|
Count Dooku or pick any of the dudes who get smoked by Anakin at the end, one of them was probably a hero.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 16:55 |
|
|
# ? May 28, 2024 10:05 |
|
FuturePastNow posted:Who is heroic on the Separatist side? Dooku But more generally, we'd see more obviously "heroic" actions by the Separatists if the story was told from their perspective, which it is not.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 16:56 |
|
FuturePastNow posted:Who is heroic on the Separatist side? The droids, I'd say.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 16:57 |
|
In George Lucas' really early drafts for Star Wars, before he even started to split it up into multiple movies, that idea of the Republic becoming so corrupt it morphs into the Empire was there, too. So before anyone besides George Lucas and a few of his loved ones even knew what a Star War was, that was already part of the story.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 17:02 |
|
By the way, here's the novelization prologue I was talking about :Star Wars: From the Adventures of Luke Skywalker posted:Another galaxy, another time. Interestingly, for the first EU novel about the Clone Wars (Shatterpoint), Lucas wrote a prologue that's basically a rewrite of the above one with the details filled in: Shatterpoint posted:For a thousand years, the Old Republic prospered and grew under the wise rule of the Senate and the protection of the venerable Jedi Knights. But as often happens when wealth and power grow beyond all reasonable proportion, an evil fueled by greed arose. The massive organs of commerce mushroomed in power, the Senate became corrupt, and an ambitious politician named Palpatine was voted Supreme Chancellor. Most disturbingly, the Dark Lords of the Sith reappeared, after a thousand years of seeming absence.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 17:03 |
|
There are also these, from a 1975 draft of Star Wars, as printed in the Making of Star Wars book:quote:The REPUBLIC GALACTICA is dead. Ruthless trader barons, driven by greed and the lust for power, have replaced enlightenment with oppression, and “rule by the people” with the FIRST GALACTIC EMPIRE. quote:As the Republic spread throughout the galaxy, encompassing over a million worlds, the GREAT SENATE grew to such overwhelming proportions that it no longer responded to the needs of its citizens. After a series of assassinations and elaborately rigged elections, the Great Senate became secretly controlled by the Power and Transport guilds. When the Jedi discovered the conspiracy and attempted to purge the Senate, they were denounced as traitors. Several Jedi allowed themselves to be tried and executed, but most of them fled into the Outland systems and tried to tell people of the conspiracy. But the elders chose to remain behind, and the Great Senate diverted them by creating civil disorder. The Senate secretly instigated race wars, and aided anti-government terrorists. They slowed down the system of justice, which caused the crime rate to rise to the point where a totally controlled and oppressive police state was welcomed by the systems. The Empire was born. The systems were exploited by a new economic policy which raised the cost of power and transport to unbelievable heights. Many worlds were destroyed this way. Many people starved … quote:During one of his lessons a young PADAWAN-JEDI, a boy named Darklighter, came to know the evil half of the force, and fell victim to the spell of the dreaded Bogan. He ran away from his instructor and taught the evil ways of the Bogan Force to a clan of Sith pirates, who then spread untold misery throughout the systems. They became the personal bodyguards of the Emperor. The Jedi were hunted down by these deadly Sith knights. With every Jedi death, contact with the Ashla grows weaker, and the force of the Bogan grows more powerful. While not identical to what was depicted in the Prequels, the basis for them is clear. It's really interesting seeing how much of the themes, archetypes, motifs, and plot points from all six of the Lucas films are present in an unrefined form in those early drafts.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 17:35 |
|
Beeez posted:There are also these, from a 1975 draft of Star Wars, as printed in the Making of Star Wars book: Wow, this poo poo is too real. No wonder it didn't make it intact into the movies.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 17:38 |
|
FuturePastNow posted:Who is heroic on the Separatist side? No one character on the Separatist side is really presented as "heroic", in a traditional sense. They're a bunch of unsympathetic characters who start wearing the trappings of heroic Rebels, to contrast against the sympathetic characters on the Republic side who nevertheless start wearing the trappings of an oppressive Empire. It's a thematic statement about how the Republic is losing the moral high ground. The Separatists who show up on screen are still outwardly the same group of free market assholes from the last two movies. The PT is told from the perspective of characters who are loyal to the Republic and don't start seeing the folly in the war against the Separatists until it's too late. We know from dialogue that the Separatists started off as a resistance movement against an increasingly corrupt Republic, but we tellingly are never shown any of these Separatists in the PT; we're only shown the big business representatives who cynically hijack the movement. This is how the viewpoint characters see the movement, and so it's also how we see it. As an audience member, you're not really supposed to viscerally sympathize with any of the Separatist characters until the moment when Anakin starts mercilessly slaughtering them as they beg for their lives. And we sympathize with them even though we know they're jerks, not because they're suddenly revealed to be decent guys. The true Separatist heroes, the ones who are fighting for idealistic reasons, are all doing their thing off-screen. It's enough to know that they exist. "There are heroes on both sides" is flavor text meant to set the tone for the entire movie, which is about Anakin switching sides in the Jedi vs. Sith struggle for reasons that are, from his perspective, heroic. It's why the track that plays during the Mustafar duel is called "Battle of the Heroes." The movie isn't really specifically about heroic Separatists, it's just one part of the equation to consider. The heroic Separatists don't show up until the next movie (episodically speaking), which begins the portion of the story which is told from the perspective of the rebels against the establishment, rather than the other way around. Cnut the Great fucked around with this message at 17:42 on Jun 1, 2017 |
# ? Jun 1, 2017 17:40 |
|
Beeez posted:There are also these, from a 1975 draft of Star Wars, as printed in the Making of Star Wars book: There's that 70's cynicism.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 18:17 |
|
quote:During one of his lessons a young PADAWAN-JEDI, a boy named Darklighter, came to know the evil half of the force, and fell victim to the spell of the dreaded Bogan. Noice
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 18:28 |
|
Beeez posted:It's really interesting seeing how much of the themes, archetypes, motifs, and plot points from all six of the Lucas films are present in an unrefined form in those early drafts. Just as one other interesting example, the very first scene in the script seems to contain a rough prototype of the final battle between Darth Maul and Obi-Wan in Episode I: quote:Finally, Annikin is able to assume a defensive stance, and the two warriors stand, sizing up each other. The black knight is at least seven feet tall, and dwarfs the young JEDI. They stand for a few moments, almost frozen, then in a flurry of blows, lazerswords clash with the sound of electric snapping and popping. Annikin is barely able to hold his own against the experienced knight. Many blows are exchanged before the SITH warrior is able to back Annikin up against a deep crevasse. Annikin stumbles and almost falls over the cliff to his death. Some of the parts are rearranged, but they're all there. One difference is that instead of being backed up against a crevasse and having to be rescued by his father, Obi-Wan is backed up into a crevasse and ends up rescuing himself by metaphorically becoming his father (claiming his lightsaber and all that)--in both cases dispatching the Sith Lord by surprising him from behind and slicing him in half. Then in both cases a loved one who was killed by the Sith Lord at the outset of the duel is cradled in the arms of a mourning hero, ending the scene. Of course Lucas actually ended up using something from this scene even in A New Hope. From the beginning of the scene: quote:With the aid of the electrobinoculars, Deak watches the running lights of the starship flash on and off. Suddenly, something huge moves in front of his field of view. Before either of the two young boys can react, a large, sinister SITH warrior in black robes and a face mask looms over them. One thing people don't understand about these very rough drafts is that--as per Lucas's own description of his writing process--they're essentially just Lucas letting his mind run free in one long, unrefined, stream-of-consciousness jumble. He intentionally doesn't go back and refine almost anything at all until the next draft, when he tries to condense things down, get rid of the chaff, and give everything more structure. This draft, for instance, was never in any way remotely intended to be any sort of finished product. But it obviously ended up giving him a lot of interesting ideas and concepts to mine from and further refine. I mean, it's essentially the basis for the entire original trilogy as well as a lot of the prequel trilogy.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 21:07 |
|
Kane Starkiller
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 22:03 |
|
Cnut the Great posted:No one character on the Separatist side is really presented as "heroic", in a traditional sense. They're a bunch of unsympathetic characters who start wearing the trappings of heroic Rebels, to contrast against the sympathetic characters on the Republic side who nevertheless start wearing the trappings of an oppressive Empire. It's a thematic statement about how the Republic is losing the moral high ground. The Separatists who show up on screen are still outwardly the same group of free market assholes from the last two movies. The prequels are basically that "Are We the Baddies?" sketch stretched out over 3 movies.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 22:39 |
|
General Dog posted:Kane Starkiller Rare costume test still
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 23:07 |
|
drat it these double posts are out of control!!!
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 23:08 |
|
General Dog posted:Kane Starkiller Definitely loving the use of that name in TFA. I can't remember who it was that pointed that Starkiller Base is Darth Vader, but it's a great point.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 23:16 |
|
Padme says point blank: "maybe we are the baddies?"
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 23:18 |
|
Hodgepodge posted:Definitely loving the use of that name in TFA. I can't remember who it was that pointed that Starkiller Base is Darth Vader, but it's a great point. One of the things I do really like in TFA is the theme of villains aspiring to be Darth Vader, but getting him all wrong. Starkiller Base copies Vader's cyborg nature, but it's actually an affront to what Vader himself believed.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 23:20 |
|
euphronius posted:Padme says point blank: "maybe we are the baddies?" Padme is kind of the anti-Leia. Leia is temporarily a senator but apparently can't stop being a princess, while Padme is temporarily a queen but apparently can't stop being a poli sci nerd.
|
# ? Jun 1, 2017 23:28 |
|
Hodgepodge posted:Definitely loving the use of that name in TFA. I can't remember who it was that pointed that Starkiller Base is Darth Vader, but it's a great point. Hey, it's me. ungulateman posted:Starkiller Base isn't just 'the Death Star, but bigger'. It's Darth Vader - but not SMG's cool, Christ figure. It's Disney's Star WarsTM Darth Vader, and desperately needs redeeming.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 00:15 |
|
ungulateman posted:Hey, it's me. Ah, cool. One thing not in the original post: Kylo prays to Vader to show him the power of the Dark Side, and the next scene we see him in is the one where he watches the base fire on the Republic. Kylo's prayer is answered.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 00:33 |
|
Cnut the Great posted:Just as one other interesting example, the very first scene in the script seems to contain a rough prototype of the final battle between Darth Maul and Obi-Wan in Episode I: Another interesting thing to track through Lucas' process is the way the various "father figure/mentor" characters have different traits assigned to them at different times, which sort of emphasizes how closely related on a thematic level they are. In one draft Luke's father is "The Starkiller", who has traits of both Obi-Wan and Yoda in that his physical description matches pretty much exactly Obi-Wan's in the finalized script, but much like Yoda he's implied to be far older than a normal human could be. In another version, Ben Kenobi is a cyborg who strangles a room full of bureaucrats with the Force, but he still plays the same role overall he plays in A New Hope. And as you have mentioned, in an earlier version than even the two I just referenced, the father of "Annikin" is a cyborg who sacrifices himself to save his children. Tracking how these elements evolved over the years is really interesting.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 01:28 |
|
Not only that, but Obi-Wan Kenobi was a fairly late edition to the scripts. Originally Luke was in search of his living father, and his older brother plays a prominent role as well. Through the drafting you can see how Lucas shuffled all of these things around until he found a much reduced and simplified version of these dynamics (for the better). Likewise with TPM, Lucas struggled for a long time with Obi-Wan's character until he created Qui-Gon Jinn.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 02:49 |
|
Hodgepodge posted:Ah, cool. One thing not in the original post: Kylo prays to Vader to show him the power of the Dark Side, and the next scene we see him in is the one where he watches the base fire on the Republic. Kylo's prayer is answered. the ability to destroy a planet is insignificant next to the power of the force. the ability to destroy several planets however,
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 03:30 |
|
TWIST FIST posted:the ability to destroy a planet is insignificant next to the power of the force. the ability to destroy several planets however, RIP Starkiller Base, destroyed the entire government but ultimately fell prey to a few bombers and a disgruntled janitor.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 04:07 |
|
General Dog posted:RIP Starkiller Base, destroyed the entire government but ultimately fell prey to a few bombers and a disgruntled janitor. The Dark Side is capable of immense destruction, but vulnerable to plucky idealists.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 06:24 |
|
I feel like you could start at Episode 3 and watch the rest chronologically and you would be good. I personally would do this: Watch Clone Wars Play Republic Commando Episode III Play all the way through Dark Forces Begin playing Xwing but only until the last mission. Episode IV Play TIE fighter Episode V AND play Shadows of the Empire on another screen. Play Xwing Alliance and Rogue Squadron Episode VI Play Jedi Knight Play Mysteries of the Sith Play Jedi Knight II Play Jedi Academy Read the Thrawn trilogy Episode VII dialhforhero fucked around with this message at 15:25 on Jun 2, 2017 |
# ? Jun 2, 2017 15:23 |
|
haha holy gently caress... or you could just watch the movies in the order they were released like a normal person
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 16:06 |
|
dialhforhero posted:I feel like you could start at Episode 3 and watch the rest chronologically and you would be good. Yeah, but you'd miss out on a couple good movies.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 16:21 |
|
When I'm in the mood for some Star Wars I just randomly pop one of them in based on my mood at the time. Guess I'm just not a true Star Wars fan if I don't have a preferred viewing order.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 16:23 |
|
They're good in any order.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 16:29 |
|
Watch the movies in reverse order, but also in reverse, so you too can receive the knowledge of space satan.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 16:38 |
|
If you watch Star Wars backwards it becomes about Luke very quickly building a giant space station and the Empire using it to very quickly rebuild Alderaan.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 17:05 |
|
dialhforhero posted:I feel like you could start at Episode 3 and watch the rest chronologically and you would be good. and the video game adaptation of Episode III with the alternate ending.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 17:17 |
|
Watch the movies in order of release, as each was made with the audience's presumptive knowledge of the movies that came before in mind.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 17:28 |
|
I recommend reading only the wikipedia articles and then writing a 5,000 word essay on Star Wars from a Khmer Rouge perspective.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 17:46 |
|
Instant Sunrise posted:If you watch Star Wars backwards it becomes about Luke very quickly building a giant space station and the Empire using it to very quickly rebuild Alderaan. And then Darth Vader becomes human again and enters into some kind of Benjamin Button scenario, and rebuilds a space station as a kid.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 18:00 |
|
Checks out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aQa9AnOKdaQ
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 18:30 |
|
PenguinKnight posted:And then Darth Vader becomes human again and enters into some kind of Benjamin Button scenario, and rebuilds a space station as a kid. And then is lost into slavery by a Jedi master
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 21:33 |
|
|
# ? May 28, 2024 10:05 |
|
Davros1 posted:And then is lost into slavery by a Jedi master Not only that, he specifically fixes the dice so he loses.
|
# ? Jun 2, 2017 21:36 |