AVeryLargeRadish posted:

Another tip if you want to be really diabolical. I pulled this once on a group of friends with some white habanero spiked ones. Present a plate of them and tell them that one of them contains a secret ingredient, then ask who wants to go first. After your brave volunteer is done having their fun with it you tell everyone else to dig in. However, all of them are spiked with the habanero. But! One of them also has a maraschino cherry or something like that at the center, and that is your secret ingredient.