Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Ichabod Sexbeast
Dec 5, 2011

Giving 'em the old razzle-dazzle
:suspense:

e: Well this was a terrible snipe. Still though, jfc.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Lichtenstein
May 31, 2012

It'll make sense, eventually.
GM of the Infinite Action Wrestling Campaign and can confirm not a single soul in that game knew poo poo about wrestling other than "Hulk Hogan is a man who existed". I fed my usual group a steady diet of Shockmaster memes and took basic effort to prepare some helpful materials (what's the few acknowledged pretend rules of wrestling, a bunch of sample moves so people have something to use for bullshitting up fisticuffs) and it pretty much rolled smoothly from there. And since it is very open to a revolving door troupe play* (there's no 'party', musclemen just get booked in matches) I kept it completely open and even invited some online randos, some of which knew anything about wrestling and it was super cool. Though I went and watched a bunch of Lucha Underground to prep for GMing and I regret none of this.

Out of all PbtAs out there this one, by virtue of its kayfabe-conscious premise, is best at having players work at cross-purposes for fun times (including the original ApocWorld) and one pretty close to a storygame. I usually dislike the latter, with the 'roll outcome decides who gets to narrate the scene' mechanic being the cut-off point for me where the game is just too light, but it works for me here - probably because it's confined to pretend matches where it makes perfect sense to do it that way, while there's still a GM to gently caress with people.

One caveat is that while the game is great at prodding people to do stuff, you still need a crew that is able to roll with the punches and bullshit up fun stuff. That guy who never really comes up with anything, but is happy to just chill with his friends and actas party's healbot can make for some lovely times here. "Yeah, I, uh... clothesline him. *rolls dice on the Work stat he maxed, figuring that's what wrestlers do* Okay, I keep control. So I uh... let me check the sheet... Powerbomb him, I guess."

Also a player in the current game and I'm:
- dating my boss
- kinda sorta running the show atm
- not a wrestler and steadfastly confident you can treat the medium like a musical that happens to feature fights instead of songs (I'm the theater kid Tekopo mentioned)
- running a twitter with intentionally bad VPW memes for one of our NPCs that GM once made an off-hand comment how he's bad and out of touch online.
- caplocking my heart out as a not-Alex Jones ring announcer I thought up on a whim and sorta stuck with him, even though his very existence probably doesn't make much sense**

* The current goon Discord game veered heavily enough into personal drama it's less true there, but that's more of a matter of player preference than the system's framework.

** Or is that what the BIG WRESTLING wants you to think???

Lichtenstein fucked around with this message at 02:58 on Jan 6, 2020

Quidthulhu
Dec 17, 2003

Stand down, men! It's only smooching!

Is this an open discord people can hop into and play because holy poo poo your wrestling world is amazing :3:

Aniodia
Feb 23, 2016

Literally who?

Lichtenstein posted:

I fed my usual group a steady diet of Shockmaster memes...

I went and watched a bunch of Lucha Underground to prep for GMing and I regret none of this.

:golfclap: Take some time, look up some CHIKARA and some other independent federations as well. There's a lot of neat stuff out there, if you wanna look for it.

Lichtenstein
May 31, 2012

It'll make sense, eventually.

Aniodia posted:

:golfclap: Take some time, look up some CHIKARA and some other independent federations as well. There's a lot of neat stuff out there, if you wanna look for it.

Oh yeah, I've gotten into it a little since then. Rather liking how AEW is shaking out, death to McMahon.

Chikara and Kaiju Big Battel are loving insane.

Tunicate
May 15, 2012

I assume you're familiar with the Ironman Heavymetalweight Championship?

Skip past the list of champions to the 'notable champions'.

EthanSteele
Nov 18, 2007

I can hear you
Some friends did the Tomb of Horrors 5e and after just going "nope, gently caress that" to anything that was suspicious and getting all the 50/50 stuff right, they defeated the demilich by grappling him and putting him in a bag filled with flasks of holy water and using the Bigby hand to crush and punch him. Turns out the demilich only has 2 moves that don't require him to be able to see the target so it didn't matter than the barbarian had thrown away the +1 flail for a nonmagical axe and did literally no damage because welp, can't see through the bag.

One of them got drangled by the brain fog, but the very first thing they said after "hi, how are you, what are you doing down here?" was "do you mind coming over here to talk?" so that whole thing was easy too after a couple of restorations. In the end there were no deaths, closest was the "hp to 0" Howl, but the barbarian had the thing makes you survive with 1 hp AND death ward so he survived that twice and the polymorphed Siren got hit too so she just got spat out of owlbear form with full hp too.

CobiWann
Oct 21, 2009

Have fun!
According to my GM, there is no such thing as Night City Comic-Con.

But in a few weeks we are playing an all-day Cyberpunk 2020 session...

Luigi's Discount Porn Bin
Jul 19, 2000


Oven Wrangler

berenzen posted:

Story #1: The Mandusa.
W... Why did Steve have to be golden and hairless? That's not really a medusa thing... Was it just a "make something extremely horrific looking" idea that someone had? Or did Steve have an early childhood sexual awakening while watching Goldfinger on TBS?

Reclaimer
Sep 3, 2011

Pierced through the heart
but never killed



CobiWann posted:

According to my GM, there is no such thing as Night City Comic-Con.

Of course not, the original Comic-Con sued so they had to change it to something less catchy.

Agrikk
Oct 17, 2003

Take care with that! We have not fully ascertained its function, and the ticking is accelerating.
Manga Mash(tm)

berenzen
Jan 23, 2012

Luigi's Discount Porn Bin posted:

W... Why did Steve have to be golden and hairless? That's not really a medusa thing... Was it just a "make something extremely horrific looking" idea that someone had? Or did Steve have an early childhood sexual awakening while watching Goldfinger on TBS?

I have no desire to delve into the minds of either Steve or the game runner at the time, who was eventually ousted as a sex pest and forced out of the community.

Yawgmoth
Sep 10, 2003

This post is cursed!
One of my players used a spell he's had since forever to call in a big evil fire elemental to fight for them, and promptly named it Burnie Cinders.

the_steve
Nov 9, 2005

We're always hiring!

EthanSteele posted:

Some friends did the Tomb of Horrors 5e and after just going "nope, gently caress that" to anything that was suspicious and getting all the 50/50 stuff right, they defeated the demilich by grappling him and putting him in a bag filled with flasks of holy water and using the Bigby hand to crush and punch him.

Reminds me of a boss fight we had in the first VtM campaign I larped in.
It was some sort of Super Ghost, I can't remember the actual name for it, and our plan was to wrap it in a blessed burial shroud and beat them like a pinata.

joylessdivision
Jun 15, 2013



Tunicate posted:

I assume you're familiar with the Ironman Heavymetalweight Championship?

Skip past the list of champions to the 'notable champions'.

:allears: oh Japan. Seriously that list of notable champions is hilarious and I thought "Oh it can't get better than a Ladder but then it just keeps getting better.

Tekopo
Oct 24, 2008

When you see it, you'll shit yourself.


Two of the people in the wrasslegame (me included) are fans of NJPW, although the game really gave me some motivation to watch more wrestling and even go to some local shows.

DivineCoffeeBinge
Mar 3, 2011

Spider-Man's Amazing Construction Company

CobiWann posted:

According to my GM, there is no such thing as Night City Comic-Con.

Of course not. It's a Cyberpunk future.

It's Night City Anime-Con.

LupusAter
Sep 5, 2011

Well, I guess I'll bring some more wrassletales. I am too in the goon game, playing as Javier aka Fragata, the Luchador.


He's a third-generation luchador, so he literally grew up in the biz. The thing is that the gimmick of his family promotion is that everyone there has a bird-themed mask and name, and the callbacks and jokey references have reached the point where I enlisted comedy wrestling master Ganso Sin Nombre as help for a match.

Backstage I've somehow managed to avoid most drama, which has made Javier one of the reasonable people in the locker room, which is hilarious as he's a dyed-in-the-wool carnie, probably incapable of surviving in polite society, and perfectly willing to put his personal safety in jeopardy if he thinks it'll lead to good lucha.

The big storyline I've concluded has been saving our giant jobber's career by training him and having him debut as the hoss luchador Casuario to help me take revenge on the heels that had kidnapped my PC's grandfather, the original Fragata.

I'm one of the more diehard wrestling fans in the game, and I must say that writing up matches in the system is a delight, it doesn't constrain what you can try to do but has you live with the consequences.

Tunicate
May 15, 2012

joylessdivision posted:

:allears: oh Japan. Seriously that list of notable champions is hilarious and I thought "Oh it can't get better than a Ladder but then it just keeps getting better.

There are compilation videos on youtube which are great

Phy
Jun 27, 2008



Fun Shoe

LupusAter posted:

Ganso Sin Nombre

Oh my god, talk about your heels with face heat

BallisticClipboard
Feb 18, 2013

Such a good worker!


I'm running a 13th Age game for my friends and a lot weird stuff happens like the Roll20 dice gaining sentience for a few sessions. One of my players is playing a dragonborn named Jubilee, the first daughter of the White Dragon, Whom we renamed La Blanche because saying 'The White' made everyone a reasonable amount of uncomfortable. La Blanche and Jubilee get their power from the moon. As a bit for the first few sessions, I said what phase the moon was in to add some flavor. One week, I said it was a super moon because there was one in real life. Roll20 ran wild with this; Jubilee could not roll below an 18 for that entire session, even when I rolled for her. Then next session, I said it was a new moon and Jubilee missed with every roll. That solidified that they should only adventure during the full moon. I haven't stated what phase the moon is in for a little while and I really need to next session.

Another short story, also featuring Jubilee, showcases her relationship with her mom. Jubilee's player decided that as the first daughter of La Blanche, she has the worst of her sibling. She's the smallest, has the lowest magical skill ceiling of her siblings and is basically the runt. As a result, her mom doesn't really care for her. Jubilee is a Cleric going around spreading the good word about the moon. Her mom sends her into the world with hand-me-down equipment and her church is basement room in a bar in the bad part of town. Later we meet her brother, clad in pristine armor and robes, who is preaching out of a large church in the hills. I posted this as a reference for it


As I recall this stuff, I think I have a few more stories to write. Like the creation of the moon which doesn't exist in the game world by default. And my players accidentally making an imitation of a legendary magical item too well.

BallisticClipboard fucked around with this message at 05:45 on Jan 7, 2020

Wrestlepig
Feb 25, 2011

my mum says im cool

Toilet Rascal
WWWRPG owns, I had a one shot that ended with the boss getting screwed and the championship belt going to a jobber heel with a Top-hat evil vaudeville robber baron gimmick.

Preechr
May 19, 2009

Proud member of the Pony-Brony Alliance for Obama as President

LupusAter posted:

Well, I guess I'll bring some more wrassletales. I am too in the goon game, playing as Javier aka Fragata, the Luchador.


He's a third-generation luchador, so he literally grew up in the biz. The thing is that the gimmick of his family promotion is that everyone there has a bird-themed mask and name, and the callbacks and jokey references have reached the point where I enlisted comedy wrestling master Ganso Sin Nombre as help for a match.

Backstage I've somehow managed to avoid most drama, which has made Javier one of the reasonable people in the locker room, which is hilarious as he's a dyed-in-the-wool carnie, probably incapable of surviving in polite society, and perfectly willing to put his personal safety in jeopardy if he thinks it'll lead to good lucha.

The big storyline I've concluded has been saving our giant jobber's career by training him and having him debut as the hoss luchador Casuario to help me take revenge on the heels that had kidnapped my PC's grandfather, the original Fragata.

I'm one of the more diehard wrestling fans in the game, and I must say that writing up matches in the system is a delight, it doesn't constrain what you can try to do but has you live with the consequences.

Oh my god he has a literal pepperoni nipple, it’s amazing :discourse:

Synthbuttrange
May 6, 2007

that cat rear end tattoo.

neonchameleon
Nov 14, 2012



Tevery Best posted:

WWW is very explicit about how it's all predetermined - the winners and losers of fights are decided by literal GM fiat

Unless one of the ways to overturn the booking is used (as you posted in your story).

Aniodia posted:

:golfclap: Take some time, look up some CHIKARA and some other independent federations as well. There's a lot of neat stuff out there, if you wanna look for it.

The other one to look up right now is NWA Powerrr on youtube - seriously retro modern wrestling. But for third parties I'd recommend starting with Lucha Underground - or Netflix' GLOW (which is a TV show rather than an actual wrestling league).

CobiWann
Oct 21, 2009

Have fun!
Two words - Orange Cassidy.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9WFs_WJH04

Senerio
Oct 19, 2009

Roëmænce is ælive!

JustJeff88
Jan 15, 2008

I AM
CONSISTENTLY
ANNOYING
...
JUST TERRIBLE


THIS BADGE OF SHAME IS WORTH 0.45 DOUBLE DRAGON ADVANCES

:dogout:
of SA-Mart forever

CobiWann posted:

Two words - Orange Cassidy.

Ah yes... the one that Jim Cornette calls "My little dog pockets" because he refuses to promote him in any way.

the_steve
Nov 9, 2005

We're always hiring!

Just got back from a game day, played in a couple PFS games.
Two modules, two near death experiences.

The first module was some sort of big overland race. At each checkpoint, you had to complete a challenge related to this guy's legend, though you were granted a ton of leeway in how you actually solved each puzzle.
The race starts with our sled falling apart at the starting line. We get it repaired, and we have our suspicions about it being sabotaged and by who, but we're unable to find any conclusive evidence.
It doesn't matter though, because the way the module is written, we loving steamroll everything and rack up so many progress points that even if all the other teams combined theirs, we'd still be beating them.
Whether this is because the DM misunderstood how it was supposed to go, or if the module just wasn't written that well, I dunno. Regardless, we broke the challenges over our knee.

At the third checkpoint though, we discover the mutilated corpse of a caribou. Everybody crit fails their check to determine anything useful, and I joke that they all think Tiamat did it.
"Yes, Tiamat, the 5 headed goddess of evil dragons, she killed this caribou."

NPC with actual ranks in Survival: "Actually it was some sort of bear. We've seen this thing before."

"Well obviously Tiamat taped a polar bear to each of her claws in order to cover up her involvement."

The DM announces that this is exactly what everyone who crit-failed believes, and we all have a good laugh about it.
"Is Tiamat even in Pathfinder!?"
"She is now!"

All the fun died as we get to the end of the module, when we get attacked by the previously alluded to bear.
A Giant Short-Faced Bear, or something like that.
This motherfucker was a tank and a half.
24 AC, and so much +to hit that anything higher than a 3 or 4 on the die was a hit.
Oh, and when it hits you, it auto-grapples you and it gets to throw you 20 feet away, and that also deals it's full melee damage to you. And it doesn't have to roll to succeed, it just happens.
So, on any given round, it was probably doing a minimum of 20 damage.

Our average party level was just shy of 3.

It was basically a war of attrition. We had a Cleric and 2 Sorcerers who were able to focus on healing (save for the two times the Cleric used that Fire Ray focus spell to great effect), which kept my monk and the barbarian standing, which allowed us and the Champion to maintain a constant flanking bonus and eventually wear the bear down and beat it.

We dragged it back to town and made a stew out of it for our victory banquet.

The second module. Jesus loving Christ.
For a bit of background: My very first PFS character was a Magus back in 1e. Several years ago, he had his throat torn out by a Bearded Devil, and even though he had enough banked Prestige to get rezzed, a number of factors stopped me from playing for a long time, I lost his chronicle sheets, and I functionally retired him. To this day, he still just hangs out in the Dark Archives doing busywork down there.
Pretty sure I posted about it way back when it happened, either in this thread or one of the previous iterations.
So, I have a bit of faux-PTSD when Bearded Devils are involved.

Our mission for the second module was to find a previously unknown Pathfinder Lodge that some ancient legendary pathfinder had established centuries ago, and bring back any info about her and the stuff she was up to, since a lot of the stories about her have big blank spots in them.
After getting an idea of where to even find the place from a vintner whose ancestor used to own the land in question, we make our way there.

Inside, the place is infested with kobolds. Enough so that it became a threat, as they were able to flank us at numerous points and just take advantage of their superior numbers.
This was especially bad when they brought a spellcaster with them and used themselved to form a barricade between us and the spellcaster who kept laying into people with Magic Missile to great effect.

After a long time (because we kept rolling for poo poo on our attack and damage rolls - as in, doing 4 damage on a crit bad) we kill the minions and take the time to rest up.
Earlier, we had encountered the ghost of the guy who originally owned the keep, and he explained how he had tried to get one over on a Bearded Devil, since he figured a devil would be less expensive than provisioning actual troops.
The ghost makes a deal with us that he'd help us seal the Devil inside of a stone throne that kept is bound to the Keep, or something.
Honestly, I completely misunderstood what we had agreed to, as I found out later.

Fully rested and recovered, we make our way to the main chamber where the Devil awaits us.
We haggle for awhile, offering to send it back to Hell so it won't be stuck in the Keep with nothing but kobolds for another century, and it tries to get us to hand over the Ghost (who is inside an old Wayfinder we found) and he'll let us leave alive.

Negotiations fall through, and combat begins.
In the first round, the Devil stabs me with the glaive for a critical 35 points of damage, plus persistent bleed and then busts me for another 10 on a regular hit.
My max HP is like 47.

"I swear to god, if another one of my characters dies to a bearded devil, I am loving done with Pathfinder."

Fortunately, although the Devil gets a few solid hits in, we're able to keep ourselves standing and score some large hits despite his absolute smorgasbord of resistances and DR.
In a bit of closure/full circle, it was my monk with a Positive energy charged Ki Strike/Flurry of Blows combo that dropped the Devil.

With the Devil down, I complete the ritual to bind it to the stone throne while the Champion stabilizes the rogue and deals with everyone's persistent bleed damage.

Now, here's the thing: When we were talking to the ghost, I completely misunderstood what he was asking us to do, and I thought he was giving us instructions on how to unbind the Devil from the throne when it died so it would go back to the Hells.
What actually happened was the Devil is bound to the throne like an infernal battery.

As a result, as far as the chronicle sheet is concerned, I have a slottable Boon that says I am the rightful master of an infernal keep. Once per adventure, I can do the Pathfinder equivalent of Hellish Rebuke, using a Reaction to torch an enemy for fire damage if/when it targets me or an ally for an attack.

I've also decided that, since my character considers himself as training for the Starstone Trial, one of his Godly edicts is going to involve a personal grudge against devils. Not for any moral reason, just because gently caress Em.

Edit: Wow, more :words: than I thought that was going to be.

hyphz
Aug 5, 2003

Number 1 Nerd Tear Farmer 2022.

Keep it up, champ.

Also you're a skeleton warrior now. Kree.
Unlockable Ben
So, instead of moaning on chat, here’s an experience from our last session that I find representative and you all might find amusing.

We’re playing through the standard adventure set for Pathfinder 2e. The players are about to head into the last section of the module, but are just slightly below the recommended level for it. The module suggests a couple of encounters to throw at them on the way to tip them over the XP threshold. As they are sailing upriver on a stolen boat, I go with a Rusalka. Basically a siren.

So. I tell the players that as they are sailing up the river, they see a strange blue-skinned creature emerge from the water onto some rocks, and it begins to sing a haunting song. I ask them to make Fort saves for the ability.

I of course know exactly what to expect, and have the book ready to answer the inevitable flurry of tactical questions:
- how wide is the river?
- how wide and long is the boat?
- how far is the boat from the bank?
- are you sure that people standing on the opposite side of the boat would be affected?
- how far was the ship from the Rusalka at the moment it appeared?
- did you roll to see if anyone spotted the Rusalka waiting in the water before it came up?
- are there any other ships, and did we see or hear them getting attacked?

Which were headed off when I pointed out that the range of their song is 300 feet according to the book.

We go into initiative, which I preroll having taken an example from Dragon Friends. There is, as always in PF2e, some minor dithering because the start of combat rules in PF2e are screwy.

Everyone except two PCs make their save and are now immune. The others are Fascinated and obliged to move towards the Rusalka for 1 round. We stop to discuss and reference if casting Flight on oneself to gain the ability to move towards the Rusalka is acceptable (I say yes). The other asks if steering the ship towards the bank would be acceptable and I say yes to that to, since hey that’s what sirens did, but the other player points out that the PC who was previously steering the ship (and made their save) is in the way of them turning the wheel, and asks if they can try and fail to reach the wheel in order to satisfy the charm.

On their turns, the PCs Grapple the non-flying charmed PC. We look up if they can be Pinned (not in PF2e) and what happens if like 3 other PCs dogpile them (RAW nothing but we can fudge it)

On their turn, the Rusalka extends the charm on the other PCs, although both make saves, meaning the charm will end after 2-3 rounds. After a round of movement and grappling, I try to consider what they would do next. Trying to climb onto the boat is suicide. I notice they can summon a Living Waterfall, which might help with the people on the boat, so they do that. “How do they know everyone has made their saves against the song?” is muttered.

I break out the Bestiary and look up Living Waterfall. It also can’t exist outside the water. There are no listed HP or defences for boats, so no way to adjudicate an attack. It does have Control Water, but the effect of this spell is to raise or lower water uniformly in a wide area by up to 10’, and to “Slow any marine creatures in it”. A spell which can only mildly inconvenience a fish is going to do sod all against a boat of any size.

So next round the flying PC breaks the charm and turns around and I have both the fae just gently caress off into the river because there’s nothing they can do. The flying PC suggests trying to hunt the Rusalka down, but can’t thanks to their huge Stealth bonuses underwater.

The game goes on with the players unimpressed by the unproductive, uninteresting and lengthy sidetrack.

I’m pretty sure I did a bunch of stuff wrong. But I hope this puts my previous attitudes in some context..

Golden Bee
Dec 24, 2009

I came here to chew bubblegum and quote 'They Live', and I'm... at an impasse.
Ran a Fallout game sat in the Coachella valley.

It was a mixture of Palm Springs decadence, and western tale. Turns out this area wasn’t nuked during the great war, so it was a paradise attracting way too many people.

There was a saga about a crooked tribal leader trying to attract people with rumors of a (fake) gold mine, and the Rangers of Joshua Tree National Park expanding and trying to create a national park the size of the entire state.

Meanwhile, one of the players was a taker who just wanted to be left alone but was under the thumb of the crooner and mayor Frankie Z.

The Rangers attacked a PC’s ranch, doing brutal damage with boulder catapults and sniper fire. (Boulders were much more effective than rockets or atomic weapons in preserving the land.)
What I didn’t expect to happen was the Tinkerer stealing an airplane from the Palm Springs airfield, attaching his lightning gun, and bombing the Rangers from the air... and landing perfectly.

I was so willing to drop in consequences but every airplane flying roll was perfect. A bloody land battle, by a joyrider looking to impress his friend the rancher.

Very Fallout.

Golden Bee fucked around with this message at 04:08 on Aug 15, 2023

Angrymog
Jan 30, 2012

Really Madcats

hyphz posted:

I’m pretty sure I did a bunch of stuff wrong. But I hope this puts my previous attitudes in some context..
I'd have just given them the level as a 'reward' for reaching the endgame, but I get the feeling that wouldn't wash with your group. Could also have adjusted the difficulty of the dungeon down.

Re. The ruskalla and the waterfall, dropping the water under the boat by 10' would have possibly damaged the boat with the drop, and sunk it the moment the surrounding water rushed back in, leading to everyone being in the drink.

Ilor
Feb 2, 2008

That's a crit.

hyphz posted:

I’m pretty sure I did a bunch of stuff wrong. But I hope this puts my previous attitudes in some context..
Maybe...quit playing games with lovely rules that don't help the GM work with the players to create compelling stories? I'm not sure what to tell you here.

Yawgmoth
Sep 10, 2003

This post is cursed!

Ilor posted:

Maybe...quit playing games with lovely rules that don't help the GM work with the players to create compelling stories? I'm not sure what to tell you here.
This, but also stop playing with crazy people who absolutely need to follow every single rule to the letter as if fudging anything will cause the whole table to burst into flame and melt at once.

Baku
Aug 20, 2005

by Fluffdaddy

Yawgmoth posted:

This, but also stop playing with crazy people who absolutely need to follow every single rule to the letter as if fudging anything will cause the whole table to burst into flame and melt at once.

The only worse thing are people who combine playing-to-win and rules-as-written, because they dutifully police the other players and the GM for any infraction upon the letter of the law and then become creative storygaming libertines who love the spirit of the law the moment their own turn starts

Agrikk
Oct 17, 2003

Take care with that! We have not fully ascertained its function, and the ticking is accelerating.
One of my biggest mistakes as a GM was to say “whatever the die rolls, stands.” I killed too many players to stupid dice rolls in a Twilight:2000 campaign that I am embarrassed by it.

In that same vein, players who stick to the rules are also mistakes.

Groups that treat the rules of a game as holy gospel passed down from God on high are missing the facts that: the game system was created by people who did plenty of adjusting to the rules to make it playable to them and: these games are meant to entertain and when they don’t do that then changes need to be made.

HiKaizer
Feb 2, 2012

Yes!
I finally understand everything there is to know about axes!
As Whose Line Is It Anyway says, the points are made up and the rules don't matter.

the_steve
Nov 9, 2005

We're always hiring!

No. 1 Apartheid Fan posted:

The only worse thing are people who combine playing-to-win and rules-as-written, because they dutifully police the other players and the GM for any infraction upon the letter of the law and then become creative storygaming libertines who love the spirit of the law the moment their own turn starts

Don't some of the newer rulebooks, like 5e (shut up, 5 years ago is still newer enough for me) and PF2 actively encourage DMs to view the rules as more of a suggestion/framework than an absolute "This is how it must be." ?

CobiWann
Oct 21, 2009

Have fun!
According to my DM, I am not allowed to hire a goblin to follow the PC's around and steal the verbal, somatic, and material signs of the Wizard in order to have the goblin bang on a drum during a fight with the Big Bad to let them know which spells are incoming and if they're worth Counterspelling.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

hyphz
Aug 5, 2003

Number 1 Nerd Tear Farmer 2022.

Keep it up, champ.

Also you're a skeleton warrior now. Kree.
Unlockable Ben

the_steve posted:

Don't some of the newer rulebooks, like 5e (shut up, 5 years ago is still newer enough for me) and PF2 actively encourage DMs to view the rules as more of a suggestion/framework than an absolute "This is how it must be." ?

Yep, but ask a Pathfinder Society GM what happens when a PC dies and see what they say ;)

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply