Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Lugubrious
Jul 2, 2004

teekun posted:

That's exactly where I found the one and only beaver I've ever encountered in the game.

Head straight north up the river that forms the western border of West Elizabeth - there's a path right along the bank, and I found a bunch of beavers (and loving bears) heading north along it to the cabin with the US Army outfit scrap.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

The Berzerker
Feb 24, 2006

treat me like a dog


teekun posted:

Isn't that at the top of a huge cliff? Seems a strange place for Beavers to be hanging out.

No, it's near the river that runs along Great Plains.

D C
Jun 20, 2004

1-800-HOTLINEBLING
1-800-HOTLINEBLING
1-800-HOTLINEBLING
Red Dead Redemption: Epic Quest for Beaver

Mills
Jun 13, 2003

I just finished and is it me or is the 2nd picture in the OP actually Jack rather than John?

icantfindaname
Jul 1, 2008


BlazeKinser posted:

I think everyone's gotten that one at least once. One that I've been noticing more is that I'll be riding along at nighttime and there'll be a dead body just off the side of the road. Nothing anywhere near it, no explanation, just a black X appearing on the map and some dead guy laying there. The fact that it only happens at night is actually kind of unsettling. I keep wondering if there's some shadowy beast about to leap at me from behind a rock when I stop to check the body. :tinfoil:

Honestly, the more I play this game the more it reminds of the setting for Deadlands (a western/horror tabletop game) in ways. Something about this version of the west just feels... not quite right.


You have to collect them all in one session. It resets otherwise.

I like the one where 2 guys are fiddling with some explosives next to a wagon full of tnt, and then everything explodes like 30 seconds later. The first time I saw that it dawned on me just as it was too late...

A big dumb baby
May 2, 2003

Mills posted:

I just finished and is it me or is the 2nd picture in the OP actually Jack rather than John?

It's just you.

Jack doesn't have horrific scars all over his face

Angryhead
Apr 4, 2009

Don't call my name
Don't call my name
Alejandro




So is there any place you can play Poker for higher stakes than the 100$ table in Blackwater?

I'm addicted to it. (Mental note: never go to a casino in real life)

Lugubrious
Jul 2, 2004

Angryhead posted:

So is there any place you can play Poker for higher stakes than the 100$ table in Blackwater?

I'm addicted to it. (Mental note: never go to a casino in real life)

Sign up for Rockstar's Social Club and you get the Gentleman's Attire which lets you play $250 buy-in in Blackwater.

Lord Hydronium
Sep 25, 2007

Non, je ne regrette rien


I found the area to the west and southwest of the Pacific Union Railroad Camp to be swarming with beavers. Quite a few near the steamboat wreck, too.

But as one who only found two boars the entire time I was in New Austin, and not a single one where they show up on the map, I know the pain of random spawns.

A big dumb baby
May 2, 2003

Lord Hydronium posted:

I found the area to the west and southwest of the Pacific Union Railroad Camp to be swarming with beavers. Quite a few near the steamboat wreck, too.

But as one who only found two boars the entire time I was in New Austin, and not a single one where they show up on the map, I know the pain of random spawns.

I didn't think you could even find boars in New Austin. Weird.

a cyborg mug
Mar 8, 2010



Had a funtastic bug yesterday. I've been all through Mexico and just entered Blackwater, but I still hadn't picked up the courage to knife two cougars. Yesterday evening I decided to finally just man up and do it.

So I did. It wasn't THAT hard, after all, although I did die once during the quest (why the gently caress do those bastards always come in duos? gently caress). I unlocked the next hunting challenge, the one with 5 raccoons, foxes and skunks or whatever. Luckily, Rio Bravo where I was huntin' happened to be just teeming with those aforementioned skunks! Of course I immediately start blasting those furry little cuties to hell so I could skin 'em.

Except their corpses just... disappear. Literally the second the skunk's ragdoll stops jigglin', the creature disappears. This happened to each and every one of the 20+ skunks I shot. None of the other animals were affected.

The hilarity/weirdness of the bugs in this game almost rival those in Dwarf Fortress

Sankis
Mar 8, 2004

But I remember the fella who told me. Big lad. Arms as thick as oak trees, a stunning collection of scars, nice eye patch. A REAL therapist he was. Er wait. Maybe it was rapist?


I'm so confused about people having trouble finding beavers. Throughout playing I kept finding them along the north of the map without even trying. Is the spawn restricted or something when you get that mission?

BlazeKinser
Feb 28, 2003

SMEEEEEE!!!

Sankis posted:

I'm so confused about people having trouble finding beavers. Throughout playing I kept finding them along the north of the map without even trying. Is the spawn restricted or something when you get that mission?

It might be. I know that when I was looking for Red Sage for the Survivalist challenge I couldn't find that poo poo anywhere it was supposed to be, except way out in the middle of nowhere. After I completed that it was all over the place.

Mexcillent
Dec 6, 2008

BlazeKinser posted:

Honestly, the more I play this game the more it reminds of the setting for Deadlands (a western/horror tabletop game) in ways. Something about this version of the west just feels... not quite right.

The game does obviously have some of Cormac McCarthy's or Robert Howard's darker, weirder West to it.

Not enough exactly to be a real on-the-nose influence, but between some early interviews name checking Blood Meridian and stuff like (I Know You stranger mission spoiler) the Angel of Death (presumed) floating around there is a legitimate weird West undertone to the game.

Mexcillent fucked around with this message at 08:09 on May 31, 2010

milquetoast child
Jun 27, 2003

literally
I just beat the game and the last 30 seconds of the game are some of the best in gaming history.

It's just so good.

Pirate Jet
May 2, 2010
Do any other movies play at Armadillo's movie theater than the Medical Science one? If not, are there other theaters I can view other movies at?

Fuzz
Jun 2, 2003

Avatar brought to you by the TG Sanity fund

Pirate Jet posted:

Do any other movies play at Armadillo's movie theater than the Medical Science one? If not, are there other theaters I can view other movies at?

There's another theater in the last town you get to in the game. I just watched a fun little movie about the Women's Suffrage movement there.

ElwoodCuse
Jan 11, 2004

we're puttin' the band back together
Everyone mentioning their favorite westerns in this thread reminded me of the awesome video for Phil Collins' "Don't Lose My Number". Also because my Social Club avatar is Phil Collins from Vice City Stories.

High Noon. Shane. Once Upon A Time In The West. The Alamo. The 3:10 to Yuma. The Wild Bunch. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. A Fistful of Dollars. The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. Clint Eastwood. Gary Cooper. John Wayne. Henry Fonda. Burt Lancaster. Kirk Douglas. Robert Redford. Paul Newman. Steve McQueen.

Only registered members can see post attachments!

ElwoodCuse fucked around with this message at 09:01 on May 31, 2010

Mills
Jun 13, 2003

Hey You Pifuckyou! posted:

Had a funtastic bug yesterday. I've been all through Mexico and just entered Blackwater, but I still hadn't picked up the courage to knife two cougars. Yesterday evening I decided to finally just man up and do it.

So I did. It wasn't THAT hard, after all, although I did die once during the quest (why the gently caress do those bastards always come in duos? gently caress). I unlocked the next hunting challenge, the one with 5 raccoons, foxes and skunks or whatever. Luckily, Rio Bravo where I was huntin' happened to be just teeming with those aforementioned skunks! Of course I immediately start blasting those furry little cuties to hell so I could skin 'em.

Except their corpses just... disappear. Literally the second the skunk's ragdoll stops jigglin', the creature disappears. This happened to each and every one of the 20+ skunks I shot. None of the other animals were affected.

The hilarity/weirdness of the bugs in this game almost rival those in Dwarf Fortress

If you use a gun that is too big, the critters get blasted too much and there is nothing left to skin.

a cyborg mug
Mar 8, 2010



Mills posted:

If you use a gun that is too big, the critters get blasted too much and there is nothing left to skin.

The problem is I shot them with my revolver, and they didn't explode. They just died, had their ragdolly jiggling and disappeared without a trace.

AndyElusive
Jan 7, 2007

Hey You Pifuckyou! posted:

The problem is I shot them with my revolver, and they didn't explode. They just died, had their ragdolly jiggling and disappeared without a trace.

Skunks ragdoll-jiggle after you shoot them? Mine usually just...die.

THE BOMBINATRIX
Jul 26, 2002

by Lowtax

The Berzerker posted:

If anyone is having trouble finding beavers, try this area marked in green:


Click here for the full 1210x897 image.


It's technically not in Tall Trees, but I literally found seven beavers here (it was about midnight in-game, which may be relevant).

When in the game does that north east area open up? Right now, I'm in Mexico and I just rescued that chick from the cave. Am I close?

a cyborg mug
Mar 8, 2010



Alex DeLarge posted:

When in the game does that north east area open up? Right now, I'm in Mexico and I just rescued that chick from the cave. Am I close?

Uh, not even remotely close. If you haven't done any of De Santa's missions yet, you have like 90% of Mexico left before that area opens up :shobon:

Sankis
Mar 8, 2004

But I remember the fella who told me. Big lad. Arms as thick as oak trees, a stunning collection of scars, nice eye patch. A REAL therapist he was. Er wait. Maybe it was rapist?


You'll know when Mexico begins to finish, too. It'll become very obvious Plot-wise.

Bloody Hedgehog
Dec 12, 2003

💥💥🤯💥💥
Gotta nuke something
Is the 100% checklist on the Social Club working for anyone lately? It was glitchy and wasn't even showing stats for me a week ago, but now it doesn't even load and just throws up an error page.

Bohemian Nights
Jul 14, 2006

When I wake up,
I look into the mirror
I can see a clearer, vision
I should start living today
Clapping Larry
This game is so good, it's ridiculous. I've been killing myself to play it more, hell, even after a grueling training session I RAN rather than jogged home so that I could get to playing it faster.

I've only just gotten to mexico and it's starting to dawn on me just how big the game really is. For some reason, the map doesn't really do it justice, and even if it's not that HUGE, they've managed to cram it with so much cool scenery I just don't care.


One thing, though, is the computer REALLY terrible at playing poker, or does the game give you certain advantages (disregarding the cheating, of course), because I know for a fact that I am one of the worst poker players in the entire world, yet I still manage to win consistently when playing it in RDR. What gives?

Lugubrious
Jul 2, 2004

Bohemian Nights posted:

One thing, though, is the computer REALLY terrible at playing poker, or does the game give you certain advantages (disregarding the cheating, of course), because I know for a fact that I am one of the worst poker players in the entire world, yet I still manage to win consistently when playing it in RDR. What gives?

The computer will often make some pretty loving stupid decisions, like betting/calling your bet with nothing but a king high or ace high, even after the river where they obviously aren't hoping to get another card. Some people say certain NPCs have "personalities," but I don't pay enough attention to notice.

The liar's dice AI is pretty bad too, since they will literally never call spot-on, and often call you out on bids that are obviously not bluffs.

Crooked Vulture
Mar 26, 2010
Looking for a few quick ideas on getting 100% if anyone's finished that. Right now I'm at 99.5% and havent found anything to move it in a while. I tried going back to do bounties, and got a few in Chuparosa before they started repeating/not giving anymore %. I went to Armadillo and Blackwater and got repeats as well. I have all the species, challenges, jobs, gambling, and outfits. Did I miss a place for bounties possibly? Should I keep doing repeat bounties hoping a new one or named one pops? All 3 locations kept giving the ??? bounties. Also, my horseshoes winnings were negative, could that possibly be it? Even though its only .5% left, I feel like I'm probably missing something big.

Rusty
Sep 28, 2001
Dinosaur Gum

Martytoof posted:

This game has an awesome story for a horse riding simulator.

All joking aside though, this game is awesome, and that's just from someone two hours in.
That's what I thought two hours in and up until about 50% completion. Unfortunately, the game is pretty much exactly the same 20 hours in. I think Mexico really burned me out, because on completing Mexico and going to Blackwater, I don't have any desire to finish the story. It's repetitive, buggy and I don't really care about how the story ends. It's a great concept and I really enjoyed the mechanics of the game, but the fun really wore off quickly.

Anyway, it only took a couple hours to get most of my money back on Craig's List. If the multiplayer had any replay value, I may have overlooked the single player, but it's also repetitive. Anyway, time to read the spoilers and see if the story is in any way interesting. I think one thing that ended up helping in my decision to sell it was the "I know you mission". People here seemed to think it was really something special but it wasn't any more interesting than any of the other stranger missions.

Fidel Cuckstro
Jul 2, 2007

Rusty posted:

That's what I thought two hours in and up until about 50% completion. Unfortunately, the game is pretty much exactly the same 20 hours in. I think Mexico really burned me out, because on completing Mexico and going to Blackwater, I don't have any desire to finish the story. It's repetitive, buggy and I don't really care about how the story ends. It's a great concept and I really enjoyed the mechanics of the game, but the fun really wore off quickly.

Anyway, it only took a couple hours to get most of my money back on Craig's List. If the multiplayer had any replay value, I may have overlooked the single player, but it's also repetitive. Anyway, time to read the spoilers and see if the story is in any way interesting. I think one thing that ended up helping in my decision to sell it was the "I know you mission". People here seemed to think it was really something special but it wasn't any more interesting than any of the other stranger missions.

Mexico was nice for a change of scenery for me, but the story still moves at a snail's pace, and they blabber on forever. When not-Bill Hickock was lecturing me about Mexican politics every time we rode out for a mission I wanted to scream.

Mills
Jun 13, 2003

I can't be the first to find this but you can hog-tie someone, kneel down, pull out your knife and then slit their throat with R2.

Speedball
Apr 15, 2008

Well, while we're talking about westerns...

One western I've only seen bits and pieces of, but which I liked what I saw of it, was Silverado. There's a lot of star power in that movie; Jeff Goldblum is a wily gambler man, among other thing! Only problem is, Silverado is really long, so I need to set up a special time to watch it...

There's another that most of you guys probably haven't heard of. Hannie Caulder, starring Raquel Welch. A woman's family gets wiped out by three evil (and stupid) bandits, and she learns to be a gunfighter herself to take them down, being tutored by a surprisingly intellectual bounty hunter. It's actually pretty good.

Bandit: I heard you got smart!
Caulder: Funny. I haven't heard the same about you.

Bloody Hedgehog
Dec 12, 2003

💥💥🤯💥💥
Gotta nuke something

DeclaredYuppie posted:

Mexico was nice for a change of scenery for me, but the story still moves at a snail's pace, and they blabber on forever. When not-Bill Hickock was lecturing me about Mexican politics every time we rode out for a mission I wanted to scream.

Heh, they seemed to realize this as the story goes on, as you start to encounter more missions where they don't talk during the ride and it just gives you the option to skip to your destination.

a cyborg mug
Mar 8, 2010



Bloody Hedgehog posted:

Heh, they seemed to realize this as the story goes on, as you start to encounter more missions where they don't talk during the ride and it just gives you the option to skip to your destination.

You can skip any and all of those conversations during the game, you don't have to listen to any of them.

I've personally loved the chatter and have only skipped the rides where they don't talk anything. Also there seems to be quite a lot stuff they recorded, because during one West Dickens mission I somehow accidentally failed the mission right before the ride ended so that I had to replay it, and they actually had a completely different conversation from the first one! Neat.

I also love the amount of minuscule little touches in this game. For example, has anyone else noticed that if your character is currently speaking (e.g. Marston during those aforementioned rides, your character in multiplayer while taunting), it's not possible to whistle for your horse? Of course it's only natural, but I wouldn't have thought they'd pay attention to something seriously unremarkable as that. Although they could've used that time for ironing out some bugs but oh well

\/\/\/\/ They get better in my opinion, I don't recall being as disappointed with a Stranger mission in this game as with that one.

a cyborg mug fucked around with this message at 13:06 on May 31, 2010

Renoistic
Jul 27, 2007

Everyone has a
guardian angel.
I'm very disappointed at how lifeless and cold the stranger missions structure is. I just finished the mission with the cannibal in the hills and there's NO pay-off. I hogtied the guy but I couldn't carry him to the sheriff. I cut loose the victim but I get no thanks from him and his wife is gone. I don't get to tell the families of the other victims the bad news. It's unstructured and unsatisfying. Why bother with the introductory scenes if you're going to treat the missions like any other random encounter, Rockstar? Mass Effect was a game that at least tried to give every single mission, small and big, both a beginning and an end.

Crooked Vulture
Mar 26, 2010
Make sure you read the paper, there is typically a lot of follow up on stranger missions and story stuff alike.

Bloody Hedgehog
Dec 12, 2003

💥💥🤯💥💥
Gotta nuke something
Yeah, some of the stranger stuff is just left hanging. It was still early while I was figuring out the mechanics of everything when I cam across that church girl in the desert. When the mission ended I felt there should have been more I could do for her, so I hogtied her and took her back to town. Doing the right thing just got me a bounty on my head.

Boring
Nov 29, 2004

nuhhh
woo hoooooo finally found dogshit rock aka the treasure in map 5!!!

treasure hunting is truly the most gratifying thing in this game.

Spitshine
May 13, 2004
I may be bad, but I feel good.

Boring posted:

woo hoooooo finally found dogshit rock aka the treasure in map 5!!!

treasure hunting is truly the most gratifying thing in this game.

I'm still looking for that pile o feces :(

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Apocadall
Mar 25, 2010

Aren't you the guitarist for the feed dogs?

I don't know if its just me or it happens for everyone but (ENDING) When I went to go hunt down the guy for the final mission where hes duck hunting, there was a massive lightning storm raging. When it came time to duel it just looked awesome having rain and lightning adding to the dramatic effect.

  • Locked thread