Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Dudley
Feb 24, 2003

Tasty

iospace posted:

e: how many top car series today still use NA engines? I know NASCAR does and LMP2/DPi do, but beyond those two I'm drawing a blank (though I'm also tired atm).

Depends what we're calling "top" I guess.

The Ex-Formula Renault 3.5 is still NA V8s, Formula 2 does this year but goes turbo next, GP3 is NA.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Genocide Tendency
Dec 24, 2009

I get mental health care from the medical equivalent of Skillcraft.


iospace posted:

Ok, so. Mod post inbound. You didn't gently caress up, so this isn't anything bad.

But I need your help. I'm going to be running a competition on the 28th regarding all three races, and I need a description of the 500 (such as history, why it's important, etc) for the eventual thread OP. Best submission one will get featured in it (and perhaps some bonus points for it)! PM me, or if you don't have plat, quote this post with your submission. Thank you!

Do you want an actual fact driven history lesson on why the 500 is the most prestigious race in the world?


Or do you want something that people will actually read? Because I could do both. But prefer to write the latter.

iospace
Jan 19, 2038


Genocide Tendency posted:

Do you want an actual fact driven history lesson on why the 500 is the most prestigious race in the world?


Or do you want something that people will actually read? Because I could do both. But prefer to write the latter.

It's going to be a predictor contest, because seriously, you have three of the biggest races in each series that day and given that racing does have a decent following here, should get some good participation (I hope). So whichever you think will work best works.

hunnert car pileup
Oct 28, 2007

the first world was a mistake

All the prestige you need is right here. Just look at these names:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-MgsiN-NNEg

DoctorGonzo
Jul 25, 2016

by Jeffrey of YOSPOS

iospace posted:

It's going to be a predictor contest, because seriously, you have three of the biggest races in each series that day and given that racing does have a decent following here, should get some good participation (I hope). So whichever you think will work best works.

whats the third race?

Cygni
Nov 12, 2005

raring to post

iospace posted:

Right now, it feels like production engines are going one of three ways:

1. High fuel eco NA engines
2. High HP turbo engines
3. Hybrids

Uncle probably knows better than me (i think he works in this world), but it sure seems like Hybrids are dying unless your name is Toyota or youre making a hyper car. Pretty much every new non-truck I see these days is an I4 turbo or V6 turbo. 2017 Lexus NX, Merc GLC, Lincoln Continental, Volvo S90, etc. Unless you are reusing an older engine, really seems like everything new is I4 or V6 with a snail.

Even the low end is getting them these days. 2 of the 3 Civic engines are turbos, 2 of the 3 Elantra engines. In both of those cases, thats the lowest end and highest end engine, too. Non-toyota hybrids seem to mostly be low volume greenwashing attempts to me, especially now that oil prices are low and probably staying low. Im no expert though.

If you were gonna make a racecar engine spec from scratch today with an eye towards manufacturer involvement, V6 and/or I4 turbo is the way to go.

I do think the current IndyCar engine, while really good, is missing something though. Obviously could use 100 or so hp on the road courses, but maybe more revs? More noise?

wicka
Jun 28, 2007


I would also like to hear from someone who actually works in the industry, but it seems like if you're sincerely trying to be environmentally-friendly, the last thing in the world you want to do is produce batteries en masse.

KingShibby
Jan 30, 2004

Wherever you go, whatever you do, I will be right here waiting for you...

Yams Fan

Cygni posted:

I do think the current IndyCar engine, while really good, is missing something though. Obviously could use 100 or so hp on the road courses, but maybe more revs? More noise?

I remember Michael Andretti saying that switching to methanol is an instant 150hp boost, but the series is contracted with E85R for a while

WindyMan
Mar 21, 2002

Respect the power of the wind

DoctorGonzo posted:

whats the third race?

NASCAR Coke 600 at Charlotte.

Lord Crapulus
Feb 12, 2003

About as successful at Le Mans as Toyota
I'm watching Rossi warm up to throw the first pitch at the Cubs game. I wonder if there are 100 other people here who know who he is.

IOwnCalculus
Apr 2, 2003





KingShibby posted:

I remember Michael Andretti saying that switching to methanol is an instant 150hp boost, but the series is contracted with E85R for a while

It'd also be about a 30% cut in fuel range on a tank. Give 'em gumball tires to go with it.

njsykora
Jan 23, 2012

Robots confuse squirrels.


Lord Crapulus posted:

I'm watching Rossi warm up to throw the first pitch at the Cubs game. I wonder if there are 100 other people here who know who he is.

Go ask every 13 year old you can find.

Lord Crapulus
Feb 12, 2003

About as successful at Le Mans as Toyota
But I want to watch the whole game and not get escorted out for being creepy!

Rossi threw like a 13 year old girl, that must be the connection.

iospace
Jan 19, 2038


DoctorGonzo posted:

whats the third race?

WindyMan posted:

NASCAR Coke 600 at Charlotte.

This. It's the longest race in NASCAR's lineup, clocking in at 600 miles (960km). Pretty much it's one of their biggest races in terms of prestige (not the biggest, that's the Daytona 500 easily), and does the same thing as Bahrain: starts in the early evening, goes into twilight, and finishes at night. Some drivers have done both the Indy 500 and the Coke 600 in the same day, but only once has a driver finished on the lead lap of both (Tony Stewart).

So for the North American race fans, you get Monaco in the morning, Indy 500 mid-day, and the Coke 600 in the evening. And all three races mean a lot to their perspective series. It's why I personally consider it the greatest day in racing (though note I said day, not 24 hours).

iospace fucked around with this message at 22:28 on May 4, 2017

wicka
Jun 28, 2007


Any good YouTube channels out there with full IndyCar races?

Roller Coast Guard
Aug 27, 2006

With this magnificent aircraft,
and my magnificent facial hair,
the British Empire will never fall!


iospace posted:

But I need your help. I'm going to be running a competition on the 28th regarding all three races,

Gonna assume the other of the 'three races' on the 28th is the GTs at Snetterton? :britain:

IOwnCalculus
Apr 2, 2003





wicka posted:

Any good YouTube channels out there with full IndyCar races?

Indycar's own channel puts up quite a few.

dsriggs
May 28, 2012

MONEY FALLS...

...FROM THE SKY...

...WHENEVER HE POSTS!
Go and buy some Indycar Lego OYO Minifigures!

My favorite:
http://shop.ims.com/yellow-shirt-security-oyo-minifigure/

Human Grand Prix
Jan 24, 2013

by FactsAreUseless

wicka posted:

Any good YouTube channels out there with full IndyCar races?

Recent? INDYCAR official. For older ones I use asopher or asopher1.

iospace
Jan 19, 2038


Dear IMS, please give me my orange diecast. YOU KNOW EXACTLY WHICH ONE I'M TALKING ABOUT :argh:

Full Collapse
Dec 4, 2002

wicka posted:

Any good YouTube channels out there with full IndyCar races?

Racing Jungle and IndySnake are good.

FuzzySkinner
May 23, 2012

Minto Took posted:

Racing Jungle and IndySnake are good.

Asopher1 is the best.

Feels Villeneuve
Oct 7, 2007

Setter is Better.
I'm pretty sure asopher has close to the entire run of televised CART races.


What's strangely impossible to find is early IRL.

Cygni
Nov 12, 2005

raring to post

Frye's take on why they didn't run the solid floor at Phoenix is pretty logical. Chevy didn't get a chance to test it because of Ganassi's switch, but Honda did. Hopefully next year is better.

http://www.racer.com/indycar/item/140203-frye-sure-2018-aero-will-fix-phoenix-show

Human Grand Prix
Jan 24, 2013

by FactsAreUseless

Feels Villeneuve posted:

I'm pretty sure asopher has close to the entire run of televised CART races.


What's strangely impossible to find is early IRL.

He is missing some. Like Fontana '97 and Road America 2000. But yeah it's amazingly complete. There is also ChampcarCrapwagonfan, who has the races sopher missed, with commericials though.

wicka
Jun 28, 2007


Human Grand Prix posted:

He is missing some. Like Fontana '97 and Road America 2000. But yeah it's amazingly complete. There is also ChampcarCrapwagonfan, who has the races sopher missed, with commericials though.

Well I'm literally watching Fontana 1997 on asopher1 rn so

Feels Villeneuve
Oct 7, 2007

Setter is Better.
I always liked that race, I thought the Hanford races were good but Fontana '97 is one of the last 500 milers that felt like a grueling attrition-fest which was always the best part of CART 500 milers.



Fontana 2000 was kinda like that, too.

DEEP STATE PLOT
Aug 13, 2008

Yes...Ha ha ha...YES!



Feels Villeneuve posted:

I always liked that race, I thought the Hanford races were good but Fontana '97 is one of the last 500 milers that felt like a grueling attrition-fest which was always the best part of CART 500 milers.



Fontana 2000 was kinda like that, too.


also fontana 2013 which is still one of my favorite races in any series ever

Cygni
Nov 12, 2005

raring to post

this will look pretty good wadded up on the turn 1 wall

Full Collapse
Dec 4, 2002

Nobody said Sage had a seat this year.

Bentai
Jul 8, 2004


NERF THIS!


financially racist posted:

also fontana 2013 which is still one of my favorite races in any series ever
That was a great race. The 2014 race paled in comparison since the teams had sort of figured out the new DW12 by then.

Cygni
Nov 12, 2005

raring to post

Minto Took posted:

Nobody said Sage had a seat this year.

Ya, the 33 are already set pretty much.


Ganassi - Honda
Dixon - ?
TK - NTT
Chuck - Beetus
Max - Papa money

Penske - Chevy
Sipag - Menard
Newgarden - Miller Lite?
Power - Verizon
HCN - Pennzoil
Montoya - Truck Nutz

Andretti - Honda

RHR - DHL
Rossi - Napa (w/ Herta)
Marco - UFD
Sato - Honda bux
Alonso - Papaya Orange (w/ McLaren)
Harvey (w/ Mike Shank)

SSM - Honda
Hinch - Arrow
Aleshin - Embezzled Funds
Howard - Tony Stewarts Charity

Foyt - Chevy
Munoz - ABC
Daly - ABC
Veach - Alfe?

Coyne - Honda
Bourdais - Sonnys
Jones - Scouts
Pippa - Boobs Extortion

ECR - Chevy

Ed - Golf Vodka
Hildebrand - Polar Bears

Rahal - Honda

Rahal - Penngrade
Oriol - ?

Juncos - Chevy

Kaiser - intervision
Pigot

D&R - Chevy
Karam - Meecum
Chaves - Harding (w/ Harding Racing)

Lazier - Chevy
Lazier - 96 Champ in ur Fuckin Faces

FuzzySkinner
May 23, 2012

Feels Villeneuve posted:

I'm pretty sure asopher has close to the entire run of televised CART races.


What's strangely impossible to find is early IRL.

I'm buds with him on twitter so I'm gonna ask him about it.

He oddly enough has a lot of :911: telecasts of F1 races. I wish he had the ability to post those, but you know...F1 being anal about their media being posted and all.

Human Grand Prix posted:

He is missing some. Like Fontana '97 and Road America 2000. But yeah it's amazingly complete. There is also ChampcarCrapwagonfan, who has the races sopher missed, with commericials though.

To add? I wanna see someone attempt to get the '96 Indy 500 and US 500 synced up so we can see how that plays out. The article I read was that IRL officials were cackling like idiots at the hosed up start.

Uncle Jam
Aug 20, 2005

Perfect

Cygni posted:

Uncle probably knows better than me (i think he works in this world), but it sure seems like Hybrids are dying unless your name is Toyota or youre making a hyper car. Pretty much every new non-truck I see these days is an I4 turbo or V6 turbo. 2017 Lexus NX, Merc GLC, Lincoln Continental, Volvo S90, etc. Unless you are reusing an older engine, really seems like everything new is I4 or V6 with a snail.

Even the low end is getting them these days. 2 of the 3 Civic engines are turbos, 2 of the 3 Elantra engines. In both of those cases, thats the lowest end and highest end engine, too. Non-toyota hybrids seem to mostly be low volume greenwashing attempts to me, especially now that oil prices are low and probably staying low. Im no expert though.

If you were gonna make a racecar engine spec from scratch today with an eye towards manufacturer involvement, V6 and/or I4 turbo is the way to go.

I do think the current IndyCar engine, while really good, is missing something though. Obviously could use 100 or so hp on the road courses, but maybe more revs? More noise?

Pretty much local regulations drive what OEMs offer in that region, EV, hybrid, turbo, diesel whatever. Every company has development programs for each powertrain but due to patents and profits in reality it becomes a messy tech share orgy. Motorsports are a showcase and marketing effort primarily so the world racing series like F1 and WEC have to appeal to wide range of markets. Hybrid is perfect for that. Hybrid powertrains aren't some clearly separate and unique thing from other powertrains, but are basically a EV coupled to an ICE with a motor generator in between. So, with a single effort you can cover all markets.

I think overall hybrids are in ok shape, they've really moved from specialized chassis to higher trim levels in most fleets and you probably don't even notice them driving around anymore. They actually help the most in SUVs, and while gas prices now don't help I'm sure they'll come back. If standard high throughput charging becomes better then EVs will probably supplant them. For small, affordable cars it is hard to see batteries coming in for a while - for these cars sometimes absolute profit margins become smaller than smartphones. Which is ridiculous when you compare supply chains. So reducing displacement with turbos makes sense in that class as long as the turbo is robust.

Honestly a lot of the passenger car secret sauce resides in ECUs and instrumentation which is controlled strictly in every racing series. I wish there was a series which took out aero and let them try to get traction back through electronic controls. I think these days aero development costs more than these electronic solutions - its not 1994 anymore and everyone KNOWS how to do it. Then you also get back custom engine control and monitoring...

If they can make the engine do more, and expose it a little so you could see that poo poo on TV, that'd be good.

wicka
Jun 28, 2007


Feels Villeneuve posted:

I always liked that race, I thought the Hanford races were good but Fontana '97 is one of the last 500 milers that felt like a grueling attrition-fest which was always the best part of CART 500 milers.



Fontana 2000 was kinda like that, too.

Yeah this poo poo was totally nonsense. Cars dropping like flies. Couple invisible methanol fires. Classic ESPN Speedworld theme currently playing. All around an A+ race.

FuzzySkinner
May 23, 2012

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVDGiF97gvc

It's really weird how the traditions of IndyCar racing and the Indy 500 proper are looked at by the f1 community. I don't mean this in a "HURR DURR SNOOTY EUROPEANS" way. Like...any IndyCar driver from overseas would kinda pipe up in a conversation that these guys are going on about and be as proud as a guy like AJ Foyt about the traditions that the "500" has. (Dario, TK, Helio, etc).

Like to see someone be amazed about the drinking of the milk? that's kinda confusing to me. Like it's so ingrained in :911: racing, hell sports culture at this point.

Proud Christian Mom
Dec 20, 2006
READING COMPREHENSION IS HARD
the drinking of the milk is retarded and Emerson Fittipaldi is the greatest 500 winner ever

FuzzySkinner
May 23, 2012

Proud Christian Mom posted:

the drinking of the milk is retarded

Counterpoint:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kj4fn8DTugA&t=2m19s

tupacalypse
Jan 1, 2013

by Pragmatica

Proud Christian Mom posted:

the drinking of the milk is retarded

Tony Montana sockpuppet spotted

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

FuzzySkinner
May 23, 2012

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0RjbYohogN4

Yo Cygni.

Any thing this guy is missing? He seems pretty thorough, but I imagine you have some info about how the engine was developed.

  • Locked thread