|
ReV VAdAUL posted:Unless they're deliberately throwing the election this is dumb as hell. The public may not like Miliband but they'll hate the backstabbing lying politician that replaces him. The right wing media will make sure of that. I would guess they think they can keep their current poll standing and get a boost and a honeymoon period from a more popular leader. Instead they'll learn traitors aren't very popular. I can just about understand the argument that replacing Miliband with Alan Johnson might give them a boost - he's managed to create a popular profile for himself outside of politics, and that plus his background means he comes across as quite likeable and much less drone-like than Miliband and the other prominent members of the political class. However, that plan only works if enough voters understand Johnson in that way. Is he well-known enough and perceived in that way by enough voters? Or do most voters have little idea who he is? This is one of those things it's hard to judge if you follow politics very closely.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 13:23 |
|
|
# ? Jun 12, 2024 15:23 |
|
This Heat is always appropriate on Remembrance Sunday.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 13:27 |
|
Fans posted:It makes more sense for me to Vote Lib Dem in Brecon and Radnorshire than Labour. Labour's not done very well here the past few elections, it's usually a run between Conservatives and the Lib Dem's. Ugh tactical voting makes me sick. Have some loving integrity and vote for who you want to win for gods sake. Caroline Lucas got a seat despite being from a minor party, it is possible. Patrick Harvie got a Holyrood seat the same way. Now they're being heard and Green party membership has rocketed. The more places small parties manage to chip out of the system the more their policies are heard and the more likelihood of them doing even better next time. Even voting numbers matter, because if a party gets a ton of votes across the country despite winning few individual elections they have to be taken a bit more seriously. It's a slow process but it's the only way to break the ridiculous two party cycle we have now. Labour managed it at the beginning of the 20th C, the SNP managed it. It's possible. Just stop voting for the least worst guy who might get in over the best guy who probably won't.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 13:27 |
|
Continuing the playlist with the Banshees' Poppy Day and the Groundhogs' Soldier
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 13:59 |
|
Answers Me posted:So when did the theme of Armistice Day change from 'war is hell' to 'BACK OUR BOYS '? I must have missed it The Legion used Green Fields of France for one of their videos and cut the verses that explicitly state that WW1 was a pointless waste. They also sell "Future Soldier" T-Shirts and there's a lot of people talking about how soldiers fought for our freedoms with no mention of what freedoms were actually fought for in WW1. Every year it's like there's an effort to change the narative around WW1 from a pointless waste to the noble and moral defence of the British Empire that totally wasn't evil you guys.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 14:12 |
ThomasPaine posted:Ugh tactical voting makes me sick. Have some loving integrity and vote for who you want to win for gods sake. Caroline Lucas got a seat despite being from a minor party, it is possible. Patrick Harvie got a Holyrood seat the same way. Now they're being heard and Green party membership has rocketed. The more places small parties manage to chip out of the system the more their policies are heard and the more likelihood of them doing even better next time. Even voting numbers matter, because if a party gets a ton of votes across the country despite winning few individual elections they have to be taken a bit more seriously. Tactical voting doesn't matter much in Holyrood (Patrick Harvie's a list MSP).
|
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 14:14 |
|
Gonzo McFee posted:The Legion used Green Fields of France for one of their videos and cut the verses that explicitly state that WW1 was a pointless waste. They also sell "Future Soldier" T-Shirts and there's a lot of people talking about how soldiers fought for our freedoms with no mention of what freedoms were actually fought for in WW1. The first part of this post was very interesting, but you let yourself down a bit towards the end.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 14:20 |
|
bitterandtwisted posted:Tactical voting doesn't matter much in Holyrood (Patrick Harvie's a list MSP). Yes, I know. Point stands.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 14:21 |
|
Burqa King posted:The first part of this post was very interesting, but you let yourself down a bit towards the end. The British Empire was a genocidal and terrible thing that slaughtered untold millions.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 14:24 |
|
If we accept, and I almost do that we have reached a point where the majority of people vote for a party or perhaps in particular the party leader rather than voting for the local MP they favour then we can see where the problem is with Milliband. I mean this really should be an election Labour walk but this isn't looking to be the case and a lot of that seems to be because Ed isn't a particularly charismatic or rememberable fellow, so you can see why the party may want shot of him. However ditching him with less than a year to go before the election is totally absurd it leaves no time for a new leader to establish themselves and reeks of the party throwing the election, perhaps they fear the next governmental term will be a horrific one that leaves whoevers in charge unelectable for years and are trying to avoid that or they could just be dumb, who knows really.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 14:41 |
|
Gonzo McFee posted:The British Empire was a genocidal and terrible thing that slaughtered untold millions. Yeah, but it was our etc etc (Jingo was a good book and I really need to catch up on the Watch novels I haven't read) It is awful, but hardly surprising that it's going in this direction. It would be pretty hard to hold a correct remembrance day whilst also reserving the right to get involved in foreign military action when it suits us.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 14:44 |
|
Problem with trying to find a charismatic and credible labour leader is that they can only be so if they are right wing, because they are presented to the public by the media.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 14:49 |
|
I wonder if Lily Allen got together with David Cameron to discuss how best to use their dead children for publicity, given she's been weeping about her stillborn at every opportunity she can get this week. She got a new single out or something?
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 15:08 |
|
Goldskull posted:I wonder if Lily Allen got together with David Cameron to discuss how best to use their dead children for publicity, given she's been weeping about her stillborn at every opportunity she can get this week. She got a new single out or something? Jesus Christ, dude.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 15:10 |
|
Meet UKIP's new bestest buddy in Europe - the one's helping them get a shitton of funding:quote:Nigel Farage’s new friend in Europe: ‘When women say no, they don’t always mean it’ I could just bold the whole thing and cover it in
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 15:10 |
|
Junior G-man posted:Meet UKIP's new bestest buddy in Europe - the one's helping them get a shitton of funding: now see that may sound bad but if ukip hadn't taken him into the fold they'd have lost a lot of money and access and money and money so it was for the greater good really
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 15:18 |
|
Goldskull posted:I wonder if Lily Allen got together with David Cameron to discuss how best to use their dead children for publicity, given she's been weeping about her stillborn at every opportunity she can get this week. She got a new single out or something? Yo Lily Allen is definitely a total arsehole but this is far too far, there's a huge difference between being asked about it and deciding it's worth stepping forward to let other women know they aren't alone and using a dead child as a cricket bat to knock away all criticism ffs LemonDrizzle posted:now see that may sound bad but if ukip hadn't taken him into the fold they'd have lost a lot of money and access and money and money so it was for the greater good really I see you've been reading the comments section
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 15:40 |
|
Goldskull posted:I wonder if Lily Allen got together with David Cameron to discuss how best to use their dead children for publicity, given she's been weeping about her stillborn at every opportunity she can get this week. She got a new single out or something? I miss the stiff upper lip. I think when I'm PM I'll make public grief a crime. I think Ed Miliband would be fine if he was himself and not the committee-made protoman the party PR machine seems to think he has to be. I feel bad for him, in the same way that Gordon Brown was heckled by the media for utterly trivial things as he entered parliament, Miliband's getting the same treatment. I just wish someone would challenge this poo poo as it's released. Having a go at someone for the way they eat a loving sandwich? Is this seriously a metric by which we should judge parliamentary candidates?
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 15:51 |
|
winegums posted:I miss the stiff upper lip. I think when I'm PM I'll make public grief a crime. Miliband is legitimately crap though, "for work" and not for workers, anti-union, anti-nationalisation. He's a dreadful candidate but this coup is utterly ridiculous and it reeks of sabotage by either the media or Johnson, but I can't believe anyone in the party is organising it because it's such a bloody stupid time. He was always going to get outed because the unions hate him, but why now and not two years ago? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tsMHefCD34s
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 15:59 |
|
Junior G-man posted:Meet UKIP's new bestest buddy in Europe - the one's helping them get a shitton of funding: A libertarian who wants an absolute monarchy. Yeah, I think we're about done here.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 16:06 |
|
goddamnedtwisto posted:A libertarian who wants an absolute monarchy. what's more self-made than someone who bootstrapped out of a bloodied inbred vagina and made themself monarch? LemonDrizzle posted:The unions and their backing are the sole reason he holds the leadership. This ends the second they realise he's not nationalising the railways, as they've made clear on several occasions. They want him there because they think they can make him a puppet, it's not working. I don't think we even can nationalise anything anymore, the EU has some really dodgy regulations against that. e; Going to clarify I'm actually repeating something and I've not seen a source for that "no nationalisation" bit, because the only Brussels-related stuff I know from-source is where to get the best free lunch. Spangly A fucked around with this message at 16:13 on Nov 9, 2014 |
# ? Nov 9, 2014 16:09 |
|
Spangly A posted:He was always going to get outed because the unions hate him
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 16:10 |
|
goddamnedtwisto posted:A libertarian who wants an absolute monarchy. This is just typical leftist media bias reporting things that people in or related to UKIP have actually said in their own words. I mean, when someone quotes you verbatim, how is that fair??
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 16:13 |
|
LemonDrizzle posted:now see that may sound bad but if ukip hadn't taken him into the fold they'd have lost a lot of money and access and money and money so it was for the greater good really A real alternative to the corrupt LibLabCons.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 16:27 |
|
goddamnedtwisto posted:A libertarian who wants an absolute monarchy. http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Neoreactionary_movement
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 16:39 |
|
Wow that sperm thing is impressively insane.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 18:04 |
|
Gonzo McFee posted:They also sell "Future Soldier" T-Shirts I felt guilty about it though, and caved this year.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 18:17 |
|
LemonDrizzle posted:Surely a timebomb is something that you know is bad and are setting up just out of spite, though? If Mandelson was OK with five figure fees (and if you're OK with the tuition fee/loan system in general, I don't see why you wouldn't be), then there's no time bomb, just a continuation of established policy. Think of it electorally: Labour were leaching student supporters between 2005 and 2010, towards both the Lib Dems and Tories. By setting the review to report back after the 2010 election – which had, by that point, already been written off – you have a stick to beat the Lib Dems and/or Tories with. Basically, NOLS are loving nasty.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 18:37 |
|
quote:He hungers for what he says is a lost Europe of dog-eat-dog economic rules, the freedom to buy arsenic over the counter by the kilo, drive without seatbelts and give free rein to the aggression that he says made the continent great. “If someone gives money to an unemployed person he should have his hand cut off because he is destroying the morale of the people,” Korwin-Mikke said, adding that the state should not give anyone a cent either. “Europeans were very aggressive and now the boys are taught not to be aggressive … Give them the pistol, give them a sword.” Not many people watch Mad Max and think it a utopia So I take it he would be okay with a poor person getting hold of a gun, killing this guy, and taking all this property for himself? Seems to me the exact social 'order' he is in favor of.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 18:40 |
|
Spangly A posted:e; Going to clarify I'm actually repeating something and I've not seen a source for that "no nationalisation" bit, because the only Brussels-related stuff I know from-source is where to get the best free lunch. We can absolutely renationalise the railways, as the rails work under a contract based system. This means it's entirely possible just to wait for the current period to end, and then award all new contracts to a state company (i.e British Rail).
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 18:47 |
|
With parliamentary sovereignty would you be able to just say gently caress it and cancel all of the private contracts and renationalise everything? I think PFI contracts have a clause stopping this but wouldn't that also be over-rideable?
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 18:50 |
|
Junior G-man posted:Meet UKIP's new bestest buddy in Europe - the one's helping them get a shitton of funding: It's hard to believe that a single person could hold that many objectively wrong views. Gonzo McFee posted:They also sell "Future Soldier" T-Shirts and there's a lot of people talking about how soldiers fought for our freedoms with no mention of what freedoms were actually fought for in WW1. It's like they remember Wilson's line "Dulce et Decorum est (Pro patria mori)", but forget all the horrific preceding lines about war being nightmareish death. I recall hearing something a while back about them selling "fashionable" Remembrance jewellery, and glittery poppies (which is bad enough on its on), but I think it's the first I've heard of the Future Soldier t-shirts thing - that's pretty hosed up.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 18:57 |
|
Pesky Splinter posted:I recall hearing something a while back about them selling "fashionable" Remembrance jewellery, and glittery poppies (which is bad enough on its on), but I think it's the first I've heard of the Future Soldier t-shirts thing - that's pretty hosed up. Fun times.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 19:08 |
|
Gonzo McFee posted:The British Empire was a genocidal and terrible thing that slaughtered untold millions. Yeah what else is new in history? So was any given empire.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 19:16 |
|
tooterfish posted:
Disturbing.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 19:18 |
|
tooterfish posted:
Jesus Christ.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 19:24 |
|
ThomasPaine posted:Ugh tactical voting makes me sick. Have some loving integrity and vote for who you want to win for gods sake. If our voting system let me do this I would, as is though I'm encouraged to vote against who I want to lose.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 19:49 |
|
Gonzo McFee posted:The Legion used Green Fields of France for one of their videos and cut the verses that explicitly state that WW1 was a pointless waste. They also sell "Future Soldier" T-Shirts and there's a lot of people talking about how soldiers fought for our freedoms with no mention of what freedoms were actually fought for in WW1. It feels like this has been a post-2001 thing. I did a lot of Remembrance Day services as a kid, lugging a Girl Guide flag around at local parades and church services, and it always seemed more of a "Never again" thing. Lots of Wilfred Owen and what not on the horrors of war. I noticed just in the last few weeks that the Scottish Poppy Appeal is subtitled something like "Support Our Heroes" and got rather pissed off. For me, poor guys who got conscripted and killed are not heroes by that virtue alone. They were ordinary people who got forced into a horrible situation. And I don't see them talking about the guys who got PTSD before it was known about and got shot for cowardice when they talk about heroes either, but it's as much a day to remember them in my mind. And I am really rather pissed about Green Fields of France (I've been listening to the Corries version for like 20+ years). It's not like it's even an old old song that they could make claims about, the guy who wrote it is still alive and says all of the verses are specifically leading up to that anti-war message as a climax! We're turning into everything I've always shat on about America and their stupid military fetishisation and "freedom" nonsense.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 19:57 |
|
nopantsjack posted:With parliamentary sovereignty would you be able to just say gently caress it and cancel all of the private contracts and renationalise everything? Yeah they can do that. They can also legislate that profit-takers and landlords be driven into the sea. Never going to happen though. (That's putting aside the practicalities of such legislation, as it would strike pretty much at the very root of our legal system - if a Government can decide arbitrarily not to enforce contracts, contract law itself becomes effectively worthless and we turn into Zimbabwe with worse weather)
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 19:58 |
|
|
# ? Jun 12, 2024 15:23 |
|
goddamnedtwisto posted:Yeah they can do that. They can also legislate that profit-takers and landlords be driven into the sea. Never going to happen though. That's somewhat hopeful though, the political tools are there. I mean maybe after WW3 we'll get a new Labour party doing all the poo poo that needs to be done and then we get a good 50 years as the establishment attempts to take it all back off us.
|
# ? Nov 9, 2014 20:14 |