Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
(Thread IKs: Stereotype)
 
  • Post
  • Reply
Deep Dish Fuckfest
Sep 6, 2006

Advanced
Computer Touching


Toilet Rascal

Laterite posted:

general rule of thumb is that 1 cubic yard of topsoil is ~1.5 tons. i bet someone like bar ran dun could extrapolate out the capacity and fuel costs of shipping enough material to cover greenland or northern canada

what if we used slavery instead?

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

BoothBaberGinsburg
Jan 4, 2021


lol :negative:

Hubbert
Mar 25, 2007

At a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.

Deep Dish Fuckfest posted:

what if we used slavery instead?

start loading the triremes

Hubbert
Mar 25, 2007

At a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.

Unironically this.

:unsmith:

:smith:

Hubbert
Mar 25, 2007

At a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.
Just be grateful for the luxuries you were able to enjoy today, before they are squandered tomorrow:

- Relatively cheap and nourishing food all times of the year.

- Potable clean drinking water

- Outdoor conditions that are not completely inhospitable to life

- Posting with ur pals

- Family and friends, who may or may not be blissfully ignorant of the world to come

- The relative peace and quiet of everyday life, especially on a local level

- The sounds of nature, whether it be the croaking of frogs or the twitter of birds

- The terrible treats from our fossil fueled cornucopia, which was nothing more than the squandered wealth of humanity's inheritance

Hubbert has issued a correction as of 16:01 on Oct 31, 2022

Deep Dish Fuckfest
Sep 6, 2006

Advanced
Computer Touching


Toilet Rascal
oh the frogs are croaking alright

take_it_slow
Jul 7, 2011

Wakko posted:

tens of thousands of years of consumption have brought us here, and you whine? imagine a tuberculosis bacterium mewling like this
is the [ethical] consumption/ tuberculosis double-entendre intentional here, because :laffo:

Car Hater
May 7, 2007

wolf. bike.
Wolf. Bike.
Wolf! Bike!
WolfBike!
WolfBike!
ARROOOOOO!

Hubbert posted:

squandered wealth of humanity's inheritance

Grave-robbing does not count as inheritance

Hubbert
Mar 25, 2007

At a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.

Car Hater posted:

Grave-robbing does not count as inheritance

It definitely will in the future.

FlapYoJacks
Feb 12, 2009

Hubbert posted:

Just be grateful for the luxuries you were able to enjoy today, before they are squandered tomorrow:

- Relatively cheap and nourishing food all times of the year.

- Potable clean drinking water

- Outdoor conditions that are not completely inhospitable to life

- Posting with ur pals

- Family and friends, who may or may not be blissfully ignorant of the world to come

- The relative peace and quiet of everyday life, especially on a local level

- The sounds of nature, whether it be the croaking of frogs or the twitter of birds

- The terrible treats from our fossil fueled cornucopia, which was nothing more than the squandered wealth of humanity's inheritance

where does twerk and eat hot chip fit in with all of this?

Colin Mockery
Jun 24, 2007
Rawr



FlapYoJacks posted:

where does twerk and eat hot chip fit in with all of this?

posting with your pals
blissfully ignorant family and friends
cheap food

Baudolino
Apr 1, 2010

THUNDERDOME LOSER
So soil transplantation is technically doable on a small to medium scale? It wont feed the world, but maybe Canada could feed itself if it gets its hand on enough fertile topsoil?
Greenland could at least be self-sufficent in calories even as fishing and hunting collapses completely?
Honestly that`s a lot better then i imagined.

Fell Mood
Jul 2, 2022

A terrible Fell look!

Laterite posted:

general rule of thumb is that 1 cubic yard of topsoil is ~1.5 tons. i bet someone like bar ran dun could extrapolate out the capacity and fuel costs of shipping enough material to cover greenland or northern canada
This is a very rough estimate.
Ok, 1 square mile = 640 acres. That's a medium sized field, of which there are hundreds of thousands in America.

640 acres = 3,097,600 square yards. Assuming we want our dirt 3ft deep that gives us that many cubic yards, which weighs about 4,646,400 tones.

A large dump truck can carry about 16cu yards. A gondola rail car can carry about 92 cubic yards.

So, either 193,600 truck loads, or 336 trains. (Assuming 100 car trains).

Now we need a distance. From some random spot in the Midwest to a fair ways over the Canadian border, let's use 1000 miles.

Those dump trucks get 8 to 10 mpg. Let's use 10. 193,600 trucks driving 1000 miles one way equals 19,360,000 gallons, or 352,000 barrels. They will do a little better on the return trip, lets say 300,000 barrels. I don't know how to estimate the fuel use of the excavators and tractors that will be digging up the soil and spreading it in Canada, but it shouldn't be more than the fuel to transport it. Let's say it's roughly a third for 148,000.

That gives us 800,000 barrels of fuel to dig up a square mile (640 acres) and transport it 1000 miles north and then spread it out with tractors.

The us has about 900,000,000 acres under cultivation. We all agree that a lot of that is wasted with cattle grazing. If you take just corn, soy, and wheat together we have about 240 million acres. So we will be digging up our square mile 375,000 times.

We are combining gas and diesel together here, as a mix of both will be used. My numbers will be a little off as you don't get equal amounts from a barrel of oil, but they shouldn't be way off. We need 300 billion barrels, or about 16 trillion gallons of fuel. Assuming the US uses about 8 million barrels per day of gas and 4mpd of diesel, that comes to about 25,000 days, or about 67 years of US fuel consumption to dig up the Midwest and haul it to Canada, which is less than I expected. There are about 2 million semis in use in the US currently.

Obviously there is a lot left out here. Besides my fuel numbers being off by a few billion barrels in either direction, 200k trucks and tens of thousands of excavators and tractors need to be built. Roads, fuel stations, and other infrastructure needs to be built. Irrigation and water lines need to be built. We need to double our refinery capacity. A fair amount of dirtwork needs to be done in Canada to keep our new topsoil from just washing away. The best I can say is that for about 100 years worth of gdp and fuel consumption, the US may be able to pick up its staple crop acreage and haul it to central Canada.

Femur
Jan 10, 2004
I REALLY NEED TO SHUT THE FUCK UP

Laterite posted:

general rule of thumb is that 1 cubic yard of topsoil is ~1.5 tons. i bet someone like bar ran dun could extrapolate out the capacity and fuel costs of shipping enough material to cover greenland or northern canada

I don't think weight matters that much, just how well it packs and how many shis you order. like the lumber people got $80/container rates or some bs, because they can fill up several ships.

Turtle Sandbox
Dec 31, 2007

by Fluffdaddy

bagual posted:

Al Saqr i know you know this deep in your heart but every westerner is either hostile, clueless or completely checked out on the environment, they either embrace some sort of green grift or just give up and turn into a sad ball of over-intellectualized excuses.

For example, in this thread there was some guy going around saying he's a sentient extinction event. Cringe.

These guys will keep going "but the number!!!" and "we're already dead!!!" for the rest of our lives.

I feel like "the solution to climate change is full communism now" is cspam as hell and unrealistic.

Car Hater
May 7, 2007

wolf. bike.
Wolf. Bike.
Wolf! Bike!
WolfBike!
WolfBike!
ARROOOOOO!

Turtle Sandbox posted:

I feel like "the solution to climate change is full communism now" is cspam as hell and unrealistic.

Correct, because the solution to climate change is full nuclear Armageddon now

kater
Nov 16, 2010

how did Star Trek open a portal to the time people blared beastie boys from convertibles? let’s do that

Perry Mason Jar
Feb 24, 2006

"Della? Take a lid"

Turtle Sandbox posted:

I feel like "the solution to climate change is full communism now" is cspam as hell and unrealistic.

You have three options: a bunch of stuff that won't work and it's too late to do; or that but with fantasy :); or that but with dialectical materialist fantasy, er, revolutionary optimism

JAY ZERO SUM GAME
Oct 18, 2005

Walter.
I know you know how to do this.
Get up.


the solution to climate change is communism (textbook definition, classless, stateless, moneyless, etc.) or something very much like it

that's why we won't have a solution

🤷‍♀️

Deep Dish Fuckfest
Sep 6, 2006

Advanced
Computer Touching


Toilet Rascal
eco-stalinism might work in a pinch

1glitch0
Sep 4, 2018

I DON'T GIVE A CRAP WHAT SHE BELIEVES THE HARRY POTTER BOOKS CHANGED MY LIFE #HUFFLEPUFF

kater posted:

how did Star Trek open a portal to the time people blared beastie boys from convertibles? let’s do that

gently caress JJ Abrams

Hubbert
Mar 25, 2007

At a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.
As this thread is clearly filled with malthusian ecofascists who do not believe in humanity's future, I would like to provide you with Exhibit A to prove you doomers wrong:

1glitch0
Sep 4, 2018

I DON'T GIVE A CRAP WHAT SHE BELIEVES THE HARRY POTTER BOOKS CHANGED MY LIFE #HUFFLEPUFF

Hubbert posted:

As this thread is clearly filled with malthusian ecofascists who do not believe in humanity's future, I would like to provide you with Exhibit A to prove you doomers wrong:



oops turns out there ARE major limits to human intelligence, imagination, and wonder.

Crazypoops
Jul 17, 2017



My approach to climate change

err
Apr 11, 2005

I carry my own weight no matter how heavy this shit gets...

Hubbert posted:

As this thread is clearly filled with malthusian ecofascists who do not believe in humanity's future, I would like to provide you with Exhibit A to prove you doomers wrong:



Lol at saying this to all the wage slaves trying to survive

a strange fowl
Oct 27, 2022

Hexigrammus posted:

That's part of developing a palliative care mindset - hug the blackberry!
:unsmith:

MightyBigMinus
Jan 26, 2020

jesus christ you guys really are trying to commoditize it

none of the logistics around shipping weights matter at all. soil biology is destroyed simply by tilling in place. if you scraped it up and put it some container and kept it there for days you would all but sterilize it. by the time you ship fertile soil literally anywhere, even down the street, it is no longer fertile soil, thus utterly defeating the purpose long before your spreadhseet poo poo comes in to play.

a strange fowl
Oct 27, 2022

Hubbert posted:

- The sounds of nature, whether it be the croaking of frogs or the twitter of birds
there is a frog native to southeastern australia that is called a pobblebonk because when they're horny they go pobble pobble pobble BONK pobble BONK BONK BONK pobblebonk

they are also called a banjo frog because the bonking sounds kind of like a banjo. every time i hear them, i think of leonard cohen watching his death slowly approach across the dark infested sea

Fell Mood
Jul 2, 2022

A terrible Fell look!

MightyBigMinus posted:

jesus christ you guys really are trying to commoditize it

none of the logistics around shipping weights matter at all. soil biology is destroyed simply by tilling in place. if you scraped it up and put it some container and kept it there for days you would all but sterilize it. by the time you ship fertile soil literally anywhere, even down the street, it is no longer fertile soil, thus utterly defeating the purpose long before your spreadhseet poo poo comes in to play.

Yes, people were really trying to figure it out. It wasn't tounge in cheek.

You tool. You absolute fool.

taqueso
Mar 8, 2004


:911:
:wookie: :thermidor: :wookie:
:dehumanize:

:pirate::hf::tinfoil:

Relax, we are sending it next day air

TeenageArchipelago
Jul 23, 2013


I hear that glaciers are melting. Are we sure that that is what's going on? It could just be that everyone is using the glaciers for ice, like gas stations and stuff

skooma512
Feb 8, 2012

You couldn't grok my race car, but you dug the roadside blur.

MightyBigMinus posted:

jesus christ you guys really are trying to commoditize it

none of the logistics around shipping weights matter at all. soil biology is destroyed simply by tilling in place. if you scraped it up and put it some container and kept it there for days you would all but sterilize it. by the time you ship fertile soil literally anywhere, even down the street, it is no longer fertile soil, thus utterly defeating the purpose long before your spreadhseet poo poo comes in to play.

But dirt has what plants crave.

goochtit
Nov 2, 2021



Fell Mood posted:

This is a very rough estimate.
Ok, 1 square mile = 640 acres. That's a medium sized field, of which there are hundreds of thousands in America.

640 acres = 3,097,600 square yards. Assuming we want our dirt 3ft deep that gives us that many cubic yards, which weighs about 4,646,400 tones.

A large dump truck can carry about 16cu yards. A gondola rail car can carry about 92 cubic yards.

So, either 193,600 truck loads, or 336 trains. (Assuming 100 car trains).

Now we need a distance. From some random spot in the Midwest to a fair ways over the Canadian border, let's use 1000 miles.

Those dump trucks get 8 to 10 mpg. Let's use 10. 193,600 trucks driving 1000 miles one way equals 19,360,000 gallons, or 352,000 barrels. They will do a little better on the return trip, lets say 300,000 barrels. I don't know how to estimate the fuel use of the excavators and tractors that will be digging up the soil and spreading it in Canada, but it shouldn't be more than the fuel to transport it. Let's say it's roughly a third for 148,000.

That gives us 800,000 barrels of fuel to dig up a square mile (640 acres) and transport it 1000 miles north and then spread it out with tractors.

The us has about 900,000,000 acres under cultivation. We all agree that a lot of that is wasted with cattle grazing. If you take just corn, soy, and wheat together we have about 240 million acres. So we will be digging up our square mile 375,000 times.

We are combining gas and diesel together here, as a mix of both will be used. My numbers will be a little off as you don't get equal amounts from a barrel of oil, but they shouldn't be way off. We need 300 billion barrels, or about 16 trillion gallons of fuel. Assuming the US uses about 8 million barrels per day of gas and 4mpd of diesel, that comes to about 25,000 days, or about 67 years of US fuel consumption to dig up the Midwest and haul it to Canada, which is less than I expected. There are about 2 million semis in use in the US currently.

Obviously there is a lot left out here. Besides my fuel numbers being off by a few billion barrels in either direction, 200k trucks and tens of thousands of excavators and tractors need to be built. Roads, fuel stations, and other infrastructure needs to be built. Irrigation and water lines need to be built. We need to double our refinery capacity. A fair amount of dirtwork needs to be done in Canada to keep our new topsoil from just washing away. The best I can say is that for about 100 years worth of gdp and fuel consumption, the US may be able to pick up its staple crop acreage and haul it to central Canada.

Hmmm :thunk: how do the numbers change if we use a fleet of these?
https://twitter.com/PortofNewcastle/status/1584419448726749185
It's carrying 100,000 tons of coal

biceps crimes
Apr 12, 2008


Car Hater posted:

Correct, because the solution to climate change is full nuclear Armageddon now

this is ableist AND Malthusian as gently caress. the solution to climate change is fifty billion humans

a strange fowl
Oct 27, 2022

i can generate an acre of topsoil in a week, purely from my abundant rear end in a top hat

Egg Moron
Jul 21, 2003

the dreams of the delighting void

buy my boxes of dirt bitches

Mayor Dave
Feb 20, 2009

Bernie the Snow Clown

goochtit posted:

Hmmm :thunk: how do the numbers change if we use a fleet of these?
https://twitter.com/PortofNewcastle/status/1584419448726749185
It's carrying 100,000 tons of coal

Lol love that stinger

A Bakers Cousin
Dec 18, 2003

by vyelkin

a strange fowl posted:

i can generate an acre of topsoil in a week, purely from my abundant rear end in a top hat

Heh

"Top" "soil"

Hubbert
Mar 25, 2007

At a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.

a strange fowl posted:

there is a frog native to southeastern australia that is called a pobblebonk because when they're horny they go pobble pobble pobble BONK pobble BONK BONK BONK pobblebonk

same

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

bagual
Oct 29, 2010

inconspicuous

Turtle Sandbox posted:

I feel like "the solution to climate change is full communism now" is cspam as hell and unrealistic.

there is no solution to climate change, it's just we'll go through it with either socialism or barbarism

i think the "there's no mitigation to be done" camp is just waiting for an ersatz biblical apocalypse, a day of reckoning which will come when "the climate change" will finally destroy everything, something like that

there's no true relief in giving up, it's not like it's just climate change that's the problem, there's the slew of problems that are political in nature and totally avoidable like britain spewing poo poo and toxic waste all over it's coast, dam neglect flooding entire hydro basins with arsenic mud mining byproduct, ambitiously stupid water use expansion projects causing rivers to literally run dry when a drought hits, it's endless bullshit really, even if it's gonna all turn to desert it doesn't need to be a toxic desert too

so that's why in my opinion if you think doing something about these isn't worth it because climate scenario RCP8.5 will destroy everything in a couple of years then i don't think you're fit to talk about what's worth doing really, too far up your own rear end to see the biosphere collapse that's already happening in front of you, the issue is society is not only not decelerating it's stepping hard on the gas, if you can't oppose that even in idle thought you're too far gone

not that i expect anything of you really, we're just here to lol and lmao and :justpost:

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Post
  • Reply