Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012
Before you went full time did you make your friends switch between names and pronouns depending on how you were presenting or did you use female pronouns while presenting male?


Also why has Hunter X Hunter not got the recognition it deserves as the supreme anime?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Gazpacho posted:

i hear a lot of kids are trying something called "gender fluid", where can i get it?

You have to go Greek God on it and gently caress a swan.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Fajita Fiesta posted:

have you talked to your therapist about your need to constantly attention whore / feed your narccism / seek validation by posting your pics and posting about how much of a troon you are all over the forums at all times

It can happen quite a lot. If your body and life was off-putting and caused you discomfort until you did something to address it, as you became more comfortable with yourself you'd be more inclined to show yourself off. People who lose a lot of weight do it, people who get into body building do it, people who have achieved something in life after a lot of work like to show it off, etc. It's pretty normal behavior and I'm surprised when people don't understand it.

As life continues most people just get back to living their lives without any need for external validation.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

psyopmonkey posted:

Where did the injecting horse piss come from? Ive never heard of this.

Estrogen medication was originally made from pregnant mare urine. I don't think there's any medication left on the market that uses that method.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

de_dust posted:

is the colon pussy actually a thing?

Yes, it is. Most surgeons use penis and scrotum tissue though, which is a different method.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

keyvin posted:

How did you feel about Leonardo DeCaprio not dying at the end of inception?

I haven't seen Inception but I've been very upset at seeing him dying in a different film so I am glad he did not die.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012
Do you ever hang out with any troons?

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

whoflungpoop posted:

that's hosed up yo, everyone knows that girls can't do math

0, 0, 0 is the easiest solution

He's trying to be smart by invoking Fermat's Last Theorem. There was a really popular book released about it in the 90s (I think.) It's about right angled triangles. It was proven that nothing exists to solve the equation successfully.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Maoist Pussy posted:

Where in your life did you miss the realization that actually nobody likes being a dude

I'd recommend seeing a therapist that specialises in gender issues.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

boom boom boom posted:

2. Why do trans people be all, "you shouldn't care about my genitals"? Have they not noticed that everyone everywhere always cares about genitals?

Why would you care about them unless you want to look at them for five or so minutes and/or stick things in them/on them?

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

whoflungpoop posted:

itt we wax pedantic about misspelled titles in japanese animation, universally hailed as proper entertainment for mature persons of culture and taste

But Cowboy Bebop is great (almost as good as Hunter x Hunter.)

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

whoflungpoop posted:

it had great music and a corgi, so yeah i cant blame it for anything but being an exception to the rule

I watched a documentary about jazz last night. There was a bit about bebop in it. Then I went to bed.

Maybe I'll find a documentary about dogs tonight. And there'll be a bit about corgis in it. Then I'll go to bed.

That'd be spooky.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

whoflungpoop posted:

Have one for dinner


What a wooferly doggy.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

psyopmonkey posted:

Sabel, can you jump in and answer trans questions. Im about to enjoy the bar and then run errands.

Wow! You go to bars and everything? Live that life gurl.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Maoist Pussy posted:

This is evasive. Answer the question, question answerer.

It's not evasive. It was a method of saying that unless you're a sexual partner (or doctor) then genitals are irrelevant.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Moridin920 posted:

I dunno I think people are naturally curious about poo poo like that. Genitals aren't really irrelevant in a discussion about gender are they

although it's understandable that someone wouldn't want to talk about their genitals

That's the problem though. Medical science has progressed long past any issues with genitals when it comes to trans people. For trans people the genital issue is private, something for doctors and partners and mostly incredibly boring. It has no real bearing on pretty much any issue that the general public needs to know about or care itself about. Also, it's really loving immature for someone to ask about dongs. There's far more interesting things about the trans experience.

Only one of my friends has asked me about my genitals, and that was more about concern with cost and availability of surgery. And apart from that one other person has asked me and I told them what I've told them what I'm telling you, it's irrelevant to pretty much every everyday concern, a boring question and unless you want to run the risk of insulting trans people you shouldn't really ask.

If you have a question beyond, "Lol, are you getting your dick cut off?" ask, but chances are the answer is really mundane to most trans people. Also, it's probably irrelevant on the level that you have absolutely no connection to the person you're asking, so why should they bother answering you.

But if you have a question that can't be answered by a simple Google or a little bit of thought, ask away.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Ignoarints posted:

What kind of gear do you have in your crotchel region

I don't do drugs.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Willias posted:

at what point were you like, yup i'm def trans and it isn't some other psychological thing that makes me feel this way?

I "accepted" I was trans when I was 27. I was sitting in female clothing in my room and just thought, "This is loving stupid, who else but a trans person would be doing this and dreaming of somehow waking up female. Stop hiding in your room wishing for impossible magic to happen and deal with this like an adult." So I went and saw a therapist. He agreed after a few sessions that I'm trans, or at least meet the criteria for hormone treatment. I of course kept thinking about whether I'm trans or just crazy for a while. I did a lot of thinking about what would make me happy in life, how I would like to be addressed and treated, how I would like my body to be, how I would like to be seen. I came out to people, and went a few places in "girl-mode." And all of that added up to me being comfortable with the idea I'm trans. If I wasn't all of that would have been a hellish experience rather than providing me with comfort.

There's no "trans-test." There's no indicator that you're definitely trans. However it all makes sense and makes me feel comfortable. I was honest with doctors and therapists, and honest with myself. That amounted to their being no other issues and me being trans as the correct answer. I'm comfortable with that answer and although I know it means I'll have a difficult life it's something that's right for me.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

frajaq posted:

is tranny offensive to you

Yes.

boom boom boom posted:

I mean, you say that, but you also spend a lot of time fending off people's interest in genitals.

I think you want to believe that you're more interesting than an artificial vagina, but maybe you aren't. That's hard for anyone to admit.

Ok. Maybe I'm not more interesting than an artificial vagina. Now what?

Sabel posted:

Why is Janet Mock so full of herself jesus loving christ

I don't know.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Maoist Pussy posted:

For people people, knowing what kind of genitals you have is not private and is, instead, incredibly obvious at a glance and has bearing on lots of different issues, so pretending otherwise is fake and dumb.

I bet you have angry, rage filled genitals. rawr!

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

boom boom boom posted:

What's up with your genitals?

Not much, how about yours?

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

boom boom boom posted:

I have a smaller than average human male penis, with two testicles.

I'm glad we had this chat.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

powerful weedlock posted:

sounds like you really should have gotten a second opinion. who the gently caress trusts a doctor when they jump to semi-permanent or permanent treatment options essentially right out the gate? it's like getting really minor lung cancer or something that got caught at almost the earliest possible moment and then he just throws up his hands and says 'double lobecetomy and a transplant is the only possible solution!!!' while staring w/ drool coming out of their mouth at an insurance receipt.

I do have a second opinion. The endocrinologist required it before he would treat me. I also have my own opinion which I came to after a lot of consideration.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Torka posted:

did your ability to read maps or imagine 3d shapes diminish after you started taking hormones :v:

I was kicked out of my Unreal Tournament clan because I could no longer pwn.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Sabel posted:

Which restroom do you use and have you had any restroom-related incidents
Never mind rear end in a top hat dudes, what do other women think

I'm not very far along the transition process. The only place I've been to for any decent length of time is my local bar where I know the people. I generally use the male bathroom because I know I won't get beaten up in there, however I use the female bathroom if I'm wearing a skirt as there's no lock in the male cubicle.

Using bathrooms terrifies me as it's the most likely place for a seriously bad reaction. I've avoided going places because of it. I've never had an issue using a bathroom in my local.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Sabel posted:

What's your daily fashion sense like. I like to be as androgynous as possible.

Converse, jeans and hoodie/top and cardigan/cowl necked purple sweatshirt that is badass. I don't pass so I guess people would consider it androgynous, or at least gender bending to a degree.

Sabel posted:

Have you done any voice training, do you ever go back and forth and selectively use both registers to your advantage

Not much. It's incredibly dysphoric and I had no idea if I was making progress as I was doing it. I need to get back to doing it.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Sabel posted:

Did you do that thing that supposedly some nerdy rear end trans do where they consistently play as opposite-sexed characters in games if they can or do you just not actually give a gently caress and pick based on utilitarian things like move set or armor or abilities or whatever

I don't play games very often anymore, but I mostly played as female characters. The last game I played was The Wolf Among Us and you play as a dude in that.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

de_dust posted:

are there any instances of transexualism occurring in nature?

Well, it happens all the time in humanity, which is a part of nature. There are sex-changing animals. There is also evidence among primates of both male and female members of a group adopting behaviour of the opposite sex and being accepted by the other members of the group.

Zombies' Downfall posted:

Do you think transwomen have an unfair advantage over other women in e-sports???

I don't follow e-sports or much about competitive gaming so I don't know. I can't see how they could though.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Sabel posted:

Thoughts on "chasers"?

In the vast majority of cases they're creepy as gently caress. They fetishize trans people and treat trans people like objects. An example is at a trans club where two of the trans people there were presenting male but most female. The chasers would come up to the group and completely ignore the male presenting people (even though it was obvious we were trans.) This of course didn't go down well with any of the people and they were told to gently caress off.

I have no objection to people being attracted specifically to trans people, as a fetish or kink or anything like that. I do have a problem with creepiness. I've talked to a few "chasers" online that aren't creepy at all. They're just normal people who have a thing for trans people. I wouldn't call them chasers though as that's a pretty negative thing.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Pumpy Muffinz posted:

Should trans-women be able to compete in women's sports?

Short answer, yes. Longer answer would have to do with hormone levels, level of transition, time after transition and level of competition.

Sabel posted:

What's the gender ratio of your friends
What was the gender ratio of your friends in the past, pre-transition to childhood


I went to an all boys school, so all boys during primary school.
High school was mostly women.
College was mostly men.
Now it's about a 50:50 split.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Pumpy Muffinz posted:

It was a real question. Should Transwomen be allowed to compete in women's sports?

I don't know why you're quoting my answer on chasers but I answered about trans women in sports.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Sabel posted:

Would you say that, other than a fetish/preference/kink/whatever, there's a fundamental difference between chasers and just plain lovely, creepy, uncouth straight dudes

I've found chasers to be a lot more predatory, but I haven't experienced either to be able to give a definitive answer. Sorry.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

boom boom boom posted:

So each professional women's sport could have some sort of commission to determine whether or not potential trans player are sufficiently a woman?

This is pretty much what happened at Olympic level. There's certain criteria that have to be met (I believe it's two years post-surgery and constant female hormone levels.) For many of the organisations that have policy they maintain that criteria throughout all levels, other organisations loosen the requirements as the competition level decreases. There are also a lot of organisations where there's no "competition" as such and games are recreational and their concerns are far less with some simply about addressing safety with regards to muscle mass, etc.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Sabel posted:

If there was a mutual attraction between you and a potential partner, but they still thought of you as a man, would that be a dealbreaker?

I can't see how I could be attracted to someone like that. If it happened though I don't know what I'd do, I honestly can't imagine such a situation at the moment.

powerful weedlock posted:

that leads me into a followup about how many nerds who are also trannies that you know

I've had significant conversations with about ten troons, three of them were nerdy enough to be considered full blown nerds. The rest were regular non-nerds.

Edit: Excluding online troons, who are almost all nerds.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Jim Rustler posted:

do you now consider yourself straight, or gay, and do you think your thoughts growing up or your parents opinions on homosexuality had a influence on your decision to become a trans?

I'm straight (I like dudes.)

I was always trans so my parents opinions have no bearing on that. My parents' along with society's views on homosexual and transgender people definitely had an effect on how long it took for me to be comfortable with me being trans.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

VanSandman posted:

Are there more troons per goon than there are transfolk per capita in, say, the United States and why do you think that is?

From entirely anecdotal evidence I think there are more troons per online capita than real life capita. A lot of troons are hidden away, shy, etc. and are naturally drawn to online communities even if they're not very nerdy people (they don't play games, don't watch animes, don't read comics, etc.)

I remember reading about this back in the early 90s so it's probably quite well documented. Sherry Turkle, an MIT professor has done quite a bit on online communities. Her book that I read is Life On the Screen.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

boom boom boom posted:

What sci-fi univers would you prefer to live in, Star Trek, STar Wars, Warhammer 40k, Marvel, DC, Stargate, sliders, culture, foundation, Uplift, Red Mars, Martian Chronicles, Gundam, 5 star stories, riddick, aliens, starcraft, VOTOMS, I,robot, John Carter, Halo, Defiance, Hainish, Man-Kzin, Pacific Rim, Dune, Xeelee, Foreigner, RIFTS, Shadowrun, X-COM, Infinity, Riverworld, world of tiers, Alliance-Union, Quantum Leap, Hunger Games, Primer or other PLEASE SPECIFY

The Culture. Iain Banks was pretty progressive when it comes to troons.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

boom boom boom posted:

yeah, Culture is best. but it was flat out stated that anyone who just stuck with one genderwas considered a biit of a weirdo, and you switched back and forth as the mood struck you, so I don't think there were any trans characters

From what I remember most people seemed to settle down into one gender for longer periods as their live's progressed. If there was a magic pill that switched me from cis male to cis female at random I'd probably be down with that. Presuming that being cis in one particular gender doesn't trap you there with a lack of desire to switch to the other. But I guess that's not in the science behind the Culture.

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

Jim Rustler posted:

I hope just because he killed some people, you don't think im comparing trans people to him, that's not my intention. just his body language and the way he sorta "holds" himself, I dunno, he seems like a very confused guy, sexually, that seems to have repressed something so far down that it turned into annihilation.

I honestly don't know. It's very hard to e-diagnose people with the trans. There are obvious signs like people being unhappy with their gender, or gender roles, ideation about switching genders, "cross-dressing," etc. but unless someone actively decides to progress themselves along a trans life route it's not really possible to know. There's lot of very happy men who are just incredibly twinky or camp. And equally there's tonnes of stories of incredibly masculine seeming guys who turn out to be trans.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Mrenda
Mar 14, 2012

boom boom boom posted:

Hey, serious question, my understanding is that dysmorphia is a mental illness, and transitioning is the only effective treatment, but what if someone developed a pill that made you be perfectly comfortable in your body(well, in your gender, not even a lot of cis people are perfectly comfortable int their bodies) with no other side effects. would you take it?

I don't think I would. It's something that makes up a fundamental part of me. It informs my thoughts and being and I'd be extremely worried that changing something so fundamental to me would change me completely. I know that being trans has brought and will bring me a lot of problems but it's a part of who I am. I don't think there's any direct comparisons but uneasy parallels could probably be drawn with offering a "gay cure" pill and maybe with deaf people and deaf culture.

Basically I am a transgender person, which is a different set of experiences to a cisgender person. I'm not sure I could happily go from what I see as a female identity to being happy with a male body without a total change in who I am.

  • Locked thread