Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Judas Iscaredycat
Mar 14, 2013

alcaras posted:

You get it.

Thanks. I was actually kind of hoping it would be the other way around.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

victrix
Oct 30, 2007


Eric the Mauve posted:

victrix:

1) No; as of BNW lump sums of gold are only allowed to be traded between civs with a DOF, for the precise purpose of eliminating that exploit.

Ah, this is still the issue I had problems with, it was too easy to make friends, effectively steal their inflated gold supply and then back stab them, giving up nothing.

If they spend their gold better after this fall patch, that might help at least

uPen
Jan 25, 2010

Zu Rodina!

victrix posted:

Ah, this is still the issue I had problems with, it was too easy to make friends, effectively steal their inflated gold supply and then back stab them, giving up nothing.

If they spend their gold better after this fall patch, that might help at least

You can't backstab them now, if you DoW someone you have a declaration of friendship with everyone on the planet will hate your guts and you'll be at war with everyone forever.

victrix
Oct 30, 2007


That's not the same thing as 'can't' :D

The issue with it was that you could abuse it as an endgame gambit. Because the AI gets such stupid bonuses on higher difficulties, it can and often does amass a ridiculous fortune by the late game.

Because it wasn't (when I last played, pre-fall patch) spending that cash, I could 'break' it by waiting until the end game, promising a bunch of per turn trades for ALL my stuff in a series of trades for lump sum gold, get 20-30-40k gold, and then either a) buy out every city state and win or b) buy ALL the military and win.

It just felt really cheesy and exploitive, and also dumb because the AI should have been spending that money in the first place, on units, buildings, or fighting for city state control, and it wasn't.

I guess I should just play a few games through and see if they tinkered with anything else, but that quirk was a major problem for me.

Eric the Mauve
May 8, 2012

Making you happy for a buck since 199X
I can't see why it's such a problem; if it bothers you then why not, y'know, just not do it?

Fojar38
Sep 2, 2011


Sorry I meant to say I hope that the police use maximum force and kill or maim a bunch of innocent people, thus paving a way for a proletarian uprising and socialist utopia


also here's a stupid take
---------------------------->

Chamale posted:

GDP: Total gold income
Manufacturing: Total hammers
Crop yield: Total food production

Something I'm too lazy to check myself; is manufacturing total hammers being worked or total potential hammers?

TacMan
Aug 8, 2002

Vert used Hyperbeam,
It's super effective!


:steam: El Mole :steam:
does the AI bonus to production and buying units also apply to faith bought units, like great prophets and missionaries? is this why I'll see a flock of 3-5 enemy great prophets at a time, all game long? or like 15 missionaries?

How can you really compete against that without straight up killing those units...which is what I usually do.

it seems a bit odd to give the AI discounts on those units, if that's what is happening. I can't think of how else it could happen since that's several hundred faith per turn it feels like that would be required for the AI to generate those units normally.

edit: I'm talking like on immortal difficulties, where the AI gets 75% or similar production bonuses.

TacMan fucked around with this message at 07:03 on Oct 31, 2013

Supersheep
Nov 11, 2009
Playing wide with Desert Folklore tends to give you plenty of faith to counter enemy missionaries. I just finished a game (as William of all people) where I ended up with 14 000 faith stored by the end, and nothing to spend it on, because the only faith buying SP tree I'd finished was tradition, and my production was so ridiculously good I didn't need GEs for wonders.

Chamale
Jul 11, 2010

I'm helping!



Fojar38 posted:

Something I'm too lazy to check myself; is manufacturing total hammers being worked or total potential hammers?

Hammers being worked, or used to produce wealth and research. If you go from city to city and add up the current production of each city, that should equal your manufacturing statistic.

Nektu
Jul 4, 2007

FUKKEN FUUUUUUCK
Cybernetic Crumb

Dr Snofeld posted:

Can anyone recommend a good newbie guide? Enough has changed between 4 and 5 that I'm a bit out of my depth regarding how to open, when to get workers out, what works as a military and suchlike.
Same request, but the other way around: after that comparison of Civ4 and 5 on the last pages I got curious and want to try my luck with Civ4. Any particularly good newbie resources? Any mods that are a must-have for Civ4?

Phobophilia
Apr 26, 2008

by Hand Knit
If I had could recommend a good guide for Civ4 (and the whole Civ/4X series in general), it'd be Sisiutil's guide.

A good mod for Civ4 is the BUG mod, it basically adds alot more features to the UI. This is quite powerful, but it's easy to get information overload from it. I wouldn't necessarily recommend it for new players, fortunately the interface already gives alot more information in Civ4 than Civ5.

Supersheep
Nov 11, 2009
Has anyone else encountered this bug?



At this point, the only civs I've met are Napoleon and Lizzy, but it seems like I can pay Napoleon to go to war with civs neither he nor I have met.

I'm not using any mods. Has there been a recent update?

Phobophilia
Apr 26, 2008

by Hand Knit
Looks like those other civs are greyed out, so you won't be able to click them and request behaviour. But it's still a huge amount of spoiler information about who you're up against. Like you know the other continent will be a backwards clusterfuck thanks to the warmongers.

Dirk the Average
Feb 7, 2012

"This may have been a mistake."

Eric the Mauve posted:

I can't see why it's such a problem; if it bothers you then why not, y'know, just not do it?

I think his problem was more along the lines of the fact that the AI simply wasn't using the money - if it were properly spending its reserves, it would be more of a challenge because it would have more buildings, units, city states, etc. It's silly to give the AI tons of money and then not have the AI actually spend said money on anything.

Kazzah
Jul 15, 2011

Formerly known as
Krazyface
Hair Elf

Phobophilia posted:

If I had could recommend a good guide for Civ4 (and the whole Civ/4X series in general), it'd be Sisiutil's guide.

A good mod for Civ4 is the BUG mod, it basically adds alot more features to the UI. This is quite powerful, but it's easy to get information overload from it. I wouldn't necessarily recommend it for new players, fortunately the interface already gives alot more information in Civ4 than Civ5.

Speaking of which, does anyone know a cheap place to get Civ IV? It's $30 on GMG and Steam, and about $25 on Amazon. Is there anywhere else trustworthy, or should I just wait for a sale?

Microplastics
Jul 6, 2007

:discourse:
It's what's for dinner.

Krazyface posted:

Speaking of which, does anyone know a cheap place to get Civ IV? It's $30 on GMG and Steam, and about $25 on Amazon. Is there anywhere else trustworthy, or should I just wait for a sale?

A lot of people have two copies for some reason, it's possible someone in this very thread will gift you it.

My steam tells me I have two copies, but I don't know if that's just a bug or not. It really annoys me though :mad:

RagnarokAngel
Oct 5, 2006

Black Magic Extraordinaire

KKKlean Energy posted:

A lot of people have two copies for some reason, it's possible someone in this very thread will gift you it.

My steam tells me I have two copies, but I don't know if that's just a bug or not. It really annoys me though :mad:

It's a bug kind of. The Mac version and PC version are treated as seperate entries. Most steamplay games just know to download whatever you're currently using but curiously Civ 4 does not.

computer parts
Nov 18, 2010

PLEASE CLAP

RagnarokAngel posted:

It's a bug kind of. The Mac version and PC version are treated as seperate entries. Most steamplay games just know to download whatever you're currently using but curiously Civ 4 does not.

It was a licensing deal iirc, basically it couldn't legally be treated as the same piece of software so they just gifted both versions to everyone.

Anyway just wait for a sale, it's not really worth $30 even though it's a good game.

Mr. Pumroy
May 20, 2001

Gyshall posted:

The production, free settler, and free worker from Liberty are so goddamn good.

I tend to play Korea on King difficulty and filling out Liberty is my new favorite thing to do. I tend to be very Wonder-heavy in my opening (I build a library and Great Library for the double research boost in my capitol, then go down to the other side for Mausoleum of Halicarnassus) so Tradition's Great Wonder bonus was very attractive. But when I tried Liberty I found that it sped my empire along quite well. The free settler and free worker lets me build without having to immediately worry about expanding, and the free Great Person at the end of the tree means I can get a 10 research tile from a Great Scientist early in the game (plus the 100 gold from building the Mausoleum gives me options to purchase another settler).

Flython
Oct 21, 2010

Mr. Pumroy posted:

I tend to play Korea on King difficulty and filling out Liberty is my new favorite thing to do. I tend to be very Wonder-heavy in my opening (I build a library and Great Library for the double research boost in my capitol, then go down to the other side for Mausoleum of Halicarnassus) so Tradition's Great Wonder bonus was very attractive. But when I tried Liberty I found that it sped my empire along quite well. The free settler and free worker lets me build without having to immediately worry about expanding, and the free Great Person at the end of the tree means I can get a 10 research tile from a Great Scientist early in the game (plus the 100 gold from building the Mausoleum gives me options to purchase another settler).

Are you saying you build a regular library and then the Great Library? I was pretty sure that building the Great Library gives you a free regular one in the city in which it's built.

dayman
Mar 12, 2009

Is it a yes, or...
Ugh, I wish that the game wouldn't return the melee unit that liberates a city back to the nearest city under your control. I took back New York for Washington and as a thanks he dropped my destroyer in the port of a captured city on a small inland sea.

Mr. Pumroy
May 20, 2001

Flython posted:

Are you saying you build a regular library and then the Great Library? I was pretty sure that building the Great Library gives you a free regular one in the city in which it's built.

You do, but Korea's UA is a research boost for each scientific building and wonder. If you build a GL first, you just get one boost from the GL and you can't build a library. But you can build a library first, get the boost from that then build the GL and get a boost from that.

edit: at least... I'm almost sure that's the case. Dammit, now I have to check. I could be assuming there's a boost hidden by the free tech bonus. I'm going to run a Quick game to see what happens.

edit 2: okay, just tested and yes, you do get a double boost. I cut down time on drama and poetry for the first boost while building library, then philosophy got a boost when I finished the GL and I chose optics for the free tech.

So in summary that owns.

Mr. Pumroy fucked around with this message at 14:23 on Oct 31, 2013

DarthBlingBling
Apr 19, 2004

These were also dark times for gamers as we were shunned by others for being geeky or nerdy and computer games were seen as Childs play things, during these dark ages the whispers began circulating about a 3D space combat game called Elite

- CMDR Bald Man In A Box

Mr. Pumroy posted:

You do, but Korea's UA is a research boost for each scientific building and wonder. If you build a GL first, you just get one boost from the GL and you can't build a library. But you can build a library first, get the boost from that then build the GL and get a boost from that.

edit: at least... I'm almost sure that's the case. Dammit, now I have to check. I could be assuming there's a boost hidden by the free tech bonus. I'm going to run a Quick game to see what happens.

edit 2: okay, just tested and yes, you do get a double boost. I cut down time on drama and poetry for the first boost while building library, then philosophy got a boost when I finished the GL and I chose optics for the free tech.

So in summary that owns.

Could you theoretically sell the library and build it again for another boost? Would it be worth it in the early game? How much science do you actually get?

EDIT:: Apparently the tech boost is the same as a RA and there was a bug that allowed you to sell and rebuild the library for another boost. May have been patched out now though - it has, you can't sell science buildings. Seems a funny way to fix an exploit

DarthBlingBling fucked around with this message at 14:43 on Oct 31, 2013

Mr. Pumroy
May 20, 2001

DarthBlingBling posted:

Could you theoretically sell the library and build it again for another boost? Would it be worth it in the early game? How much science do you actually get?

EDIT:: Apparently the tech boost is the same as a RA and there was a bug that allowed you to sell and rebuild the library for another boost. May have been patched out now though

I never tried the selling thing. Probably has been patched out.

As for how much research you gain, yeah it is meant to be equivalent to a RA, though I did get more beakers from the GL. That might be a result of me having more beakers per turn at that point, though (I have no idea how the quantity of beakers an RA provides you is calculated). I actually took the time to write down the numbers I got while doing this, if that's something people want to look at.

Keep in mind I'm running this on Quick at King level, so the numbers will be different depending on speed/difficulty:

Library:
Beakers per turn before library: 8
After: 10

Progress on Drama and Poetry before library: 58/123, 9 turns
After: 83/123, 4 turns
Boost: 25 beakers

Great Library:
Beakers per turn before GL: 12
After: 15

Progress on Philosophy before GL: 70/123, 5 turns
After: 109/123, 1 turn
Boost: 39 beakers

DarthBlingBling
Apr 19, 2004

These were also dark times for gamers as we were shunned by others for being geeky or nerdy and computer games were seen as Childs play things, during these dark ages the whispers began circulating about a 3D space combat game called Elite

- CMDR Bald Man In A Box
Apparently a RA gives you the median of all the available techs you can currently research and multiplies it by 0.5. So it may just be that when you built the GL the available techs required more science to research, therefore giving you slightly more science.

Also it seems there are certain buildings you cannot sell in the capitol, but you can sell them in the other cities. Probably an easy fix to stop exploits like this.

Not that I would have used it, would suck the fun out of the game. But when playing multiplayer with some friends it would've been funny to see their reaction when my science began to exponentially grow. Would only have worked in the later eras when the library would have taken only 1 turn to build.

SurreptitiousMuffin
Mar 21, 2010
Ugh, is there any way to turn off the AI's religion bonuses? Right now, it feels like "oh, an AI is actively building missionaries, well I sure wasted time even bothering with a religion."

They can outproduce you 3-1 on missionaries: it's ridiculous.

SlightlyMadman
Jan 14, 2005

Do they actually get faith bonuses, or just the same reduced costs for missionaries and great people that they do for other units? If you turn the difficulty down, I assume those bonuses would be reduced. I've personally not had a problem keeping up on Immortal, unless Ethiopia is in the game (in which case you need to just form a containment border, densely convert it to your religion, and work back into safer territory from there). Any game I play religion-heavy, I can usually get 1/3 of the world at least.

Mameluke
Aug 2, 2013

by Fluffdaddy
Buy an inquisitor in any city that missionaries are coming for. They can't convert if you keep it parked there.

Cynic Jester
Apr 11, 2009

Let's put a simile on that face
A dazzling simile
Twinkling like the night sky

Mameluke posted:

Buy an inquisitor in any city that missionaries are coming for. They can't convert if you keep it parked there.

Another advantage of going tall, if you stop at 4 cities, dumping an inquisitor in all of your cities is so much more feasible.

SurreptitiousMuffin
Mar 21, 2010
Well yeah, but what if you want to spread your religion to cities that aren't yours? There's a ton of tenets that work best if you can get your gods as worshipped as possible, and they're all useless if a single AI player decides they want to spread their religion more.

Chamale
Jul 11, 2010

I'm helping!



SurreptitiousMuffin posted:

Well yeah, but what if you want to spread your religion to cities that aren't yours? There's a ton of tenets that work best if you can get your gods as worshipped as possible, and they're all useless if a single AI player decides they want to spread their religion more.

Go tall, take a growth pantheon and beliefs that give you benefits based on number of followers rather than number of cities.

SlightlyMadman
Jan 14, 2005

SurreptitiousMuffin posted:

Well yeah, but what if you want to spread your religion to cities that aren't yours? There's a ton of tenets that work best if you can get your gods as worshipped as possible, and they're all useless if a single AI player decides they want to spread their religion more.

Itinerant Preachers. The AI seems to never prioritize it, so I get it almost every game.

alcaras
Oct 3, 2013

noli timere
For Immortal difficulty, anyone recommend a solid Liberty opener?

I'm used to doing Tradition and I find myself struggling with Liberty -- I seem overextend and inevitably piss off all neighbors and get dragged into an early war, leaving me scrambling to make enough archers to hold them. When's the inflection point to stop expanding and start growing/building military (Tradition is very clearly at 4 max, Liberty seems much more situational).

SlightlyMadman
Jan 14, 2005

alcaras posted:

For Immortal difficulty, anyone recommend a solid Liberty opener?

I'm used to doing Tradition and I find myself struggling with Liberty -- I seem overextend and inevitably piss off all neighbors and get dragged into an early war, leaving me scrambling to make enough archers to hold them. When's the inflection point to stop expanding and start growing/building military (Tradition is very clearly at 4 max, Liberty seems much more situational).

The hardest part of playing Liberty at high difficulties is that it's specifically set up to allow you to expand quickly, but expanding quickly will result in an immediate dogpile. You can really only get away with it if you've got an isolated or easily defensible start, or go super heavy on your military. Failing those things, just keep an eye on everyone else and make sure you don't top out the city counts or cut too close to anyone else's territory. If another civ becomes an early expansionist warmonger pariah, you'll have an easier time going unnoticed.

Tradition is definitely an easier choice on Immortal.

Gyshall
Feb 24, 2009

Had a couple of drinks.
Saw a couple of things.
Going Liberty on higher difficulties demands you settle on/near luxuries, especially ones you don't already have. Also the AI can be a oval office in that regard and out-settle you pretty fast.

Poil
Mar 17, 2007

SurreptitiousMuffin posted:

Well yeah, but what if you want to spread your religion to cities that aren't yours? There's a ton of tenets that work best if you can get your gods as worshipped as possible, and they're all useless if a single AI player decides they want to spread their religion more.

Yeah, you don't actually get to use those. I think they're mostly so the AI has some junk beliefs it can randomly grab instead of the useful ones.

RagnarokAngel
Oct 5, 2006

Black Magic Extraordinaire
Spreading religion for me tends to be a crapshoot. Sometimes only people on one side of the world found religions, leaving a fertile land to spread the true faith on the other continent. It's nice when that happens.

SlightlyMadman
Jan 14, 2005

Speaking of which, what are considered the top tier founder beliefs these days, after tithe? I used to always go for the +1 happiness per city (Ceremonial Burial, I think) if I'm going wide, but since they nerfed it to per two cities it's a bit lackluster.

epiphanylol
Sep 18, 2013
Is the new map pack worth it?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Chamale
Jul 11, 2010

I'm helping!



epiphanylol posted:

Is the new map pack worth it?

Not really, no. Just download mods for free maps.

  • Locked thread