|
Liquid Communism posted:Given that Yud has never had an original thought in his life, why would yet another poorly understood ripoff of another work be a surprise? Because as an atheist post-Judaic cult leader, referencing Christian apologia would render him powerless? Then again, nobody in LW would process it that way, so maybe it cancels out. e: i need to stop loving sniping these pages
|
# ? Feb 16, 2018 05:38 |
|
|
# ? Jun 1, 2024 14:10 |
|
TheGreatEvilKing posted:Ugh, Dumbledore burning Narcissa alive is just taking a giant poo poo on that character. Narcissa is alive; Dumby just gave her amnesia and stuck her in a care facility. Still a dick move, but he was fighting a war against Magic Pol Pot.
|
# ? Feb 16, 2018 09:24 |
|
Added Space posted:Narcissa is alive; Dumby just gave her amnesia and stuck her in a care facility. Still a dick move, but he was fighting a war against Magic Pol Pot.
|
# ? Feb 16, 2018 18:05 |
|
Xander77 posted:Ok. What about the 10 years after Voldy was "defeated", with that lie being the main thing fueling his animosity with Lucius? Never mind what it does to Draco and Narcissa? I assume Yud's explanation is either 'Dumbledore knew all along' or 'She deserved eternal torture for not helping defeat him faster'.
|
# ? Feb 17, 2018 07:18 |
|
A prophecy made him do it
|
# ? Feb 17, 2018 07:39 |
|
Chapter 83: Taboo Tradeoffs, Aftermath 1quote:Rumor said that the Aurors had discovered that the Defense Professor had Polyjuiced as Granger to fool Malfoy.
|
# ? Feb 22, 2018 19:06 |
|
So I stopped following this thread when it took so long to actually go through it and started reading the fic itself as some sort of weird hate reading. It’s cute enough to have the concept of harry dismantling the wizard Ong world with logic but I feel it could have sustained a short story at best at a decent level of quality. That said I’m still reading it so what the gently caress do I know. I was on chapter 22 and what the gently caress is the line about padma patel doing well as she is from a non English background so her parents believe in education, and someone Goldstein is from a “tiny ethnic group that gets 25% of the worlds nobel prizes” Surely people weren’t happy with this- is that why there is a note at the start saying it’s not his opinion just that of the character? It’s such a pointless addition.
|
# ? Mar 11, 2018 01:14 |
|
teacup posted:So I stopped following this thread when it took so long to actually go through it and started reading the fic itself as some sort of weird hate reading. It’s cute enough to have the concept of harry dismantling the wizard Ong world with logic but I feel it could have sustained a short story at best at a decent level of quality. That said I’m still reading it so what the gently caress do I know. As an uncritical embrace of the Enlightenment, HPMOR includes more than a few weird racist bits. See my post history in this thread for a couple more.
|
# ? Mar 11, 2018 14:49 |
|
teacup posted:...and someone Goldstein is from a “tiny ethnic group that gets 25% of the worlds nobel prizes” That’s a thing, though. What causes it is open to research and debate. Why it was included in the text? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Jewish_intelligence E: even a small difference in average intelligence creates huge differences in outliers.
|
# ? Mar 11, 2018 20:44 |
|
Pvt.Scott posted:That’s a thing, though. What causes it is open to research and debate. Why it was included in the text? I figured it was just Yud doing a little bit of an ethnic brag there.
|
# ? Mar 12, 2018 11:44 |
|
Epicurius posted:I figured it was just Yud doing a little bit of an ethnic brag there. The rationalist subculture tends to a variant on white nationalism which includes Ashkenazi Jews, which both EY and Scott Alexander happen to be. (and /r/slatestarcodex is the sort of place where white nationalists get very upset if you call them white supremacists, where "race realism" isn't necessarily racist, and one of the mods calls himself an "ethno-utilitarian")
|
# ? Mar 12, 2018 17:16 |
divabot posted:The rationalist subculture tends to a variant on white nationalism which includes Ashkenazi Jews, which both EY and Scott Alexander happen to be. I found it weird that he kept bringing them up but that actually explains a lot.
|
|
# ? Mar 12, 2018 18:14 |
|
Chapter 84: Taboo Tradeoffs, Aftermath 2quote:"Surely you don't believe it?" said Professor McGonagall. "Miss Granger, you cannot believe of yourself that you would turn to murder!" quote:"I should - I should've -" quote:She wasn't awed by the list of precautions. Impressed with the cleverness, but not awed; she was a Transfiguration Mistress, after all. But it still sent shivers of disquiet through her, that Harry Potter now thought Hogwarts as dangerous as spell research. quote:"So you did not." Albus's eyes were saddened. "No, Minerva, you must not apologize. It is well. For what you have seen of me this day - if your first loyalty is now to Harry Potter, and not to me, then that is right and proper." She opened her lips to protest, but Albus went on before she could say a word. "Indeed - indeed - that will be necessary and more than necessary, if the Dark Lord that Harry must defeat to come into his power is not Voldemort after all -" quote:Let us repeat this for emphasis: Slobber slobber on another knob. quote:From his belt, the Auror took a mirror, tapped it once, and then said, "This is Junior Auror Arjun Altunay, I'm calling in code RJ-L20 on cell three." quote:"I shall not name any names," said the old witch. "But I shall tell a story, and see if it sounds familiar." Amelia Bones looked back down, turning to the next parchment. "Born 1927, entered Hogwarts in 1938, sorted into Slytherin, graduated 1945. Went on a graduation tour abroad and disappeared while visiting Albania. Presumed dead until 1970, when he returned to magical Britain just as suddenly, without any explanation for the missing twenty-five years. He remained estranged from his family and friends, living in isolation. In 1971, while visiting Diagon Alley, he fended off an attempt by Bellatrix Black to kidnap the daughter of the Minister of Magic, and used the Killing Curse to slay two of the three Death Eaters accompanying her. Beyond this all Britain knows the story; need I continue it?" The old witch looked up from her folder again. "Very well. There was a trial in the Wizengamot, during which this young man was exonerated for his use of the Killing Curse, not least due to the efforts of his grandmother, the Lady of his House. He was reconciled with his family, and they held a House gathering to welcome his return. The guest of honor arrived at that gathering to find his entire family slain by Death Eaters, even to the house elves; and that he himself, of cadet line, was now the last remaining scion of a Most Ancient House." quote:She looked at the green eyes of the Boy-Who-Lived, the mess of hair that didn't quite obscure the scar on his forehead; she looked upon the face of the boy who'd given all his money to save her without a second thought. There were feelings inside her - guilt, shame, embarrassment, other things as well - but no words. There was nothing she knew how to say. quote:The man stood within that doorway, saying nothing; and she couldn't see his eyes. What was he even doing there in the first place - quote:"I was going to be a hero, once," said Professor Quirrell, still looking upward. "Can you believe that, Miss Granger?" quote:"But you can, Miss Granger." Now the pale blue eyes watched her intently. "Whatever you wish to make of your life, you cannot attain it at Hogwarts, not anymore. This place is ruined for you now, even leaving aside all other threats. Simply ask Harry Potter to command you to go to Beauxbatons and live out your life in peace. If you stay here, he is your master in the eyes of Britain and its laws!" Xander77 fucked around with this message at 11:40 on Mar 19, 2018 |
# ? Mar 12, 2018 18:19 |
|
Xander77 posted:HPMOR ...Even with the entirety of the story bending over backwards to paint Harriezer as the smartest, most brilliantly creative person to ever exist , and the plot reeking of , Hermione still manages to the smartest (and best?) character.
|
# ? Mar 19, 2018 02:22 |
|
Chapter 85: Taboo Tradeoffs, Aftermath 3, Distancequote:Harry had seen Hermione safely off to bed. quote:After that Harry had left the common room quickly, because all the kindly forgiving sentiments he'd reasoned out were getting harder and harder to remember. Sometimes Harry thought the deepest split in his personality wasn't anything to do with his dark side; rather it was the divide between the altruistic and forgiving Abstract Reasoning Harry, versus the frustrated and angry Harry In The Moment. quote:Two nights ago his war had begun, and Harry didn't know with who. That, or the bad guy will outright reveal himself and they will monologue endlessly at each other until Voldy bows down to the sheer heights of assholishness display by Harriezer. One or the other. quote:At least his dark side hadn't asked anything of him in exchange for saving Hermione. Maybe because his dark side wasn't an imaginary voice like Hufflepuff; Harry might imagine his Hufflepuff part as wanting different things from himself, but his dark side wasn't like that. His "dark side", so far as Harry could tell, was a different way that Harry sometimes was. Right now, Harry wasn't angry; and trying to ask what "dark Harry" wanted was a phone ringing unanswered. The thought even seemed a little strange; could you owe something to a different way you sometimes were? quote:And then there was that promise Harry had sworn. quote:The Nazis had tried to ship the deuterium already refined to Germany, aboard a civilian Norwegian ferry, the SS Hydro. quote:Even in the world of comic books, the only reason a superhero like Batman even looks successful is that the comic-book readers only notice when Important Named Characters die, not when the Joker shoots some random nameless bystander to show off his villainy. Batman is a murderer no less than the Joker, for all the lives the Joker took that Batman could've saved by killing him. quote:What were the ultimate possibilities of invention, if the underlying laws of the universe permitted an eleven-year-old with a stick to violate almost every constraint in the Muggle version of physics? quote:If Hermione had been put in Azkaban, Harry would have called the phoenix and gone there and burned away every last Dementor and it wouldn't have made a single difference how crazy it was or what else he'd wanted to do with his life. That was just - that was - that was just how it was.
|
# ? Mar 19, 2018 12:27 |
|
Is it just me, or is Dumbledore the best written character in this story?
|
# ? Mar 19, 2018 12:50 |
|
The forums have trouble with long posts right now. Let's see if I can break this up a bit: Chapter 86: Multiple Hypothesis Testing quote:Toronto Magical Tribune: quote:"Prophecies are strange things," said Albus Dumbledore. The old wizard's eyes were half-lidded, as though in weariness. "Vague, unclear, meaning escaping like water held between loose fingers. Prophecy is ever a burden, for there are no answers there, only questions." quote:The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches... born to those who have thrice defied him, born as the seventh month dies..." It remains to be seen whether HPMOR complicates the final phrase out of sheer fetish for needless obfuscation, or it will actually matter in some way. quote:. "Then there's the power the Dark Lord knows not, which probably refers to my scientific background -" (Obviously, this question was answered a few times - welcome to HPMOR, where the plot lurches randomly and the themes don't matter - but it's worth reiterating) Anyways, there's some really pointless "so is Voldy back from the dead?" discussion that should have been resolved like 30 chapters ago: quote:Odds of a hundred to one, times a likelihood ratio of one to five, equals odds of twenty to one that the Dark Lord is dead - quote:"But what I'm qualitatively getting at is why the observation, 'The Dark Mark has not faded', is not adequate support for the hypothesis, 'The Dark Lord is immortal.' The evidence isn't as extraordinary as the claim." quote:"Could it be," Minerva said falteringly, "that You-Know-Who - that Voldemort - transferred some of his own powers to Mr. Potter, the night he gave him that scar? Not something he intended to do, surely. Still... I don't see how Mr. Potter could be his equal, if he had any less magic than the Dark Lord himself..." quote:"And after that, like I said, any behavioral difference between spies and nonspies can be used to identify spies. Once you've identified at least one magically censored secret of the Dark Mark, you can test someone for the Dark Mark by seeing if they can reveal that secret to somebody who doesn't already know it -" quote:And the true and honest reason Harry knew the Dark Lord couldn't have been that smart... well... there wasn't any tactful way to say it, but... Meanwhile at the Griffyndor table: quote:"I, for one, think it perfectly clear that Granger is Potter's moirail, and that Potter was auspisticing between Malfoy and Granger." The witch who'd spoken nodded with the self-satisfaction of someone who has just precisely nailed down a complicated issue. quote:There was a blur of motion as the resolving figure snapped up a wand, smoothly spinning with the Floo's momentum like a ballet dance step, so that his firing arc covered the entire 360-degree arc of the room; and then just as abruptly, the figure stopped in place. quote:I have a lead on a recent host of Voldie's. You're certain his shade is in Hogwarts now?"
|
# ? Apr 5, 2018 15:56 |
|
quote:Harry opened his eyes, his head feeling like it had been stuffed with cotton wool. quote:"That eye," said Harry Potter. There was a strange fierce light in the boy's eyes. "That isn't any ordinary device. It can see right through my invisibility cloak. You dodged my Transfigured taser as soon as I started raising it, even though I didn't speak any incantations. And now that I've watched it again - you spotted all my Time-Turned selves the moment you Flooed into this room, didn't you?" quote:Moody frowned. "Son, nobody gains power that fast without being up to something." I think there's a lot to unpack here about how "the good guys" of HPMOR apparently operate without Harriezer there to restrain them and what it means... eh. Leaving that aside for now on the off chance that the story returns to that theme. Brief interlude - Quirremort and Harriezer ponder who could have messed with Hermione: quote:"I can think of one other suspect," Harry said. "Someone you didn't put on your list at all. Would you analyze him to me, Professor?" quote:And then there were the various still-breathing bodies of Harry Potter he'd stashed in one quiet corner, cleaning up a mess that was his own in more ways than one. (Only one body wasn't inside a copy of the Invisibility Cloak; but then it merely took a small effort of concentration for Harry to perceive his other selves beneath the Cloak of which he was master - an effort which Harry had carefully not put forth earlier, to avoid getting advance temporal information he wanted to determine by his own decision.) Back to MEM, and the ostensible reason he even came here: quote:"eight years of complete horror after Monroe disappeared and Regulus Black - he was Monroe's private source in the Death Eaters, we're pretty sure - was executed by Voldie. Like a dam breaking and gore flooding out, drowning the whole country. Albus bloody Dumbledore himself had to step into Monroe's shoes, and that was barely enough for us to survive." quote:"And to answer your question, boy, there's two reasons why that spell's in the blackest book. The first is that the Killing Curse strikes directly at the soul, and it'll just keep going until it hits one. Straight through shields. Straight through walls. There's a reason why even Aurors fighting Death Eaters weren't allowed to use it before the Monroe Act." Harriezer doesn't note that. He just decides he's going to ask Quirrelmort some things only the original David would know to resolve the matter. quote:"Yes," Harry said, "that's exactly what I need to ask you about. In front of the Wizengamot, when Lucius Malfoy was saying that Hermione was no part of House Potter and that he wouldn't take the money, you told Hermione how to swear that oath. I want to know, if something like that comes up again, if your first duty is to the Hogwarts student Hermione Granger, or to the head of the Order of the Phoenix, Albus Dumbledore."
|
# ? Apr 5, 2018 15:58 |
|
quote:"In any case, Mr. Potter, Severus has always been entirely indifferent to the stares of those young girls. But now -" Professor McGonagall seemed to realize something, and hastily said, her hands rising in warding, "Please don't mistake me, Professor Snape certainly has not taken advantage of any young witches! Absolutely not! He has never even so much as smiled at one, not that I ever heard. He has told the young girls to stop gaping at him. And if they stare at him regardless, he looks away. That I have seen with my own eyes." quote:When the Potions Master was done, he spoke again. "I... do not know how to broach this topic, Mr. Potter, so I will simply say it... before the Dementor, you recovered your memory of the night your parents died?" quote:"The Dark Lord seized my mind and saw the mystification there, even if he could not seize the mystery, and so he knew the prophecy had been true. The Dark Lord could have killed me then, having taken what he wanted - I was a fool indeed to go to him - but he saw something in me I do not know, and took me into the Death Eaters, though on his terms rather than mine. That is how I brought it about, brought it all about, from beginning to end, always my own doing." Severus's voice had gone rather hoarse, and his face was filled with naked pain. "Now tell me, please, how did Lily die?"
|
# ? Apr 5, 2018 16:00 |
It's pretty clear that Yud didn't read the whole series because the theme of "good guys abusing government powers and becoming what they hate" is pretty much Barty Crouch and later the Ministry.
|
|
# ? Apr 6, 2018 01:17 |
TheGreatEvilKing posted:It's pretty clear that Yud didn't read the whole series because He just doesn't think it matters.
|
|
# ? Apr 6, 2018 18:35 |
|
quote:Harry lifted his glasses and rubbed his eyes, briefly. "Fine. How do we get Hermione off the hook, exactly? I suppose it's too much to hope that with all the lawyers gone, the judges understand the concept of 'common sense' and 'prior probability' well enough to realize that twelve-year-old girls basically never commit cold-blooded murders?"
|
# ? Apr 6, 2018 20:14 |
|
Cardiovorax posted:The most hilarious thing about this part is that it's basically suggesting that we should put social and sexual profiling over what the actual evidence and perpetrator statement indicate has actually happened... and that this is also what Yudkowsky's pathetic miscomprehension of Bayesian decision theory really says is what people should be doing. The "prior probability" of twelve year old girls murdering someone is substantially more important than personally seeing a twelve year old girl murdering someone in his worldview.
|
# ? Apr 7, 2018 02:54 |
|
Cardiovorax posted:The most hilarious thing about this part is that it's basically suggesting that we should put social and sexual profiling over what the actual evidence and perpetrator statement indicate has actually happened... and that this is also what Yudkowsky's pathetic miscomprehension of Bayesian decision theory really says is what people should be doing. The "prior probability" of twelve year old girls murdering someone is substantially more important than personally seeing a twelve year old girl murdering someone in his worldview. He absolutely does believe that. He and his followers are mostly, uh, "race realists", for instance.
|
# ? Apr 7, 2018 04:03 |
|
Cardiovorax posted:The most hilarious thing about this part is that it's basically suggesting that we should put social and sexual profiling over what the actual evidence and perpetrator statement indicate has actually happened... and that this is also what Yudkowsky's pathetic miscomprehension of Bayesian decision theory really says is what people should be doing. The "prior probability" of twelve year old girls murdering someone is substantially more important than personally seeing a twelve year old girl murdering someone in his worldview. who do you believe, profiling, or your own lying eyes?
|
# ? Apr 7, 2018 04:35 |
|
Remember, Yud is such a loving idiot that he believes that there's a chance that not bringing about the Singularity fast enough will drat you to having identical copies of you tortured forever. He is not a person who is at home with sense.
|
# ? Apr 7, 2018 06:57 |
|
Roko's Basilisk is the best thing https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DR7rurcamNo (Also the TF2 machinima version for anyone who hasn't seen it!) You don't exactly sign an actual contract in blood that is enforced by the literal Robot Devil to get trapped in Rationalist Robot Hell (in New Jersey!), sure. The contract is instead written in your own strength of conviction in the Singularity™ and enforced by your own concomitant abject terror of Rationalist Robot Hell. It's pretty poetic in a way.
|
# ? Apr 7, 2018 16:07 |
|
was this the part where Harry figured out he should distract Mad-Eye Moody with a spell that makes a bunch of invisible lights because he can still see them with his magic eye that was an actually clever bit of logic that I enjoyed
|
# ? Apr 12, 2018 17:11 |
|
No, he hit him with Stuperfy, a stunning spell with a bit of tracking. He learned it from Flitwick, a champion duelist. On the one hand this is kind of clever. On the other, it adds a plot hole for why this superior version isn't the standard.
|
# ? Apr 12, 2018 18:24 |
|
He did the lights thing first, to prime him for the stunner. The stunner isn't the world standard because it's explicitly a little secret trick of Flitwick's that he came up with himself. Honestly, sometimes I despair in y'all's extremely basic ability to follow a meandering 2500-page transhumanist nerdwank fanfiction serial. NihilCredo fucked around with this message at 18:51 on Apr 12, 2018 |
# ? Apr 12, 2018 18:48 |
|
Grace Baiting posted:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DR7rurcamNo ... Also, wizards apparenty lack scientific curiosity and understanding about how magic actually works - except coming up with new spells or improvements upon standard spells isn't even particularly remarkable. Welp. Xander77 fucked around with this message at 10:09 on Apr 17, 2018 |
# ? Apr 12, 2018 19:49 |
|
Grace Baiting posted:Roko's Basilisk is the best thing It's basically Pascal's Wager, except way more hosed-up, and since singularitarians don't believe that anything exists unless they invent it themselves nobody's thought about the Marcus Aurelius quote on the same subject or Michael Martin's extension of the subject across "believer" and "non-believer" categories.
|
# ? Apr 16, 2018 23:05 |
|
Chapter 87: Hedonic Awarenessquote:And ever since she'd been wondering what Harry thought of her now - if he hated her for having lost all his money - or if he really was in love with her and that's why he'd done it - or if he'd given up on her keeping pace with him because she couldn't frighten Dementors - she couldn't face him now, she just couldn't, she spent sleepless nights worrying what Harry thought of her now, and she was afraid, and she'd been avoiding the boy who'd spent all his money to save her, and she was a horrible ungrateful wretch, and a terrible person and - Anyways, Hermione is focused on coming up with a way to repay Harry's debt. Now that we're forced to come up with some get rich scheme that doesn't rely on the wizarding world being idiots, it's a lot harder. Oh, and the Philosopher's stone is unrealistic, obviously. quote:the Philosopher's Stone gives you unlimited gold and eternal life, not because there's a single magical discovery that would produce both of those effects, but because someone made up a story about a super happy thingy." Harriezer is doing the "find out who framed Hermione" quest right now. quote:"Okay, I guess," Hermione said leadenly. "Fine. You do everything. You gather all the clues and talk to all the suspects while I just sit here in the library. Let me know after it turns out that it was Professor Quirrell who did it." Harry is willing to acknowledge is pure sueishness at the moment, and turn it elsewhere, just to give Hermione a chance to shine with her canon smartness. Isn't that nice of him? Also, is Dracon a pure loving rear end in a top hat? quote:"If you believe that," she said with her voice unsteady, "if you can believe that, then you're evil. People are always responsible for what they do. It doesn't matter what anyone tells you to do, you're the one who does it. Everyone knows that -" quote:"You were doing SCIENCE with him? " quote:"Well..." she said in a rather high-pitched voice, "it's... oh, I don't know, Harry! Is it just a metaphor? When a boy spends a hundred thousand Galleons to save a girl from certain doom, she's entitled to wonder, don't you think? It's like being bought flowers, only, you see, rather more so -" quote:Tano Wolfe, of fifth-year Ravenclaw, slowly stood up from his library desk, from which vantage point he'd just watched Granger flee the library, sobbing. He hadn't been able to hear the argument, but it had clearly been one of those. Xander77 fucked around with this message at 21:09 on Apr 20, 2018 |
# ? Apr 17, 2018 11:42 |
|
Xander77 posted:but... still ugh. I feel like this is an apt summary for large swathes of this book tbh.
|
# ? Apr 17, 2018 16:10 |
|
|
# ? Apr 17, 2018 17:03 |
|
What the even gently caress is hedonic awareness? Jizzing in your pants because you’re just so smart and observant? I guess Stephen King was right; write what you know.
|
# ? Apr 18, 2018 17:19 |
|
Pvt.Scott posted:What the even gently caress is hedonic awareness? Jizzing in your pants because you’re just so smart and observant? I guess Stephen King was right; write what you know. it's probably being aware of the things that modify your hedonic levels, i.e. figuring out what is making you happy/unhappy and why
|
# ? Apr 18, 2018 22:38 |
|
DACK FAYDEN posted:gotta remember it's Big Yud Gibberish(tm) So... reinventing sati?
|
# ? Apr 18, 2018 23:44 |
|
Pvt.Scott posted:What the even gently caress is hedonic awareness? Jizzing in your pants because you’re just so smart and observant? I guess Stephen King was right; write what you know. Someone mentioned the hedonic treadmill to Yud and he went off on a dumbass tangent, I'm sure.
|
# ? Apr 19, 2018 02:52 |
|
|
# ? Jun 1, 2024 14:10 |
|
Roadie posted:So... reinventing sati? Sati is part of a religion and therefore This is obviously totally different because Yud said so.
|
# ? Apr 19, 2018 04:19 |