Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Leperflesh
May 17, 2007



I got that clockwork dragon too, and as I mentioned in the KS thread, I'm disappointed in it. On the other hand, I forgot I'd added on Cthulhu at the last second, so... bonus! It looks like it'll be amazing, and I got an airbrush which is going to work great for this.


Lethemonster posted:

Your problem will be that washes are primarily aqueous. This will not want to party with the bare plastic. You can paint straight on them because paints are based on polymer binders, rather than being mostly water. This means to be able to just dunk them in wash you will need to give them a little spritz of primer. All washes are like 90% water, so brand/type isn't going to change much, except maybe using oil washes.

I thought part of the point of Bones is that they have a surface that you don't need to prime? My wife recently painted a Bones purple worm (she really wanted to use my airbrush) and she did not prime it first. Came out pretty well:

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Lethemonster
Aug 5, 2009

I was hiding under your bench because I don't want to work out

Leperflesh posted:



I got that clockwork dragon too, and as I mentioned in the KS thread, I'm disappointed in it. On the other hand, I forgot I'd added on Cthulhu at the last second, so... bonus! It looks like it'll be amazing, and I got an airbrush which is going to work great for this.


I thought part of the point of Bones is that they have a surface that you don't need to prime? My wife recently painted a Bones purple worm (she really wanted to use my airbrush) and she did not prime it first. Came out pretty well:



Paints and washes are very different in their composition though. Any plastic / polymer surfaces will take paint 'ok' at least. Washes are different. Being made so much more of water means it's not going to want to get all groovy with the plastic surfaces of models. Paints however have much more binder and it's own polymer binder in.

It's probably still going to give you a better result washing a bones model than another random plastic model, but it's not very analogous to painting.

Ashcans
Jan 2, 2006

Let's do the space-time warp again!

I am excited about this thread! For ages I have been picking up random Reaper figures when I'm at a game store, because they always have something neat and characterful to mess with. Or for DnD games, they're the best place to turn for character miniatures. I wasn't able to shell out for the Vampire pledge, which was a bummer, but probably for the best because there are lots of things in it that I'm not really excited about. I really hope that it doesn't take them too long to get the new Bones stuff on the shelves for sale, there are tons of random figures in there I'd love to have.

Indolent Bastard
Oct 26, 2007

I WON THIS AMAZING AVATAR! I'M A WINNER! WOOOOO!
Wouldn't Krylon spray paint be a good base then use something like Quick Shade from Army Painter?

LumberingTroll
Sep 9, 2007

Really it's not because
I don't like you...
I don't know if you want to add it to the OP but when bones are commercially available, I can get and sell them at 40% off MSRP. I usually do orders once a month. I don't really make any money off this, but I don't keep my distribution account to make money so its no big deal.

Things I can get are listed here: http://www.warpathgames.com

LumberingTroll fucked around with this message at 19:33 on Mar 29, 2013

KingFisher
Oct 30, 2006
WORST EDITOR in the history of my expansion school's student paper. Then I married a BEER HEIRESS and now I shitpost SA by white-knighting the status quo to defend my unearned life of privilege.
Fun Shoe
So where could I locate some of the surplus stuff for sale?

Leperflesh
May 17, 2007

OK here is an effortpost about a sculptor. I figure this belongs in this thread because these days she sculpts a lot of stuff for Reaper. Let's chat about

Julie Guthrie

I first became vaguely aware of Julie Guthrie when I noticed her name on certain lines of miniatures, back when I first got into the miniature hobby (late 80s). I kind of forgot the name again for a long time. But, a few years ago a friend of mine was moving to Hawaii and decided that in the name of efficiency, he needed to divest himself of most of his belongings (since shipping them all would have been ruinously expensive anyway). So he gave me his entire gaming collection, which included piles of elderly miniatures some of which date back to the late 1970s and the very inception of Dungeons and Dragons (which, as a teenager, he was playing within a year of its first publication).

So a little while ago I started sorting through his collection. Most of these figures have been treated very poorly - they have the typical awful paintjobs of the early 1980s, done with huge cheap brushes and glossy enamel model paint. Many are badly damaged from use, many were ham-fistedly modified to better match some character's equipment or lack thereof, and, well, how do I put this? Scantily-clad (or entirely nonclad) female miniatures comprise a surprisingly large percentage of the total collection. My buddy was a horny teen male in a time before internet pornography.

Anyway. Going through these old figures, I decided to start by sorting them into manufacturer and then identifying them based on online resources. Easily half the figures are old Ral Partha (unsurprisingly) and I found some useful websites, including hosted scanned copies of their oldest catalogs.

I was surprised to discover that as early as 1982, Julie Guthrie was sculpting fantasy 28mm-scale miniatures for gamers. She was credited with designing an entire line of minis in the 1983 Ral Partha catalog, "All Things Dark and Dangerous," and was also added in credit for the "The Adventurers" line in that catalog, joining Tom Meier and Dennis Mize as the third major credited sculptor for the company's fantasy miniatures. (Although George Freeman, William Murray, Brian Apple, and Ann Gallup had credits for Ral Partha back in the late 70s, mostly for historical minis, these sculptors were absent from the credits by '83. Apple and Gallup had only co-credits for a few limited historical lines.) Guthrie's name subsequently came up on sculpts from Ral Partha, Grenadier, Iron Wind, Reaper, Emperor's Choice, and probably others I don't know about.

She has multiple lines of minis from Grenadier, including "Julie Guthrie's Personalities" and "Julie Guthrie's Personalities II," lines which explicitly advertised with her name, indicating that at that time her name was more recognizable to miniature-buyers than practically anyone else in the industry. The masters for these sculpts have been bought and sold repeatedly, and remarkably are still in production today, despite now being 15+ years old. (See also: Her page on the Lost Minis wiki). In 1995, she was inducted into the Origins Hall of Fame in recognition of her contributions to the hobby.

And she's still sculpting today. You can review her work at Reaper on this page; she has some figures that are being converted to Bones, such as this scary ghost, but she's also sculpting new and fantastic stuff, including the Nethyrmaul the Undying figure, the non-cheescake Male Storm Giant, and this adorable snakeman warrior.

I figure if she was maybe 20 back in 1983 doing her first sculpts, then she'd be 50 today. You see plenty of 50+ year old men involved in this hobby, but precious few 50+ year old women. I think it's fantastic that this woman has made a full career, going back to the earliest days of D&D, making high-quality sculpts of tiny little people and monsters and stuff, and is still churning out top-notch stuff today.

Here are some pictures of Julie Guthrie's work, new and old.

Newest:
Nethyrmaul:

Male Storm Giant:

Snakeman Warrior:

Barrow Warden Lord:

Witch of the Dark Lord:


Contemporary:
Lion Man:

Guardian Beast:

Cazalet, Plague Priest:

Pathfinder Red Dragon:


Older:
Troll, Julie Guthrie 700 series, circa 1986-ish:

Dungeoneers, same series:

Familiars, Ral Partha 1987: (I actually have this set, still in its blister!)

Best of Julie Guthrie "Women of Adventure", 1992 (note lack of blatant cheesecake):

Best of Julie Guthrie, "Lords of Decay", 1992

Julie Guthrie's Dragons, "Green Dragon", 1990

Julie Guthrie's Dragons, "White Ice Dragon", 1990


Really old:
Elfquest "Wolfriders 1", (Ral Partha), 1982:

Armoured Centaurs, Male and Female, Ral Partha 1983:

Two-Headed Ogre, Ral Partha 1983:

Hydra, Ral Partha 1983:

El Estrago Bonito
Dec 17, 2010

Scout Finch Bitch
I love the storm giants but the female one is the best. She looks like she's taunting some adventurer right before she hits him with her club and eats him. The facial expression conveys a really awesome trickstery villain feel, like she's thinking "OH BOY ANOTHER DELICIOUS PALADIN NOMNOMNOMNOM.". The male one on the other hand is pretty good but really feels like he needs a shield of some sort to tie him together.

Does anyone actually play Warlord? I've been curious if it actually is a good system for generic small scale fantasy battles ever since the local groups gave up on WHFB due to 8th Eds lacklusterity.

I have a copy of it I won from a contest Reaper did when the game first came out but I haven't done more than casually peruse it. It seemed like it was in dire need of a graphic designer and layout specialist since its mostly Microsoft Excel esque stat cards and some sort of haphazard illustrations and artwork.

Leperflesh
May 17, 2007

El Estrago Bonito posted:

I love the storm giants but the female one is the best. She looks like she's taunting some adventurer right before she hits him with her club and eats him. The facial expression conveys a really awesome trickstery

I can't say I totally agree:


Although the original artwork was worse (and I didn't order this pair as an add-on because of it) Edit: oh, this was added to Vampire regardless, so I guess I'm getting one.



Just a little too much "sexy model pose" for my tastes. Although it's assuredly not horrible, there's much worse out there. What is interesting is that they had two different sculptors do these two models: Julie Guthrie did the dude, and Patrick Kieth did the lady. I would have thought, if they wanted a contiguous look and feel to this pair, they'd go with just one sculptor.

Leperflesh fucked around with this message at 21:25 on Mar 29, 2013

lilljonas
May 6, 2007

We got crabs? We got crabs!
I thought I bought a bunch of extras, but it was nothing compared to you guys:

Vampire x1 $100
Fire Giants x1 $10
Frost Giants x1 $10
Figure Case x1 $25
Nethyrmaul x1 $25
Kaladrax Reborn x1 $10
C'thulhu x2 $20
Undead Giant x1 $10
Red Dragon x1 $10
Fire Giant Warriors x1 $10

Now that we've seen more sculpts, I'm really happy that I sprung for the undead dragons. I'm planning to use my Bones to make a dungeon crawler for my nephew, he is turning 5 so the softer plastic should be just perfect for him.

Ashcans
Jan 2, 2006

Let's do the space-time warp again!

Yea, I agree with Leperflesh. The sculpt is very nicely done, but the pose is cheesecake. Even if you set aside the matter of clothing (which is at least reflected by the male giant) the stance is totally wrong for anything but a pose. It doesn't look like she's prepared to heft or wield the mace, it comes across as a prop.

I am kind of disappointed in the male version as well. I would have interpreted the picture as him sort of hunching down, preparing to rush, but the sculptor took it more literally so that he has no neck at all and very high shoulders and back. It makes him look kind of like a lion. And some bestial elements to the giants is cool, but it clashes with the very human shape of the female version.

El Estrago Bonito
Dec 17, 2010

Scout Finch Bitch
I thought it sort of looks like she's leaning over to examine someone standing in front of her but that could not be the case depending on how tall she is compared to an average adventurer.

Ravendas
Sep 29, 2001




I got in on this, and paid $25us for the international shipping. That was way back when I thought I'd live abroad forever, but now I'm moving back to America within the next few months, so I changed the address to my American address. Emailed the Webmaster@reaper, asking if they could convert that $25us for shipping into random bones or something, but I haven't gotten a reply yet.

Anyone better I should email?

Fix
Jul 26, 2005

NEWT THE MOON

Man, I should have bought more Cthulu's. With as durable as this stuff is, it'd be totally worth it to line a bunch of them up and do Cthulu bowling.

JackMann
Aug 11, 2010

Secure. Contain. Protect.
Fallen Rib
So, painting Bones.

You can apply paint directly to Bones. But it's a bit different from painting a normal model. For the base coat, you do not thin your paints. Think of your basecoat as your primer. It goes on straight from the bottle and then you can thin paints from there.

If this just seems wrong to you, you can prime the bones instead. Some people have been painting their Bones that way because they just don't like the idea of an unthinned base coat. Just keep in mind that some primers work a bit oddly on Bones. The Reaper boards has a list of primers that work with the Bones. If no one else does, I'll try and find the list tonight and post it here.

If you have to strip the Bones, make sure you use a stripping agent that won't melt the Bones. Simple Green apparently works best for this.

Pierzak
Oct 30, 2010
My first Kickstarter actually :allears:

When I heard that Reaper's doing a KS I immediately got interested, when Isaw how much they actually offer my jaw hit the floor. I immediately pledged for something like $250, i.e. Vampire, 3 of the 4 paint sets (now I regret not getting the fourth), some dragons (including the 2 huge undead ones), blah.

I'v been a Reaper fan for a longest time. I started (unsurprisingly) with GW, but they had their serious aesthetics problems even back then in the 90s, especially with elf/female minis (insert joke how GW sculptors had never seen real women). In contrast, Reaper's are awesome, I love Klocke's elves. It's one of the rare companies that I can trust to make something totally random and there's a 90% chance they not only won't gently caress it up but it'll match my taste. And I simply looove RMS paints :3: so silky smooth coverage and awesome to blend :syoon:
My main problem with Reaper is that there are like 2 online stores importing them to Poland, they have limited range, and I can't afford to pay some ridiculous shipping every time I order a mini or two (no I can't plan 50 minis ahead). And don't even start about the paints. I saw them once on a clearance sale and each time I remember it I curse myself for not buying the whole available range :(
So, that was my big chance, I spend way more than I usually do on minis (especially when I'd see them in several months) and I think I have enough fantasy proxies to last me a few years. Skirmish games, board games, bookends, whatever. Still worth it.

Have you tried out any Bones minis already? How good is the detail compared to their metal counterparts? It's very hard to see in photos and if I'm gonna be disappointed, I want to be prepared. Also, apparently they come already assembled/glued, how careful is their assembly (misaligned parts, superglue spills, etc.)?

moths posted:

I'm considering "painting" most of my bones with a black wash and using them as playing pieces. I don't want to go nuts, but I'd like a look that compliments the printed out terrain I'm into using.

But man alive I'm having trouble finding a wash that gets along with the bones plastic. Going to try GW's Nuln Oil next.
If you want a low-effort look, maybe go for the Army Painter method - brighter base colors, dip/wash with the Strong Tone or equivalent (or wood stain :v:), let dry for 48 h, done! Lots of people do their low-detail minis (historicals, boardgames) this way.

JackMann
Aug 11, 2010

Secure. Contain. Protect.
Fallen Rib
It begins

JoshTheStampede
Sep 8, 2004

come at me bro

JackMann posted:

So, painting Bones.

You can apply paint directly to Bones. But it's a bit different from painting a normal model. For the base coat, you do not thin your paints. Think of your basecoat as your primer. It goes on straight from the bottle and then you can thin paints from there.

If this just seems wrong to you, you can prime the bones instead. Some people have been painting their Bones that way because they just don't like the idea of an unthinned base coat. Just keep in mind that some primers work a bit oddly on Bones. The Reaper boards has a list of primers that work with the Bones. If no one else does, I'll try and find the list tonight and post it here.

If you have to strip the Bones, make sure you use a stripping agent that won't melt the Bones. Simple Green apparently works best for this.

I can attest that Rustoleum grey spray primer acted weirdly with Bones - went on fine but stayed tacky to the touch for a week before finally drying enough to deal with.

Vallejo black airbrush primer worked like normal though.

To answer the detail question, they LOOK a lot less detailed out of the box, but partly that is because white plastic hides detail from the eye more than metal or grey plastic. Once primed or painted they are very, very close to metal/plastic. Maybe not close to the absolute top of what GW or PP can do with plastic or McVey resins or whatever, but almost identical to what Reaper does with metal anyway. On the Reaper forums there was a guy who painted up a metal and Bones version of the same model, and had people guess which was which, and it was a toss-up.

CaptainPete
Apr 26, 2009

I'm glad I didn't order a ton of add-ons, and I'm in the first 5k or so backers. Hopefully, I'll get mine shipped before the ReaperCon gap. Fingers crossed on that one.

What do people think of the Swords and Wizardry PDF? I downloaded it and skimmed a bit. I'm not sure if I missed old D&D that much...

JackMann
Aug 11, 2010

Secure. Contain. Protect.
Fallen Rib
Here's the thread.

Primers that have been noted to work:

Army Spray Primer
Gesso
Reaper brush-on primer (though it dries slightly tacky, it's almost unnoticeable, and doesn't affect painting)

Krylon, Testor's, and GW have all been reported to end up undesirably tacky.

mllaneza
Apr 28, 2007

Veteran, Bermuda Triangle Expeditionary Force, 1993-1952




Almost as much as all the cheap mis, I'm excited for Reaper because they got Julie Guthrie to sculpt for them. I ran the minis department for Games of Berkeley in 1990, and her stuff sold like hotcakes. Even at the new price point of $1.25 (the average humanoid mini cost $1.10 back then) I'd re-order a good chunk (20-30 figures at the high end) of her stuff every week.

FROOOOOOOOG
Jan 28, 2009

Leperflesh posted:

I can't say I totally agree:


Although the original artwork was worse (and I didn't order this pair as an add-on because of it) Edit: oh, this was added to Vampire regardless, so I guess I'm getting one.



Just a little too much "sexy model pose" for my tastes. Although it's assuredly not horrible, there's much worse out there. What is interesting is that they had two different sculptors do these two models: Julie Guthrie did the dude, and Patrick Kieth did the lady. I would have thought, if they wanted a contiguous look and feel to this pair, they'd go with just one sculptor.

I liked how in the artwork there was an extra curve between the lady's pelvis and hips(?). It's not on the model and that's a bit disappointing.

JackMann
Aug 11, 2010

Secure. Contain. Protect.
Fallen Rib
Just some food-for-thought. Reaper Bryan just announced on the Reaper boards that their one-click-all-vampire option on their website is going to cost $399 (a 20% discount on buying them individually).

EDIT: As far as the giantess goes, I wouldn't have minded it quite so much if it wasn't for the fact that all the female giants are in very passive poses, where the males are in full combat swing.

Leperflesh
May 17, 2007

JackMann posted:

EDIT: As far as the giantess goes, I wouldn't have minded it quite so much if it wasn't for the fact that all the female giants are in very passive poses, where the males are in full combat swing.

Hmm.





You know, I honestly hadn't noticed that before, but you're right. Apparently giant queens are like... yeah, I've got this spear, I could totally kill you, but not just yet. Whereas the male giants are all "raaagh we're fighting!"

Now I think about it, tons of female minis, even the ones in armor with weapons, tend to be in more passive poses. I can't think of that many female figures I've got that are in a mid-strike combat pose.

I still love these figures, though. They're loaded with detail and character and I especially like how they don't just look like very big humans - they've got different proportions.

Fix
Jul 26, 2005

NEWT THE MOON

I actually prefer passive poses in a lot of cases, both male and female. It gets a little boring to have everyone always in the motion of swinging an axe or whatever.

LumberingTroll
Sep 9, 2007

Really it's not because
I don't like you...

Fix posted:

I actually prefer passive poses in a lot of cases, both male and female. It gets a little boring to have everyone always in the motion of swinging an axe or whatever.

I agree, games don't feel right when you know your just moving your figure and it looks like the model is rushing to take someones head at that very instant.

Ashcans
Jan 2, 2006

Let's do the space-time warp again!

Yea, one of the things that I live about Reaper is that you can get miniatures of people just sort of hanging out or standing around. It's nice for characters, when you don't necessarily want someone permanently waving a sword or whatever. Having said that, it's still an issue if you have 90% of female characters being passive and 90% of male ones being aggressive. I think the ratios are actually much better than that though, but it can still be an issue in certain ranges - like the giants.

They definitely have ladies wrecking face though, like these ones:
http://www.reapermini.com/FigureFinder#detail/03283
http://www.reapermini.com/FigureFinder#detail/50007
http://www.reapermini.com/FigureFinder#detail/14609
http://www.reapermini.com/OnlineStore/60149/sku-down/60149

And dudes just chilling:
http://www.reapermini.com/OnlineStore/60148/sku-down/60148
http://www.reapermini.com/OnlineStore/50291/latest/50291
http://www.reapermini.com/Miniatures/Chronoscope/sku-down/50256
http://www.reapermini.com/FigureFinder#detail/02795

I definitely think there are other companies with a worse problem - a lot of the earlier Infinity stuff, for instance, seemed to have a pretty serious pinup problem.

CaptainPete
Apr 26, 2009

Most of the Cronoscope line has some passive models. Rex, the Mad Max inspired one, is my favorite: http://www.reapermini.com/OnlineStore/rex/sku-down/50065

LumberingTroll
Sep 9, 2007

Really it's not because
I don't like you...
Not sure I would call aiming a double barreled sawed off shotgun passive... But if he was holding it at his side or across his chest then yeah I would agree with that and the pose being passive.

CaptainPete
Apr 26, 2009

LumberingTroll posted:

Not sure I would call aiming a double barreled sawed off shotgun passive... But if he was holding it at his side or across his chest then yeah I would agree with that and the pose being passive.

Eh, it isn't exactly an action shot. But, I suppose you could call it a 'causal' pose. I imagine him causally blowing away some dude in bad BDSM gear while walking forward.

Pierzak
Oct 30, 2010
I never noticed that, and come to think of it, it's pretty offensive. Are they implying that men are dumb primitives only useful for fighting or what?

quote:

http://www.reapermini.com/OnlineStore/60148/sku-down/60148
That looks like the perfect Zachariah proxy for Descent. Thanks!

demota
Aug 12, 2003

I could read between the lines. They wanted to see the alien.
I only just found out about this and now I'm kind of bummed. What are the odds of them doing something like this again?

JoshTheStampede
Sep 8, 2004

come at me bro

demota posted:

I only just found out about this and now I'm kind of bummed. What are the odds of them doing something like this again?

Something of this scale? Zero. This came out of nowhere and almost broke Reaper and Kickstarter. They changed the rules afterwards partially in response to it.

Feeple
Jul 17, 2004

My favorite part of this hobby is the rules arguments.
Fortunately, they will be retailing all the models (IIRC there are few that were KS exclusive,) as Bones figs, as the whole thing was to raise capital for production. That sweet dragon that someone picked up for $10 on KS may retail at $30-40, but hey, you still get the bitchin' dragon.

SilentGeek
Jul 24, 2011

Feeple posted:

Fortunately, they will be retailing all the models (IIRC there are few that were KS exclusive,) as Bones figs, as the whole thing was to raise capital for production. That sweet dragon that someone picked up for $10 on KS may retail at $30-40, but hey, you still get the bitchin' dragon.

I think the giant dragons like Nethyrmaul and Kaladrax are gonna retail for $75 so the people that got them for $10 through the Kickstarter got a hell of a deal. I'm kicking myself for not getting either.

TheLawinator
Apr 13, 2012

Competence on the battlefield is a myth. The side which screws up next to last wins, it's as simple as that.

Yea, I'm regretting not picking up a couple more of the dragons I skipped out on along with that big rear end Cthulu.

Fix
Jul 26, 2005

NEWT THE MOON

I backed down from ordering all the dragons, but once I start seeing pics I may be banging down your door, LT.

moths
Aug 25, 2004

I would also still appreciate some danger.



Does anyone else remember them estimating MSRP at ~2x KS pledge levels? I know there were a few things I passed on, thinking that I'd be saving :10bux: at most, but the $75 tag on Kaladrax really caught me off-guard.

Ashcans
Jan 2, 2006

Let's do the space-time warp again!

I don't remember that, but it's possible they just misjudged what the actual cost of the larger miniatures would be - I mean it's a new material and process for them, so that sort of error seems pretty believable. Ok, if they were saying 2x it would mean that they misjudged by a pretty wide margin. It just seems weird that they would develop and sell a line on the concept of 'holy poo poo this stuff is cheap' and then try to gouge people with it. I mean if they were selling those dragons for $50 instead of $75 they'd probably turn over considerably more.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

JackMann
Aug 11, 2010

Secure. Contain. Protect.
Fallen Rib
That's pretty much what they've said. They gave their best ballpark estimates of what these were going to cost, and ended up missing on a few.

There's even one case where the final figures ended up much cheaper than they anticipated; the owlbear and the griffon will actually retail slightly cheaper than the Kickstarter pledge.

  • Locked thread