|
I’ve kinda made it my mission now to get a concrete answer from Awaken Realms about their policy on AI art. No Pun Included responded to my YouTube comment on his Lords of Ragnarok review, so hopefully his larger media presence can force an answer. I kinda kicked the hornets nest on the Dragon Eclipse campaign page and BGG forum. So many backers go into full defense mode because they’d not want to think about it or don’t care (AI bros).
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 14:33 |
|
|
# ? May 18, 2024 02:39 |
|
You're probably right that they're using AI. Going forward, it seems inevitable that AI is going to be, at the minimum, part of the process for commercial art projects. The question is, how are they using it? Just dumping AI images into the final product? Creating AI and then having a human touch it up? Or pulling elements into a larger work? Or generating a ton of AI images and then using them for inspiration? I'm not remotely an expert on this, but to my eye the cards have a more or less coherent style. Does that not suggest a heavy human involvement, even if there's AI somewhere in the process?
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 15:49 |
|
It’s trivial to have AI engines produce a large chunk of consistent files. The heavy human involvement idea doesn’t make it much better, as at that point it’s basically them just using other artists work for 90% of the process and painting on top of it, which isn’t far from tracing and comping in various elements from other artists a la the Scythe artist that got caught doing that.
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 15:58 |
|
Maneck posted:I'm not remotely an expert on this, but to my eye the cards have a more or less coherent style. Does that not suggest a heavy human involvement, even if there's AI somewhere in the process? It’s just this illogical way of subjects being put together, some of the finer details on armor or object design, etc…
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 16:30 |
|
My hand sculpted zero-AI Kickstarter is still going! *waves* Link to the campaign is here>> http://kck.st/48nVBhI
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 18:19 |
|
Bottom Liner posted:Those 100% look like “AI+” where the base is AI then the artist paints over some of it manually to refine it to be usable. On the one hand yeah but on the other hand Awaken Realms art has looked like that since before AI art was much of a thing. The truth is out there.
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 18:31 |
|
The Moon Monster posted:On the one hand yeah but on the other hand Awaken Realms art has looked like that since before AI art was much of a thing. The truth is out there. Eh, looking through Etherfields/Nemesis/Tainted Grail I'm not seeing it. JazzFlight posted:The tells are so subtle to the average person that I end up sounding like I’m wearing the glasses from They Live and shouting to everyone that the aliens are here. I think it's safe to trust your instincts on it unless proven otherwise. And even if it turns out to not be AI generated, it's pretty damning of the artwork if it's messy enough to give that impression anyways.
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 18:41 |
|
Bottom Liner posted:And even if it turns out to not be AI generated, it's pretty damning of the artwork if it's messy enough to give that impression anyways. Oh, good, let's keep putting the screws to artists that aren't involved with AI just because some people think it looks like AI art. That's definitely not indicative of a witch hunt and is totally reasonable and logical.
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 18:56 |
|
Saying I personally don't want artwork that looks like AI generated stuff is not a witch hunt
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 18:59 |
|
Bottom Liner posted:Saying I personally don't want artwork that looks like AI generated stuff is not a witch hunt That isn't what you said, though. You said it was safe to assume it's AI until proven otherwise, and that even if it WAS proven otherwise, it's "pretty damning" anyway.
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 19:03 |
|
Zurai posted:That isn't what you said, though. That's not what I said either. I told a specific poster it's safe to trust their instincts, which is the smart approach to crowd funding in general if you think something looks off. I did not give a call to action, ban the artist from Reddit, or anything else. And calling it damning is a judgement of its quality, which would apply wether AI was in the conversation or not. I don't want artwork that looks like lovely AI blobs the same as I don't want any other kind of bad artwork in games. Is your position that consumers aren't allowed to make value judgments on the quality of artwork in a hobby heavily driven by aesthetics? The artwork in your linked article is amateurish and wouldn't earn my interest or money even if I don't think it looks like AI. Bottom Liner fucked around with this message at 19:09 on Oct 3, 2023 |
# ? Oct 3, 2023 19:06 |
|
At this point in the industry where it's becoming more prevalent by the day, companies need to clearly state their policy on AI art. The onus is not on me, it's on them. Give me a break about AI art accusations when they've already done it without question on this S.T.A.L.K.E.R. promo video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TiEZ0knxmRc Unlike Kickstarter, Gamefound has not implemented a disclaimer on campaigns using AI generation. Surprise, Gamefound is run by Awaken Realms, so I'm not sure that will ever be a policy (if my suspicions are correct).
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 19:07 |
|
JazzFlight posted:
In timely related news, Backerkit just did release theirs saying that they explicitly restrict the use of AI on their platform: https://www.backerkit.com/blog/backerkit-ai-policy/?ref=mailchimp_100223
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 19:11 |
|
Bottom Liner posted:Is your position that consumers aren't allowed to make value judgments on the quality of artwork in a hobby heavily driven by aesthetics? No, my position is that "just assume it's AI until proven otherwise, and gently caress them anyway if it looks close" is not a particularly well-reasoned approach to the subject and hurts artists more than the companies you're pissed off at. I agree that there should be clear notices when AI content is involved, and companies like GameFound, Kickstarter, and so on should also have clear policies. But just going, "eh, looks like AI art, therefore I'm going to treat it as AI art even if proven otherwise" is seriously unhinged.
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 19:15 |
|
If it "looks close" to AI but I get a clear statement from them saying they do not use AI generation whatsoever in any part of the process, then I'll actually be fine with it. Like, I want to back the game. I've gone all-in on a ton of Awaken Realms games. The reason I'm so fired up is specifically because I don't want to believe that a company whose games I enjoy would do this.
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 19:26 |
|
Zurai posted:"just assume it's AI until proven otherwise, and gently caress them anyway if it looks close" I don't know if you are misinterpreting my words intentionally or not, but calling it unhinged is dumb as hell either way. I never said "assume its AI until proven otherwise" I said "I think it's safe to trust your instincts unless proven otherwise". Saying it's damning either way is simply saying I don't want lovely art that looks like AI could have made it. I can both accept an artist didn't use AI and still not like their work. I don't know why you are having trouble processing that. This is somehow dumber than your argument that Slay the Spire was not a digital board game and that Gloomhaven digital was an entirely different game than physical. Bottom Liner fucked around with this message at 19:32 on Oct 3, 2023 |
# ? Oct 3, 2023 19:27 |
|
JazzFlight posted:If it "looks close" to AI but I get a clear statement from them saying they do not use AI generation whatsoever in any part of the process, then I'll actually be fine with it. This I've got no problem with. It's 100% cool to want an answer, and it's a question that they 100% should have to answer.
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 20:30 |
|
In other theft-adjacent board game news, Mythic Games, the folks behind the Darkest Dungeon and 6 Siege board games, have not yet made the previously announced second ransom demand from Darkest Dungeon backers. It was due this week. While it is technically not yet late, a couple of developments to the dumpster fire raise some interesting possibilities. First, Redhook, publisher of the Darkest Dungeon video game and owner of the intellectual property, piped up on Reddit that they hadn't heard from Mythic Gaming about a second contribution demand: RedhookMichaela posted:Hello everyone. Redhook paid money to defray the previous demand for contributions, even though they're just the license holder. Given that history and Redhook's desire to not have an utter disaster associated with their IP, Mythic's decision to keep Redhook in the dark is curious. Also, apparently Mythic is by the terms of their license required to obtain Redhook's approval to make significant announcements about the project. Presumably the first time around Redhook was told (as backers were) that everything was fine except for out-of-control shipping costs. In retrospect, this was obviously untrue. Unlike backers, Redhook may well be in a position to insist on an explanation before allowing the announcment. Second, 6 Siege's printing has been delayed. Again. Mythic demanded a ransom payment from backers of that project in April, telling them it was ready to publish they just had run out of money. Six months later, the model printing has started. Paper printing has not. The last update was paper printing was supposed to start in late September. That didn't happen. The timing on the delay is fascinating. It gives the impression that Mythic Games has again failed to manage money and needs money from Darkest Dungeon backers to get the 6 Siege game produced. A delay in making the second contribution demand could make it very obvious that Mythic can't hit print because they're out of cash, again.
|
# ? Oct 3, 2023 21:49 |
|
"out of control shipping costs" A year ago. Yes. Right now? I should get an updated rate sheet this week but it's the cheapest it's been in about 2 and half years. If they charged shipping a year ago and it's going out in the near future they should have plenty of cash. Unless they spent it in other stuff.
|
# ? Oct 4, 2023 01:41 |
|
All of this seems like a really good way to get put on some sort of "do not license your IP to these guys" blacklist.
|
# ? Oct 4, 2023 01:58 |
|
TheDiceBagLady posted:My hand sculpted zero-AI Kickstarter is still going! Can confirm the greatness of BSG, as well as the great elements of keeping traditional sculptin’ alive and well.
|
# ? Oct 4, 2023 14:06 |
|
Bottom Liner posted:In timely related news, Backerkit just did release theirs saying that they explicitly restrict the use of AI on their platform: People are talking about that like it's in stark contrast to Kickstarter's policy but if you actually read it it would absolutely allow projects like the Terraforming Mars expansion(s) (which used human beings to rework AI generated starting points) among other AI-related stuff. I guess it's slightly more restrictive than KS's "just say you're using it" though.
|
# ? Oct 4, 2023 14:57 |
|
Cohorts Cthulhu Kickstarter is live.. They have a link to download quickstart rules, which is nice. I hadn't realized until now that Doug Seacat was the writer on this. His world building was the best part of Privateer Press back when he worked for them, so I'm double excited for this now.
|
# ? Oct 5, 2023 14:05 |
|
Really excited for Cohors Cthulhu, love 2d20 as a system and its a really fun time period to play in. Additionally, if anyone is an Aeon Trespass sicko completist like myself. They are selling a Talespinner titan mini with rules content as a Essen and webstore thing during Essen. https://aeontrespass.com/titans/talespinner There is also a promo gear card you get if you order ANYTHING from their web store during Essen. The Talespinner lost a community vote to be included in SoH, so I’m quite glad it showed up here. Again only for sickos like me, but its there.
|
# ? Oct 5, 2023 14:10 |
|
rydiafan posted:Cohorts Cthulhu Kickstarter is live.. They have a link to download quickstart rules, which is nice. Welp just threw some denari at the screen.
|
# ? Oct 5, 2023 14:40 |
|
HidaO-Win posted:Really excited for Cohors Cthulhu, love 2d20 as a system and its a really fun time period to play in. I *am* a sicko completist...but I'm not a mini-assembly or dealing with resin sicko. Annoys me that they're attaching gameplay content to what is essentially a display model.
|
# ? Oct 5, 2023 14:43 |
|
TheDiceBagLady posted:
I get a 403 when I click the link, please make it https and it works
|
# ? Oct 5, 2023 17:27 |
rydiafan posted:Cohorts Cthulhu Kickstarter is live.. They have a link to download quickstart rules, which is nice. Is there any additional info on the 3 extra pdfs? I am wondering how many adventures are included in the 20£ and the 40£ pledges.
|
|
# ? Oct 5, 2023 18:51 |
|
Edit: misunderstood, disregard
|
# ? Oct 5, 2023 19:51 |
|
JazzFlight posted:I’ve kinda made it my mission now to get a concrete answer from Awaken Realms about their policy on AI art. No Pun Included responded to my YouTube comment on his Lords of Ragnarok review, so hopefully his larger media presence can force an answer. I kinda kicked the hornets nest on the Dragon Eclipse campaign page and BGG forum. So many backers go into full defense mode because they’d not want to think about it or don’t care (AI bros). I think you might be right, like 90% of the cart art shown is vague, sometimes not at all on theme or connected to the name, art of nature. very little of it features the actual mystlings I also can't see any WIP or mentions of the state of the art which is concerning. combined with the extra add ons bumping up the price and I might cancel as well...
|
# ? Oct 6, 2023 03:21 |
|
CODChimera posted:I think you might be right, like 90% of the cart art shown is vague, sometimes not at all on theme or connected to the name, art of nature. very little of it features the actual mystlings Flaming Bite: https://i.imgur.com/j4FShud.jpg Bing AI Image Generator: https://imgur.com/a/79baDlc Now, it's not the exact style they used, but I'm sure they have a specific secret prompt that ensures all of the images end up looking consistent. Plus, their in-house art team would no doubt touch up the pics to make sure they fit better together. So, in my opinion, it's pretty plausible that this was the method they used.
|
# ? Oct 6, 2023 03:38 |
|
Those pictures really make the case that its all AI art. In other news Mythic Games finally put their update on Darkest Dungeon Wave 2. It's been crafted to seem not so bad, but even a shallow inspection reveals a pile of lies and deception. The announcement is huge, and I'll post the whole thing (apologies for the following text wall) to emphasize how much text is there without touching what's actually going on. There's a summary afterwards because, really, Mythic's update is intended to obtain money through obfuscation: quote:
Key points as they present them:
Key obfuscations or outright lies:
Bottom line: Everyone must pay a lot more. And despite this being an update about how much more, Mythic won't say exactly. For all in backers, $64 plus more for shipping. This is in addition to the $69 those folks already paid, and it's notable because that first contribution covered far more. Somehow non-English backers are getting it even worse. And this is because of the war in Ukraine, not financial incompetence. Maneck fucked around with this message at 16:35 on Oct 6, 2023 |
# ? Oct 6, 2023 16:29 |
|
JazzFlight posted:As an experiment absolutely for demonstration purposes only, I decided to try to recreate some of the card art to see if it could get close to some of the Dragon Eclipse art. I picked "Flaming Bite" for the Emberling, which is represented by a crystal fireball for some reason (and not teeth/mouth/etc?). I just quickly guessed something like "bright crystallized fireball over ground red and orange hand-painted concept art style, shards exploding off with wisps of white flames." Here are the results: I managed to get one which seems to source the lightning effect from the same place
|
# ? Oct 6, 2023 16:51 |
|
Maneck posted:I managed to get one which seems to source the lightning effect from the same place
|
# ? Oct 6, 2023 19:24 |
|
JazzFlight posted:Boom, you got super close with that one. Why would they name that “Flaming Bite” if all things? So lazy.
|
# ? Oct 6, 2023 19:39 |
JazzFlight posted:Boom, you got super close with that one. Why would they name that “Flaming Bite” if all things? So lazy.
|
|
# ? Oct 6, 2023 20:07 |
|
DropTheAnvil posted:I get a 403 when I click the link, please make it https and it works Oh no! It works here, try this one https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/badsquiddogames/ghouls Last 24 hours now! Ends 8pm Sunday UK Time. More Ghouls Unlocked! Cheesy Poster:
|
# ? Oct 7, 2023 20:39 |
Crossposting from the Dungeons and Dragons thread, this is a campaign I have worked on as a freelancer and it is just launching! https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/lionbanner/hellwatch-rpg-infernal-oath It's a Tier 1 to 3, 5e dark fantasy campaign and setting; I have helped design and punch-up the monster stat blocks, items, spells and custom classes for it. There is a free pdf sample (and I have asked the author to expand it a bit, so you may get more free stuff soon). If nothing else, go check it out for a free fun statblock for a small, swarming undead monster that hunts by sound and covers you in toxic drool.
|
|
# ? Oct 10, 2023 17:52 |
|
The game I'm most excited for just hit Kickstarter! GUBAT BANWA! Filipino fantasy 4e style tactics TTRPG, looks sick, excellent team, and they're basically funded already hell yeah
|
# ? Oct 10, 2023 18:51 |
|
|
# ? May 18, 2024 02:39 |
|
Nemesis Of Moles posted:The game I'm most excited for just hit Kickstarter! Been looking forward to this for awhile, so excited to see the launch notification.
|
# ? Oct 10, 2023 19:23 |