Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Piso Mojado

how would you do it?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Tiberius Thyben

Gone Phishing


Piso Mojado posted:

how would you do it?

If I blew up Pearl Harbour first, then Japan couldn't attack it.

Manifisto


wow, good question op, with lots of tough moral ramifications. is it ethical to expose a large populace, including civilians, to a viral agent that they are utterly unprepared to face if, on balance, more lives will be saved by doing so? after long thought I am going to say "yes," and feel there is not only an argument but a duty to immobilize the ranks of the japanese army by exposing them to the macarena

alnilam

I'd ask yamamoto not to do it and he'd be like "wait don't attack WHERE? I'd never thought of that, what an idea!" And I'd be like :doh:

Piso Mojado

alnilam posted:

I'd ask yamamoto not to do it and he'd be like "wait don't attack WHERE? I'd never thought of that, what an idea!" And I'd be like :doh:

So the real answer to this thread is to kill alnilam. :evilbuddy:

Piso Mojado

I would probably not do anything and instead work on a plan to warn people about aids

Piso Mojado

me (woke time traveller): listen in two days Pearl harbor will be attacked by the 2nd Japanese fleet led by Gen. Mitsuo Fuchida. There's nothing we can do about that. But we can start warning people about how bad cigarettes are for your health.

Business Gorillas

:harambe:



Piso Mojado posted:

me (woke time traveller): listen in two days Pearl harbor will be attacked by the 2nd Japanese fleet led by Gen. Mitsuo Fuchida. There's nothing we can do about that. But we can start warning people about how bad cigarettes are for your health.

i'd preemptively start harassing the future leaders of the feminist movement about ethics in video games journalism


joke_explainer


What are the parameters of our time machine? Do we only get to time travel once, or can we do it an arbitrary number of times? How quickly can we get in and out and with what sort of precision?

I'd probably just 'Millennium' it and save just the people that died or went permanently missing if it was possible and bring them to the present day as I'd worry about even that screwing up my own birth with the butterfly effect...

Piso Mojado

joke_explainer posted:

What are the parameters of our time machine? Do we only get to time travel once, or can we do it an arbitrary number of times? How quickly can we get in and out and with what sort of precision?


Let's just say you're on hard difficulty setting but not brutal

Robot Made of Meat

Business Gorillas posted:

i'd preemptively start harassing the future leaders of the feminist movement about ethics in video games journalism

What do you think got them started?


Thanks to Manifisto for the sig!

That Robot

ask me anything about robots
this is rather simple

i would swim out to sea (with motors on my boots) before the carriers reached within range of pearl harbor, dive under each carrier and attach depth charges.

i would then swim away before boom goes the dynamite

it would probably try and kill hitler too, but only if i was concentrating my efforts on killing something he was holding. that's how you get around the three laws and why the carrier gambit would work.

Piso Mojado

That Robot posted:

this is rather simple

i would swim out to sea (with motors on my boots) before the carriers reached within range of pearl harbor, dive under each carrier and attach depth charges.

i would then swim away before boom goes the dynamite

it would probably try and kill hitler too, but only if i was concentrating my efforts on killing something he was holding. that's how you get around the three laws and why the carrier gambit would work.

In your case there's also another slightly more advanced robot hunting you as well.

Robot Made of Meat

I'm thinking that it was inevitable that the US would get involved in WWII, so preventing the attack on Pearl Harbor would only change the details of who and when.


Thanks to Manifisto for the sig!

joke_explainer


Robot Made of Meat posted:

I'm thinking that it was inevitable that the US would get involved in WWII, so preventing the attack on Pearl Harbor would only change the details of who and when.

sure, but I think the goal is to prevent people from dying at pearl harbor. as time travelers we're okay if they die in europe

Manifisto


joke_explainer posted:

sure, but I think the goal is to prevent people from dying at pearl harbor. as time travelers we're okay if they die in europe

so free one-way tickets to europe for everyone in hawaii, then.

joke_explainer


Manifisto posted:

so free one-way tickets to europe for everyone in hawaii, then.

we come back to the present and the nazi hawaiian surfer legion has completely changed tide of history...

Plebian Parasite

I'd probably get a giant projector screen and show a long video of the open ocean on it and when the Japanese rolled up they'd see just a bunch of ocean and be like "oh we got our intel wrong" and then they'd go back home.

RazzleDazzleHour

two words:

kantai collection

Slugnoid

id warn the japanese abot the A bomb and midway so that the right side would win the war and could all anime :3:

Plebian Parasite

Slugnoid posted:

id warn the japanese abot the A bomb and midway so that the right side would win the war and could all anime :3:

seeing as how every other anime is an extended metaphor for the bombing of hiroshima and nagasaki I think that would backfire on you.

Piso Mojado

Please keep this thread anime free ty godbless

Fredflonston


Well, if I were to stop Pearl Harbor then we'd (The USA) have to find another excuse to whip someones rear end. It was high time for a butt-whippin and that kind of porn wasn't yet available en mass. You had to get it in-situ.

GODSPEED JOHN GLENN


I put my thumb up my bum and shut one eye, and my thumb blotted out the planet Earth.


Stop Pearl Harbor? I would help the Japanese finish the job and tell them about Pearl Harbor 2

oliwan

by Nyc_Tattoo
I've thought about this one a lot, because who wouldn't want to avert such a tragedy? I don't think I'd need to kill anyone though, I think I'd just drop the script of transformers into Michael bay's lap, and he'd focus his time on that instead of pearl Harbor.

Android Blues

Seems like a long time, but alright. I would use my future knowledge of high-level editing techniques, and of how much people love the Cloverfield monster, to establish a rip-roaring film career under various pseudonyms across key points in history. Each of these time dispersed releases would be designed to replicate one of Michael Bay's major successes, "edging him out" of the industry. At the same time, I'd use my growing web of Hollywood connections to pitch screenplays and collect on favours such that the 1990s were subject to a punishing glut of Pacific Theatre-themed WW2 blockbusters, starring all the great celebrities of the day. Ben Affleck would be in three of them. Pearl Harbor's prospects in the meeting room would be absolute toast, I don't see how it could survive this.

oliwan

by Nyc_Tattoo
lol

Android Blues

In my hubris, I am astonished and shaken to find upon returning to 2017 that all I have managed to do is set the stage for the Pearl Harbor Cinematic Universe.

FactsAreUseless

I guess I'd have sex with her, she was pretty -- oh. Oh! Pearl HARBOR! Like the place with the boats. Gotcha. Uhhh... I dunno, maybe like a big dome?

Moon Atari

It is a difficult ethical conundrum, but ultimately I don't think I could bring myself to take any action that would deny the world Michael Bay's 2001 masterpiece Pearl Harbor.

Manifisto


I would replace the japanese bombs with butterflies, the bomber planes with unicorns, hirohito with an adorable pug, hitler with an angora rabbit, churchill with three squabbling geese, fdr with a salt lick, stalin with smooth jazz, hawaii with easter island, easter with arbor day, vanilla ice cream with chocolate (because come on, vanilla?), and becky from 10th grade with someone who actually appreciates an extensive collection of star wars figurines over some fleeting sports achievements, oh god becky it still hurts after all these years


ty nesamdoom!

treasure bear

Without the attack prompting the US to enter the war, the Wehrmacht would have consolidated power in Europe and been able to focus on the Soviet Union.

Piso Mojado

Android Blues posted:

In my hubris, I am astonished and shaken to find upon returning to 2017 that all I have managed to do is set the stage for the Pearl Harbor Cinematic Universe.

Ben Affleck's Pearl Harbor Christmas Special

Android Blues

In the dystopian alt-Harbor future, Disney now owns Pearl Harbor. Not the movie franchise, the historical event. Following this legal precedent, Hardee's owns the Battle of the Bulge, and Foot Locker owns the Alamo.

FactsAreUseless

Android Blues posted:

In the dystopian alt-Harbor future, Disney now owns Pearl Harbor. Not the movie franchise, the historical event. Following this legal precedent, Hardee's owns the Battle of the Bulge, and Foot Locker owns the Alamo.
The whole thing, or just the basement?

Entropic

patriarchy sucks
I'm trying to look up the fbi's tipline but no one here has wifi!!

LawfulWaffle

Well, that aligns with the vibes I was getting. Which was, like, "normal" kinda vibes.
Preventing the attacks on Pearl Harbor would have wide reaching effects that could potentially prevent the Nintendo and Nintendo brand games from being released, so instead I would mosey on down to the nearest 1941 bookie and put big money on "Massive Tragedy on December 7"

joke_explainer


LawfulWaffle posted:

Preventing the attacks on Pearl Harbor would have wide reaching effects that could potentially prevent the Nintendo and Nintendo brand games from being released, so instead I would mosey on down to the nearest 1941 bookie and put big money on "Massive Tragedy on December 7"

Ria McLennan knocked the hidden compartment lose and cool air crisp against her respirator mask. She dropped down into the deck of the B-29 superfortress as it hurtled through the skies. According to the timer glowing softly on her retinal display, it had been 5 hours, 31 minutes, and 22 seconds. If the historical record was accurate, Morris R. Jeppson had just returned to the cabin after disarming the final safeties on the weapon. No one else would be checking on it until the drop. Stopping this genocide would be as simple as re-engaging the safeties, and then Nagasaki will never happen -- and the war will end without the deaths of hundreds of thousands. Her hand grew seams, and gently unfolded as she auged into her toolkit, approaching the primitive atomic weapon. She could feel the psychological weight of the weapon, a pure embodiment of the unbridled destructive potential of man. Though primitive compared to the nuclear weapons they'd design in coming decades, this was one of only two in the Surveilled timeline that was used against civilian targets. The Great Wars Injunction meant even being here was a capital crime, but if all went well there was nothing they could do to restore it, short of bombing Hiroshima itself, and she knew they'd never do it.

She got to work on the bomb. Primitive tumbler-key mechanism as the primary arming switch. It was all too easy, but she heard a noise behind her, and dove into a roll, popping up to her feet down the bomb bay corridor just as a heavy pipe swung toward where her head previously was. How could they have found her at this spacetime so quickly? She took in her opponent. A man, twenty five to thirty, pasty white skin, patchy wisp of a beard and slighty chubby. His gear looked very retro: Some gimmicky thin glasses with projected displays, what looked like an ancient laptop computer strapped to his waist with cords hanging off it and going to headphones hanging on his neck. His eyes looked wild as he stared her down. He didn't look like your average marshal, but they all have their quirks.

The man glared at her. "You don't know what you're doing. You don't understand the consequence of your actions here. I have to stop you."

Ria glared and dropped into a combat stance, her fingertips extending nanofilament-sharp blades. "Hundreds of thousands have to die just so the precious War Timeline stays intact? I've done the math, Marshal, and I'm sure you have too. The war ends anyway!"

The man shook his head. "I'm not a marshal. I'm from 2016. There's more at stake than just lives." He clumsily lunged forward, swinging the pipe -- where'd he even get that? She dodged and kicked, knocking him to the ground. "I'm done playing these games. This bomb is going offline and there's nothing you or anyone time-cleared can do to stop me." 2016? They didn't have the technology for time travel. What was going on here?

The man struggled to sit up, gasping for air thanks to his bruised solar plexus. "Stop! If you sabotage that bomb..." His lips thinned, his eyes pleading as he slowly got to his feet. "Pokémon will never exist. 801 unique creatures, over 7 generations. Millions of unique companions and travelling partners throughout history. Please."

Farecoal

There he go

joke_explainer posted:

Ria McLennan knocked the hidden compartment lose and cool air crisp against her respirator mask. She dropped down into the deck of the B-29 superfortress as it hurtled through the skies. According to the timer glowing softly on her retinal display, it had been 5 hours, 31 minutes, and 22 seconds. If the historical record was accurate, Morris R. Jeppson had just returned to the cabin after disarming the final safeties on the weapon. No one else would be checking on it until the drop. Stopping this genocide would be as simple as re-engaging the safeties, and then Nagasaki will never happen -- and the war will end without the deaths of hundreds of thousands. Her hand grew seams, and gently unfolded as she auged into her toolkit, approaching the primitive atomic weapon. She could feel the psychological weight of the weapon, a pure embodiment of the unbridled destructive potential of man. Though primitive compared to the nuclear weapons they'd design in coming decades, this was one of only two in the Surveilled timeline that was used against civilian targets. The Great Wars Injunction meant even being here was a capital crime, but if all went well there was nothing they could do to restore it, short of bombing Hiroshima itself, and she knew they'd never do it.

She got to work on the bomb. Primitive tumbler-key mechanism as the primary arming switch. It was all too easy, but she heard a noise behind her, and dove into a roll, popping up to her feet down the bomb bay corridor just as a heavy pipe swung toward where her head previously was. How could they have found her at this spacetime so quickly? She took in her opponent. A man, twenty five to thirty, pasty white skin, patchy wisp of a beard and slighty chubby. His gear looked very retro: Some gimmicky thin glasses with projected displays, what looked like an ancient laptop computer strapped to his waist with cords hanging off it and going to headphones hanging on his neck. His eyes looked wild as he stared her down. He didn't look like your average marshal, but they all have their quirks.

The man glared at her. "You don't know what you're doing. You don't understand the consequence of your actions here. I have to stop you."

Ria glared and dropped into a combat stance, her fingertips extending nanofilament-sharp blades. "Hundreds of thousands have to die just so the precious War Timeline stays intact? I've done the math, Marshal, and I'm sure you have too. The war ends anyway!"

The man shook his head. "I'm not a marshal. I'm from 2016. There's more at stake than just lives." He clumsily lunged forward, swinging the pipe -- where'd he even get that? She dodged and kicked, knocking him to the ground. "I'm done playing these games. This bomb is going offline and there's nothing you or anyone time-cleared can do to stop me." 2016? They didn't have the technology for time travel. What was going on here?

The man struggled to sit up, gasping for air thanks to his bruised solar plexus. "Stop! If you sabotage that bomb..." His lips thinned, his eyes pleading as he slowly got to his feet. "Pokémon will never exist. 801 unique creatures, over 7 generations. Millions of unique companions and travelling partners throughout history. Please."

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Pot Smoke Phoenix



Smoke 'em if you gottem!

joke_explainer posted:

Ria McLennan knocked the hidden compartment lose and cool air crisp against her respirator mask. She dropped down into the deck of the B-29 superfortress as it hurtled through the skies. According to the timer glowing softly on her retinal display, it had been 5 hours, 31 minutes, and 22 seconds. If the historical record was accurate, Morris R. Jeppson had just returned to the cabin after disarming the final safeties on the weapon. No one else would be checking on it until the drop. Stopping this genocide would be as simple as re-engaging the safeties, and then Nagasaki will never happen -- and the war will end without the deaths of hundreds of thousands. Her hand grew seams, and gently unfolded as she auged into her toolkit, approaching the primitive atomic weapon. She could feel the psychological weight of the weapon, a pure embodiment of the unbridled destructive potential of man. Though primitive compared to the nuclear weapons they'd design in coming decades, this was one of only two in the Surveilled timeline that was used against civilian targets. The Great Wars Injunction meant even being here was a capital crime, but if all went well there was nothing they could do to restore it, short of bombing Hiroshima itself, and she knew they'd never do it.

She got to work on the bomb. Primitive tumbler-key mechanism as the primary arming switch. It was all too easy, but she heard a noise behind her, and dove into a roll, popping up to her feet down the bomb bay corridor just as a heavy pipe swung toward where her head previously was. How could they have found her at this spacetime so quickly? She took in her opponent. A man, twenty five to thirty, pasty white skin, patchy wisp of a beard and slighty chubby. His gear looked very retro: Some gimmicky thin glasses with projected displays, what looked like an ancient laptop computer strapped to his waist with cords hanging off it and going to headphones hanging on his neck. His eyes looked wild as he stared her down. He didn't look like your average marshal, but they all have their quirks.

The man glared at her. "You don't know what you're doing. You don't understand the consequence of your actions here. I have to stop you."

Ria glared and dropped into a combat stance, her fingertips extending nanofilament-sharp blades. "Hundreds of thousands have to die just so the precious War Timeline stays intact? I've done the math, Marshal, and I'm sure you have too. The war ends anyway!"

The man shook his head. "I'm not a marshal. I'm from 2016. There's more at stake than just lives." He clumsily lunged forward, swinging the pipe -- where'd he even get that? She dodged and kicked, knocking him to the ground. "I'm done playing these games. This bomb is going offline and there's nothing you or anyone time-cleared can do to stop me." 2016? They didn't have the technology for time travel. What was going on here?

The man struggled to sit up, gasping for air thanks to his bruised solar plexus. "Stop! If you sabotage that bomb..." His lips thinned, his eyes pleading as he slowly got to his feet. "Pokémon will never exist. 801 unique creatures, over 7 generations. Millions of unique companions and travelling partners throughout history. Please."

https://i.imgur.com/QKTkerO.mp4
Sig elements by Manifisto and Heather Papps
Sig File protected by SigLock. do NOT steal this sig!

  • Locked thread