Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
my bony fealty
Oct 1, 2008

algebra testes posted:

John Hawkes is absolutely killing as just the worst dude ever, by the way. Just total dogshit. Great performance.

Yeah he sucks rear end (the character), really great performance. I'm more interested in knowing how his Russian wife saga ends than the murder mystery.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Open Source Idiom
Jan 4, 2013

CatstropheWaitress posted:

It's been borderline jarring to see, as I only really know the actor from Deadwood where he's playing the West's biggest sweetheart. Sal, what happened my dude

You've not seen Mary Marcy May Marlene yeah? He's a real POS in that

I AM GRANDO
Aug 20, 2006

DeadFatDuckFat posted:

All the crap with the cop sister and cop daughter better go somewhere/tie in to anything because its pretty awful and a waste of screen time each week if they end up not mattering at all.

There was a point in the second episode of Mare of Easttown where I realized that it wasn’t a mystery crime drama but a drama involving a mystery. This one still feels like a crime drama halfway through and I also don’t know how to take the family stuff.

I will say that the scenes of the daughter going out with her girlfriend make me really reflect on how lovely dating must be in that town. Go walk around the supermarket? Great! Where else is there? Uh, the protest planning session in a big dirty garage where people break down crying about how their families are dying?

mystes
May 31, 2006

I AM GRANDO posted:

There was a point in the second episode of Mare of Easttown where I realized that it wasn’t a mystery crime drama but a drama involving a mystery. This one still feels like a crime drama halfway through and I also don’t know how to take the family stuff.
I'm still watching this, but I do think this show has an issue where the pacing of the mystery is quite slow so it really needs the other elements to keep it interesting, but the drama stuff doesn't feel like it's quite fleshed enough to to do that in the vein of Mare of Easttown

I'm probably going to keep watching to the end at this point, but considering that we're half way through, unless some crazy poo poo starts happening or the writing massively improves, I have trouble imagining it ending as anything more than average at this point (hopefully I'm wrong)

right arm
Oct 30, 2011

Lmfao just watched the newest episode. this turd is getting stinkier

TheBizzness
Oct 5, 2004

Reign on me.
The most recent episode was not good imo but I still have hope.

THIS_IS_FINE
May 21, 2001

Slippery Tilde
I like the show so far I'm genuinely surprised so many people seem to be hate watching. There is way worse poo poo on TV.

my bony fealty
Oct 1, 2008

I would feel a lot more satisfied with the show if just one of the mysteries had been solved by now, halfway through. Or at least progress made. Instead we've got a bunch of stuff that presumably will get some kind of resolution near the end.

This is something S1 does exceptionally well, there's a huge climax with a (false) resolution to the murder mystery at the end of the 5th episode and a really tense build up to it in the 4th. The audience is left feeling like the detectives did their job and solved the case, even if we also feel something isn't quite right.

Maybe we'll get some kind of climax in episode 4, I hope so, the wheel spinning is frustrating.

counterfeitsaint
Feb 26, 2010

I'm a girl, and you're
gnomes, and it's like
what? Yikes.
Two of the mysteries have been solved. We know the one lady died in an ice cave, terrified, by what sounds like some eldritch monster poo poo.

We also learned what your mother sucks in hell

covidstomper58
Nov 8, 2020

Next episode we should see the mid season shootout which I'm guessing will be possessed polar bears attacking the mining company blasting ice breath and throwing oranges at the miners which turn them into screaming hell zombs.

Rust Cohle shows up and announces he's a Brujo, and has to escort Navarro and Captain Danvers across the battlefield to the center of it to cast his spell in a technological marvel of an 8 minute single take.

Marnie shows up at the last minute to disrupt the lines of his magic circle which are made of meth.

mystes
May 31, 2006

covidstomper58 posted:

Next episode we should see the mid season shootout which I'm guessing will be possessed polar bears attacking the mining company blasting ice breath and throwing oranges at the miners which turn them into screaming hell zombs.

Rust Cohle shows up and announces he's a Brujo, and has to escort Navarro and Captain Danvers across the battlefield to the center of it to cast his spell in a technological marvel of an 8 minute single take.

Marnie shows up at the last minute to disrupt the lines of his magic circle which are made of meth.
I would watch this

TheBizzness
Oct 5, 2004

Reign on me.
True Detective Blood

Doltos
Dec 28, 2005

🤌🤌🤌
I think the problem with this season is that everyone's just a mean, nasty rear end in a top hat for no good reason. Peter is like the only person who isn't a complete douchebag to other characters. His girlfriend calls him stupid and demeans him. Danvers is just a mean boss. Navarro kinda sexual assaulted a guy in episode 1 and then showed up on his doorstep when he told her not to... and she's a lead character we're supposed to cheer for. Hank is just a seedy creep. Every town member is either stupid, incompetent, or mean. I don't know who we're supposed to cheer for.

Despera
Jun 6, 2011
I loved succession and everyone is an rear end in a top hat in it. Root for your favorite rear end in a top hat, who cares?

boo boo bear
Oct 1, 2009

I'm COMPLETELY OBSESSED with SEXY EGGS
just like magnets got two poles, some assholes are fascinating and others are repulsive. this show is only giving us the latter.

I AM GRANDO
Aug 20, 2006

Who’s the kindest true detective? I vote Hays in season 3. Taylor Kitsch didn’t seem too bad either.

Sickening
Jul 16, 2007

Black summer was the best summer.

boo boo bear posted:

just like magnets got two poles, some assholes are fascinating and others are repulsive. this show is only giving us the latter.

Can't have rupulsive assholes in my tv show, it ruins the experience!

Open Source Idiom
Jan 4, 2013

boo boo bear posted:

just like magnets got two poles, some assholes are fascinating and others are repulsive. this show is only giving us the latter.

wait wait wait wait wait

wait

magnets repel magnets that are alike

:tinfoil:

boo boo bear
Oct 1, 2009

I'm COMPLETELY OBSESSED with SEXY EGGS

Sickening posted:

Can't have rupulsive assholes in my tv show, it ruins the experience!

yes. let's compare it to a better show, say deadwood. you've got calamity jane and sy tolliver, both tremendous pieces of poo poo by any definition, but we want one to be redeemed and the other to be hit in the face repeatedly with a brick because they're fascinating characters who draw us into the world. find me a character with similar appeal in this show.

Doltos
Dec 28, 2005

🤌🤌🤌
The two leads being assholes is applicable here because S1 is defined more by McConaughey and Harrelson than the story, I think. They had complex characters that weren't exactly nice or good people but were somewhat understandable and relatable.

I don't even think it's Foster or Reis at fault. The writing itself seems thin across the board. Nothing seems particularly fleshed out, from the other townsfolk to the town itself. So far the most development has been with the indigenous people, which is fine, but there's a bunch of other threads just hanging.

Doltos fucked around with this message at 06:43 on Jan 31, 2024

Despera
Jun 6, 2011

boo boo bear posted:

yes. let's compare it to a better show, say deadwood. you've got calamity jane and sy tolliver, both tremendous pieces of poo poo by any definition, but we want one to be redeemed and the other to be hit in the face repeatedly with a brick because they're fascinating characters who draw us into the world. find me a character with similar appeal in this show.

If you are looking for deadwood quality characters in the 4th season of a show that wasnt deadwood good to begin with I dont know what to tell you.

boo boo bear
Oct 1, 2009

I'm COMPLETELY OBSESSED with SEXY EGGS

Despera posted:

If you are looking for deadwood quality characters in the 4th season of a show that wasnt deadwood good to begin with I dont know what to tell you.

not sure how you wound up there, so... miracles from mistakes, I suppose.

algebra testes
Mar 5, 2011


Lipstick Apathy

Doltos posted:

I think the problem with this season is that everyone's just a mean, nasty rear end in a top hat for no good reason.

This too has bothered me. It's like they watched Slow Horses and that's the one thing they took away from it.

Despera
Jun 6, 2011

boo boo bear posted:

not sure how you wound up there, so... miracles from mistakes, I suppose.

You are asking me to find someone in true detective season four with similar level of appeal, "a character that draws you in" like a character in deadwood. You arent going to find any because the writing is not a good as deadwood was. You said it yourself. Seems kinda pointless.

The golden age of tv was 20 years ago

Season one was a decade ago

I am enjoying the "There are too many assholes in MY True Detective" takes though.

boo boo bear
Oct 1, 2009

I'm COMPLETELY OBSESSED with SEXY EGGS
you said you weren't gonna tell me stuff, I was looking forward to that.

mark immune
Dec 14, 2019

put the teacher in the cope cage imo
the science teacher was wrong, the heart is an emoji

ruddiger
Jun 3, 2004

I AM GRANDO posted:

Who’s the kindest true detective? I vote Hays in season 3. Taylor Kitsch didn’t seem too bad either.

The scene where Hays says he’s going to cry if his wife keeps fighting with him is really good.

He’s got a ton of sweet moments in s3 come to think of it.

Except the times when he’s threatening people with prison rape.

DaveKap
Feb 5, 2006

Pickle: Inspected.



I've had the Billie Eilish theme stuck in my head since watching the latest episode aired, freakin' earworm.

Lampsacus
Oct 21, 2008

I AM GRANDO posted:

Who’s the kindest true detective? I vote Hays in season 3. Taylor Kitsch didn’t seem too bad either.
Chief, that stuff we did. Black Mountain. We did it for America.

But yeah, I think Hays and Taylor for sure.

Cranappleberry
Jan 27, 2009

mark immune posted:

the science teacher was wrong, the heart is an emoji

some say the greatest emoji

Colostomy Bag
Jan 11, 2016

:lesnick: C-Bangin' it :lesnick:

TheBizzness posted:

The most recent episode was not good imo but I still have hope.

Yeah, a lot of folks thought the same thing on the Titanic.

HootTheOwl
May 13, 2012

Hootin and shootin
The heart is winning Marty

TheBizzness
Oct 5, 2004

Reign on me.

Colostomy Bag posted:

Yeah, a lot of folks thought the same thing on the Titanic.

I’m gonna play my Tuba until this bitch is submerged!

CatstropheWaitress
Nov 26, 2017

I don't mind all the main characters being butts. S1 had Rust tell a woman to kill herself, among other things. It was way stronger, but the core of the show is that you have grizzled detectives who won't let a case go and how they eventually and at cost solve it. Taking inspiration from Sherlock Holmes, the only thing that matters is that the case gets solved. Them being assholes feeds into that - they may be awful and a mess, but dammit, they're going to find absolution through the good deed of figuring this poo poo out.

TheBizzness
Oct 5, 2004

Reign on me.
Rust is my dad and he is a wonderful person.

Cranappleberry
Jan 27, 2009
as long as we can all admit the best screen version of sherlock holmes is robert downey jr.

HootTheOwl
May 13, 2012

Hootin and shootin
Better than wishbone?
Data?

I AM GRANDO
Aug 20, 2006

Sherlock Holmes works best as a concept and as a character when he is in the 22nd century.

Bright Bart
Apr 27, 2020

False. There is only one electron and it has never stopped
Or, hear me out, take the petit bourgeoise Englishman and have him try to solve the cult killings in Louisiana.

He can re-spawn every time he gets his throat slit by a biker on meth, or shot and buried in the fields by a farmer he accidentally trespasses on. Like the movie(s) where death brings up back to the lack major bit of progress you made in life.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

joepinetree
Apr 5, 2012

Cranappleberry posted:

as long as we can all admit the best screen version of sherlock holmes is robert downey jr.

Nicholas Rowe

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply