Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


British capitalists killed 2 million Indians throughout the Bengal Famine of 1948.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Jewel Repetition posted:

Has anyone ever denied a genocide/atrocity happened and been on the right side of history?
What do you mean?

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


The Saurus posted:

I don''t give a gently caress about luxury goods, but if I have to give up pizza as a precondition of socialism then I'd rather live in a neoliberal paradise.

where did this self-denying spiritualistic philosophy of ascetism start with some socialists? Late 19th c. Russian revolutionaries like the Men of the 60s and 80s?

Marxism is like the most materialistic philosophy ever its entirely based around material goods.

I have good news, friend. Under socialism you will be able to keep all your pizzas and other personal property.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


What we need is someone pragmatic enough to negotiate her way out of this partisan gridlock!

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


The Saurus posted:

The solution for lovely conditions in other countries is for socialist revolution there and elsewhere and international solidarity, helping to develop their countries.

It's not for everyone to come and live in the developed world so they can maybe eke out a better existence under the capitalist system while totally weakening the working class and putting more and more concentrated power in the hands of the elite.

:agreed:

Mass immigration is a safety valve that keeps capitalism functioning smoothly, (for capitalists like the narcos)

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Did we talk about how Cuba has won a massive concession from the US yet?

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Pener Kropoopkin posted:

It's fascinating how far the goal posts were moved from "communism isn't a dead ideology in the Global South" to, "oh yeah? Well FARC is giving up their war with the Colombian state, so what about that?" As if communism isn't real if there's not an active militant insurgency.

And anyway, going by your own standard there are two notable exceptions I can think of, which were the successful Maoist insurgency in Nepal - which has led a leftist government in Parliament ever since, and the ongoing Naxalite insurgency in India. The Indian communist parties are also organizing a general strike planned for September, which is expected to have 150 million participants.

And Cuba! Why does everyone forget about Cuba?!

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Typo posted:

right so basically you are describing a generic social democratic party

I'm getting the feeling that you don't really understand what you are posting about.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Typo posted:

How do you tell a communist? Well, it's someone who reads Marx and Lenin. And how do you tell an anti-Communist? It's someone who understands Marx and Lenin.

nicemeltdown

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


"Nice meltdown" seems like something a modern Ronald Reagan would say to win a debate. lol

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


There you go again.. :jerkbag:

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Are you implying that the USSR created a sizable pseudo middle class capable of purchasing automobiles out of a backwater slave nation, but instead of focusing on manufacturing cars and improving its economy, the USSR put its meager resources towards improving its overall standard of living?

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Constant Hamprince posted:

gotta shift shift shift that rhetorical focus btw horseshoe theory is a mythhhhhhhh

Haha horseshoe theory oh my god 😂

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


"I like to imagine that political ideologies exist on a horizontal plane from left to right. Also, this plane loops back around on itself so two ideologies that are very different from another are exactly the same."

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Jack of Hearts posted:

Do you know what a plane is?

I guess you're right, horseshoe theory is kinda retarded.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


The only practical application for horseshoe theory is as liberal propaganda.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


I will be the commissar who works at your child's school. Hope she doesn't share any counter-revolutionary or bourgeois sentiments that she might pick up around the house.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SnfioOtrBro

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


asdf32 posted:

Heh yeah just skimmed his posts and saw that nonsense about how the US subjugates multiple internal nations. What an idiot.

The US literally subjugates multiple internal nations.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


The subjugated nations are the Indians not the states. Dixie was a subjugated nation too for a while but that was a good thing.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Not that it changes your argument, but the US waged a serious terror campaign against Cuba.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


The Saurus posted:

They're indigenous Americans, not "Indians" you loving bigot

Aren't you British?

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


The US was the most barbarous world power of the Cold War period.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015



Holy poo poo, the old Dali Lama was a US asset?!

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


The goal of creating a utopia is in fact..

*researches diligently. Late nights in the library and long hours spent interviewing experts in multiple fields.*

Very good!

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Pener Kropoopkin posted:

I think the best strategy for the First World Left to pursue, is to utilize state power to transform private businesses into cooperatives. The state is a massive tool, and it shouldn't be rejected if you don't have to.

Oh yeah for sure. Corporate Democracy is the obvious next fight for the economic left.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Pener Kropoopkin posted:

If you guys are so concerned about achieving revolution in the first world, you could always ditch liberalism and become communists yourselves. All this talk about ecological collapse and refugee crises is where you're taking us right now, anyway.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Ultraleftism is extremely cool.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


That is real cringey my dude.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Constant Hamprince posted:

; he's spinning around the horseshoe so fast that his brain is in a quantum superposition of extremist politics and you can't tell if his next post is going to be 'eat the rich' or 'nuke the muslims' until you observe it.

He's an extremely useful demonstration of why horseshoe theory is bullshit.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


My irony is actually quite funny I can assure you that.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Constant Hamprince posted:

Look man, you can't industrialize a nation without starving a few hundred thousand peasants and keeping millions more in a state of impoverished quasi-serfdom so you can use their agricultural surplus to pay for western machinery.

Well, you can, but Stalin couldn't think of a better way so we're gonna go with 'impossible' here.

Which is the liberal model for modern industrialization?

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Pener Kropoopkin posted:

The early 20th century was an era of unprecedented barbarism and destruction, so the willingness to make a militarized industrial omelette was much more desperate than the situation for anyone in the global north today. Nowadays the primary problem is what we're doing to other people, and not what other people can do to us. The United States is mobilized to combat relatively insignificant threats, and we live in a farcical age.

This is not wrong.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


It seems to me like those people care deeply about ideology.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Different people have all sorts of ideas and this is a terrible dilemma.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Do we all believe that capitalism is a system?

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


Constant Hamprince posted:

lol how's that working out for u

"class is an inevitable result of the division of labour, but uh don't worry we're totally gonna transcend that when we achieve full communism, just keep hewing that coal comrade" *speeds on in east german limo*

Class is a description of the individual's relationship to how important economic and political decisions are made. There will be no class distinctions and therefor no class when everyone wields the same degree of control over political and economic decisions.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


asdf32 posted:

Right, the elite officers of United Fruit get whatever they want from the (capitalist) democratic state but the [elite] officers of "Collective Fruit", now with no competition and complete monopoly will definitely be held in check by the (socialist) democratic state.

Might be easier to believe if real life socialist states didn't fail precisely because they were unable to check the power of their elite.


Global warming is bad.

In a truly socialist system, the elite officers of Collective Fruit will be elected administrators and their decisions will subjected to approval by the worker's councils.

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


asdf32 posted:

The part where officials are elected to represent the people is similar. So is that part where those officials are required to check the power of industry. In one system the checks may end there. The other system adds competition and consumer markets.

Officials are not elected to check the power of industry under socialism. Administration of industry is chosen from the factory floor on up to manage all aspects of production according to the interests of the workers.

The Kingfish fucked around with this message at 03:37 on Oct 6, 2016

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

The Kingfish
Oct 21, 2015


E: fuckin double post

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5