- Eifert Posting
- Apr 1, 2007
-
Most of the time he catches it every time.
-
Grimey Drawer
|
I feel like we've seen enough of these guys to have a good idea of their trajectory and I'm bored, so buckle up people who have been around here long enough to look stupid.
Format:
Questions:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year? (Both, One, Neither)
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects? (Most 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 Least)
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum? (Goff, Wentz)
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
5. Do you believe this draft class taken as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
-5- Unquestioned franchise QB [Rodgers, Brady]
-4- Controversial franchise QB [Flacco, Alex Smith]
-3- QB purgatory [Circa 2014 Andy Dalton]
-2- Embattled starter, has been benched or shopped [Tannehill, Cutler]
-1- No longer a starter [Locker, Ponder, Geno Smith]
-0- Literally Jimmy Clausen irl
Goff:
Wentz:
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Answers coming
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 00:00
|
|
- Adbot
-
ADBOT LOVES YOU
|
|
|
#
?
May 5, 2024 23:37
|
|
- Eifert Posting
- Apr 1, 2007
-
Most of the time he catches it every time.
-
Grimey Drawer
|
Benne posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
One
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
3
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
Goff for sure
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Yes, if only because 2011 and 2013 are low bars
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 4
Wentz: 3
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Yes (Paxton Lynch)
Eifert Posting posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Neither
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
2 I follow NFL podcasts and read about them, but I haven't watched either play.
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Wentz The knocks against Wentz are overrated to me. Level of competition and arm strength are not good predictors of NFL success.
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No 2013 maaaaybe.
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Yes But probably not in the top 2/3
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff going conventional wisdom here.
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz I expect him to play longer than Goff.
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 2 I don't like the scheme he ran in college and I expect he will have injury problems.
Wentz: 3 I don't see him as exceptional in any way but I expect him to be good enough to stick.
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Yes I think both will be average so odds are one other QB will be better, no guess who, though
The Glumslinger posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
One
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
3
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Wentz
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
Yes
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
No
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 4
Wentz: 4
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
No
Coldforge posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Yes, Goff for quite a while.
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
4
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
Maybe Goff. Four years for sure, bit iffy on five.
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Yes, it's a pretty deep class, and the odds are with more than a couple panning out.
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Entirely depends on the offense they land in.
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
See above, but I've little doubt Goff will have a longer and more successful career.
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 5
Wentz: 4
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
No. (edit: and just so it's on the record, I think Lynch will crash and burn in the NFL within 3 years.
Metapod posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
nope
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
very low
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
yes
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
yes
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 4
Wentz: 2
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
lynch baring who drafts him
Kirios posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year? (Both, One, Neither)
Both, Goff more than Wentz...as a Texans fan I've learned to look at future QB prospects in the coming years.
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects? (Most 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 Least)
Goff - 4
Wentz - 3
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum? (Goff, Wentz)
Wentz
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
Yes - at the end of the day as QB prospects both of them would have been taken #1 in almost any year without franchise level QB prospects (Winston, Newton, Luck, etc.)
5. Do you believe this draft class taken as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Yes, I'm still of the opinion it's a good QB class.
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Wentz
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 2
Wentz: 5
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Nope - Wentz will top the others.
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 00:03
|
|
- Eifert Posting
- Apr 1, 2007
-
Most of the time he catches it every time.
-
Grimey Drawer
|
Chichevache posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year? Nah.
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects? I don't know poo poo, now let me tell you what I think.
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum? Yes, I would. Maybe not for the Seahawks in the first round, but for QB needy teams.
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft? No. I think the realization that even an average starter is worth #1 overall for a team that needs a quarterback didn't really take hold of the league until Cam Newton completely ruined everyone's expectations of what a rookie QB can be, and then the very next season the already historic 2012 class produced three rookies who had all time great seasons. The expectations are now completely different and youth, athleticism, and attitude (combined with cheap rookie contracts ) are far more valued than a consistent, mediocre, veteran *coughfitzpatrickcough*. Tl;dr, while I think Wentz has the ceiling to be a top 5 QB, I don't believe Goff or Wentz would have warranted a #1 pick on the majority of the recent drafts only because I don't believe GMs would have prior to 2013.
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years? yeah, lots of potential top talent in this draft. These guys will be faces of the nfl for years to come.
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year? Goff, because, and try not to laugh, I think the Rams are probably a better landing place for a rookie QB than Philly.
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career? Wentz is going to be a staple of this league for the next decade. I can see Goff being a top guy as well, but I think he is more likely to plateau early in his career and eventually bounce around the league as a journeyman. Point to Wentz.
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale: Goff: 29, he will be fine. Wentz: 558, he will be great.
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career? Christian Hackenburg, because when he leads the Texans to the Super Bowl in four seasons we will revisit this thread and you will gaze in awe at my prediction. Intruder will cede his power of moderator to me and the goons will hail me as I ascend to rule this forum. And, for my first official order of business, I will create a chat thread.
Bonus points for predicting the chat thread, all lost for Hack.
Cavauro posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
no
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
0
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
no
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
no
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Wentz
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 4
Wentz: 2
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
sure
blue squares posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
nah
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
1 out of 10
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Wentz
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
Yes
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Yes
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 89,100
Wentz: 4
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
No
aBagorn posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Goff, marginally
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
1
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Wentz
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
yes
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
yes
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 3
Wentz: 4
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Dak Prescott maybe
korrandark posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Yes
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
3
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Wentz
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Yes
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 3
Wentz: 3
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Probably not no.
No Butt Stuff posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
No
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
3 out 10
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No.
They would've been No 1 in 2013.
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
No
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
Wentz won't play
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
Wentz will eventually play for Doug Pederson
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: bad
Wentz: real bad
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Yes
Probably Dak if he finds a good home. Lynch with the same caveat.
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 00:12
|
|
- Eifert Posting
- Apr 1, 2007
-
Most of the time he catches it every time.
-
Grimey Drawer
|
fsif posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Neither
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
1
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
Yes
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Yes
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 4
Wentz: 3
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
No.
3 DONG HORSE posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
No
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
1
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
No
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 2
Wentz: 2
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Yes- Lynch, Cardale Jones, and Dak Prescott
Fabreeze posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Nope
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
2 out of 10
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
yes, because QBs are the kind of player worth #1 picks
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
nah, it'll be average
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff, because I predict he'll last longer
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: Journeyman, forever flirts with being a mediocre starter for a while
Wentz: Bust, lingers on a bench for several seasons
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Hackenberg because life is a cruel joke
This post is why he hasn't been around for years
parm basil posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
No. Not a big college fan!
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
Negligible since I only watch tape on dudes that might end up on my team
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Wentz
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No. They do not seem as ready to go as Newton did coming out.
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
An interesting question! Probably.
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Wentz
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 4
Wentz: 5
lol Alex Smith is not a four no matter what you think about him. You must be trolling goon sire!
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Paxton Lynch on the Chiefs gets a ring this year but no otherwise
I have to stick with my fellow Missouri Valley Conference alum! Go Wentz!
Fenrir posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
No
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
2
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
Probably 5 or 6 so yes. Neither would have gone over Winston/Luck/Newton/Stafford. Bradford is iffy.
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
As a whole, maybe. For QBs? No.
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 3
Wentz: 2
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
I want to say Prescott but watch, it'll be Hackenberg just because
zimbomonkey posted:
. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Goff yes, Wentz No
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
4
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
No
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No With the understanding that a number one pick should be one of the top 5 of his position, no. He isn't better looking than Luck or RG3 was, Cam was, or Winston or Mariota were. I probably wouldn't have taken him over Stafford. I don't remember what I thought of Bradford or Russell but I know i at least thought bradford would succeed based solely on how disappointed I am in him now.
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
No I think it will have more players starting overall, but the quality of their contributions will be less than many of the previous drafts.
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff The eagles need to shore up their horrible receivers or it doesn't matter who's back there. At least Goff will be have Gurley alleviating pressure.
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz If the eagles build around him he has the physical tools and effort and (I believe) capability to learn how to be a great NFL passer. of a great QB.
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 3
Wentz: 4
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Hackenberg The universe is Chaos and all plans turn to dust
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 00:18
|
|
- Cavauro
- Jan 9, 2008
-
|
can't believe i was 100% right. Thanks to everyone for playing my game.
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 00:20
|
|
- Eifert Posting
- Apr 1, 2007
-
Most of the time he catches it every time.
-
Grimey Drawer
|
General Dog posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
No
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
1
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 2
Wentz: 1
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Paxton Lynch
Raku posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Yes
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
3
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Not for QBs
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 1
Wentz: 1
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Jeff Driskel will inexplicably hang around as an eternal monument to Muschamp's stupidity
Logicblade posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Neither I'm an armchair scout and I only follow college ball when the senior bowl rolls around.
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
Solid 4. More knowledgable about Wentz than Goff though.
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff But both would probably die without oxygen.
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No but just barely. Both over Clowney (but not over Mack), both over Bradford, Jamarcus and Eric Fisher. The Winston draft is arguable, but otherwise I wouldn't.
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Yes. I think this draft has a lot of talented players who will make substantial impact on teams. It's a little suspect at some positions, but no class is perfect.
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Carson Wentz He'll be pulling a lot of miracles out of his rear end.
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Jared Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 4 on the cusp of 5
Wentz: 3 on the cusp of 4
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
I don't expect the odds to be high, but I could see either Kessler or Hogan having a surprisingly good career.
Kalli posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
Neither
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
1 - Passing familiarity based on seeing some other people show excerpts of film
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Goff
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
No - Either overall or for QB's
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Wentz - I don't trust Fisher to be able to develop any QB
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz - I don't trust Fisher to be able to develop any QB
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 1
Wentz: 1
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Paxton Lynch only because a friend of mine is a huge Tenn homer so I've had to hear a lot of him and watch highlights.
TheBizzness posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
no
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
2
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Wentz
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
no
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
no
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 2
Wentz: 3
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
yes
axeil posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
No
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
1, I am A Dumb on college football
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Wentz, because I'm a giant homer
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
Probably Not, but then again if you go back 10 years we have some truly atrocious #1 picks
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
No idea
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff, since he'll actually play
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz, since he won't be broken by playing in LA for his career
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 3
Wentz: 4
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
No because gently caress the Broncos and beyond that I have no idea who anyone else is
It's me, the blind Eagles fan optimist.
WAMPA_STOMPA posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
No
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
2
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
Only if I had a solid QB who could sit in front for 2-3 years
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
Unlikely
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
No
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Goff
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Goff
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 3
Wentz: 2
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Paxton Lynch because he's starting off with the defending SB champions and a strong chance to remain playoff contenders regardless of his performance, putting him in a position to learn in a low-pressure environment
Korranus posted:
1. Did you follow one or both of the QBs before this draft year?
No
2. How would you rate yourself as knowledgeable about these prospects?
Goff slightly, more on knowledge of the Air Raid offense and less on the man himself.
Wentz no
3. Would you select Goff or Wentz in a vacuum?
No, but if I HAD to choose I'd go with Wentz.
4. Do you believe either selection would be a valid #1 pick in five or more of the last ten years of the draft?
No
5. Do you believe this draft class as a whole will rate in the top five of the last ten years?
Average
6. Which QB will have the better statistical rookie year?
Wentz
7. Which QB will have the better statistical career?
Wentz
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 1 - Only because LA has Jeff Fisher's QB ruining rear end. Some physical calamity will happen to him as a result and he'll be released before the contact expires. He'll go on to make a very nice living as a backup.
Wentz: 3 - He'll be a decent starter, but unpopular with Philly fans who want something better. Wentz will get a nice big second contract somewhere else.
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
Yes - Paxton Lynch will be a franchise QB in Denver. I also think Connor Cook will end up in that 2-3 range.
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 00:26
|
|
- Vando
- Oct 26, 2007
-
stoats about
|
Remember when we all thought Paxton Lynch was going to be a thing? Heady days.
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 00:48
|
|
- Benne
- Sep 2, 2011
-
STOP DOING HEROIN
|
My Paxton Lynch take ... did not age well
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 00:58
|
|
- indigi
- Jul 20, 2004
-
how can we not talk about family
when family's all that we got?
|
Wentz rules Goff sucks balls
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 02:24
|
|
- Raku
- Nov 7, 2012
-
Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights with whom there is no variation or shadow due to change.
Roll Tide
|
*ahem*
nailed it
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 04:30
|
|
- bean mom
- Jan 30, 2009
-
|
wow a shitload of paxton lynchers itt
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 04:34
|
|
- WinnebagoWarrior
- Apr 8, 2009
-
I eat Rotheseburgehergh's like you for breakfast
|
We should make more of these, I'm very keen to embarrass myself in new and exciting ways
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 04:52
|
|
- Impossibly Perfect Sphere
- Nov 6, 2002
-
They wasted Luanne on Lucky!
She could of have been so much more but the writers just didn't care!
|
Paxton Lynch and Hackenberg lol.
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 14:56
|
|
- Chichevache
- Feb 17, 2010
-
One of the funniest posters in GIP.
Just not intentionally.
|
Anyone who said Paxton Lynch is a full-on retard.
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 17:02
|
|
- dirty shrimp money
- Jan 8, 2001
-
|
Anyone who said Paxton Lynch is a full-on retard.
that's insulting to actual retards
like me
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 17:32
|
|
- Eifert Posting
- Apr 1, 2007
-
Most of the time he catches it every time.
-
Grimey Drawer
|
real question: is that dog a treeing walker?
Yes but he identifies as a lab.
I'll use this template next draft for a similar pairing but a different position group.
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 18:15
|
|
- Vando
- Oct 26, 2007
-
stoats about
|
Paxton Lynch and Hackenberg lol.
I mean the Hack posts were jokes or "well he sucks but the world makes no sense so WHATEVER maybe he'll be amazing idk" takes but the faith in Paxton was very real and oh no I'm laughing again help
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 21:27
|
|
- LiquidFriend
- Apr 5, 2005
-
|
Paxton Lynch had some cool games at Memphis and heck I am glad he went to Denver and promptly never gave a poo poo.
|
|
#
?
Oct 3, 2018 01:50
|
|
- kalensc
- Sep 10, 2003
-
Only Trust Your Respirator, kupo!
Art/Quote by: Rubby
|
Coldforge was dialed in that day:
quote:
8. Rate both QBs at the end of their rookie contract according to the following scale:
Goff: 5
Wentz: 4
9. Do you expect another QB from this draft class to have a better career?
No. (edit: and just so it's on the record, I think Lynch will crash and burn in the NFL within 3 years.
|
|
#
?
Oct 3, 2018 04:46
|
|
- Vando
- Oct 26, 2007
-
stoats about
|
Come to think of it Lynch is probably the most crash and burn of any first round QB in a while. Even worse than JFF, which is saying something.
|
|
#
?
Oct 3, 2018 09:54
|
|
- Eifert Posting
- Apr 1, 2007
-
Most of the time he catches it every time.
-
Grimey Drawer
|
Meanwhile Hackenberg might be the new Jimmy Clausen for examples of a 1 out of 5.
|
|
#
?
Oct 4, 2018 00:16
|
|
- Adbot
-
ADBOT LOVES YOU
|
|
|
#
?
May 5, 2024 23:37
|
|
- syzpid
- Aug 9, 2014
-
|
Meanwhile Hackenberg might be the new Jimmy Clausen for examples of a 1 out of 5.
He's the first QB taken in the 2nd round to never play a snap since the late 70s/very early 80s. It's so amazingly bad I have no words for it. Plus considering he played for Penn State and was a Jersey kid, it's amazing the Jets whiffed that hard.
|
|
#
?
Oct 4, 2018 03:30
|
|
#
?
Oct 2, 2018 00:00
