|
Leon Trotsky 2012 posted:The quote in the post you quoted literally says she wants them to stop being a cult. I'd appreciate if you could read and respond to the rest of my post, or at least the sentence immediately following the one you selectively quoted. The problem is that she also said that the country needs a strong Republican party. She could have just not said that.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 19:34 |
|
|
# ? May 27, 2024 03:08 |
|
Congressional Republicans are threatening to let the Bush PEPFAR program, that delivers anti-HIV medication and education to Africa, expire because the Biden administration changed a rule that prevented money from going to organizations that also advise patients about or perform abortions. None of the PEPFAR money actually goes to abortions, but they are upset that health clinics that advise patients on abortions or perform abortions could receive money to distribute HIV treatment drugs to their patients and therefore the money is indirectly supporting abortion in Africa. Several major pro-life groups are also now saying they will count a vote in favor of PEPFAR reauthorization as a "pro-choice/pro-abortion" vote on their pro-life scorecard for this year as well. The Politico article is also an amazing example of both sides-ism and passive voice. "Republicans claim that the money will be used to fund abortions, a charge the Biden administration, the program’s leaders and outside experts say is not true." https://twitter.com/politico/status/1699060797631312092 quote:Congress is almost certain to blow past a Sept. 30 deadline to re-up the law governing the United States’ global HIV/AIDS relief work as the widely praised program becomes mired in the fight over abortion.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 19:43 |
|
Leon Trotsky 2012 posted:- If they can't pick Trump, then Ron DeSantis is the significant favorite second choice of Republican voters with 35%. Sounds like DeSantis has this in the bag just as soon as a pre-impeachment ruling comes down from the Senate. Any day now.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 19:48 |
|
Leon Trotsky 2012 posted:Congressional Republicans are threatening to let the Bush PEPFAR program, that delivers anti-HIV medication and education to Africa, expire because the Biden administration changed a rule that prevented money from going to organizations that also advise patients about or perform abortions. it's my understanding that pepfar is one of the few things we do that actually builds good will for us in africa, seems like this would be a pretty major blow to our foreign policy efforts on the continent for some culture war signaling the average gop voter won't even hear about
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 19:52 |
|
GhostofJohnMuir posted:it's my understanding that pepfar is one of the few things we do that actually builds good will for us in africa, seems like this would be a pretty major blow to our foreign policy efforts on the continent for some culture war signaling the average gop voter won't even hear about Part of Trump's appeal to his voters is that he wants to discontinue US support for the rest of the world. This 100% plays into that - that money could be going to good GOP causes like school vouchers and tax breaks for billionaires.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 19:58 |
|
GhostofJohnMuir posted:it's my understanding that pepfar is one of the few things we do that actually builds good will for us in africa, seems like this would be a pretty major blow to our foreign policy efforts on the continent for some culture war signaling the average gop voter won't even hear about Everything Republicans do makes America weaker. This is very on brand for the "America First" party that always puts Americans last.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:11 |
|
it's also one of the few decent things the second bush did in between his litany of horrors, so seems on brand for the modern gop to feel fine with getting rid of it
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:14 |
|
Skex posted:Everything Republicans do makes America weaker. This is very on brand for the "America First" party that always puts Americans last. I gotta be real when I hear that America is losing influence or power, I immediately pivot to hoping that this makes life easier for a working person somewhere. If I lived in the global south getting the US out of my business would pretty much always be a plus. It sucks that they’re doing this to aid programs, no doubt, but the idea that these programs build American power is a sick byproduct that leans on the idea that they give us power because we could take them away, or carefully control what groups benefit from them and who we withhold them from.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:14 |
|
GhostofJohnMuir posted:it's my understanding that pepfar is one of the few things we do that actually builds good will for us in africa, seems like this would be a pretty major blow to our foreign policy efforts on the continent for some culture war signaling the average gop voter won't even hear about I have it on good authority that those are all shithole countries anyway Seriously, though, I'm not all that surprised that the Mexico City policy is next on the "poo poo or get off the pot" list. Both sides are tired of it being reversed every 4-8 years and one side is seizing the initiative to nail it permanently to their preferred option
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:15 |
|
selec posted:I gotta be real when I hear that America is losing influence or power, I immediately pivot to hoping that this makes life easier for a working person somewhere. Things will surely improve when our benevolent CCP and/or Wagner friends arrive.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:16 |
|
The controversial Superintendent of Oklahoma State Schools (who even has other Republicans opposing some of his measures) has announced that public schools in Oklahoma will be partnering with PragerU kids to provide "pro-American" content for schools in Oklahoma. PragerU kids famously features a lesson where Fredrick Douglas explains why the Black Lives Matter movement is wrong, accuses the North of seeking war instead of negotiating to prevent the civil war, and explains why confederate generals weren't racist. Superintendent Ryan Walters is also currently attempting to form the first public Christian school in Oklahoma and the case is already going to the Supreme Court before the school even begins accepting students. https://twitter.com/RyanWaltersSupt/status/1699090720831783324
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:18 |
|
GhostofJohnMuir posted:it's my understanding that pepfar is one of the few things we do that actually builds good will for us in africa, seems like this would be a pretty major blow to our foreign policy efforts on the continent for some culture war signaling the average gop voter won't even hear about It’s a perennial issue that voters, most of them low info, vastly overestimate the portion of the federal budget on foreign aid. And so it is regularly a campaign talking point for conservatives to cut foreign aid, because it’s red meat for the base and because in reality it’s not hard to gum up the pittance in funding we allot for that and chalk up a “win” for the base. Saying they did something big when really it was just petty. https://www.fic.nih.gov/News/Global...nt%20or%20less. quote:U.S. funding for global health has hovered at around $10 billion since Fiscal Year 2010. An additional $3.7 billion was allocated in FY 2015 for the Ebola response. They actually will hear about it if only because demagogues never stop messaging on it.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:24 |
|
Quixzlizx posted:Things will surely improve when our benevolent CCP and/or Wagner friends arrive. I mean, there’s a (maybe apocryphal) quote from a Kenyan politician that goes something like “when the British come here we get lectures, when the Chinese come here we get hospitals” so the Anglosphere could definitely take some pointers on how to properly do some imperialism in this millennium. Cuba’s soft power via doctors is another great example of supposedly oppressive states outclassing the The Land of the Free when it comes to outreach. We are way too gun-and-debt forward, probably feels like an MLM sale when you meet with our diplomats.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:25 |
|
Fister Roboto posted:She could have just said she wants the GOP to stop being a cult then. Saying that the US needs a strong Republican party is unnecessary, because it's a completely independent idea from them not being a cult. You're missing a key piece of context: in a democratic country, it's generally a bad thing for the leader of the legislature to imply or say that the opposition parties should be ineffectually weak or cease to exist altogether. Not only is it bad for the health of the democratic system as a whole, but it also tends to be harmful for their party's electoral chances in areas where the voters hold some level of respect for the opposition parties. As such, there are various political reasons why a party leader might insincerely say nice things about the political opposition, even as they work hard to defeat that party. This is especially true given the particular dynamics of the American political system, a two-party system in which it is very rare for a party to be completely destroyed and replaced.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:33 |
|
Main Paineframe posted:Not a chance in hell. Even if such a rule existed, inventing a technicality to disqualify the guy who is by far the most popular choice for the nomination would be political suicide (and possibly also actual suicide, given how militant his diehard base is). They should just go to the classics such as Shakespeare and see what the O.G. republicans did to Caesar.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 20:54 |
|
Main Paineframe posted:You're missing a key piece of context: in a democratic country, it's generally a bad thing for the leader of the legislature to imply or say that the opposition parties should be ineffectually weak or cease to exist altogether. Not only is it bad for the health of the democratic system as a whole, but it also tends to be harmful for their party's electoral chances in areas where the voters hold some level of respect for the opposition parties. There are a lot of things wrong with this. First of all, I didn't say that she needed to say that the GOP should be weak or cease to exist. I said that she shouldn't have said that the country needs a strong GOP. Sometimes not saying something is the best course of action. Second, you're conflating the general and specific cases. Yes, it would be bad for a politician to say that all opposition parties in general should be weak or cease to exist. No, it's not bad to say that the GOP specifically should be weak or cease to exist. Because the GOP are fascists. Fascists should be weak or not exist. Third, there are plenty of other opposition parties out there other than the Democrats and GOP. And they've all been made ineffectually weak or nonexistent by the two big parties. Is that not unhealthy for democracy? Finally, yes, I know there are political reasons why she would say this. That doesn't mean it's not valid to criticize her for it.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 21:00 |
|
U.S. demand for the new blockbuster weight loss drug WeGovy is so high that the Danish company that produces it (Novo Nordisk) has taken in so many U.S. dollars that it has become the most valuable company in all of Europe and the Danish government is having to intervene to stabilize the price of the Danish Kroner due to all the foreign currency coming in to the country. The company is now worth nearly half a trillion dollars. https://twitter.com/cnni/status/1699150476757930388 https://twitter.com/crampell/status/1692360992506761374 quote:Novo Nordisk has dethroned Bernard Arnault’s luxury goods giant LVMH as Europe’s most valuable company.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 21:09 |
|
selec posted:I mean, there’s a (maybe apocryphal) quote from a Kenyan politician that goes something like “when the British come here we get lectures, when the Chinese come here we get hospitals” so the Anglosphere could definitely take some pointers on how to properly do some imperialism in this millennium. Cuba’s soft power via doctors is another great example of supposedly oppressive states outclassing the The Land of the Free when it comes to outreach. The CCP also wants to flat out own as much of the infrastructure and farmland of a client country as possible, which doesn't strike me as particularly benevolent.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 21:11 |
|
selec posted:I mean, there’s a (maybe apocryphal) quote from a Kenyan politician that goes something like “when the British come here we get lectures, when the Chinese come here we get hospitals” so the Anglosphere could definitely take some pointers on how to properly do some imperialism in this millennium. Cuba’s soft power via doctors is another great example of supposedly oppressive states outclassing the The Land of the Free when it comes to outreach. Quixzlizx posted:The CCP also wants to flat out own as much of the infrastructure and farmland of a client country as possible, which doesn't strike me as particularly benevolent. This. If you believe the US is predatory when it comes to foreign lending, do some reading on China. China’s loans pushing world’s poorest countries to brink of collapse AP News posted:A dozen poor countries are facing economic instability and even collapse under the weight of hundreds of billions of dollars in foreign loans, much of them from the world’s biggest and most unforgiving government lender, China. More details in the full article, but the whole thing is worth a read. Something not mentioned in the article is that unlike loans from other sources, when China finances major infrastructure projects in other countries, they often bring in their own engineering and construction firms to design and build it. Instead of building the local economy with jobs, which is far more beneficial, they effectively claw most of the money back. The recipient country winds up saddled with a lot of debt, and a dam or port, but no lasting economic improvement.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 21:35 |
|
This is the apparent source for that quote. Why are we doing this. Why do we have to engage with "maybe apocryphal" unattributed quotes from random-rear end italian twitter accounts mainlining Chinese and Russian propaganda outlets. In the US Current Events thread.
Discendo Vox fucked around with this message at 22:02 on Sep 5, 2023 |
# ? Sep 5, 2023 21:47 |
|
selec posted:I gotta be real when I hear that America is losing influence or power, I immediately pivot to hoping that this makes life easier for a working person somewhere. If you think any country delivers foreign aid without discrimination or without its own interests in mind you're truly naive. Democratic countries in particular are beholden to the electorate but all countries have limited resources that they want to use effectively to further some particular national goals. What is the true and correct model for foreign aid in your opinion? Which country is building a global workers paradise again? It feels pretty keyboard warrior to say that if you were dirt poor you'd prefer nothing to US aid. I very much doubt that sick poor people getting medicine from us would rather the us stay out of their business and let them die of aids in peace. Of all the ways to attack the us I don't feel that foreign aid is the best angle.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 22:05 |
|
Michigan passing safe storage law for firearms is awesome. It’s s great practical gun control measure that is proven to help.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 22:22 |
|
Quixzlizx posted:The CCP also wants to flat out own as much of the infrastructure and farmland of a client country as possible, which doesn't strike me as particularly benevolent. Isn't that what we do, and why the term "banana republic" even exists? Hell, we straight-up annexed Hawaii.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 22:31 |
|
Byzantine posted:Isn't that what we do, and why the term "banana republic" even exists? Hell, we straight-up annexed Hawaii. So CCP imperialism has evolved all the way to Victorian age Western imperialism, and that's supposed to be some sort of own?
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 22:40 |
|
Quixzlizx posted:So CCP imperialism has evolved all the way to Victorian age Western imperialism, and that's supposed to be some sort of own? We couped Bolivia four years ago to get at them sweet sweet resources. It's not an own, it's a quit pretending we're The Good Guys, not like those dastardly Orientals who try to control resources.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 22:49 |
|
Fister Roboto posted:There are a lot of things wrong with this. First, as I said, there are various political reasons why a party leader might insincerely say nice things about the political opposition, even as they work hard to defeat that party. Especially when that party is absolutely not going anywhere, period. Second, the GOP specifically is not an inherently fascist party any more than any other right-wing party would be. Dismantling the GOP and replacing them with the Libertarian Party wouldn't be any less fascist, because all the far-right people voting for fascists are just going to migrate to the new right-wing party. Third, the two-party system was not created by the two parties themselves. While they certainly haven't played along with any theoretical ways to potentially reduce the absolute dominance of the two parties, it's quite an exaggeration to say it's their fault that third parties have few electoral prospects in the American system. Finally, Nancy's statement there is an obvious lie told for very obvious and very practical political reasons. Trying to make it into an actual issue, especially an entire year later, just looks like fairly transparent grudge-holding. There's enough actual things to get mad about in American politics that we don't need to waste our time combing through TV appearances for out-of-context sentences that we can use to lay the groundwork for conspiracy theories. And yes, I think the implication that the entire Democratic Party nationwide are going to happily and willingly give up their own seats to the Republicans qualifies as conspiracy theory.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 22:55 |
|
Quixzlizx posted:So CCP imperialism has evolved all the way to Victorian age Western imperialism, and that's supposed to be some sort of own? Is the implication here that the west is no longer imperialist? Because the way I see it, we’re better at imperialism than we’ve ever been. We have managed to move on from military conquest and forcing addictive substances on a country at gunpoint to doing those things via proxies and covert action. We’re not “better” but we certainly are better at accomplishing the same goals with much less obviously horrifying methods. Have you read The Jakarta Method? We have been innovating in this space a long time and you can’t be mad that China saw a lot of the west’s actions and decided to iterate on our methods in a way that fit their goals. I agree imperialism sucks, but if it’s a foregone conclusion (which statements like “if it’s not us it’ll be the CCP” seem to nod towards) then I’m not opposed to giving someone else the controller for a while. We’ve had it way past any reasonable window unless you have a religious or some other mystical belief that The West Deserves Our Place.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 23:05 |
|
Byzantine posted:We couped Bolivia four years ago to get at them sweet sweet resources. It's not an own, it's a quit pretending we're The Good Guys, not like those dastardly Orientals who try to control resources. This is a weird and reductionist take on Bolivia, especially considering we sat on our hands / vaguely supported the fall of the coup government. Countries can sometimes have a little bit of their own agency. Yes, even in South America. see also the interesting examples of Honduras (US government literally divided on it, some dod officials probably should have gotten canned) and Brazil (FBI helps lawfare Lula in the most indirect way possible, then when Bolsonaro loses election to him just recently the Biden admin tells Bolso to sit down and shut up)
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 23:05 |
|
Byzantine posted:We couped Bolivia four years ago to get at them sweet sweet resources. It's not an own, it's a quit pretending we're The Good Guys, not like those dastardly Orientals who try to control resources. Putting aside whatever you're saying about Bolivia, which I'm not going to take your word on since anything that ever goes wrong in LA is a CIA plot according to a certain crowd, I never said that the US are the good guys, I was responding to someone who said that it would be great if the US stopped sending HIV medication to Africa because any American involvement anywhere is BAD, which is: 1. Reductive to a lazy degree. That kind of lazy analysis/worldview is what causes portions of the "anti-imperialist left" to become Z cheerleaders, supporting the definitely opposite of imperialist special military operation. 2. My OP pointed out that the US withdrawing its presence from a country would lead to the reaction of another imperialist nation increasing its influence, rather than resulting in some sort of utopia free from outside influence.
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 23:15 |
|
The idea that western institutions don't set conditions on loans is also inaccurate. From an article on Zambia and Chinese funding:https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/09/07/zambia-china-debt-imf-economy/ posted:Accusations of debt-trap diplomacy often fail to take into account African leaders’ choices as well as the unfavorable terms offered by Paris Club lenders. As the Guardian tells it, between 2002 and 2008 the value of Zambia’s mineral exports grew 500 percent, from $670 million to $4 billion, but it did not boost its tax revenue because Western and Indian commodity giants operating there were exempted from taxation on the recommendation of the IMF. (Zambia is Africa’s second-largest copper producer.)
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 23:16 |
|
Main Paineframe posted:
Could you please not put words in my mouth? None of this is anything that I have ever argued. Where are you getting this implication from?
|
# ? Sep 5, 2023 23:47 |
|
Leon Trotsky 2012 posted:Not incredibly surprising, but roughly 7 in 10 Republicans said that Trump being convicted would have no impact on their support for him and only 13% said it would cause them to no longer support him. The most recent polls on a Trump v Biden 2 election are also disturbingly close
|
# ? Sep 6, 2023 00:43 |
|
celadon posted:The idea that western institutions don't set conditions on loans is also inaccurate. From an article on Zambia and Chinese funding: Sure it's an inaccurate idea, did anyone here actually say that though? I really don't like this general trend amongst leftist that imperialism is good or better as long as it's not American brand imperialism. We see it whenever China does anything in Africa, we see it with people bending over backwards to justify what Russia is doing even though someone doing the same for America in the same scenario would be rightfully shouted down.
|
# ? Sep 6, 2023 00:49 |
|
BiggerBoat posted:The most recent polls on a Trump v Biden 2 election are also disturbingly close Well duh, we're more than a year out from the election, and roughly half of the country is conservative, roughly half is liberal, and most voters don't really pay too close attention to things Like I get it from a purely-intellectual "man I sure wish this indictment would have more of an impact on the voting public" perspective but anyone telling you to panic because Trump is definitely going to win now are either paid by a conservative think tank or someone with severe anxiety issues (and I say this as someone with pretty severe anxiety issues).
|
# ? Sep 6, 2023 00:52 |
|
Fister Roboto posted:Could you please not put words in my mouth? None of this is anything that I have ever argued. Where are you getting this implication from? That wasn't you, it was this post by the_steve that asserted that Democratic belief in "a strong Republican party" would prevent them from trying to squeeze Republicans out of seats. the_steve posted:Given that the sentiment among Democratic party politicians seems to be "Actually, we need a strong Republican party", I doubt it. The whole thing doesn't require any view into Pelosi's heart of hearts: it only takes basic reading of the English language and a middle school civics class understanding of how the government works. The Republican party is not going to dissolve tomorrow, and even if it does the voters will still exist: having whatever exists to the right of the Democrats* believe in at least keeping the lights on and running on policies rather than violence is very much in the interests of Democratic legislators. Even the ones who oppose the policies of serious business Republicans. Saying "I want a strong opposition with real ideas I can respect rather than these jokers" is pretty transparent political talk of the "I want the to see my opponent fighting his best so when I knock him out there's no question I'm the best." Democrats wanting to lose on purpose is dumb conspiracy theory in general, but on this specific issue that's beside the point. It's just that "Democrats want to keep the Republican party strong" is as dishonest a reading of Pelosi quotes as when the right-wingers said "Democrats want to pass Obamacare even though no one knows what's in it!" and it deserves as much consideration. *The only ways a major party realignment creates a significant power bloc to the left of today's Democrats are if former Republican voters push the Democrats right, if there are significant changes in the beliefs of the electorate, or if the whole electoral system gets overhauled. There's no reason to believe Pelosi wants the first or expects the others.
|
# ? Sep 6, 2023 01:01 |
|
Fister Roboto posted:I'd appreciate if you could read and respond to the rest of my post, or at least the sentence immediately following the one you selectively quoted. The problem is that she also said that the country needs a strong Republican party. She could have just not said that. And you’ll notice nowhere in the Pelosi quote does she say the Republican Party needs to win X many elections to be strong. For all we know in this context “strong” means morally strong or just hardened against fascism. It’s kind of hard to complain the_steve’s post our your take on this is being taken out of context when they’re not recognizing context either. Like the whole thing is such penny ante poo poo anyway because I defy anyone to find anyone other than the terminally online who is aware and cares about what Pelosi said, and the terminally online will act exactly the same regardless. yronic heroism fucked around with this message at 01:23 on Sep 6, 2023 |
# ? Sep 6, 2023 01:06 |
|
Main Paineframe posted:Second, the GOP specifically is not an inherently fascist party any more than any other right-wing party would be. It's true, any right-wing party is going to be fascist as gently caress.
|
# ? Sep 6, 2023 01:22 |
|
socialsecurity posted:Sure it's an inaccurate idea, did anyone here actually say that though? I really don't like this general trend amongst leftist that imperialism is good or better as long as it's not American brand imperialism. We see it whenever China does anything in Africa, we see it with people bending over backwards to justify what Russia is doing even though someone doing the same for America in the same scenario would be rightfully shouted down. The thesis of the AP article upthread is 'China is acting outside of international norms regarding lending, and as a result is immiserating developing nations and removing their sovereignty'. Chinese policy and actions as far as they diverge from existing international policies is what drives that story. When you are drawing attention to Chinese control of an infrastructure project as a result of a loan, the fact that other major lending institutes also heavily influence policies as a condition for loans undermines your thesis. If you believe influence over taxation is a completely different thing than influence over infrastructure, you'd have to defend that. If their interest rate is usurious but yours is reasonable, you'd need to put out some numbers and the historical context. So its very relevant to know exactly what is outside of the norm, here.
|
# ? Sep 6, 2023 01:50 |
|
Bel Shazar posted:It's true, any right-wing party is going to be fascist as gently caress. Under the current conditions, that's definitely the case. In 2020, 74 million people turned out to cast their vote for thinly disguised fascism, and every indication so far suggests a substantial chunk of that number are willing to show up again in 2024 and vote for fascism that doesn't even bother disguising itself anymore. As long as that's the case, fascism isn't going away. Even if the Republican Party magically ceases to exist tomorrow, the party that rises up to follow it will be one that's similarly appealing to those people. All the staffers and advisors from the former Republican Party will join that party too. Before long, it'd just be GOP Mark II, very similar except with a different name and a scrambled leadership slate. Ultimately, the source of the political swing toward fascism in the US is not the Republican Party, or even Trump itself. It's the Republican voters (who in turn developed that stance thanks to the right-wing media outlets feeding them a steady diet of hate). Even Trump isn't really responsible for it - the rising tides of fascism were clearly visible a few years before 2016, Trump just demonstrated how high the waters had risen.
|
# ? Sep 6, 2023 02:18 |
|
|
# ? May 27, 2024 03:08 |
|
I think the only thing rhat *might* make it better is kneecapping Fox, and I'm not even sure that would do it by this point
|
# ? Sep 6, 2023 02:40 |