Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Bape Culture
Sep 13, 2006

I can’t keep up I was just expecting to see cool valkyries and stuff like that. I’ll just watch vln again and forget all about it. They could have all just hybrid powered stuff and talked about future sustainability blah blah.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Space Butler
Dec 3, 2010

Lipstick Apathy

track day bro! posted:

LMP1H was cool when there were 3 competing teams, but like all sportscar stuff it never lasts. Everyone is cutting their motorsport stuff as it costs too much and it doesn't align with pushing for EV's idk. I don't even have anything against ev's I'd love to see a balls to the wall ev series openwheel or hybrid.

Weren't porsche going in on the LMDH which is like a hopped up hybrid lmp2 or summat? I really lost interest in motorsport over the last year lol

Porsche and Audi. It's kind of sad really, the thing is literally an LMP2 chassis with a 40hp off the shelf kers unit.

Theoretically there are still three hypercar teams, Toyota, Glickenhaus and Peugeot coming later. Four if you count bykolles, and I don't know quite what Alpine are up to. They're running one of the rebellion LMP1s this year.

Cygni
Nov 12, 2005

raring to post

Hypercar has been bad since the day they announced it, and Toyota deciding to trash the aero they were developing and bolt the P1 bodywork to the car instead because it’s going to be running alone in class really sums up how bad an idea the whole thing was in the first place.

MazeOfTzeentch
May 2, 2009

rip miso beno
The only real change from P1 is the single hybrid system (optional) on the front axle that is limited on when it can be deployed, less power, more weight, bigger cockpit (to sit the drivers upright and lessen lower back injuries), and a limit on aerodynamic efficiency (hard limit on lift:drag ratio)

The aero efficiency limits are what the ACO helped would bring more styling. They're still prototypes. They can have a road car chassis (because aston martin asked for it and then never came) but it's far cheaper and more efficient to use a carbon prototype chassis

Cessna
Feb 20, 2013

KHABAHBLOOOM

orange juche posted:

Formula E gonna pack up shop in a season or 2?

Okay, bumping for a dumb question about Formula E.

They used a shorter track at Monaco, without the hairpin, but this year they're using the whole thing if Covid doesn't cancel it. Why'd they use the shorter track before, couldn't the cars make it around that turn?

njsykora
Jan 23, 2012

Robots confuse squirrels.


Cessna posted:

Okay, bumping for a dumb question about Formula E.

They used a shorter track at Monaco, without the hairpin, but this year they're using the whole thing if Covid doesn't cancel it. Why'd they use the shorter track before, couldn't the cars make it around that turn?

I believe it was because Monaco wasn't willing to close off that additional section of the city for Formula E in its early years. Now it's gotten bigger and has bigger names on the grid they have a bit more pull. Nothing to do with the casino hairpin as far as I know, if F1 cars can get round there with how long they are pretty much anything can, I don't think it would've even been the tightest hairpin on the FE calendar at that point.

meowmeowmeowmeow
Jan 4, 2017
Track for sx tomorrow is looking pretty good:

https://youtu.be/F2WszMdDREY

Cessna
Feb 20, 2013

KHABAHBLOOOM

Makes sense, thanks.

If things line up and I can get a vaccine before July I might try to go see their race in Brooklyn. I'll have to right up some sort of anti-noise-cancelling headset to make it sound right.

orange juche
Mar 14, 2012



njsykora posted:

I believe it was because Monaco wasn't willing to close off that additional section of the city for Formula E in its early years. Now it's gotten bigger and has bigger names on the grid they have a bit more pull. Nothing to do with the casino hairpin as far as I know, if F1 cars can get round there with how long they are pretty much anything can, I don't think it would've even been the tightest hairpin on the FE calendar at that point.

I wonder how they're going to handle battery drain issues on the full track. The run from Portier through the tunnel down to Nouvelle Chicane will be one of the longest flat-out sections in Formula E, right?

njsykora
Jan 23, 2012

Robots confuse squirrels.


I think it's about equal with the straights at Berlin, and it'll have more braking than that track for regen too so shouldn't be an issue. Assuming the race actually takes place of course.

harperdc
Jul 24, 2007

Bape Culture posted:

I can’t keep up I was just expecting to see cool valkyries and stuff like that. I’ll just watch vln again and forget all about it. They could have all just hybrid powered stuff and talked about future sustainability blah blah.

that stuff was because what became LM Hypercar was being pulled in three or four different directions, and the ACO said "yes" to all of them:

  • Aston Martin wanted to race the Valkyrie (V12, road car, without hybrid) as-is because they wanted to play but didn't have much money
  • Glickenhaus wanted to join with something that matched the spirit of the 1960s, when these top prototypes could also drive off with license plates
  • Toyota is a racing team and has road-car engineering budget so they're willing to build something road-ish but really race-car based
  • others wanted to come in but have it be cheaper than what LMP1H was, and look more like street cars because marketing

So the Hypercar rules became a bit of a mess. They allowed for road-car based with or without hybrids, and race cars with and without hybrids. The Toyota is a hybrid, it's still under development but the Peugeot is also a hybrid, while the Glickenhaus is going without.

These will be allowed to run in the WEC, and possibly at some of the top events for IMSA, but that's still a bit of a question mark.

Meanwhile, we know that the IMSA LMDh rules will allow those cars to run in the WEC and/or at Le Mans alongside the primary job of forming the top class in IMSA. Those LMDh cars are, like current DPI, based off of LMP2 car chassis -- with slightly different bodywork, more for marketing than performance, and a homologated engine. Big difference is there will be a hybrid system - but a spec one, starting at about 40 hp, which should fit all of the chassis. The cars will also all be BoP'd together to ensure a close window of performance.

As of now, LMDh should include

  • Porsche, rumored to be running the V8 currently used in the Cayenne (and also the Bentley GT3...), with rumors also pointing to their factory team for IMSA being run by Penske
  • Audi, rumored to use the DTM 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder, and with various customer teams who have been connected to Audi in DTM and GT3 racing

Note that both have said they'll support customer teams, so that's a good sign for those who long for Group C/GTP days.

  • Acura appears to be next to confirm their LMDh, though whether that's IMSA only or also WEC is TBD
  • General Motors is expected to continue in IMSA and possibly going to Le Mans
  • Mazda has been quiet but could continue, especially if the Japanese arm wants to go to Le Mans again on a budget
  • rumors have circled around Ferrari, McLaren, Hyundai, and seemingly every other manufacturer. One potential hint: look at which LMP2 teams in ELMS and WEC have been 'loaned out' factory drivers from GT3 manufacturers.

The tl;dr is that with a more reasonable budget, less need to develop (which is what killed the LMP1H days), BoP to keep things close, and ability to race in the U.S., World Championship and Le Mans, it looks like the LMDh formula could be the right choice for this era. Especially if customer cars can fill the grids for the top class.

The downsides? Looks like GTE is dead man walking as a pro, factory-backed class. Porsche's out in the U.S., Aston's out in the WEC, and that leaves 3 full-time cars in IMSA and a small grid in the WEC. While they've gotten things controlled for prototypes, next question will be what the ACO does for the sports cars.

Dudley
Feb 24, 2003

Tasty

All of which means, why the hell would you spend any money on your hypercar when they're going to BoP an LMP2 in a dress to your speed anyway?

They would already have sunk a lot of money into the Toyota when this was decided.

It's a shame really, you'd get some "racing" sure but it's yet another series being transformed into effectively spec. For all the technical interest you might as well just mandate Oreca 07s and Lambo Super Trofeo cars and call that LeMans, at least it'd be cheaper.

Dudley fucked around with this message at 11:49 on Jan 16, 2021

harperdc
Jul 24, 2007

Dudley posted:

All of which means, why the hell would you spend any money on your hypercar when they're going to BoP an LMP2 in a dress to your speed anyway?

They would already have sunk a lot of money into the Toyota when this was decided.

It's a shame really, you'd get some "racing" sure but it's yet another series being transformed into effectively spec. For all the technical interest you might as well just mandate Oreca 07s and Lambo Super Trofeo cars and call that LeMans, at least it'd be cheaper.

I think this is a way to try and revive the event ahead of that centenary running, and I also think if they're going to have a true open prototype class again, it won't be with internal combustion engines - think Group C but with a set amount of hydrogen (or, more generally, energy spend in mega joules) for the race distance. That would be 'road relevant,' that would require some R&D again, and that would be attractive to both engineering and marketing for many of the OEMs.

There are hints that in 2023 there might be a Garage 56-style car running with alternative fuels, if they weren't so in the poo poo right now I'd suggest it's BMW running a hydrogen car, but I can see a few other makers wanting to do that.

Bape Culture
Sep 13, 2006

Glcikenhause has been saying he wants to do a hydrogen thing

Dudley
Feb 24, 2003

Tasty

harperdc posted:

I think this is a way to try and revive the event ahead of that centenary running, and I also think if they're going to have a true open prototype class again, it won't be with internal combustion engines - think Group C but with a set amount of hydrogen (or, more generally, energy spend in mega joules) for the race distance. That would be 'road relevant,' that would require some R&D again, and that would be attractive to both engineering and marketing for many of the OEMs.

There are hints that in 2023 there might be a Garage 56-style car running with alternative fuels, if they weren't so in the poo poo right now I'd suggest it's BMW running a hydrogen car, but I can see a few other makers wanting to do that.

Yeah, and I get RIGHT NOW is the wrong time to be asking people to spend.

But the thing is, it's kinda always the wrong time, especially as there are fewer and fewer manufacturers every year. Hell this week the entire Fiat and Peugeot empires merged, so it'll be harder and harder to convince them to compete against themselves.

Cygni
Nov 12, 2005

raring to post

Dudley posted:

For all the technical interest you might as well just mandate Oreca 07s and Lambo Super Trofeo cars and call that LeMans, at least it'd be cheaper.

With how much of a joke WEC has been for actual racing lately, that would be an extreme upgrade.

WindyMan
Mar 21, 2002

Respect the power of the wind

harperdc posted:

The downsides? Looks like GTE is dead man walking as a pro, factory-backed class. Porsche's out in the U.S., Aston's out in the WEC, and that leaves 3 full-time cars in IMSA and a small grid in the WEC. While they've gotten things controlled for prototypes, next question will be what the ACO does for the sports cars.

We've seen this story when GT1 died out and GT2 became the premier pro GT class. Everything should slot down to GT3 and GT4 cars.

WindyMan
Mar 21, 2002

Respect the power of the wind
Double post for Supercross! I will be stream sharing the NBCSN live broadcast on Discord as often as I can this year, including tonight! I'll start after the Chili Bowl stream switches over to MavTV and Facebook.

wicka
Jun 28, 2007


Dudley posted:

All of which means, why the hell would you spend any money on your hypercar when they're going to BoP an LMP2 in a dress to your speed anyway?

This is kind of a backwards question. Hypercar isn't failing because LMDH is an option, LMDH is an option because Hypercar failed.

harperdc
Jul 24, 2007

WindyMan posted:

We've seen this story when GT1 died out and GT2 became the premier pro GT class. Everything should slot down to GT3 and GT4 cars.

Of course, but it's a little different now considering the scope of GT3 use worldwide. But that doesn't mean they shouldn't go forward with it.


your friend wicka posted:

This is kind of a backwards question. Hypercar isn't failing because LMDH is an option, LMDH is an option because Hypercar failed.

yeah, that's a better way to look at it. despite the necessity of BoP, at least they'll be able to compete together.

Dudley
Feb 24, 2003

Tasty

your friend wicka posted:

This is kind of a backwards question. Hypercar isn't failing because LMDH is an option, LMDH is an option because Hypercar failed.

It kinda doesn't matter which way round, if you won't or can't have a technical series you might as well go all out on the racing without needing to BoP it into the loving ground.

harperdc posted:

yeah, that's a better way to look at it. despite the necessity of BoP, at least they'll be able to compete together.

One man's "compete" is another's "Take turns to be given the win" and GTE especially sailed very close to the latter thing a lot.

Feels Villeneuve
Oct 7, 2007

Setter is Better.
it's especially a problem in BOP series where teams have budgets and/or are manufacturers, where the entire series newsfeed becomes an endless series of BOP complaints and accustations


WTCC was maybe the worst i've ever seen of this, at it's worst, the series consisted of SEAT 1-2-3-4-5 one week, BMW 1-2-3-4-5 one week, Chevrolet 1-2-3-4 one week, repeat et al

algebra testes
Mar 5, 2011


Lipstick Apathy
https://twitter.com/EraMotorsport/status/1350881035190464514?s=20


owns

MazeOfTzeentch
May 2, 2009

rip miso beno
deeply

wicka
Jun 28, 2007


Dudley posted:

It kinda doesn't matter which way round, if you won't or can't have a technical series you might as well go all out on the racing without needing to BoP it into the loving ground.

My point is that most manufacturers chose not to spend money on Hypercar long before LMDH was a thing, hence LMDH. You're right that there's basically no point in choosing Hypercar over LMDH unless you're Toyota and you love spending money, but it was either this or continuing with the 24 Heures du Toyota.

Feels Villeneuve
Oct 7, 2007

Setter is Better.
I mean, the latter route would have been more keeping with history than BOP

Frond
Mar 12, 2018
Didn't Audi race themselves for like 8 years?

Brass Hand
Feb 27, 2020
I’m glad to have cars racing, anyway.

algebra testes
Mar 5, 2011


Lipstick Apathy

Frond posted:

Didn't Audi race themselves for like 8 years?

It changed, some years it was only Audis but at least there were customer teams, some years they'd be up against the Team To Beat Audi who would often explode in the race leading to a comfortable win, and occasionally they had a team put up a real fight and run them real close.

I think 2012? Where Peugeot finished second by 11 seconds having run nose to tail all race was spectacular.

algebra testes
Mar 5, 2011


Lipstick Apathy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01eWObrfgLk

Hypercar video confirming Toyota, Peugot, Audi and Porsche by 2023.

Cessna
Feb 20, 2013

KHABAHBLOOOM


Hell yes.

Feels Villeneuve
Oct 7, 2007

Setter is Better.

algebra testes posted:

It changed, some years it was only Audis but at least there were customer teams, some years they'd be up against the Team To Beat Audi who would often explode in the race leading to a comfortable win, and occasionally they had a team put up a real fight and run them real close.

I think 2012? Where Peugeot finished second by 11 seconds having run nose to tail all race was spectacular.

yeah, my first LM was 2005 and that one was an Audi semi-works team versus Pescarolo. Not exactly thrilling but it was still fun to watch.

IIRC some of the Pescarolos put up a decent fight before mechanical issues.


but yeah there's been several Le Mans periods which have been a single dominant manufacturer so having a 24 Hours of Toyota would technically be more "accurate" than running BOP at what is supposedly the top endurance racing event of the year

Basticle
Sep 12, 2011



https://twitter.com/EraMotorsport/status/1350908533169123336

:3:

orange juche
Mar 14, 2012




Owen's a cool kid, good to see a young petrolhead :3:

Basticle
Sep 12, 2011


idk how many people here took advantage of that half off for a year deal on Motor Trend On Demand a year ago but it just renewed for the same half off price for me :v:

meowmeowmeowmeow
Jan 4, 2017
If you aren't watching sx you're missing out, pretty good racing last night and shaping up for a very good season with a DEEP field in the 450 class, something like 7 previous 250 season champions in one of the heat races last night. Basically 15 dudes who could be a winner on any given night and a tight schedule that should give some good racing as the season heats up.

WindyMan
Mar 21, 2002

Respect the power of the wind

meowmeowmeowmeow posted:

If you aren't watching sx you're missing out, pretty good racing last night and shaping up for a very good season with a DEEP field in the 450 class, something like 7 previous 250 season champions in one of the heat races last night. Basically 15 dudes who could be a winner on any given night and a tight schedule that should give some good racing as the season heats up.

Lots of crashes too if you're into that poo poo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=610bKfV-Rjs

net work error
Feb 26, 2011

https://twitter.com/Ourand_SBJ/status/1352700248800579588?s=19

No more racing on TV I guess

orange juche
Mar 14, 2012




loving lol

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

wicka
Jun 28, 2007



Everything is moving to USA

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply