Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
Suave Fedora
Jun 10, 2004

steinrokkan posted:

Voodoo and cajun aristocrat families living in their swamp mansions like nothing changed? Sign me up!

Djanghoul Unchained

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Duckbox
Sep 7, 2007

Rutibex posted:

I don't fully understand why the Enclave and Brotherhood are at odds with each other. They are both remnants of the pre-war American government, both dedicated to preserving technology, both are pretty much amoral. It seems to me that they should be bros, the have almost identical agendas. I mean yeah sure the DC "good guy" branch doesn't like them, but you would think the outcasts would be knocking at their door.

Are the Enclave just racist against the Brotherhood for being out in the wastes so long and mutated or something?

I'm still not sure if you're trolling or just dense, but the Brotherhood is dedicated to keeping pre-war technology out of the "wrong hands" and it's pretty hard to find wronger hands than the people who blew up the world in the first place. The BoS rebelled (and started executing evil scientists) while the bombs were still dropping. The Enclave are the only ones who act like the USA is worth bringing back.

Superuser008
Feb 7, 2011

Duckbag posted:

See, it actually doesn't bother me at all that I disagree with him. It gives me an excuse to argue and show off my sweet, sweet superiority complex.

Really though, I read his posts mainly because I'm inclined to agree with him. Fallout 3 did have serious issues and is worthy of a well-considered reevaluation. That's not what he gave us by a long stretch, but it did get us thinking about some interesting things, like the lack of coherent themes in the game (it's got a clear sins of the past vs. brighter future thing going on, but that's about all I can parse), or the vague and sometimes contradictory motivations of many characters. He's also right on that the worldbuilding is lousy, but is utterly confused about why that might be. He thinks he knows what Fallout is "about," but he's so consistently off base I wonder if he even played the originals. He's also one of the most willfully obtuse vidya game writers I've ever seen. Take this:


The answer, for the kids at home, is "yes." Yes that is what this particular battle (not the "war," the war started 30 years earlier, this is just another skirmish) is about. He got it in one. He understands what the game is about. He's just too pigheaded to put it together. Project Purity at this point has been established as the key to building a new Wasteland, and the Enclave thinks that by controlling it they can control DC (Eden says exactly this in one of his speeches). Evidently, the Brotherhood agrees with them. The Brotherhood cannot afford to see the Enclave take control of DC, so they attack it before the Enclave can get established at the Purifier and use the promise of access (or lack of access) to clean drinking water to drive a wedge between the Wastelanders and the BoS and from there rebuild fascist America in their image. It's all pretty straightforward really.

We support the BoS not because of what they're trying to get, but what they intend to do with it. Shamus is the guy watching Raiders of the Lost Ark and thinking: what's the big deal they're both trying to get the Ark? How do I even know who the good guys are?

It's worth noting that the Enclave probably wants the project up and running under their control so they can dump the FEV into it just in case the Lone Wanderer chooses not to use the sample President-for-battery-life Eden gives him at Raven Rock.

Rutibex
Sep 9, 2001

by Fluffdaddy

Duckbag posted:

I'm still not sure if you're trolling or just dense, but the Brotherhood is dedicated to keeping pre-war technology out of the "wrong hands" and it's pretty hard to find wronger hands than the people who blew up the world in the first place. The BoS rebelled (and started executing evil scientists) while the bombs were still dropping. The Enclave are the only ones who act like the USA is worth bringing back.

Oh yeah, I guess I forgot that part of the BoS back story, I hadn't played Fallout 1 in years.

To be fair, in New Vegas Caesar talks about meeting some Brotherhood members that don't even remember the name of their founder, Rodger Maxton. If the Brotherhood can't even remember what their mission is I can't be expected to!

SirDan3k
Jan 6, 2001

Trust me, you are taking this a lot more seriously then I am.

King Vidiot posted:

That's not what "post-apocalyptic" means. Even in Mad Max, the grand-daddy of modern post-apocalyptic fiction there's always some glimmer of hope, even if it's just the fact that there's a crazy guy out there loving up the plans of bondage-wearing raider parties. "Post-apocalyptic" just means that the fiction takes place after some catastrophic event destroys civilization, and the people left behind have to pick up the pieces.

Then every modern shooter/story/and literally everything is post-apocalyptic as we have had plenty of societal collapses that we picked the pieces up from.

In the grand-daddy Mad Max, Max was that glimmer of hope and the movie was about the coming world breaking him for it. The glimmer of hope is always gilded and never amounts to anything but people are seemingly demanding that it should. Three hundred years after the bombs dropped in Fallout with the number of people alive and the tech available it would just be civilization, it'd be CoD: Art Deco Warfare not Fallout.

History Comes Inside!
Nov 20, 2004




Can't we just enjoy the game about "adventures in the nuclear wasteland" because that sounds way more fun than "adventures in civilisation because theoretically enough time has passed in the fiction to allow for the rebuilding of civilisation"

Just pretend the magic fallout universe background radiation has made everyone retarded so they subconsciously avoid getting too civilised if it really upsets you that much.

Bicyclops
Aug 27, 2004

MAKE WAY NEW STARS posted:

Can't we just enjoy the game about "adventures in the nuclear wasteland" because that sounds way more fun than "adventures in civilisation because theoretically enough time has passed in the fiction to allow for the rebuilding of civilisation"


That's my opinion.

cargohills
Apr 18, 2014

SirDan3k posted:

Then every modern shooter/story/and literally everything is post-apocalyptic as we have had plenty of societal collapses that we picked the pieces up from.

Please stop being such a dense baby, tia

chitoryu12
Apr 24, 2014

Rutibex posted:

Oh yeah, I guess I forgot that part of the BoS back story, I hadn't played Fallout 1 in years.

To be fair, in New Vegas Caesar talks about meeting some Brotherhood members that don't even remember the name of their founder, Rodger Maxton. If the Brotherhood can't even remember what their mission is I can't be expected to!

The length of time since the creation of the Brotherhood of Steel is the direct result of the splits it suffers. The original BoS started out trying to preserve pre-war technology, but evolved into essentially a xenophobic technocult that tries to actually take advanced tech from wastelanders using it to keep it out of their filthy hands. The East Coast Brotherhood in turn evolved from that to a mission of protection, preserving technology but also trying to use it to help the wasteland. The Brotherhood Outcasts are a group of the East Coast Brotherhood who believe in the "original" mission they set out with and split off to keep up the xenophobia.

Farm Frenzy
Jan 3, 2007

SirDan3k posted:

Except that's dumb because an apocalypse where people rebuild afterwards isn't an apocalypse. Society will never rebuild in Fallout and shouldn't, the NCR should be in flames held up as a failed attempt that was eaten alive by the new reality that is the wasteland. The Enclave and the Brotherhood should keep fracturing apart into splinter groups that work against each other.

poo poo should stay irrevocably hosed and any settlement big enough to stand as a ray of hope should be overrun in a matter of years.

isnt there enough hoplessly nihlistic post apocalpyse stuff floating around? the interesting thing about the fallout series, even in FO3 and tactics, is that they show how new communities spring up and try to reform society.

Bicyclops
Aug 27, 2004

I think "adventures in a nuclear wasteland" can still have hope in it, though. It doesn't have to be misery porn just because society hasn't really reformed.

History Comes Inside!
Nov 20, 2004




Its almost as if a game with a story generally requires an objective for you to want to work towards to compel you to move the narrative along

Hmmmmmmmmmm

marshmallow creep
Dec 10, 2008

I've been sitting here for 5 mins trying to think of a joke to make but I just realised the animators of Mass Effect already did it for me

Fallout should be a tower defense game where you keep mutants, ghouls, raiders and deathclaws from ransacking your vault. That's it. No outside civilizations except for other Vaults that are slowing losing their own wars. The game only ends when your vault is finally destroyed. There is no win condition, because this is the apocalypse.

marshmallow creep
Dec 10, 2008

I've been sitting here for 5 mins trying to think of a joke to make but I just realised the animators of Mass Effect already did it for me

Actually, being able to hold off a siege of Vault 13 from the Master's Army would have been pretty boss.

Bicyclops
Aug 27, 2004

Lotish posted:

Fallout should be a tower defense game where you keep mutants, ghouls, raiders and deathclaws from ransacking your vault. That's it. No outside civilizations except for other Vaults that are slowing losing their own wars. The game only ends when your vault is finally destroyed. There is no win condition, because this is the apocalypse.

I don't know where you got the information for the next mobile game, but someone here at Bethesda is losing their job for breaking confidentiality! :mad:

History Comes Inside!
Nov 20, 2004




Fallout should be an ascii roguelike where you die immediately after character creation because apocalypse.

Would really save on dev costs and speed up that release cycle for the inevitable yearly updates they'll be putting out to cash in on this smash hit idea everyone has been craving.

chitoryu12
Apr 24, 2014

Lotish posted:

Fallout should be a tower defense game where you keep mutants, ghouls, raiders and deathclaws from ransacking your vault. That's it. No outside civilizations except for other Vaults that are slowing losing their own wars. The game only ends when your vault is finally destroyed. There is no win condition, because this is the apocalypse.

I'd be cool with a Fallout mod for Dwarf Fortress.

2house2fly
Nov 14, 2012

You did a super job wrapping things up! And I'm not just saying that because I have to!

Moridin920 posted:

lol but why?

Because that's just ~Fallout~ or what?
It's not Fallout! The very first game had you dealing with functioning towns and trading groups right from the beginning.

Rutibex
Sep 9, 2001

by Fluffdaddy

Lotish posted:

Fallout should be a tower defense game where you keep mutants, ghouls, raiders and deathclaws from ransacking your vault. That's it. No outside civilizations except for other Vaults that are slowing losing their own wars. The game only ends when your vault is finally destroyed. There is no win condition, because this is the apocalypse.

Bethesda litteraly just made that game 10 days ago:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bojh0L-VArs

Man Whore
Jan 6, 2012

ASK ME ABOUT SPHERICAL CATS
=3



chitoryu12 posted:

I'd be cool with a Fallout mod for Dwarf Fortress.

It's been a while since I played it and it was alpha as gently caress but there was one.

2house2fly
Nov 14, 2012

You did a super job wrapping things up! And I'm not just saying that because I have to!
I spend 20 minutes adjusting character's facial features and choosing stats. Once done, I exit character creation. I am standing in the wasteland, nothing but silence and desolation in every direction. My character, obviously starving, trudges forward three agonising steps before vomiting blood and collapsing to the floor, dead of radiation sickness. Later, a one-legged feral child happens on my corpse and attempts to eat it, but lacks the energy to chew. The child also dies. I turn off the console, satisfied with my post apocalyptic video game experience.

Cream-of-Plenty
Apr 21, 2010

"The world is a hellish place, and bad writing is destroying the quality of our suffering."
The next Fallout game should take place after society rebuilds from the apocalypse and returns to a normality indistinguishable from our own and the game is basically Tony Hawk Pro Skater with a main character named "Bogus".

Cojawfee
May 31, 2006
I think the US is dumb for not using Celsius
The only difference is they still use bottlecaps. Mountain dew bottle caps. You scan in the code to buy things. Sponsored by Doritos.

Rutibex
Sep 9, 2001

by Fluffdaddy

2house2fly posted:

I spend 20 minutes adjusting character's facial features and choosing stats. Once done, I exit character creation. I am standing in the wasteland, nothing but silence and desolation in every direction. My character, obviously starving, trudges forward three agonising steps before vomiting blood and collapsing to the floor, dead of radiation sickness. Later, a one-legged feral child happens on my corpse and attempts to eat it, but lacks the energy to chew. The child also dies. I turn off the console, satisfied with my post apocalyptic video game experience.

I would play the hell out of The Road: The Game. It could be a rogue-like, the only objective is to survive as long as you can, there is no winning:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M8RuQrhVBvo

Bicyclops
Aug 27, 2004

2house2fly posted:

I spend 20 minutes adjusting character's facial features and choosing stats. Once done, I exit character creation. I am standing in the wasteland, nothing but silence and desolation in every direction. My character, obviously starving, trudges forward three agonising steps before vomiting blood and collapsing to the floor, dead of radiation sickness. Later, a one-legged feral child happens on my corpse and attempts to eat it, but lacks the energy to chew. The child also dies. I turn off the console, satisfied with my post apocalyptic video game experience.

Lead writer, Joe Lidster.

Cream-of-Plenty posted:

The next Fallout game should take place after society rebuilds from the apocalypse and returns to a normality indistinguishable from our own and the game is basically Tony Hawk Pro Skater with a main character named "Bogus".

The series obviously wore out its welcome some time ago, but I would have played a Tony Hawk: Nuclear Wasteland DLC pack for THPS2 or 3 back in the day.

Moacher
Oct 10, 2007

In a few moments my neighbor is going to exit this building's ground floor, out onto the sidewalk. According to my math, from this height, I can kill him by pissing on him.

Cojawfee posted:

The only difference is they still use bottlecaps. Mountain dew bottle caps. You scan in the code to buy things. Sponsored by Doritos.

Oh my god... It... It was Earth all along! :negative:

catlord
Mar 22, 2009

What's on your mind, Axa?

MAKE WAY NEW STARS posted:

Fallout should be an ascii roguelike where you die immediately after character creation because apocalypse.

Would really save on dev costs and speed up that release cycle for the inevitable yearly updates they'll be putting out to cash in on this smash hit idea everyone has been craving.

Wasn't there a post-apocalyptic tabletop RPG where you could die during character creation? I seem to remember there was.

I Am A Robot
Jul 1, 2006

Farm Frenzy posted:

isnt there enough hoplessly nihlistic post apocalpyse stuff floating around? the interesting thing about the fallout series, even in FO3 and tactics, is that they show how new communities spring up and try to reform society.

This is exactly why I like Fallout. Over 200 years after the apocalypse we should be seeing widespread reconstruction and the games should be examining the conflicts that arise from different groups meeting on their frontiers.

Anime Schoolgirl
Nov 28, 2002

SirDan3k posted:

Then every modern shooter/story/and literally everything is post-apocalyptic as we have had plenty of societal collapses that we picked the pieces up from.

In the grand-daddy Mad Max, Max was that glimmer of hope and the movie was about the coming world breaking him for it. The glimmer of hope is always gilded and never amounts to anything but people are seemingly demanding that it should. Three hundred years after the bombs dropped in Fallout with the number of people alive and the tech available it would just be civilization, it'd be CoD: Art Deco Warfare not Fallout.

King Vidiot
Feb 17, 2007

You think you can take me at Satan's Hollow? Go 'head on!
...but seriously, "post-apocalyptic" doesn't mean after a literal apocalypse, it just means after something wipes out most of civilization. Life can thrive in places in a post-apocalyptic setting, civilization can rebuild and it doesn't make it "less" post-apocalyptic.

Something bad happened in the past, we pick up the action in the present after the bad thing that happened. That's it. That's Fallout. Hell the word "Fallout" itself can just mean "after something (usually bad) happened".

maev
Dec 6, 2010
Economically illiterate Tory Boy Bollocks brain.
Keep away from children
Fallout 5 should be set 70 years post new vegas, focusing further on the post-post apocalyptic setting. The NCR has spread across the continent, and renamed itself the 'New American Republic'. The NCRs values of liberty, democracy and old american values has produced a society not unlike the long lost dream of old-world America itself. Contact has been made with other new, makeshift nations overseas:

The New Kentish Republic, now the New British United Kingdom has unified and their old values of constitutional monarchy, democracy and British values has produced a society not unlike the long lost dream of old-world Britain itself.

Society runs more or less the same way it did pre-war, but challenges remain. A new lone wanderer emerges in Eastern Yankstate and the NAR calls upon them to help keep order in the harsh wasteland, optic fibre cables for broadband is a key concern of citizens, with tensions between various factions (now wrapped in the flags of so called political parties) coming to the fore. But to the east a new foe emerges which seeks to undo what the west has done, because War, War never changes.

History Comes Inside!
Nov 20, 2004




Fallout 5 should turn out to be Elder Scrolls 6 because your precious time has passed and since you want it so bad the world got over the apocalypse by regressing to medieval poo poo and elves and dragons are just mutants or something and there you go Fallout is ruined and replaced with more fantasy bullshit hope you're proud of yourselves goons.

marshmallow creep
Dec 10, 2008

I've been sitting here for 5 mins trying to think of a joke to make but I just realised the animators of Mass Effect already did it for me

maev posted:

Fallout 5 should be set 70 years post new vegas, focusing further on the post-post apocalyptic setting. The NCR has spread across the continent, and renamed itself the 'New American Republic'. The NCRs values of liberty, democracy and old american values has produced a society not unlike the long lost dream of old-world America itself. Contact has been made with other new, makeshift nations overseas:

The New Kentish Republic, now the New British United Kingdom has unified and their old values of constitutional monarchy, democracy and British values has produced a society not unlike the long lost dream of old-world Britain itself.

Society runs more or less the same way it did pre-war, but challenges remain. A new lone wanderer emerges in Eastern Yankstate and the NAR calls upon them to help keep order in the harsh wasteland, optic fibre cables for broadband is a key concern of citizens, with tensions between various factions (now wrapped in the flags of so called political parties) coming to the fore. But to the east a new foe emerges which seeks to undo what the west has done, because War, War never changes.

If the British don't invade in Fallout 4, I'll be disappointed.

2house2fly
Nov 14, 2012

You did a super job wrapping things up! And I'm not just saying that because I have to!

MAKE WAY NEW STARS posted:

Fallout 5 should turn out to be Elder Scrolls 6 because your precious time has passed and since you want it so bad the world got over the apocalypse by regressing to medieval poo poo and elves and dragons are just mutants or something and there you go Fallout is ruined and replaced with more fantasy bullshit hope you're proud of yourselves goons.

Maybe there shouldn't be a Fallout 5

Cream-of-Plenty
Apr 21, 2010

"The world is a hellish place, and bad writing is destroying the quality of our suffering."

maev posted:

Fallout 5 should be set 70 years post new vegas, focusing further on the post-post apocalyptic setting. The NCR has spread across the continent, and renamed itself the 'New American Republic'. The NCRs values of liberty, democracy and old american values has produced a society not unlike the long lost dream of old-world America itself. Contact has been made with other new, makeshift nations overseas:

The New Kentish Republic, now the New British United Kingdom has unified and their old values of constitutional monarchy, democracy and British values has produced a society not unlike the long lost dream of old-world Britain itself.

Society runs more or less the same way it did pre-war, but challenges remain. A new lone wanderer emerges in Eastern Yankstate and the NAR calls upon them to help keep order in the harsh wasteland, optic fibre cables for broadband is a key concern of citizens, with tensions between various factions (now wrapped in the flags of so called political parties) coming to the fore. But to the east a new foe emerges which seeks to undo what the west has done, because War, War never changes.

Post-post apocalypse, the NCR becomes the "New United States" which, under the command of General Washington II, crosses the Delaware and does some patriotic stuff that leads to vacuum tubes and nuclear bombs, resulting in a world war that annihilates much of civilization and prompts people to shelter in vaults for decades before reemerging to reclaim the irradiated wasteland.

Sharkopath
May 27, 2009

2house2fly posted:

Maybe there shouldn't be a Fallout 5

Why?

Cream-of-Plenty
Apr 21, 2010

"The world is a hellish place, and bad writing is destroying the quality of our suffering."

Because no matter how much you love your grandmother, you don't want to see somebody dig up her corpse and use foul magicks to resurrect her corporeal form so that it might have sex with a wiry, wild-eyed T. Howard.


Have some dignity for the dead.

Cream-of-Plenty
Apr 21, 2010

"The world is a hellish place, and bad writing is destroying the quality of our suffering."
In before Sharkopath responds with a saucy "Speak for yourself!" as his eyes roll around in his fat loving head while a silly slide whistle plays.

frajaq
Jan 30, 2009

#acolyte GM of 2014


Which other company do people want the Fallout IP to go?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Mulva
Sep 13, 2011
It's about time for my once per decade ban for being a consistently terrible poster.

Lotish posted:

If the British don't invade in Fallout 4, I'll be disappointed.

The British lack the resources to invade a gecko pit, and we put rockets on the Constitution. Nobody is invading poo poo.

  • Locked thread