Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
The Before Times
Mar 8, 2014

Once upon a time, I would have thrown you halfway to the moon for a crack like that.
:getin:

Thanks for the game toml, and especially thanks for making me scum. FINALLY.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

tithin
Nov 14, 2003


[Grandmaster Tactician]



I called Lid, Splode, Mithranderp, Fruity and ODC (sorry odc) as scum.

well done WFD for flying under the radar, and boo to Gwyn for not posting enough to raise any red flags for anyone.

Also yay, I won an award. Now I'm going to policy lynch anidav all day ever day :mad:

The Before Times
Mar 8, 2014

Once upon a time, I would have thrown you halfway to the moon for a crack like that.
Well I guess I'll have to thank RNG for making me scum, but still.

G-Spot Run
Jun 28, 2005
You should have listened to me day roleclaim :(

Scum really did get the block and the bus though so nobody would have ever resolved the rest without some leaps of logic and roleclaiming

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

Also I think this list of Role PMs is complete and accurate

"Role PM sent to Gwynplaine“ posted:

You are Corrupted Waluigi!



You are Wario's mirror. But you are also Luigi's mirror. But Luigi himself is a mirror of Mario! You are a pure signifier, detatched from the signified. You are Deconstruction, you are Différance, you are pretty much Derrida himself. Only you are also HIS mirror, for he did not have so splendid a moustache.

You are a Corrupted Role Blocker! Each night you may perform the following action: Prevent a targeted player from performing any night actions.

You win when the Clean players are all eliminated, or when the Corrupted players control enough votes to ensure that this happens. (You win whether you are alive or not.)

Your Corrupted teammates are Lid (Mario), Fruity Gordo (Princess Daisy), Mithranderp (Yoshi), Splode (Wario), Whats For Dinner (Rosalina).

Each night your team may select a member of that team. That person may perform the following night action: Target a player and kill them. (A player cannot perform both this action and another action.)

You may talk to your teammates out of thread! The link to the scumdoc is https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kv_Bk77rnfJg8PnrG1JyNHoiaut3OVmUCEbTRPMWAVU/edit#gid=0

"Role PM sent to Lid“ posted:

You are Corrupted Mario!



Ever since being portrayed by Bob Hoskins, way back in 1993, you harbour a secret shame. Sure, you've still got it; you can huff mushrooms with the best of them. But it just doesn't feel quite as good any more. The magic is gone. One of these days, when you're not busy rescuing Princess Peach or figuring out how to navigate both 2D and 3D spaces without losing your loving mind, you're going to build a time machine, travel to a time when Bob was still alive, find him, and loving kill him.

You are a Corrupted Bus Driver! Each night you may perform the following action: Choose two players; all night actions performed on one of these players happens to the other, and vice versa.

You win when the Clean players are all eliminated, or when the Corrupted players control enough votes to ensure that this happens. (You win whether you are alive or not.)

Your Corrupted teammates are Fruity Gordo (Princess Daisy), Gwynplaine (Waluigi), Mithranderp (Yoshi), Splode (Wario), Whats For Dinner (Rosalina).

Each night your team may select a member of that team. That person may perform the following night action: Target a player and kill them. (A player cannot perform both this action and another action.)

You may talk to your teammates out of thread! The link to the scumdoc is https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kv_Bk77rnfJg8PnrG1JyNHoiaut3OVmUCEbTRPMWAVU/edit#gid=0

"Role PM sent to Fruity Gordo“ posted:

You are Corrupted Princess Daisy!



You stay out too late. Got nothing in your brain. At least that's what people say. But if only they knew the truth; if only they knew that you, Princess Daisy, are single-handedly responsible for writing (and sometimes even singing) roughly 90% of the #1 chart-topping club banger pop songs of the last 20 years.

You are a Corrupted Labrador! You are so loyal that you are prohibited from lynching one of your Corrupted teammates. If you do this, you will be modkilled. (You are lynching the player only if you are voting for them when they are lynched. You will not be modkilled only for voting for a Corrupted teammate, but you must not be voting for them when they are lynched.)

Your Corrupted teammates are Gwynplaine (Waluigi), Lid (Mario), Mithranderp (Yoshi), Splode (Wario), Whats For Dinner (Rosalina).

Each night your team may select a member of that team. That person may perform the following night action: Target a player and kill them. (A player cannot perform both this action and another action.)

You may talk to your teammates out of thread! The link to the scumdoc is https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kv_Bk77rnfJg8PnrG1JyNHoiaut3OVmUCEbTRPMWAVU/edit#gid=0

"Role PM sent to Splode“ posted:

You are Corrupted Wario!



Your life is legitimately really tough. It's taken you many years to convince Nintendo to render your moustache in sufficient detail, and even now you're not 100% convinced they've really nailed it. You also take issue with how all their promo materials portray you as, let's be honest, a little bit rapey. Most of all, though, you can't believe they thought you could be bought off and silenced with Wario Ware. I mean, Christ, they haven't killed all your pride. Not yet.

You are a Corrupted Inkbomb! If you are lynched or otherwise killed, no one can be killed on the following night.

Your Corrupted teammates are Gwynplaine (Waluigi), Fruity Gordo (Princess Daisy), Lid (Mario), Mithranderp (Yoshi), Whats For Dinner (Rosalina).

Each night your team may select a member of that team. That person may perform the following night action: Target a player and kill them. (A player cannot perform both this action and another action.)

You may talk to your teammates out of thread! The link to the scumdoc is https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kv_Bk77rnfJg8PnrG1JyNHoiaut3OVmUCEbTRPMWAVU/edit#gid=0

"Role PM sent to whats for dinner“ posted:

You are Corrupted Rosalina!



As the saying goes, "Rosalina ain't nothin' to gently caress with." You've routinely negotiated higher salaries than most others on the Mario cast, and without a single hair falling out of place. They're all eating out of your hand. And not once have you had to follow through on any of your threats to have their family members murdered.

You are a Corrupted Commuter! Each night you may perform the following action: Leave the game. On that night, no actions can be performed on you by any other player.

You win when the Clean players are all eliminated, or when the Corrupted players control enough votes to ensure that this happens. (You win whether you are alive or not.)

Your Corrupted teammates are Fruity Gordo (Princess Daisy), Gwynplaine (Waluigi), Lid (Mario), Mithranderp (Yoshi), Splode (Wario).

Each night your team may select a member of that team. That person may perform the following night action: Target a player and kill them. (A player cannot perform both this action and another action.)

You may talk to your teammates out of thread! The link to the scumdoc is https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kv_Bk77rnfJg8PnrG1JyNHoiaut3OVmUCEbTRPMWAVU/edit#gid=0

"Role PM sent to Anidav“ posted:

You are Corrupted Toadette!



You are Corrupted Toadette. Why, yes, as it happens, this is absolutely the castle you're looking for, Mario, you coarse-handed Mediterranean stud. Forget that stuck up monarchical frou-frou bitch and help put the "fun" back in "fungus". What? Not your type? WHY YOU GREASY LITTLE EURO VAGRANT, I WILL gently caress YOUR poo poo UP

You are a Corrupted Vigilante! Each odd-numbered night you may perform the following action: Target a player and kill them.

You win when the Clean players are all eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Mithranderp“ posted:

You are Corrupted Yoshi!



"My desires are unconventional," he said. "So show me," you said. And then he brought out the saddle. Why is it always the loving saddle. You're not a bloody horse. Jesus Christ.

You are an ordinary Corrupted player!

You win when the Clean players are all eliminated, or when the Corrupted players control enough votes to ensure that this happens. (You win whether you are alive or not.)

Your Corrupted teammates are Fruity Gordo (Princess Daisy), Gwynplaine (Waluigi), Lid (Mario), Splode (Wario), Whats For Dinner (Rosalina).

Each night your team may select a member of that team. That person may perform the following night action: Target a player and kill them. (A player cannot perform both this action and another action.)

You may talk to your teammates out of thread! The link to the scumdoc is https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kv_Bk77rnfJg8PnrG1JyNHoiaut3OVmUCEbTRPMWAVU/edit#gid=0

"Role PM sent to Kommando“ posted:

You are Bob Omb!



Live. Die. Repeat. That's all there is for you. Some tell tales of a lush landscape, to be taken in quickly or at leisure. But you do not have the choice. It's the same every single time: Run around like a god damned idiot and then explode, probably ruining some poor bastard's game in the process. One of these days you'd like to try your hand at gardening.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a Beloved Princess! If you are lynched, the next day phase will be skipped.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Sulla-Marius 88“ posted:

You are the Golden Mushroom!



WAAAAAAHHHHHEEEYYYY AIIIII YI YI YI YI YOU ARE GOOOOOOOOOOOLDEN MUSHROOOOOOOOOM AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH. You are literally the face of recreational mushroom use in the Mushroom Kingdom.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are an Innocent Child! Only once during this game, you may perform the following night action: Have the moderator declare at the start of the following day that you are not Corrupted. However, you may only do this if during the previous day you did not cast a vote.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Tommofork and then Bell Jar“ posted:

You are Princess Peach!



Anita Sarkeesian says it's emblematic of a toxic culture. Some say it's just bad luck. Your shrink says it's some kind of Munchausen's syndrome. Whatever the case, one thing's for drat sure: You're sick and loving tired of being abducted and rescued. poo poo gets old. And Mario's not even that good at it. Sometimes you swear he's more interested in collecting every gold star along the way.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a Friendly Neighbour! Each night you may perform the following action: Target a player and have the moderator PM that player, declaring that you are not Corrupted.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Bifauxnen“ posted:

You are Bullet Bill!



You were born to ride. Your life is like a Bruce Springsteen song. A good one that everyone knows the chorus to, about living fast and dying young, not one of those depressing ones about the deindustrialisation of middle America.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a Catholic! You will kill yourself out of shame and guilt if you lynch 3 other Clean players. (You are lynching the player only if you are voting for them when they are lynched.)

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to MysticalMachineGun“ posted:

You are a Goomba!



You are a Goomba. You've never quite been the same since taking two fat little plumber feet straight to the dome. You aren't a real cop, but they play a lot of Law & Order reruns at the nursing home where you and the rest of your mildly addled Goomba compatriots live out their days. On good days, the haze clears, and your thirst for justice is palpable, or maybe you just want a glass of orange juice. You really love orange juice.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a Cop! Each night you may perform the following action: Target a player and have the moderator PM you that player's alignment.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Matthew Beet“ posted:

You are Thwomp!



You've wound up working for Nintendo ever since failing to secure that role as Thor's hammer. You really wanted it, and they really wanted to make it work, but, in the end, they just couldn't get a handle on you.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a Deputy Cop! You do not currently have any night actions that you may perform, but this may change.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Gough Suppressant“ posted:

You are Luigi!



You love Mario like, well, a brother, but you are sick and tired of his antics. While you slave days with your arm down a U-bend and nights at Mushroomboro Medical School, that jackass goes to one union mandated first aid training seminar and the next thing you know he's offering people kidney transplants like it's going out of style. That stethoscope is plainly made out of cardboard, but nobody listens. You can't stand idly by while the good name of the profession is besmirched by his antics. You're a doctor, goddamnit, act like it.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a Doctor! Each night you may perform the following action: Target a player; that player cannot be killed that night.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to everythingWasBees“ posted:

You are Blue Spiny Shell!



"We knew the world would not be the same. A few people laughed, a few people cried, most people were silent. I remembered the line from the Hindu scripture, the Bhagavad-Gita; Vishnu is trying to persuade the Prince that he should do his duty and, to impress him, takes on his multi-armed form and says, "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds." I suppose we all thought that, one way or another." - Spiny Blue Shell, excerpted from Mushroom-People Magazine

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Tirade“ posted:

You are Blooper!



Everyone hates you. You've tried time and time to explain, "Bloopers gotta bloop", which is why now you often take the train back to Blooperville at night. Mrs Blooper has suggested that people just don't know the real you, and that they'll warm up with time, but after that last fifty kart pile up on the interstate, you aren't so sure.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a Commuter! Each night you may perform the following action: Leave the game. You may not be target that night.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Tithin“ posted:

You are Chain Chomp!



You love charts, graphs, spreadsheets, and stamp collecting. Chomping is just something you did at bars and clubs during college to get by, because people are so quick to stereotype and it's the only work a young black ball of teeth and fury on a stick can get without a diploma, but now everyone thinks it's, like, your Thing, and it's, like, totally not.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a 1-shot Statistician! Once during the game, you may perform the following action at night: Require the moderator post a list of half the living players (rounded up), including at least one Corrupted player, at the start of the next day. The moderator must declare that the list contains at least one Corrupted player.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to thatbastardken“ posted:

You are Bowser Jr!



As soon as you have two gold coins to rub together you are going to move out of your dad's castle and trade in this lovely Japanese egg cup hovercraft...thing you ride around in for something with some serious torque. You are insecure about your size and keep a gun stashed in the glove compartment of the egg cup for protection.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a Vigilante! Each night you may perform the following action: Target a player; that player will be killed.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to black_tangled“ posted:

You are Bowser!



You have had it up to here with the perils of castle squatting and princess abduction. There's just no room for a lizard of your proportions in such a plumber saturated market. After all you've been through, even the thought of that uppity trade-school dago gets you mad. You're working through it, and these days you stick to the sealed section of your mail order Princesses of Mushroom Kingdom Monthly for relief, mostly, but one reminder of those bad old times and you might just explode.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You are a Lynchbomb! If you are lynched, the moderator will PM you and ask you to select a player to kill. You can only select a player who is voting for you.

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Sky Coq“ posted:

You are Dry Bones!



In life, you were a steadfast Koopa shock trooper bopped into an early grave by a maniac in a red cap. In death, you carry out Bowser's wishes into perpetuity, tromping the desert sands day and night. Archaelogists throughout the Mushroom Kingdom wake up in cold sweats thinking about your dim witted animated carcass improbably disturbing their antiquities.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Milky Moor“ posted:

You are Birdo!



You are fierce. You are proud and independent. You are getting by on your own: you don't need no man, or turtle, or megalomaniacal lizard god-king to look out for you. BirdoTips88 is your makeup advice YouTube channel. You monetise just enough coins to afford all the eggs a Birdo can suck.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Asphyxious / Seagull“ posted:

You are Lakitu!



Life is pretty good up in the clouds. Or at least it is for now. Secretly, you are utterly terrified that the new residential tenancy regulations will make it financially viable for all manner of riff raff to destroy the class barrier that keeps them out of your lofty heights, and down in the sewers, where, let's be honest, they loving well belong. Your hobbies include starting Mario Kart races and fomenting panic attacks. The two are related.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

"Role PM sent to Old Dirty Cumburgs“ posted:

You are Hammer Bro!



You are Hammer Bro. The government forces you to wear a stupid helmet whenever you take your hammer out for a spin and hammering just hasn't been the same since. Studies routinely show that helmets are an impediment to good clean hammering by a skilled hammer operator, and in the (rare, undoubtedly caused by poor public hammer education) case of a hammer accident, actually do more harm than good.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not)."

"Role PM sent to Kat Delacour“ posted:

You are Potted Piranha!



Under the radar, that's how you fly. Most people think of you as just a mildly annoying obstacle. What they don't know is that you're actually a part of the Nintendo intelligence and espionage team. After training for many years (decades, even), after going on several covert missions and outplaying countless enemies, the agency has finally given you your dream job. Your mission: To enter an enemy organisation, earn the trust of those in power, and secretly foment enough trouble to bring the whole thing to its knees. That's right; you're a plant.

You are a Clean (and not Corrupted) player!

You win when all the Corrupted players are eliminated (whether you are alive or not).

Lid
Feb 18, 2005

And the mercy seat is awaiting,
And I think my head is burning,
And in a way I'm yearning,
To be done with all this measuring of proof.
An eye for an eye
And a tooth for a tooth,
And anyway I told the truth,
And I'm not afraid to die.
Anidav could've won with the scum AND won with the town and somehow managed to lose with both.

TOML in your recap you did leave out that the scum worked out that Anidav was the SK a few days ahead of time and we did block them.

BTW: A fair few of the "confusing" kills was the scum team trying to locate the SK as we were wary of them shooting us. Other days it was just to gently caress with some heads.

black_tangled
Aug 2, 2004

SKY COQ posted:

We are all loving idiots.

Yes.

Thanks to everyone who wasted our hint on the list. There were four scum on it.

MysticalMachineGun - town
Gwynplaine - scum
bell jar - town
whats for dinner - scum
Asphyxious - town
Kat Delacour - town
Mithranderp - scum
Old Dirty Cumburgs - town
Splode - scum
Metown

Anidav
Feb 25, 2010

ahhh fuck its the rats again
I can only do so much on my own :shrug:

Anidav
Feb 25, 2010

ahhh fuck its the rats again
Town was too cynical and defeated to win.

Lid
Feb 18, 2005

And the mercy seat is awaiting,
And I think my head is burning,
And in a way I'm yearning,
To be done with all this measuring of proof.
An eye for an eye
And a tooth for a tooth,
And anyway I told the truth,
And I'm not afraid to die.
SKY COQ got really unlucky, and we got really lucky. I bussed Mith and COQ (to gently caress with whatever results) and by chance Anidav tried to shoot Mith.

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

Also, here is a little bit of probability.

What's the chance of rolling a dice three times and getting a six on every occasion? Well, the way you work that out is this:

For the first roll, the chance of rolling a 6 is 1/6.
For the second roll, the chance of rolling a 6 is 1/6. The chance of rolling two sixes in a row is the chance of getting 6 the first time, multiplied by the chance of getting 6 the second time. So it's 1/6 * 1/6 = 1/36.
For the third role, the chance of rolling a 6 is 1/6. The chance of rolling three sixes in a row is the chance of getting a 6 the first time, multiplied by the chance of getting 6 the second time, multiplied by the chance of getting 6 the third time. So it's 1/6 * 1/6 * 1/6 = 1/216

You can use this same method to work out the chance of town lynching town on each day in this game - i.e. the odds of town never ever hitting a scum, even by accident.

When you do that, the odds are 5%.

You guys would have been better off rolling dice.

Those On My Left fucked around with this message at 03:32 on Mar 23, 2015

bell jar
Feb 25, 2009

anidav, for the love of mario, never type "trust me" because nobody on this forum does and it guarantees you a lynch.

good game all, v good scumming

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

black_tangled posted:

Yes.

Thanks to everyone who wasted our hint on the list. There were four scum on it.

MysticalMachineGun - town
Gwynplaine - scum
bell jar - town
whats for dinner - scum
Asphyxious - town
Kat Delacour - town
Mithranderp - scum
Old Dirty Cumburgs - town
Splode - scum
Metown

True story: When I generated this list by random (I wrote a python script to do it), I sent it to Small Keating and asked him whether it would be unfair to post it, because it included four of the seven scum players. Lol.

The last day, when Anidav got lynched, there were six people from the list still alive. Four of them were scum. No one even mentioned it.

G-Spot Run
Jun 28, 2005

black_tangled posted:

Yes.

Thanks to everyone who wasted our hint on the list. There were four scum on it.

MysticalMachineGun - town
Gwynplaine - scum
bell jar - town
whats for dinner - scum
Asphyxious - town
Kat Delacour - town
Mithranderp - scum
Old Dirty Cumburgs - town
Splode - scum
Metown

But we did use the list, we just hit town two nights in a row.

Hey, what was with the flavour text on Anidavs not lynch? I read it several times and it is word salad, it's like spam text generated, I thought you were saying the mod was corrupted?

Gough Suppressant
Nov 14, 2008
Next game someone should just roll a dice for who to lynch, would have yielded far more success

Anidav
Feb 25, 2010

ahhh fuck its the rats again
Core Auspol players are anti town because they will either eat each other or dominate the conversation to whichever outcome awaits them.

G-Spot Run
Jun 28, 2005
Beet said he was trying to ppay different, Gaspy had a crisis. Seems like we read real signals the wrong way.

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

Kat Delacour posted:

But we did use the list, we just hit town two nights in a row.

Hey, what was with the flavour text on Anidavs not lynch? I read it several times and it is word salad, it's like spam text generated, I thought you were saying the mod was corrupted?

The lynch text for Anidav was a Markov-chain generated from a bunch of data from the Mario Wiki page. Small Keating and I agreed that given how the thread was completely losing its mind, it only made sense for us to fuel that particular fire.

thatbastardken
Apr 23, 2010

A contract signed by a minor is not binding!

SKY COQ posted:

We are all loving idiots.

:agreed:

G-Spot Run
Jun 28, 2005

Those On My Left posted:

The lynch text for Anidav was a Markov-chain generated from a bunch of data from the Mario Wiki page. Small Keating and I agreed that given how the thread was completely losing its mind, it only made sense for us to fuel that particular fire.

I don't think anyone else commented on it, it was infuriating trying to be the only good girl not ghost posting.

Lid
Feb 18, 2005

And the mercy seat is awaiting,
And I think my head is burning,
And in a way I'm yearning,
To be done with all this measuring of proof.
An eye for an eye
And a tooth for a tooth,
And anyway I told the truth,
And I'm not afraid to die.
Sulla and Anidav were the two players who most correctly and most often identified scum.

black_tangled
Aug 2, 2004

Those On My Left posted:

The lynch text for Anidav was a Markov-chain generated from a bunch of data from the Mario Wiki page. Small Keating and I agreed that given how the thread was completely losing its mind, it only made sense for us to fuel that particular fire.

May I express a sense of gratitude toward you both, if not for the actual game but at least your time and efforts (especially the flavour text).

I'm going to go commit ritualistic suicide now, on theme, by ingesting a bunch of death caps.

Anidav
Feb 25, 2010

ahhh fuck its the rats again

bell jar posted:

anidav, for the love of mario, never type "trust me" because nobody on this forum does and it guarantees you a lynch.

good game all, v good scumming

It's not like you were playing anyway.

whats for dinner
Sep 25, 2006

IT TURN OUT METAL FOR DINNER!

Thanks very much for running the game Small Keating and Those On My Left. The flavour was amazing and I enjoyed it immensely!

Those On My Left posted:


The “Correct Spelling Makes Me Happy” award goes to: whats for dinner! Congratulations whats for dinner, you know the difference between ‘loath’ and ‘loathe’; very few do.
yay!

Congrats scum buds!

Thanks for playing, everyone!

Bifauxnen
Aug 12, 2010

Curses! Foiled again!


oh my god that was nuts

I was sure that Gwyn was writing all that sleuth stuff as the most obvious cop breadcrumb ever, and had looked at Gaspy D1 (which I saw as a bit of a waste).

But then Gwyn stayed alive, and MMG claimed cop... :psyduck:

Since a couple people asked for feedback on their styles, here's what I thought:

Kat - You sounded just like your earlier scumgames to me, but apart from Kingmaker I've only been in games where you were scum before. So that means you sound really consistent, actually. I only started to think you were townie once you started trying to make proper sense of claims and night actions a couple days after I was dead. But then you got pounced on for prompting roleclaims! I think it's good for town to remember that while prompting for roleclaims too early lets scum hunt down power roles, when town is already near the edge, claims can help you put the puzzle together,verify stories, finally catch some scum for real, and save your butts at the last second.

black_tangled - Your style was really good for scum cause even when you're not posting much, you never look like it's from just being lazy or not paying attention. That's what got me twigged onto you for a while, but I backed off again once you started putting more meaty opinions out there. A tad more activity probably wouldn't hurt.

Gwynplaine
Jan 24, 2015

"Let me get this straight..."
Gaspy was off his game for legit reasons and I was genuinely too busy to post often as it was my Birthday (wasnt able to celebrate with everyone at once) and instead posted either very big and very small and certainly not often. Scum did some smart things but we were also a bit lucky.

GG TOML SK

everythingWasBees
Jan 9, 2013




I don't think I like mafia anymore.

Anidav
Feb 25, 2010

ahhh fuck its the rats again
Auspol learns how to quiet post and slip slip slides to victory. Maybe Beet will stop telling us quiet posters are never scum :v:

Milkfred E. Moore
Aug 27, 2006

'It's easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism.'
Oh my god town

So many bad decisions

So many unhelpful players

Someone post the Dale Gribble twelve-headed jackass quote for me because that is pretty accurate

Lid
Feb 18, 2005

And the mercy seat is awaiting,
And I think my head is burning,
And in a way I'm yearning,
To be done with all this measuring of proof.
An eye for an eye
And a tooth for a tooth,
And anyway I told the truth,
And I'm not afraid to die.

Milky Moor posted:

Oh my god town

So many bad decisions

So many unhelpful players

Someone post the Dale Gribble twelve-headed jackass quote for me because that is pretty accurate

Can you do a write up of what you saw?

whats for dinner
Sep 25, 2006

IT TURN OUT METAL FOR DINNER!

when splode and lid were so aggressive out of the gate I thought we might have been in trouble until the slapfight began in earnest and people became so fixated on it that even beet's correct guesses were thrown to the wayside

tithin
Nov 14, 2003


[Grandmaster Tactician]



Milky Moor posted:

Someone post the Dale Gribble twelve-headed jackass quote for me because that is pretty accurate

"Bill!! Bill, you have to be the stupidest man on the planet to think this is a good idea! Have you seen what you're wearing?! That outfit makes you look like a sequined train wreck! Look at you!! You're part of a twelve-headed Jackass! This chorus is the feces that is produced when shame eats too much stupidity! You people make me envy the deaf and the blind!"

Anidav
Feb 25, 2010

ahhh fuck its the rats again
I did pretty well as scum, I should technically get a half victory.

Negative Entropy
Nov 30, 2009

SKY COQ posted:

We are all loving idiots.

we are bad at this game.

by day 4 I was seriously nor having fun.
trying to be as helpful and innocuous as possible sitting on a stressful princess role.

I was tempted to fake claim bomb I'd anyone took a hard look at me but after it was shown the roles and characters were all scrambled, lying wouldn't have got me anywhere.

it was a high chaos game and we made a total mess of it.

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

Anidav posted:

Auspol learns how to quiet post and slip slip slides to victory. Maybe Beet will stop telling us quiet posters are never scum :v:

Once or twice, I think Tirade and Kommando called out whats for dinner and gwyn for being quiet, saying this was scummy. The thread paid this literally no attention. By day four or five, these players were basically ignored and forgotten about.

Those On My Left
Jun 25, 2010

Anidav posted:

I did pretty well as scum, I should technically get a half victory.

You did pretty well as scum, and the Saulus is a really hard role, but your performance on the last day... gently caress me.

Bifauxnen
Aug 12, 2010

Curses! Foiled again!


Oh and that was a pretty sick burn on Anidav by everybody who lynched Kat instead of him after he was saying stuff like "if we have a doctor". He's really not a newbie anymore you guys! How clueless do you think he is about Mafia setups?! :lol:

whats for dinner
Sep 25, 2006

IT TURN OUT METAL FOR DINNER!

Lid posted:

Can you do a write up of what you saw?

seconding this

we did next to nothing to control the narrative in thread, as far as we could tell, just things like busing gaspy with scum :v:

tithin
Nov 14, 2003


[Grandmaster Tactician]



Realtalk, start modkilling the silent players.

Especially if they're scum.

It's poo poo to play a game of textual analysis when people aren't loving posting.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Lid
Feb 18, 2005

And the mercy seat is awaiting,
And I think my head is burning,
And in a way I'm yearning,
To be done with all this measuring of proof.
An eye for an eye
And a tooth for a tooth,
And anyway I told the truth,
And I'm not afraid to die.

whats for dinner posted:

when splode and lid were so aggressive out of the gate I thought we might have been in trouble until the slapfight began in earnest and people became so fixated on it that even beet's correct guesses were thrown to the wayside

I was fine with this as myself and Splode are always aggressive and several players wrote me as town for being myself.

  • Locked thread