Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Zodium
Jun 19, 2004

Raskolnikov38 posted:

probably a good thing since WW3 starts in 2027 in the trek timeline

i mean

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

DancingShade
Jul 26, 2007

by Fluffdaddy

skooma512 posted:

That would lead to an unacceptable loss of value for the existing home owners, who are entitled to past performance. It'll be tied up in the courts for years, and the US is not at all shy about funding cops and white supremacy.

I like your thinking but in this case it's reverse. What we're taking about a large subdivision, off the plan pre purchases and timeshare Airbnb opportunities. Removal of unfair competition by way of government monopoly.

Really by not breaking up those fema camps into speculative real estate ventures it would incur exactly what you're describing. Torturous interference to anyone in our way. We'll claim it's malicious and get treble damages.

If need be we'll cut in a few senators to get any necessary legislation changes.

atelier morgan
Mar 11, 2003

super-scientific, ultra-gay

Lipstick Apathy

DancingShade posted:

I like your thinking but in this case it's reverse. What we're taking about a large subdivision, off the plan pre purchases and timeshare Airbnb opportunities. Removal of unfair competition by way of government monopoly.

Really by not breaking up those fema camps into speculative real estate ventures it would incur exactly what you're describing. Torturous interference to anyone in our way. We'll claim it's malicious and get treble damages.

If need be we'll cut in a few senators to get any necessary legislation changes.

tortious, but torturous interference is funnier to imagine

gradenko_2000
Oct 5, 2010

HELL SERPENT
Lipstick Apathy

Raskolnikov38 posted:

probably a good thing since WW3 starts in 2027 in the trek timeline

Aren't we also on track for the Irish Unification of 2024

Hatebag
Jun 17, 2008


the bell riots are also in 2024. time to figure out if big crazy weirdo star trek guy was a prophet

Danann
Aug 4, 2013

SAM SYRIA 🇸🇾 posted:

‏الجيش العربي السوري يكثف عملياته باستخدام درونات FPV الانتحا...رية ضد الإرهابيين من تنظيم "جبهة النصرة" في أرياف إدلب في الأيام الأخيرة، تم تنفيذ العديد من العمليات النوعية أدت للقضـ..اء على عشرات الإرهابيين وتدمير عدة آليات، ومعظم الخسائر تكتم عليها الإرهابيون.
(from t.me/SAM_Syria0/11258, via tgsa)

quote:

The Syrian Arab Army intensifies its operations using FPV suicide drones against terrorists from the “Al-Nusra Front” organization in the Idlib countryside. In recent days, many specific operations have been carried out that led to the elimination of dozens of terrorists and the destruction of several vehicles, and most of the losses are concealed. On them are the terrorists.

weaponization of drone tech among the us' enemies are continuing to intensify since '22

DancingShade
Jul 26, 2007

by Fluffdaddy

atelier morgan posted:

tortious, but torturous interference is funnier to imagine

Anyone who impedes shareholder value deserves the rack! Also yes lol

Votskomit
Jun 26, 2013

Hatebag posted:

the bell riots are also in 2024. time to figure out if big crazy weirdo star trek guy was a prophet

Bell Riots were written after Roddenberry died.

Irrelevegardlessly though, if it holds true we should also expect Europe in "political anarchy", France to have trouble with neotrotskyites, and computers that work via stylus/touchpads.

mawarannahr
May 21, 2019

Votskomit posted:

Bell Riots were written after Roddenberry died.

Irrelevegardlessly though, if it holds true we should also expect Europe in "political anarchy", France to have trouble with neotrotskyites, and computers that work via stylus/touchpads.

this is all happening !!

SixteenShells
Sep 30, 2021


roddenberry was a horny old goat and I love him for it

Hatebag
Jun 17, 2008


Votskomit posted:

Bell Riots were written after Roddenberry died.

Irrelevegardlessly though, if it holds true we should also expect Europe in "political anarchy", France to have trouble with neotrotskyites, and computers that work via stylus/touchpads.

and then come the drug wars. the wars where soldiers take drugs, that is. which is pretty much every war but they have the starcraft nasal spray meth

Animal-Mother
Feb 14, 2012

RABBIT RABBIT
RABBIT RABBIT
Captain, sensors are detecting Irish cum waves emanating from Roddenberry 7..
.

Al!
Apr 2, 2010

:coolspot::coolspot::coolspot::coolspot::coolspot:

Hatebag posted:

the bell riots are also in 2024. time to figure out if big crazy weirdo star trek guy was a prophet

well theyve already started building the homeless concentration camps

stephenthinkpad
Jan 2, 2020
Are TNG and older trek the only western shows that have non sarcastic post-scarcity society?

DickParasite
Dec 2, 2004


Slippery Tilde

Votskomit posted:

Bell Riots were written after Roddenberry died.

Irrelevegardlessly though, if it holds true we should also expect Europe in "political anarchy", France to have trouble with neotrotskyites, and computers that work via stylus/touchpads.

I mean we all remember how bad the 90s Eugenics Wars were.

Slavvy
Dec 11, 2012

stephenthinkpad posted:

Are TNG and older trek the only western shows that have non sarcastic post-scarcity society?

They were the last time western pop culture had any hope for the future yes

The Oldest Man
Jul 28, 2003

stephenthinkpad posted:

Are TNG and older trek the only western shows that have non sarcastic post-scarcity society?

DS9 still had it but it was explicitly Earth and some of the other like bigshot federation planets that are actually post scarcity, not the entire society

How are they post-scarcity and where do the resources come from to sustain that?

Don't ask :)

cock hero flux
Apr 17, 2011



The Oldest Man posted:

DS9 still had it but it was explicitly Earth and some of the other like bigshot federation planets that are actually post scarcity, not the entire society

How are they post-scarcity and where do the resources come from to sustain that?

Don't ask :)

i don't even watch star trek and the obvious answer is matter replicator/holodecks+some kind of Sci fi energy tech

with the only reason that it hasn't extended to the whole society yet being because the decadent core worlders are too busy hibernating in their wank fortresses or serving in the LARPfleet to go build the infrastructure for them

The Oldest Man
Jul 28, 2003

cock hero flux posted:

i don't even watch star trek and the obvious answer is matter replicator/holodecks+some kind of Sci fi energy tech

the sci fi energy tech is matter/anti-matter reactors

the matter/anti-matter reactors require dilithium

we are shown - multiple times across different series in trek - that dilithium mining is a heavy industrial activity

this activity is shown occurring exclusively outside the "post scarcity" worlds like earth

:thunk:

corona familiar
Aug 13, 2021

The Oldest Man posted:

the sci fi energy tech is matter/anti-matter reactors

the matter/anti-matter reactors require dilithium

we are shown - multiple times across different series in trek - that dilithium mining is a heavy industrial activity

this activity is shown occurring exclusively outside the "post scarcity" worlds like earth

:thunk:

wouldn't an interstellar civilization with matter synthesizers have functionally unlimited material and energy resources? if it was "cheap" to move resources around and reconstitute them at a subatomic level, wouldn't it then make sense to move resource extraction and polluting industrial processes away from habitable worlds?

Star Trek has all kinds of hand wavey plot contrivances but banning resource extraction on central federation worlds feels like a reasonable step if the alternative is robotic asteroid mining or whatever to stuff into your matter recycler

corona familiar has issued a correction as of 23:52 on Feb 7, 2024

Hatebag
Jun 17, 2008


Al! posted:

well theyve already started building the homeless concentration camps

to my recollection the conditions in the ds9 homeless city were actually better than conditions for homeless people in contemporary san francisco.

The Oldest Man posted:

DS9 still had it but it was explicitly Earth and some of the other like bigshot federation planets that are actually post scarcity, not the entire society

How are they post-scarcity and where do the resources come from to sustain that?

Don't ask :)

i think the idea was they had infinite energy via fusion reactors and used that to basically do molecular alchemy. so you could just go up to some nebula with a bunch of hydrogen and turn it all into solid gold dildos or whatever with a replicator/3-d molecular printer. but if you want to make heavy industry type equipment, spaceships, bases, etc, you need a bigger replicator. so i don't think in that model there actually was exploitation.
but i suppose if you suck up all the nebula hydrogen there's probably going to be some consequence eventually

Raskolnikov38
Mar 3, 2007

We were somewhere around Manila when the drugs began to take hold

The Oldest Man posted:

the sci fi energy tech is matter/anti-matter reactors

the matter/anti-matter reactors require dilithium

we are shown - multiple times across different series in trek - that dilithium mining is a heavy industrial activity

this activity is shown occurring exclusively outside the "post scarcity" worlds like earth

:thunk:

dont worry they solved the problem by cloning robert picardo infinite times and having him mine all the dilithium

Hatebag
Jun 17, 2008


The Oldest Man posted:

the sci fi energy tech is matter/anti-matter reactors

the matter/anti-matter reactors require dilithium

we are shown - multiple times across different series in trek - that dilithium mining is a heavy industrial activity

this activity is shown occurring exclusively outside the "post scarcity" worlds like earth

:thunk:

oh ok. but the people that work at those jobs are shown to do so freely. isn't there a tng episode where there's an environmental problem at a mine and they show up and solve it?

Raskolnikov38
Mar 3, 2007

We were somewhere around Manila when the drugs began to take hold
ds9 shows that the trill operate a for-profit dilithium mine despite being federation members. post scarcity might be a humans only thing lol

The Oldest Man
Jul 28, 2003

Hatebag posted:

oh ok. but the people that work at those jobs are shown to do so freely. isn't there a tng episode where there's an environmental problem at a mine and they show up and solve it?

the rate of profit fell and by the time of Picard industrial workers are shown eating literal gruel in unsafe conditions on mars

Raskolnikov38 posted:

ds9 shows that the trill operate a for-profit dilithium mine despite being federation members. post scarcity might be a humans only thing lol

only if you live on earth lol

FirstnameLastname
Jul 10, 2022

Raskolnikov38 posted:

ds9 shows that the trill operate a for-profit dilithium mine despite being federation members. post scarcity might be a humans only thing lol

from the perspective of the people playing around with spaceships irl society probably appears to be post scarcity just saying

cock hero flux
Apr 17, 2011



corona familiar posted:

wouldn't an interstellar civilization have functionally unlimited material and energy resources? if it was "cheap" to move resources around, wouldn't it then make sense to move resource extraction and polluting industrial processes away from habitable worlds?

sure but then by this logic you would have every habitable world experiencing post-scarcity and the few jobs required to extract the few resources that actually need extracting would be either extremely prestigious public service positions or filled by some kind of short term national service or lottery program

as far I'm aware nobody ever talks about how they didn't make the cut as a dilithium acquisition specialist and had to become a starfleet captain instead, or reminisces about the two years that everyone has to spend as a miner after they finish high school

Hatebag
Jun 17, 2008


i suppose it's not really practical to try and divine a canon from a series of serialized television shows written by hundreds of people and produced by serial sexual harassers whose diets are 10% cocaine by mass

corona familiar
Aug 13, 2021

The Oldest Man posted:

the rate of profit fell and by the time of Picard industrial workers are shown eating literal gruel in unsafe conditions on mars

picard is an incoherent mess and trying to infer any kind of material conditions from that show is like trying to interpret the state of American defense from YouTube comments

The Oldest Man
Jul 28, 2003

The best thing about Picard is just how hard it goes at pissing on Roddenberry's utopian vision

Much like how neoliberalism exploded out of progressive liberalism's chest like a xenomorph and then stalked and killed every other american ideal one by one

The Oldest Man
Jul 28, 2003

corona familiar posted:

picard is an incoherent mess and trying to infer any kind of material conditions from that show is like trying to interpret the state of American defense from YouTube comments

it's canon, you're going to have to do a schism and declare paramount the antipope if you want to change that

corona familiar
Aug 13, 2021

The Oldest Man posted:

it's canon, you're going to have to do a schism and declare paramount the antipope if you want to change that

id rather eat a car battery

cock hero flux posted:

sure but then by this logic you would have every habitable world experiencing post-scarcity and the few jobs required to extract the few resources that actually need extracting would be either extremely prestigious public service positions or filled by some kind of short term national service or lottery program

as far I'm aware nobody ever talks about how they didn't make the cut as a dilithium acquisition specialist and had to become a starfleet captain instead, or reminisces about the two years that everyone has to spend as a miner after they finish high school

isn't that what happens? the federation worlds are like that or progressing towards that, the ones that don't want federation support aren't like that, some people don't like living in the federation and leave, and the federation, for better or for worse, is like "okay we won't stop you"

like being a miner is probably boring and dirty but there are billions of people in the civilization, surely more than enough people are interested in the work voluntarily to fill the necessary positions

corona familiar has issued a correction as of 00:08 on Feb 8, 2024

Mandel Brotset
Jan 1, 2024

The Oldest Man posted:

it's canon, you're going to have to do a schism and declare paramount the antipope if you want to change that

this sounds badass

Al!
Apr 2, 2010

:coolspot::coolspot::coolspot::coolspot::coolspot:
electing bart simpson to president of the federation

SixteenShells
Sep 30, 2021
i think it's kind of interesting for DS9 to come along and say "yeah that utopia poo poo was horsepiss"

Pf. Hikikomoriarty
Feb 15, 2003

RO YNSHO


Slippery Tilde

Raskolnikov38 posted:

ds9 shows that the trill operate a for-profit dilithium mine despite being federation members. post scarcity might be a humans only thing lol

the trill have a striver society based around taking a bunch of tests so you can (literally) join the symbiont elite

Al!
Apr 2, 2010

:coolspot::coolspot::coolspot::coolspot::coolspot:
the trill are literally slaves to an alien parasite caste, but whatever thats trill business

Lostconfused
Oct 1, 2008

The Oldest Man posted:

it's canon, you're going to have to do a schism and declare paramount the antipope if you want to change that

I'm not going to watch that show and nobody can make me.

Al!
Apr 2, 2010

:coolspot::coolspot::coolspot::coolspot::coolspot:
they never show what happens to trill who fail to be parasitized but i assume hard labor in the dilithium mines

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

The Oldest Man
Jul 28, 2003

I could talk for so long about how Picard is the perfect example of how modern American liberalism has retrenched into pure magical thinking and a low-key descent into fascism in to justify its conclusions. Like how in s1 the bad guys are defeated by Old Cool TNG Star Fleet still existing and just showing up at the last second even though everything we've been shown about Starfleet up to that point is that it's a totally rotted institution incapable of performing its functions anymore. Even though in TNG we also saw Starfleet trail of tearsing people for political expediency, so it wasn't exactly a sterling utopian institution then either. The golden past that never was calls to us!

Raskolnikov38 posted:

dont worry they solved the problem by cloning robert picardo infinite times and having him mine all the dilithium

imagining possible explanations of why robert picardo isn't seen in Picard:

1. Robert Picardo digi-slavery was outlawed; as a reaction to this, all of his clones were simply shut down and murdered rather than actually being emancipated.
2. Holograms turned out to be less cost effective somehow than a combination human workers eating gruel and physical robots. All of the Robert Picardo clones were murdered.
3. Robert Picardo did his own hologram uprising and it was brutally put down off screen between the end of Voyager and the first episode of Picard. All of the Robert Picardo clones were murdered.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply