Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
Freudian slippers
Jun 23, 2009
US Goon shocked and appalled to find that world is a dirty, unjust place

Deteriorata posted:

Another dawn is breaking and Kyiv, and it's still Ukrainian. :unsmith:

:ukraine:



Thank you. It's a joy to see these posts each morning :unsmith:

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

mrfart
May 26, 2004

Dear diary, today I
became a captain.



Fictional Russian soldiers:
You know our standing orders.
Out of commission, become a pillbox. Out of ammo, become a bunker. Out of time, become heroes.

Real ones: I'm gonna get lunch, you watch the tank.
No, YOU watch the tank.

(but I'm very happy they give up, and I don't know what happens to these guys when they get back to base sans tank. Court-martialed?)

Drone_Fragger
May 9, 2007


China isnt actuslly super happy about this - Ukraine was on their belt and road Initiative so they'd spent billions and billions on developing which Russia just bombed into worthlessness. Ans China holds a lot of russian debt which they've just defacto defaulted on.

dr_rat
Jun 4, 2001

gay picnic defence posted:

I think China probably helps Russia out and gives them enough support to keep going for a little longer. Not so much because they want the war to drag on but they really want to have strong influence over post war Russia so I think they'll attempt to walk the fine line of providing economic and military assistance to Russia without pissing off the US too much.

I'd be surprised if China sold Russia any weapons. As you say, seems like they want to tread a fine line. MRE's and medicine I can see, as those are both obviously incredibly easy to justify. There's also plenty of ways China can justify economic loans enough that you know they can still sort of tread that line, but as soon as you get into weapons, then there's no way to spin it that you haven't crossed a line. I mean China could just take that and shrug, but form their public statements they do seem to be being a bit more cautious about things, and they don't really like this war in the first place. Honestly going all in like that not sure what it would get them from russia that just given financial loans and the like wouldn't, as that gives them way more of a hook into russia.

Trump
Jul 16, 2003

Cute

gay picnic defence posted:


Over extending a counter offensive is a risk but even if it goes badly wrong it's probably limited to a single area of operations and wouldn't affect other parts of the conflict zone. From the information available it looks like there's lots of smaller scale counteroffensives rather than one big push against a localised Russian position so there's less risk to Ukraine's overall momentum if something goes wrong.

In terms of tactics, small counteroffensives are probably very effective at keeping Russian forces off balance, making it really hard to consolidate and replenish their troops in the field.

There's a difference between counter-offensives and counterattacks. One has strategic goals, the other tactical and are usually exploitative in nature.

Mystic Mongol
Jan 5, 2007

Your life's been thrown in disarray already--I wouldn't want you to feel pressured.


College Slice

mrfart posted:

(but I'm very happy they give up, and I don't know what happens to these guys when they get back to base sans tank. Court-martialed?)

They get shot in the woods by Russian special forces.

Lead out in cuffs
Sep 18, 2012

"That's right. We've evolved."

"I can see that. Cool mutations."




Blockhouse posted:

I know this is a stupid question because it's the question and has probably already been talked about at length in this thread but it's still all I can think about

What happens after this?

Because win or lose, the damage has been done. Putin's reputation as a shrewd and calculating strong man is in shambles. A major world power's army has spent the last three weeks in an embarrassing loving clown show invasion that has resorted to just throwing their hands up and war criming as they can to accomplish their goal. The Russian economy is likely going to be devastated for gently caress knows how long, And even if - and it's wild that this is even an "if" at this point - Russia takes Kyiv, pops Zelenskyy, does the "Mission Accomplished" song and dance there's still almost certainly going to be enough Ukrainian rebels to make life for an occupying force or puppet government a living Hell for decades to come.

Obviously Russia keeps the security that a nuclear deterrent gives you but uranium isn't going to feed a starving populace when most of the world treats your country like it's a leper colony. What is being accomplished? What's the endgame? Why is this still loving going on?

On the flipside from Russia, if Ukraine survives, they have already begun the EU accession process. That takes a few years, but ultimately means cheaper trade with Europe, freedom of movement for all the refugees currently fleeing, and being part of a putative European defensive alliance (the EU has troops, sorta).

There's also likely to be a lot of aid sent to Ukraine for rebuilding.

If Ukraine loses, then they're stuck behind the new iron curtain.

cant cook creole bream
Aug 15, 2011
I think Fahrenheit is better for weather

Mystic Mongol posted:

They get shot in the woods by Russian special forces.

In a weird twists those are the only ones who are competent at their job.

mobby_6kl
Aug 9, 2009

by Fluffdaddy
https://mobile.twitter.com/MarshaBlackburn/status/1503874700430258182

So it's not an invasion, just mass emigration of soldiers trying to get out of Russia, which is understandable

cinci zoo sniper
Mar 15, 2013




Blockhouse posted:

I know this is a stupid question because it's the question and has probably already been talked about at length in this thread but it's still all I can think about

What happens after this?

No one knows how or when this will end. Your question can only have speculative answers.

Brown Moses
Feb 22, 2002

Images from this morning of Kherson airbase with additional damage visible:
https://twitter.com/bellingcat/status/1504010066307002370

ganonso
Aug 1, 2011
So the mighty Republicans fear the renowned martial prowess of Mexico? Did Trump sell all your material or what?


Seriously while I see Ukraine being used as a political argument for nations with disputed territories (even if Erdogan and the Saudi crown prince seem to indicate warmongering has taken a dip at least for those who are not in danger of immediate famine) seeing it emerge in the U.S is strange. Are the Republican talks about Mexican invasion intended to be literal rather than refering to migrants?

cinci zoo sniper
Mar 15, 2013





I hope this is just a ham-fisted attempt to be funny.

cinci zoo sniper
Mar 15, 2013




Morning updates from Ukraine:

https://twitter.com/iaponomarenko/status/1504004337806323717

https://twitter.com/stratcomcentre/status/1503963957996011521

https://twitter.com/defencehq/status/1503982627522494465

https://twitter.com/reuters/status/1503987700185059329

https://twitter.com/christopherjm/status/1504014634600255490

https://twitter.com/stratcomcentre/status/1504018120209571841

Herstory Begins Now
Aug 5, 2003
SOME REALLY TEDIOUS DUMB SHIT THAT SUCKS ASS TO READ ->>

cinci zoo sniper posted:

I hope this is just a ham-fisted attempt to be funny.

That's what it looks like to me, yeah.

fatherboxx
Mar 25, 2013

https://twitter.com/BrianLaslie/status/1503874079836852226?t=53r6kXEed7wLsqdwyLx9dw&s=19

Privateering coming back for 21st century

gay picnic defence
Oct 5, 2009


I'M CONCERNED ABOUT A NUMBER OF THINGS

Shooting down a couple of Su-34s is a pretty massive blow. You never hear it reported but I wonder how many make it back with battle damage that keeps them out of action for some time.

It looks like in response Ukraine is carefully picking and choosing targets for it's own air force.

Inferior Third Season
Jan 15, 2005

gay picnic defence posted:

Shooting down a couple of Su-34s is a pretty massive blow. You never hear it reported but I wonder how many make it back with battle damage that keeps them out of action for some time.
Probably almost none. Either you get hit with a missile and explode, or you don't.

Vincent Van Goatse
Nov 8, 2006

Enjoy every sandwich.

Smellrose

How the gently caress would these even work? Assuming this somehow happened ( :lol: ), would anyone outside the US take these seriously?

I guess I'm asking just exactly how stupid this idea is beyond the obvious fact that the Russians would just declare it an act of war on America's part.

Vincent Van Goatse fucked around with this message at 10:15 on Mar 16, 2022

KitConstantine
Jan 11, 2013

Trump posted:

There's a difference between counter-offensives and counterattacks. One has strategic goals, the other tactical and are usually exploitative in nature.

Counter offensive confirmed it sounds like
https://twitter.com/Podolyak_M/status/1504001010787921924?t=skhZNHfabZMbDdS8aImbXA&s=19
AFU =armed forces of Ukraine
Guy posting is an advisor to Zelensky

Comstar
Apr 20, 2007

Are you happy now?
Why are the Russians only using 1-2 planes per strike? I thought all normal tactics would be to hit one small area with a lot of planes, insteadf of spreading them over the entire front.

cinci zoo sniper
Mar 15, 2013




https://www.lsm.lv/raksts/zinas/arzemes/bijusais-deputats-jurass-no-ukrainas-bataljona-sarezgitakais-ir-redzet-blakus-navi.a448063/

On the topic of what do foreign fighters do - recently resigned chairman of Latvian parliament's judiciary committee is deployed to Kyiv outskirts' hotspots, e.g., Irpin, Brovary. He doesn't make it clear though if they're fighting there, or doing non-fighting duties for the army, and if he's in a foreigner battalion, or embedded with the locals.

gay picnic defence posted:

Shooting down a couple of Su-34s is a pretty massive blow. You never hear it reported but I wonder how many make it back with battle damage that keeps them out of action for some time.

It looks like in response Ukraine is carefully picking and choosing targets for it's own air force.

I'd be cautious about Su-34 shootdowns. Ukrainian air-defence reporting is significantly ahead footage of verified wreckages. If true, it's a collossal fuckup, since Su-34 are effectively irreplaceable for Russia, and they don't have a lot of these modern fighters.

Edit:

https://twitter.com/PiotrMuller/status/1504023057903534080

cinci zoo sniper fucked around with this message at 10:25 on Mar 16, 2022

Hammerstein
May 6, 2005

YOU DON'T KNOW A DAMN THING ABOUT RACING !

Lead out in cuffs posted:

On the flipside from Russia, if Ukraine survives, they have already begun the EU accession process. That takes a few years, but ultimately means cheaper trade with Europe, freedom of movement for all the refugees currently fleeing, and being part of a putative European defensive alliance (the EU has troops, sorta).

It's extremely unlikely that Ukraine will meet the criteria to join the EU within the next decade. The country is a mess when it comes to democracy, independent press, economy and the legal system, the Ukraine ranks lower in these fields than most West Balkan countries. It will be a very long process until the corruption and the grip of the oligarchs are down to acceptable levels.

KitConstantine
Jan 11, 2013

Lavrov noticeably ratcheting back the belligerence
https://twitter.com/maxseddon/status/1504017549222379522?t=trQqefgnsiarKQ5owMxKGQ&s=19
There's a lot of reporting on Lavrov's words right now, but i havent seen a video yet. As for an agreement -I'll believe it when I see it.

KillHour
Oct 28, 2007


Hammerstein posted:

It's extremely unlikely that Ukraine will meet the criteria to join the EU within the next decade. The country is a mess when it comes to democracy, independent press, economy and the legal system, the Ukraine ranks lower in these fields than most West Balkan countries. It will be a very long process until the corruption and the grip of the oligarchs are down to acceptable levels.

Existential crises have a way of causing rapid change to happen.

gay picnic defence
Oct 5, 2009


I'M CONCERNED ABOUT A NUMBER OF THINGS

Comstar posted:

Why are the Russians only using 1-2 planes per strike? I thought all normal tactics would be to hit one small area with a lot of planes, insteadf of spreading them over the entire front.

They don't train for anything else basically. The US/NATO train for massive combined operations that saturate defenses and rapidly achieve air superiority, whereas Russia's training standards are far lower and the only recent practical experience they've had is bombing rebels in Syria without needing to worry too much about getting shot down (assuming they stay away from Turkey).

cinci zoo sniper posted:


I'd be cautious about Su-34 shootdowns. Ukrainian air-defence reporting is significantly ahead footage of verified wreckages. If true, it's a collossal fuckup, since Su-34 are effectively irreplaceable for Russia, and they don't have a lot of these modern fighters.



For sure. There's probably a number of cases where a plane definitely got shot down but two different missile crews claim it so two shoot-downs are recorded.

mobby_6kl
Aug 9, 2009

by Fluffdaddy
Didn't we have ~10 planes taking off reported yesterday? Even if a couple got shot down it's good news. But also planes can definitely make it back to base with massive damage e.g.



KitConstantine posted:

Lavrov noticeably ratcheting back the belligerence
https://twitter.com/maxseddon/status/1504017549222379522?t=trQqefgnsiarKQ5owMxKGQ&s=19
There's a lot of reporting on Lavrov's words right now, but i havent seen a video yet. As for an agreement -I'll believe it when I see it.

"Security guaranttee for Russia" jfc but yeah whatever it takes to get them to gently caress off.

Kchama
Jul 25, 2007

a pipe smoking dog posted:

I check this thread because I think it's a good source of information, but then I read through it and find an entire page of goons arguing that you won't get wet from being in a boat...

I'm a bit worried about this talk of a counter-offensive. The Russians are obviously struggling but a failed counter attack by over confident Ukrainian forces send exactly the sort of thing that could swing the war back in Russia's favour. It might speak to Ukraine's desperation as much as anything else.

If you read it, you would have found that the page of goons was arguing against "you won't get wet from being in a boat", so you can rest easy.

alex314
Nov 22, 2007

mmkay posted:

Please no, it's already rapidly approaching Hungary and doesn't appear to be stopping. The war appears to shut up at least some of the rabid anti-EU elements, but who knows if it will last (probably not for long, since there're already voices about EU needing to drop fines on Poland for anti-democracy stuff in the name of unity).

Recent polls show majority of people in Poland would like those dumb disagreements to be over, so there's a strong chance PiS will rein in Ziobro. Hopefully for good, the amount of damage that dude did is incredible. Probably only Macierewicz was more destructive.
And for those fines: if I were working in government I'd simply ask for them to be paid, but straight to the refugee help funds. Everyone would be happy.

mobby_6kl
Aug 9, 2009

by Fluffdaddy

alex314 posted:

Recent polls show majority of people in Poland would like those dumb disagreements to be over, so there's a strong chance PiS will rein in Ziobro. Hopefully for good, the amount of damage that dude did is incredible. Probably only Macierewicz was more destructive.
And for those fines: if I were working in government I'd simply ask for them to be paid, but straight to the refugee help funds. Everyone would be happy.

What about Turów? That getting shut down? :)

a podcast for cats
Jun 22, 2005

Dogs reading from an artifact buried in the ruins of our civilization, "We were assholes- " and writing solemnly, "They were assholes."
Soiled Meat

cinci zoo sniper posted:

https://www.lsm.lv/raksts/zinas/arzemes/bijusais-deputats-jurass-no-ukrainas-bataljona-sarezgitakais-ir-redzet-blakus-navi.a448063/

On the topic of what do foreign fighters do - recently resigned chairman of Latvian parliament's judiciary committee is deployed to Kyiv outskirts' hotspots, e.g., Irpin, Brovary. He doesn't make it clear though if they're fighting there, or doing non-fighting duties for the army, and if he's in a foreigner battalion, or embedded with the locals.

He should get a bit of credit for doing a decent thing on his last day. Namely, he voted for moving a proposed law to legally recognise civil unions (which are understood to include same sex unions) to the Latvian parliament for a first round of parliamentary voting. The parliament will now vote for the recognition of civil unions on the 24th of March. I'm not familiar with his exact political stance before, but he does represent a conservative party and the motion only won by 1 vote, with 5 for and 4 against.

As a matter of fact, the vote may have been submitted while he was physically in Ukraine or en route.

alex314
Nov 22, 2007

mobby_6kl posted:

What about Turów? That getting shut down? :)

I'm not even trying to understand that mess.

Mokotow
Apr 16, 2012

mobby_6kl posted:

What about Turów? That getting shut down? :)

They reached an agreement with the Czechs, but are supper unhappy because the EU is still expecting the pre-agreement fines to be paid.

CSM
Jan 29, 2014

56th Motorized Infantry 'Mariupol' Brigade
Seh' die Welt in Trummern liegen

Blockhouse posted:

I know this is a stupid question because it's the question and has probably already been talked about at length in this thread but it's still all I can think about

What happens after this?

Because win or lose, the damage has been done. Putin's reputation as a shrewd and calculating strong man is in shambles. A major world power's army has spent the last three weeks in an embarrassing loving clown show invasion that has resorted to just throwing their hands up and war criming as they can to accomplish their goal. The Russian economy is likely going to be devastated for gently caress knows how long, And even if - and it's wild that this is even an "if" at this point - Russia takes Kyiv, pops Zelenskyy, does the "Mission Accomplished" song and dance there's still almost certainly going to be enough Ukrainian rebels to make life for an occupying force or puppet government a living Hell for decades to come.

Obviously Russia keeps the security that a nuclear deterrent gives you but uranium isn't going to feed a starving populace when most of the world treats your country like it's a leper colony. What is being accomplished? What's the endgame? Why is this still loving going on?
I wonder whether Russia is still planning to actually enter Kyiv (or other large cities), or will try to permanently occupy large swaths of the country (except for Crimea and Donbass). It seems it would be a wise plan to avoid both those things.

The endgame is now probably a settlement with concessions about at least Crimea and Donbass from Ukraine (and maybe some more territories depending on how the war proceeds) and forcing Ukraine to stay out of the EU. And then hoping everyone forgets about the whole thing, and western sanctions just slowly fade away.

cinci zoo sniper
Mar 15, 2013




a podcast for cats posted:

He should get a bit of credit for doing a decent thing on his last day. Namely, he voted for moving a proposed law to legally recognise civil unions (which are understood to include same sex unions) to the Latvian parliament for a first round of parliamentary voting. The parliament will now vote for the recognition of civil unions on the 24th of March. I'm not familiar with his exact political stance before, but he does represent a conservative party and the motion only won by 1 vote, with 5 for and 4 against.

As a matter of fact, the vote may have been submitted while he was physically in Ukraine or en route.

My man, that’s a plan if I’ve ever seen one. Vote for gay marriage, die fighting for Ukrainian freedom to avoid hearing NA opinions.

More seriously though, credit is definitely due, despite his past.

Dapper_Swindler
Feb 14, 2012

Im glad my instant dislike in you has been validated again and again.

CSM posted:

I wonder whether Russia is still planning to actually enter Kyiv (or other large cities), or will try to permanently occupy large swaths of the country (except for Crimea and Donbass). It seems it would be a wise plan to avoid both those things.

The endgame is now probably a settlement with concessions about at least Crimea and Donbass from Ukraine (and maybe some more territories depending on how the war proceeds) and forcing Ukraine to stay out of the EU. And then hoping everyone forgets about the whole thing, and western sanctions just slowly fade away.

I doubt sanctions are fading away at this point and I doubt zelenksy will except No Eu and troops outside the break aways.

Deteriorata
Feb 6, 2005

WAR CRIME GIGOLO posted:

Deteriorata forgive me if you've said this but are you actually in Kyiv

No, I'm in Chattanooga, TN. The webcams are in Kyiv. :)

CSM
Jan 29, 2014

56th Motorized Infantry 'Mariupol' Brigade
Seh' die Welt in Trummern liegen

Dapper_Swindler posted:

I doubt sanctions are fading away at this point and I doubt zelenksy will except No Eu and troops outside the break aways.
It depends on how the war will proceed. It's still an enormously uphill battle for Ukraine, and they will have to retain the current stalemate in some form and keep Kyiv from being surrounded. Failing that, Zelensky will have to choose between how many concessions he refuses, and how much of Kyiv he wants razed to the ground.

Small Strange Bird
Sep 22, 2006

Merci, chaton!

Blockhouse posted:

I know this is a stupid question because it's the question and has probably already been talked about at length in this thread but it's still all I can think about

What happens after this?

Because win or lose, the damage has been done. Putin's reputation as a shrewd and calculating strong man is in shambles. A major world power's army has spent the last three weeks in an embarrassing loving clown show invasion that has resorted to just throwing their hands up and war criming as they can to accomplish their goal. The Russian economy is likely going to be devastated for gently caress knows how long, And even if - and it's wild that this is even an "if" at this point - Russia takes Kyiv, pops Zelenskyy, does the "Mission Accomplished" song and dance there's still almost certainly going to be enough Ukrainian rebels to make life for an occupying force or puppet government a living Hell for decades to come.

Obviously Russia keeps the security that a nuclear deterrent gives you but uranium isn't going to feed a starving populace when most of the world treats your country like it's a leper colony. What is being accomplished? What's the endgame? Why is this still loving going on?
Putin's entire motivation for this seems barely comprehensible from a western point of view. He's the undisputed biggest fish of a nuclear-armed power, who could do pretty much anything he wanted without consequences within Russia and even beyond (see Salisbury), he's gained his country an enormous amount of soft power and money-hosed his assets and useful idiots into positions of importance in the west (Trump, Carlson, Nigel Farage and lots of Tories and right-Labour figures in the UK), acquired enormous personal wealth through running Russia like a mafia boss and taking a direct or indirect cut from any companies that want to operate in an expanding market, had the countries of Europe terrified of upsetting the bear for fear of economic retribution or having their gas cut off... and has just pissed all of that away, likely for decades to come, because he apparently still sees the world from a Cold War mindset of "everything Soviet is still Russia's, and NATO must be kept from our borders!"

Now he's united the EU, strengthened NATO, strengthened the case for NATO, wrecked his economy, encouraged countries like Germany to find ways to wean themselves off Russian energy as quickly as possible, got all his oligarch cronies sanctioned, made the west look seriously at anyone who's received Russian money, turned Russia into a pariah and exposed its armed forces as weak and incompetent (as well as getting a lot of people killed). And for what, even if he actually takes Ukraine? Some extra oil and gas fields in the Black Sea and a buffer state against an imagined Clancy-style NATO invasion?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Just Another Lurker
May 1, 2009

Deteriorata posted:

No, I'm in Chattanooga, TN. The webcams are in Kyiv. :)

And yet we look forward to your morning affirmation of a free Kyiv. :tipshat:

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5