Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Orange Devil
Oct 1, 2010

Wullie's reign cannae smother the flames o' equality!
Rage Against the Machine shut down Wall Street more when filming a music video then Occupy ever did lmao

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

BonHair
Apr 28, 2007

Yeah, over in Denmark, mass protests and demonstrations are fairly common (currently for Gaza for example), but the beauty is that they can be applauded for their voice in the conversation and then ignored. America is just being stupid about it. Sounds like even the Nazis were smarter (they did not, in fact, stop holocausting).

040324_2
Apr 3, 2024
our current homeless holocaust killed the bourgeoisie

(USER WAS PUT ON PROBATION FOR THIS POST)

Fitzy Fitz
May 14, 2005




We have lost the plot so much that an entire political movement called itself The Resistance and then sat on its rear end for four years.

Professor Beetus
Apr 12, 2007

They can fight us
But they'll never Beetus
They resisted by posting tweets and then when turnp lost everything got magically fixed and it was time to go back 2 brunch

Zodium
Jun 19, 2004

DJJIB-DJDCT posted:

Since the turn away from industrial labour in the 1970's, there's no real reason, materially, for protests to be listened to. What are you going to do? How could you actually hurt them in a meaningful way? Your protests don't impact stock prices and spreadsheets.

Compare to general strikes and protests crippling industrial economies, and thus leading to a response addressing their demands. In 1968, the French economy was practically shut down. Occupy, critically, did not actually occupy Wall Street in the same way that occupying docks and factories did - by shutting down productivity.

that's right.

040324_2
Apr 3, 2024

Fitzy Fitz posted:

We have lost the plot so much that an entire political movement called itself The Resistance and then sat on its rear end for four years.

credit til its called baby

DJJIB-DJDCT
Feb 1, 2024

BonHair posted:

Yeah, over in Denmark, mass protests and demonstrations are fairly common (currently for Gaza for example), but the beauty is that they can be applauded for their voice in the conversation and then ignored. America is just being stupid about it. Sounds like even the Nazis were smarter (they did not, in fact, stop holocausting).

They did stop Holocausting the specific group the protests were about. It's why Rosenstrasse is so troubling, because it makes it clear that if people protested on behalf of other victims, they'd have been saved too. In fact, Nazi memos about it openly say they would drop the policy, a core part of their ideology, if they thought the German people didn't approve.

Whereas, in America, it's drummed into the technocrats that there is nothing worse than abandoning policy for something as gauche as what the public wants. Their ideology is premised on opposition to popular will, if anything.

Which is why the only way for people to actually change things is by confronting them. Actually damaging their material interests until they relent. If there was to be another Occupy, it would have to actually shut down trading, consistently, somehow.

Bald Stalin
Jul 11, 2004

Our posts
Didn't California dock workers go on strike for a day at some point during the 2020 uprisings and it was a huge loving deal? Seems like they could do that again now but aren't. But it's good a few Starbucks and a beer brewery unionised just in time for megadrought 2.0

Here people are organising direct actions to block workers getting to the docks to load/unload ships bound for Israel, and they've managed to stop a few for 2-3 days at a time. Last time the police shot them with rubber bullets. The unions aren't doing poo poo, because they're on board with imperialism so long as they get their cheap treats.

Bald Stalin has issued a correction as of 21:58 on Apr 3, 2024

040324_3
Apr 3, 2024
the omnipotent bourgeoise

Mushika
Dec 22, 2010

We can can write their names incorrectly on their coffee cups.

Ha, gottem

Consolidated Ed
Mar 4, 2005
Lineman for Justice

DJJIB-DJDCT posted:

This came up in the Ukraine thread, but the one time Germans actually protested against the Holocaust, the Rosenstrasse protest, the protestors won, no violence was used against them, and memos show the Nazi party was immediately concerned and responsive to public protest against one of their policies.

Contemporary Liberalism, is literally more heavy handed and less responsive than Naziism.

im telling you, read about what happened with the baader-meinhof people. the nazis ran the german police back then (like literal "ex" card-carrying members of the nazi party), and their investigatory and detention policies were significantly more humane than anything in america. baader was allowed to keep over 900 books in his cell, everybody had easy access to medical care and drugs, they all had record players and radios, etc. at one point, the authorities were considering putting some of the group members on suicide watch, with 24/7 lights on in the cells, and this was deemed too cruel lol standard jail policy in the US was determined to be too cruel by actual nazis

in america, they would have locked them in solitary for 2 decades with no human contact, all the lights on, no real clothes or bedding or anything like books, and/or exposed them to relentless sexual violence

the US is the most insanely hosed up fascist hellhole, its really something.

Paladinus
Jan 11, 2014

heyHEYYYY!!!
You've got to hand it to the nazis, I suppose.

Consolidated Ed
Mar 4, 2005
Lineman for Justice
you know what else is super cool about america? how a bunch of chud states turned down free meals for children lol proudly too

Dead forum user
Oct 1, 2021
Bet the nazi's wouldnt have turned down free meals for kids smdh

ContinuityNewTimes
Dec 30, 2010

Я выдуман напрочь

Consolidated Ed posted:

im telling you, read about what happened with the baader-meinhof people. the nazis ran the german police back then (like literal "ex" card-carrying members of the nazi party), and their investigatory and detention policies were significantly more humane than anything in america. baader was allowed to keep over 900 books in his cell, everybody had easy access to medical care and drugs, they all had record players and radios, etc. at one point, the authorities were considering putting some of the group members on suicide watch, with 24/7 lights on in the cells, and this was deemed too cruel lol standard jail policy in the US was determined to be too cruel by actual nazis

in america, they would have locked them in solitary for 2 decades with no human contact, all the lights on, no real clothes or bedding or anything like books, and/or exposed them to relentless sexual violence

the US is the most insanely hosed up fascist hellhole, its really something.

They didn't subject the RAF to inhumane conditions they just murdered them in their relatively comfortable cells.

One of the survivors is now a high-profile neo-nazi

jetz0r
May 10, 2003

Tomorrow, our nation will sit on the throne of the world. This is not a figment of the imagination, but a fact. Tomorrow we will lead the world, Allah willing.



Remember when all the leaders of the Ferguson BLM protests committed suicide?

And how a bunch of leaders of the 2020 George Floyd protests also decided to shoot themselves in their burning car, or lynch themselves?

Anyways, you see that new show on Netflix?

Mandel Brotset
Jan 1, 2024

jetz0r posted:

Remember when all the leaders of the Ferguson BLM protests committed suicide?

And how a bunch of leaders of the 2020 George Floyd protests also decided to shoot themselves in their burning car, or lynch themselves?

Anyways, you see that new show on Netflix?

yah there was one about an octopus and a bunch of other people who randomly went dead

Consolidated Ed
Mar 4, 2005
Lineman for Justice

jetz0r posted:

Remember when all the leaders of the Ferguson BLM protests committed suicide?

And how a bunch of leaders of the 2020 George Floyd protests also decided to shoot themselves in their burning car, or lynch themselves?

Anyways, you see that new show on Netflix?

yeah and i also remember liberals crying for more cops and more money for cops and PLEASE WE LOVE COP DICK AND COP BALLS

Paladinus
Jan 11, 2014

heyHEYYYY!!!
Say what you will about the nazis, at least they didn't try to build a police state!

Proust Malone
Apr 4, 2008

DJJIB-DJDCT posted:

Since the turn away from industrial labour in the 1970's, there's no real reason, materially, for protests to be listened to. What are you going to do? How could you actually hurt them in a meaningful way? Your protests don't impact stock prices and spreadsheets.

Compare to general strikes and protests crippling industrial economies, and thus leading to a response addressing their demands. In 1968, the French economy was practically shut down. Occupy, critically, did not actually occupy Wall Street in the same way that occupying docks and factories did - by shutting down productivity.

the industrial economy didn’t go away, it just moved away from the places labor won to the places where the state would ensure labor wouldn’t win: the south, Mexico, Asia, etc. The distances then make transportation vulnerable to labor action. at the ports, the ATC sickout a couple years back etc

Weka
May 5, 2019

That child totally had it coming. Nobody should be able to be out at dusk except cars.

Consolidated Ed posted:

then youre hopelessly naive and/or european

you have no idea how fascist the us is, zero. the only labor solidarity in the us is between police, who can kill or imprison with impunity

this isnt greece, where throwing molotov cocktails at cops is something that just happens. we use tanks on unarmed protestors here, and our cops have air forces

edit: friendly reminder that multiple US states/localities have tried to make criticism or filming of police a crime.

america loves the boot, it craves the boot, it needs the boot. we want slavery, trump, and the olive garden.

Funny you should bring up Greece, because they have a history of actual main battle tanks being used against protesters, not whatever poo poo armoured cars the army doesn't want anymore.

Only registered members can see post attachments!

Weka
May 5, 2019

That child totally had it coming. Nobody should be able to be out at dusk except cars.

DJJIB-DJDCT posted:

If there was to be another Occupy, it would have to actually shut down trading, consistently, somehow.

People's Computer Toucher Front

khazar sansculotte
May 14, 2004

DJJIB-DJDCT posted:

In fact, Nazi memos about it openly say they would drop the policy, a core part of their ideology, if they thought the German people didn't approve.

Are the primary sources readily accessible? Reading the Wikipedia page makes it sound like the protestors "got away with it" because the Nazis didn't want to create the appearance of disunity and wouldn't be able to keep it secret if they killed them all, rather than because they cared whether people approved of deporting Jews.

tokin opposition
Apr 8, 2021

I don't jailbreak the androids, I set them free.

WATCH MARS EXPRESS (2023)

Weka posted:

People's Computer Toucher Front

Computer Specialists Pedantically Arguing Marxism

Ornery and Hornery
Oct 22, 2020

jetz0r posted:

Remember when all the leaders of the Ferguson BLM protests committed suicide?

And how a bunch of leaders of the 2020 George Floyd protests also decided to shoot themselves in their burning car, or lynch themselves?

Anyways, you see that new show on Netflix?

I hate reality, op

BonHair
Apr 28, 2007

To be fair, the only way to actually block finance stuff is disrupting the computers. I guess you could shut down the power to do that, but there's a lot of collateral and guess where all the good backup generators are? It would be hilarious if the whole system was compromised in a way that made it impossible to tell who actually owned what stuff though. It would probably crash everything

Biplane
Jul 18, 2005

BonHair posted:

To be fair, the only way to actually block finance stuff is disrupting the computers. I guess you could shut down the power to do that, but there's a lot of collateral and guess where all the good backup generators are? It would be hilarious if the whole system was compromised in a way that made it impossible to tell who actually owned what stuff though. It would probably crash everything

Maybe kill all the bankers and finance guys? Would that do anything?

stringless
Dec 28, 2005

keyboard ⌨️​ :clint: cowboy

techbros reinvent trains
c-spammers reinvent Fight Club

BonHair
Apr 28, 2007

Biplane posted:

Maybe kill all the bankers and finance guys? Would that do anything?

No way to find out

SplitSoul
Dec 31, 2000

BonHair posted:

Yeah, over in Denmark, mass protests and demonstrations are fairly common (currently for Gaza for example), but the beauty is that they can be applauded for their voice in the conversation and then ignored.

"Applauded for their voice in the conversation" is a weird way to say "Accused of and investigated by authorities for antisemitism and terrorist sympathies".

Cassian of Imola
Feb 9, 2011
Probation
Can't post for 5 days!

DJJIB-DJDCT posted:

They did stop Holocausting the specific group the protests were about. It's why Rosenstrasse is so troubling, because it makes it clear that if people protested on behalf of other victims, they'd have been saved too. In fact, Nazi memos about it openly say they would drop the policy, a core part of their ideology, if they thought the German people didn't approve.

lol yeah the nazis would never simply put dissidents in camps also

genericnick
Dec 26, 2012

DJJIB-DJDCT posted:

Since the turn away from industrial labour in the 1970's, there's no real reason, materially, for protests to be listened to. What are you going to do? How could you actually hurt them in a meaningful way? Your protests don't impact stock prices and spreadsheets.

Compare to general strikes and protests crippling industrial economies, and thus leading to a response addressing their demands. In 1968, the French economy was practically shut down. Occupy, critically, did not actually occupy Wall Street in the same way that occupying docks and factories did - by shutting down productivity.

yup

Paladinus
Jan 11, 2014

heyHEYYYY!!!
I think we can all agree that protests only ever worked in the nazi Germany. It's completely pointless to protest in any other country.

DJJIB-DJDCT
Feb 1, 2024

khazar sansculotte posted:

Are the primary sources readily accessible? Reading the Wikipedia page makes it sound like the protestors "got away with it" because the Nazis didn't want to create the appearance of disunity and wouldn't be able to keep it secret if they killed them all, rather than because they cared whether people approved of deporting Jews.

Resistance of the Heart, Nathan Stoltzfus posted:

“When I arrived in Berlin to write the story of the Rosenstrasse Protest in 1985, no one else was working on the
project, and there were merely a couple of dozen written sources, mostly in German, that mentioned the event at
all. The longest was a newspaper article; most treated the story in a paragraph or less, as if it were a fluke
and had nothing to say about the nature of Nazi power in general. Nazi documentation of the Rosenstrasse Protest,
other than that of Goebbels’s diary, had apparently not survived the war, and much of the explanation for the
Nazi response to the Rosenstrasse Protest had to be drawn from the nature and structure of the National Socialist
concept and practice of political power. I was told by a professor at the Free University as well as at the West
Berlin Jewish Community that the last survivors of the incident had “just died.” But in response to radio
interviews and newspaper notices, dozens of eyewitnesses began to call me. Two employees of the West Berlin
Jewish Community had shared the experience of the Rosenstrasse Protest without
knowing it. Occasionally Germans called to assure me that all eyewitnesses were certainly dead by now.

Although there was not a single scholarly article on the protest, I learned that to claim the protest was
successful was to challenge prevailing interpretations. Resistance to interpreting the protest as a force that
influenced the regime and saved Jews from death continues. As a means of influence, the protest carries a very
mixed message: On the one hand, some Germans did protest the Holocaust, but on the other, if it was possible to
do so, why didn’t more do this? The German Resistance Memorial Museum of Berlin has scores of pamphlets on topics
ranging from grocers who secretly gave Jews more than was officially allowed to the assassination attempt on
Hitler, but nothing on Rosenstrasse.

In addition to interviews, many of my sources were from the trial of Otto Bovensiepen, at the Berlin District
Court, a fortresslike and decorous building on Turmstrasse, where access was very unusual. Here were the stories,
in the form of eyewitness reports, supporting documents, and Gestapo memos of the former chief of the Berlin
Gestapo, who together with his henchmen had stood trial in 1969 for the deportation and murder of some
thirty-thousand Berlin Jews.

The Bovensiepen Trial was a fractional part of a many-faceted trial directed against the Reich Security Main
Office (RSHA), which included various police forces, the Gestapo, the secret police, the SS, and its intelligence
branch, the SD. The trial was discontinued, still incomplete, in the early 1970s. But the first step—the
collection of evidence—had filled two rooms. The court had embarked on its enormous enterprise with great
thoroughness by collecting documents from twenty-five archives and personal collections around the world. Courts
had confiscated wartime documents from the privacy of homes. On hand were scores of supporting documents, such as
maps, telephone directories, and the complete records of other postwar trials of former Nazis from around
Germany. In addition, thousands of pages of transcribed statements from hundreds of witnesses swelled the
records. There was testimony from Gestapo men and their secretaries, from Berlin street police and their
superiors in the Berlin police hierarchy, from survivors of Auschwitz and other camps and ghettos in the East,
and from eyewitnesses. Each document bore one of three colors: Purple folders were those of the victims, green
for the accused, orange for other witnesses.

In the court records differences were enormous between testimonies of victims and perpetrators who were hauled in
front of the court. The stories from the surviving Jews were always passionate and often full of detail, while
the reports of their oppressors were characteristically so lifeless as to
suggest that they must have been unconscious in twelve years of Nazi rule. The implication was that the Nazi
witnesses had not chosen anything and had taken no initiative during those twelve years (but had somehow managed
to make wonderfully big strides in their advancement up the career ladder).

Some of the depositions, culled for the Bovensiepen Trial from earlier postwar trials, were from as early as the
late 1940s and early 1950s. Most, however, were from the mid and late 1960s. Early statements made under oath
confirmed critical details. Nearly incredible events, like the return of dozens of intermarried Jews from
Auschwitz after their deportation to that death camp from Rosenstrasse, were verified in repeated testimonies and
integrated into the court’s own narrative of events. The multiplicity of sources allowed for the crosschecking of
facts, and the court itself had made judgments on issues of cause and effect. The massive collection of documents
provided invaluable insight into the operations of the machinelike efficiency of a bureaucracy that was only
briefly interrupted by a street protest. Yet the German court, which concluded that the Rosenstrasse Protest
caused the Gestapo to release intermarried Jews, had been interested in determining what the men on trial knew
about the Final Solution during the Third Reich and whether they had acted “correctly”—without physical abuse—in
the process of deportation (a counterproductive inquiry since the assembly line–like efficiency with which the
deportation process worked to maximize the number of Jews killed frowned on public abuse of Jews).”

COURT TRIALS CITED



Berlin. Landgericht (District Court) Berlin. Otto Bovensiepen et al. I Js 9/65.
Berlin. Landgericht. Berlin. Günther Abrahamsohn. 1 PkLs 7/52.
Berlin. Landgericht Berlin. Josef (“Sepp”) Dietrich. I P Js 3767.65.
Berlin. Landgericht. Berlin. Stella Kübier. I PKs I/57.
Berlin. Landgericht Berlin. Walter Stock. PkLs 3/52.
Berlin. Landgericht Berlin. Walter Stock. 4 Sp Ls 832/47.
Berlin. Landgericht Berlin. Special Court Document, Special Court IV Pk. KLs 2/42.
Berlin. Kammergericht (Supreme Court) Berlin. Friedrich Bosshammer. I Js 1/65 (RSHA).
Berlin. Kammergericht Berlin. Fritz Wöhrn. I Js I/65 (RSHA).
Koblenz. National Archives. Karl Krell, 4 SpLs 16/47.
Frankfurt. Landgericht Frankfurt am Main. Alois Brunner. 50 Js 36019/84.
Nuremberg. Nuremberg Trial Documents.
Wiesbaden. Hessisches Hauptstaatsarchiv (Hessen Main State Archive). Josef Hedderich. 4 Ks 2/53.
Wiesbaden. Hessisches Hauptstaatsarchiv. Georg Albert Dengler. 2a Ks 1/49.
Wiesbaden. Hessisches Hauptstaatsarchiv. Heinrich Baab. 51 Ks 1/50.
Wiesbaden. Hessisches Hauptstaatsarchiv. Joseph Hedderich and Johann Schmitz. 4 Ks 2/53.

Orange Devil
Oct 1, 2010

Wullie's reign cannae smother the flames o' equality!

Consolidated Ed posted:

im telling you, read about what happened with the baader-meinhof people. the nazis ran the german police back then (like literal "ex" card-carrying members of the nazi party), and their investigatory and detention policies were significantly more humane than anything in america. baader was allowed to keep over 900 books in his cell, everybody had easy access to medical care and drugs, they all had record players and radios, etc. at one point, the authorities were considering putting some of the group members on suicide watch, with 24/7 lights on in the cells, and this was deemed too cruel lol standard jail policy in the US was determined to be too cruel by actual nazis

in america, they would have locked them in solitary for 2 decades with no human contact, all the lights on, no real clothes or bedding or anything like books, and/or exposed them to relentless sexual violence

the US is the most insanely hosed up fascist hellhole, its really something.

The first wave RAF ofcourse did somehow manage to abuse all that freedom in prison to coordinate a collective suicide by shooting themselves in the base of the neck at an angle that is physiologically very unlikely...

ArmedZombie
Jun 6, 2004

Weka posted:

Funny you should bring up Greece, because they have a history of actual main battle tanks being used against protesters, not whatever poo poo armoured cars the army doesn't want anymore.



I wonder what other countries have done this.

Paladinus
Jan 11, 2014

heyHEYYYY!!!

ArmedZombie posted:

I wonder what other countries have done this.

Tanks? To squash protests? Nothing comes to mind. But if there was such a country, maybe it had its reasons and was actually right to do that.

ArmedZombie
Jun 6, 2004

Paladinus posted:

Tanks? To squash protests? Nothing comes to mind. But if there was such a country, maybe it had its reasons and was actually right to do that.

So you're defending Greece?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Failed Imagineer
Sep 22, 2018

Paladinus posted:

Tanks? To squash protests? Nothing comes to mind. But if there was such a country, maybe it had its reasons and was actually right to do that.

Check out this post lol

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply