Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
I am affraid infringe rules of forum. And i made new topic about Ukraina.

Sorry, I made the mistake in topic. I don't know how i can correct it.

utjkju fucked around with this message at 06:01 on Aug 3, 2014

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?threadid=3610151&pagenumber=11#lastpost
"Credibility is important.

Do you have any sources other than blogs, Russia Today, or 'a guy I know in Germany'?
I want to agree with you. I know you want us to agree with you. But first you have to actually try and understand our viewpoint on the matter.
This is not a personal attack. We want actual facts, not fringe accounts and testimony."

I show vidio of people from Germany that i have not blogs in Germany. But you can see real people who show other opinions.
I wrote real facts about of policy of Ukraine. Is Site of governmant of Ukraina bad source? Facts which i wrote are not secret

utjkju fucked around with this message at 05:41 on Aug 3, 2014

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Only facts:
http://www.kmu.gov.ua/control/en/pu...e=1402389839487
Vice Prime Minister of Ukraine - SYCH Olexandr Maxymovych. Member of Political Committee of the All-Ukrainian Movement Svoboda (Freedom), Deputy Chairman of the Party for ideology.

Now:
On 1 July 2014 six MPs left the Communist Party faction in parliament, reducing it to 23 members.[17][18] A vote, supported by 232 MPs, on 22 July 2014 gave the Chairman of the Verkhovna Rada (the speaker of Ukraine's parliament) the power to dissolve a faction that has lost some of its members compared to the number it had while it was formed during the first parliamentary session after the precious election, pending a signature from President Petro Poroshenko.[3][16][19] Later that day Poroshenko signed this bill giving effect to this new parliamentary regulation.[16] The next day speaker (and former Acting President) Turchynov announced the party's impending dissolution and added to MPs "We only have to tolerate this party for another day".[16] The party's faction in parliament was indeed dissolved 24 July 2014 by Turchynov.[3] The same day it was announced that at the time 308 criminal proceedings against members of the party had been opened.[20] Communists were accused of openly supporting the annexation of Crimea by Russia, supporting the creation of self-proclaimed Donetsk People's Republic and Lugansk People's Republic and agitating for annexation of the Dnipropetrovsk Oblast to Russia.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist_Party_of_Ukraine

History:
Soon after the appointment of Hitler as Chancellor, the Reichstag was set on fire and Dutch council communist Marinus van der Lubbe was found near the building. The Nazis publicly blamed the fire on communist agitators in general, although in a German court in 1933, it was decided that van der Lubbe had acted alone, as he claimed to have done. After the fire, the Reichstag Fire Decree was passed, under the pretext of snuffing out "Communist state-endangering acts of violence." Its actual effect, however, was to suspend most civil liberties. The KPD was banned shortly afterward. The Enabling Act, which legally gave Hitler dictatorial control of Germany, was passed by a Reichstag session held after all communist deputies had been arrested and jailed.

The KPD was efficiently suppressed by the Nazis. Thousands of Communists were imprisoned in concentration camps, including Thälmann and the party's leader in the Reichstag, Ernst Torgler. The most senior KPD leaders to escape were Wilhelm Pieck and Walter Ulbricht, who went into exile in the Soviet Union. The KPD maintained an underground organisation in Germany throughout the Nazi period, but the loss of many core members severely weakened the Party's infrastructure.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist_Party_of_Germany

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Svoboda (political party) in Ukraina http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svoboda_%28political_party%29

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

Bip Roberts posted:

Ukraine is game to you?

Not, it is not game.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
IATA chief executive Tony Tyler attended the meeting on Tuesday on behalf of his group’s airline members, which include Qantas and Virgin Australia Holdings.

Mr Tyler said there was no escaping that what happened to MH17, which was shot down by a surface-to-air missile over eastern Ukraine, should not have happened.

“It exposed a gap in the system,” he said. “The system is not broken. It works extremely well in the vast majority of cases. And the proof of that is clearly evident in that air transport is the safest mode of global mass transit known to humankind. So the challenge is to close the specific gap or gaps that allowed this tragedy to happen.”
In the case of MH17, Ukraine had advised its airspace was safe for travel above 32,000 feet, but the aircraft was shot down when flying at 33,000 feet. Mr Tyler said it was essential that airlines received clear guidance regarding threats to their passengers, crew and aircraft.

“This is the responsibility of states,” he said. “There are no excuses. Even sensitive information can be sanitised in a way that ensures airlines get essential and actionable information without compromising methods or sources.”

Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/business/avia...l#ixzz39AM4dXUH

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
MH17. English.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eiu2s-8MRJA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zhqVdybvAFY

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Interesting situation.

About Igor Ivanovich Strelkov (Girkin)

English Wiki:(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Igor_Girkin):
Igor Vsevolodovich Girkin (Russian: Игорь Всеволодович Гиркин), also known as Igor Ivanovich Strelkov (Russian: Игорь Иванович Стрелков), born on 17 December 1970,[1] is a Russian citizen from Moscow[2] who a key figure behind the War in Donbass as the military commander of the Donetsk People's Republic rebellion.[3][4] Strelkov, a Russian nationalist and veteran of several other conflicts, was charged by Ukraine authorities with terrorism[5] and is currently sanctioned by the European Union for his leading role in the insurgency in eastern Ukraine.[6] By his admission, he served in the Russian FSB until March 2013,[7] and according to Ukrainian and EU authorities, he is a retired Russian military intelligence GRU colonel who has previously participated in the 2014 Crimea crisis.[6][8][9]

Russian Wiki:(http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A1...%B2%D0%B8%D1%87)
Igor Ivanovich Strelkov (Igor Vsevolodovich Girkin is also known under a name; On December 17, 1970, Moscow [1][2][3]) — one of leaders of the unrecognized Donetsk People's Republic. Within several months I was the commander of insurgents in the city of Slavyansk, now heads forces of "a national militia" in Donetsk.

The colonel of FSB of Russia in resignation and never served in GRU ("I never served in GRU, I was the employee of FSB. Now in resignation") [2][4][5][6].

I received popularity in the spring of 2014 during armed conflicts in the east of Ukraine as the active participant of the armed organizations of the insurgents, headed "A national militia of Donbass" [7]. Since May 12, 2014 — the commander of "Donetsk People's Republic armed forces" [8][9], since May 16 — the Minister of Defence of DNR[10], since July 6 declared himself "the military commandant of Donetsk" [11].

GRU is not FSB. Girkin from FSB. English Wiki wrote falsehood.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
FSB - The federal service of safety.
http://www.fsb.ru/fsb/structure.htm - FSB of Russia.

Investigation

Investigation — activity of bodies of FSB of Russia within the Russian Federation on production, delivery and processing of the classified information connected with organized criminal and terrorist groups. Prospecting activity outside the Russian Federation is carried out by body of foreign intelligence — SVR of Russia according to the Federal law of the Russian Federation "About foreign intelligence"

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
About Girkin:
He took part in operations in Transnistria in June-July, 1992 (the volunteer of the 2nd platoon of the Black Sea Cossack army, Koshnits — Bendery), in Bosnia from November, 1992 to March, 1993 inclusive (the 2nd Russian voluntary group, the 2nd Podrinsky easily infantry and 2nd Mayevitskaya of crew of Army of the Republika Srpska, Vysehrad — the Surf), in Chechnya (the 166th Guards separate motor-shooting crew, March-October, 1995, and in parts of a special purpose from 1999 to 2005), he performed special tasks in other regions of Russia [12][17][13]. In the late nineties he published autobiographical "The Bosnian diary" [12].
http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A1...%B2%D0%B8%D1%87

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

comaerror posted:

Hi utjkju,

The US and EU have imposed some sanctions on certain people and aspects of Russia's economy over the situation in Ukraine. I was curious if it's causing any trouble for the general public in Russia.

Also, how do people there feel about possible Russian involvement in Ukraine? Do people support the separatists, or do they want to stay out of it, or is it mixed?

Many people support the separatists. But people don't like that Putin does not support the separatists.
Yesterday rally ( meeting) for support the separatists was in Moscow.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Women against mobilization of men in Army of Ukraina.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRGuhR5g2ZU

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qtbWuqrcFqU

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Qcaaq0-Q0Q

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gmbl_23oRGc

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Today 12 soldiers of the army of Ukraina laid down arm (ceased from strife). Soldier talked that the government of Ukraina betrayed them. Soldiers asked for help Russian soldiers in the frontier of Russia. 12 soldiers of the army of Ukraina crossed the frontier of Russia. Our people are delivering medical care to these soldiers.
(Soldiers from the territory of Kotel)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LOBEb7QYQtE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VerPn9OMa2k

utjkju fucked around with this message at 14:14 on Aug 3, 2014

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Boy in army of separatists. Boy tells that he defends his native land.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7dqkkZQm0U

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Maydan 3. Harkov.)))
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5kf3_3Y5NQo

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
«Jeder anständige Deutsche hat die Pflicht, der Kriegshetze zu widerstehen» (MH17)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lzrMl93KIOI

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

Aristotle Animes posted:

oh well, let us not question the reasoning powers of a 14 year old as he spouts the party line. I usually form all my opinions based on slogans on toddlers t-shirts at tea party rallies as well.

Boy has 15 years old. This boy works in educational group of army of separatists. Probability to die in educational group = probability to die in town. It is war. Children see how other children die. And boy made choosing .

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

A Keg posted:

How are the dogs in Sochi doing these days


MadMattH posted:

They are probably thriving on the population of rats left when the Olympic village got deserted and all fell apart from shoddy construction and all the leftover Olympic garbage. Unless the rats ate the dogs.

I don't know about dogs and rats in Sochi.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

Ferdinand the Bull posted:

I heard a theory that it's easier to sway Russians ideologically because they're the only country that really speaks Russian. Sure, you've got parts of some countries like Ukraine, Kazakhstan, and other countries within the old Soviet sphere of influence, but the Russian speaking populations of those countries still consider themselves Russian and look to Russia first.

Unlike English speakers, which many countries all around the world report and read in, Russian speakers don't really have many choices except what comes from Russia.

This must explain how facts from Russia never line up with the rest of the world's.

No. Many Russian people know 2-3 languages. Popular languages in Russia: english, german, china, japanese, french. We make translating. And russian people have good education.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=opApBwqoUKU - buk

utjkju fucked around with this message at 06:33 on Aug 4, 2014

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Information war)

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Double standard

"Intercepts of separatist communications posted on YouTube by the Ukrainian government indicate the separatists were in possession of a SA-11 system as early as Monday July 14th. In the intercepts, the separatists made repeated references to having and repositioning Buk (SA-11) systems."
YouTobe is very, very importent source of information for USA government.

Russian film in YouTobe?
Russian Kyoon? Or agent of Putin?

utjkju fucked around with this message at 08:07 on Aug 4, 2014

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".


- Your mass-media tell falsehood!!!
- No. Your mass-media tell falsehood!!!
(together)
- TV set told this!!!

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
In university teacher told that there are facts and there are subjective opinions. Us were taught to divide facts and subjective opinions.
What is facts i know?
Maydan is fact.
In Ukraina there are party Freedom. It is fact.
Vice Prime Minister of Ukraine - SYCH Olexandr Maxymovych. It is fact.
The party's faction (Communist) in parliament was indeed dissolved 24 July 2014 by Turchynov. It is fact.
War in Ukraina is fact.
Accident of Boeing MH17 is fact.
Sanctions is fact.
These facts which people can not confute.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Today
As the representative of frontier management of FSB of the Russian Federation on the Rostov region Vasily Malayev reported, 438 servicemen from Ukraine appealed to the Russian frontier guards about a shelter, to them opened a humanitarian corridor, transfers RIA Novosti news agency. Among them there were 164 employees of the Public border service of Ukraine. Still so mass transition of the Ukrainian soldiers and officers to Russia it wasn't observed.

Article original: http://russian.rt.com/article/43779#ixzz39PZiN4Vf

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

JustNorse posted:

And I'm slightly daft. Could you enlighten me as to the conclusions you draw from these "facts"? (Quotation marks as it, for instance, is open for debate whether MH17 was an accident.)

I have not conclusions. I show different opinions. I have friends and relatives in different countries. We are not enemies.

To learn a cause of accident of plane, it is necessary to collect plane's fragments. Then it will be possible to establish the causes of accident. This opinion of our engineers.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
MH17
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fp_-rBL6n6Q

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

HoratioRash posted:

Really OP? You should know better that the first thing they teach here is grammar - grammar, synthax, phonetics first, for hell, half a year when school starts. Then, only then vocabulary lessons start.

Nobody talks like that, nobody writes like that. If you get someone who didnt pay attention in class they wont make mistakes in basic sentence forming like this. Instead, you go on into an unfunny hollywood-style Russian-accented writeups.

I am from Russia. And i learn English language. I wrote about it in my topic.
http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?threadid=3606581
I live in the West Siberia.
I have a pause in the lessons of english, because i improve my czech language. I am traveling in Czech republic in autumn.

utjkju fucked around with this message at 14:46 on Aug 4, 2014

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

jimma posted:

You live more than 2,000 miles away from Ukraine. What makes you qualified to start an Ask thread about this? Exactly how many people do you know who live in Ukraine?

I wrote about it. I have relatives and friends from Ukraina. My father was born in Ukraina. And my grandmother and other relatives live in the East Ukraina.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

tweekinator posted:

If anyone is interested, my friend's fiance is trapped in Donetsk now, and he shared some excerpts from their chats with me about what her life is like now and gave me the go-ahead to share them with others. I'm phone posting now, but I can get them up once I'm home.

Your friend from army of Ukraina? ( Твой друг мобилизован, ополченец или мирный житель?)

utjkju fucked around with this message at 15:36 on Aug 4, 2014

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

tweekinator posted:

No, my friend from America, whose only connection to Ukraine is through his fiancee.

I did not understood.
Fiancee of your friend from America is living in Doneck. Your friend live in America.
Is this correct?

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

jimma posted:

I'd much rather hear direct quotes from them. At this point, this thread is just "Ask me to post YouTube and Russian media content about the Ukraine conflict", which I don't think anyone really wants.

Where do your relatives and friends live in Ukraine? Have they seen any fighting? They're all okay, I hope ...

My relatives live in Kirovograd and in Aleksandria.
Forum of Kirovograd http://forum.rks.kr.ua/

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

DumbWhiteGuy posted:

for sure, one cannot confute these facts. i, too, learned the difference between fact and opinion when i was in college. sanctions is fact, what do you people not get about this??

Some companies changed the organization of work. But sanctions are not very big problem.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

tweekinator posted:

Yes, they met in college.

What fiancee of your friend tells?

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

litany of gulps posted:

A lot of these people are being sarcastic, which may not translate well. Tread carefully here! The language barrier is not doing you any favors for political argument.

Ok, therefore i don't write story of my relatives. I show vidio and news.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

litany of gulps posted:

Your story will be more credible than videos and news, because much of this news is coming from sources that are not considered credible. You're also a pretty good storyteller, from what I remember of your other thread!

My best advice would be to try and find German or French or other European news stories that corroborate what you're trying to say with your Russian news and social media.

Edit: It's like the Israel/Palestine arguments. If you use something from The Times of Israel, Fox News, or Al Jazeera, anything of substance actually said is immediately lost in arguments about the source. Something like the BBC usually has strong reporting and less of a bias than many of these other sources, so can provide a neutral ground for establishing facts and their relevance to the discussion.

Personal anecdotes become more valuable in the absence of reliable information authorities.

Russian and Ukraina news and social media have information, which i can not find in German or French or other European news. Therefore people make translating russian and Ukraina news and social media on other language. I filter information. I check some sources to which I can trust.
Some facts are very awful. And difficult to believes that such is possible.
For example, people from Kirovograd raise money for bullet-proof vests of soldiers of the Ukrainian army. Soldiers from the Ukrainian army don't have bullet-proof vests. You can read about it in forum of Kirovograd, but European news don't tell about it. Many people don't wish war. Many people against mobilization. But European news don't tell about it.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
Meeting against war in Kirovograd. People wish that other people will know about it.











http://rk.kr.ua/v-kirovogradi-batki-polonenih-vimagali-vid-politikiv-ne-zavazhati-im-zvilnjati-ihnih-ditei

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".
But there are people from Kirovograd who have opinion that russian people are fascists. And war is good.

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

tweekinator posted:

Alright, a bit of background on my source: She is from Ukraine, lived and studied in Moscow, and went to a pretty good college here in the US for a bit. Prior to the Ukraine fiasco, she thought positively of Putin and his policies in general, and only started to get leery with the Crimea issue. She and her family are from Donetsk, and trapped there now. They were preparing to move closer to family near Kiev to escape this when their car broke down and they were notified that the separatists were not allowing anyone to leave the city. In these excerpts, whenever she is referring to the terrorists, she means the pro-Russian Donetsk forces.

She works on the other side of the city from where her family lives, and often just stays at work, where there is a kitchen and sleeping area now, rather than risk travelling across the city, especially at night. She has had 2 of her childhood friends killed in the fighting/siege. She still goes to work across a warzone everyday, and is a braver and tougher person than I will ever be.

I don't believe she is lying in her conversations. I realize I'm posting this with little credibility, and no sourcing beyond "my longtime friend's fiance". This is the perspective of someone living through a truly awful situation, believe it or not, make of it what you will.

I showed film where there are people who disagree with separatists. But there are people who against Poroshenko.
There are looters. People of separatists find they and chasten.
Hunta (army of Ukraina) make shelling in town.

utjkju fucked around with this message at 10:29 on Aug 5, 2014

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

utjkju
Feb 3, 2014

I told it: "leave" But To me answered: "rrrrrrrrrrrr".

Duzzy Funlop posted:

They do tell about it.
But your sources/forums tell you that they don't, so they don't.

:ussr::foxnews:

My sources/forums don't tell me. I don't find they. Show me they.

  • Locked thread