Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
  • Locked thread
gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
Time for a little bit of a Seiyuu Trivia to support Crispin's badass role.

Avan's VA is Hiroyuki Yoshino. Known for voicing Alleluah Baptism in Gundam 00

Cosette's VA is Eri Kitamura. She was cast for Queens Blade's Alleyne and Tora Dora's Ami

Zeri' VA is Hiroshi Kamiya. He was most well known as Tieria Erde in Gundam 00.

Lawerence Kluviert is voiced by the late Takeshi Aono. We all knew him as Roy Cambell from Metal Gear

Hubert Brixham is voiced by Ryotaro Okiayu. He was voice cast as Treize from Gundam Wing as well as Andy Waltfield from Gundam Seed

Juliana Everhart is voiced by Ryoko Shiraishi. She voiced Anew Returner from Gundam 00, Asuka Kazama from Tekken as well as acted a indie VA for Gunhound Ex As the main heroine.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Internet Kraken posted:

So does Cosette ever become useful or is she just a weight tied to your ankle for the entire game?


YEAH BUT WE BLEW UP A TANK WOOOOOO! Hey Helmut did you see how- oh right he's bleeding out back at base.

....WOO!! :haw:

VVV I thought for a second maybe those buffing subclasses might be slightly less awful. At least if you give Cosette a trumpet she won't find a way to shoot herself in the foot with it.

All of the squadmates have a negative potential until you complete their personal mission. Sadly Cossette and Zeri is campaign based.

And Lanseal is more like a more looser version of west point

And VC3 also vives us the token Darscen force that refuses to be treated like dogs to offset the abuse they had received in the previous games In an half hearted attempt to go "not all Darscen are scared cowards whos only purpose is target practice"

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
To give the tournament arc a good reason to win is because of the graduate reputation. If they decided to enlist in the army. Getting a tourney win can give very good promotion aspects as well as a chance of ennoblement.

That said, does West Point have wargames competitions between classes?

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

King of Bleh posted:

VC1 was pretty lighthearted for a WWII story, but I don't think it was significantly sillier than other "anime goes to war" type franchises like Fire Emblem. The tone was definitely never outright farcical, a goal that this game unfortunately seems to have made a beeline for.

It's sad because in the right hands, there's some interesting things that can be done by mixing genre schlock and more serious depictions of WWII, Inglorious Basterds came out around the time of VC1 and managed it masterfully.

So should it be an gritty HBO series? Raita could probably push the envelope if he wanted to. Or we can have it like those gritty police academy series that have thigns like sneaking out to get drunk, high and get out the frustrations of a military academy life as well as truly hardass commanders.

gyrobot fucked around with this message at 20:01 on Apr 7, 2015

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Nick Buntline posted:

I suppose, in a certain way, I have to admire the sheer balls and/or critical lack of self-awareness it takes to design absolute territory into the bomb-proof armor, and then put in a caption about how important it was to add extra armor to the shins.

The general theory is if it hits the vitals you are dead anywat. At least if shrapnel hits your limbs you are not going to end up crippled in combat.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

BioMe posted:

A blast armored soldier dies because a low velocity shrapnel hits the femoral artery? Nothing could have prevented this tragedy. Now put her shins in a box and send her back home.

(You don't mean like "the general theory in real life", right? :psyduck:)

Well with enough ragnaid you can prevent a fuckup aside from critical wounds.

Another reason why the Militia isnt allowed to get involved is because Cordelia has to deal with an already hostile nobility who would see them being mobilized to crush a revolt as an heavy handed move and go and join the revolt. She had to placate the nobles to at least grudgingly accept her.

gyrobot fucked around with this message at 03:43 on Apr 8, 2015

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

SSNeoman posted:

Whoah, let's not say things we wanna take back later. Though I will admit I'm waiting for when Avan will have some :masterstroke: of a plan and earns everyone's respect. Index did this all the loving time, the protag was incompetent and poo poo on by the world. The suddenly come battle time and he was an extremely calculating and experienced fighter who knew how to effectively void others' powers and cripple them before punching them in the face.
I dunno how well that ended up for him, I stopped reading it about a quarter of the way in. Index isn't very good despite the face punching.

VC1 sorta did this with Welkin's knowledge of nature, but it felt way less contrived cause he was the son of a famous general and was a smart person in his own right. I'm not against the trope, but you should at least be creative with it.

Technically he does this through personal missions that you get later. Everyone in Class G has a chip up their shoulder. Completing them eliminate their negative potentials for positive ones. Ani's issue is that while she can sing (Unlike Edy who's voice can be used as psychological warfare), she has next to no stamina.

gyrobot fucked around with this message at 08:58 on Apr 8, 2015

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
Alright we got more main VAs so I am going to give out trivia on their seiyuus.

Aliasse is voiced by Haruka Tomatsu, voicing Nagi in Kannagi as well as Mileena Vashti from Gundam 00 and Shiho from Zettai Karen Children, she would be known for her role as Asuna from SAO.

Clementia is voiced by Mami Koyama, cast as Talia Gladys from Gundam SEED Destiny as well as Karen Joshua from 8th MS team.

Lavina is voiced by Satomi Satou, when she debuted, her major breakthrough role was Ritsu from K-On.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
To be fair the weapon also have A suppression on top of Def drop. So its a tradeoff To kill defense heavy units quicker.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Zyrden posted:

So what happens if you lose the match against class C? Is it as game over as losing a real battle is, or can you actually end up not winning the tournament?

Game over. A fatal round hits Avan. Remember just because they are using practice rounds doesn't mean it's not fatal.

Also seiyuus for the GRA.

Baldren is voiced by Hikaru Midorikawa, we all know him as Heero Yuy from Gundam Wing.

Audrey is voiced by Ayako Kawasumi, she voiced Saber as well as Reina from Queen's Blade

Dirk is voiced by Souichiro Hoshi, most well known at the time for Kira Yamato from Gundam SEED

Gilbert is voiced by Banjo Ginga, or more importantly...GIHREN ZABI!

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Tae posted:

I would be less annoyed if this wasn't the 2nd classmate quest that involves playing matchmaker. He's still helping Nichol with his love problems, and will be helping 2 more in the future.

And Avan is a dense sunnuvabitch himself.

Also with Audrey she is the typical Zealot. If Baldren is doing it for glory of Gallia then Audrey is doing this because she sees it as following the will of the Valkyrie. Gallia means little to her compared to Baldren.

The extended lore also shows Gilbert hates the Gallian Nobility and wanted an absolute monarchy for Gallia rather than the soft power Cordelia has. With the Empire has an even crueler policy towards Darscen drove him off the deep end As he saw this war not just a war of resources but an active campaign at eliminating Darscen and supposed sympathizers

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Neddy Seagoon posted:

You mean the family with the dumb brute of a son, the ambitious idealistic son, and the intelligent plotting daughter?

To be fair VC3 was a macross fanfic.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Monkey Fracas posted:

Ha ha, I love those things. I thought MGS3 made the weapon up the first time I saw it in the game.

Not too far of a stretch because most of the MGS cast also voiced the NPCs

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

David Corbett posted:

Hmm. You'd think that if you could fire ragnite death beams and use invincible bullshit ragnite shields, you'd just skip the intermediary and put them on the same tank as the power source.

Tanks cant hold ground or capture buildings

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Cake Attack posted:

but you see, who would expect that class g of all people could be escorting the archduchess, and not some random chump?

i mean, the main villains i guess, considering, so uh...

Avan is Leons bro. Every other Class has a problem with Darscen and given the chance they could backstab Cordelia and dub it an accident or the rebels are too good.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Night10194 posted:

Alright, see, what Rainer's dealing with? This is the poo poo this game should be about, not all this anime bullshit. They're fighting a civil war. Friend against friend, brother against brother, sister against sister. That poo poo should be coming up all the time, as should the idea that under their (stupid) masks the Rebels are still people, even if they're turboracists fighting for a fundamentally unjust cause.

To the revolutionaries, a Darscen queen is effectively a "shoot us all" that is going to come up eventually. They got invaded for reasons and now religious fervor comes into play, if it isn't the empire then it will be revolutionaries, if not revolutionaries then Yggists zealots who would make rebel and empire Atrocities look like an act of war. We are talking about beheadings, burnings, public executions and drat the opinions of anyone who disagrees.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
I still remember Dog Life Dog Style. If Japan doesnt have harsh censorship laws for gaming maybe we would see the envelope pushed. Too bad the OCU damashi is in your face. The only non Japanese OCU guy gets treated like a real rear end in a top hat

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Pureauthor posted:

Crap, the rebels have starting equipping their soldiers with Windamium.

After the worst gundam grunt of the franchise that somehow managed to suck harder than Leos?

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
If Dahau was still around it would have mixed things up. Another revolutionary movement who defends the Darscens as Lanseal also have to shut them down. Zeri would have seen him as the beacon of hope.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Agean90 posted:

It kinda feels like there was like one or two dudes on the writing staff who wanted to do interesting things with it, then got overridden by their higher ups.

"I got this idea for a guy whos being held as a political hostage"
"Sweet, im writing up a character whos part of an oppressed culture, theyll work well of each other"
":downs: HEY GUYS, PERSONA SOLD LIKE HOTCAKES, THIS SHITS GOIN TO HIGH SCHOOL :downs:"

Would it improve with HBO style drama? You guys would prefer a gritty JRPG with sex, gore and rear end in a top hat protags you want to see die.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Agean90 posted:

Night10194 said it better than I could. I just want characters that have more to them than a quirk.

That is a problem when you add a lot of character, you either have a wide cast of characters or you have a limited group of well developed characters. It pretty difficult to flesh out everyone.

Still going by your recommendation I would go for the WRPG's approach, aka Avan wanting to go grab some liquor from outside of town to drink away the frustration of the ongoing rebellion. Zeri making effigies of GRA soldiers and executing them one by one, Sophia's maneater personality being more fleshed out beyond "Massage my leg". Helmut decking Zeri after the comment he made about imperial soldiers. And instead of wanting to be an idol, Anisette performs at the local cabaret at the Academy singing dirty cabaret songs for a thankless audience where the watered down wine only serve to make them aggressive drunks.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Tae posted:

They should've probably done the entire tournament arc first, instead of fighting the rebel leaders twice, beating them twice, go through 3 ethnic cleansing, prevent the assassination of the Queen, and introduce artificial and real Valkyrians.

Instead, we got all that before the 2nd round of the Laevintein cup. During a civil war that needs all hands on deck.

The civil war at the moment seems like sporadic attacks on Darscen settlements and the odd botched recon. Since the Darscens are of little concerns to the people, they rarely get reported until the fighting spills to an uncontrollable situation that have Lanseal being called in. The Gassernels also have to contend with Landseal counterattacks (which so far have been repulsed). The other classes are probably the ones attacking Gassernel forces in retaliatory raids but as they mentioned it is a tough nut to crack, not helped by the V2.

Plus it means glory for the other classes, let Class G do the glorified grunt work, when Class A takes Gassernel fortress and brings the family to Justice they will be the ones to be remembered as the ones who brought stability back to Gallia

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Night10194 posted:

I actually kind of liked the twist with Helmut's mission. He's still a jerk, but at least he's a professional, and he understands why he's in Gallia and the stakes of what's going on. That's a bit more interesting than I expected from VC2.


Sadly he probably burnt through the interesting personal missions and now left withe dull ones

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
Hey hunters got to prep traps for killing enemies vietcong style. Plus survivalist mentality means she has taught herself to treat injuries.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
A good idea to understanding GRA racism...

Picture this...

Your people have been a neutral nation who suddenly been invaded by another country woth some hardline bigots. No problem, resource conflicts happen all the time no problem. But they then start escavating your ruins for WMDs to end the war quickly because you are holding on with tooth and claw. However suddenly your head of state reveal she is one of the people responsible for the end of the world by the religion you follow? Sure you repelled the empire but you now got an ursurper faction ruling your people? So who else who want Gallia aside from the Empire?

-Darscen fanatics who sees her capture as the establishment of an Darscen state. Eventually recruiting people who saw enough oppression to make non loyal members hang while others will suffer a dozen times more?

-A Yggist version of the People Crusades, ragtag Yggists who join together to purge the illegitimate kingdom. Its going to be an brutal slaughter. Not shooting people in rampages but rounding up and commiting horrific atrocities like live burnings, beheadings and impaled corpses.

At this point you are utteely convinced either you remove them or they do it for you.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
Well her family despises Darscen. She simply follows her familys train of thought

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Night10194 posted:

No, that was a plot point. It's designed to shame them for supposedly burning down the world, which we know is complete made up horseshit.

E: f,b

Of course, it doesn't stop some of them from saying "gently caress IT! YOU ACCUSE OF DOING THIS MADE UP CRIME THEN I AM GOING TO DO SAID CRIME IN FRONT OF EVERYONE!"

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
They are talking about economics, rebuilding after the war is a dicey issue. On one hand, subsidizing the agricultural sector means North Gallia could produce more food for the army and civilians which will keep the other villages from volunteering to join the GRA for food. Of course Zeri realize this is bull since the nobility will simply skim from the coffers and the people would still starve.

If only they focused on the political aspect also like Dog Life and Dog Style, it shows just how hosed up civilian life out of the warzone is like.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

BioMe posted:

gyrobot, I have to say I'm starting to love your anti-humor even though I haven't figured out if it's intentional or not

Tae makes it look like he is getting his teeth pulled by high school antics. So I try to make more bearable for him even though I would just remind myself this is just a loving game and turn my mind off.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

thetruegentleman posted:

What the rebels say they are protecting Gallia from IS the Darcsens; their willingness to destroy everything else to do that is what makes them seem like hypocrites. Also, ordering soldiers to gun people doesn't work on a consistent basis: for example, while the Nazi police battalions (the people tasked with the killings) had initial "success" in rounding up/killing minorities, so many of them deliberately missed, or turned a blind eye to escapees, or found an excuse to avoid their 'duty' that thousands of Jews managed to escape them. Not to say there weren't a fair share of psychos who volunteered for the later hunts, but most soldiers tried to avoid them as best they could. It even went the other way as well: there were cases of both enlisted men *and* officers walking away from shootings they were ordered to commit (generally because they knew the victims, either personally or because they shared a dialect), and suffering nothing from their insubordination.

Even those willing to perform the executions had their problems: one officer was crippled by stomach craps every time a hunt was scheduled, eventually costing him his position and getting him sent to the front lines due to 'cowardice'. When he got there? He earned the Iron Cross and managed to work his way up the chain of command, even surviving the war (IE, not a coward in the least). Not to say he wasn't ashamed of being unable to order the deaths of innocent people personally (he was), but it helps illustrate the problems the soldiers faced, many of whom turned to alcohol in order to cope.

That's the reason for the dehumanization the Jews were forced to go through before their deaths, and why the killing process ultimately had to be dehumanized: broken down into separate steps, with different soldiers at each one performing the same action repeatedly. While psychos could be relied on to hunt down small groups, killing a whole town required a methodical process; and we saw that in the first game through the Darcsen camps. The idea of front line soldiers trying to do this crap is laughably dumb, all the more so when the class literally has a photographer with them to prove the murders, and it was EXACTLY such photos that practically ended institutionalized racism in the west.

This isn't a professional "soldiers gunning down" action, this is a Pogrom. Spur of the moment style razings that have little thought beyond "kill them all".

Also, the occupation of Korea and Armenian genocide can serve as counterexamples of willing people who didn't flinch.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
This potential pretty much put Cosette as a backliner until later on, her potential was all defensive anyway, she is at the moment a strict healer which would be great if we actually have to hold ground and face infinite respawns.

weso12 posted:

I still think that theses writers aren't *that* bad, it feels like they were two groups and one told to write about the drama of high schoolers and the other told write serious war drama, and they decided to awkwardly clump them together. If the game wrote decided to go all serious war drama dealing with the youth and going into war drama, like this Cossette drama here is actually somewhat competently written if it didn't contrast with the classmate missions whole heartily it could have worked. Heck if it went Advance Wars "war is fun" kind of route, with the cut out characters it be at least tonally consistent and not too cringe worthy. Actually if the game put all the classmate anime drama stuff for the first part of the game, then evolving into a more serious game after that point, with character development focusing on the effects of war particularly with dealing youth having to be soldier, it honestly probably fail the depth it go for but we could give it credit for a good vision at least.


Actually they did actually do *one* thing that somewhat surprised me during the plot, but more in the "I should have seen it coming, but I didn't" category.

Also I'm gonna give them a break on the whole colorblindness thing in that her colorblindness probably isn't an actual issue with her eye but some bizarre reaction to emotional trauma that's giving her colorblindness somehow (the closest thing I can actually find is Cerebral achromatopsia buts thats only caused by physical trauma or illness as far as I can tell).

The thing I want to know is how she got into the academy, shouldn't they have a colorblindness test.

High school drama is fine if it is the debauchery type antics, underage drinking! Civies vs military brats! And Generation Kill style antics!

gyrobot fucked around with this message at 04:48 on Apr 26, 2015

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
How much damage does Rocket Barrage do? Its about 4 Lancers worth of shots in an area out of Lancer reach. Plus Lancers only get a limited amount of shots so its a trade off.

Also the Darscen Hater debuff applies to him so the Darscen racism is mostly a nobility issue. If Cordelia never revealed herself as a Darscen queen the revolt would never happen.

gyrobot fucked around with this message at 00:02 on Apr 27, 2015

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

thetruegentleman posted:

You know, the rebels do have a fair point (if their telling the truth): Gallia is already battered from the war, and taking care of thousands of migrants fleeing certain-death in the Empire might be logistically impossible to do without putting major strain on an already over stressed populace...and the idea of being turned into a second class citizen in your own country, after fighting on behalf of those very same people, must be very unnerving. It's not an unjustified fear either, because the Darcsen's are themselves second class citizens, and the people of Gallia know things could be flipped around rather easily with enough Darcsens. And what are the Darcsens going to do to prove otherwise? Hand out cinnamon rolls? I'm sure those would make up for everything.

Worse, when one considers that the circumstances the resulted in the formation of modern Israel also began with a massive influx of Jews into the Middle East after WW2, well...going from majority to minority is very possible, and always costly for the latter.

Of cpurse even if Baldren wasnt racist he is still an absolute monarchist which Cordelia is not going to like. He hated the Gallian generals and nobility who would toss Gallian lives away and wanted a Gallia with an absolute monarchy.

[modedit: C'mon man, the goddamn page you linked even says "significant spoilers"!]

Somebody fucked around with this message at 21:53 on Apr 28, 2015

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

thetruegentleman posted:

I'm going to second this; in a worse game, we would be seeing the female soldiers stripped of their clothes upon being shot. I honestly don't get why so many games have a swimsuit or hot spring scene (do Japanese games get some kind of tax credit for it?), but at least its just the one scene, not the whole game.

Besides, this kind of scene is usually bad because its pointless: not developing the characters, advancing the plot, or building suspense. Generally speaking, media should *always* do one of those three for each scene, and eliminate everything that doesn't live up to the standard; in this games case, however, there are so many pointless scenes and uninteresting characters that seeing what kind of swimsuit each person wears probably counts as character development, because that's as close to unique as most of them are going to get.

It's all terribly sad.

Edit: Missed the post ever so slightly. Surely the other characters will get their own scenes, and not just the main group? Then again, it would be kind of funny if they designed suit for each character and then never bothered to use them.

Database syndrome, what do you guys want? An academy party where Zeri have a spiked drink and enter a happy/angry/sad drunk period? Or a firing range moment where Zeri uses pictures of Baldren and Audrey as target practice?

That said, a poolside scene is a great way for the main cast to bond and have Juliana knocked down a peg.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
On Marion getting reconcilliation is because she saw a Darscen who is leadership material. He literally stood up for a blue blooded noble and calmed down the team he just beat even though it was in reason to rub it in.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

scissorman posted:

Oh hey, you finally got to the part where they "reveal" the truth about the artificial valkyries.
So, not only is the military wasting what is apparently a tremendous amount of resources on super soldiers (instead of something that can't be killed either by shooting it with a rifle or just shelling it into submission like better tanks), they also are using up their best and brightest officers to do it.
Given the effect of leadership, especially special anime leadership, I believe this is a lovely tradeoff.
The game could have been much better by leaving it out but it's a common anime trope, so of course they have to include it.

Though I do wonder how the rebels got their hands on your brother, did they just walk off with him along with the "combat data"?
I don't remember it ever being clarified or at least being satisfied with the explanation.

Another waste is the whole Juliana death scene.
While the whole romance is again nothing new, their treatment of it would have been much more interesting if they actually had to deal with the fact that she's still an anime racist.
But I guess that would be too much to ask for in this game.

V2s make the most outta the Ragnite Gallia has. You can use them in surgical strikes.

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011
Baldren is an absolute monarchist. If he wasnt a Darscen Hater he is going to purge every noble house that dont agree with him and still become monarch.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

gyrobot
Nov 16, 2011

Night10194 posted:

Baldren is the villain this game deserves.

It's also funny that Brixson's whole schtick is 'We don't need superpowers, just the undying nationalistic spirit of the youth and their vigorous desire to shed blood for the mother country!'

Like, that's not actually that much better.

As in standing united regardless if you were from the Empire, Gallia, Atlantic Fed, Darscen and Valkyria.

Ah well good to know the lp is done at last.

  • Locked thread