Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Alzabo posted:

As someone who grew up in a union household, I can say my parents have a lot of trouble wrapping their mind around stuff like unstable employment and 401(k) instead of defined benefit pension.

They are also boomers, so . . .

Does your mom have big tits?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


funny Star Wars parody posted:

after 4 to 8 years of Republican rulership we will be in Victorianesque working conditions with all form of collective bargaining and workers rights completely eliminated

You joke but 2000-2008 and the resulting 2010 governors races brought about the current neovictorian atmosphere, and people cheered for it as it was enacted.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:

no, you organize your fellow workers in bangalore and raise their standards of living, too

lol

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


I'm taking a big poo poo.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:


baseball players are unionized because they work in an industry dominated by a monopsony. there is effectively only one employer: the MLB and its cronies. even with the union, the bottom-end major league players make 1/100th what the top-end players do.


lol no. The MLB doesn't employ a single baseball player.

The MLBPA was formed to fight for the removal of the Reserve Clause from player contracts. Prior to that happening, free agency did not exist and players essentially became the property of the team that they first signed with.

The minor league teams are all staffed with players who are employees of major league teams.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:

all of the teams are franchises of the MLB. as you pointed out, they didn't even "compete" internally for talent until the union forced them to do so

i am not sure there has ever been a better real-world example of monopsony than professional sports leagues in the u.s.

Maybe, but saying that the players are employees of "MLB" is factually incorrect. Each of the teams is a separate business organization.

Hell, the real name of the Pirates is "Pittsburgh National League Base Ball Club."

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


It was about collusion, not a monopsony. Calling baseball a monopsony is factually incorrect.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


No. There are 30 separate buyers, which compete with each other for labor. You are wrong and you don't know what you're talking about.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Single point of negotiation is easier? I don't know. I'm not involved with that. I'm just pointing out that you are wrong and don't know what you're talking about with regard to the baseball labor market.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


bump_fn posted:

wtf is a monopsony

A market with a single buyer, which is emphatically not what baseball is.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:

the "market," such as it is, is itself a creature of the negotiations between the union and the single buyer, the MLB

if the MLB wished to end all competition for players once and for all, they could lock out the players and begin again without the union.

You are wrong. The MLB does not employ a single baseball player.

It's okay to admit you're wrong when you're called on it. Just admit that you don't know what you're talking about and move on.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:

the MLB does not sign any paychecks, it's true. nevertheless, all professional baseball players in the united states are employed by MLB franchises, and MLB performs all labor negotiations on the behalf of their franchisees.

they literally have an anti-trust exemption written into law for this poo poo dude.

No, the loving MLB doesn't negotiate contracts. They negotiate the CBA. The individual teams negotiate contracts.

http://www.spotrac.com/mlb/los-angeles-dodgers/clayton-kershaw-5273/

You have no idea what you're talking about.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:

unions are mostly good but the pittsburg pee rat doesn't seem to understand how and why unions are formed

You're really mad about being wrong.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:

the cba determines the terms of all contracts, just like the franchise agreement determines in extraordinary detail how the franchisees will behave

it's also worth noting the cba is, itself, a contract

a master contract, negotiated by a union and the mlb, determines the possible terms in all individual contracts

Holy poo poo, look at those goalposts fly.

You are wrong.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:

i don't think you understand how a corporation works. the "competition" between the pittsburgh pirates and the new york mets would be little different from "competition" between a pontiac plant and a chevrolet plant.

the important difference is that the mlb is a monopsony, so the artificial "competition" between franchises, enforced by a union contract, creates real benefits for the employees. it's a sham, but it's a valuable sham.

You do not seem to understand that the Pirates and the Mets are completely different companies that are not associated in any way beyond membership in the MLB.

The MLB does not employ a single baseball player.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


H.P. Hovercraft posted:

lol you think tori is arguing in good faith

He's completely wrong and he can't admit it.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:

i don't think you understand how a corporation works. the "competition" between the pittsburgh pirates and the new york mets would be little different from "competition" between a pontiac plant and a chevrolet plant.

the important difference is that the mlb is a monopsony, so the artificial "competition" between franchises, enforced by a union contract, creates real benefits for the employees. it's a sham, but it's a valuable sham.

I'm quoting this again because it's incredible how wrong it is.

Pontiac and Chevrolet are trademarks owned by one corporation.

The Mets and the Pirates are entirely separate companies.

You are, and continue to be, wrong.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


"all mlb teams are one corporation adurr durrrrr" - Guy who lives in a world where pitchers are getting $250M+ contracts due to competition that he claims doesn't exist.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


mishaq posted:

nbsd's 'tism is quite strong

It's the most internet thing possible in that he made a simple mistake when talking about something he doesn't know anything about ("MLB is a monopsony"), and instead of saying "oh, okay, thanks for the correction" he argues for two hours about it because he's terrified of ever being seen to be wrong about anything.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


A Pinball Wizard posted:

lol @ tori getting owned by nbsd of all people

Being dumb and wrong isn't owning anyone.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


jony ive aces posted:

on the contrary, i read every one of your posts itt and now i feel well and truly owned

Yeah, dumb and wrong people feel intimidated by knowledgeable people. Sorry about your life.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


lol at the Dumb and Wrong Advocacy Corps

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Yeah... IF YOU SUCK!

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Sniep posted:

DH's are an abomination to the sport and take away from the real true form of baseball and invalidate all of it

Ban the AL.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


"Baseball sucks! Waaah" - a baby with a thirty second attention span

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Suspicious posted:

maybe if it didn't take so drat long between pitches baseball would be more entertaining? good for highlights but lol if you watch a game from start to finish

Why? Between pitches is when most of the action happens.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Y'all are trying to watch it like you watch football. Baseball is a more subtle, nuanced, grown-up sport.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Less shameful than comics and science fiction chat.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


I bring my sports with me wherever I go.

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Notorious b.s.d. posted:

i barely know what's going on

this is why no one here likes baseball

it isn't football. quit expecting football. football is custom-tailored for short attention spans and people who don't know the rules

you've got people in this thread asking for between pitch time to be cut down when that's when most of the action happens for fucks sake

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


mishaq posted:

nothing better than gathering in a stadium to sit in uncomfortable chairs and drink $12 beers on a nice summer day

can't think of a better way to spend one

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


uh, then do that instead of doing something you don't like? No one is forcing you to like baseball, you loving goon

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


Bloody posted:

actually football is completely unwatchable without knowing the intricacies of the rules. its the most rules lawyering sport and absolutely nothing about the game is intuitive.

basketball is the sport for short attention spans and no rules knowing. its simple: you put the ball in the hoop, and its fast: someone puts the ball in the hoop every few seconds

Football is very easy to follow if you don't know the rules, because the field is one big progress bar

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Pittsburgh Fentanyl Cloud
Apr 7, 2003


mishaq posted:

i found a pic of stymie's car



To be honest, he's right.

  • Locked thread