|
MarcusSA posted:Maybe I’m an an actor. Perhaps even a bad one
|
# ? Jun 19, 2021 19:13 |
|
|
# ? Jun 7, 2024 07:06 |
|
Lol. China gonna China. https://twitter.com/niccijsmith/status/1406241035819253765?s=19
|
# ? Jun 20, 2021 01:26 |
|
BrigadierSensible posted:This is a Chinese cartoon character. His name is Hui Tai Lang. Darn goats! I will definitely come back again!
|
# ? Jun 20, 2021 03:20 |
|
Redgrendel2001 posted:Lol. China gonna China. Lol, US playing vacinne diplomacy, why send it to Taiwan that had few cases when India needs it so much more. Also, Taiwan can buy the Biontech vacinne from Fosun Pharmaceutical at anytime they want, they just refuse to score political points. And since Fosun has exclusivity for the greater China region its purely contractual why Taiwan can't buy directly from Biontech, politics has nothing to do with it.
|
# ? Jun 21, 2021 05:19 |
|
GlassEye-Boy posted:Lol, US playing vacinne diplomacy, why send it to Taiwan that had few cases when India needs it so much more. Because 2.5 million doses can make a much bigger difference in a small island nation like Taiwan, can have a noticeable impact in slowing community transmission.
|
# ? Jun 21, 2021 07:50 |
|
Didn't they boast about giving Trinidad 80 vials? Could have covered the entire nation.
|
# ? Jun 21, 2021 12:38 |
|
So did Dong Jingwei defect to the US or is he still chairing meetings in China?
|
# ? Jun 21, 2021 21:54 |
|
radicaldreamer posted:So did Dong Jingwei defect to the US or is he still chairing meetings in China? The last I'd heard of him, it was in a government report article from last Friday which said he was chairing a meeting on counterintelligence. No direct quotes or photos, so there is naturally some speculation. I'd be very surprised if the CCP released a report that could be so quickly proven false if Dong had defected.
|
# ? Jun 22, 2021 00:15 |
|
Epinephrine posted:Umm, do you know who runs and administers that website? Do you think they might have a vested interest in presenting false or misleading data? It's hilarious that you have the guts to dare to ask about the "backing" of a website that clearly shows your cold war V2 propaganda is wrong but then quote Adrian Zen, the German fundamentalist that never step foot in China but totally knows all about the genocide. Hell, they're STILL SHARING BDSM PORN as documented evidence of the genocide: https://mobile.twitter.com/auighur/status/1272360467479085056
|
# ? Jun 26, 2021 19:15 |
|
Mans posted:It's hilarious that you have the guts to dare to ask about the "backing" of a website that clearly shows your cold war V2 propaganda is wrong but then quote Adrian Zen, the German fundamentalist that never step foot in China but totally knows all about the genocide.
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 01:55 |
|
Fojar38 posted:As you've pointed out, there is a very large amount of evidence corroborating the Chinese governments ongoing genocide of the Uigher peoples that has nothing to do with Adrian Zenz. The only reason he ever comes up nowadays is when tankies want to deny the genocide as his other (and irrelevant) beliefs are what they've chosen to latch onto to undermine the evidence. At this point seeing anyone go "but Adrian Zenz" should be a red flag in the same sense that bringing up George Soros out of the blue is. Fritz the Horse posted:Yeah, Zenz may be a wacky evangelical Christian but that doesn't really have any bearing on the fact that almost all of his work is drawing from official Chinese government documents. And is corroborated by other sources including lots of eyewitness testimony. As for this: Mans posted:Hell, they're STILL SHARING BDSM PORN as documented evidence of the genocide: Why did you link a random Twitter account and why are you claiming it's BDSM porn?
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 06:08 |
|
Epinephrine posted:Did you mean to quote someone else in this thread or to post some other thread? Why would I mean to quote this on any other thread? Your main sources of arguments in favor of the alleged genocide is a German nutjob and the United States foreign secretary, so it's incredibly brave to, and I quote, try to raise suspicious on "who runs and administers that website" simply for contradicting your narrative or if "they might have a vested interest in presenting false or misleading data" when, I repeat, the main sources of propaganda dissemination about the supposed genocide are literally posting BDSM porn as proof of the genocide. There's a clear and intentional misinformation campaign going on while the United States tries to desperately conjure a new cold war due to seeing their relevancy quickly fading from the international world. You can believe it and the comically untrustworthy sources all you want, but I'd rather not applaud and drag myself into yet another war justification zeitgueist. Where's the Iraqi weapons of mass destruction? Where's the bodies of the babies that were ripped out of incubators in Kuwait? Where in Afghanistan did we find Bin Laden? How can 60% of the Uighur population be detained (or KILLED!) and yet there's no internal resistance, the cities in the region are thriving and open to literally any western to visit at any time and not a single Muslim country has actually condemned it? Will the number rise to eight million today? Nine million tomorrow? Tune in to the $300 million trust fund built explicitly to finance propaganda against China to find out! https://www.scmp.com/comment/opinio...Di1XiSpKv8nUiuc (USER WAS PUT ON PROBATION FOR THIS POST) (USER WAS PUT ON PROBATION FOR THIS POST)
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 13:14 |
|
Mans posted:Why would I mean to quote this on any other thread? Your main sources of arguments in favor of the alleged genocide is a German nutjob and the United States foreign secretary, so it's incredibly brave to, and I quote, try to raise suspicious on "who runs and administers that website" simply for contradicting your narrative or if "they might have a vested interest in presenting false or misleading data" when, I repeat, the main sources of propaganda dissemination about the supposed genocide are literally posting BDSM porn as proof of the genocide. Whataboutism at its finest.
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 13:18 |
|
Mans posted:the cities in the region are thriving and open to literally any western to visit at any time and not a single Muslim country has actually condemned it? This is absolutely not true, please look it up. Foreign tourists are not allowed to visit certain no-go areas in Xinjiang. I wonder why? EDIT: Although in fairness, you did say cities, maybe the larger cities are all open, but there are certainly towns that are often on blacklists. But the point stands: as a visitor you cannot go anywhere you like, certain parts of the region are verboten at any given time. I'm sure all the places on the main tourist trails are great! But that doesn't really mean anything. Rabelais D fucked around with this message at 13:52 on Jun 27, 2021 |
# ? Jun 27, 2021 13:44 |
|
Best of luck my friend but it's abundantly clear that this thread will dogpile anyone who claims anything short of 'China is literally doing a Holocaust', it's not worth the headache (USER WAS PUT ON PROBATION FOR THIS POST)
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 14:23 |
|
I actually kinda think it may be interesting to get into the weeds as to just how flawed Mans genocide denial argument is. 1. Repeatedly ignoring the evidence and selectively overemphasizing evidence they can most easily attack. quote:Your main sources of arguments in favor of the alleged genocide is a German nutjob and the United States foreign secretary There have been plenty of collaborated sources in this thread among others collaborating whats happening in Xianjiang, I'm not sure why you think the US Foreign Secretary (or did you mean Secretary of State?) is a bad source but they're usually picked because they are a credible face to present to the international community and possess much expertese on the diplomatic and geopolitical happenings around the world. Regardless even with the most surface level internet search I can find plenty of sources, such as the BBC and Al Jazeera that collaborate these reports. Yes they refer to Blinken but the main new body of evidence is the report. Leftist Youtube Vaush actually did a good deal of research to confirm the fact that there's a lot of collaborating evidence. Research stream You keep repeating and attacking Adrien Zens or the US but the fact is there's loads more evidence then that and most people that I can see in this thread aren't remotely relying on it even if they mention it at all. But you keep repeating it as if it was all people had which isn't true and is deeply disingenuous. 2. Appeal to Conspiracy & Appeal to motive: quote:There's a clear and intentional misinformation campaign going on while the United States tries to desperately conjure a new cold war due to seeing their relevancy quickly fading from the international world. You're adopting a siege mentality almost word for word from Umberto Eco; the US is behind the evidence for what China is doing, and they're doing it to "conjure a new cold war" which of course has to ignore that China is invading its neighbours thus causing many nations in Asia to ally with the United States for mutual defence. And even if we pretend for a moment that I think the US containing Chinese aggression in the SCS is morally quantifiable as "wrong" It's not the fact remains the US is doing something in response to China doing something bad; that China is a bad international actor is irrefutable, and if the US is "setting up a new cold war" it's doing so at China's invitation. However most importantly the evidence is coming from the US, the US didn't fabricate the evidence, it didn't set people up to misconstrue any information, there are plenty of international orgs, plus Chinese government documentation, and imagery taken from literally space that all collaborates this information and it isn't the United States that's the origin of this information. 3. The "Media/Science was wrong before" fallacy. quote:Where's the Iraqi weapons of mass destruction? Where's the bodies of the babies that were ripped out of incubators in Kuwait? Where in Afghanistan did we find Bin Laden? So first, one of these is not like the others. Osama was in Afghanistan during the US invasion, but he escaped. So disregarding that example; you seem to be suggesting that just because the media (I point out, the media reporting on these issues, not necessarily the US) was wrong before or gave credence to exaggerated reports of atrocities; it means all such reports forever more are just automatically wrong should be obviously fallacious to any reasonable observer. Especially when we consider the wider body of evidence that collaborates what the US is saying. At most one should be healthily skeptical until enough evidence is provided and collaborated to come to a conclusion based on the preponderance of the evidence. And right now that preponderance points to that a genocide by any definition is occurring. 4. "If the holocaust was happening why didn't the Jews resist?" quote:How can 60% of the Uighur population be detained (or KILLED!) and yet there's no internal resistance, the cities in the region are thriving and open to literally any western to visit at any time and not a single Muslim country has actually condemned it? A totalitarian government like China is easily able to control all facets of a sparsely populated region; but people have already spoken to the fact that much of the region is off limits to visitors and that obviously China is going to provide well polished Potemkin villages for the benefit of outsiders. 5. Revisionism. quote:Will the number rise to eight million today? Nine million tomorrow? Tune in to the $300 million trust fund built explicitly to finance propaganda against China to find out! The timestamps on those tweets suggest that there is a gap of months if not years between reports on the numbers; maybe the numbers aren't accurate but its a bad argument to appeal to this kind of, I wanna say slippery slope? Because obviously the number of people arrested or put into the camps/gulags is going to rise as the program enters into full swing. Just like the number of people killed in every previous past atrocity spiked after the initial period. It takes time to build the camps and arrest and relocate people so of course the numbers will steadily increase and perhaps accelerate as a bunch of camps come online and more security forces are deployed to the region. The other thing that makes this argument bad is that you seem to be pointing at one specific account citing numbers as a proxy to doubt all numbers being relayed to the wider public; the BBC suggests its 1 million people. But I don't think it matters if its 1 million or 10 million or 10,000 wrong is wrong. In short you're making a sort of guilt by association fallacy argument to suggest that because this one account might be inflating the numbers, all accounts are in doubt? Please.
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 17:53 |
|
On top of what everyone else said, it's incredibly strange to take all of that and try to lay it at my feet, specifically. Also, what is cold war V2 propaganda, is poster trying to say that the German rocket program was a lie made up by the allies or something?
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 18:14 |
|
I'm glad China has been improved upon over a century despite so many trying to stifle their success. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACA774bm9wU
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 18:17 |
|
Epinephrine posted:Also, what is cold war V2 propaganda, is poster trying to say that the German rocket program was a lie made up by the allies or something? They mean like Cold War 2.0
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 18:41 |
|
I do not think that we're in danger of entering a "cold war 2.0" with China that will be a repeat of the first cold war with the USSR. Different ideology, different history, different regional and global ambitions, etc. I actually see the value in the argument that Biden is making, that we're heading into the 21st century at a crossroads between democracy and authoritarianism, and that we need to prove that democracy is the better model. If that type of framing, that type of competition, gets us to reinvest in things that we have neglected for decades like education and manufacturing and building back a middle class then I'm for it.
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 19:12 |
|
Why is it incredibly difficult for certain people in this thread to hold two ideas in their head at the same time? “The US is lovely and has done/is doing/will almost certainly continue to do awful things” and “China is lovely and has done/is doing/will almost certainly continue to do awful things” are not two contrarian opinions. You can believe both! One does not negate the other!
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 19:34 |
|
tigersklaw posted:Why is it incredibly difficult for certain people in this thread to hold two ideas in their head at the same time? “The US is lovely and has done/is doing/will almost certainly continue to do awful things” and “China is lovely and has done/is doing/will almost certainly continue to do awful things” are not two contrarian opinions. You can believe both! One does not negate the other! Because rooting for a team is always more popular than pointing out how dumb the game itself is. Also, the failure mode of the above sentiment is extreme relativism, which doesn't help improve anyone's situation. Just to be clear, I fully agree with what you said.
|
# ? Jun 27, 2021 23:10 |
|
Mans posted:Where's the Iraqi weapons of mass destruction? Where's the bodies of the babies that were ripped out of incubators in Kuwait? Where in Afghanistan did we find Bin Laden? this is the sort of whataboutism which is so excruciatingly transparent and boring and rote that its really why weirdly one-note china apologists basically have to have canned responses ready for when they get called whatabouters for all the painfully straightforward whatabouting. like, it isn't even mixed up or made fresh at all, it's just a textbook play. bless
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 04:06 |
|
Raenir Salazar posted:but people have already spoken to the fact that much of the region is off limits to visitors and that obviously China is going to provide well polished Potemkin villages for the benefit of outsiders. do you have any more info on this? before covid i was planning to visit xinjiang and would still like to go at some point, but i can’t really find any info on this other than the karakorum highway sometimes needing a permit
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 04:50 |
|
fart simpson posted:do you have any more info on this? before covid i was planning to visit xinjiang and would still like to go at some point, but i can’t really find any info on this other than the karakorum highway sometimes needing a permit I did a quick search, there's at least one travel blog I was able to quickly find that attests to secret or off limits areas albeit its buried within the article: https://journeybeyondhorizon.com/xinjiang-travel-regulations-foreigners/#Forbidden_areas_in_Xinjiang its in comic sans so I know its credible. This website also discusses forbidden areas: https://caravanistan.com/east-turkestan/#forbidden-areas Both articles also discusses the extremely frequent checkpoint stops and police & secret police presence in Xinjiang; so I expect any protests or indication that an area might give foreigners information on the situation presumably get sweeped prior to you reaching there.
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 05:24 |
|
Raenir Salazar posted:I actually kinda think it may be interesting to get into the weeds as to just how flawed Mans genocide denial argument is. drat son you killed him
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 09:56 |
|
So this is why all the pro-genocide crypto-fascists have been turning up in the GBS thread. They've been getting their loving asses handed to them in this one. (USER WAS PUT ON PROBATION FOR THIS POST)
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 14:19 |
|
Megillah Gorilla posted:So this is why all the pro-genocide crypto-fascists have been turning up in the GBS thread. I sure hope you don't think a dude linking a loving Vaush video, the pewdiepie of "socialists" on youtube, is owning anyone. I believe it was the QCS drama that signal boosted thats we have a bunch of psycho racists really concerned about the Chinese question and "yellow hitler"
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 15:38 |
|
Terminal autist posted:I sure hope you don't think a dude linking a loving Vaush video, the pewdiepie of "socialists" on youtube, is owning anyone. I believe it was the QCS drama that signal boosted thats we have a bunch of psycho racists really concerned about the Chinese question and "yellow hitler" What?
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 16:06 |
|
Terminal autist posted:I sure hope you don't think a dude linking a loving Vaush video, the pewdiepie of "socialists" on youtube, is owning anyone. I believe it was the QCS drama that signal boosted thats we have a bunch of psycho racists really concerned about the Chinese question and "yellow hitler" You're literally acting out that drill tweet.
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 16:38 |
|
Terminal autist posted:I sure hope you don't think a dude linking a loving Vaush video, the pewdiepie of "socialists" on youtube, is owning anyone. I believe it was the QCS drama that signal boosted thats we have a bunch of psycho racists really concerned about the Chinese question and "yellow hitler" What do you actually mean by "the pewdiepie of socialists"? Like, I have no clue who Vaush is, so it would be helpful if you had a specific criticism rather than a vague assertion that just sort of implies he's generically bad. Is there something about him that makes him less credible?
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 16:49 |
|
Do you have anything to say about the stream that is objectionable? I watched close to the entirety of it and it seems like it is a good primer for the genocide happening in Xinjiang by China in addition to going over the available open source evidence. The history background, the events leading up to today, going over various documents, and so on. I didn't see anything sketchy in there, can you point out any flaws to Vaush's arguments and evidence?
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 16:51 |
|
Android Blues posted:What do you actually mean by "the pewdiepie of socialists"? Like, I have no clue who Vaush is, so it would be helpful if you had a specific criticism rather than a vague assertion that just sort of implies he's generically bad. Is there something about him that makes him less credible? I think it's referring to his use of the n-word, which he has a history of throwing out there.
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 16:53 |
|
Terminal autist posted:I sure hope you don't think a dude linking a loving Vaush video, the pewdiepie of "socialists" on youtube, is owning anyone. I believe it was the QCS drama that signal boosted thats we have a bunch of psycho racists really concerned about the Chinese question and "yellow hitler" Please point out the psycho racists in this thread thanks (believing that what's going on in Xinjiang is bad does not make one a racist hth)
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 16:57 |
|
Terminal autist posted:I believe it was the QCS drama that signal boosted thats we have a bunch of psycho racists really concerned about the Chinese question and "yellow hitler" I'm concerned that the Chinese government is committing genocide, because of the doing genocide thing that they're doing and trying to pass off as "vocational training," aren't you concerned? I'm always concerned by genocide, personally.
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 17:04 |
|
Terminal autist posted:I sure hope you don't think a dude linking a loving Vaush video, the pewdiepie of "socialists" on youtube, is owning anyone. I believe it was the QCS drama that signal boosted thats we have a bunch of psycho racists really concerned about the Chinese question and "yellow hitler" It is some really wild rhetorical boomeranging to argue in favor of denying a genocide and then in the same sentence use "the Chinese question" to equate the state actually committing the genocide to Jews in Nazi Germany.
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 18:57 |
|
Terminal autist posted:I sure hope you don't think a dude linking a loving Vaush video, the pewdiepie of "socialists" on youtube, is owning anyone. I believe it was the QCS drama that signal boosted thats we have a bunch of psycho racists really concerned about the Chinese question and "yellow hitler" What in the utter gently caress are you on about.
|
# ? Jun 28, 2021 23:47 |
|
Looks like the July 1 walk in HK is banned again this year.
|
# ? Jun 30, 2021 02:05 |
|
|
# ? Jun 7, 2024 07:06 |
|
stop saying "collaborating evidence" when you mean "corroborating evidence"
|
# ? Jun 30, 2021 10:20 |