Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
What is the best system of Government?
Socialism
Capitalism
Communism
Fascism
Gokuism
View Results
 
  • Locked thread
BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice
This a thread for blowing off some steam discussing socialism and heck maybe other political ideologies too in the fallout of the 2016 presidential election.

GBS is an inclusive and openminded place where everyone is welcome to post they thoughts and feelings but please be respectful of our posting culture and refrain from walls of boring text, try to keep it light hearted and make a joke or two.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice

Crash74 posted:

Effort Post:



This is a good read and it opened my eyes about socialism / communism please consider reading it:


https://www.amazon.com/Mig-Pilot-Final-Escape-Belenko/dp/0380538687

It's about Viktor Belenko, a soviet fighter pilot in the 1980's. Dude was a rock star for the communist party. At the beginning of his career he was a hard core party member and in the elite class. He was paid 600 rubles a month (ruble / dollar value where roughly the same) which was 5x what a normal person got. He could afford a black and white tv when very few people could. The jet that he flew was top of the line cutting edge, costing 6 million dollars. His life, and the lives of his people were pure hell.

The party bosses were corrupt and syphoning away every bit of money they could get. His people were forced to stop military operations to plow fields two months out of the year to help local farmers plant crops with hand tools, and harvest by hand because there was no machinery and if the military did not intervene the entire crop would spoil. The military leadership was incompetent and afraid of punishment for reporting anything negitive, to the point where the enlisted soldiers were illegally having to sneak off base to shoot deer so they wouldn't starve to death. Most became raging alcoholics to endure life in there lovely barracks. With men routinely being killed in safety accidents. His personal life was being destroyed because of the grueling hours his commander placed on him.

The plane's jet engines, bleeding edge technology allowing the jet to blast off to 20,000 feet in two minutes would destroy itself in it was not properly cooled. This was done with a 500 gallon tank of pure alcohol. So much of this industrial grade booze was being siphoned off by the soldiers the planes only had enough for two flights a month. The base he was stationed at had over 100 million dollars of planes, Top Secret, The best the Soviets had. They could not afford to feed the people that maintained the machines.

Everything Victor was seeing was making him panic inside, his leadership was actively trying to sabotage any change that would make the situation better.

He decided to defect.

He waited an entire year, planning his escape because they only allowed the planes to be fully fueled in rare training exercises. Finally he had enough fuel to reach Japan.

It was so close that he ran out of fuel costing down to the japanese airport, sliding off the runway and coming to a stop in a field.



His decision helped prevent a third world war and changed his life for ever.

When he was taken into custody of the "Dark Forces" both in japan and the U.S. he could not believe his eyes.

Did not believe, for months that what he was seeing was real. That it was all faked to impress him.

After being granted citizenship UNANIMOUSLY BY THE ENTIRE U.S. CONGRESS (wtf right), he went on a road trip across the country and lived on a farm of one of his CIA handlers relative's.

He came to the conclusion that the U.S. is the ideal Communist paradise.

Everyone was fed, everyone was wealthy, even the hobos were more wealthy than the people he saw starving in a ditch on the side of the road in russia. Even people who worked in denny's were making more than he did as a fighter pilot. Everyone had a color t.v., a car, a house. You could walk into any hospital and get top notch treatment. People that were out of their luck still could get help. No one was starving, with thousands of grocery stores, piles of food everywhere you looked.

The Communist Dream was America.

The farm where he stayed at and worked as a farm hand in the midwest had four people. It out produced an entire division of Soviet troops toiling away in the fields with shovels and pick akes.

The people were happy. Everyone worked hard for jobs they took pride in. In a year of driving around the country he was only in one bad situation where someone tried to rob him. When in Russia you would be robbed or killed if you were caught going outside the base by yourself.

Viktor Belenko, a true hero and overall cool and good guy:

People should be wearing pictures of this dude on their shirts, not che guevara.

Read the entire book here: http://testpilot.ru/review/mig_pilot/ch_6.htm


Working capitalism is the best ideal of communism. Be proud you live in the best country in the world.

thanks for posting this its pretty dang interesting ill add the book to my pile

the issue here is that the ideal of communism the the soviets claimed to be working towards is its own whole thing and they transitional socialism is a widely acknowledged and documented failure and definitely not what most people are talking about when we talk about socialism in 2016. thats why i personally wouldnt call myself a socialist that shits so broad as to be meaningless

the results belenko was so impressed by were the result of capitalist america adopting aspects of social democracy under fdrs new deal legislation following the great depression namely a welfare state, collective bargaining, strict economic regulation and progressive taxation all of which was being slowly repealed at the time and are either going or long gone in modern times and those are the policies we desperately needed to return to this electoral cycle imo

DoctorStrangelove
Jun 7, 2012

IT WOULD NOT BE DIFFICULT MEIN FUHRER!

Socialism is the best. Viva Chavez! Viva Maduro!

Nefarious 2.0
Apr 22, 2008

Offense is overrated anyway.

socialism owns bitch

Xtra Innings Lovin
Nov 11, 2016

There are still factional struggles between Trotskyists and the Stalinist wing of a dead ideology LMAO. The Stalinist wing is still the prevailing ideology and they try and stamp out Trotskyists from their FB pages, etc.

With that being said, I think the Permanent Revolution will occur, we just need to wait until this whole capitalism thing runs its course.

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice
i legit think chavez while flawed is a pretty successful example of modern revolution he did great things for the poor and the people who opposed him were the grossest most arrogant bougie shills imaginable before the hillarymen took that title and ran with it

proof of concept
Mar 6, 2005

by FactsAreUseless

H.H
Oct 24, 2006

August is the Cruelest Month

Xtra Innings Lovin posted:

There are still factional struggles between Trotskyists and the Stalinist wing of a dead ideology LMAO. The Stalinist wing is still the prevailing ideology and they try and stamp out Trotskyists from their FB pages, etc.

With that being said, I think the Permanent Revolution will occur, we just need to wait until this whole capitalism thing runs its course.

There are still Stalinists around? LMAO.

Are they walking around going "Stalin did nothing wrong, the 20th communist congress was a reactionary betrayal of Leninist ideas by Khrushchev"?

I mean, with all of Hitler's unpopularity with sane people at least he wasn't discredited by his own party and regime.

Being a Stalinist in the 21st century sounds like the lamest, least ideologically consistent way to go through life.

Dandywalken
Feb 11, 2014

More like.... BelenkOWNS!

LuisN
Sep 10, 2011
Yeah, I read Jacobinmag. Does that make me a revolutionary? No, it makes me part of a movement, part of a new scene that will upend existing power structues, forged in a genuine struggle with the working class toward social movement unionism :agesilaus:

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice

a whole buncha crows
May 8, 2003

WHEN WE DON'T KNOW WHO TO HATE, WE HATE OURSELVES.-SA USER NATION (AKA ME!)
gbs has been under the tyranny of the thought police for too long

soupbone sal
Oct 29, 2016

Well, I wasn't convinced in the socialist dream before but this did it. Thanks for keeping it classy, socialists.

Xtra Innings Lovin
Nov 11, 2016

H.H posted:

There are still Stalinists around? LMAO.

Are they walking around going "Stalin did nothing wrong, the 20th communist congress was a reactionary betrayal of Leninist ideas by Khrushchev"?

I mean, with all of Hitler's unpopularity with sane people at least he wasn't discredited by his own party and regime.

Being a Stalinist in the 21st century sounds like the lamest, least ideologically consistent way to go through life.

Pretty much. I "liked" some group on Facebook because they had free e-books; and they'd get real uppity if anyone questions the sanctity of the 5 year plans, collectivization, etc. It was kind of funny at first, but then got sad like that scene in Life of Brian where The People's Front of Judea is arguing over what their official title is.

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice
ideology and belief is the death of understanding people should try having ideas and opinions instead

Fart Puzzle
Jul 25, 2007

compressed fart pieces

SOCIALISM IS loving LIT BITCHEZZZZ

Dicere
Oct 31, 2005
Non plaudite modo pecuniam jacite.

The US will eventually reorganize public life in such a way as that every worker has some ownership in the outcome and profit of his or her labor. It might be a long way off, and it may require the state losing any claim to legitimacy before being remade. Or the planet will burn. I'm not Nostradamus.

Dicere
Oct 31, 2005
Non plaudite modo pecuniam jacite.

BIG PUFFY NIPS posted:

ideology and belief is the death of understanding people should try having ideas and opinions instead

Truth.

Like Deng XiaoPeng said, doesn't matter if it's a black cat or a white cat, as long as the mouse gets caught at the end of the day.

Grand Prize Winner
Feb 19, 2007


Dicere posted:

The US will eventually reorganize public life in such a way as that every worker has some ownership in the outcome and profit of his or her labor. It might be a long way off, and it may require the state losing any claim to legitimacy before being remade. Or the planet will burn. I'm not Nostradamus.

rock hard right now, thx

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice
the first function of the state should be to consider the basic needs of every citizen inalienable rights and ensure they are met

reasonable people might disagree on what those needs fully encompass but food water shelter and security are not debatable

the state that fails to provide those is a failed state and should be overthrown

Hell Yeah
Dec 25, 2012

i feel that discussing political ideology in gbs is against the spirit of this forum. i object to this thread.

The Dennis System
Aug 4, 2014

Nothing in Jurassic World is natural, we have always filled gaps in the genome with the DNA of other animals. And if the genetic code was pure, many of them would look quite different. But you didn't ask for reality, you asked for more teeth.
I don't really get what socialism is and the OP's post about it was too long to read. Do those Scandinavian countries like Sweden count as socialist? Isn't the goal of a lot Bernie Sanders type people to be like those Northmen? Or does socialism just exist now in hellhole countries like Cuba and that South American country that made a bunch of money off oil and then spent all of their money and then when the price of oil plummeted they went bankrupt and the country became a lawless hellscape? I don't know. I hope when millennials take over and institute socialism they don't spend all the money at least.

Zorodius
Feb 11, 2007

EA GAMES' MASTERPIECE 'MADDEN 2018 G.O.A.T. EDITION' IS A GLORIOUS TRIUMPH OF ART AND TECHNOLOGY. IT BRINGS GAMEDAY RIGHT TO THE PLAYER AND WHOEVER SAYS OTHERWISE CAN, YOU GUESSED IT...
SUCK THE SHIT STRAIGHT OUT OF MY OWN ASSHOLE.

BUY IT.
robots are going to do all of our jobs. When the underclass has nothing left to contribute, you either feed the poor or they eat the rich.

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice

Hell Yeah posted:

i feel that discussing political ideology in gbs is against the spirit of this forum. i object to this thread.

i respect your objection citizen it has been noted by the positburo

Hell Yeah
Dec 25, 2012

i would like to call upon genesplicer, mega64, or jeffrey of yospos to close this thread, as the deadpan serious discussion of socialism is unwanted and unwelcome in gbs, even in jest.

Zorodius
Feb 11, 2007

EA GAMES' MASTERPIECE 'MADDEN 2018 G.O.A.T. EDITION' IS A GLORIOUS TRIUMPH OF ART AND TECHNOLOGY. IT BRINGS GAMEDAY RIGHT TO THE PLAYER AND WHOEVER SAYS OTHERWISE CAN, YOU GUESSED IT...
SUCK THE SHIT STRAIGHT OUT OF MY OWN ASSHOLE.

BUY IT.

Hell Yeah posted:

i would like to call upon genesplicer, mega64, or jeffrey of yospos to close this thread, as the deadpan serious discussion of socialism is unwanted and unwelcome in gbs, even in jest.

someone cover this man in bees

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice

The Dennis System posted:

I don't really get what socialism is and the OP's post about it was too long to read. Do those Scandinavian countries like Sweden count as socialist? Isn't the goal of a lot Bernie Sanders type people to be like those Northmen? Or does socialism just exist now in hellhole countries like Cuba and that South American country that made a bunch of money off oil and then spent all of their money and then when the price of oil plummeted they went bankrupt and the country became a lawless hellscape? I don't know. I hope when millennials take over and institute socialism they don't spend all the money at least.

yeah pretty much denmark sweden norway until very recently or hell the US from the 40's-60's are all social democracies to one degree or another

proof of concept
Mar 6, 2005

by FactsAreUseless
Gokuism you loving cocksuckers. you loving gay faggots. :weed:

(USER WAS PUT ON PROBATION FOR THIS POST)

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice

Hell Yeah posted:

i would like to call upon genesplicer, mega64, or jeffrey of yospos to close this thread, as the deadpan serious discussion of socialism is unwanted and unwelcome in gbs, even in jest.

tbh im kinda disappointed no one called me out for immediately ignoring my own posting suggestions

Shaquin
May 12, 2007

calm down

proof of concept
Mar 6, 2005

by FactsAreUseless
yeah that's really not that big a deal nips

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice
heh uh that was meant to be one of my jokes

Code Jockey
Jan 24, 2006

69420 basic bytes free

proof of concept posted:

Gokuism you loving cocksuckers. you loving gay faggots. :weed:

I voted for both gokuism and socialism, I am a goku-socialist

Dreddout
Oct 1, 2015

You must stay drunk on writing so reality cannot destroy you.
Personally I identify as a Marxist-Leninist-Gokuist.

All power to the weeb class!

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice

Code Jockey posted:

I voted for both gokuism and socialism, I am a goku-socialist

:same:

i picture gokuism basically as being this guy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oGfyKA7o3tc

Jeffrey of YOSPOS
Dec 22, 2005

GET LOSE, YOU CAN'T COMPARE WITH MY POWERS
Can I change this thread to be about socializing in 2017? Everyone here should be socializing regularly, we can do it GBS.

glowstick party tonight
Oct 4, 2003

by zen death robot
lets share it guys

proof of concept
Mar 6, 2005

by FactsAreUseless
I'm listening to a cassette of crowd noise so I don't feel so alone in my empty apartment

Jeffrey of YOSPOS
Dec 22, 2005

GET LOSE, YOU CAN'T COMPARE WITH MY POWERS
warning: this isn't a socializing 101 thread. It's not my job to educate you - please have the basics of latin and english grammar down before attending any function beyond the "beginner" level.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

BIG PUFFY NIPS
Mar 7, 2007

College Slice

Jeffrey of YOSPOS posted:

Can I change this thread to be about socializing in 2017? Everyone here should be socializing regularly, we can do it GBS.

i made it cause we were making GBS threads up the liberal tears thread talking about socialism so as long as we can still do that here you follow your bliss my dude

  • Locked thread