Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Mikl
Nov 8, 2009

Vote shit sandwich or the shit sandwich gets it!

Lord of the Llamas posted:

I thought 5 Star were some kind of batshit insane anti-growth party as opposed to fascists?

I don't think I'll ever understand Italian politics even a little bit.

Refer to my previous two posts regarding the 5SM:

Mikl posted:

Not quoting anyone in particular, but re: the Five-Star Movement, summing up.

Beppe Grillo is a very popular actor and comedian, and he had a very popular blog, which was an online rallying place for the leftist anti-establishment people. These were the Berlusconi years (circa 2005-2006), where many people didn't feel the left was doing very well in going against Berlusconi.

Through his blog, in 2007, Grillo set up several anti-government demonstrations, which he called "vaffanculo-day" (literally translated as "gently caress you day"), which attracted a lot of people (again, these were the Berlusconi years).

Seeing how he had a lot of success, stemming from that Grillo set up the Five-Star Movement in 2008, which fancies itself as a "popular movement against the establishment". It gained a moderate support in small, local elections, but didn't run in the general election of 2008.

When Berlusconi's government fell in 2011 and was replaced with Monti's, the FSM campaigned heavily to everyone who was fed up with the establishment, which were a lot of people. As a result, in the 2013 general election they took more than a quarter of the popular vote, coming in third behind the left-wing coalition and Berlusconi's people. As a result, because of the then-current electoral law, no party has a majority in parliament: Italy is currently governed by a rag-tag band made up of the left-wing coalition and some right-wing people who decided "you know what? gently caress Silvio" (the left-wingers lost some pieces as a result, since many didn't want to ally with the right-wingers at all or only did so grudgingly).

Since then, the FSM has gained a lot of ground, winning several major local elections (including Rome and Turin), and as it stands right now it's not unlikely they could gain a majority in the next general election.

Now, about how the Five-Star Movement works: it's literally run through online polls. Grillo regularly runs polls through his blog, where everyone who has been registered for a long enough time that they're considered "trustworthy" is allowed to vote, and that vote determines the official party line. Problem is, the vote is 1. not open to every Five-Star Movement party member, and 2. run onto Grillo's propietary software, which he refuses to have inspected by third parties. As a result, there are very serious concerns about the internal democratic process of the party: there have been multiple instances of someone going against the official party line and being expelled as a result, through online votes ("should we kick out this terrible lovely dude?") which last only about two hours (in the middle) of the afternoon and always, always result in a landslide for "yes, kick them out".

Everyone who goes against them is "corrupt, paid off, part of the establishment", no matter if they have a legitimate objection on how they do things. And when things go awry for them, IT'S A CONSPIRACY! EVERYONE IS PLOTTING AGAINST THEM FOR THE DOWNFALL OF THE FIVE-STAR MOVEMENT! LIKE AND SHARE!

Also, the people who were elected, both in Parliament and in local elections, are absolutely incompetent and have no idea how to run anything. For example, Rome recently elected their first female mayor, Virginia Raggi, who has no idea what she's doing, and since she's been elected (six months ago now) she's taken no personal initiative and just did what Grillo and the other party leaders told her to.

As a capstone to all that, since the party originally started on the internet, it attracted all the scum of the net. Anti-vaxxers, conspiracy theorists, chemtrailers, and so on, they are all part of (and supported in their beliefs by) the Five-Star Movement, which heavily employs social networking sites to campaign and discredit their opponents (think "Trump's Troll Army" and you'll have a very good idea of what it's like on italian Facebook and Twitter now).

Plus, Grillo officially endorsed Trump: he celebrated Trump's victory in a blog post about how "finally, the people have the power again, the establishment has been defeated", and so on.

So yeah, we're in for a Very Bad Time if they ever come to power. Which might be very soon, depending on the constitutional referendum's results.

Mikl posted:

[In response to a "the 5SM are not fascists" post]

They're getting really close. Their entire party and all their actions are predicated on the following principle: "our Leader is right and perfect and will lead us to glory. There is no fault in anything He does. We must obey Him in anything He says. Whoever dares say otherwise or oppose us, whether within or outside the Party, is our enemy, and must be eliminated."

So far their methods for "elimination" are mostly political, but they also resort to false accusations and character assassination through the internet (give that buzzfeed article about them a good once over). From there to physical elimination there's a very short distance.

They might not be fascists yet, but they are literally one step removed from becoming fascists.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Flowers For Algeria
Dec 3, 2005

I humbly offer my services as forum inquisitor. There is absolutely no way I would abuse this power in any way.


Where the gently caress did grampa Le Pen get so much money in the first place, anyway? He couldn't have gotten so many gold fillings from looting Algerian corpses in the fifties, could he?

Tesseraction
Apr 5, 2009

Flowers For Algeria posted:

Where the gently caress did grampa Le Pen get so much money in the first place, anyway? He couldn't have gotten so many gold fillings from looting Algerian corpses in the fifties, could he?

Some cement baron left him 30 million francs and a Mansion in the 70s.

BabyFur Denny
Mar 18, 2003

Pinch Me Im Meming posted:

Keenly awaiting the Fourth (or Fifth? Sixth?) Rome.

We're easily in the double digits by now

Kurtofan
Feb 16, 2011

hon hon hon

Flowers For Algeria posted:

Where the gently caress did grampa Le Pen get so much money in the first place, anyway? He couldn't have gotten so many gold fillings from looting Algerian corpses in the fifties, could he?

he ate a rich

Tesseraction
Apr 5, 2009

BabyFur Denny posted:

We're easily in the double digits by now

I'm assuming you're talking about century? :v:

Phlegmish
Jul 2, 2011



Pluskut Tukker posted:

It's going to differ per country but for the Netherlands, going across the border to work is actually quite rare. This is partly because the Eastern border with Germany is less populated than the rest of the countryy, but mostly because there is a language barrier, a difference in social security and tax systems that can make working across the border quite a hassle, a difference in school systems that makes German employers somewhat hesitant to take on Dutch workers (the German labour market is heavily based on credentials for the sort of jobs that Dutch workers would take), and infrastructure links are also not great everywhere. There's also a difference in workplace culture, where German firms are more hierarchical and Dutch firms more informal. Generalizing very heavily, Dutch people respect authority only conditionally so going to work in Germany takes some adaptation. It's more common for Dutch people to go live across the border and commute to the Netherlands, since housing in the German regions bordering the Netherlands is much cheaper. It is also more common for German university students to come study in the Netherlands, particularly for those studies where there is a numerus clausus in Germany, but also because higher education here is superior in terms of scale (much smaller), international outlook (plenty of programs in English), and quality of facilities. It is more expensive though.

There are plenty of expats in the Netherlands but they are either in high-skill jobs (science,engineering, IT) where there is a real shortage of Dutch workers or in low-skill jobs. In either case, they'll be in jobs where knowledge of Dutch isn't necessary. IF you would come here with a liberal arts degree you would probably find it very difficult to find a job in the Netherlands.

There are a ton of Dutch people in Flanders and Brussels, or at least it seems that way to me. But that would be the language factor, I suppose. I don't even really consider them to be 'expats' even if many of them technically fit the definition.

What you said about German students coming to the Netherlands is interesting, there were plenty of Dutch students at my (Flemish) university, so I assumed you had strict numerus clausus rules for most courses.

His Divine Shadow
Aug 7, 2000

I'm not a fascist. I'm a priest. Fascists dress up in black and tell people what to do.
Good news, I've learned how 2017 is gonna beat out 2016
http://www.cnbc.com/2017/01/02/massive-volcano-is-rumblingright-under-one-italys-biggest-cities-report.html

And this volcano is apparently something bigger than usual, this article didn't mention it but the non english one I read said it was one of 10 super volcanoes, and the last time one went off was Tambora in 1815, which was followed by 1816, the year without a summer. Basically this whole thing is a huge caldera like yellowstone.

His Divine Shadow fucked around with this message at 17:41 on Jan 4, 2017

BabyFur Denny
Mar 18, 2003

Tesseraction posted:

I'm assuming you're talking about century? :v:

Nah. But there easily have been a dozen Romes by now.

Tesseraction
Apr 5, 2009

His Divine Shadow posted:

Good news, I've learned how 2017 is gonna beat out 2016
http://www.cnbc.com/2017/01/02/massive-volcano-is-rumblingright-under-one-italys-biggest-cities-report.html

And this volcano is apparently something bigger than usual, this article didn't mention it but the non english one I read said it was one of 10 super volcanoes, and the last time one went off was Tambora in 1815, which was followed by 1816, the year without a summer. Basically this whole thing is a huge caldera like yellowstone.

"This Volcano, known to be called 'the banking system' is expected to perform a supereruption some time in the near future."

Pinch Me Im Meming
Jun 26, 2005


quote:

Dare to follow your dreams...

Become A CLEANING AUXILIARY(?)

Oh, Belgium...

Phlegmish
Jul 2, 2011



Walloons have a good sense of humor, that's ironic for sure.

And if that actually is your dream, well, tant mieux.

Cat Mattress
Jul 14, 2012

by Cyrano4747

His Divine Shadow posted:

Good news, I've learned how 2017 is gonna beat out 2016
http://www.cnbc.com/2017/01/02/massive-volcano-is-rumblingright-under-one-italys-biggest-cities-report.html

And this volcano is apparently something bigger than usual, this article didn't mention it but the non english one I read said it was one of 10 super volcanoes, and the last time one went off was Tambora in 1815, which was followed by 1816, the year without a summer. Basically this whole thing is a huge caldera like yellowstone.

There's this one, too.

throw to first DAMN IT
Apr 10, 2007
This whole thread has been raging at the people who don't want Saracen invasion to their homes

Perhaps you too should be more accepting of their cultures

His Divine Shadow posted:

Good news, I've learned how 2017 is gonna beat out 2016
http://www.cnbc.com/2017/01/02/massive-volcano-is-rumblingright-under-one-italys-biggest-cities-report.html

And this volcano is apparently something bigger than usual, this article didn't mention it but the non english one I read said it was one of 10 super volcanoes, and the last time one went off was Tambora in 1815, which was followed by 1816, the year without a summer. Basically this whole thing is a huge caldera like yellowstone.

It's -20C in Helsinki right now and I'm happier than I been for ages so I'm personally welcoming the year without a summer.

Nyandaber Z
Apr 8, 2009

Toplowtech posted:

So :france: update
So recently Marine Le Pen had to borrow 6 million € from daddy to found her campaign, because french banks told her to gently caress off. Since the russian bank who used to finance her went down. And now some Russian bank agency under the the Russian National Bank control and defending the shareholders of the failed bank sued her today to get the 9 million € she owns them reimbursed. Look like either Fillon may be enough for Vladimir, or it's an affair that gonna get buried in court.

Banks are getting more and more wary of lending to any political formation, not only the FN. UMP had to go beg people for money, and are still not doing so good. They're probably hanging for the next legislative elections where they'll increase their number of seats and get more of this sweet taxpayer money. PS has been riding the gravy train of the last legislatives, but the oasis of UMP will be their drought. And EELV is also struggling, because you don't get money when nobody votes for you.

Among cited reasons, the uncertainty of getting payed back as political parties rely a lot on successful elections, and the increasing amount of financial scandals. They also don't want to be associated with a given party, which is tougher for the FN for obvious reasons, but I'm sure nobody wants to be "the banker who worked with Cahuzac or Bygmalion" either. Politics are handling finance like they're Trump's casinos, and they're telling us how they'll fix the economy of the country while they can't even fix their own party. Seems like they could use a cure of austerity!

Namarrgon
Dec 23, 2008

Congratulations on not getting fit in 2011!

Phlegmish posted:

What you said about German students coming to the Netherlands is interesting, there were plenty of Dutch students at my (Flemish) university, so I assumed you had strict numerus clausus rules for most courses.

It really depends on the individual major. For example, entry to a psychology major is severely limited in Germany, but in the Netherlands it is (was up until a few years ago?) free-for-all entry, so in my border college town psychology is easily 90% Germans.

From what I understood the reason why Dutch students are now going to Belgium is mostly economical. Because the Belgian student financial system has not been thoroughly gutted lately and Belgium has no numerus fixus (= limited number of students, entry decided by lottery which is determined by your high school grades) studies at all. So if you lucked out getting into medicine in the Netherlands loving off to Antwerpen becomes a very attractive alternative. Also in general Belgian college costs and room rent are all lower.

Toplowtech
Aug 31, 2004

First PS primary polls of the year

First Round vote intentions:
Manuel Valls 43%
Arnaud Montebourg 25%
Beno๎t Hamon 22%
Vincent Peillon 7%

Potential Second Rounds;
Valls 55% - Montebourg 45%
Valls 57% - Hamon 43%

Toplowtech fucked around with this message at 18:46 on Jan 5, 2017

Pinch Me Im Meming
Jun 26, 2005

Toplowtech posted:

First PS primary polls of the year

First Round vote intentions:
Manuel Valls 43%
Arnaud Montebourg 25%
Beno๎t Hamon 22%
Vincent Peillon 7%

Potential Second Rounds;
Valls 55% - Montebourg 45%
Valls 57% - Hamon 43%

Who the hell is voting Valls??? :psyduck:

Dawncloack
Nov 26, 2007
ECKS DEE!
Nap Ghost
People who vote PS reflexively, thinking it's left wing? Fifth-columnists? Beats me.

Toplowtech
Aug 31, 2004

Pinch Me Im Meming posted:

Who the hell is voting Valls??? :psyduck:
Hey if Montebourg wins, some polls show Macron in front of Le Pen in the first round and the second turn is Fillon versus Macron!. POLLS!!!!

icantfindaname
Jul 1, 2008


if macron wins the presidency lol i don't even know

you feelin fucky
May 23, 2009

Squalid posted:

What's it like living as a European expat in Europe anyway? Is it very common for someone in The Netherlands to take a job in Germany and vice versa? Are there districts in Germany cities full of lots Italians? Is it hard to get a job in Croatia if you don't speak Croatian, if you're like a University Professor or electrical engineer?

Depends massively on the field and if it's north or south europe. If you're an engineer, or in IT or biomed and you have a few years experience you can find a job almost anywhere in northern europe since almost every company in those fields speaks english. Outside of that it happens only in rare exceptions where there's a massive shortage in a certain field (teachers, elderly caretakers) and then that country will try to recruit from the adjacent one's border region. Then there's also the category of jobs where it's simply cheaper to hire eastern europeans, such as construction, farm hands, meat packing, transport or prostitution. They usually work through dubious temp agencies and get housing provided by that agency.

Germany and to a lesser degree Netherlands suck in engineers something fierce from southern europe for example. Norway did as well, but I don't know if that's currently a thing still. Marine and electrical engineering companies can easily have a 30% foreign workforce. Same for academics. Those markets are almost fully international.

If you studied psychology or are trying to find a job in greece then good luck because they don't trust your degree for poo poo and you might as well put "Allahu Akbar" on every second line of your CV because they don't understand your barbaric language either.

Private Speech
Mar 30, 2011

I HAVE EVEN MORE WORTHLESS BEANIE BABIES IN MY COLLECTION THAN I HAVE WORTHLESS POSTS IN THE BEANIE BABY THREAD YET I STILL HAVE THE TEMERITY TO CRITICIZE OTHERS' COLLECTIONS

IF YOU SEE ME TALKING ABOUT BEANIE BABIES, PLEASE TELL ME TO

EAT. SHIT.


you feelin fucky posted:

Depends massively on the field and if it's north or south europe. If you're an engineer, or in IT or biomed and you have a few years experience you can find a job almost anywhere in northern europe since almost every company in those fields speaks english. Outside of that it happens only in rare exceptions where there's a massive shortage in a certain field (teachers, elderly caretakers) and then that country will try to recruit from the adjacent one's border region. Then there's also the category of jobs where it's simply cheaper to hire eastern europeans, such as construction, farm hands, meat packing, transport or prostitution. They usually work through dubious temp agencies and get housing provided by that agency.

Germany and to a lesser degree Netherlands suck in engineers something fierce from southern europe for example. Norway did as well, but I don't know if that's currently a thing still. Marine and electrical engineering companies can easily have a 30% foreign workforce. Same for academics. Those markets are almost fully international.

If you studied psychology or are trying to find a job in greece then good luck because they don't trust your degree for poo poo and you might as well put "Allahu Akbar" on every second line of your CV because they don't understand your barbaric language either.

That seems a bit hyperbolic going by the migrants/expats/whatever I know. According to the Norwegian Institute for Labour and Social Research, about 15% of EU8 (Eastern Europeans basically) workers have been first recruited through temporary staffing agencies, as opposed to about 8% for EU15. Most of the rest have been directly employed (in their first job) by construction and agriculture businesses (~40%), another 14% have been employed directly by hospitality companies (and 6% in cleaning companies which is kinda similar) and 12% directly in manufacturing. Other migrants were mostly first directly employed in administration, healthcare, education and other qualified sectors, making up the rest at about 16%. There's no specific section for engineering, but it's safe to assume it's probably most of the 'other' sector, which is 6% (and maybe a percent of so of the manufacturing sector too).

So somewhere between a quarter and a third of qualified migrants are engineers, and one in seven EU8 migrants is in a qualified position, as opposed to one in four for migrants from the older member states. Temp workers are roughly as common as qualified immigrants among the EU8, while being around four times less common than qualified migrants from EU15. Either way most of the intra-eu migrants from both EU8 and EU15 are employed directly and in unqualified professions.

e: ended up looking up the data from Norway so I'm not just saying anecdotes

e2: Here's data from the UK, showing that the majority of inter-eu migrants/expats do not even have a definite job offer before moving, as well as which sectors migrants work in (doesn't have a section for temp workers unfortunately, and I accept that UK is probably a bit special because of the language accessibility. You can compare it with the Norwegian numbers above to see that)


Table 5 posted:

Agriculture, forestry and fishing 22,000 6.5%
Mining and quarrying < 10,000 6.0%
Manufacturing 311,000 10.2%
Electricity, gas, air conditioning supply < 10,000 2.9%
Water supply, sewerage, waste 18,000 8.3%
Construction 210,000 9.1%
Wholesale, retail, repair of vehicles 277,000 6.6%
Transport and storage 154,000 9.6%
Accommodation and food services 243,000 14.2%
Information and communication 93,000 7.7%
Financial and insurance activities 79,000 6.2%
Real estate activities 17,000 4.8%
Professional, scientific and technical activities 151,000 6.6%
Administrative and support services 144,000 9.6%
Public administration and defence 40,000 2.1%
Education 146,000 4.4%
Health and social work 215,000 5.2%
Arts, entertainment and recreation 37,000 4.4%
Other service activities 36,000 4.1%
Households as employers 18,000 26.8%
Extraterritorial organisations < 10,000 6.3%

Private Speech fucked around with this message at 23:34 on Jan 5, 2017

you feelin fucky
May 23, 2009

Private Speech posted:

I guess it differs from country to country, but I personally don't know any Eastern Europeans (from the EU) who were imported through temp agencies like that into other EU countries (I do in America though) and I know probably more than a hundred in several different EU countries. That's usually associated more with semi-legal immigration from Ukraine and Russia and such. Oh sure lots of unqualified Eastern Europeans (and at least in the UK also young unemployed French, Italians and Spaniards) do temp work, but that's not the same thing, most of the ones I know looked for work directly in the host country. I mean I've read newspaper articles about near-slave-labour gangs that lure people in from Romania, but in my personal experience it's not like that for most people. My anecdotes trump your anecdotes and all that, and I'm sure it happens sometimes, but how many Eastern European immigrants/expats do you personally know?

And aside from that I agree with you that there's a lot of expat engineers, but I don't think it's as limited to it among qualified professions as you say, there's quite a few expat architects, doctors, finance people, dentists, various handcrafting artisans etc. It sounds like you just see it only in your day to day life in you own profession (engineering) so that's what you're aware of, to be honest.

Don't remember saying anything about slave camps but ok. Still, if you don't think there's a massive difference between fields where employees and customers communicate in english and where they don't I don't know what to tell you. That has nothing to do with raah engineering superiority or whatever but simply with employers not hiring people they can't talk to unless they come at a discount.

Private Speech
Mar 30, 2011

I HAVE EVEN MORE WORTHLESS BEANIE BABIES IN MY COLLECTION THAN I HAVE WORTHLESS POSTS IN THE BEANIE BABY THREAD YET I STILL HAVE THE TEMERITY TO CRITICIZE OTHERS' COLLECTIONS

IF YOU SEE ME TALKING ABOUT BEANIE BABIES, PLEASE TELL ME TO

EAT. SHIT.


you feelin fucky posted:

Don't remember saying anything about slave camps but ok. Still, if you don't think there's a massive difference between fields where employees and customers communicate in english and where they don't I don't know what to tell you. That has nothing to do with raah engineering superiority or whatever but simply with employers not hiring people they can't talk to unless they come at a discount.

Yeah I mean sure, from an employers perspective you can hire migrants for less which is the main thing that offsets the disadvantages of it, and being able to communicate with people is important. Just saying that it's not limited to engineering and academia only. I've edited my post a bit so that it's not as personal, sorry for that jab at the end.

Private Speech fucked around with this message at 23:47 on Jan 5, 2017

you feelin fucky
May 23, 2009

Private Speech posted:

Yeah I mean sure, from an employers perspective you can hire migrants for less which is the main thing that offsets the disadvantages of it, and being able to communicate with people is important. Just saying that it's not limited to engineering and academia only. I've edited my post a bit so that it's not as personal, sorry for that jab at the end. And I have an MEng so I shouldn't exactly talk poo poo about engineers, heh.

No worries, the only eastern europeans I personally know are actually a doctor and phd in engineering and I'm pretty sure they're tired of what assumptions people make about them. I did construction myself though and lived in an immigrant neighborhood that saw a large influx of poles in 2008ish. Worst I've seen was a dude walking through a rain gutter 3 stories up without any kind of fall protection at 7pm on a sunday in order to build another story on top. They were their own company though so couldn't blame that on the temp agencies.

Phlegmish
Jul 2, 2011



Namarrgon posted:

It really depends on the individual major. For example, entry to a psychology major is severely limited in Germany, but in the Netherlands it is (was up until a few years ago?) free-for-all entry, so in my border college town psychology is easily 90% Germans.

From what I understood the reason why Dutch students are now going to Belgium is mostly economical. Because the Belgian student financial system has not been thoroughly gutted lately and Belgium has no numerus fixus (= limited number of students, entry decided by lottery which is determined by your high school grades) studies at all. So if you lucked out getting into medicine in the Netherlands loving off to Antwerpen becomes a very attractive alternative. Also in general Belgian college costs and room rent are all lower.

I think they recently raised tuition to around €1000 (at least at the KUL) from about €500-600 back when I was still a student, but as I understand it that's still much cheaper than in the Netherlands. And yeah, I know quite a few people who study or studied medicine in Leuven, and there are apparently a lot of Dutch people there. I'm all for it.

Don't the Germans in your town have trouble following courses in Dutch?

Deltasquid
Apr 10, 2013

awww...
you guys made me ink!


THUNDERDOME
Leuven right now hovers around the 800 euros range IIRC. Was a lot of student outcry for raising the fees.

So yes, a very attractive alternative for Dutch students. Even law (as in, studying Belgian law, a degree that is marginally useful in the Netherlands) has a dozen Dutch students every year.

Namarrgon
Dec 23, 2008

Congratulations on not getting fit in 2011!

Phlegmish posted:

Don't the Germans in your town have trouble following courses in Dutch?

There's a (mandatory?) six week language course they get. Now as with all things, how well any individual understands the language after that comes on a wide spectrum. Some are barely literate at it even after a full year of living here, some are fluent after the language course. Regardless, it is not unusual for students to repeat the first year, especially in engineering.

It helps that a lot of courses are in English though. But again this depends on the major.

9-Volt Assault
Jan 27, 2007

Beter twee tetten in de hand dan tien op de vlucht.

Deltasquid posted:

Leuven right now hovers around the 800 euros range IIRC. Was a lot of student outcry for raising the fees.

So yes, a very attractive alternative for Dutch students. Even law (as in, studying Belgian law, a degree that is marginally useful in the Netherlands) has a dozen Dutch students every year.

So about 2,5 times cheaper than studying in the Netherlands. Nice. How expensive is it to do another degree if you already got one? Because right now i would have to pay between €7000 and €18000 a year for that, depending on the degree. But our politicians insist we have a knowledge economy and people should be stimulated to be life-long learners guys and people who lose their job should just go back to college to retrain in another field!!! :lol:

Pluskut Tukker
May 20, 2012

9-Volt Assault posted:

So about 2,5 times cheaper than studying in the Netherlands. Nice. How expensive is it to do another degree if you already got one? Because right now i would have to pay between €7000 and €18000 a year for that, depending on the degree. But our politicians insist we have a knowledge economy and people should be stimulated to be life-long learners guys and people who lose their job should just go back to college to retrain in another field!!! :lol:

It is really expensive to educate college students (if you already have a degree the government may already have paid something like €70,000 to educate you, while you will have paid out at most 10k in tuition fees over the course of your studies). Since the majority of the financial benefits of a college education tends to accrue to students themselves, it is not unreasonable to expect them to cover the costs themselves if they want to be educated further.

Tesseraction
Apr 5, 2009

Pluskut Tukker posted:

It is really expensive to educate college students (if you already have a degree the government may already have paid something like €70,000 to educate you, while you will have paid out at most 10k in tuition fees over the course of your studies). Since the majority of the financial benefits of a college education tends to accrue to students themselves, it is not unreasonable to expect them to cover the costs themselves if they want to be educated further.

Provided by student loans or should they have the cash on hand?

Lord of the Llamas
Jul 9, 2002

EULER'VE TO SEE IT VENN SOMEONE CALLS IT THE WRONG THING AND PROVOKES MY WRATH

Pluskut Tukker posted:

It is really expensive to educate college students (if you already have a degree the government may already have paid something like €70,000 to educate you, while you will have paid out at most 10k in tuition fees over the course of your studies). Since the majority of the financial benefits of a college education tends to accrue to students themselves, it is not unreasonable to expect them to cover the costs themselves if they want to be educated further.

I like how you toss this in as if it's unchallenged fact. Completely ignores the positive externalities of a well educated highly skilled population and also that people who earn more pay more tax anyway.

Cat Mattress
Jul 14, 2012

by Cyrano4747

Lord of the Llamas posted:

I like how you toss this in as if it's unchallenged fact. Completely ignores the positive externalities of a well educated highly skilled population and also that people who earn more pay more tax anyway.

These benefits are reduced when the educated people then leave the country to go work elsewhere.

Tesseraction
Apr 5, 2009

Cat Mattress posted:

These benefits are reduced when the educated people then leave the country to go work elsewhere.

It is time to make newer, larger iron curtains.

Namarrgon
Dec 23, 2008

Congratulations on not getting fit in 2011!

Lord of the Llamas posted:

I like how you toss this in as if it's unchallenged fact. Completely ignores the positive externalities of a well educated highly skilled population and also that people who earn more pay more tax anyway.

I had rewritten a response about benefits to society and how we are all in this together combined with the fact that a professor pays more in taxes than 15 minimum wage employees but in the end did not post because sometimes it just feels like swimming upstream in a river trying to convince people the bootstraps aren't real.

GABA ghoul
Oct 29, 2011

Lord of the Llamas posted:

I like how you toss this in as if it's unchallenged fact. Completely ignores the positive externalities of a well educated highly skilled population and also that people who earn more pay more tax anyway.

I think he is talking about getting a second education(like getting another Bachelor's after you've finished your Master's degree).

Pluskut Tukker
May 20, 2012

Yes, I was talking about getting a second master's degree, or maybe a second bachelor's. I am in fact a great fan of government-subsidized higher education. People here might be surprised to learn that I am well aware of the social benefits of higher education. I would be an even greater fan if the benefits of higher education though weren't so concentrated among the wealthy, including in the Netherlands (another study from the OECD if you happen to have institutional access).


Namarrgon posted:

I had rewritten a response about benefits to society and how we are all in this together combined with the fact that a professor pays more in taxes than 15 minimum wage employees but in the end did not post because sometimes it just feels like swimming upstream in a river trying to convince people the bootstraps aren't real.

This is actually really funny to me: what about the bootstraps for the minimum wage people? In the real world where public resources aren't unlimited, why should those minimum wage people who in all likelihood aren't going to college themselves subsidise someone els้s second master's degree?

Lord of the Llamas
Jul 9, 2002

EULER'VE TO SEE IT VENN SOMEONE CALLS IT THE WRONG THING AND PROVOKES MY WRATH
Maybe the answer is to raise minimum wages to liveable levels and make the tax system more progressive and not start adding complexity and arbitrary rules to socially positive things like the education system.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Pluskut Tukker
May 20, 2012

Lord of the Llamas posted:

Maybe the answer is to raise minimum wages to liveable levels and make the tax system more progressive and not start adding complexity and arbitrary rules to socially positive things like the education system.

The Dutch tax system is quite progressive and we do a lot of redistribution through various kinds of benefits for housing, childcare and health insurance. I'd be for efforts to get more people into work, but I doubt that raising the current minimum wage is going to accomplish that.

Anyway, there's nothing complex about a rule which says that you will have to pay only a fraction of the true cost for your first degree and a larger share for your second. We can argue about who benefits to what extent from the first college degree, but I would require some explanation as to how subsidising some people's second degree yields additional social benefits beyond those already flowing from the first one.

Pluskut Tukker fucked around with this message at 19:26 on Jan 6, 2017

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply