Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
i say swears online
Mar 4, 2005

I'm driving less so I bought a month of wow classic to catch up on podcasts, rip

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Zerg Mans
Oct 19, 2006

i say swears online posted:

I'm driving less so I bought a month of wow classic to catch up on podcasts, rip

The only reason I bought a 2nd screen for my computer is because I got tired of warping to a spot in eve, alt tabbing to youtube, and coming back after 5 minutes to find my wreckage

papa horny michael
Aug 18, 2009

by Pragmatica
gwzegsnydermans

gradenko_2000
Oct 5, 2010

HELL SERPENT
Lipstick Apathy
Podcast listening during my daily commute has been replaced by podcast listening while cooking meals, washing dishes, and cleaning around the house

I remember I stopped listening to Dan Carlin's HardR History when his WWI series was using Niall Ferguson as a reference, and now I'm getting mad again because he read Shattered Sword to research the Battle of Midway and he still didn't take the right lessons from it.

OctoberCountry
Oct 9, 2012

Lol

The Muppets On PCP
Nov 13, 2016

by Fluffdaddy

Phone posted:

when the atlantic council is funding your paycheck and you’re publishing poo poo that MI6 is feeding you, you might be laundering the imperial project buddy

tankie jeff foxworthy is a good idea for a bit

Trabisnikof
Dec 24, 2005

crepeface posted:

did you guys know it's possible to do work that is bad and also do work that is good

Next you’re going to bring up the Autobahn.

Atrocious Joe
Sep 2, 2011

Atrocious Joe posted:

I ended up listening to "It Could Happen Here" this week, which is a former Cracked writer trying to predict what a new US civil war would look like.

It was fine, but I mostly finished it to figure out what goes on in the mind of a self-described leftist who views the Ukrainian Maidan protesters and Syrian FSA militias as examples to emulate.

lol that this was my first post in this iteration of the thread

I've been complaining about Evans for over a year at this point

Omnicarus
Jan 16, 2006

gradenko_2000 posted:

Podcast listening during my daily commute has been replaced by podcast listening while cooking meals, washing dishes, and cleaning around the house

I remember I stopped listening to Dan Carlin's HardR History when his WWI series was using Niall Ferguson as a reference, and now I'm getting mad again because he read Shattered Sword to research the Battle of Midway and he still didn't take the right lessons from it.

I'm in a similar boat on Dan. I'm convinced he didn't actually read modern accounts because he references some superb histories like Shattered Sword as too technical and then promptly uses sources that have been debunked for 40 years and accounts that are explicitly called out as physically impossible. It was extremely frustrating and I just turned it off after a bit.

Gripweed
Nov 8, 2018

Retromancer posted:

I would severely question the sanity of a person who listens to a podcast without doing anything else.

I have a nice stereo system and a papasan and if I'm not busy I'll spend an hour or two just listening to podcasts.

PoontifexMacksimus
Feb 14, 2012

gradenko_2000 posted:

I remember I stopped listening to Dan Carlin's HardR History when his WWI series was using Niall Ferguson as a reference, and now I'm getting mad again because he read Shattered Sword to research the Battle of Midway and he still didn't take the right lessons from it.

Omnicarus posted:

I'm in a similar boat on Dan. I'm convinced he didn't actually read modern accounts because he references some superb histories like Shattered Sword as too technical and then promptly uses sources that have been debunked for 40 years and accounts that are explicitly called out as physically impossible. It was extremely frustrating and I just turned it off after a bit.

What does he gently caress up?

THS
Sep 15, 2017

I only listen to Chapo Trap House in a sensory deprivation tank. After five minutes it’s like they are in the tank with you. I get a lot more out of it this way, with Felix and myself walking through my mind palace holding hands.

uber_stoat
Jan 21, 2001



Pillbug
me when I listen to podcasts.

Impkins Patootie
Apr 20, 2017





Goast posted:

CIA goons

Ytlaya
Nov 13, 2005

crepeface posted:

i guess i'll bow to thread consensus on evans' since you all seem to be way more informed about him. i just don't see this version you guys are presenting in his recent coverage or podcasts

That's the thing about many liberal figures; they'll talk about some people who are actually bad and generally speak from a similar moral framework to the left, but use it to harmful ends. Even when he's not directly advocating for awful things (like in the tweets Goast linked), he deliberately limits his focus to certain topics in a way that ends up influencing the way the listener perceives the world (through influencing what they choose to focus on).

The reason why many of us react strongly is that Evans, do to being a goon (ex-goon? not sure if he ever still posts as Brown Moses) acquired his own share of enthusiastic support on these forums, who treated him as some sort of expert on topics like Syria or Libya when those issues were contemporary during the Obama administration.

Basically people perceiving him in the way you perceive him (and the fact that it's easy to imagine how an otherwise reasonable person could view things that way), despite the guy essentially being a US war propagandist, is a big reason why he is so concerning.

Pirate Jet
May 2, 2010

Ytlaya posted:

That's the thing about many liberal figures; they'll talk about some people who are actually bad and generally speak from a similar moral framework to the left, but use it to harmful ends. Even when he's not directly advocating for awful things (like in the tweets Goast linked), he deliberately limits his focus to certain topics in a way that ends up influencing the way the listener perceives the world (through influencing what they choose to focus on).

The reason why many of us react strongly is that Evans, do to being a goon (ex-goon? not sure if he ever still posts as Brown Moses) acquired his own share of enthusiastic support on these forums, who treated him as some sort of expert on topics like Syria or Libya when those issues were contemporary during the Obama administration.

Basically people perceiving him in the way you perceive him (and the fact that it's easy to imagine how an otherwise reasonable person could view things that way), despite the guy essentially being a US war propagandist, is a big reason why he is so concerning.

Evans isn’t Brown Moses. he posts in the RGD thread about Behind the Bastards.

but otherwise this is correct. inexperienced socialists - and myself if I’m gonna be honest - have their biggest weakness in foreign policy. this is mostly because the most effective way to do politics is to show people what’s in it for them, and socialism does have some very good answers for converting Americans, given more and more of us wind up impoverished every day. it’s easy to sell people on leftism with concepts like M4A, wealth inequality, and workers’ unions, but much harder to get people to care about a country they will never go to.

people like Evans are uniquely dangerous because his opinions on domestic issues can be largely correct (he was a Warren stan, that dumbass) so when inexperienced leftists see him espouse those views, they start to trust the dude. and then when foreign policy talk starts happening they’re like “I don’t know anything about that, but Evans has a really strong opinion on this and I trust him on other matters.” and then they start repeating those opinions without interrogating or knowing anything about them because that’s just the nature of the Internet.

so if the accusations of Evans being a CIA stooge are true, he’s aware of this phenomenon and is intentionally exploiting it to run damage control on American empire’s recent string of failures and further disenfranchisement of left-leaning people. and if they’re not true, then he’s an imperialist dumbass who’s doing incalculable damage to the left by not just shutting the gently caress up.

Pirate Jet has issued a correction as of 20:43 on Jul 27, 2020

Honest Thief
Jan 11, 2009
i realised the other day was i drunkly talking about Virgil Abloh going to LVMH with a washed cousin who's into fashion and i kept calling him virgil texas

i say swears online posted:

I'm driving less so I bought a month of wow classic to catch up on podcasts, rip

factorio my dude

i say swears online
Mar 4, 2005

Honest Thief posted:

factorio my dude

best game ever, but if I fire it up I will not move for twelve hours. I installed some complexity mods that are kicking my rear end

The Atomic Man-Boy
Jul 23, 2007

The Muppets On PCP posted:

tankie jeff foxworthy is a good idea for a bit


When you've seen the violence of ISIL first hand, but support the killing of Qasem Soleimani, you might be a fed-neck.

When YUUUUU say you're an anarchist, but think Epstein killed himself, you might be a fed-neck.

docbeard
Jul 19, 2011

Some podcasts I'll listen to without actively doing anything else, but those are mostly scripted audio drama where I actually want to pay attention.

People chattering about things or playing D&D for an audience or whatever is for choretime/videogame time.

Halloween Jack
Sep 12, 2003
Probation
Can't post for 6 hours!
Fortunately, I know that the US should not militarily intervene anywhere in the world ever for any reason, and don't particularly care if the people who disagree have been to Syria or wherever.

papa horny michael
Aug 18, 2009

by Pragmatica
agreed. and also that evans guy writes like a cop

MonsieurChoc
Oct 12, 2013

Every species can smell its own extinction.
I listen either while working from home or playing videogames.

I just started a game of EU IV as the Papal State.

AnEdgelord
Dec 12, 2016

MonsieurChoc posted:

I listen either while working from home or playing videogames.

I just started a game of EU IV as the Papal State.

be careful about subjugating Naples, if you don't have truces with some of the north Italian states its very easy to have a coalition fire immediately after you vassalize them

babypolis
Nov 4, 2009

Doc Hawkins posted:

Materialist historical theories are not exercises in moral justification. Do you also think Marx's account "excuses" capitalism? He says directly that the capitalist is just as trapped by the system as the worker!

yeah this seems strange as gently caress to me. might as well say that every historian endorses war and wanton slaughter

Epic High Five
Jun 5, 2004



babypolis posted:

yeah this seems strange as gently caress to me. might as well say that every historian endorses war and wanton slaughter

It's more complicated than that, it's more that the individual capitalist is only as free as he is willing to further the status quo, and that any who try to buck the trend by forgoing infinite growth forever or more fairly compensating employees will be destroyed by those who embrace those things, because the system provides a million ways for the crazy to destroy the kind but only one way for the kind to destroy the crazy

thotsky
Jun 7, 2005

hot to trot

zegermans posted:

That's a good point, no one listens to a podcast unless they're unable to do other things

Yeah, like sleep.

babypolis
Nov 4, 2009

Epic High Five posted:

It's more complicated than that, it's more that the individual capitalist is only as free as he is willing to further the status quo, and that any who try to buck the trend by forgoing infinite growth forever or more fairly compensating employees will be destroyed by those who embrace those things, because the system provides a million ways for the crazy to destroy the kind but only one way for the kind to destroy the crazy

did you quote the wrong post or something? what does this have to do with what said

Epic High Five
Jun 5, 2004



babypolis posted:

did you quote the wrong post or something? what does this have to do with what said

It's the rationale in Kapital for the argument that the capitalist is just as trapped in the system as the worker

Epic High Five
Jun 5, 2004



Probably should've responded to the original but time spent reading posts is time spent not posting. Not efficient

cenotaph
Mar 2, 2013



Someone in the protests thread called people bringing up Evans' intelligence connections tankies and I nearly spontaneously combusted.

Xaris
Jul 25, 2006

Lucky there's a family guy
Lucky there's a man who positively can do
All the things that make us
Laugh and cry

Doc Hawkins posted:

Materialist historical theories are not exercises in moral justification. Do you also think Marx's account "excuses" capitalism? He says directly that the capitalist is just as trapped by the system as the worker!
It's been many years since I read Diamond but yeah, my take away was never "he loves da imperialism and genocide! just random acts of entropy aka white apologism!!" at all. that seems more like a dumb take the libs who love white fragility or something would say to appear academically-woke. it was very much like capitalism or proto-capitalism/feudalism/monarchocapitalism = bad and self-destructing and that europeans are terrible people inflicting mass suffering in their wake, this was pretty clearly spelled out many times over. there is certainly a lot that diamond did not do right or well, but he set out, very specifically, to disprove the notion of 'european supremacy' and phrenology-biotruth poo poo that is/was al the rage amongst libs n think-tankers and point out no white europeans bad. this is much less useful in tyool 2020 than in 1996.

now whether you can start a book with a thesis of saying "europeans and imperialism = bad" and then spooling around it like cotton candy to flesh it out is a different question

V. Illych L.
Apr 11, 2008

ASK ME ABOUT LUMBER

GGS tries to answer 'why europe' from a basically materialist/determinist perspective. it's deeply speculative and methodologically suspect, but it tells a good story. it's overrated insofar as it's been massively hyped over the years, but it's a very fine pop-sci book

Ytlaya
Nov 13, 2005

Pirate Jet posted:

Evans isn’t Brown Moses. he posts in the RGD thread about Behind the Bastards.

but otherwise this is correct. inexperienced socialists - and myself if I’m gonna be honest - have their biggest weakness in foreign policy. this is mostly because the most effective way to do politics is to show people what’s in it for them, and socialism does have some very good answers for converting Americans, given more and more of us wind up impoverished every day. it’s easy to sell people on leftism with concepts like M4A, wealth inequality, and workers’ unions, but much harder to get people to care about a country they will never go to.

people like Evans are uniquely dangerous because his opinions on domestic issues can be largely correct (he was a Warren stan, that dumbass) so when inexperienced leftists see him espouse those views, they start to trust the dude. and then when foreign policy talk starts happening they’re like “I don’t know anything about that, but Evans has a really strong opinion on this and I trust him on other matters.” and then they start repeating those opinions without interrogating or knowing anything about them because that’s just the nature of the Internet.

so if the accusations of Evans being a CIA stooge are true, he’s aware of this phenomenon and is intentionally exploiting it to run damage control on American empire’s recent string of failures and further disenfranchisement of left-leaning people. and if they’re not true, then he’s an imperialist dumbass who’s doing incalculable damage to the left by not just shutting the gently caress up.

Oh I confused Evans and Elliot Higgens (who actually founded Bellingcat); I remember the angle involved people really liking Bellingcat because it was a "goon thing." Their politics seem about the same.

Panzeh
Nov 27, 2006

"..The high ground"

Omnicarus posted:

I'm in a similar boat on Dan. I'm convinced he didn't actually read modern accounts because he references some superb histories like Shattered Sword as too technical and then promptly uses sources that have been debunked for 40 years and accounts that are explicitly called out as physically impossible. It was extremely frustrating and I just turned it off after a bit.

Yeah, when you talk about naval battles in WW2, you kinda do need to get into technical details- it was a very technical kind of war, technology and the way it was used was really important and critical to answering some common questions about the battle of Midway in particular.

MizPiz
May 29, 2013

by Athanatos
Geez, if only there was some way to guarantee that people with Evans' foreign policy outlook could be delegitimized and shunned from leftist organizations and communities. The left really needs to make it customary for people's opinions to be scrutinized and for them to be promptly ostracized if they are found wanting.

THS
Sep 15, 2017

MizPiz posted:

Geez, if only there was some way to guarantee that people with Evans' foreign policy outlook could be delegitimized and shunned from leftist organizations and communities. The left really needs to make it customary for people's opinions to be scrutinized and for them to be promptly ostracized if they are found wanting.

perhaps some kind of Deletion Discourse

Xaris
Jul 25, 2006

Lucky there's a family guy
Lucky there's a man who positively can do
All the things that make us
Laugh and cry

V. Illych L. posted:

GGS tries to answer 'why europe' from a basically materialist/determinist perspective. it's deeply speculative and methodologically suspect, but it tells a good story. it's overrated insofar as it's been massively hyped over the years, but it's a very fine pop-sci book

yeah no disagreement there. i consider it more like MMT, not very good but something easy to grasp and can enlighten euro/whitesupremacy liberals. in 1997 that probably made more an impact, even in a pop-sci way, because even howard zinn and like was still largely shunned in favor of end-of-history euro-supremacy neoliberalism, than it does today where things are accepted writ-large and much more information is widely accessible than back in 97.

Percelus
Sep 9, 2012

My command, your wish is

chapo managed to get their reddit to hate them way faster than o and a which is impressive

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

PawParole
Nov 16, 2019

happy jersey day!

why are you thankful for new jersey

Only registered members can see post attachments!

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply