Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
StrangersInTheNight
Dec 31, 2007
ABSOLUTE FUCKING GUDGEON

Jeffrey of YOSPOS posted:

Well $20 is a lot of junk food and that's to just brush the bottom end of that range. Hitting the halfway point of 125 would be a tall order.

Honestly I forgot about the premium for 3d movies because I don't like them.

Honestly, even regular movie prices are getting up there. I went to a regular movie screening in Queens, NY two months ago and it was $18 per ticket, $23 per ticket for 3D.

You could argue it's BWM, but $100 for 4 people at the movies, even with bodega snacks, is not an unrealistic price for people who live in large urban centers with rising property values, without access giant to sprawling urban megaplexes. We actually have cool poo poo to do in our space, so it's at a premium.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

hanales
Nov 3, 2013

antiga posted:

I suspect that part of the reason that payday loans charge usurious rates is that they have an equally outrageous expenses (collections, write offs for non payment/bk). Not to suggest that the owners of such outfits aren't living large, but otherwise there would be a line of hedge funds a mile long operating payday loan shops and driving down the rates.

At the population level, i can only imagine the primary reason banks don't want to do business with such a big segment of the country is that they're not profitable customers.

The reason they are referred to as predatory, is that they take advantage of people with little to no financial acumen, and often are undereducated. It's no different than buy here pay here car loan places.

"It costs a lot of money to have bad credit, no bank account, and a limited income. Allow me to explain in some detail. If your income is limited and you make a choice between two bills one week, and the other gets shut off, you now have an arbitrary payment to make to get it turned back on. In Youngstown the water reconnect fee is 50 dollars. That amount does not scale based on income, so if you're poor, you are arbitrarily hit harder than someone with a higher income than you. To deal with it, since you don't have a credit card, you go to a payday loan service, that charges interest rates in the hundreds of percents. Not hundredths. Hundreds."

The majority of customers of payday places are people who pay their bills, but are just broke. Bankruptcy is not an option to most of them (you need some amount of money to declare bankruptcy in the first place).

Anyway, sorry, :words: derail I'll say no more.

Here's some content to make up for it.


Evidently there are ironclad lifetime magazine subscription contracts out there posted:


Several years ago, I agreed to a magazine subscription service by the name of North America's Reader's Choice over the phone. I thought I could get out of it after an introductory period (like with really anything else offered by a telemarketer) and found out that this was not the case. They basically told me I was stuck paying around $50 a month for several years because of that one phone conversation. It was recorded btw. Back then, I was a broke college student and was stressed at the thought of adding this money to my already small budget. After a few months of not voluntarily making the payments, I discovered that they'd simply used my BOA debit card that they had on file. I WAS PISSED!!! So I closed my accont with BOA. I began to receive calls from the company and eventually agreed to settle the account. By this time, I had graduated but was still on a small budget. That, coupled with my feeling of being taken advantage of,really upset me, and I wanted all of this to be over and to not ruin my credit. I finally made my last payment to them (after thinking that I'd made a payment to them before, so this was my SECOND last payment Smiley Mad) and was told that I would be receiving something from them saying that I was done dealing with them. That never came, and I let it go. That was maybe 2 years ago, and I've been receiving calls from a magazine service lately and finally answered the phone today. I was talking to the third person about my subscriptions when I realized that these weren't the magazines that I recently subscribed to (through a legit source) but the company that screwed me over last time! The rep told me that I'd paid the company off for only 2 years and still had 30 more payments of $59.90 to make. WHAT?! This was after she'd taken off 6 months and helped me avoid having my contract automatically renewed for 5 more years. So sweet. Smiley Frustrated Afraid that if I didn't give them my card info this would be reported to the CRAs, I went along and gave it to them. Thankfully, this time I gave them a CC so I can dispute the charge while I do more research on this company. I googled them and see that many people have had negative experience with NARC and consider it a scam. I plan to file a complaint with the BBB and am hoping to not have to give them any of my money. Is there anything I can do, or do I just have to suck it up and pay? I already have 1 baddie on my report that's scheduled to fall off in 2018 and would rather not get another. My EX and TU scores are in the 650s but should increase somewhat because of a CC that's going to report soon (10k cl with 0% util). Also, this isn't showing up on my credit reports at all, so I'm wondering what steps they'd take if I decided to not pay. Another thing is that I never received magazines from them, so I feel like that woud strengthen a complaint.



tl;dr woman signs up for 50$ a month magazine subs, doesn't realize it's a multiyear auto-renewing contract, never even gets the magazines.

Krispy Wafer
Jul 26, 2002

I shouted out "Free the exposed 67"
But they stood on my hair and told me I was fat

Grimey Drawer
If charging 400% APR's was as profitable as it sounds, there'd be plenty of competitors willing to undercut those rates. More likely, most borrowers take short loans and the ones actually paying 400% on their loans default at such a high rate that the profit is no where near those levels. I guess if it's a title loan, the lender gets to hire a repo man who may or may not get his hands on a 10 year old Chevy.

I'm not saying it isn't profitable, but I'd be surprised if they got most of their money from interest income. I imagine they learned from 'reputable' banks a long time ago that the real money is in fees.

Not a Children
Oct 9, 2012

Don't need a holster if you never stop shooting.

It's far, far easier to get a well-meaning sucker to pay $40 every couple months than it is to get a deadbeat to make a payment.

SmuglyDismissed
Nov 27, 2007
IGNORE ME!!!

StrangersInTheNight posted:

Honestly, even regular movie prices are getting up there. I went to a regular movie screening in Queens, NY two months ago and it was $18 per ticket, $23 per ticket for 3D.

You could argue it's BWM, but $100 for 4 people at the movies, even with bodega snacks, is not an unrealistic price for people who live in large urban centers with rising property values, without access giant to sprawling urban megaplexes. We actually have cool poo poo to do in our space, so it's at a premium.

http://www.fandango.com/queens_+ny_movietimes?date=10/24/2015

I see plenty of tickets for <15 dollars.

Space Gopher
Jul 31, 2006

BLITHERING IDIOT AND HARDCORE DURIAN APOLOGIST. LET ME TELL YOU WHY THIS SHIT DON'T STINK EVEN THOUGH WE ALL KNOW IT DOES BECAUSE I'M SUPER CULTURED.

Krispy Kareem posted:

If charging 400% APR's was as profitable as it sounds, there'd be plenty of competitors willing to undercut those rates. More likely, most borrowers take short loans and the ones actually paying 400% on their loans default at such a high rate that the profit is no where near those levels. I guess if it's a title loan, the lender gets to hire a repo man who may or may not get his hands on a 10 year old Chevy.

I'm not saying it isn't profitable, but I'd be surprised if they got most of their money from interest income. I imagine they learned from 'reputable' banks a long time ago that the real money is in fees.

You're making two assumptions not founded in reality.

First, there are poo poo tons of payday loan places in poor neighborhoods. So, there are in fact plenty of competitors.

Second, the customers for these places don't necessarily shop on rate. They're too desperate to invest lots of resources in finding the economically optimal solution, and often poorly educated about financing to boot.

If you don't have a car, you have to work two jobs, and the water company says they're cutting you off tomorrow, you don't go to every place around town looking for who's cheapest. You go to the first one that will take you. Which, you'll notice, neatly explains why there are a bunch of small payday loan joints instead of megaplexes that can take advantage of economies of scale: it's a competitive advantage in that business to be close to your customers.

There's also a big advantage to jacking up your marketing spend, so that desperate people have your jingle or wacky mascot pop into their head when they need money. And, if you watch daytime or late-night TV, you will in fact find that payday lenders buy an enormous amount of cheap-to-make, catchy ads. Those ads focus on speed, convenience, and acceptance, not rate, because that's how the targets shop.

paperchaseguy
Feb 21, 2002

THEY'RE GONNA SAY NO

DrSunshine posted:

If that's the case, I wonder if it'd be GWM to start a payday loan business?

When I first heard of "tribal internet financial products", I thought it was going to be some hilariously weird Native American Bitcoin but it turns out to be a more mundane internet payday loans.

http://www.anunlikelysolution.com/

Krispy Wafer
Jul 26, 2002

I shouted out "Free the exposed 67"
But they stood on my hair and told me I was fat

Grimey Drawer

Space Gopher posted:

You're making two assumptions not founded in reality.

First, there are poo poo tons of payday loan places in poor neighborhoods. So, there are in fact plenty of competitors.

Second, the customers for these places don't necessarily shop on rate. They're too desperate to invest lots of resources in finding the economically optimal solution, and often poorly educated about financing to boot.

If you don't have a car, you have to work two jobs, and the water company says they're cutting you off tomorrow, you don't go to every place around town looking for who's cheapest. You go to the first one that will take you. Which, you'll notice, neatly explains why there are a bunch of small payday loan joints instead of megaplexes that can take advantage of economies of scale: it's a competitive advantage in that business to be close to your customers.

There's also a big advantage to jacking up your marketing spend, so that desperate people have your jingle or wacky mascot pop into their head when they need money. And, if you watch daytime or late-night TV, you will in fact find that payday lenders buy an enormous amount of cheap-to-make, catchy ads. Those ads focus on speed, convenience, and acceptance, not rate, because that's how the targets shop.

You make a good point about competition. I'm sure payday loan places make getting the second or third loan much easier than the first (less paperwork, quicker turnaround time) to keep people coming back to the same lender rather than shopping around as well.

Still, most people don't pay those incredibly high APR's, or at least don't pay them the way people with access to the regular banking system pay their credit cards. The average length of payday loans is about 200 days and those would be multiple loans rolling over every couple of weeks. That probably makes the interest rate less - but ensures a steady stream of fee income.

The worst part is people think payday lenders are the bad guys, but they're the only lenders servicing that demographic. The real issue is why they need emergency money in the first place. But it's easier to point the finger at predatory lending rather than at all the other stuff that makes being poor so expensive (daycare, sin taxes, non-progressive criminal fines, etc).

canyoneer
Sep 13, 2005


I only have canyoneyes for you
Pawn shops used to be the short term credit option. Pawn an instrument, tools, hobby equipment, whatever and get it back on payday.

Series DD Funding
Nov 25, 2014

by exmarx

Uncle Enzo posted:

2. Lol if you think hedge funds getting involved in something would make it cheaper

Airbnb is heavily invested in by hedge funds

Series DD Funding
Nov 25, 2014

by exmarx
The really hosed up businesses are the rent-to-own places. At least payday lending can arguably solve problems; rto just causes them

OneWhoKnows
Dec 6, 2006
I choo choo choooose you!

FrozenVent posted:

Drugs are expensive though.

I wonder how Slow Motion is these days.

Mercury Ballistic
Nov 14, 2005

not gun related
I know someone who works at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Their advice for when you have an issue with a bank or lender is to file a complaint in their system. I had one with a client's bank and filed. I had their bank leaving me messages within 24 hours trying to resolve the issue. I think half of reddit could benefit to know to ask the cfpb for help.

Jeffrey of YOSPOS
Dec 22, 2005

GET LOSE, YOU CAN'T COMPARE WITH MY POWERS

Series DD Funding posted:

The really hosed up businesses are the rent-to-own places. At least payday lending can arguably solve problems; rto just causes them

Required reading on the matter:
http://www.somethingawful.com/comedy-goldmine/stories-from-renttoown/1/

Nail Rat
Dec 29, 2000

You maniacs! You blew it up! God damn you! God damn you all to hell!!

hanales posted:

Here's some content to make up for it.


tl;dr woman signs up for 50$ a month magazine subs, doesn't realize it's a multiyear auto-renewing contract, never even gets the magazines.

"Smiley Frustrated Afraid" is a great way to sum up something like this. I can't believe she actually gave her CC at the last phone call.

hanales
Nov 3, 2013

Krispy Kareem posted:

You make a good point about competition. I'm sure payday loan places make getting the second or third loan much easier than the first (less paperwork, quicker turnaround time) to keep people coming back to the same lender rather than shopping around as well.

Still, most people don't pay those incredibly high APR's, or at least don't pay them the way people with access to the regular banking system pay their credit cards. The average length of payday loans is about 200 days and those would be multiple loans rolling over every couple of weeks. That probably makes the interest rate less - but ensures a steady stream of fee income.

The worst part is people think payday lenders are the bad guys, but they're the only lenders servicing that demographic. The real issue is why they need emergency money in the first place. But it's easier to point the finger at predatory lending rather than at all the other stuff that makes being poor so expensive (daycare, sin taxes, non-progressive criminal fines, etc).

No the point is there is a cycle that people get into.

They do pay those APRs. They pay 25 dollars for a 100$ loan for a two week period. After that additional fees and interest are tacked on unless you pay it off 100%.

They need money because there is a bare minimum amount of money needed to survive in society, and not everyone has it every week, because the majority of jobs in poor communities pay like poo poo.

Uncle Enzo
Apr 28, 2008

I always wanted to be a Wizard

Krispy Kareem posted:

You make a good point about competition. I'm sure payday loan places make getting the second or third loan much easier than the first (less paperwork, quicker turnaround time) to keep people coming back to the same lender rather than shopping around as well.

Still, most people don't pay those incredibly high APR's, or at least don't pay them the way people with access to the regular banking system pay their credit cards. The average length of payday loans is about 200 days and those would be multiple loans rolling over every couple of weeks. That probably makes the interest rate less - but ensures a steady stream of fee income.

The worst part is people think payday lenders are the bad guys, but they're the only lenders servicing that demographic. The real issue is why they need emergency money in the first place. But it's easier to point the finger at predatory lending rather than at all the other stuff that makes being poor so expensive (daycare, sin taxes, non-progressive criminal fines, etc).

Ok, I agree that in a larger sense payday lenders only exist because of larger systematic problems in our economy. That said they are most certainly bad guys- giving someone a 600% interest rate loan isn't doing them a favor. They provide loans and financial services to the poor in the same way a hangman provides rope services to death row inmates.

Delta-Wye
Sep 29, 2005
Still seems lovely to place the entirety of the blame for an unjust system at the feet of the hangman - he's just doing his job!

silicone thrills
Jan 9, 2008

I paint things
Washington state did a thing where we limited pay day loans to a maximum amount per year - like 3 loans? and also required that the actual APR be posted.

Payday loan industry basically shut down overnight and everyone danced on their terrible graves. Now they are pouring money into the local races to get most of the requirements overturned.

Devor
Nov 30, 2004
Lurking more.

Mercury Ballistic posted:

I know someone who works at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Their advice for when you have an issue with a bank or lender is to file a complaint in their system. I had one with a client's bank and filed. I had their bank leaving me messages within 24 hours trying to resolve the issue. I think half of reddit could benefit to know to ask the cfpb for help.

Government agencies are awesome. Comcast was screwing me around with some stupid service change fee after I spoke with them about my service, without notifying me. I called my county's public service commission to lodge a complaint, who acts as an intermediary for cable even though it isn't directly regulated by the county.

Had the fee waived "as a courtsey" by Comcast the next day.

Uncle Enzo
Apr 28, 2008

I always wanted to be a Wizard

Delta-Wye posted:

Still seems lovely to place the entirety of the blame for an unjust system at the feet of the hangman - he's just doing his job!

I'm not blaming the exploitative nature of our financial system 100% on payday lenders. The exploitative nature of payday loans, the crazy interest rates, purposely revolving debt that can't be paid off, repo'ing and selling at the same value and then collecting on property you already took, etc? Yeah, I blame the payday lenders. They're scumbags and deserve harm.

SmuglyDismissed
Nov 27, 2007
IGNORE ME!!!
If you are going to give out short term, high apr loans. The least you can do is be socially responsible about it. :rolleyes:

https://www.lendup.com/responsibility

antiga
Jan 16, 2013

BWM: falsely charging time. A coworker of mine is being investigated for rather brazen mischarging of labor hours. They've been here for six months and if they quit or get fired in year one, they're obligated to reimburse the entire relocation package and signing bonus. Easily 2/3 of this person's annual salary in total.

OneWhoKnows
Dec 6, 2006
I choo choo choooose you!

SmuglyDismissed posted:

If you are going to give out short term, high apr loans. The least you can do is be socially responsible about it. :rolleyes:

https://www.lendup.com/responsibility

quote:

Access more money at better rates

As you earn more points, you ascend in status from Silver, to Gold, to Platinum, to Prime.

Starting at Platinum, you can choose to have your repayment behavior reported to a major credit bureau. At Prime, you can borrow up to $1000 at rates as low as 29% APR.

Wow, gently caress those people.

Uncle Enzo
Apr 28, 2008

I always wanted to be a Wizard

OneWhoKnows posted:

Wow, gently caress those people.

29% apr is in line with a mediocre credit card. Payday loans not uncommonly charge 300%+ interest.



They're charging 1/10th of what a payday lender would, it's a step in the right direction.

SmuglyDismissed
Nov 27, 2007
IGNORE ME!!!

Uncle Enzo posted:

29% apr is in line with a mediocre credit card. Payday loans not uncommonly charge 300%+ interest.



They're charging 1/10th of what a payday lender would, it's a step in the right direction.

Uh, they charge 200-800% too.



They just claim that you can maybe earn the right to pay 29% but it isn't clear what that takes.

OneWhoKnows
Dec 6, 2006
I choo choo choooose you!

Uncle Enzo posted:

29% apr is in line with a mediocre credit card. Payday loans not uncommonly charge 300%+ interest.



They're charging 1/10th of what a payday lender would, it's a step in the right direction.

Well, that's at their top tier.

From their examples:


I suppose you're right in that it's still better than payday lenders.

Magic Underwear
May 14, 2003


Young Orc

SmuglyDismissed posted:

Uh, they charge 200-800% too.



They just claim that you can maybe earn the right to pay 29% but it isn't clear what that takes.

They just want to "opportunity" some money to the most disadvantaged in the community. Can you blame them for taking a healthy profit off people who are least able to afford it?

BloodBag
Sep 20, 2008

WITNESS ME!



OneWhoKnows posted:

I wonder how Slow Motion is these days.

He's posting in E/N now, but only twice a couple weeks ago.

Hyrax Attack!
Jan 13, 2009

We demand to be taken seriously

I have a seasonally appropriate BWM story.

An acquaintance is in his mid 30s and is a big Firefly fan, so he's planning to go as Captain Mal Reynolds for Halloween. Seems fine so far, as that costume could be pieced together from some Goodwill leg work. That would be appropriate as this fellow is prone to being out of work for months and has credit card/student loan debt.

He went the quickest route by buying the gun and coat from ThinkGeek, for nearly $500 total. (Gun: http://www.thinkgeek.com/product/ec6f/, coat: http://www.thinkgeek.com/product/14c4/)

Making the whole thing more absurd is that he already went as the same character for Halloween last year! I don't know if he threw away that m version of the costume or what, but ThinkGeek sure appreciated it.

Guinness
Sep 15, 2004

Look at that goony motherfucker.

Only registered members can see post attachments!

Devian666
Aug 20, 2008

Take some advice Chris.

Fun Shoe

Magic Underwear posted:

They just want to "opportunity" some money to the most disadvantaged in the community. Can you blame them for taking a healthy profit off people who are least able to afford it?

Looking at the documentary I posted earlier the lender said pay the whole loan off or you can only pay the "fee". No partial repayments so some of these payday loans are a deliberate trap. In saying that in NZ we have some pay loans places charging 3-4 million %.

Blinkman987
Jul 10, 2008

Gender roles guilt me into being fat.

Mojo Threepwood posted:

I have a seasonally appropriate BWM story.

An acquaintance is in his mid 30s and is a big Firefly fan, so he's planning to go as Captain Mal Reynolds for Halloween. Seems fine so far, as that costume could be pieced together from some Goodwill leg work. That would be appropriate as this fellow is prone to being out of work for months and has credit card/student loan debt.

He went the quickest route by buying the gun and coat from ThinkGeek, for nearly $500 total. (Gun: http://www.thinkgeek.com/product/ec6f/, coat: http://www.thinkgeek.com/product/14c4/)

Making the whole thing more absurd is that he already went as the same character for Halloween last year! I don't know if he threw away that m version of the costume or what, but ThinkGeek sure appreciated it.

He was just waiting for the coat to go on sale 3%. Good deal.

pathetic little tramp
Dec 12, 2005

by Hillary Clinton's assassins
Fallen Rib
I was gonna do a shaye st john costume, but decided to be GWM and just mugged an old guy for a wheelchair, sliced off his face and stole his prosthetic legs.

Xenoborg
Mar 10, 2007

antiga posted:

BWM: falsely charging time. A coworker of mine is being investigated for rather brazen mischarging of labor hours. They've been here for six months and if they quit or get fired in year one, they're obligated to reimburse the entire relocation package and signing bonus. Easily 2/3 of this person's annual salary in total.

Even better if they are government contractors and the false time charging becomes a criminal offense.

Guinness
Sep 15, 2004

antiga posted:

BWM: falsely charging time. A coworker of mine is being investigated for rather brazen mischarging of labor hours. They've been here for six months and if they quit or get fired in year one, they're obligated to reimburse the entire relocation package and signing bonus. Easily 2/3 of this person's annual salary in total.

I'm dying of curiosity; just how brazen are we talking?

pig slut lisa
Mar 5, 2012

irl is good


Nice try, wedding loan company, but my friends are too smart for you :colbert:

flyboi
Oct 13, 2005

agg stop posting
College Slice
Discover sent me a SUPER SELECTIVE invite with a printed card that looked like a credit card for an unsecured loan of up to 35k in the mail yesterday. APR of only 15% sign me up :getin:

RIP Paul Walker
Feb 26, 2004

flyboi posted:

Discover sent me a SUPER SELECTIVE invite with a printed card that looked like a credit card for an unsecured loan of up to 35k in the mail yesterday. APR of only 15% sign me up :getin:

Why hello there turbo kit, wheels, LSD, and non-blown speakers.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Virigoth
Apr 28, 2009

Corona rules everything around me
C.R.E.A.M. get the virus
In the ICU y'all......



RIP Paul Walker posted:

Why hello there turbo kit, wheels, LSD, and non-blown speakers.

Don't forget the driving lessons. I feel that could be important to you.

  • Locked thread