Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Post
  • Reply
AverySpecialfriend
Jul 8, 2017

by Hand Knit
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M2E1m90YSpA

Singing is making music with your voice. It's costs nothing, requires no instruments, and can be done anywhere at anytime. Okay, well, the first two aren't entirely true, in that you'll likely need a microphone if you plan on recording or playing in a band, and you should probably get professional lessons if you're serious about singing and don't want to injure yourself -- but the last one is definitely true! Sing in the car! Sing on public transit and get weird looks! Sing butt naked and soaking wet in the shower, the best possible way to sing! Who doesn't like singing along to their favorite songs? It's so much fun!!

I decided to take it on myself and put this thread together for all the other folks out there who wanna talk singing. I'm not much more than a beginner but talking voice with some knowledgeable folks might help me, and you dear reader, get better at singing and have fun doing it. So, let's jump right in: what's the deal with singing?!


:o: :o: :o:


Pt. 1: Vocal Anatomy

The most basic understanding of the voice goes like this: your throat contains vocal cords, which are stretchy folds of flesh that can lengthen or contract. You breathe out and the air passing over the vocal cords makes them vibrate, just like a guitar or other stringed instrument. Then you use your mouth to modulate the sound.

In reality, the human voice is incredibly complex and involves all sorts of different muscles, bones, and organs. Here's a short list of some of the most important bits and pieces:
  • The vocal cords are contained in the larynx, a set of muscles and cartilage pieces (think: Adam's apple) situated above your trachea. Your laryngeal muscles control the amount of tension in your vocal cords. More tension = more stretched vocal cords = faster vibration = higher pitch.
  • The pharynx is a cavity and set of muscles behind your mouth and nasal cavity, and where the real magic of singing happens. It's your body's primary resonator (where sound resonates, as you may or may not have guessed) and the muscle action modulates between head voice and chest voice. More on those shortly.
  • The mouth can be better considered in terms of its individual components, including the tongue, lips, and soft palette. These components work in tandem to form phonemes, the indivisible elements of the sound of speech -- roughly speaking, these are your vowels and consonants, turning the raw tone of your singing into words.
  • The nasal cavity is another important resonator - where your head voice lives, more or less. It's a big hollow space in your head connected to the pharynx.
  • The diaphragm is the semi-involuntary muscle beneath your lungs. When you engage it, it expands your lungs (and by extension your chest cavity), which creates a pressure differential that air rushes in to fill. This is called breathing! Wow! We have to use air to sing, and the diaphragm is how we control how much air we're letting out how fast it's moving.
  • You know how you can't breathe and swallow at the same time? This is because of your epiglottis, The Mouthbreather's Delight! In addition to keeping you from aspirating food into your lungs and dying of pneumonia, it interacts with your pharynx and larynx during phonation, and by partially constricting the outward flow of air past your larynx, can amplify certain pitches. This produces a vocal quality known as twang. More on this one later, too.
  • Your skull and jawbone are in on the action too! The bones in ya dome (mainly the facial bones nearest to your mouth and nasal cavity) vibrate and amplify your voice, and this is where a LOT of your volume comes from.
  • Every other frickin' muscle in your body because you need to coordinate all this junk and keep good posture so your throat is open, your airflow is strong, and your resonance is clear. Plot twist! It's all important!!!

"So about men's and women's voices?!" you may ask naively. Testosterone makes vocal folds thicker and they vibrate at lower frequencies because of it, but the voice box is only one of many parts of your vocal production or tessitura. The cool part about this is that almost everyone's vocal range in both pitch and tonality is a lot wider than they think it is! Check out YouTube-famous singer Nick Pitera doing the thing he got YouTube-famous for:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9IWAxSpgKA


:o: :o: :o:


Pt. 2: Registers, Resonators, and Techniques

You might hear head and chest voice sometimes referred to as head and chest register, which isn't totally accurate. The human voice has four registers, from low to high being vocal fry (think Tina from Bob's Burgers groaning), modal (this is your primary speaking/singing voice), falsetto (think people singing Queen badly), and whistle, which is distinct from whistling. When singing, you might use your falsetto, you probably won't use your vocal fry, and you almost definitely won't use your whistle unless your name is Mariah Carey -- but you'll definitely use your modal.

Your modal register can be thought of as having your vocal cords fully engaged. The folds make contact with each other along their entire length, and when air passes by them they rapidly open and close, vibrating the whole fold. Your falsetto register is a fully open state - there's less air resistance so you can pass air through at higher speeds (hence higher pitch), but only the edges of the folds vibrate, producing a more breathy/hollow sound. Men who might believe they won't be able to sing high pitches commonly use their falsetto in place of their head voice.


That being said: what the heck are head and chest voice, exactly?
  • Your head voice is the upper half of your modal register. Your pharyngeal muscles open up airflow into your nasal cavity, producing a light, bright, high-pitched tone. Classical women's voice types (alto, mezzo-soprano, soprano) primarily operate in head voice. Try humming a high note, and see if you can feel it buzzing behind your nose.
  • Your chest voice is the bottom half of your modal register. Your pharyngeal muscles close off airflow into your nasal cavity and your voice resonates almost entirely in your pharynx -- contrary to the name, chest voice does NOT come from the chest cavity, though your chest voice can be felt vibrating there. It's a full and rich tone, and where classical men's voice types (tenor, baritone, bass) operate. Hum a real deep note and see if you can feel it resonating all the way down into your upper chest.

The pitches you can hit in head and chest voice typically overlap in an area where both voices can be weak, a transitionary part of your modal register known as the passagio. This is where your voice might crack if you try to ascend in a continuous tone. How do you deal with that?

Belting is singing as LOUDLY and POWERFULLY as you dang near can. By using a lot of air and putting a lot of tension into your laryngeal muscles, you can sing higher notes in your chest voice than you might singing at lower volumes. Sometimes being LOUD and POWERFUL are good things, but you will only be able to hit LOUD and POWERFUL high-pitched notes this way. More important to know however is that :siren: you can seriously injure your voice this way. :siren: If you've ever gone to a concert and screamed along and had a bum voice for the next week, it's probably because you were belting irresponsibly. :siren: Please be careful with your voice!!!!! :siren: It is a delicate and beautiful meat instrument.

Mixing or blending is engaging your pharyngeal muscles to control the degree of openness of your nasal cavity. Using your mix to transition between head and chest is more responsible form and allows for a much greater degree of control over tone and volume. Notes that you can hit in both head and chest voice can sound completely different from one another, and using your mix, you can modulate the ratio of 'head tone' to 'chest tone' in your voice to make all sorts of dynamic variations.


In addition to where your voice resonates and thus the general timbre it takes on, you have the ability to amplify our voice using different parts of our vocal anatomy. Resonant voice production, or singing forward, is how you make your voice LOUD without straining. By keeping your tongue, jaw, and throat relaxed and open, sound can travel into your facial bones, which vibrate and project sound forward.

A more specific type of amplification is known as twang, in which you partially close your epiglottis like you would close drawstrings. This shapes and constricts the sound coming from your larynx, amplifying certain pitches the human ear is very sensitive to and can more easily be heard above instrumentation. There are other types of selective amplification as well, which taken to the extreme can be used for polyphonic singing in which the voice produces two distinct tones simultaneously. Here's a fascinating explanation by the polyphonic singer Anna-Maria Hefele:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UHTF1-IhuC0


:o: :o: :o:


Pt. 3: Learning to Sing

Everyone can learn to sing! Unless you're actually mute, if you can make sound with your voice, you can learn too, and here's how!
  • Get yourself a vocal instructor. As a reminder, unlike most other instruments, you're the instrument when you're singing, and :siren: it's very possible to hurt yourself with bad form. :siren: Your guitar can take much more physical and stylistic abuse than your voice can, so it's important to learn how to take care of it. A good voice teacher can help you learn good form, how to practice on your own, and judge your singing much more objectively than you can. That means they can tell you what to practice, and you'll become a much better singer much faster than you would have without a teacher.
  • Record your voice lessons and practice. There's no way you can judge your voice accurately while you're singing, so it's important to hear it played back so you know what you actually sound like. You will almost definitely hate how you sound on recording and want to fling the recorder out a window, but don't turn away from the truth! The truth will set you free, and will help you become a better singer!
  • Actually practice. Practice everyday. If you're self conscious about it, practice in the shower where nobody is gonna judge because everyone sings in the shower. Learn good warmups and hiss and pbbbt like a maniac, and listen to your most recent voice lesson to know what you should be practicing.
  • Check out Singing YouTube. There's a whole slew of good videos on YouTube with instructors not only explaining but demonstrating any singing style or technique you could imagine. It won't replace a real vocal instructor who can give you direct feedback, but it's a great way to learn new exercises and concepts.

:o: :o: :o:


I hope you enjoyed reading my OP and maybe learned something new! Let me know if you have something good to add or if I said something dumb or incorrect. Let us all know how you're progressing, and share your voice with us if you're feeling brave! I guess we probably won't have gearchat as much as they do in the other megathreads, but please feel free to talk mics or vocoders or whatever too (good mic info can be found in the recording and live music threads). It can be hard to not feel shy about your voice, so let's all keep it chill and positive and encouraging! Everyone in the world has a voice all their own, and yours deserves to be heard too!

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

alnilam
Nov 10, 2009

Thanks, i enjoyed reading about chest vs head voice, that's a neat distinction i hadn't thought about before

e: more content: I really enjoy singing loudly to myself while I hike or bike. In fact, singing while hiking is a great way to avoid an unfortunate surprise encounter with a bear, and can also can be a great morale booster when you're getting tired. And plus the voice is the one instrument you always have! It's easy to pack a harmonica but even easier to bring your throat along.

The specific thing i want to bring up here is that not all songs sound great totally solo a capella. However, you know what does? Old Irish folk, Scottish folk, and Appalachian songs. They tend to have very melodic lead vocal parts that are good for this, and they're basically purpose built to be easy to remember too. I've been trying to learn more of them recently for this purpose, and also relatedly for campfire singing.

alnilam fucked around with this message at 01:00 on Nov 21, 2017

POOL IS CLOSED
Jul 14, 2011

I'm just exploding with mackerel. This is the aji wo kutta of my discontent.
Pillbug
Oh man, I wish I'd learned even a fraction of this in my chorus class.

What sort of factors influence a person's range? Besides sex, I never got a sense for what sort of things influence the extremes of a singer's range and how wide or narrow that is and what can change it.

Hoshi
Jan 20, 2013

:wrongcity:
Good OP!

Anyone who wants to get better, it can't be emphasized enough, practice practice practice with a recording device.

Getting a teacher is a good idea, but keep in mind that good singing should be comfortable. If you feel like you're not making progress and/or vocal production is getting worse (less stamina, smaller range, general discomfort) it's a problem with the teaching method, not you.

Finally, have fun, because it is a lot of fun.

City of Glompton
Apr 21, 2014

I learned more from this op than I did in choir from middle school to college. thank you for sharing. I don't see a voice teacher in my future but youtube videos are do-able :)

mags
May 30, 2008

I am a congenital optimist.
i love to singa

I usually do Junior's part in Move Your Feet at karaoke

AverySpecialfriend
Jul 8, 2017

by Hand Knit

alnilam posted:

Thanks, i enjoyed reading about chest vs head voice, that's a neat distinction i hadn't thought about before

There's a lot of singing :biotruths: floating around but aside from the parts of the voice that are expressly dimorphic, there's not a significant difference in the mechanics of voice in most people. Commonly, men just don't get taught to use their head voice because unless you sing countertenor it's not a huge part of pieces written for men's voice types. Voice ranges are also largely overlapping, which is called a bimodal distribution in statistics and more voices than not fall somewhere that's within both normal male and female variation.

POOL IS CLOSED posted:

Oh man, I wish I'd learned even a fraction of this in my chorus class.

What sort of factors influence a person's range? Besides sex, I never got a sense for what sort of things influence the extremes of a singer's range and how wide or narrow that is and what can change it.

Vocal cord thickness will determine your mean vocal pitch, but the width of your range probably has more to do with the strength of your laryngeal muscles and elasticity of your vocal cords, which as far as I've been able to learn mainly comes down to phenotypic variance without much correlation to hormone exposure. The average human range is about three octaves and change plus or minus maybe 2/3rds, so a wide range would be around 4 octaves and a narrow one shy of 3.

Vocal range, of course, has nothing to do with your singing ability as you can have a wide range and be a bad singer or a narrow range and be a fantastic one - Adele notably only has a range around 2 and a half octaves. You can expand your range with training but it mainly comes down to chance (though you can definitely shrink your range through smoking, injury, etc).

Hoshi posted:

Good OP!

Anyone who wants to get better, it can't be emphasized enough, practice practice practice with a recording device.

Getting a teacher is a good idea, but keep in mind that good singing should be comfortable. If you feel like you're not making progress and/or vocal production is getting worse (less stamina, smaller range, general discomfort) it's a problem with the teaching method, not you.

Finally, have fun, because it is a lot of fun.

Thanks!! :) This is a good point too. With singing, the hard part should be coordination --
which is more of a mental exercise than anything -- not exerting or straining your body in any way. You learn to resist your body's natural inclination towards tension in your mouth and throat, which aside from damping some of your voice's best qualities (e.g. clear, loud resonance) can cause injury if you strain too hard. Don't hurt yourself singing because singing is fun and if you hurt yourself you won't be able to sing as much and that's no fun!

City of Glompton posted:

I learned more from this op than I did in choir from middle school to college. thank you for sharing. I don't see a voice teacher in my future but youtube videos are do-able :)

Shucks, thank you! My teacher is a PhD vocal student so aside from having an amazing voice, she knows a ton about the mechanics of it all and picked up that I'm the kind of dweeb who would want to learn how everything functions in tandem from a scientific viewpoint. Vocal anatomy is super cool, humans have this complex and incredible instrument just hiding inside their mouths and throats all the time!

mister magpie posted:

i love to singa

Hawkperson
Jun 20, 2003

That is a much better OP than I would have made, great work :)

Vocal cords/folds don’t compare well to string instruments IMO, they work almost identically to brass instruments if you want to get what’s going on. Brass players press their lips together and use the force of their air to make ridiculous elephant sounds that then resonate in their instruments and come out sounding pretty. That’s basically what your body does to talk/sing, too. There’s some cool YouTube videos of what your vocal folds look like when they’re working (and sad ones of what damage looks like, too :()

Simone Poodoin
Jun 26, 2003

Che storia figata, ragazzo!



Great OP, OP.

I started singing lessons two weeks ago after a few years of dabbling with bass, guitar and drums. Turns out I can sing the correct pitch after listening to it very easily IF I don't think about it, if I start thinking I'll mess it up. I'm also better than expected when going upwards on a scale, but have big tone control issues when going downwards. And my tone/timbre is terrible but I'm really excited to practice and improve.

I dug up my old xbox 360 and rockband 3 to try the singing part (which I never did before) and I'm finding that on many songs I find the range awkward, on many songs I feel more comfortable singing an octave below what the actual singer is doing, but can't hit the lower notes. If I sing up then I can't hit the high notes. I guess it will come with practice but it's all really fun and interesting so far.

mags
May 30, 2008

I am a congenital optimist.

Simone Poodoin posted:

Great OP, OP.

I started singing lessons two weeks ago after a few years of dabbling with bass, guitar and drums. Turns out I can sing the correct pitch after listening to it very easily IF I don't think about it, if I start thinking I'll mess it up. I'm also better than expected when going upwards on a scale, but have big tone control issues when going downwards. And my tone/timbre is terrible but I'm really excited to practice and improve.

I dug up my old xbox 360 and rockband 3 to try the singing part (which I never did before) and I'm finding that on many songs I find the range awkward, on many songs I feel more comfortable singing an octave below what the actual singer is doing, but can't hit the lower notes. If I sing up then I can't hit the high notes. I guess it will come with practice but it's all really fun and interesting so far.

i had the same problem when my old band covered a Rise Against song, I found it hard to hit the same notes in Give It All's chorus, and had to improvise something that was lower but still sounded alright

Jazz Marimba
Jan 4, 2012

Thank you so much for this! PM a mod so you can get this stickied and changed to the school tag, cuz this is some great info!

AverySpecialfriend posted:

There's a lot of singing :biotruths: floating around but aside from the parts of the voice that are expressly dimorphic, there's not a significant difference in the mechanics of voice in most people.
What are some of those :biotruths:?

AverySpecialfriend posted:

The average human range is about three octaves and change plus or minus maybe 2/3rds, so a wide range would be around 4 octaves and a narrow one shy of 3.
Good to know I have a large range. Is there any way I can leverage that into sucking less, or is it just a random factoid about my voice?

AverySpecialfriend posted:

Shucks, thank you! My teacher is a PhD vocal student so aside from having an amazing voice, she knows a ton about the mechanics of it all and picked up that I'm the kind of dweeb who would want to learn how everything functions in tandem from a scientific viewpoint. Vocal anatomy is super cool, humans have this complex and incredible instrument just hiding inside their mouths and throats all the time!
Hi, wow. I love this stuff too. Tell me more?

Hoshi
Jan 20, 2013

:wrongcity:
Fun tip for breath control!

Get a candle with a scent you like, light it, then practice blowing on it lightly to make it flicker consistently without going out. Hold it as close to your mouth as you can safely.

Simone Poodoin
Jun 26, 2003

Che storia figata, ragazzo!



Which apps have you found useful for practice? I have been trying Sing Sharp but find it a bit clunky, tried a few random others and they were waaay worse.

PTSDeedly Do
Nov 24, 2014

VOID-DOME LOSER 2020


If you are nervous about singing out I would recommend joining a local choir. Pieces, unless written as professional repertoire, tend to be written so as to be singable by a wide range of voice types. Choirs are often heavily weighted towards female singers in terms of membership, so if you’re a male and by any mean possess a decent ear/music reading skills, chances are the director and group will be thankful for having you there.

A human heart
Oct 10, 2012

Have you guys ever put a contact mic on your throat and made weird mouth noises, it's pretty fun

Jazz Marimba
Jan 4, 2012

A human heart posted:

Have you guys ever put a contact mic on your throat and made weird mouth noises, it's pretty fun

omg what?! do you have recordings of this?

AverySpecialfriend
Jul 8, 2017

by Hand Knit
Hi folks! Sorry for not responding, it's been a whirlwind couple of weeks for me.

Hawkgirl posted:

That is a much better OP than I would have made, great work :)

Vocal cords/folds don't compare well to string instruments IMO, they work almost identically to brass instruments if you want to get what's going on. Brass players press their lips together and use the force of their air to make ridiculous elephant sounds that then resonate in their instruments and come out sounding pretty. That's basically what your body does to talk/sing, too. There's some cool YouTube videos of what your vocal folds look like when they're working (and sad ones of what damage looks like, too :()

This is a good point, and thank you!! I was kind of being overly simplistic on purpose but I don't wanna be factually incorrect about it, so I'll go edit that when I get around to tidying up the OP (there are a couple of weird grammatical errors, etc.)

Simone Poodoin posted:

Great OP, OP.

I started singing lessons two weeks ago after a few years of dabbling with bass, guitar and drums. Turns out I can sing the correct pitch after listening to it very easily IF I don't think about it, if I start thinking I'll mess it up. I'm also better than expected when going upwards on a scale, but have big tone control issues when going downwards. And my tone/timbre is terrible but I'm really excited to practice and improve.

I dug up my old xbox 360 and rockband 3 to try the singing part (which I never did before) and I'm finding that on many songs I find the range awkward, on many songs I feel more comfortable singing an octave below what the actual singer is doing, but can't hit the lower notes. If I sing up then I can't hit the high notes. I guess it will come with practice but it's all really fun and interesting so far.

This sounds like a head/chest voice thing to me. I would guess that your passagio lies in a place that's kinda awkward for the songs you're singing, so it's easier to sing down an octave in a comfortable chest voice even if you can't ascend down quite far enough to hit some of the lower notes. When you're getting to higher notes, your chest voice might be giving out and you might need to learn to transition to your head voice to hit those notes.

As far as scales go, keep your energy up! I do this too where I do very bright and clean vowels going up that get kinda lazy and mushy coming down. A good thing to practice is watching yourself in the mirror and making sure your mouth isn't getting droopy. My teacher likes to tell me that when I go down, I should think up - keep your posture upright and don't let your chest collapse or you'll have trouble controlling your diaphragm. Also, thank you too!!!

Jazz Marimba posted:

Thank you so much for this! PM a mod so you can get this stickied and changed to the school tag, cuz this is some great info!

What are some of those :biotruths:?

Good to know I have a large range. Is there any way I can leverage that into sucking less, or is it just a random factoid about my voice?

Hi, wow. I love this stuff too. Tell me more?

1) The one old white dude meme that always stood out to me was that it's LITERALLY IMPOSSIBLE for there to ever be a 'male alto' despite the fact that the classic 3 octave ranges for tenor and alto pieces are like 90% overlapping and there are definitely many folks with wider ranges than that. Of course, none of those people making a stink about male altos ever mention female tenors. :rolleyes:

2) Having a wide range is good, but having a narrow range isn't bad, is kind of the way to look at it I think. If you work on your fundamentals, your range should naturally expand a bit, but having a wide range won't really do much for tone on its own. So keep practicing!

3) I don't have PMs! Anyone wanna message a mod on my behalf? Also change the thread name to Human Instrumentality Project tia

Hoshi posted:

Fun tip for breath control!

Get a candle with a scent you like, light it, then practice blowing on it lightly to make it flicker consistently without going out. Hold it as close to your mouth as you can safely.

Neat trick! Some good breath exercises I know are short and long hisses. Basically, you take one big breath (imagine you're sucking in air through a straw and really fill up those lungs and let your chest expand), and then do somewhere in the realm of 15-25 consecutive short hiss hiss hisses or one long steady hiss for that amount of time. They work out different things too -- the short hisses are all about activating your diaphragm and as you get better at this you can really feel your diaphragm moving in and out and forcing air through. The long hiss is about keeping your diaphragm engaged and sloooooooowly letting the air out as evenly as you can.

I think I'll write a bit more sometime soon about exercises into the OP, and I've also been thinking about twang a lot because it's something I've been practicing. If you wanna know what twang sounds like, listen to some Grimes cuz she sings with a lot of it and it's what makes her voice sound so nasally and higher pitched than it actually is.

AverySpecialfriend fucked around with this message at 01:29 on Dec 1, 2017

Simone Poodoin
Jun 26, 2003

Che storia figata, ragazzo!



AverySpecialfriend posted:

As far as scales go, keep your energy up! I do this too where I do very bright and clean vowels going up that get kinda lazy and mushy coming down. A good thing to practice is watching yourself in the mirror and making sure your mouth isn't getting droopy. My teacher likes to tell me that when I go down, I should think up - keep your posture upright and don't let your chest collapse or you'll have trouble controlling your diaphragm. Also, thank you too!!!

Thanks, my teacher told me pretty much the same last week lol.

We're working on songs too, not only technical stuff and exercises so it's fun and also useful to find interesting details. In my case if I'm singing along to a song I can match pitch with the lead singer and do ok, but if there are backup vocals, I will start matching their pitch not the lead singer's. My teacher says that it might be because my main instrument is bass so I naturally move to the background, I like that explanation but need to work to prevent that.

A human heart
Oct 10, 2012

Jazz Marimba posted:

omg what?! do you have recordings of this?

nope, it's just a fun thing you can do

AverySpecialfriend
Jul 8, 2017

by Hand Knit

Simone Poodoin posted:

Thanks, my teacher told me pretty much the same last week lol.

We're working on songs too, not only technical stuff and exercises so it's fun and also useful to find interesting details. In my case if I'm singing along to a song I can match pitch with the lead singer and do ok, but if there are backup vocals, I will start matching their pitch not the lead singer's. My teacher says that it might be because my main instrument is bass so I naturally move to the background, I like that explanation but need to work to prevent that.

That makes sense, but also more generally I can understand how it would throw your ear with multiple voices going.

What songs do you like to practice? My teacher makes me do this one John Dowland song called Flow My Tears that was written in like 1650 or something and I frickin' hate it now (she warned me I was gonna keep singing it even if I hated it) but it's really good practice for breath control and long clean vowels. My personal favorite song to practice is I Will by Mitski and I sing it every morning for my warmup. It helps its a song I like so much and don't get tired of, but I kinda wonder about the neighbors lol...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjy6au_whJg

Tweezer Reprise
Aug 6, 2013

It hasn't got six strings, but it's a lot of fun.
Any online voice coaches worth a drat?

AverySpecialfriend
Jul 8, 2017

by Hand Knit
I'd say it depends on what you're looking for. When you say online vocal coach do you mean like video tutorials or actual face time? Videos are good for learning exercises and new things to experiment with but they can't meaningfully replace direct feedback. An online coach can give you feedback on certain aspects of your singing but a) that doesn't include your posture which is a big part of singing and b) the audio quality might get in the way of them giving accurate critique depending on your setup. So I'd say, if you want to find an online coach go for it but don't overpay and consider looking for in person lessons anyway.

Also, hi thread!! I haven't been posting much because I've been on hiatus with lessons because of winter break and the holidays, etc. I'll be picking back up in January so expect more content then!

Tweezer Reprise
Aug 6, 2013

It hasn't got six strings, but it's a lot of fun.
Right, thanks! I'm probably going to go with a face-to-face coach, then.

AverySpecialfriend
Jul 8, 2017

by Hand Knit

Tweezer Reprise posted:

Right, thanks! I'm probably going to go with a face-to-face coach, then.

Good call imo, and best of luck!

Sexpansion
Mar 22, 2003

DELETED

Tweezer Reprise posted:

Any online voice coaches worth a drat?

I honestly think you can learn a lot through skype. What genre do you want to sing? If you want to sing contemporary, I think both https://www.philmoufarrege.com/ and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=user?VocalLiberation seem to know what they're talking about and, most importantly, they have students that have gotten significantly better.

Honestly, voice teaching is a racket. You have to be really careful with teachers because it's very, very easy to act like you know what you're talking about when it comes to singing but not really know. If you do end up going with a face to face teacher, get a really good idea of how they teach before you commit. For instance, what is their pedagogical style? How do they teach? What do they fundamentally believe leads to a solid technique? etc.

Edit: Also, if the teacher can't DO the things he/she is describing then run away as fast as you can.

Sexpansion fucked around with this message at 20:40 on Feb 28, 2018

Tweezer Reprise
Aug 6, 2013

It hasn't got six strings, but it's a lot of fun.

Sexpansion posted:

I honestly think you can learn a lot through skype. What genre do you want to sing? If you want to sing contemporary, I think both https://www.philmoufarrege.com/ and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=user?VocalLiberation seem to know what they're talking about and, most importantly, they have students that have gotten significantly better.

Honestly, voice teaching is a racket. You have to be really careful with teachers because it's very, very easy to act like you know what you're talking about when it comes to singing but not really know. If you do end up going with a face to face teacher, get a really good idea of how they teach before you commit. For instance, what is their pedagogical style? How do they teach? What do they fundamentally believe leads to a solid technique? etc.

Edit: Also, if the teacher can't DO the things he/she is describing then run away as fast as you can.

thank you so much for this! i didn’t end up getting those lessons due to logistical reasons (i don’t drive) but i’ll definitely check these out! My main goal is being able to sing my own songs that I've written to my satisfaction, funny enough

AverySpecialfriend
Jul 8, 2017

by Hand Knit
Hey vocal thread! I was meaning to revive this, I just got the pieces for a vocal recording setup and hopefully I'll record something soon I'm not embarrassed to share! I'll post pics of my setup in a couple of days too.

I can't speak to vocal lessons in general, but my experience taking lessons with a classically trained singer was incredibly positive and I went from square zero to not actually that bad anymore in six months on and off, and a lot of that has to do with her coaching the minutae of my form and posture. If you can find an instructor who can teach you good fundamentals (and who you get along with, also very important!), that will translate to any style of singing. If you live near a university you can definitely find a poor grad student who would be more than happy to teach you.

syntaxfunction
Oct 27, 2010
Hey vocal thread! I have a weird request for advice. I've been left responsible for everything for my main project. This includes vocals. Problem is I despise my voice. I would like to get my voice presentable. I'm honestly not looking for a great voice.

The main points are first, does anyone know a directory of teachers I can peruse in my area? I'm located Brisbane, Australia for reference.

Second, my main goal is a "bad good" voice like Billy Corgan and stuff. Specifically I'd love to sound like Ruby from The Football Club. I am very obviously not trying to get on one of those singing talent shows on TV.

For reference my most recent song with vocals is this song. I am fully aware of how breathy and fake my voice sounds. I've literally never had a lesson in my life and I wasn't encouraged to sing growing up (but that's a whole 'nother thing). I would just start recording and practicing but I am afraid of loving up my voice, hence the recommendation for a teacher.

If it's any help I have speech exercises I'm doing to train my vocals for talking. It's where a lot of breathiness comes from, as I'm trying to project from my head and mouth instead of chest.

Thanks for any advice. Y'all are too good.

Hawkperson
Jun 20, 2003

Hmmm that’s an interesting dilemma you have as your reference recording does seem to have a lot of chest voice in it. I think I would seriously recommend trying to approach your music from a more “talky” standpoint, like Shatner spoken word style. Your end goal is much more like talking than like singing, you know? Once you give it a few tries as talking (like, seriously pretend you are giving a speech without a microphone), try it again singing and see if it’s better, I think it might be.

Finding private lessons on the other hand is tough, especially when you want a unique sound like you’re going for. Wish I could be more help on that front.

syntaxfunction
Oct 27, 2010
Thanks for the advice anyway! I'll give the talky singy thing a crack at some stage. Anything's gotta be better than what I have now right?

I have my current vocal rehabilitation to do but once I feel okay with that I've seen a few local recommended teachers for not crazy money (my current coach is $90/hr and these are $35/hr so definitely cheap for me) so that might be an avenue.

magnificent7
Sep 22, 2005

THUNDERDOME LOSER

syntaxfunction posted:

I have my current vocal rehabilitation to do

What is this I need this. I used to have a voice, I used to sing almost weekly at 4 hour shows. Now, there's this range of four or five odd notes in the middle of my overall range, where my throat takes a dump and it sounds like a rat stuck in a fan. Over those notes? Great. Under? Good. HIT those notes? Run. Hide.

Edit - at audible volumes - (I used to sing pretty loud. Not metal, but soul) at quieter volumes, the notes are there, I can falsetto my way over the rough spots. But going into my singing voice, oh, it's like I've got two flat tires.

syntaxfunction
Oct 27, 2010
Oh dear, I guess I should clarify it's not rehabilitation for singing or throat injury. It's uh, learning to speak like a woman instead of a dude.

Sorry if I got your hopes up with potential exercises or something! My bad!

magnificent7
Sep 22, 2005

THUNDERDOME LOSER

syntaxfunction posted:

Oh dear, I guess I should clarify it's not rehabilitation for singing or throat injury. It's uh, learning to speak like a woman instead of a dude.

Sorry if I got your hopes up with potential exercises or something! My bad!
Well poo poo. Now I gotta go find somebody to make it up so I can start taking those lessons.

AverySpecialfriend
Jul 8, 2017

by Hand Knit
Learning to use your mix voice isn't easy because it's hard to know which direction to approach those notes from. The best advice my teacher gave me for when you're singing in your passagio is to really relax and let your voice go where it wants to go without trying to force it to do anything specific.

Hawkperson
Jun 20, 2003

magnificent7 posted:

Well poo poo. Now I gotta go find somebody to make it up so I can start taking those lessons.

You sound like you might have vocal nodes, so maybe go see an ENT doc that specializes in vocalists? They would probably have a referral to the kind of rehabilitative vocal therapy that you were thinking of.

AverySpecialfriend
Jul 8, 2017

by Hand Knit

Hawkgirl posted:

You sound like you might have vocal nodes, so maybe go see an ENT doc that specializes in vocalists? They would probably have a referral to the kind of rehabilitative vocal therapy that you were thinking of.

This is also a possibility :(

magnificent7
Sep 22, 2005

THUNDERDOME LOSER

Hawkgirl posted:

You sound like you might have vocal nodes, so maybe go see an ENT doc that specializes in vocalists? They would probably have a referral to the kind of rehabilitative vocal therapy that you were thinking of.
I went. The doc said no, it's not nodes. It's lazy vocal chords, I should join a choir. And while I probably won't do that, I definitely do need to start practicing more; they're muscles and I guess they're old like me?

Hawkperson
Jun 20, 2003

magnificent7 posted:

I went. The doc said no, it's not nodes. It's lazy vocal chords, I should join a choir. And while I probably won't do that, I definitely do need to start practicing more; they're muscles and I guess they're old like me?

Ha!! I mean, in the end, that’s a LOT better than having nodes at least :)

Jazz Marimba
Jan 4, 2012

syntaxfunction posted:

Oh dear, I guess I should clarify it's not rehabilitation for singing or throat injury. It's uh, learning to speak like a woman instead of a dude.

Sorry if I got your hopes up with potential exercises or something! My bad!

I don't know where you're located, but my friend Liz Jackson Hearns gives trans voice lessons in Chicago, runs the second trans choir in the U.S., and wrote a book on it (textbook-priced, and isn't out quite yet, but she just got the proof copy today).

Here's her website if you want to check it out https://www.thevoicelabinc.com/transgender-voice-chicago.html

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

syntaxfunction
Oct 27, 2010

Jazz Marimba posted:

I don't know where you're located, but my friend Liz Jackson Hearns gives trans voice lessons in Chicago, runs the second trans choir in the U.S., and wrote a book on it (textbook-priced, and isn't out quite yet, but she just got the proof copy today).

Here's her website if you want to check it out https://www.thevoicelabinc.com/transgender-voice-chicago.html

That's really cool! Sadly I'm located in Australia so it might be a wee bit too far :) But it's always nice to see stuff like this around.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply