Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Femur
Jan 10, 2004
I REALLY NEED TO SHUT THE FUCK UP
All his starting problem were dumbledoors fault through.. He did have fmily, and lots of money they kept from him.
And the magical flinstone poo poo was genius

Femur has issued a correction as of 23:57 on Jan 5, 2022

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

LIVE AMMO COSPLAY
Feb 3, 2006

Lib and let die posted:

Why do they have to keep all the magic tucked away in a pocket dimension? Why don't the wizards solve scarcity or cancer they have loving MAGIC

It's a silly children's series. Or was for like two books, until you're suddenly expected to treat the name "Hogwarts" as a serious and dramatic thing.

LIVE AMMO COSPLAY
Feb 3, 2006

Book One - Be careful at your magic school or you might die in a whacky mishap and come back as a prank-playing ghost!

Book Five - Some people are actually happy to be slaves. Furthermore,

Good Soldier Svejk
Jul 5, 2010

double negative posted:

i have had a bit of success putting some of my harry potter-loving students onto stuff like hitchhiker's guide, then they ask me if there's a movie adaptation and i tell them no

I still think that movie is charming on its own terms even if some of the changes are very very stupid

mawarannahr
May 21, 2019
Probation
Can't post for 18 hours!

LIVE AMMO COSPLAY posted:

It's a silly children's series. Or was for like two books, until you're suddenly expected to treat the name "Hogwarts" as a serious and dramatic thing.

I never thought about it but its named after having warts on your hog. drat

i say swears online
Mar 4, 2005

Miss Lonelyhearts posted:

This is a pretty bad movie review that doesn't event attempt to confront half the critiques of this thread - https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/dont-look-up-movie-review-2021

lol this reviewer thinks the tech CEO is an amalgamation of elon musk and joe biden

babypolis
Nov 4, 2009

double negative posted:

i don't know exactly what makes it so appealing, but it seems like a big part of what harry potter fans love is being able to identify themselves with the school houses. i've experienced multiple full-grown adults being like "haha im such a hufflepuff" and then when someone acknowledges the reference, they make it clear it wasn't just a passing thought, they've done a 500 question self-assessment to confirm this

the whole houses thing is kinda brilliant from a marketing standpoint tbh. not a coincidence that that is the one aspect every other YA book stole wholesale

DR FRASIER KRANG
Feb 4, 2005

"Are you forgetting that just this afternoon I was punched in the face by a turtle now dead?

babypolis posted:

the whole houses thing is kinda brilliant from a marketing standpoint tbh. not a coincidence that that is the one aspect every other YA book stole wholesale

are there Hunger Games fans who identify as hailing from a specific impoverished district?

Lib and let die
Aug 26, 2004

I'm gonna have to go ahead and own up to the Divergent movies being some of my favorite lovely background noise TV movies

double negative
Jul 7, 2003


Good Soldier Svejk posted:

I still think that movie is charming on its own terms even if some of the changes are very very stupid

i'll take your word for it. haven't rewatched it since, though i do like martin freeman and i really wanted mos def to be a good ford prefect

babypolis posted:

the whole houses thing is kinda brilliant from a marketing standpoint tbh. not a coincidence that that is the one aspect every other YA book stole wholesale

yeah, i do kinda get it, especially from the standpoint of young adults who are generally trying out all kinda poo poo in order to define themselves. a world with clearly defined personality-based factions makes self-inserting feel easier and more fun, serves as a language for the fanbase, etc. that new game show (lol) is predicated entirely on that premise from the commercial i saw. it's a great expression of ip as identity

Trabisnikof
Dec 24, 2005

When you realize Harry Potter is just Monty Python fanfic (from the sketch “man turns into Scotsman” on the episode “you’re no fun anymore”) everything makes a lot more sense!

AnimeIsTrash
Jun 30, 2018

skooma512
Feb 8, 2012

You couldn't grok my race car, but you dug the roadside blur.
Read HP as a teen because my first GF was super into it and I liked it well enough. It's passe to me now though because I can't just dwell on it forever.

I think the main part of the appeal is that series is many character's entire adolescence, which is nice when you're growing up as the books are coming out, and again when the movies are coming out and the actors are growing up on screen.

mastershakeman posted:

Harry Potter thinks he's a special magic boy and totally ignores that he's one of, if not the , richest person in the world. A safe full of gold and a legendary magic artifact gifted to him his first days of being a wizard

He was trying a vanilla run and ignored all the DLC goodies in the vault.

LionArcher posted:

A character can have an arch. Should is debatable. And Harry does arc, many times in the books. Starts with no family, a need to have that connection, ends the series happy with a big family, and a love for enemy's that became friends, and so on. Sees the flaws of his parents and mentors, and tries to be better. Of course what ends up happening is he settles to being a cop to keep the status quo going that created the dark lord in the first place.

There could be a very interesting fan fiction piece that could be written that his youngest kids rebel against him (because he's a cop) by becoming an even worse dark wizard than Voldy, because they realize the muggles have killed the planet and wizards have been too busy being assholes to do anything to fix it, so why not be a selfish rear end in a top hat.

I like how the wizard economy is you either work for the government, run some weird rear end shop, or gently caress off to your family farm and just vibe out there doing whatever.

Lastgirl
Sep 7, 1997


Good Morning!
Sunday Morning!
libs like to nest egg from mental breaks i.e. reality

harry potter is a cottagecore cozy mental nestegg for shitlibs, without having to do mental gymnastics, thats for the other atrocities they're willing to excuse

indigi
Jul 20, 2004

how can we not talk about family
when family's all that we got?

Judakel posted:

i love everyone saying she has been a jewish ally just because she's a billionaire who didn't like a socialist and thought to disguise it as anything other than driven by material interest lmao

I don’t think she’s perceptive enough to realize that being anti-socialist is in her class interest, she’s just reflexively regurgitating the anticommunist sentiments drilled into her head as a child. if she was still a house mother on like £30,000/year as a part time secretary I doubt her opinion on that (or indeed any other substantial issue) would be any different

KomradeX
Oct 29, 2011

indigi posted:

I don’t think she’s perceptive enough to realize that being anti-socialist is in her class interest, she’s just reflexively regurgitating the anticommunist sentiments drilled into her head as a child. if she was still a house mother on like £30,000/year as a part time secretary I doubt her opinion on that (or indeed any other substantial issue) would be any different

The English are a sick people and England should be sunk into the sea. Except I'm pretty sure that would just create Pedophile Atlantis

Lib and let die
Aug 26, 2004

KomradeX posted:

The English are a sick people and England should be sunk into the sea. Except I'm pretty sure that would just create Pedophile Atlantis

England is Florida with funny accents

DoombatINC
Apr 20, 2003

Here's the thing, I'm a feminist.





Trabisnikof posted:

When you realize Harry Potter is just Monty Python fanfic (from the sketch “man turns into Scotsman” on the episode “you’re no fun anymore”) everything makes a lot more sense!

you can really see how the tennis playing blancmange eventually lead to the canon that wizards poo poo on the ground and ta-da it away, maybe they ta-da it to andromeda??

i say swears online
Mar 4, 2005

inserting a bag of holding into my colon

slicing up eyeballs
Oct 19, 2005

I got me two olives and a couple of limes


DR FRASIER KRANG posted:

are there Hunger Games fans who identify as hailing from a specific impoverished district?

Since those can all be traced back more or less to actual us regions you better fuckin believe it

vyelkin
Jan 2, 2011

Lib and let die posted:

Why do they have to keep all the magic tucked away in a pocket dimension? Why don't the wizards solve scarcity or cancer they have loving MAGIC

The system works for them so they dgaf. Like how Superman spends his time beating up criminals instead of solving climate change using space magic.

Trabisnikof
Dec 24, 2005

DoombatINC posted:

you can really see how the tennis playing blancmange eventually lead to the canon that wizards poo poo on the ground and ta-da it away, maybe they ta-da it to andromeda??

A man named Harold Potter saves the world and the death eaters are the men turned into scotsmen.


Also there’s the sketch that’s the inspiration for all the dumb magical candy like cockroach clusters

vyelkin
Jan 2, 2011
Harry Potter is a rich failson who defeats WIzard Hitler through the power of destiny and luck rather than by being good at anything at all and ends up working for the Wizard FBI.

DoombatINC
Apr 20, 2003

Here's the thing, I'm a feminist.





Trabisnikof posted:

A man named Harold Potter saves the world

this is Angus Podgorny erasure

Smythe
Oct 12, 2003

LionArcher posted:

I'm so frustrated by Harry Potter. Growing up, I was already a reader, (high fantasy got me into it) but I loved them. The last few were dropping as I was a late teen, and I devoured them.

stopped reading here

Zvahl
Oct 14, 2005

научный кот

Smythe posted:

stopped reading here

lol if you can read

Lady Militant
Apr 8, 2020

The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles.

Big Mad Drongo posted:

Yeah one of the unspoken problems with Harry Potter is it's so loving unimaginative. Most bottom-tier fantasy series had something resembling whimsy, just held back by generic plots and bad writing. Like in retrospect I should be banned from reading after enjoying the Myth Adventures books as a kid, but as wretched as they were at least it was about a crazy dimension-hopping trash wizard and his wise-cracking, green-scaled partner in crime. It was bad and stupid and probably all kinds of offensive, but it was vaguely interesting.

Harry Potter had bad writing, a generic plot AND all the magic was mainly used to recreate worse versions of real-world stuff. Modern day, no less.


same except i payed video games and the magic in them was way better than gay rear end harry potter magic.

Smythe
Oct 12, 2003
2 classic goon tropes:

- reading at an early age. genius level iq

- devouring descartes. always devouring, books are only to be devoured. you would think being such an epic reader would broaden ones vocabulary to choose another word for this act but oddly this is seldom the case

Smythe
Oct 12, 2003

Lady Militant posted:

same except i payed video games and the magic in them was way better than gay rear end harry potter magic.

agreed harry potter had fail magic so i never read the books after book #1 which was fail. very simple. try casting a corp por harry. bitch rear end noob.

Zvahl posted:

lol if you can read

this

Xaris
Jul 25, 2006

Lucky there's a family guy
Lucky there's a man who positively can do
All the things that make us
Laugh and cry
i wish someone would devour my dick and balls. like jaws devoured those dudes on a boat

AnimeIsTrash
Jun 30, 2018

Xaris posted:

i wish someone would devour my dick and balls. like jaws devoured those dudes on a boat

Smythe
Oct 12, 2003

Xaris posted:

i wish someone would devour my dick and balls. like jaws devoured those dudes on a boat

check please

indigi
Jul 20, 2004

how can we not talk about family
when family's all that we got?
if James Potter had a shotgun none of this would have happened

Mr Hootington
Jul 24, 2008

I'M HAVING A HOOT EATING CORNETTE THE LONG WAY

indigi posted:

if James Potter had a shotgun none of this would have happened

Wizards don't kill. Until one does then he is unstoppable

Wraith of J.O.I.
Jan 25, 2012


the wizards let ww1 & 2 & the holocaust & all the other bad poo poo happen (or did they cause it?), not to mention allowing scarcity & poverty & hunger to persist....... they can all rot imo

Horizon Burning
Oct 23, 2019
:discourse:

porfiria posted:

I may be off the mark here but I think Harry Potter effectively invented the "YA" genre. Of course there was "middle grade" fiction before that, things like Wizard of Earthsea and the Chronicles of Prydain, but they existed somewhere in a big ambiguity between children's literature and adult literature. They were reasonably serious.

harry potter was definitely one of the precursors but it's generally some combination of hunger games and twilight that're attributed to really codifying and creating the tropes and patterns of the YA genre as it exists today. harry potter began as a children's series that grew with the readers, becoming YA as a side effect. but if you crack open any best selling YA or YA-adjacent novel, you basically have the hunger games model. there are some newer releases in the genre that're definitely aping something closer to harry potter these days, however.

mastershakeman
Oct 28, 2008

by vyelkin

skooma512 posted:



He was trying a vanilla run and ignored all the DLC goodies in the vault.


Yeah except for the artifact invisibility cape that turned out to be one of the best things ever made

Some Guy TT
Aug 30, 2011

https://mobile.twitter.com/BeatlesEarth/status/1478745525008715778

Crusader
Apr 11, 2002

Mr Hootington posted:

Wizards don't kill. Until one does then he is unstoppable

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

double negative
Jul 7, 2003



dungeons & dracos

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply