Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
minivanmegafun
Jul 27, 2004

echinopsis posted:

there is a SA set on massdrop which looks cool ish but a bit tacky and also ABS and expensive as gently caress

yeah i put it in my cart and once I added a full ansi set and the mac keys I went $110? for abs? gently caress that poo poo and didn't buy it

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


minivanmegafun posted:

yeah i put it in my cart and once I added a full ansi set and the mac keys I went $110? for abs? gently caress that poo poo and didn't buy it

it's still within the realm of reason for a re-issue of a popular set

weirdo nerd idiocy, envy and greed gave us this last summer:
https://originative.co/products/sa-penumbra
https://originative.co/products/sa-hyperfuse

the part that i found especially insulting is that for effectively three hundred earth dollars shipped all you got is a bastardized re-issue in row 3 only with other small stuff that got hosed with

they did that to preserve the ~prestige~ of owning a "true" round one issue all the while charging something crazy retarded knowing idiots would fall for it, since penumbra has been known to sell in the almost four figgie range

https://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/5nt6h7/the_problems_with_penumbra_r2/?st=j3mes05z&sh=888aa386

can't wait for :china: to come in and smash all this pretentious nerd poo poo

LochNessMonster
Feb 3, 2005

I need about three fitty


surebet posted:


can't wait for :china: to come in and smash all this pretentious nerd poo poo

you mean shif t, right?

I hope max keys will become competative.

pgroce
Oct 24, 2002

surebet posted:

it's still within the realm of reason for a re-issue of a popular set

weirdo nerd idiocy, envy and greed gave us this last summer:
https://originative.co/products/sa-penumbra
https://originative.co/products/sa-hyperfuse

the part that i found especially insulting is that for effectively three hundred earth dollars shipped all you got is a bastardized re-issue in row 3 only with other small stuff that got hosed with

they did that to preserve the ~prestige~ of owning a "true" round one issue all the while charging something crazy retarded knowing idiots would fall for it, since penumbra has been known to sell in the almost four figgie range

https://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/5nt6h7/the_problems_with_penumbra_r2/?st=j3mes05z&sh=888aa386

can't wait for :china: to come in and smash all this pretentious nerd poo poo


e: active now! artisanal!

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


LochNessMonster posted:

you mean shif t, right?

I hope max keys will become competative.

well right off the bat zfrontier is making sure to impress:


with the disclaimer that i joined the group order in march, getting a set of fully sculpted sa doubleshots loving overnighted from china for around $92 canadian (~$68 in freedom dollars) is pretty amazing

some pictures of the finished product at zfrontier's office:







i'm not a huge fan of the arrow cluster or the lack of meta keys, so i'm thinking of getting a few r6 leftover keys from 7bit to complete the look (and do a direct comparison between the two).

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist



$70 is dumb, but in the realm of ~artisan~ keycaps it's not even close to being the worse:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/112339372875
(pretty sure i saw some single cap, four figgie sales)

that spacebar at least has the merit of looking like a finished product

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


ah, there we go

http://www.ebay.com/itm/252489877984
http://www.ebay.com/itm/252508109002
http://www.ebay.com/itm/291436814456
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/151687883770

Salt Fish
Sep 11, 2003

Cybernetic Crumb
Look for my line of artisinal mouse feet coming soon!

BONGHITZ
Jan 1, 1970

1.5k american dollars for a single keycap.

very lol

BONGHITZ
Jan 1, 1970

this is hilarious

http://www.ebay.com/bfl/viewbids/252489877984?item=252489877984&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2565

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


what's even more hilarious is that all of these can now be found for $30 at boutique-ish chinese sites like k3kc and probably a buck shipped somewhere on taobao

that eighty bucks spacebar at least has the merit of being an original design



that's about 65 caps including 50+ of literally the same thing but in different colors, probably ranging from $40 per to something three figgie each. that's at the bare minimum 2k worth of nerd bait, probably much more

pram
Jun 10, 2001

surebet posted:

well right off the bat zfrontier is making sure to impress:


with the disclaimer that i joined the group order in march, getting a set of fully sculpted sa doubleshots loving overnighted from china for around $92 canadian (~$68 in freedom dollars) is pretty amazing

some pictures of the finished product at zfrontier's office:







i'm not a huge fan of the arrow cluster or the lack of meta keys, so i'm thinking of getting a few r6 leftover keys from 7bit to complete the look (and do a direct comparison between the two).

the packaging is extremely good

JewKiller 3000
Nov 28, 2006

by Lowtax

surebet posted:

what's even more hilarious is that all of these can now be found for $30 at boutique-ish chinese sites like k3kc and probably a buck shipped somewhere on taobao

that eighty bucks spacebar at least has the merit of being an original design



that's about 65 caps including 50+ of literally the same thing but in different colors, probably ranging from $40 per to something three figgie each. that's at the bare minimum 2k worth of nerd bait, probably much more

this is just loving nonsense. completely disconnected from the feels, like how is this even a keyboard i'm supposed to want to type on

Cocoa Crispies
Jul 20, 2001

Vehicular Manslaughter!

Pillbug

pram
Jun 10, 2001
:golfclap:

Silver Alicorn
Mar 30, 2008

𝓪 𝓻𝓮𝓭 𝓹𝓪𝓷𝓭𝓪 𝓲𝓼 𝓪 𝓬𝓾𝓻𝓲𝓸𝓾𝓼 𝓼𝓸𝓻𝓽 𝓸𝓯 𝓬𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓽𝓾𝓻𝓮

I'm just gonna quote dis

DR FRASIER KRANG
Feb 4, 2005

"Are you forgetting that just this afternoon I was punched in the face by a turtle now dead?
my lab is surplusing a Dolch system and im trying to figure out how to make it mine.

apparently we paid $13k for it when we bought it.

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


HEY NONG MAN posted:

my lab is surplusing a Dolch system and im trying to figure out how to make it mine.

apparently we paid $13k for it when we bought it.

offer to match whatever offer the recycler will give them

ie somewhere between gently caress & all

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


no joke it'll probably be sold at scrap weight value

LochNessMonster
Feb 3, 2005

I need about three fitty


surebet posted:

well right off the bat zfrontier is making sure to impress:


with the disclaimer that i joined the group order in march, getting a set of fully sculpted sa doubleshots loving overnighted from china for around $92 canadian (~$68 in freedom dollars) is pretty amazing

some pictures of the finished product at zfrontier's office:







i'm not a huge fan of the arrow cluster or the lack of meta keys, so i'm thinking of getting a few r6 leftover keys from 7bit to complete the look (and do a direct comparison between the two).

That looks pretty good and really cheap compared to SP/GMK sets. I love the stock PBT caps that came with my pok3r and I'm not sure if I want to get an ABS set to replace them.

Bloody
Mar 3, 2013


this keyboard looks amazingly stupid lmao

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


Bloody posted:


this keyboard looks amazingly stupid lmao

i see what they were trying to do, but they didn't use a period correct keeb. like at all. it's a 2005-2008 g80 something. had they gone for something older (or at least without blue leds, gently caress) it would've come out less bad

dump them on a 1980s g80 and it starts to make sense:

(pictured with a honeywell round 5 set)

the honeywell btrm (on which round 5s and this colorway of maxkeys are based on) was a mostly beige keeb:


my maxkeys are in, i'll post some pics after i'm done playing with them

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


alrighty, here we go

:siren: tl;dr these are good and you should consider both maxkey's product and zfrontier's retail channel for your next idiot nerd purchase. in my case i joined a group order with a ~4 month cycle, however i believe that some of the more common colorways are kept stock, albeit on taobao (essentially alibaba but with gently caress all english or out of china purchase support) :siren:

first things first, some housekeeping:


i remembered wrong when i said this set was $91cad/$68usd, it's actually $91usd shipped. note that the $16.80 shipping cost is the only one available for the couple addresses i tried (mine + a few us ones). they will ship for free if you buy more than $100 worth of stuff.

again, i feel i need to stress that they shipped the set overnight, which :psyduck:, but at least it's not adding 4-6 weeks to the group order process

my experience with zfrontier has been pretty good, especially for a chinese retailer; decent enough comms in proper english, tracking number that works, paypal support.

waybill is straight up fraudulent, per china standard, claiming contents with no commercial value (ncv). i don't like this, but heh

with the caveat that i'm not at all setup for macro photography, have a few shots!


plain brown box with a tiny qr sticker on the side. card is good stock and the inner baffles hold everything in place very well during transport.


box contains 2 two part plastic trays with a thin foam insert. like pram said, the packaging is extremely good and i'll be keeping it in case i need to store another set of keys or something.


actual important stuff, beautiful double shot honeywell caps with crisp legends. i really want to emphasize that proper qc went into this; the manufacturing process involved in doubleshot caps is hella sketchy at small scale and i was expecting some issues. no alignment, flashing, overmolding or whatever issues as far as i can tell.

important to note: the set i bought came with a fair amount of redundant keys in different sizes. always make sure that the poo poo you're buying will actually fit your keeb, especially if you're rocking a special snowflake layout. google "[keyboard model] keycap sizes" or ask around. in my case, my code/wasd is rocking a standard ansi layout.


legend insert is properly level with the cap bodies, and a subtle texture is present on top (vs a polished side finish). hard to tell without a scale, but because of the added material in the fab process, key weight is around the same of pbt caps

double shot process is proper and legit looks identical to signature plastic's, which for me confirms that these are made with the tooling comptec (sp's france branch) surplused when it went bankrupt. everything is double shot except for the spacebars (obviously). speaking of those, the set includes both a 6.25u and 7.25u bar

important to note: these are still abs caps, so they'll eventually develop some shine, but if you can be arsed to you can re-etch the surface since the legends aren't printed. i personally don't mind the shine, and i might even refinish & polish the set at some point.


redundant keys come in enough different sizes to cover most use cases. lower controls come in 1.25u and 1.5u, you have a set of 1.75u, 2.25u & 3u shifts, and the choice between flat or sculpted capslock keys, among others.


kinda lovely to show off of a keeb, but the sculpt is the same as correct sp sa. left/red being the top row esc key and going down the layout towards the right, we're looking at r1 r1 r2 r3 r4 r3. to quote pram again, quite tall and luxurious.


legends are clean and crisp in two weights and a couple sizes of gorton modified. rumor has it that the original maxkey run had the same kerning issues as old sp runs ( shif t ), lending more credibility that these are made on old comptec/sp tooling. the issue isn't present on this set, so if it was a thing they fixed it.

colors seem to mirror a possible 7bit round 5 configuration. i don't have a sp color ring or round 5 keys to compare, but assuming they match more or less, we're looking at white (wfk), red (ras) & medium grey (gpa).

one minor aesthetics issue when comparing this set to round 5 or the btrm it's based on is the total lack of black. white keys have grey legends instead of black ones, although it still looks pretty good imho. this seems to be standard operation for maxkey, for example the original run had pink or cyan on white mains with white on pink or cyan modifiers. the do produce a white mains on black mods set so i might grab one down the line

all in all this purchase is pretty needs suiting, especially since i was so desperate to get a nice round 5 set that i was cognitive dissonancing myself into considering spending $500+ for a set off of r/mechmarket

i hope we'll start seeing more of maxkey, the whole sa monopoly thing with massdrop & sp.

pros:
- hella cheap in the context of an sa set
- fully sculpted
- faster turnaround than a lot of group orders, both in fabrication and shipping time
- good qc, good packaging (might be zfrontier specific, ymmv)
- good amount of spare keys in different sizes (to the best of my knowledge maxkey standard)

cons:
- white keys in gpa/wfk instead of nn/wfk
- lack of "super" & "meta" legends, using "win" & "menu" instead
- arrows keys look weird & fat imho, would've gone for text personally or at least a not-a-triangle arrow

BONGHITZ
Jan 1, 1970

can you type faster now?

pram
Jun 10, 2001
looks good grats

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


BONGHITZ posted:

can you type faster now?

i don't have an mx stemmed keeb at home at the moment

:smith:

pram posted:

looks good grats

i'm still jelly of your r5 stuff tho

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


bonus content:


:black101:

Bloody
Mar 3, 2013

im the kill+

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


Bloody posted:

im the kill+

we all aspire to be

minivanmegafun
Jul 27, 2004

ok I really really want one of those sets now

Silver Alicorn
Mar 30, 2008

𝓪 𝓻𝓮𝓭 𝓹𝓪𝓷𝓭𝓪 𝓲𝓼 𝓪 𝓬𝓾𝓻𝓲𝓸𝓾𝓼 𝓼𝓸𝓻𝓽 𝓸𝓯 𝓬𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓽𝓾𝓻𝓮
:staredog:

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


minivanmegafun posted:

ok I really really want one of those sets now

well i have good news and bad news

this is the current offering on taobao:

("portland" aka dolch, black, cyan and pink)

https://world.taobao.com/search/search.htm?q=maxkey

they're available ($80-$100 shipped within mainland china) but to interface directly with taobao you basically need a chinese bank account. some sellers will accept paypal & ship to north america, most won't since it's a sale entirely outside of the platform.

you have the option of going through what's called a taobao agent, basically a third party mail forwarding agent. expect maybe :20bux: in service & shipping charges or something. back when i was doing b2b on taobao we had our own local agent, so i have no experience with consumer level reshippers.

the product is available, it's just a complete pain in the dick to get to

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


since i've been cheating on you guys with the grey thread, if you aren't following that one, here's a couple things of interest i thought i'd merge in here

building an ergodox (not the massdrop one, the open sores reference design) from scratch:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLBgJd5LCeXxmNQJnwcQyFuCwz3gV_oShV
http://shop.profetkeyboards.com/product/ergodox-pcbs
https://www.ergodox.io/
(the videos aren't mine, i just made the playlist)

if you want to go down the ergodox route and are diy inclined, you can save a few buck and build it to your exact spergy reqs. it's obviously super loving labour intensive, but the nerd cred and bragging rights of showing up to the office with a thing you built from scratch is considerable. a neat, actually functional project if you want to learn this stuff instead of the usual make-light-go-blink-with-an-arduino-and-a-breadboard crap

echinopsis
Apr 13, 2004

by Fluffdaddy
holy guacamole

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


not quite sure how it took canada post a weeks to move a box from mississauga to near montreal, and still gently caress it up enough to 1) not even try to deliver, 2) not leave a pick up card, 3) stage the package 2 towns over despite the perfectly fine post office less than a kilometer from my home, but hey, keyboard is here!

too brokebrain'ed to sperg at lenght today so check out what's in the box of a capsless wasd w/ clears and what it looks like once you dress it up:


keyboard: good, clicky and heavy
usb->mini usb cable: does it thing
usb->ps/2 adapter: iirc required for nkro, using it regardless because gently caress yeah ps/2
lube: lubes
stabilizers: just enough to populate the keeb, they seem ok but a spare or two would've been nice
cap puller: unexpected, not the greatest, good enough

bonus "don't gently caress this up" warning:

pram
Jun 10, 2001
how are the clears compared to browns

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


pram posted:

how are the clears compared to browns

quite needs suiting, i honestly have trouble telling the difference between browns and reds sometimes since the brown tactile bump is really discrete to me as a ubermensch model m user

my plan was to take the new board to an office that complained about the m i have over there is too noisy, but i'll probably keep it at home for a week to get used to it, i'm still smashing the keys all the way down expecting buckle spring like resistance

i dislike reds, blacks feel weird to me, blues are meh but greens are goods (i'd have to update my will before bringing a board with greens in public though), browns are also quite meh, clears are looking like the sweet spot for me

i'm still trying to track down a beam spring keeb to settle once and for all what a loud keyboard is with a few people though

Cocoa Crispies
Jul 20, 2001

Vehicular Manslaughter!

Pillbug

surebet posted:

usb->ps/2 adapter: iirc required for nkro, using it regardless because gently caress yeah ps/2

usb can do nkro, and what kind of cave computer comes with a ps/2 hole anyways

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


Cocoa Crispies posted:

usb can do nkro, and what kind of cave computer comes with a ps/2 hole anyways

a whole bunch still, in my case it's though my docks

it's kinda weird having parallel/serial/ps2 and usb3/displayport on the same thing, but as a toucher of old computer stuff it's quite useful

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

surebet
Jan 10, 2013

avatar
specialist


also usb can do nkro, but that's dependent on a few things both on the kb & bios sides, and more often than not it gets capped to 6kro. the code/wasd for example can only do 6kro over usb. on the other hand, ps/2 has nkro as a default feature.

now the better argument is do you really need nkro over 6kro, but i got the port and something to shove in it so that's what i'm doing

  • Locked thread