba and north korea are surely preferable to living in Germany or the US and if you think otherwise I suggest you read das kapital again until you understand

Dreddout
Oct 1, 2015

You must stay drunk on writing so reality cannot destroy you.

That Robot posted:

liberals don't hate the poor op

only conservatives hate the poor

This_is_what_liberals_actually_believe.txt

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

Dreddout posted:

This_is_what_liberals_actually_believe.txt

they also believe woody allen movies are good

Pener Kropoopkin
Jan 30, 2013

gobbagool posted:

Yes cuba and north korea are surely preferable to living in Germany or the US and if you think otherwise I suggest you read das kapital again until you understand

Why wouldn't you want to live in Cuba?

call to action
Jun 10, 2016

by FactsAreUseless

gobbagool posted:

Yes cuba and north korea are surely preferable to living in Germany or the US and if you think otherwise I suggest you read das kapital again until you understand

I wouldn't want to live in Cuba but that's mainly because everyone there is so much healthier that I'd be embarrassed



Call me a communist, but those outcomes with 95% less spending doesn't SEEM to be an example of government inefficiency

edit: lol they switched cuba and the US for blood glucose and high blood pressure, unless somehow america is fatter without having any of the associated health effects

call to action fucked around with this message at 20:13 on Mar 22, 2017

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

Pener Kropoopkin posted:

Why wouldn't you want to live in Cuba?

so this is where you tell me Cuba is actually a really kickin rad country and way more free than the US, right?

call to action
Jun 10, 2016

by FactsAreUseless

gobbagool posted:

so this is where you tell me Cuba is actually a really kickin rad country and way more free than the US, right?

Cuba is indeed kicking rad, unless you're into fat people

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

call to action posted:

I wouldn't want to live in Cuba but that's mainly because everyone there is so much healthier that I'd be embarrassed



Call me a communist, but those outcomes with 95% less spending doesn't SEEM to be an example of government inefficiency

edit: lol they switched cuba and the US for blood glucose and high blood pressure, unless somehow america is fatter without having any of the associated health effects

I guess if your sole concern is where your country ranks on a health survey, and nothing else matters, then yeah, you should break your way into cuba. I imagine there's plenty of rafts in south florida from people (obviously employing double plus wrongthink) who came the other way

call to action
Jun 10, 2016

by FactsAreUseless

gobbagool posted:

I guess if your sole concern is where your country ranks on a health survey, and nothing else matters, then yeah, you should break your way into cuba. I imagine there's plenty of rafts in south florida from people (obviously employing double plus wrongthink) who came the other way

As a human being, yes, my physical health is a primary concern of mine. There's no need to take rafts as Frontier flys cheap from Miami to Havana. Lots of people go to Cuba for cheaper, better medical care though, to your point.

Pener Kropoopkin
Jan 30, 2013

Life seems pretty great when you're the privileged middle class of countries that extract imperialist super profits.

the bitcoin of weed
Nov 1, 2014

imagine being on the side of the people fleeing Cuba after the revolution when that includes the people who spawned Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

call to action posted:

As a human being, yes, my physical health is a primary concern of mine. There's no need to take rafts as Frontier flys cheap from Miami to Havana. Lots of people go to Cuba for cheaper, better medical care though, to your point.

So when are you leaving for Cuba? I can't imagine a reason why you wouldn't go, as you've stated, your physical health is a primary concern for you, and you don't seem the type to be able to figure out the American healthcare system. Do you have a patreon where I can donate for your airfare?

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

Pener Kropoopkin posted:

Life seems pretty great when you're the privileged middle class of countries that extract imperialist super profits.

OK, yeah, i'm a white male with a mid 6 figures job living well, so you have a point. What makes you and your fellow travellers think that life in Cuba is so great though? I mean, people arent sneaking into cuba, they're putting their lives on the line to escape, on primitive rafts in dangerous waters. Why are they doing that? Because healthcare is so great in cuba that they just cant stand all the winning? Seriously, why is it that people are always fleeing communist paradises, to go to capitalist horrorshows like western europe and the US?

call to action
Jun 10, 2016

by FactsAreUseless

gobbagool posted:

So when are you leaving for Cuba? I can't imagine a reason why you wouldn't go, as you've stated, your physical health is a primary concern for you, and you don't seem the type to be able to figure out the American healthcare system. Do you have a patreon where I can donate for your airfare?

I have a job with a good healthcare plan, so I'm good even if I can see how hosed things are for others. I agree that it's pretty silly we have a healthcare system we have to "figure out"

gobbagool posted:

OK, yeah, i'm a white male with a mid 6 figures job living well, so you have a point. What makes you and your fellow travellers think that life in Cuba is so great though? I mean, people arent sneaking into cuba, they're putting their lives on the line to escape, on primitive rafts in dangerous waters. Why are they doing that? Because healthcare is so great in cuba that they just cant stand all the winning? Seriously, why is it that people are always fleeing communist paradises, to go to capitalist horrorshows like western europe and the US?

Why would you sneak in? Like I said, Frontier offers cheap flights there for the savvy medical tourist.

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

call to action posted:

I have a job with a good healthcare plan, so I'm good even if I can see how hosed things are for others. I agree that it's pretty silly we have a healthcare system we have to "figure out"

so when are you leaving for Cuba? Is your health your primary concern or not? If i didnt know better, I'd say you're just a contrarian marxist dipshit, but I mean that in the nicest possible way. If you think people are too stupid to make their own decisions, no wonder you're a totalitarian fanboy.

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

call to action posted:


Why would you sneak in? Like I said, Frontier offers cheap flights there for the savvy medical tourist.

Sure, so why don't cubans just fly out? Oh yeah that's right, they need permission, and most cubans are far too poor to contemplate a plane flight, ever, but yeah they do get those super sweet che tshirts and 'free' medical care so I guess that makes up for the grinding poverty and lack of freedom

Bear Retrieval Unit
Nov 5, 2009

Mudslide Experiment

Zoq-Fot-Pik
Jun 27, 2008

Frungy!
Gas or destroy the Yoda loving Luke GBS guy please.

Pener Kropoopkin
Jan 30, 2013

gobbagool posted:

What makes you and your fellow travellers think that life in Cuba is so great though?

Healthcare, public transit, local and workplace democracy, tropical environment, better education, more attractive people. All that seems like a fair trade off from being able to grow morbidly obese and vote for a useless bourgeois party that doesn't represent public interests. People don't move there mostly because they can't, not because it's not as if they'd like to. There's actually a lot of people from the United States who are retiring to Cuba, but they've got a lifetime of savings and investments behind them - people like you.

Have you ever given any pause to why, for instance, if capitalism is such a superior system then why is the flood of refugees flowing into Europe and the United States primarily from other capitalist countries?

Crowsbeak
Oct 9, 2012

by Azathoth
Lipstick Apathy

Zoq-Fot-Pik posted:

Gas or destroy the Yoda loving Luke GBS guy please.

I prefer a ten year mandatory vacation to siberia for him.

The_Politics_Man
Aug 25, 2015

gobbagool posted:

OK, yeah, i'm a white male with a mid 6 figures job living well, so you have a point. What makes you and your fellow travellers think that life in Cuba is so great though? I mean, people arent sneaking into cuba, they're putting their lives on the line to escape, on primitive rafts in dangerous waters. Why are they doing that? Because healthcare is so great in cuba that they just cant stand all the winning? Seriously, why is it that people are always fleeing communist paradises, to go to capitalist horrorshows like western europe and the US?

So are you trying to be an example of why people hate libs or does it just come naturally?

gobbagool
Feb 5, 2016

by R. Guyovich
Doctor Rope

Pener Kropoopkin posted:


Have you ever given any pause to why, for instance, if capitalism is such a superior system then why is the flood of refugees flowing into Europe and the United States primarily from other capitalist countries?


cuba - noted 'other capitalist country' has provided over 1.1m refugees to the United States. my god you're as bad as borneo jimmy

Pener Kropoopkin
Jan 30, 2013

gobbagool posted:

cuba - noted 'other capitalist country' has provided over 1.1m refugees to the United States. my god you're as bad as borneo jimmy

quote:

http://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/mexican-immigrants-united-states
After four decades of rapid growth, the size of the Mexican immigrant population in the United States has remained stable in recent years. In 2014, more than 11.7 million Mexican immigrants resided in the United States, accounting for 28 percent of the 42.4 million foreign-born population—by far the largest immigrant origin group in the country.

Between 2006 and 2010, the number of Mexican immigrants increased by 200,000 compared to the more than 2 million who arrived in the five years prior (see Figure 1). Following this trend, in the last decade and a half, the Mexican share among all immigrants dropped from 29.5 percent in 2000 to 27.6 percent in 2014.

The_Politics_Man
Aug 25, 2015

gobbagool posted:

cuba - noted 'other capitalist country' has provided over 1.1m refugees to the United States. my god you're as bad as borneo jimmy

So is Mexico communist? What about Haiti?

Mc Do Well
Aug 2, 2008

by FactsAreUseless
When is the last time a raft came here from Cuba - the 90's? Update your bullshit grandpa - those rafts are vectors for terrorists preying on bleeding heart liberals!

Oh Snapple!
Dec 27, 2005

It's me, I'm the guy who feels sorry for the displaced bourgeois in the wake of getting their poo poo seized

call to action
Jun 10, 2016

by FactsAreUseless
Also Cuban women are loving gorgeous blends of like every race, sorry no objectify. Hybrid vigor indeed.

Scrub-Niggurath
Nov 27, 2007

"If socialism is so great why does Cuba suck?" -a very smart and cool guy

The_Politics_Man
Aug 25, 2015

Oh Snapple! posted:

It's me, I'm the guy who feels sorry for the displaced bourgeois in the wake of getting their poo poo seized

For people who follow an ideology that got its start cutting rich assholes heads off, liberals sure hate politcal violence.

The_Politics_Man fucked around with this message at 20:57 on Mar 22, 2017

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Pener Kropoopkin
Jan 30, 2013

I can't even afford to move to the next county, let alone another country.

  • Locked thread