Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Syncopation
Feb 21, 2020
\

Syncopation has issued a correction as of 21:30 on Mar 22, 2023

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

mawarannahr
May 21, 2019

Judge Dredd Scott posted:

is the Seattle DSA better than it was a few years ago. i left because the # of sex pests, i got groped at least once at a meeting so i got the hell out

i know SA is relatively big here also but i cant say i know much about them beyond Sawant being good the vast majority of the time, but wary of trots because of the sex pest thing, also

1) It’s not better from how I first found it a few years ago.

2) Your experience will depend a lot on the branch and the actions you go to. It is more demanding on the average member than DSA. Although there’s always some drama going on, it’s usually on political issues and not personal. I have not heard of sex pests in the Seattle organization and I’ve only seen people interact respectfully toward each other. (My totally subjective spider sense experience — I got a “vibe” from ISO that told me to stay away; I don’t get that from SA. I looked into PSL, too, and it felt similarly iffy, even if I prefer some of their stances.) What I liked most by comparison to being a DSA member was the cohesion and the action orientation instead of endless debates, book-club-only comrades, and no shows. There’s always something to be done, and people will tell you what to do.

If you like Kshama, you like SA’s decisions (at least when it comes to governing a city and using the position as a platform). I left because I couldn’t get on board with their positions on China and some specifics about campaigning in pandemic times (which worked out better than I expected as I was wrong in my assessment). Check out one of their events online or IRL. These days there’s a focus on defending Kshama from recall.





Ps, it’s fun to be hooting and hollering in city hall when that was a thing

mawarannahr has issued a correction as of 10:24 on Mar 17, 2021

Syncopation
Feb 21, 2020

mawarannahr posted:

1) It’s not better from how I first found it a few years ago.

2) Your experience will depend a lot on the branch and the actions you go to. It is more demanding on the average member than DSA. Although there’s always some drama going on, it’s usually on political issues and not personal. I have not heard of sex pests in the Seattle organization and I’ve only seen people interact respectfully toward each other. (My totally subjective spider sense experience — I got a “vibe” from ISO that told me to stay away; I don’t get that from SA. I looked into PSL, too, and it felt similarly iffy, even if I prefer some of their stances.) What I liked most by comparison to being a DSA member was the cohesion and the action orientation instead of endless debates, book-club-only comrades, and no shows. There’s always something to be done, and people will tell you what to do.

If you like Kshama, you like SA’s decisions (at least when it comes to governing a city and using the position as a platform). I left because I couldn’t get on board with their positions on China and some specifics about campaigning in pandemic times (which worked out better than I expected as I was wrong in my assessment). Check out one of their events online or IRL. These days there’s a focus on defending Kshama from recall.





Ps, it’s fun to be hooting and hollering in city hall when that was a thing

genuine bummer about the DSA. i know its easy to dismiss them as cops/libs but i'd rather they be good, so its sad to hear. happily surprised with what youve said about SA though, i'll give it a look once i get vaccinated, thank you very much for this post!!!

Hefty Leftist
Jun 26, 2011

"You know how vodka or whiskey are distilled multiple times to taste good? It's the same with shit. After being digested for the third time shit starts to taste reeeeeeaaaally yummy."


bit e/n but i can't find any other place to post this poo poo

is there anything one can do to help with political burn out in organising? i organised with various different groups and people in my city for the past few years before i totally crashed and fell apart from it, both from physical and mental burn out as well as traumatic experiences. these days i can't get any positivity or joy out of politics, and i can only really find things to critique in movement work rather then wanting to participate in it and help build. because of past experiences, just the thought of doing organising again gives me horrible anxiety and makes me avoid anything beyond discussions and reading groups. at most i've been trying to run a few reading groups and slowly build myself up again, which is something i'm working on doing with good people.

if anyone has some kind of advice as to how i can get trust, faith and passion back in organising again, i'd really love to know. i miss organising greatly but i've got so many mental blocks that stop me from getting involved in anything again that i can't figure out how to move beyond.

kingcobweb
Apr 16, 2005

Hefty Leftist posted:

bit e/n but i can't find any other place to post this poo poo

is there anything one can do to help with political burn out in organising? i organised with various different groups and people in my city for the past few years before i totally crashed and fell apart from it, both from physical and mental burn out as well as traumatic experiences. these days i can't get any positivity or joy out of politics, and i can only really find things to critique in movement work rather then wanting to participate in it and help build. because of past experiences, just the thought of doing organising again gives me horrible anxiety and makes me avoid anything beyond discussions and reading groups. at most i've been trying to run a few reading groups and slowly build myself up again, which is something i'm working on doing with good people.

if anyone has some kind of advice as to how i can get trust, faith and passion back in organising again, i'd really love to know. i miss organising greatly but i've got so many mental blocks that stop me from getting involved in anything again that i can't figure out how to move beyond.

burnout is real, don't feel bad that you're experiencing it! take some time to yourself, talk to a therapist or another professional, maybe accomplish some personal goals. if, for example, there's some political writing you've always wanted to do, by the time you've finished it you'll probably be itching to get back out there and organize again.

The Saucer Hovers
May 16, 2005

why dont you join by frickin balls over here

Fortaleza
Feb 21, 2008

Yet another thing with no action? No thanks

In Training
Jun 28, 2008

agreed OP. it's good to be in a political org

Coolness Averted
Feb 20, 2007

oh don't worry, I can't smell asparagus piss, it's in my DNA

GO HOGG WILD!
🐗🐗🐗🐗🐗

Hefty Leftist posted:

bit e/n but i can't find any other place to post this poo poo

is there anything one can do to help with political burn out in organising? i organised with various different groups and people in my city for the past few years before i totally crashed and fell apart from it, both from physical and mental burn out as well as traumatic experiences. these days i can't get any positivity or joy out of politics, and i can only really find things to critique in movement work rather then wanting to participate in it and help build. because of past experiences, just the thought of doing organising again gives me horrible anxiety and makes me avoid anything beyond discussions and reading groups. at most i've been trying to run a few reading groups and slowly build myself up again, which is something i'm working on doing with good people.

if anyone has some kind of advice as to how i can get trust, faith and passion back in organising again, i'd really love to know. i miss organising greatly but i've got so many mental blocks that stop me from getting involved in anything again that i can't figure out how to move beyond.
Take some time to recharge, there'll still be plenty of work when you get back. Hell, I'm in the same boat. It's okay to do whatever little good you can in the meantime, if that's just occasionally buying a houseless person a meal, listening to a friend decompress, or just not harming yourself, that's fine.

mark immune
Dec 14, 2019

put the teacher in the cope cage imo
nice try fbi

Suspicious
Apr 30, 2005
You know he's the villain, because he's got shifty eyes.
wouldn't joining anything remotely progressive just be adding my name to a fascist kill list

In Training
Jun 28, 2008

Suspicious posted:

wouldn't joining anything remotely progressive just be adding my name to a fascist kill list

being spied on by your local PD is Pog

Coolness Averted
Feb 20, 2007

oh don't worry, I can't smell asparagus piss, it's in my DNA

GO HOGG WILD!
🐗🐗🐗🐗🐗

Suspicious posted:

wouldn't joining anything remotely progressive just be adding my name to a fascist kill list

If you remotely pass as a normal looking cis het white dude you'll probably be fine if you're not in an area where folks just regularly have accidents.
If you're black rip tho
like I've been recorded by the fash dozens of times at rallies and poo poo, but my nose is clean and I'm just square cracker with no criminal record and a white collar job

Coolness Averted has issued a correction as of 06:12 on Aug 24, 2021

Retarded Goatee
Feb 6, 2010
I spent :10bux: so that means I can be a cheapskate and post about posting instead of having some wit or spending any more on comedy avs for people. Which I'm also incapable of. Comedy.
im joining my local larouche set, op

croup coughfield
Apr 8, 2020
Probation
Can't post for 89 days!

Suspicious posted:

wouldn't joining anything remotely progressive just be adding my name to a fascist kill list

thats what got me into it but sadly im still alive

War and Pieces
Apr 24, 2022

DID NOT VOTE FOR FETTERMAN
Fight the TradCaths;

join the Catholic Worker Movement

paul_soccer12
Jan 5, 2020

by Fluffdaddy

Victory Position posted:

bumping thread, get invovled with SAlt or PSL, local orgs in your area

no

F Stop Fitzgerald
Dec 12, 2010

breadnsucc posted:

since some people are still being willfully ignorant re official organizations and just organizing, have some fun with this, i could go through all the super liberal garbage like greenpeace or indivisible or our revolution or whatever but lets focus on the favorites, at least in my neck of the woods

join dsa guys we can sit around and talk about electoralism for four years and then accomplish (????) Has DSA accomplished anything? I don't know because it certainly doesn't here in the PNW.

join sra guys we cant talk about anything political at all because we're too scared to combine our politics and guns because opsec(?????)

join socialist alternative guys we will get an elected official and then completely stop doing anything else (?)

these are organizations that are effectively politically useless in part because they are 'official' and incorporated under the law as Organizations 501cfuckoffs or whatever. They have strangled themselves by becoming an 'official' thing in the eyes of the state, as far as I can tell these groups mostly serve to siphon what little dollars (and time) the working left has into pointless bureaucracy, at least in my ~20 years of being an activist. Maybe someone has some nice stories from other places where these orgs have actually loving done something. And honestly, I may just be loving bitter that where I live these orgs are useless and full of garbage liberals that gasp and run away at the sound of breaking glass.

The only official political organization that I can think of that has accomplished any good is probably the IWW which has fairly effectively been helping unionize some small businesses, and my understanding is that the IWW relies entirely on direct action rather than political action to effect change

By contrast, something like John Brown Gun Club is not an incorporated "official" thing, it does everything SRA does(but better and more) and it very much combines political ideology in its mission of demystifying guns to the unwashed masses, and then actually puts that knowledge to use

or

Food Not Bombs which has been more effectively mutual aiding plus spreading propaganda since like the 80s than loving any left political organization I've heard of in the past 30 years(I bring this up because 'mutual aid' has become a hot topic among a lot of these garbage political organizations and I've sat through many a zoom call where people are trying to organize how to food distribution, when other people have been doing it for decades and better, and I'm like, why not just volunteer with Food Not Bombs or Egyhop(A local org that is better than Food Not Bombs)? And I just get silence.

The most effective form of political organization as far as I can tell is small, local, autonomous, groups, untethered from such simple ideas as becoming "official" or even tying themselves to "official" political ideologies, ie socialism or communism or whatever the gently caress other political organizations are wasting their loving time on.

lol @ this post

paul_soccer12
Jan 5, 2020

by Fluffdaddy
Gritty sez go to your next local DSA meeting

paul_soccer12
Jan 5, 2020

by Fluffdaddy

F Stop Fitzgerald posted:

lol @ this post

Why

F Stop Fitzgerald
Dec 12, 2010


check the username

mawarannahr
May 21, 2019


the author later did some newsworthy praxis

paul_soccer12
Jan 5, 2020

by Fluffdaddy
Oh lol rip

Buck Wildman
Mar 30, 2010

I am Metango, Galactic Governor


join antifa guys we can shoot some toes and then (?????)

BrutalistMcDonalds
Oct 4, 2012


Lipstick Apathy

quote:

demystifying guns to the unwashed masses

BrutalistMcDonalds
Oct 4, 2012


Lipstick Apathy

quote:

The most effective form of political organization as far as I can tell is small, local, autonomous, groups, untethered from such simple ideas as becoming "official" or even tying themselves to "official" political ideologies, ie socialism or communism or whatever the gently caress other political organizations are wasting their loving time on.

quote:

Thus the very premise of petty-bourgeois radicalism is that it is impossible to win the working class in the struggle against capitalism. From this it follows that mass concepts of struggle are not possible, necessary or realistic. This leads to actions based on small elite groups––or to individual action. Because this concept is not concerned with winning over masses, it promotes and condones actions that alienate masses. There is an inner logic to this path. Specific actions are taken because there is a lack of confidence in mass–in class–actions. These ill-considered actions result in widening the gap between the petty-bourgeois radical movements and the masses. This widening gap then becomes “proof” that you cannot win masses and therefore the line of conduct of these movements is justified. Each step leads to a further isolation. This is the inner logic of petty-bourgeois radicalism.

https://www.marxists.org/archive/hall/1970/crisis-petty-bourgeois-radicalism.htm

BrutalistMcDonalds
Oct 4, 2012


Lipstick Apathy

Retarded Goatee posted:

im joining my local larouche set, op
you better get to work on your verdi-tuned classical singing voice, leibniz

unwantedplatypus
Sep 6, 2012
What do people think about PSL?

MLSM
Apr 3, 2021

by Azathoth

unwantedplatypus posted:

What do people think about PSL?

They’re useless socdems like all U.S. communist parties are

unwantedplatypus
Sep 6, 2012
Can you explain your reasoning?

Honky Mao
Dec 26, 2012

PSL is more hosed up and more rapey than SAlt in my area. However SAlt are also huge dweebs and neither are very appealing

unwantedplatypus
Sep 6, 2012
What if, and hear me out, there was a party that wasn’t rapey, had an actionable model for growth, and was interested in expanding beyond large cities primarily on the coasts or lakes.

fermun
Nov 4, 2009

unwantedplatypus posted:

What do people think about PSL?

My opinion as a DSA member is that they are too small to effectively do much of anything, which is a problem you could potentially help with.

From people I know in the org, they have pretty robust and occasionally heated internal debate, people who remain with the org are therefore typically people who don't take that personally. Once they reach a consensus they are good about everyone acting together. They are usually pretty good about not airing drama on social media, which is one of the worst things DSA does constantly. They do some things I disagree with like run a candidate for presidential elections, which I think is a waste of their time, effort, and money. Organizing with them will take more of your time than DSA as they ask more from their members.

Joining PSL is better than not being a part of any org.

unwantedplatypus
Sep 6, 2012

fermun posted:

My opinion as a DSA member is that they are too small to effectively do much of anything, which is a problem you could potentially help with.

From people I know in the org, they have pretty robust and occasionally heated internal debate, people who remain with the org are therefore typically people who don't take that personally. Once they reach a consensus they are good about everyone acting together. They are usually pretty good about not airing drama on social media, which is one of the worst things DSA does constantly. They do some things I disagree with like run a candidate for presidential elections, which I think is a waste of their time, effort, and money. Organizing with them will take more of your time than DSA as they ask more from their members.

Joining PSL is better than not being a part of any org.

May I ask what are the pros and cons of the DSA in your view?

fermun
Nov 4, 2009

unwantedplatypus posted:

May I ask what are the pros and cons of the DSA in your view?

it's big, there are lots of members and so if a chapter is able to organize its members to do something, the chapter can accomplish it. you can put in as much time as you're comfortable with and so you probably won't wind up burning out.

that's a con as well, dsa chapters are often bad about getting all of their members to show up, there's a problem of a lot of paper members that pay dues but never go to meetings or actions or canvassing, etc. DSA is also big-tent, it's multi-ideology from socdem left, and that creates a lot of internal conflicts about what people want to do and there's a bunch of anarchists in dsa as well so chapters often try to do everything all at once with no effective organization about how exactly they're going to do what they're trying to do. dsa members also constantly post whatever interpersonal or organizational drama that is going on on social media. the chapter structure is also something of a weakness because there's nothing above a chapter than the national organization, which makes it harder to organize things between two chapters that border each other. you can also wind up with vastly different structures and goals between two chapters that border each other, like one might focus exclusively on trying to get candidates elected and another might try to help a unionization campaign. dsa candidates also just run on the democrat party line and they rarely go to dsa events if they take office and there's nothing that holds them accountable to what dsa as an organization is supposed to stand for.

there's a lot to complain about on how dsa is organized, but if you have a local chapter that is good, then it's probably very good. my local chapter has unionized some workplaces. we've passed a bunch of ballot measures and stopped a police union written one from passing. we have an elected member of the board of supervisors that is an active member that shows up to meetings, tries to do what the chapter stands for, and all his aides are members. we've written a ballot measure for this coming november election, and generally we punch way above our weight in city politics.

the organizational structure means that state assembly districts cross multiple chapter borders, so even my chapter, which i think is probably one of the best, has a hard time doing anything above city politics.

apropos to nothing
Sep 5, 2003
if youre genuinely interested in getting involved in a political organization you should email or message or call the organization or one of its chapters or sign up online or whatever and talk to someone about it because if you ask people online and especially in this forum you get replies like

SorePotato posted:

PSL is more hosed up and more rapey than SAlt in my area. However SAlt are also huge dweebs and neither are very appealing

which is nice because the implication is that organizations have the character or quality of being rapists and that getting involved in one makes you either more or less of a rapist, but never a non-rapist, which is a normal thing to think and say about an entire group of hundreds or thousands of people. 99% of people that you interact with online are weirdos who talk about politics online precisely because they dont have anyone to talk to about them irl. they all just accuse every group or organization of being rapists, being a cult, being problematic, whatever. just talk to an actual human being in the organization and a few times and see if you agree with their politics and methods.

The Voice of Labor
Apr 8, 2020

unwantedplatypus posted:

What if, and hear me out, there was a party that wasn’t rapey

american communists grossly misunderstanding what ho chi minh meant when he repeatedly admonished his party for not doing more to get the women involved

AxGrap
Jan 11, 2005

☝☯ Ŧ𝓤𝒸Ҝ 𝓨𝕠𝔲! 🐼👽
Seems like MN DSA is actually getting people elected which is cool so maybe I will try find something to sit in on. I do NOT want to talk to people.

croup coughfield
Apr 8, 2020
Probation
Can't post for 89 days!

apropos to nothing posted:

preferably a socialist organization. its difficult to get involved in socialist or left politics because there isnt a mass socialist or workers party in the US and so if we want something like that we have to build it. im a member of socialist alternative and would encourage anyone here looking to join a marxist political organization to check us out and feel free to pm me if you have any questions or wanted more info but also can look at our website: https://www.socialistalternative.org/get-involved/

theres also a whole DSA thread in this sub which you should also consider joining or looking into, theyre currently running a membership drive to reach 100k members. theres a wokrplace organizing thread which is pinned to the top of the sub forum. theres also a myriad of other unions, organizations, parties, etc. whos politics you may find you align with and i encourage anyone whos a member of one to drop their info and pitch into the thread or discuss them here. politics is (unfortunately) something you have to be an active participant in and the kind of organization necessary to effect a real change in society isnt one that you can just join, its one you will have to actively and consciously build yourself, so everyone go and do that.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

In Training
Jun 28, 2008

AxGrap posted:

I do NOT want to talk to people.

this doesn't work the word Social is right there in socialist

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply