Which teams have zero dispute over their best player?

The Something Awful Forums > Discussion > Sports Argument Stadium > The Football Funhouse > Which teams have zero dispute over their best player?

sean10mm: Jun 29, 2005; It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, MAD-2R World

Mr. Nice! posted:

I think Romo was the best QB to ever play for Dallas and the only competition there is Staubach.

Witten and Novacek are pretty much tied for TE. Ditka was a beast back in the day, but I don't think he's up to the level of Jay or Jason especially since he only played a couple of seasons with Dallas.

WR is Irvin and I can't even think of anyone else close. Should have been Moss, but Jerry is a moron.

RB Emmitt and no one else even near him.

FB Moose is an easy choice.

On the defensive side of the ball there's Deion in the secondary with Ware and Charles Haley for LBs, but I'm not really able to pick any other positions off the top of my head.

If you adjust stats for era then Staubach was IMO pretty clearly the greatest Cowboys QB.

Staubach:

code:

                                                                                                  
Year    Age  Tm Pos No.   G  GS   QBrec  Att Y/A+ NY/A+ AY/A+ ANY/A+ Cmp%+ TD%+ Int%+ Sack%+ Rate+
1970     28 DAL  qb  12   8   3   2-1-0   82   97    74    74     66   107   80    62     40    76
1971*    29 DAL  QB  12  13  10  10-0-0  211  139   128   147    139   125  128   132     90   144
1973     31 DAL  QB  12  14  14  10-4-0  286  136   119   131    121   133  135   100     76   133
1974     32 DAL  QB  12  14  14   8-6-0  360  109   103   108    105   101   91   110     84   103
1975*    33 DAL  QB  12  13  13   9-4-0  348  116   115   114    114   112  107   105     95   112
1976*    34 DAL  QB  12  14  14  11-3-0  369  112   115   118    120   112   97   123    108   116
1977*    35 DAL  QB  12  14  14  12-2-0  361  111   113   123    124   117  110   130    105   125
1978*    36 DAL  QB  12  15  15  11-4-0  413  123   123   128    129   110  124   115    105   126
1979*    37 DAL  QB  12  16  16  11-5-0  461  120   120   133    133   111  121   131    101   132
Career                  131 114 85-29-0                                                       2958

Aikman:

code:

                                                                                                  
Year    Age  Tm Pos No.   G  GS   QBrec  Att Y/A+ NY/A+ AY/A+ ANY/A+ Cmp%+ TD%+ Int%+ Sack%+ Rate+
1989     23 DAL  QB   8  11  11  0-11-0  293   78    82    70     72    91   88    68    106    74
1990     24 DAL  QB   8  15  15   7-8-0  399   88    84    83     81   101   86    87     88    86
1991*    25 DAL  QB   8  12  12   7-5-0  363  114   109   112    109   130   90   113     95   114
1992*    26 DAL  QB   8  16  16  13-3-0  473  109   115   113    117   120  114   108    115   118
1993*    27 DAL  QB   8  14  14  11-3-0  392  122   122   127    126   133  101   128    104   129
1994*    28 DAL  QB   8  14  14  10-4-0  361  114   121   108    113   120   98    97    117   109
1995*    29 DAL  QB   8  16  16  12-4-0  432  122   130   124    129   123   97   126    120   122
1996*    30 DAL  QB   8  15  15  10-5-0  465  100   109    99    104   124   83   106    118   103
1997     31 DAL  QB   8  16  16  6-10-0  518   92    93    99    100    98   97   113    106   101
1998     32 DAL  QB   8  11  11   7-4-0  315  111   122   115    122   111   98   123    126   113
1999     33 DAL  QB   8  14  14   7-7-0  442   99   105   102    105   108   98   108    117   104
2000     34 DAL  qb   8  11  11   4-7-0  262   90    95    78     82   106   85    68    114    81
Career                  165 165 94-71-0                                                       4715

Romo:

code:

                                                                                                  
Year    Age  Tm Pos No.   G  GS   QBrec  Att Y/A+ NY/A+ AY/A+ ANY/A+ Cmp%+ TD%+ Int%+ Sack%+ Rate+
2006*    26 DAL  QB   9  16  10   6-4-0  337  135   131   123    122   117  119    88    104   119
2007*    27 DAL  QB   9  16  16  13-3-0  520  125   124   121    121   113  133    90    111   121
2008     28 DAL  QB   9  13  13   8-5-0  450  114   116   112    114   101  119    98    112   110
2009*    29 DAL  QB   9  16  16  11-5-0  550  122   121   123    122   107  108   118    101   117
2010     30 DAL  qb   9   6   6   1-5-0  213  108   115   106    110   128  110    95    123   112
2011     31 DAL  QB   9  16  16   8-8-0  522  119   116   122    120   120  119   115     98   123
2012     32 DAL  QB   9  16  16   8-8-0  648  109   110   105    106   117  100    97    109   106
2013     33 DAL  QB   9  15  15   8-7-0  535  100    99   109    108   109  116   113    102   113
2014*    34 DAL  QB   9  15  15  12-3-0  435  131   126   131    128   130  138   108    101   134
2015     35 DAL  qb   9   4   4   3-1-0  121  102   107    78     82   123   96    38    111    85
Career                  156 127 78-49-0                                                       4335

# ¿ Sep 28, 2017 19:22

Adbot: ADBOT LOVES YOU

# ¿ May 19, 2024 15:30

The Something Awful Forums > Discussion > Sports Argument Stadium > The Football Funhouse > Which teams have zero dispute over their best player?