Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Pener Kropoopkin posted:

And in my mind socialized agriculture looks more like Thomas Sankara's Burkina Faso, in which lands were redistributed to the peasants who worked them, while fertilizers and agricultural capital were provided by the government. Within 3 years Burkina Faso went from a food importer which relied on foreign aid, to a food exporter which had achieved food security for all Burkinabe.

In the United States, agriculture has become so overwhelmingly Capital intensive that it's impossible for small farmers to exist anymore without permanently indebting themselves to the major agcorps. Agricultural lands are slowly being bought up and consolidated by these corporations, or tributized through debt payments and licensing agreements. It's getting to the point where the sheer scale of modern agriculture makes it impossible for farmers to survive, unless of course the brunt of the capital was being covered by society instead of banks and agcorps.

No but you see a system where poor farmers are forced into selling their staple crops to upper middle class American citizens is actually better for them because

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
I'm being 100% serious in saying that you shouldn't engage anything The Saurus posts because he is astoundingly stupid.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

The Saurus posted:

Illegal immigrants are more lumpenproletariat then Sex Workers are Marx you loving sexist piece of poo poo.

What are you talking about? Are you saying sex workers aren't working class?

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
Nobody outside of SA or Reddit will be swapping from Bernie to Trump. His biggest internet support base (Facebook) loathes the Donald even more than they hate Clinton and will mobilize against him.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

The Saurus posted:

The number of jobs requiring Spanish speakers are far higher than the proportion of Spanish-only speakers.

This essentially provides a whole class of jobs for a particular privileged demographic in order to pander to an even smaller demographic.

Do you have any evidence to back this up or is this just the latest update on the strange reality that exists inside your mind

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Lol

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
if this thread has taught me anything it's that half of bernies fans are fake leftists

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Constant Hamprince posted:

A solid 30% of Americans think Obama is a Muslim lizard so uh good work there guys, revolution's just over the horizon, keep it up etc.

you're right, the politically expedient course of action is to do nothing except complain as the world slowly backslides into a ditch

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

crabcakes66 posted:

More people are living better than ever. Welcome to reality.

That doesn't mean that inequality and the political ramifications thereof are just going to go away.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

The Saurus posted:

Aren't you a Hillary supporter?

:lol:

Where on earth did you get THAT idea

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

GlitchThief posted:

Jesus Christ. Was this thread here all along? I've been missing out!

I live in a very small and isolated city that definitely has no running politicians that embrace any sort of socialism or communism. But I'm starting to think that engaging in political elections is just negotiating with a capitalist society that won't brook any truly revolutionary options anyway. Besides the fact that any third party is a dead end option for the general election, how does the PSL reconcile its positions with the nation's extremely limited tolerance of its ideals?

Socialism is less intolerable to the average American than they realize. And while elections are a bad way to go about affecting change for certain problems, reform within the political system can have positive effects which allow the working class greater ability to organize and survive and should not be outright discounted.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
i didnt realize "china is state capitalism" was a controversial opinion

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
I can't imagine why HE would skip engaging with people who do nothing but construct effigies of his views and then just act smug about it

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
Russia lost a lot of geopolitical power as well as having its politics internally compromised and its economy looted. It's not a surprise that the ensuing kleptocracy didn't go so hot compared to that of the place which cracked the seal in the first place by liberalizing.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
Social democracy has really served Europe well by demolishing its own base with austerity and labor reform while doing nothing to stop the rise of the xenophobic right, agreed

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
Social democracy has given us such achievements as...either losing all its political relevance to conservatism or implementing policies that affect the working class's bottom line when they are in power just as much as conservatives

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Bip Roberts posted:

Hmm yes, lets line up ideologies for what they have achieved - a marxist.

it gave American supremacy a run for its money for a little while there. Then it was stamped out of existence at the same time as crushing austerity was instituted for the lower classes by conservatives and liberals.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
Lol just lol at the idea of the US oppressing nations within its borders. Pipeline? What pipeline?

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
Pepper spraying and setting attack dogs on peaceful protestors on their native land = "just a dog" gotcha

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
The idea is that dialectical materialism conceivably talks about geopolitics in a manner that is testable and therefore scientific. I was never adequately convinced of that though.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Jack of Hearts posted:

That was my take, but I figured I was being uncharitable. I'm open to an interpretation that makes the use of the word less pretentious.

Remember Marx and engels were philosophers and its slightly less so

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
You also can construct an internally logical view of history through the lens of economics > everything else. But even so

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
The lefts biggest hurdle at this juncture is its ability to convince itself that violent revolution is even remotely possible.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

I said violent revolution, not civil disobedience which has translated into electoral feasibility in Europe

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Typo posted:

and the fate of said revolutionaries says a lot about their ideology in general

Yeah industrializing an agrarian nation into a global superpower in spite of fending off nazis and the other global superpower was a real stinker.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
I thought he meant just in general. Obviously I don't recommend being a twentieth century revolutionary at all if possible.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

JeffersonClay posted:

How does the party view hybrid systems like China and Vietnam, with private ownership existing in parallel with state and worker ownership? Are these capitalist countries? Or is there some threshold of private ownership that distinguishes them from European social democracies with large state sectors in transportation and human services?

They are state capitalist countries, yes.

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
Capitalists may be literally stealing what remains of our water supply but the free market and nonprofit industrial complex will fix it!!!

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Typo posted:

so what is the socialist plan for envriomentalism

Literally anything other than pure profit this really isn't hard

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
Sure our current system necessitates the depletion of non renewable resources for constant growth because its only rule is "gently caress you got mine" but have you considered huh uh the soviet union?

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Typo posted:

So your solution is to cap economic growth

The solution is to collectivize the means of energy production in such a way that it can be uniformly transformed into clean energy as is necessary to power any and all human economic endeavor, instead of relying on the profit gained off of slave labor to power the economy

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

asdf32 posted:

Unlike the others I know you're not dumb. So why in the world do you think that's unique to capitalism.


Which if you pay attention, is exactly what liberalism is with power distributed between the state, voters, consumers, and private institutions.

Lol liberalism is 95% "private institutions" 5% unicorn farts posing as democracy

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Typo posted:

so what kind of clean energy are you looking to transform to that couldn't be done under the current system?

Well its fundamentally more profitable to drag your feet as much as possible so you can continue to profit at the ideal margin, which is what capitalism entails

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Constant Hamprince posted:

ok not getting the sense that you actually know what profit is so here's a quick fyi 4 u

revenue - costs = profit

sorry if this is a little to mathy for u i can draw some helpful pictures in mspaint using apples as a metaphor if u think it will help

Ok now try this math problem

Value of workers' labor - wage earned from labor = profit

What's wrong with this picture?

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
this thread just proves that while not all liberals are stupid, those liberals who seek to "prove" Marx false are exceptionally stupid

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011

Homework Explainer posted:

time 2 nationalize all industries with heavy subsidy or with 50% + 1 of business coming from government contracts methinks

This is what I don't get

We already have similar structures in place for many industries but everyone insists were gonna turn into Venezuela and seize the toothbrushes if we consider a command economy structure

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
Please stop responding to the low effort shitposts

Thanks

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
it kills me when people act like socialism is something confined to internet arguments now that the sole unitary representative of socialism (the society union) is dead and it'll never be back or have anything to offer that liberal democracy doesn't

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
I mean it'll be hard not to develop class consciousness when the thiels of the world finally achieve immortality while hundreds of millions die from climate change induced hunger

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Fiction
Apr 28, 2011
I think the means of production are still privately controlled and used for profit. Last time I checked.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5