Register a SA Forums Account here!
JOINING THE SA FORUMS WILL REMOVE THIS BIG AD, THE ANNOYING UNDERLINED ADS, AND STUPID INTERSTITIAL ADS!!!

You can: log in, read the tech support FAQ, or request your lost password. This dumb message (and those ads) will appear on every screen until you register! Get rid of this crap by registering your own SA Forums Account and joining roughly 150,000 Goons, for the one-time price of $9.95! We charge money because it costs us money per month for bills, and since we don't believe in showing ads to our users, we try to make the money back through forum registrations.
 
Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

WarpedLichen posted:

So is it normal to have a guy in high command have two prison stints? I guess it's stuff early in his career but it just seems so weird to have a a culture that glamorizes criminals.

Is it a modern western thing where having been to prison once often ruins your life forever?

Reading history about famous people. Back in ye olden days, it seems that everyone did a tour in prison at one point or another and no one cared.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

I know Russia is supposed to have exemptions for skilled workers etc. But I doubt that the skilled workers trust the corrupt recruiters that run around kidnapping people.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-blocks-starlink-in-crimea-amid-nuclear-fears-report-2022-10?r=US&IR=T

quote:

Elon Musk blocks Ukraine from using Starlink in Crimea over concern that Putin could use nuclear weapons

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Tesseraction posted:

I went to look up Dragon's Teeth and it seems they were primarily used by Germany in WW2?

Pretty ironic for the denazifiers to be using a fortification method favoured by the losing side in WW2. A side that lost to Russia in that war, albeit I don't think they thought to put up dragon's teeth on the eastern front as they were more concerned with invading outwards and didn't have the time when the Soviets pushed back.

Unguarded dragons teeth are useless, and the Ukrainians are going to drone bomb any people left to defend them.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Inferior Third Season posted:

The bridge is a major means of transporting Russian military assets to occupied Ukrainian territories. It is absolutely a military target.

If a few people started taking cruises on aircraft carriers, they wouldn't suddenly become "civilian ships".

It's the presence of civilians that make it an invalid target. Not the presence of war materials that makes it a valid one.

This is the logic that applies every single time.

So the legal question is "what makes it a warcrime then?" And the answer is "That depends"

It depends on who captures you. On whom wins the war and who is willing to defend you.

But the ethical issue is crystal clear.

Feliday Melody fucked around with this message at 06:44 on Oct 13, 2022

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021


quote:

The town of Zhovkva (currently in Lviv Oblast, Ukraine), located near the battle, was renamed Nesterov in his honor in 1951.

You will notice that the Ukrainian town of Zhovkva is in fact not named Nesterov as of this reading :v:

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021


Yes, that was my point. Ukraine had very little interest in honouring a long dead Russian/Soviet war hero with whole towns named after him.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Alchenar posted:

It's entirely possible that Starlink and Musk are being upfront about their costs and problems. Donations and at-cost provision is great, but a private company shouldn't really be expected to be bankrolling a foreign war to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars and it's reasonable for them to ask for their costs to be covered. It's also reasonable for them to pitch for commercial funding rather than at-cost funding as an opening bid.

Starlink was a good pr donation but it was done in March and there was probably an assumption of how long the war would go on for and how much the donation would cost the company that has subsequently changed.

I believe that the sums that Musk is throwing around isn't the cost to SpaceX, but rather the retail customer price that those services would have cost.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Musk could probably have had the US government finance the whole thing with some backdoor negotiations, while simultaneously being able to take full credit for it on Twitter as charity work.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Alchenar posted:

I know you want it to wind down, but as we close off Elon-chat it's worth noting Ukraine's gov also sending clear 'don't yell at Elon' signals:

https://twitter.com/Podolyak_M/status/1580945804193587200

I like the barb that implies that Elon only care about money and that he will get his drat money.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Rinkles posted:

https://twitter.com/Reuters/status/1581019916395810816

    BERLIN, Oct 14 (Reuters) - Sweden has rejected plans to set up a formal joint investigation team with Denmark and Germany to look into the recent ruptures of the Nord Stream 1 and 2 pipelines, a Swedish prosecutor investigating the leaks, said.

    Mats Ljungqvist, the prosecutor involved in Sweden's criminal investigation into the Nord Stream leaks in the Swedish economic zone, said Sweden was already co-operating with Denmark and Germany on the matter.

    He said Sweden had rejected the proposal for a Joint Investigation Team (JIT) from judicial co-operation agency Eurojust because a such a joint investigation would include legal agreements under which Sweden would have to share information from its own investigation that it deemed confidential.

    "This is because there is information in our investigation that is subject to confidentiality directly linked to national security," Ljungqvist told Reuters.

    He made his comment after a report in German weekly Der Spiegel on Friday that Sweden had rejected plans for a joint investigation with Denmark and Germany, citing German security sources.

    A Swedish Security Services spokesperson said the security police were co-operating closely with other authorities, also internationally, as part of the Swedish criminal investigation.

    German TV programme Tagesschau on German public broadcaster ARD said that Denmark, too, had turned down setting up a joint investigation team.

    Germany's federal police have completed their part in investigating an alleged act of sabotage on the Nord Stream pipelines and handed over their findings, said a German interior ministry spokesperson on Friday.

    Asked about reports that Sweden would not investigate together with Germany and Denmark, Swedish Prime Minister Magdalena Andersson told Reuters: "No, as I understand it that is not true. We are working together with Germany and Denmark in this issue."

    Eurojust says on its website a Joint Investigation Team is used in international cooperation in criminal matters, comprising legal agreement between authorities of two or more states for the purpose of carrying out criminal investigations.

Okay I confess. We did it. In order to get Germany to buy Swedish gas and oil, we blew up the Russian pipe.

(USER WAS PUT ON PROBATION FOR THIS POST)

Feliday Melody fucked around with this message at 07:30 on Oct 15, 2022

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

spankmeister posted:

Weird flex by Sweden imo.

That Simpsons scene with the Soviet Union returning, but instead it's Charles the 12th leaving his tomb to restore the Swedish empire.


Feliday Melody fucked around with this message at 07:44 on Oct 15, 2022

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

I always wondered what the deal was with Russia. Russia has vast amounts of land and natural resources, as well as people.

Why is the whole system going to hell? Is it the sheer amount of incompetence and corruption that just erodes every joint of it, or what?

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Charlz Guybon posted:

Joining NATO means having to participate in these kinds of things, doesn't it?

Ironically. Sweden as a non-NATO member has participated more in NATOs campaigns over the last few decades than Norway as a NATO member has.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

It's kind of refreshing how clear the world has been against the Russian misinformation campaign. Everyone in power knows that Russia did it. And all the countries move with that in mind. Russia is winning the meme war and their social media puppets all act like the USA did it, but Russia faces the full blame in practise.

Feliday Melody fucked around with this message at 11:42 on Oct 15, 2022

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Hieronymous Alloy posted:

Every so often I just think about how relatively lucky we are that Trump lost. In other contexts too but right now specifically in this context.

"Who knows who could have done it? It Could have been Russia or Germany or Ukraine or Sweden or an accident and I talked to him (Putin) and he said that.... you know and you know we can never be certain about these things so we need to be careful who we blame"

As a pebble compared to the complete poo poo show any unified resistance and sanctions would have been with a meandering USA taking centre stage.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

As Swedish military, personnel. About Sweden not sharing intel with Germany. When Russia first started the invasion of Ukraine. Sweden responded by placing tanks on Gotland. German state TV then accused Sweden of provoking Russia. Declaring it was a threat to Moscow.

As far as the Swedish military and defence was concerned. It ran home two important points. One was that Germany was thoroughly compromised. And secondly. That Sweden should prepare to be fighting alone in case of a war.


We always knew that compromised on a financial level, but this was Germany trying to influence Swedish national security on behalf of Russia. And it was considered a very big deal.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Antigravitas posted:

Can you link that DW article or video? I'd like to have a look at it.

It was right before the war even.

https://twitter.com/sumlenny/status/1484819191253377024



There's a related RT article from about the same time, which is funny in retrospect.

https://www.rt.com/russia/546166-sweden-tanks-gotland-russians-invade/

quote:

Residents of the sleepy town of Visby on the Swedish island of Gotland awoke to the sound of heavy military hardware roaring through the streets on Saturday. The Swedish Army’s Stridsfordon 90 infantry fighting vehicles had arrived overnight to secure the tranquil coastal town and its port.

The Swedish military said the effort “should be seen” as part of Sweden adapting its strategy “to the tense situation between Russia and Ukraine,” which has been grabbing media headlines for several months. The US and its NATO allies have claimed that Russian troops are set to invade neighboring Ukraine as early as January or February. Moscow has dismissed the statements as “fake news.”

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

I wonder what Russia could offer to have Iran throw in with such a loser side.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Deltasquid posted:

Who is this Josh and should we give any attention to his opinions?

What date are his figures from? It’s kind of a moot point to cite post-2014 numbers. It’d be like citing 2022 West Bank numbers to ignore all the demographic shifts happening due to colonial policies.

And, all things considered, “yes because it’s legally Ukrainian regardless of who lives there”. Or does he think Mexico could invade California on the pretext that the Latino population is the largest in the state

The entire comment section is dunking on him by showing how much of the current US was once owned by Mexico, haha.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Saladman posted:

There was never any real doubt that Hungary would have to approve them eventually, right? If Hungary threatened to leave, my main response would be "lol," like if my four year old threatened to leave the house and go off into the world on their own.

Turkey seems like a much bigger stumbling block though, since NATO needs Turkey about as much as Turkey needs NATO, and trading Sweden+Finland for Turkey would not be a no-brainer, unlike trading them for Hungary.

On the other hand, Turkey has nothing to lose by approving them. However, rejecting their application would piss off some bigger NATO players at zero gain for Turkey.

Turkey is using the situation to try and wring concessions from Sweden and Finland. Though, as the Russian military is taken apart in Ukraine. The urgent need for NATO membership is dropping quickly.

No politician in Sweden or Finland has anything to gain from appeasing Turkey. They already filed the application work. All political points are collected. If the application is rejected, then they can just blame Turkey

Giving in to Turkey on the other hand would be a political disaster for a politician in either country.


I would say that the country with the biggest burden now is Turkey. After making so much noise. They need to find a way of approving the applications while still looking like the big, tough negotiator.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Ynglaur posted:

I am not an air defense expert, but my understanding is that most ground-to-air systems are intended to protect point targets: airfields, headquarters, supply depots, etc. Cities like Kyiv are big, and Ukraine is a target-rich environment for long-range guided munitions seeking civilian targets.

For the war effort, hitting Kiev instead of a Ukrainian supply depot will just hasten Russia's defeat.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Youth Decay posted:

Could always go back to the idea of using birds-of-prey to hunt the drones down. May need to put helmets and bulletproof vests on them though.

Train seagulls into believing that drones have food, and the problem will solve itself.

I see no way that this could backfire on future society.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

WarpedLichen posted:

Most things in weapons are designed to mechanically jam in failure conditions rather than just fall off. Usually there's some special jettison mode if you really wanted to get rid of something which can involve squibs going off to break those mechanical linkages.

But then again, it's the Russians so who knows.

If the missile wasn't activated, then it probably hit the ground like a brick and went to pieces.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021


Imagine being an Iranian drone specialist, and you get deployed to Eastern Europe in November. Under the care of the Russian military.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

It would be pretty in character for Putin to have his corrupt system sell all the military equipment on the private market and then confiscate it to bring it to the military sell it on the private market again.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

D-Pad posted:

Everybody saying different things about the dragons teeth and how the tanks can or cannot handle them easily makes me think of the disagreements about tanks on the War Thunder forums leading to classified specifications getting leaked no less than 3 (and maybe 4?) separate times.

I'm not sure what the disagreement is. Dragons teeth are fine as long as they are supported with infantry.

But if you abandoned them, then the work of building them robbed you of more effort than the enemy will need to overcome them.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

cinci zoo sniper posted:

This is a ё appreciation zone. :colbert:

Edit:

https://www.lsm.lv/raksts/zinas/arzemes/ministrs-ungarija-lidz-decembrim-ratifices-zviedrijas-un-somijas-iestasanas-nato-protokolus.a479234/

Our media reported yesterday that Orban’s head of administration has confirmed that Hungary is going to ratify NATO enlargement by Sweden and Finland. Hungarian procedural formalities are expected to conclude before Christmas.

The Swedish PM is going to visit Erdrogan to negotiate this.

Our current PM is notable for giving up everything in every negotiation so far, so it doesn't look good from a human rights perspective.

Honestly, I'm not even sure if the PM has the power to negotiate handing over those journalists to Turkey. He certainly wants to. Either Turkey has the legal right or they don't. Ministers can't decide that on their own without putting legislation through parliament.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Rappaport posted:

The Finnish-Turkish argument (such as it is) seems to begin and end with our judicial system being independent, i.e. the president or the parliament can't just willy-nilly go around saying extradition verdicts should all favour mister Erdogan because he has a tummy-ache. Of course Turkey has been less, erm, persistent with us than they have been with Sweden, but surely even Ulf can manage a little vinegar in the defense of mamma Svärje.

We have the same system, which people had a very hard time understanding during the Assange extradition negotiations.


I'm not even sure why Ulf is going there. Maybe to promise weapon exports?

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

distortion park posted:

Seems clear that this is the future of at the very least small scale warfare.
https://twitter.com/SamBendett/status/1584516672425451523?t=TMQa4iwpn6IOktoDKwHqtw&s=19

Battles are going to start with releasing 200 automatic man hunting kamikaze drones with heat cameras. Then all friendly soldiers get to carry IFF transmitters to not become targets.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Rigel posted:

Yeah, drones are going to be a lot more important in conflicts going forward, but I think some people might be over-learning lessons from this war. If you aren't in a situation where AA is ridiculously oppressive to the point where air superiority is impossible, you'd probably be relying on modern aircraft and helicopters a lot more.

We shouldn't underestimate how cheap mass-produced military drones could be when compared to aircraft. Not to mention sparring trained pilots etc.


A $3000 drone with the explosive power of a hand grenade could make a world of difference to infantry.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

OAquinas posted:

Funny thing about mutual defensive pacts--they can exist outside NATO.
But yeah, that'd be an upwards climb. Russia could try again of course, but Ukraine NOW is blunting their entire military. Just imagine how it'd handle them in 5 years with full investment in western weapons and armor...though again, that's tempered by the insane debt and rebuilding costs they'll have to do.

It's a shitshow.

Of course, Russia might reform their military, like the Soviets did after the winter war with Finland.

Then in 5 or 10 years the headshot against Kiev might succeed.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Eric Cantonese posted:

Yup. Cori Bush, AOC, Ilhan Omar and Ayanna Pressley are among the signatories.

The wording's not quite "make Ukraine surrender," but it's definitely showing that we're getting closer to a western breaking point, which is exactly what Putin is counting on.

This reminds me of when the Swedish left party burned a year worth of political gains in a single day by voting against weapon shipments to Ukraine.

Yes, I get that it was some grandstand against weapon exports/NATO etc. And they knew it was going to pass anyway, but shut up! Just this once.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

As a Medic, I don't understand the controversy at all. Treating the wounded is kind of a universal prerogative.

There's certainly a lot of wounded Russians in Ukrainian hospitals, too.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

I'm surprised that soldiers could get genuinely radiation poisoned in the Chernobyl forest areas after such little exposure. It shouldn't be that bad any more.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

FMguru posted:

It's pretty safe, provided you don't dig around in the radioactive dirt and kick a bunch of radioactive dirt and dust into the air and breathe it for several weeks straight. Which is exactly what they did.

I am a CBRN operator. I was under the impression that their stay was brief. And that the soldiers poisoned at the time was mostly overplayed in an attempt to escape the war.

Certainly, breathing in the dust would increase exposure by around 30-fold. I thought they weren't there for very long.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Dick Ripple posted:

While I understand Russia blaming every failure of theirs on NATO and its members instead of Ukraine, but how likely or able are some of these Sea/Air unmanned vehicles actually being operated by someone outside of Ukraine? We know it can be done from half way around they world with US and its Predator operators and at this point since Ukraine has been supplied with so much Western equipment there will not be any smoking gun for Russia to take pictures of and say so and so is directly responsible. Is Russia or anyone else for that matter able to figure out from where drones are being operated from?

There's the risk of these drone pilots posting all over their unsecured discords about how much Russian stuff they blew up and how cool it was.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Charlz Guybon posted:

Why is it called Winter Wheat if it is harvested in the summer?

It's planted in autumn and then harvested in spring/early summer.

As opposed to being planted in spring and harvested in autumn.

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

Is it significant politically that Turkey aids Ukraine in breaking the Russian blockade?


I read that the Turkish Black Sea navy is bigger than the Russian.

Adbot
ADBOT LOVES YOU

Feliday Melody
May 8, 2021

I imagine that Russia is going to sit on Ukraine's border for the coming year, just flinging missiles at infrastructure and harassing towns.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5