Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
Which House?
Black Eagles
Blue Lions
Golden Deer
View Results
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Blaze Dragon
Aug 28, 2013
LOWTAX'S SPINE FUND

Cythereal posted:

Dancer unlocks based on the plot, and it's a good thing to shove anyone who's not turning out well into. Any of the student characters (so not Catherine, Shamir, and I think Cyril, but Flayn can do it) can do it if they have 8 charm, which is doable for most of them. So if there's anyone you like but isn't pulling their weight and you still want to use them, make them your dancer.

Flayn can do it, but if she should is an entirely different matter.

I'm just saying this because a friend of mine made the mistake of making her a Dancer...while going for Crimson Flower. Big mistake. And I nearly did the same too, thankfully he made the mistake first.

Tired Moritz posted:

I hope in the next game, they nerf flyers to the ground. Or at least give them less ugly outfits

Agreed. It's kind of absurd just how much better the flying classes are than every other class.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Cythereal
Nov 8, 2009

I love the potoo,
and the potoo loves you.

Blaze Dragon posted:

Flayn can do it, but if she should is an entirely different matter.

I'm just saying this because a friend of mine made the mistake of making her a Dancer...while going for Crimson Flower. Big mistake. And I nearly did the same too, thankfully he made the mistake first.

My main reservation against making Flayn the dancer is that she, well, looks young.

She's actually pretty well suited to it, though. She comes out of the box with more than enough Charm, she's a priest stock so she can provide some healing support when you don't need the dances, her personal trait continues to push her towards a support role, and dancer obviates her problems as a general unit (slow, lacks Physic).

As the Deer, though, Lorenz is my usual pick for dancer. Guy just never seems to turn out very well, and he lives in a house filled with specialists.

Carlosologist
Oct 13, 2013

Revelry in the Dark

Horses were made nearly worthless for what, Canto? No thanks

mycatscrimes
Jan 2, 2020

Shadow225 posted:

Thanks for the replies everyone! I'll only quote one post because I'm on mobile.

One of the things that scared me away from FE is hearing people talk about optimal characters due to their stat growth. While obviously that's good info to know, I don't know how to grok that in game. I don't have to play super optimally, but I do think that way. Here instead of heavily researching everything, I had to concede to myself that I wasn't going to be perfect.

A lot of my choices were based on a combo of trying to have one of each class plus using a character's natural proclivities.
Byleth was a strong sword man, so I made him fast strong sword man.
Claude is the only Lord I have access to, so went there over Sniper.
Lorenz could have gona Cav or Mage, but I already had Lys as mage.
Hilda had natural axe proclivity, plus I like making female melee classes to overthrow the patriarchy in video games.
Raphael is obviously guided to heavy armor, but I wanted a punch man so a punch man he became.
Marianne was already in the white magic path.
Ignatz is probably better as a Sniper, but I didn't want Byleth to be my thief. Plus, I like the idea of a classy thief.
Lys is the natural mage of Deer.
Leonie most naturally fit cavalier, but at this point I didn't have an armor knight. Decided to get at least one. Training axe probably isn't the worst thing because she already had high Lance skill for the end game classes.
Catherine and Shamir stay in their respective classes.
Cyril became a sniper because Claude and Ignatz went different routes.
Dorothea seemed like a natural fit for mage. I've heard she makes a good dancer, but I don't actually see that as an option yet? Obviously it's an end game class, but I still don't see the option.
Sylvain will replace Lorenz as my cavalier once I recruit him.

I find FE to be an interesting series because while it teaches you how to play, it does not teach you how to play optimally. I guess few games do, but hiding stat growths and also having RNG in leveling up make for some weird decisions. Also things like all magic users should be mages or all melee should know axe are things I do not naturally encounter in game (at least yet).

Hopefully all of that came off more as me explaining my choices and critiques of the game rather than critique of your feedback!

Especially on normal/casual, but even on hard/casual, I don't think you need to worry about optimal play, go with your heart and what is most fun to you. : )

mycatscrimes
Jan 2, 2020

Tired Moritz posted:

I hope in the next game, they nerf flyers to the ground. Or at least give them less ugly outfits

I love fliers, but their movement power makes them already strong enough they have no need to be as ridiculously op as they are in 3H. Not that I'm not enjoying my all flier maddening run.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

Yeah if youre on normal its seriously not worrying about being the most optimal ever

Jade Mage
Jan 4, 2013

This is Canada. It snows nine months of the year, and hails the other three.

Has anyone had an Ignatz that was good? I've tried using him twice and both times he was godawful to the point I couldn't justify using him for his intended purpose and just went back specced him into armor knight later as a defense adjutant so I can say I used everyone. He was a garbage Sniper compared to any other option, and a worse mage.

mycatscrimes
Jan 2, 2020
Ignatz gets break shot and seal strength, plus hit+20 so he's got a niche as a long range debuffer in Sniper or that plus thief in Sniper+Assassain

He's also a decent support unit because he gets rally speed and rally strength. He can be an ok dancer as well. In my experience, he's never going to shine offensively, but he's definitely got a solid niche.

edit: realized I didn't answer your actual question
I have had Ignatzes that were quite valuable in the above roles (I actually ended up keeping him on my team through endgame in my first NG+ maddening run when I had planned on swapping him out), and I consider that good!

Unwise_Cashew
Jan 19, 2014
As an assassin he just decided to go off and proc Lethality on every other combat last time I did GD. I had really wanted to bench him for Ashe originally, but then he just would not stop murdering folks.

Natural 20
Sep 17, 2007

Wearer of Compasses. Slayer of Gods. Champion of the Colosseum. Heart of the Void.
Saviour of Hallownest.
He held up for me through to RaD but got dropped because he just doesn't really compete with a lot of the recruits.

McTimmy
Feb 29, 2008
My first Ignatz I dropped because he was slumming it out with Lorenz in uselessness and only came back because I had no one else leveled and Break Shot could at least add 20 damage a few times.

My second Ignatz I made a Trickster and he was decent at that since his spell list is decent but he still needed help damaging things. At least he could eat armors this time around.


This is still better than Lorenz who still struggled to get above 20 SPD over three playthroughs.

McTimmy fucked around with this message at 22:13 on Jun 9, 2020

eating only apples
Dec 12, 2009

Shall we dance?

Jade Mage posted:

Has anyone had an Ignatz that was good? I've tried using him twice and both times he was godawful to the point I couldn't justify using him for his intended purpose and just went back specced him into armor knight later as a defense adjutant so I can say I used everyone. He was a garbage Sniper compared to any other option, and a worse mage.

Got one right now, had to babysit him for a long time and maybe I got blessed with growths but he's a monster, his natural hit+20 stacks with the one from archer, with a longbow or even just the +1 range from sniper he can hit literally everything. Love that kid


Lorenz however is always garbage

Bad Video Games
Sep 17, 2017


Assassin Ignatz with a Wo Dao+ and a Killer Bow wrecks everything that moves.

AlternateNu
May 5, 2005

ドーナツダメ!
Started this maybe a week ago. On chapter 10 with the Red Eagles.

I haven't tried to recruit anyone from other houses, yet, (outside the other professors) because I've been so focused on ensuring my house's motivation remains peaked through lunches and gifts to maximize instruction sessions. So, I may be boning myself out of a lot of power?

Bernie was my early game all-star. Archers seem to be stupid good, and the sheer number of casters I have access to is kind of nuts for an FE game.

And I just realized that I missed level B with Rhea because I didn't bother checking my support link with her last month. >_> (I didn't bother to interact with her or Seth for a long while because it seemed pretty obvious that the Central Church are a bunch of psychopaths I'll eventually have to cleanse off this planet. :getin: ) Maybe that was a mistake?

Dr. Cool Aids
Jul 6, 2009

AlternateNu posted:

Started this maybe a week ago. On chapter 10 with the Red Eagles.

I haven't tried to recruit anyone from other houses, yet, (outside the other professors) because I've been so focused on ensuring my house's motivation remains peaked through lunches and gifts to maximize instruction sessions. So, I may be boning myself out of a lot of power?

Bernie was my early game all-star. Archers seem to be stupid good, and the sheer number of casters I have access to is kind of nuts for an FE game.

And I just realized that I missed level B with Rhea because I didn't bother checking my support link with her last month. >_> (I didn't bother to interact with her or Seth for a long while because it seemed pretty obvious that the Central Church are a bunch of psychopaths I'll eventually have to cleanse off this planet. :getin: ) Maybe that was a mistake?

How are your support levels with Edelgard and Hubert?

You'll want to be sure to save at the start of chapter 11, there's an easily missed choice you can make that will affect the latter half of the game (and your subsequent enjoyment probably, going by your last couple comments)

Zulily Zoetrope
Jun 1, 2011

Muldoon
Your starting roster is designed such that you'll be fine even if you don't bother with the recruiting mechanic.

Rhea's support level affects one decision on one route, so I wouldn't concern myself overmuch with it,

AlternateNu
May 5, 2005

ドーナツダメ!

Sudden Javelin posted:

How are your support levels with Edelgard and Hubert?

You'll want to be sure to save at the start of chapter 11, there's an easily missed choice you can make that will affect the latter half of the game (and your subsequent enjoyment probably, going by your last couple comments)

I'm at the "you must wait to further your relationship" point with basically everyone on my roster except Lindhardt.

I looked up the NG+ mechanics and am I correct in assuming that if you purchase the support rank for someone not in your house who you ranked up in a previous playthrough, you'll be able to recruit them almost immediately?

AradoBalanga
Jan 3, 2013

AlternateNu posted:

I'm at the "you must wait to further your relationship" point with basically everyone on my roster except Lindhardt.

I looked up the NG+ mechanics and am I correct in assuming that if you purchase the support rank for someone not in your house who you ranked up in a previous playthrough, you'll be able to recruit them almost immediately?
It's not just the support rank. You will need to spend renown on the corresponding skill that the character desires, and this can vary widely across the board. Perfect example: in one run, to recruit Dorothea very early to my team (Golden Deer), I had to not only run up Byleth's Authority rank to A, but then spend the renown to unlock Dorothea's A support because I still did not meet the required Charm check to recruit her until unlocking said A support. Then, on another run, bumping Byleth's Authority to A+ only required unlocking Dorothea's C support to recruit her. Or, for another case on my Blue Lions run, I had completely skipped any of Caspar's supports on my first playthrough, yet managed to recruit him with a C rank in Brawling and no support ranks with Caspar.

The best advice is to make sure you've hit anywhere from C+ rank to A rank in a skill to recruit someone. This will give you enough room to at least get some right away and save time on the more difficult recruits. Some characters (like Felix and Dorothea) will require specific stats to be at a certain amount before being recruited, so be ready to potentially save scum or wait until you've built some initial support points before trying to poach students.

AradoBalanga fucked around with this message at 01:53 on Jun 10, 2020

Bongo Bill
Jan 17, 2012

Once you reach support rank B with a student, there's a small chance that they'll randomly show up during lessons to ask to join your house, bypassing the ordinary stat requirement.

Amppelix
Aug 6, 2010

and if you buy an a rank, you can bypass that too and recruit them regardless of your stats

also there's no RNG in it at all, what are you talking about

here's a page with all information about recruiting you might want: https://serenesforest.net/three-houses/characters/recruitment/

Hunt11
Jul 24, 2013

Grimey Drawer

Amppelix posted:

and if you buy an a rank, you can bypass that too and recruit them regardless of your stats

also there's no RNG in it at all, what are you talking about

here's a page with all information about recruiting you might want: https://serenesforest.net/three-houses/characters/recruitment/

With the request to join your class with B rank there is.

Amppelix
Aug 6, 2010

yeah i was talking about this part from AradoBalanga: "And even then, there's still an element of RNG to recruit someone. On my Blue Lions run, I had completely skipped any of Caspar's supports on my first playthrough, yet managed to recruit him with a C rank in Brawling and no support ranks with Caspar."

turns out Caspar just wants C brawling and 10 strength. why did you think there was RNG involved?

AradoBalanga
Jan 3, 2013

Amppelix posted:

yeah i was talking about this part from AradoBalanga: "And even then, there's still an element of RNG to recruit someone. On my Blue Lions run, I had completely skipped any of Caspar's supports on my first playthrough, yet managed to recruit him with a C rank in Brawling and no support ranks with Caspar."

turns out Caspar just wants C brawling and 10 strength. why did you think there was RNG involved?
I was editing my post and put stuff in the wrong places. That's my bad.

Amppelix
Aug 6, 2010

ah, i see. well the pertinent point is that yes, you can ignore all the stat requirements with bought supports. with B rank the chance seems to be high enough that it'll happen within about a month usually, and you can also spend a bit more for an A and just get them instantly.

Endorph
Jul 22, 2009

I think on beagles route you'll want one person from another house to fill deployment limits on a couple maps? A flier would be good if you arent making petra one.

Hunt11
Jul 24, 2013

Grimey Drawer
If you are going Beagles it makes sense to grab Felix and Lysethia.

Zyxyz
Mar 30, 2010
Buglord
I've always wondered what would happen if you hacked Flayn's charm base low enough to lose the White Heron Cup (bc she joins with enough of it to guarantee a win normally, and everyone else has unique monastery dialogue afterwards for losing), but I don't have the knowledge to set up something like that myself and I don't have enough twitter presence to be able to ask one of the experts about it and actually get a reply :saddowns:

also, re: Ignatz chat

BisbyWorl
Jan 12, 2019

Knowledge is pain plus observation.


Hunt11 posted:

If you are going Beagles it makes sense to grab Felix and Lysethia.

It always makes sense to grab Lysithia, just so you have a magic nuke on hand at all times.

Shinji117
Jul 14, 2013

Hunt11 posted:

If you are going Beagles it makes sense to grab Felix and Lysethia.

Also Mercedes. And you should always grab Marianne, no matter what route you play on.

Cloacamazing!
Apr 18, 2018

Too cute to be evil

Shadow225 posted:

Thanks for the replies everyone! I'll only quote one post because I'm on mobile.

One of the things that scared me away from FE is hearing people talk about optimal characters due to their stat growth. While obviously that's good info to know, I don't know how to grok that in game. I don't have to play super optimally, but I do think that way. Here instead of heavily researching everything, I had to concede to myself that I wasn't going to be perfect.

A lot of my choices were based on a combo of trying to have one of each class plus using a character's natural proclivities.
Byleth was a strong sword man, so I made him fast strong sword man.
Claude is the only Lord I have access to, so went there over Sniper.
Lorenz could have gona Cav or Mage, but I already had Lys as mage.
Hilda had natural axe proclivity, plus I like making female melee classes to overthrow the patriarchy in video games.
Raphael is obviously guided to heavy armor, but I wanted a punch man so a punch man he became.
Marianne was already in the white magic path.
Ignatz is probably better as a Sniper, but I didn't want Byleth to be my thief. Plus, I like the idea of a classy thief.
Lys is the natural mage of Deer.
Leonie most naturally fit cavalier, but at this point I didn't have an armor knight. Decided to get at least one. Training axe probably isn't the worst thing because she already had high Lance skill for the end game classes.
Catherine and Shamir stay in their respective classes.
Cyril became a sniper because Claude and Ignatz went different routes.
Dorothea seemed like a natural fit for mage. I've heard she makes a good dancer, but I don't actually see that as an option yet? Obviously it's an end game class, but I still don't see the option.
Sylvain will replace Lorenz as my cavalier once I recruit him.

I find FE to be an interesting series because while it teaches you how to play, it does not teach you how to play optimally. I guess few games do, but hiding stat growths and also having RNG in leveling up make for some weird decisions. Also things like all magic users should be mages or all melee should know axe are things I do not naturally encounter in game (at least yet).

Hopefully all of that came off more as me explaining my choices and critiques of the game rather than critique of your feedback!

One of the endgame classes is Great Knight, it requires Axe, Lance and Riding. Your Leonie might be a good fit for that.

About replacing Lorenz, one thing you should be warned about is that all your initial students are required for one very difficult battle. If you neglect Lorenz, you might find yourself in a difficult situation. Make sure you keep him leveled even if you don't plan to take him through endgame.

Tired Moritz
Mar 25, 2012

wish Lowtax would get tired of YOUR POSTS

(n o i c e)
Honestly, you should buy skills instead of supports if you want to do recruitments because you also get an instruction bonus for the pain in the rear end skills like riding/armor/flying/authority and you can also skip talking to teachers to get your axe/reason up for death blow/fiendish blow if you want to pick up Hilda or Lorentz.

That and buying your students' friendship is not cool.

Amppelix
Aug 6, 2010

that assumes that you actually trained in those skills during a previous game though

on your first NG+ you're definitely not going to have the all skills at C byleth

Zulily Zoetrope
Jun 1, 2011

Muldoon

Endorph posted:

I think on beagles route you'll want one person from another house to fill deployment limits on a couple maps? A flier would be good if you arent making petra one.

You can fill all the deployment slots with just your core students, teachers and knights on every route. It's maybe not ideal, but it's enough to get by on any non-Maddening difficulty.

Amppelix
Aug 6, 2010

if you want to fill all adjutant slots you will need to poach some people though (including adjutants the maximum deployment limit in 3H is 15)

snoremac
Jul 27, 2012

I LOVE SEEING DEAD BABIES ON 𝕏, THE EVERYTHING APP. IT'S WORTH IT FOR THE FOLLOWING TAB.
The transition between accepting Ingrid's paralogue and the battle leaves a lot of questions. It goes from the monastery to "Well, now that we found evidence your suitor is corrupt here in this lava cave, let's go home."

Cythereal
Nov 8, 2009

I love the potoo,
and the potoo loves you.

snoremac posted:

The transition between accepting Ingrid's paralogue and the battle leaves a lot of questions. It goes from the monastery to "Well, now that we found evidence your suitor is corrupt here in this lava cave, let's go home."

You'll eventually discover that the lava area in question is a volcanic crater on the border between the Kingdom and Alliance, and a popular place for meetings and transactions away from prying eyes. The location makes sense, the mission just doesn't explain it.

Amppelix
Aug 6, 2010

that reminds me: in general the before battle-storytelling in 3H is super sparse for no apparent reason. like a pretty high number of the maps in the game begin with some sort of "ah, now let us see what is going on over there" dialogue, which immediately and very jarringly transitions to battle preparations with the enemy already in formation on the map. what happened to the part where your characters arrive on the soon-to-be battlefield, have a short conversation, and then all the enemies jump out from a pocket dimension?

snoremac
Jul 27, 2012

I LOVE SEEING DEAD BABIES ON 𝕏, THE EVERYTHING APP. IT'S WORTH IT FOR THE FOLLOWING TAB.

Cythereal posted:

You'll eventually discover that the lava area in question is a volcanic crater on the border between the Kingdom and Alliance, and a popular place for meetings and transactions away from prying eyes. The location makes sense, the mission just doesn't explain it.
Ah. Yeah, it was jarring without that info.

AlternateNu
May 5, 2005

ドーナツダメ!
So, I just got past the split in the Eagles route. :stare:

The hosed up part is I chose the path that apparently made me lose all the non-core units I was training except Shamir. :cry:

Edit: Oh wait. NM. I just lost Flayne. Still...she was my main ferry boat with access to 6 x Rescue. :/

AlternateNu fucked around with this message at 16:05 on Jun 10, 2020

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

cams
Mar 28, 2003


AlternateNu posted:

So, I just got past the split in the Eagles route. :stare:

The hosed up part is I chose the path that apparently made me lose all the non-core units I was training except Shamir. :cry:
you made the right choice, gently caress em

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply