Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
Randarkman
Jul 18, 2011

Blitz of 404 Error posted:

Pretty sure it was Ukrainian Spetsnaz

Them as well, but it was also some rapid response unit of the national guard.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Telsa Cola
Aug 19, 2011

No... this is all wrong... this whole operation has just gone completely sidewaysface

Blitz of 404 Error posted:

Pretty sure it was Ukrainian Spetsnaz

It was a mixed force iirc. Spetsnaz doesn't tend to roll around with tanks.

punishedkissinger
Sep 20, 2017

Comstar posted:

https://twitter.com/IAPonomarenko/status/1497381890386497543?s=20&t=mDiEV7BHn7G5XKl_uhtbtQ

Sounds like a LOT of fighting around the Kiev Zoo :(


Maybe an ammunition dump going off?

this has to be the only way a zoo could be more depressing

BIG FLUFFY DOG
Feb 16, 2011

On the internet, nobody knows you're a dog.


https://twitter.com/hayesbrown/status/1496710912648044548?s=21

A day old and you all probably posted about it while I was asleep but lol excellent bureaucratic trolling by Ukrainian UN delegation

ZombieLenin
Sep 6, 2009

"Democracy for the insignificant minority, democracy for the rich--that is the democracy of capitalist society." VI Lenin


[/quote]

Betty Wight posted:

Let’s also point out, for all the US’s issues, it’s military is battle hardened after literally decades of fighting. We have no absence of experience. There is no modern rival to the US war machine.

Oh, no argument; and as a reminder, on your typical day I am a Marxist who abhors what the United States does with its military, so I am not doing a flag waiving "USA! We're badass!"

I am just trying to offer a clear assessment of the facts of the matter. Putin's war has demonstrated the United States Armed Forces is orders of magnitude more capable than what most professional military analysts have rated the second best military on Earth. This has to be absolutely eye opening for a lot of people in the American, Russian, and Chinese governments for very different reasons.

CommieGIR
Aug 22, 2006

The blue glow is a feature, not a bug


Pillbug

BIG FLUFFY DOG posted:

https://twitter.com/hayesbrown/status/1496710912648044548?s=21

A day old and you all probably posted about it while I was asleep but lol excellent bureaucratic trolling by Ukrainian UN delegation

Yeah its old and pretty sure got debunked. Russia got adopted into the UN after the USSR fell.

Charlz Guybon
Nov 16, 2010
https://twitter.com/maxwelltani/status/1497299896398974984

cinci zoo sniper
Mar 15, 2013




ZombieLenin posted:

This pretty much should tell you all you need to know. The Russian soldiers involved were from the 11th Guards Air Assault Brigade. This is elite airborne infantry. The closest American analog I can think is that this would be like sending in part of the US 82nd Airborne Division and then having those soldiers get their asses kicked by Ukrainian national guard.

Kaufman said 31st was there. 11th we had 2 POWs of somewhere else.

Not to nitpick, 31st is flying Russian MARSOC.

i am a moron
Nov 12, 2020

"I think if there’s one thing we can all agree on it’s that Penn State and Michigan both suck and are garbage and it’s hilarious Michigan fans are freaking out thinking this is their natty window when they can’t even beat a B12 team in the playoffs lmao"

Betty Wight posted:

Let’s also point out, for all the US’s issues, it’s military is battle hardened after literally decades of fighting. We have no absence of experience. There is no modern rival to the US war machine.

This winds up being overrated. The US does have an unmatched war machine, but even so the lessons learned in Iraq and Afghanistan might not carry to the next war and reconfiguring training/tactics/etc. for the next one isn’t easy. The most battle hardened of soldiers our are probably getting out, suffering from physical/mental injuries, or are going to be aging out of being effective in line units pretty quickly.

We wage war with overwhelming combined arms. That’s the doctrine. And it’s recently proven to be useless in the kind of poo poo Russia is attempting right now. Punching a conventional army in the face during an invasion is a fraction of what’s necessary.

Kill All Cops
Apr 11, 2007


Pacheco de Chocobo



Hell Gem

Majorian posted:

Please don't make generalizations like this. It's extremely unfair; most zealous American leftists don't support Putin, and we're definitely better than the extreme right.

I don't see widespread condemnation of Putin in Our Leftist Forum. Quite the opposite, really.

khwarezm
Oct 26, 2010

Deal with it.

cinci zoo sniper posted:

Not that I have seen, but this person essentially says that there’s no absolute evidence to prove it. In absence of them having a way to get radio backups from Russian navy, there’s likewise then no evidence to disprove it. Consequently, what normal people should do is avoid writing 875 page thesis on the geostrategic implications of that verbal argument, and just move on. To discuss it at lengths serves no purpose other than to hear yourself talking.

As far as I know, the most relevant footage from that island that we have is a Ukrainian soldiers TikTok live stream cutting out shortly after something significantly larger than a firearm starts shooting in the soldier’s direction. Soldier ducks, and stream cuts out.
I don't really get the tone of this post, its one of the most prominent pieces of video I'm seeing floating around on the internet concerning the war so far and has gotten lots of people fired up. Is it really beyond the pale to ask about whether or not its giving the full picture?

cinci zoo sniper
Mar 15, 2013




Blitz of 404 Error posted:

Pretty sure it was Ukrainian Spetsnaz

National Guard Rapid Response Brigade did force Russians off the airfield, and VDV Spetsnaz was then hunting stragglers in nearby town and forest.

A big flaming stink
Apr 26, 2010

Omon Ra posted:

Yeah, this is absolutely a "masks off" moment for zealous American leftists. No better than the extreme right, just bloodthirsty, clueless morons all around.

i recommend you do not take seriously anything posted on twitter, and absolutely do not use it as the basis to form judgments about the sentiments of all leftists in america

Shes Not Impressed
Apr 25, 2004


https://twitter.com/KyivIndependent/status/1497389145760616448?s=20&t=OdvJoOBHKMYSGA0xWC0_sA

KitConstantine
Jan 11, 2013

Human rights watch confirmed that Russian sluster munitions were used *near a hospital in Ukraine

https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/02/25/ukraine-russian-cluster-munition-hits-hospital

*edited to near, but c'mon

BIG FLUFFY DOG
Feb 16, 2011

On the internet, nobody knows you're a dog.


A big flaming stink posted:

i recommend you do not take seriously anything posted on twitter,

No I refuse. the ghost of Kyiv is real, Ukraine’s taking Russia’s security council seat, and Ukrainians are tracking Russian troop movements by monitoring Grindr.

the popes toes
Oct 10, 2004

It doesn't seem like there is any shred of possibility that Putin gets anything he wanted out of this.

With a failed blitzkrieg, diplomatic and financial isolation, and now it seems clear, the promise of unending violent citizen resistence, what can he possibly salvage?

I initially figured he'd dismantle Ukrainian military and call it a day, just to present to the world as determined and dangerous. But now? For Putin? Nothing. What a miscalculation. He's finished. Not yet, but this will finish him.

CommieGIR
Aug 22, 2006

The blue glow is a feature, not a bug


Pillbug

BIG FLUFFY DOG posted:

No I refuse. the ghost of Kyiv is real, Ukraine’s taking Russia’s security council seat, and Ukrainians are tracking Russian troop movements by monitoring Grindr.

https://twitter.com/KrisGoldsmith85/status/1497360394570108933?s=20&t=2x7H1IJQZKYUEadn1lAywg

BattleMaster
Aug 14, 2000

BIG FLUFFY DOG posted:

No I refuse. the ghost of Kyiv is real, Ukraine’s taking Russia’s security council seat, and Ukrainians are tracking Russian troop movements by monitoring Grindr.

:yeah:

Randarkman
Jul 18, 2011

khwarezm posted:

I don't really get the tone of this post, its one of the most prominent pieces of video I'm seeing floating around on the internet concerning the war so far and has gotten lots of people fired up. Is it really beyond the pale to ask about whether or not its giving the full picture?

You should read the article if you haven't though if you are asking these questions. Upon reading it I don't agree that it calls everything into question like that tweet reposting it suggest, it mostly questions the chronology of events and exactly what happened when the Russians took the island and whether some recordings from the island (which it says are almost certainly from the island), which have it may have had the audio recording of the exchange between the garrison and the warship grafted on, though it doesn't appear conclusive in suggesting it.

OctaMurk
Jun 21, 2013

the popes toes posted:

It doesn't seem like there is any shred of possibility that Putin gets anything he wanted out of this.

With a failed blitzkrieg, diplomatic and financial isolation, and now it seems clear, the promise of unending violent citizen resistence, what can he possibly salvage?

I initially figured he'd dismantle Ukrainian military and call it a day, just to present to the world as determined and dangerous. But now? For Putin? Nothing. What a miscalculation. He's finished. Not yet, but this will finish him.

The OG blitzkrieg took like 40 days. It's been two days and the Russians are fighting in Kyiv, so their blitzkrieg is actually going pretty well even if it fell short of their wildly optimistic expectations.

KitConstantine
Jan 11, 2013

Russians trying to take another airport, hard to say how it's going

https://twitter.com/IAPonomarenko/status/1497389484362461187?t=09grdnywDQBLQolF1H72UQ&s=19

Also Russia was using mechanical turks to aid their targeting. Gives some credence to the claims I've seen that Russian saboteurs are marking buildings for airstrikes/specific handling

https://twitter.com/hiddenmarkov/status/1497351111656751109?t=WHIHzLIYsho7FnjVDBK0GQ&s=19

cinci zoo sniper
Mar 15, 2013




khwarezm posted:

I don't really get the tone of this post, its one of the most prominent pieces of video I'm seeing floating around on the internet concerning the war so far and has gotten lots of people fired up. Is it really beyond the pale to ask about whether or not its giving the full picture?

It’s definitely not beyond pale to ask that. It’s a relatively clear cut case of limited information availability - we can only reasonably confirm that Ukrainian soldiers told the ship to gently caress off, and we’re fired upon; if you believe Ukrainian government - that they are dead, and that the island is lost. No amount of further bloviating over 7 tweets is going to move the needle from “at least some of it happened” to “definitely true” or “definitely false”, so I can only ask myself why are they fixated on wasting their time on the question.

cinci zoo sniper fucked around with this message at 03:29 on Feb 26, 2022

Nessus
Dec 22, 2003

After a Speaker vote, you may be entitled to a valuable coupon or voucher!



OctaMurk posted:

The OG blitzkrieg took like 40 days. It's been two days and the Russians are fighting in Kyiv, so their blitzkrieg is actually going pretty well even if it fell short of their wildly optimistic expectations.
At the same time, :hitler: had three million men for the Battle of France. I do not think Putin has that deep a bench.

BoldFace
Feb 28, 2011
Yeah, there's no possibility of any kind of truce negotiations until Russia has killed the Ukrainian government and other politically important targets hiding in Kyiv. Unless there's a regime change, Putin will not be able to say that he has achieved the goals laid out in his speech.

Youth Decay
Aug 18, 2015

KitConstantine posted:

Russians trying to take another airport, hard to say how it's going

https://twitter.com/IAPonomarenko/status/1497389484362461187?t=09grdnywDQBLQolF1H72UQ&s=19

Also Russia was using mechanical turks to aid their targeting. Gives some credence to the claims I've seen that Russian saboteurs are marking buildings for airstrikes/specific handling

https://twitter.com/hiddenmarkov/status/1497351111656751109?t=WHIHzLIYsho7FnjVDBK0GQ&s=19

Seems that now would be a good time for Bezos to get some positive PR and disable MT (and the rest of Amazon) in Russia.

khwarezm
Oct 26, 2010

Deal with it.

Randarkman posted:

You should read the article if you haven't though if you are asking these questions. Upon reading it I don't agree that it calls everything into question like that tweet reposting it suggest, it mostly questions the chronology of events and exactly what happened when the Russians took the island and whether some recordings from the island (which it says are almost certainly from the island), which have it may have had the audio recording of the exchange between the garrison and the warship grafted on, though it doesn't appear conclusive in suggesting it.

Which is fair enough, I just want to be cautious about swallowing every inspiring story I encounter considering the vested interests various sides have in pushing them. Like I'm highly skeptical of the Ghost of Kiev thing and and in a lot of the internet that's been spun into some pretty wild directions, regardless of one's stance on its use for lifting people's spirits.

Fritz the Horse
Dec 26, 2019

... of course!

Kill All Cops posted:

I don't see widespread condemnation of Putin in Our Leftist Forum. Quite the opposite, really.

Actually, ADTRW posters have been quite unanimous in their condemnation of Putin. It's Coupons I'd be concerned about.

If you have concerns about what's happening in other forums, take it to the mods of those forums or QCS, thanks.

KitConstantine
Jan 11, 2013

Youth Decay posted:

Seems that now would be a good time for Bezos to get some positive PR and disable MT (and the rest of Amazon) in Russia.

To be clear, I was using mechanical turks as shorthand - it wasn't Amazon's platform. But this would be a very good thing, yes

hump day bitches!
Apr 3, 2011


There’s a whole lot of people ready to declare the war a failure 2 days into it, with the defenders fighting around the capital, doing all kinds of psychological pop culture hot takes, and with an incredibly thick fog of war and propaganda blaring full volume.

cinci zoo sniper posted:

National Guard Rapid Response Brigade did force Russians off the airfield, and VDV Spetsnaz was then hunting stragglers in nearby town and forest.

Vdv are Russian paratroopers. Russian special forces were hunting themselves?

hump day bitches! fucked around with this message at 03:09 on Feb 26, 2022

Kill All Cops
Apr 11, 2007


Pacheco de Chocobo



Hell Gem

Fritz the Horse posted:

Actually, ADTRW posters have been quite unanimous in their condemnation of Putin. It's Coupons I'd be concerned about.

If you have concerns about what's happening in other forums, take it to the mods of those forums or QCS, thanks.

It would appear that you haven't been reading those forums recently, but thank you for the advice.

Comstar
Apr 20, 2007

Are you happy now?

KitConstantine posted:

Also Russia was using mechanical turks to aid their targeting. Gives some credence to the claims I've seen that Russian saboteurs are marking buildings for airstrikes/specific handling

https://twitter.com/hiddenmarkov/status/1497351111656751109?t=WHIHzLIYsho7FnjVDBK0GQ&s=19

Google will do it for free.

https://twitter.com/RALee85/status/1497387050194120709?s=20&t=RDCY66qMLeT-1kvHQ_9kfQ

Cirvot
Oct 21, 2012
I feel like it's worth pointing out again that leftists being pro-Putin is not a thing in Europe. The only Putin support you will find there is among the far right shitheads.

So this seems to be largely a US phenomenon. Why this is I cannot say for certain but I would vager it has something to do with the US never having had a proper mainstream left movement. The US left is also a pretty young movement compared to the European one, which had to deal with and learn from these kind of situations during the world wars and cold war of the 1900s. A mature left would never take the side of the invading authoritarian major power in a conflict like this and it's quite hard to look at the US leftist movment acting so naively in the matter, but it's understandable in the way that the left in most of the rest of the world has about 100+ years on their US counterparts.

the popes toes
Oct 10, 2004

OctaMurk posted:

The OG blitzkrieg took like 40 days. It's been two days and the Russians are fighting in Kyiv, so their blitzkrieg is actually going pretty well even if it fell short of their wildly optimistic expectations.

Yeah, you're right. But I can't shake the feeling that, as far as invasions go, this has gone horribly (wonderfully) wrong for the Russians in terms of price and what appears that they will have to pay in the future.

Does anyone think if Putin knew then what he knows now, he would still do this? I don't think I do.

FizFashizzle
Mar 30, 2005







Panthers? Hornets? Ukraine?

Whatever

https://twitter.com/_jasonhuber/status/1497385235666907136?s=21

Randarkman
Jul 18, 2011

khwarezm posted:

Like I'm highly skeptical of the Ghost of Kiev thing and and in a lot of the internet that's been spun into some pretty wild directions, regardless of one's stance on its use for lifting people's spirits.

Ok... It's almost certainly people collating and exaggerating a number of separate incidents that may or may not involve the same person into a legend essentially. Happy?

Sir John Falstaff
Apr 13, 2010

CommieGIR posted:

Yeah its old and pretty sure got debunked. Russia got adopted into the UN after the USSR fell.

It did, but I think the argument is that the original permanent Security Council members were (and still are) specified in the U.N. Charter (Article 23: The Security Council shall consist of fifteen Members of the United Nations. The Republic of China, France, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the United States of America shall be permanent members of the Security Council.), so a later agreement couldn't really alter that.

quote:

But why did Russia get the USSR’s seat following its dissolution? In 1991, the Alma-Ata Protocol was signed by the majority of Soviet republics, declaring the end of the Soviet Union and agreeing that Russia would take over the USSR’s seat. Russia then wrote to the UN requesting that the name USSR be amended to Russian Federation and that nothing else would change.

International lawyers have questioned the legality of this and have debated whether the dissolution of the USSR should have dissolved its seat at the Security Council. This is what Ukraine is now arguing. The whole matter rested on whether Russia was the “Successor State” or a “Continuing State” under international law.

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/ukraine-invasion-should-russia-lose-its-seat-on-the-un-security-council

But ultimately, whether or not there's something to it, it's not going to happen, for a variety of reasons.

Sir John Falstaff fucked around with this message at 03:12 on Feb 26, 2022

Vahakyla
May 3, 2013

Cirvot posted:

I feel like it's worth pointing out again that leftists being pro-Putin is not a thing in Europe. The only Putin support you will find there is among the far right shitheads.

So this seems to be largely a US phenomenon. Why this is I cannot say for certain but I would vager it has something to do with the US never having had a proper mainstream left movement. The US left is also a pretty young movement compared to the European one, which had to deal with and learn from these kind of situations during the world wars and cold war of the 1900s. A mature left would never take the side of the invading authoritarian major power in a conflict like this and it's quite hard to look at the US leftist movment acting so naively in the matter, but it's understandable in the way that the left in most of the rest of the world has about 100+ years on their US counterparts.

This is not true.

A significant amount of both sideism and ”NATO causing this” exist in Europe at this moment.

Sephyr
Aug 28, 2012

khwarezm posted:

Which is fair enough, I just want to be cautious about swallowing every inspiring story I encounter considering the vested interests various sides have in pushing them. Like I'm highly skeptical of the Ghost of Kiev thing and and in a lot of the internet that's been spun into some pretty wild directions, regardless of one's stance on its use for lifting people's spirits.

Yeah, same. Speaking as someone from peripherical country that gets its rear end kicked by the world powers, that kind of thing is inevitable. Sometimes it has a grain of truth, but very often it's just something to let people feel someone somewhere if punching back and actually hitting.

In the occupation of Iraq, they had this sniper called "the lion" that supposed was killing US troops by the dozen and nobody could catch him! Who cares if they got rolled and have rude foreigners patrolling their streets and searching their homes, the Lion will get them someday!

Palestinians have had a series of heroic soldiers who managed to knock out an armored vehicle, or hang-glided into a israeli base and shot several troopers.

My personal hope is that Russia is bled white in this horrible bungle and becomes a spent force, meaning Putin's successor will have to give back whatever they gain in a sane diplomacy round in a year or so.

But it really looks that the second largest country of Europe, despite putting some good resistance here and there, has its capital under assault 2 days into the invasion. I'd be looking for any sign of hope as well, that the husk or an armored vehicle shown on Twitter was a big loss for the invaders and not just something their doctrine absorbs.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

A GIANT PARSNIP
Apr 13, 2010

Too much fuckin' eggnog


BIG FLUFFY DOG posted:

https://twitter.com/hayesbrown/status/1496710912648044548?s=21

A day old and you all probably posted about it while I was asleep but lol excellent bureaucratic trolling by Ukrainian UN delegation

Sure but China will veto this faster than you can say "Republic of China"

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5